Altona Supper Club

New Holstein, 2306 Calumet Dr, New Holstein, WI 53061, United States | ★ 4.5 (1214 Review)

📞 +1 920-898-5255

Last Search

Category

Restaurant

Photos

 Altona Supper Club
 Altona Supper Club
 Altona Supper Club
 Altona Supper Club
 Altona Supper Club
 Altona Supper Club
 Altona Supper Club

Leave a Review

Reviews

Kathy Pommer

★ 5

Excellent as always

Source: Google

Raeline Springstroh

★ 5

One of Wisconsin's best supper clubs!!!

Source: Google

Becca Gerl

★ 5

Source: Google

Brenda Pagel

★ 5

Source: Google

Cherish Behrendt

★ 5

Source: Google

Shauna Marx

★ 5

Source: Google

Dan Biely

★ 5

Buffet

Source: Google

John 9107

★ 5

Was there for Sunday brunch and it was awesome and the drinks were delicious and the service was awesome. Been there many times and always great

Source: Google

Wendy Meyer

★ 4

Source: Google

Jennifer alderson

★ 5

Source: Google

Mark Thomas

★ 4

They have multiple buffets during the week Friday.Fish Fry ,Saturday night Meat lovers ,sunday brunch.

Source: Google

Don Braatz II

★ 5

Best bang for your buck! Never had a bad experience here. Awesome buffets and drinks! Never heard anyone say anything bad about this place. Except for Karen.......

Source: Google

Robert Evans

★ 5

Source: Google

Gemini

★ 3

Source: Google

Brian Frelich

★ 4

Source: Google

Kathy P

★ 4

We had fantastic service! Never had to ask for refills! Food was very good. I really enjoyed the deluxe eggs and the breaded shrimp. Lots to choose from! We will definitely come back!

Source: Google

Vic H

★ 5

Food is always the best!!!! Everyone there is polite helpful and hard workers! I would recommend highly.

Source: Google

Jorja Doherty

★ 4

Chicken needed to be a lil more done, but buffet was delicious!

Source: Google

Nick Rocks Jetzer12

★ 5

Source: Google

craig weidner

★ 5

Source: Google

Angella

★ 5

Source: Google

Russ w-d

★ 4

Nice buffet, large salad bar

Source: Google

Jason Anatole

★ 4

Source: Google

Jennai' Rusch

★ 5

What a blast from the past! It’s been over 30 years since I’ve been back and pleasantly surprised with everything. Well done and food was perfection.

Source: Google

Lucas

★ 1

Source: Google

Laurie Hamblen

★ 5

Every time I go there I am always amazed by the food and service! Highly recommended!

Source: Google

Deb Haupt

★ 5

Source: Google

Jeff Cevaal

★ 5

Source: Google

Thomas McNeely

★ 5

Source: Google

Heather Bell

★ 5

Food is not fancy but great! Staff was friendly. Prices are super low

Source: Google

Amy K. (Fairygirl76)

★ 5

Source: Google

Renee Marquardt

★ 4

Went on a Monday for the meat lovers buffet. Great food at a reasonable price!

Source: Google

Bob Heggan

★ 5

Great lunch buffet and friendly staff.

Source: Google

Kevin Anderson

★ 5

A quintessential supper club. We enjoyed our dinner with our family while partaking in a delicious and very reasonably priced buffet. Chicken, fish, shrimp, ribs and a plentiful salad bar. Great friendly service completed our experience.

Source: Google

Donna Wilhelms

★ 5

A favorite place of ours. Warm & friendly ćrowd & staff. Our hostess Ani, was lovely & very welcoming. Old Fashions were great. Food was hot & lots of choices on the buffet.Terrific salad bar & soup. Our waitress was Jada & she was very pleasant & attentive. A terrific experience..we will certainly be back. We travel about 40 minutes each way to enjoy the Altona.

Source: Google

Rob Meisenburg

★ 5

Was there for buffet style event. Staff was awesome and worked really hard. They also made the atmosphere great and comfortable. Food was good for a buffet.

Source: Google

rick Carl

★ 5

It's worth the drive. Very reasonable.

Source: Google

GingerSnap

★ 5

Always a great place to eat and have cocktails. They can accommodate large groups for different events. The food is always delicious and the staff is friendly and efficient. Great big bar area and great cocktails.

Source: Google

Bill Kissinger

★ 5

Had our lions club meeting here, was great thanks to New Holstein lions club for hosting

Source: Google

TIMOTHY STUTZMAN

★ 5

Altona supper club is one of my favorite places! I drive 45 miles to go there and worth it. Atmosphere, staff and food is always excellent. Always love the Sunday brunch.

Source: Google

Raye Ann Kuether

★ 5

Wonderful buffet & salad bar!

Source: Google

Kasandra Schurer

★ 5

Great Value for the breakfast buffet.

Source: Google

Anthony Poser

★ 5

Source: Google

Brad Cage

★ 5

Source: Google

Tracy Thomas

★ 5

Great food. Great people.

Source: Google

Troy Prahl

★ 5

Source: Google

E Roohr

★ 5

Food is great

Source: Google

Courtney Jo

★ 4

Source: Google

Aaron Bohn

★ 5

Source: Google

Wayne O

★ 4

Source: Google

Roman Sauter

★ 5

Source: Google

Linda Letz

★ 5

This is a great place to eat reasonably priced and great service

Source: Google

Cheryl Stadtfeld

★ 5

Source: Google

Wolf W

★ 2

Mother's Day Buffett was something left to be desired. Food was noticeably less than hot. Only had 1 soda with no refills offered.
With a nice event, how come only 2 vegetables were present and, the salad bar didn't have the usual ingredients? Just bacon bits, croutons, and sliced mushrooms.
Maybe we expected more. However, for $50 & $9 tip, we wanted more than chicken, ribs, and a salad.

Source: Google

Deb Schalk

★ 5

Source: Google

Cassandra Kunz

★ 3

Normal family dinner buffet. Good family choice.

Source: Google

Jeff Vollstedt

★ 4

Some of the foods vary. Rolls were hard. Salads sometimes soupy. Chicken over done. But generally speaking, it's a nice place to eat.

Source: Google

Wayne Van kooy

★ 5

Source: Google

A. Seiler

★ 5

I loved it even though I can't say that the food was the best ever or the atmosphere was the best ever, I still liked the variety of food and the price

Source: Google

Mark

★ 3

Soups were under seasoned. The salad bar was nice and fresh most of the buffet very good. Just a little more seasoning. I understood for lack of seasoning as it's a bulk crowd who may have dietary needs.
Salt and pepper were available so kudos on that. Satisfied would be the best description

Source: Google

Jeremiah Dettloff

★ 2

The food alot of it was cold

Source: Google

Liz B

★ 5

Nice place we found driving. Food was good. Like the variety. I'm used to Chinese buffets so this was a nice change. Staff was friendly. Wasn't busy so that was a plus.

Source: Google

Sandy Waskow

★ 5

Lots of delicious food and desserts!!

Source: Google

Ted Keneklis

★ 4

Good drinks but buffet food was not appetizing. Tenderloin with crab had imitation crab on top, asparagus were woody. Salad bar was good.

Source: Google

Sal Sci

★ 5

Source: Google

Donald Traynor

★ 5

We have a cousins meeting there twice a year and the food and service has always been excellent

Source: Google

Gary Gyr

★ 5

Everything was great. The hostess, bartender & server were all very courteous and prompt. We will definitely be back.

Source: Google

Stacy Beltran

★ 5

Source: Google

Monica Burt

★ 3

Source: Google

Tammy

★ 5

Source: Google

Thomas Faust

★ 4

Love coming here, and will continue. Disappointing tho to see another business is charging a fee to use a credit card. People are tired of being "fee'd" to death. Just charge the right price for doing business.

Source: Google

PARKIPLIER¡ ?¿

★ 4

Source: Google

Bob Carlos

★ 5

Butter. Scotch. Pudding!

Source: Google

Traci Lynn

★ 4

Great service and brunch was delicious.

Source: Google

Nicole

★ 5

First time here and there Sunday buffet was very good and very well priced. Several different options, all freshly made and a great salad bar. I really like that they have different buffets all week. We'll be back to check out the seafood buffet for sure!

Source: Google

Chip McCleary

★ 5

Source: Google

Kert Henning

★ 4

Source: Google

Jan Schram

★ 5

Great food

Source: Google

Mr Tags

★ 5

Your typical supper club vibe as soon as you walk through the door. The drinks were good (although an old fashioned should never be served in a pint glass!) and the bar service was quick.
We dined at a private party and they had a buffet set up. The food was good, and the people who picked up the empty plates from the tables was very fast.
I enjoyed that we had our own room - complete with a separate bar - just for the party.

Source: Google

SHANE PEIK

★ 5

Source: Google

Mary Forkins

★ 5

Source: Google

Bryan

★ 5

Went here on my way through the town for breakfast. Not really expecting a whole lot just a usual breakfast.... wow was i absolutely wrong! I walked into one of the best breakfast buffets I have ever had! With everything you could want for breakfast (yes ladies and gentlemen even biscuits and gravy) which were delicious! Plus a salad bar plus dessert! I was so full by the time I left here that I had to sit in my truck for a couple minutes to let it settle some. The staff are very friendly and wow do they run their butt's off! Never did a plate sit at a table nor was your beverage ever empty even though the place was packed. I will absolutely be stopping again, I may even go out of my way to come here again! Don't even get me started on the mouth watering ribs that they have at the buffet!!!!!

Source: Google

Alice Jashinsky

★ 4

Ive had good and bed here

Source: Google

Debora Zinkel

★ 5

Source: Google

JoAnn Wenzel

★ 5

We always think Altona is great! Good food good service what more can you ask for!

Source: Google

mary heider

★ 4

My Rib Eye Steak was suppose to have some pink in it .but was well done hard to chew....

Source: Google

June Nies

★ 5

We are always happy with Altona's food, service and friendliness!! Thank you Altona's for a fine job!!!

Source: Google

Beth Skotarzak

★ 5

Source: Google

Nancy Kucksdorf

★ 4

Only place that was open on New Year's Eve. They had New Year's buffet. Very good and lots to choose from. This place is a gold star to go and have a good food.

Source: Google

Dory Sargent

★ 5

Source: Google

Keith P

★ 5

The daily lunch buffet is a perfect break in your day. Excellent salad bar. Plenty of room for any party size.

Source: Google

Jessica Schneider

★ 5

I'm a little biased because my cousins own the place, but our family loves having the holidays here. The food is always delicious with so many options to choose from, and the atmosphere is always clean and festive. Staff are always friendly, and it's just always a great experience overall. Thank you for a memorable Christmas party!

Source: Google

Greg Hess

★ 5

Just had our Christmas party there. Everything was awesome places. Beautiful people are friendly.

Source: Google

Grace Hunsader

★ 5

Source: Google

Alan Yurk

★ 2

I don't hate the place itself. But the food just STINKS! It's not good! I'm not picky either, I'm easy to please. I love the Golden Corral! But I don't go out to eat and give them my money for a meal that tops out at "edible". I only went this time because my party chose here and I didn't want to be a bother. I guess waiting a year to go back and crossing my fingers really hard doesn't work to improve their cuisine. The texture is poor, the flavor is unsatisfying, and there's nothing remarkable about the rest of the experience to justify it. Sorry guys, but I've triple-learned my lesson! Just not great.

Source: Google

JACKIE MUELLER

★ 5

Source: Google

cynthia ascher

★ 5

Great supper club. Clean, friendly,good food & friendly staff.

Source: Google

Barbara Metz

★ 5

We go there quite often.

Source: Google

Robert Trost

★ 1

First impressions mean everything. My wife and I went there for an anniversary dinner. We ordered a Wisconsin supper club staple. Old fashions. They were not even made from scratch. Bottled mix. That was the first disappointment. We had the dinner buffet. The only thing that was good was the salad. The broasted chicken was cold and dried out. The shrimp was cold and greasy. The pork was over seasoned with pepper. The only dessert offered was slimy pudding. The pork ribs really looked disgusting. I think everything was leftover from lunch. Would never return.

Source: Google

David

★ 5

This is my favorite Supper Club. The food is excellent to superb. I love the salad bar. We had several drinks before dinner and the bartenders were friendly and the conversation was good and pleasant. The wait staff was quick, accurate, pleasant, and not overly aggressive during our meal. I love the old school atmosphere from the days when Supper Clubs were the thing to do. This place does it all and offers quite a delightful experience. The only problem with the Buffet is that sometimes the food isn't hot. I had some ribs on Saturday that were actually cold. I still however highly recommend the Altona Supper Club.

Source: Google

Curtis Robinson

★ 1

Went there for mothers day and Thanksgiving. Both experiences were sub par. There is both are both buffet and menu options but niether are very good. On mother's day I ordered a sandwich from the menu, the bread was soggy, there was pickle juice all over the plate. Wait staff was pretty short but they were busy so bit of a pass. Thanksgiving I had the buffet which is extremely limited, and the food is completely tasteless, it takes a lot of salt to be edible. Also, they were serving some leftovers from breakfast, which i thought was weird and gross being that it was probly in that hot hold for several hours. The space really isn't set up very ergonomically, Getting to and from the buffet is difficult, The desserts are just on a card table, uncovered, by the front door. And that table further restricts traffic making it even harder to get to. The bar area is nice but the dining room atmosphere is incredibly boring. I will not be going again, ever.

Source: Google

Rhonda Gerstner

★ 4

Went for thanksgiving buffet. Food was good very busy very little room to move or walk between tables. They pack people in.

Source: Google

John Thibodeau

★ 5

Source: Google

John Frost

★ 5

Nice people and good food. I will go back soon.

Source: Google

Cindy Jatczak

★ 5

Source: Google

bill jatczak

★ 4

Source: Google

Sally Carlson

★ 5

The lunch buffet was wonderful with something for everyone. We were especially pleased with the salad bar. This was our first visit here and we will be back!

Source: Google

justin Horneck

★ 5

Dave and jason are very friendly people, the bar and wait staff are very friendly as well, good prices, great food, good parking, good vibes, big place, nice looking, and great for events or meetings

Source: Google

Al Feustel

★ 5

Such great food and so inexpensive we were shocked. We each had the buffet and it was really tasty.

Source: Google

Mike Niemann

★ 5

Source: Google

Tina Franzen

★ 5

Always good food and service!

Source: Google

Tracy Smith

★ 4

Source: Google

Tracy T

★ 5

Source: Google

Jason Burke

★ 5

Quiet peaceful and great food. A little while wait for the food but the quality of the steak was more than worth it!

Source: Google

Greg Jaques

★ 5

Source: Google

Jessica Bulitz

★ 5

Awesome place. Great food & great atmosphere. Staff is fantastic!

Source: Google

John Seidl

★ 5

Awesome food & bartenders great atmosphere and Dave is an awesome man

Source: Google

David C Lepinsky

★ 5

Source: Google

Jim Tappendorf

★ 5

Source: Google

J L

★ 3

Updating past review. I'm not sure what's going on, but the quality of the food here has really gone down. My family and I used to get take out fairly often, support local business- but I have found the food to be inedible. Last time I ordered the chicken Alfredo. The piece of bread was smaller than my fist and the Alfredo sauce was not there- it was mostly noodles that were over cooked. I had 2 bites and tossed the rest. It's a shame, we really used to like coming here but I want to be able to eat the food I spend a good amount of money on.

Source: Google

David VanDensen

★ 5

Nice buffet for the price.

Source: Google

Barbe Rautenberg

★ 5

Source: Google

Thaddeus Phelps

★ 5

Source: Google

Joseph Glover Jr

★ 5

Source: Google

Shannon McWilliams

★ 5

This is a very nice place to come and have dinner. The food and service are great. We enjoy coming here.

Source: Google

Dale Krug

★ 5

Source: Google

Bud Kaufmann

★ 5

Source: Google

Karen R

★ 4

The lunch buffet is great! Soup and salad bar, you also can have ribs, chicken, mashed potatoes, and vegetables. To name a few of your choices. It's a filling and fast lunch. I have to say, though, my favorite thing at Altona is their steaks. They are so good!

Source: Google

Marilyn Birenbaum

★ 5

Source: Google

Dave Ziehr

★ 4

1st time ever....some of the items in the brunch line was barely warm...disappointing!

Source: Google

Patty Payette

★ 4

Source: Google

Eva Nechodomu

★ 5

Source: Google

ryan haskey

★ 4

We usually come here for the buffets. The brunch buffet is probably our favorite.

Source: Google

Katie Clark

★ 4

Wonderful waitress. I had the cauliflower steak swimming in butter and cheese. I love Wisconsin.

Source: Google

BlackC7 Corvette

★ 1

Ate there about a month ago, at opening time, it was bad. Watery drinks at the bar, table had salt pepper napkin silverware only. Salad bar ok, but found lot of butt pieces in the tomatoes. Food line horrible. Ribs was huge pile of bones with tiny scraps of meat/juice in bottom. Chicken old and dry. Got up to try something else, came back, our table was cleared off...drinks and all! Wth! Places like this give buffets a bad name. Now they catered a party we attended yesterday, everyone hated the food.

Source: Google

Amy Mc Carthy

★ 5

Source: Google

seth porterfield

★ 3

All the food was just mediocre, Service was better.

Source: Google

Nestor Rodriguez Cárdenas

★ 5

Source: Google

John Varga

★ 5

Source: Google

jen werner

★ 5

Source: Google

Stacy Vetter

★ 4

Source: Google

Matthew Canter

★ 2

Went on a Sunday night. Buffet style banquet food with no menu offered. About what you expect for a catering company for work. By no means bad, but a supper club in name only.

Source: Google

Rose Berlowski

★ 4

Source: Google

John C

★ 5

Source: Google

Lord Eldwyn

★ 4

Despite a full parking lot, there was a lot of space and plenty of tables and was sat quickly. The service is sending to none with quick refills and taking away any plates or spent items.

I had the brunch buffet. There were some amazing items like the mashed potatoes and broasted chicken, but others were bland or very salty. There are plenty of choices and it's all you can eat, so the great items can be reloaded on your next plate.

Very affordable on top of it all makes this a great place if cooking isn't one of the things you want to put on your to do list.

Source: Google

Cheryl Kappelmann

★ 5

Source: Google

Andy Graves

★ 4

Nice supper club. I went here for lunch with a few coworkers. Had the buffet. Ribs Fried chicken mashed potatoes corn . And a full salad bar. The atmosphere was a bit dated but about what you would expect for a Wisconsin supper club.
I would recommend.

Source: Google

Jim Myers

★ 5

Source: Google

Patricia Woelfel

★ 5

Source: Google

Tanya Villarreal

★ 5

Source: Google

Tammie Green

★ 5

Source: Google

Sean Bigelow

★ 5

Was in the area antiquing and decided to try Altona. Went a little before 5pm Saturday and the lot was pretty full. However, we were able to get seated right away. Staff was all very friendly and the buffet had a great selection for a good price. Staff was constantly watching to pull empty plates and refill drinks. The only suggestion I have would be to spread the tables out a little more. If we end up in the area in the future, would definitely go again.

Source: Google

Jesse Smith

★ 5

Great food. Michael is incredible 👍

Source: Google

Chris campbell

★ 5

Always a good time going here. Food is always fresh and well prepared, staff is friendly. Definitely recommend the Saturday dinner buffet and Sunday brunch.

Source: Google

BILL Martin

★ 5

Source: Google

brenda burns

★ 5

Food was excellent hostess and our waiter michael were for gd we had a group of 15 we brought in a cake for 2 birthday girls and they brought it out and sang happy birthday to them..I will recommend this place to anyone.i will go back again

Source: Google

Tricia Souder

★ 2

All of the food on the buffet was cold 😕. The salad bar was good. The staff was nice. The bartenders were nice. Would recommend the ice cream drinks.

Source: Google

jeffrey lentz

★ 5

Excellent service and great food

Source: Google

Jim Deer

★ 5

Source: Google

Margaret Dahlin

★ 5

Source: Google

Rich O

★ 4

The only reason I am not giving a 5 star review is because the breading on the fish is way too salty. Otherwise the food was very good and the prices are quite reasonable for the portions you get. They were short staffed but our server did a great job despite being swamped.

Source: Google

Adam Woodworth

★ 4

Source: Google

Beth Manz

★ 5

Outstanding. Great place to eat and to get a cocktail.

Source: Google

David Tadych

★ 5

Source: Google

Pamela Buyense

★ 5

Great food and wonderful service.

Source: Google

Tammy Krueger

★ 5

Great food. Great service. Great price

Source: Google

Randy Grimm

★ 5

One of my favorite places to go, The broasted chicken that wasn't a fan of maybe because it was a holiday and so much of it had to be made, but the barbecue ribs mashed potatoes ham and shrimp were great.

Source: Google

John Sobczak

★ 4

Great food, good price buffet. Everyone working there must love their job because they were always pleasant and smiling. Definitely going back, next time for their Friday seafood buffet.

Source: Google

Janice Kakes

★ 5

Great food ,great service

Source: Google

Playin' Hooky Sportfishing

★ 5

I head to Altona occasionally with family. It's always great!

Source: Google

HARDING WEBB

★ 5

Great place and good food

Source: Google

Shannon Alberts

★ 5

Classic Supper Club with a salad bar and good food! Pull tabs were not lucky for us though.

Source: Google

cato

★ 3

Most of the food tastes a little off. Still an alright place.

Source: Google

George Peretz

★ 5

Great Sunday Buffet

Source: Google

Paula Kerscher

★ 5

Even though it was extremely busy. The food and service was terrific

Source: Google

Lee David

★ 5

Great Buffet

Source: Google

Clark Kemp

★ 5

The food and service was great as usual. It seemed a little crowded to me. Dessert bar is always a favorite.

Source: Google

Jo Ann Hartman

★ 5

Source: Google

Tanya Kamimski

★ 5

Lovin it!

Source: Google

SherZano

★ 5

Source: Google

David Kvitek

★ 5

Source: Google

Kay Collins

★ 5

Review on bar only, but I hope to revisit for dinner at some point. Great service. All employees had such positive attitudes and seemed to really enjoy working together.

Source: Google

Maryann Leonhard

★ 5

Source: Google

Shannon Moody

★ 5

Source: Google

Isaac Krumbein

★ 3

The service was great. Our server was very attentive and check on us a few times. However the food was not great. We got the seafood buffet and almost everything was luke warm, and was not the quality was not great. Someone in our group got a cheeseburger and it was very mushy. It almost seemed like it was all fat and no real meat. The salad bar was a good part to the buffet, it had a large variety of different toppings and many different salad dressings along with 2 different soup. Overall I would not recommend getting the seafood buffet, but maybe try something else on the menu, and add the salad bar.

Source: Google

Connie Thull

★ 5

Source: Google

Jim Peterson

★ 4

Good food and the prices not bad.

Source: Google

Ellen Denton

★ 5

Everytime we go there, it's fantastic!!!

Source: Google

Sherry Doofenshmirtz

★ 5

Source: Google

Mark Erickson

★ 4

Well run good drinks and affordable food great atmosphere

Source: Google

PEACE

★ 4

The food was good .. but the only issue I have is when they fill the salad bar and buffet. They put fresh food on top of the old ... It's supposed to be the other way around.

Source: Google

Tom Lefeber

★ 5

Source: Google

Wendy Ruh

★ 5

Source: Google

David Lamp

★ 5

Great Buffet

Source: Google

Karlie Young

★ 5

Source: Google

Brian Rozek

★ 5

Going dood but need to lower prices

Source: Google

Deb Schuh

★ 5

Source: Google

Jean Feucht

★ 5

The staff was so so helpful, polite and loved the young people smiling and busy. Can't wait to come back!!👍❤🙏

Source: Google

FedPolice

★ 5

Source: Google

Phaedra Untitled

★ 3

Source: Google