Coop's Pizza

Hayward, 10588 California Ave, Hayward, WI 54843, United States | ★ 4.4 (1641 Review)

📞 +1 715-634-3027

Last Search

Category

Restaurant

Description

Family favorite restaurant in Hayward, WI serving homemade pizzas, burgers, lasagna, sandwiches, and salad bar. We offer an all you can eat pizza, garlic toast, soup, and salad bar buffet Sunday through Friday, 11:00am - 2:30pm. Family owned and operated since 1979. Coop’s Pizza is your 1st choice for an excellent dining experience for the entire family!

In addition to our great-tasting foods, Coop’s Pizza features an inviting log cabin-style atmosphere, with friendly, personable service, a newly remodeled bar, game room, and merchandise room!

Photos

 Coop's Pizza
 Coop's Pizza
 Coop's Pizza
 Coop's Pizza
 Coop's Pizza
 Coop's Pizza
 Coop's Pizza

Leave a Review

Reviews

Christine Czuper

★ 5

Love the food, people are great. Live 40 min away and worth the trip!!! Dined in and take out too!

Source: Google

Shawty_avakin Avakin

★ 5

The food is always delicious and the service is out of this world love this place

Source: Google

Carey Carey

★ 4

Source: Google

Colleen Kreil

★ 5

Great food and service.

Source: Google

Todd Magnuson

★ 5

Good as always! If you are in Hayward, this one place you don't want to miss. Always 100%!

Source: Google

Cory Lockwood

★ 1

My family and I went in, waited 10 minutes to be seated. We wanted pizza and salad bar, we were told the salad bar was closed. I ordered a 22 oz Coors light Nd it seemed flat. I dont know if it was pored and then sat for at least 10 minutes before it came to the table. My 22 year old daughter ordered a dirty Shirley temple could even taste alcohol in it and the same with the screwdriver My wife order. I hate vodka and I tried it and all I could taste was orange juice. WE CANCELED OUR ORDER AND LEFT. WE WILL NOT BE RETURNING

Source: Google

Mimi Sawyer

★ 5

Source: Google

Joan V

★ 5

Always delicious and good service

Source: Google

Bruce Henson

★ 3

We've been going to Coops for ages, and it has been fairly reliable. But of late the quality of the food hasn't been what it used to be, while the prices have soared. $13 for a chicken sandwich with chips seems pretty high for bar food. We had a party of 6, were seated immediately (and on Friday night, that's atypical, which may also be red flag). We each ordered the chicken sandwich and a Coors light, because the pizza crust resembles nothing like we've ever had in a pizza before, though this time it was better (I was offered a slice, and took one). Lately it's been more like flour and water with no salt or yeast. Our service was OK...the staff was small, so was too busy to get our food to the table hot. My wife ordered her sandwich with fries; it came with waffle fries that were badly overcooked, but the staff graciously deducted it from our check. But both chicken sandwiches were lukewarm at best. Overall, for us, a disappointing visit. The cost for two sandwiches and two Coors Lights each, less the cost for the waffle fries, and including a 15% tip: $61.19. We won't be returning soon.

Source: Google

Lisa Baxter

★ 5

What a wonderful place to have a pizza ! It was fabulous , great flavor and nice thin crust , sooo delicious ! The ranch is homemade daily and it's delicious dipped with pizza ! Cheese curds hit the spot , so cheesy good ! We had the best waitress , so kind and attentive ...I forgot to get her name , she did a wonderful job !

Source: Google

Grant Paw

★ 5

Source: Google

Cheri Shaffer

★ 5

Love this place !

Source: Google

Kyle Beardmore

★ 5

Source: Google

Becca Golden

★ 5

Source: Google

Bernadette McIntyre

★ 5

Source: Google

Wade Reier

★ 5

Source: Google

Heather Schmidt

★ 5

Amazing salad bar- love all the variety! Great pizza and friendly service.

Source: Google

Jeff Krantz

★ 4

Source: Google

Judith Titus

★ 5

Great, always fresh and timely!

Source: Google

Melissa Thiry

★ 5

Always a great dinner out, best pizza and service in the area.

Source: Google

Frederick The Planespotter

★ 4

I have to say, when my cousin ordered pizzas from Coop’s - I wasn’t expecting them to be great - mostly because it’s sort of in the middle of nowhere, small town Wisconsin. But I’ll honestly tell ya that I was pleasantly surprised by the pizzas when they showed up. Certainly not the best I’ve had but also nowhere near the worst and it far exceeded my expectations of a small town pizza joint in Wisconsin. I was also glad that they cut them into triangles (albeit small) - rather than the dumb Midwestern square cut. Overall, the pizzas were good - if you’re in the area and looking for a good pizza, I’d say Coop’s is the spot.

Source: Google

Michelle Carlson

★ 5

When we’re in Hayward, Coop’s is a must! It’s been our favorite for years! Great service, friendly staff and the food….so so good! 😋

Source: Google

Kayli K

★ 5

Source: Google

Michelle Ziegler

★ 5

Stopped in for a quick bite and it was amazing.

Source: Google

Jeremy Harshbarger

★ 5

Source: Google

Cory Bowe

★ 5

Source: Google

Troy Roberts

★ 5

Source: Google

Jake

★ 5

Source: Google

Jim Ksiazyk

★ 1

Source: Google

penny berg

★ 4

The pizza was really good. We enjoyed it. We also had 1919 root beer with Tito. So good.
Service was really pretty good, but as they got busier, we saw our waitress less, but really that was ok.
Our pizza was shrimp, crab, spinach, black olives, and feta!

Source: Google

ValoOrm BloodBane

★ 5

Source: Google

Heather Travel - Wi

★ 5

This place never disappoints. Great food. Always consistent. Tried something new with the pizza tonight. I got the Italian beef. OMG. So good. The meat was not fatty or grisly at all. Excellent quality meat and au Jus. Our server Heather.... Also fantastic! Keep up the good work Coop's! We love to visit every chance we are in town!

Source: Google

Lori Z

★ 5

Coops is our go to for pizza and beverages. Delicious all around. Staff is attentive, pizza arrives quickly, price is affordable. Love this place.

Source: Google

John Klatt

★ 3

Source: Google

Dawn McGuire (Big Sexy)

★ 5

I love the customer service. Above and be on for me.... thank you Alana. I'm sorry if I misspelled your name. Love Coops Italian Beef & Pizza, fries, of course the corn nuggets!!

Source: Google

Candice Pennings

★ 5

Great gluten free pizza and Grace was a wonderful server!! We will be back!!

Source: Google

Dianne Marsh

★ 5

Wonderful staff and the best salad bar I've seen in years! Thank you for a fun visit!

Source: Google

Ashley Hanson

★ 5

Source: Google

Deborah K

★ 1

We Went in for lunch buffet on our break, had to wait to be seated as we couldn't get anyone to seat us as they stood around talking, our waitress only came back to give us the check, no refills, didnt ask if we needed anything. pizza was sloppy and not very warm, the garlic toast was hard as a rock! We Could hear a woman in the back angrily yelling, The owner was speed walking around but couldn't get her attention and seemed to stuck up to "work" and just went to her office. We were very disappointed with our service! This use to be such a delightful place, such a shame to see what it's turned into

Source: Google

Kyle Loreth

★ 5

Source: Google

68vettemanjr

★ 5

Went here years ago, didn't see what all the fuss was about. Service was lacking and the pizza truthfully sucked.... Popped in today 7/25/25, the atmosphere was completely different, the fish tank is gone,seems better decorated and feels larger. The staff were keeping busy, little kids were running around which really made it feel family friendly, warm and inviting. The hostess Chloe was wonderful and extremely polite. Our server Lora H was very nice and checked in on us throughout our meal. The pizza is better made, definitely worth it! Even bought a frozen one to take home!

Source: Google

Jessica Gokee

★ 3

Source: Google

ann mazar

★ 5

I truly love the fried chicken and pizza is always great and smiles and service you is always wonderful.

Source: Google

Tina Modjeski

★ 5

Good was really good! I had a chicken dinner and my husband had a burger. My potato wedges were the best I've tasted. My husband's fries were great as well. All potatoes appeared hand cut. Great atmosphere and very kid friendly.

Source: Google

Jeffro

★ 5

The salad bar buffet is fantastic!
Definitely worth the money if you have kids ($1.25 for every year old).
The decor is awesome as well if you like Rustic atmosphere🤙🏻🤙🏻🤙🏻

Source: Google

Christine Conway

★ 4

Just cut the pizza slices in squares. Service was excellent!!

Source: Google

Brian M.

★ 4

The waitress checked on us a few times but, didn't really seem to want to be there. The food was good but, my friend didn't think his wings were cooked all the way and, my pizza could have used a couple more minutes in the oven.

Source: Google

Ryan Rittgarn

★ 5

Source: Google

Heath Eisen

★ 3

Pizza was ok, not great, toppings under the cheese made them less cooked but that's a preference. Charged $3.50 for a soda water. Friendly staff. Ok prices.

Source: Google

Steve Sires

★ 1

Not one to whine but pizza was good, Italian beef sucked

Source: Google

Seth Holte

★ 2

Food was ok, not the greatest I’ve had. My wife and I did get the burgers so the pizza might be a different story.

Source: Google

J. RO

★ 5

We are from Chicago and visit once a year. Coops is a must for us for pizza when in Hayward. Definitely check them out it you haven’t…they never disappoint.

Source: Google

Christian Stradley

★ 3

This place has great potential as the atmosphere inside and out, is great and it seems like a nice family owned and run restaurant that employs lots of kids (kudos).
We came for the buffet and the pizza was average, making it a hard sell for me to ever order their pizza off the menu instead - we waited 10 minutes for more pizza and the variety wasn’t good. Crust was too thin to make the pizza enjoyable.
The salad bar had tons of options, and that alone was worth the price. Ultimately $12 for an adult lunch buffet is good bang for your buck in today’s world.
We were disappointed with the food, but not the service, atmosphere or price!

Source: Google

Tammy Blocker

★ 5

Sat at the bar to have our pizza! Quick service and the bartender was awesome. Pizza absolutely fabulous and I’m from Chicago!

Source: Google

Damien Kinner

★ 5

I followed the reviews. Please treat yourself and do the same.

Source: Google

Janel Errthum

★ 5

We ordered for take out. Great service and the Pizza is 110% a must! The scotcheroos were a super hit!

Source: Google

Sarah Vardell

★ 5

This place never disappoints. Me and my girls keep coming back for the pizza, my husband and my mom LOVE the fried chicken here!! This is a family favorite place anytime we're in town.

Source: Google

Kim

★ 5

Sorry about the picture. It doesn’t do the pizza justice. We just couldn’t wait to dig in. We picked up a 12 inch Meat Eater and it was fantastic. We are visiting the area for a few days and we were just too tired to cook so we decided to do take out. We searched for pizza near me and this was the first place to pop up, so we decided to try it. Glad we did. Looks like a nice place to dine in as well. We noticed plenty of indoor and outdoor seating as well as a full bar. The staff was super helpful and friendly. We highly recommend Coop’s Pizza.

Source: Google

Krista Petersen

★ 5

Source: Google

Will LaBreche

★ 5

We've been going to Coop's for years, best pizza in Hayward. I have noticed they are short-handed quite often, be prepared for a little slower service and even a wait during the summer. Worth it though, don't forget the garlic cheese bread.

Source: Google

Christian Miller

★ 5

Must recommend. One of the requirements for every trip in.

Source: Google

Douglas Erickson

★ 5

Really great pizza crust - Thick, slightly chewy, bubbly. Truly wonderful! The sausage topping is chunky, but in a good way.

Source: Google

William Drawenek

★ 5

The salad bar is my absolute favorite. The tuna noodle salad is top notch, and the pizza is great. The pub style fries are to die for. Friendly staff and reasonably priced. Must stop every time I'm in Hayward

Source: Google

koolaide1964

★ 5

Awesome pizza and great service!! Ordered pizza via toast app and got 5.00 discount. It was ready and hot when I got there. I was greeted when I walked in and asked what else I needed with the pizza. Unlike another place that shall remain anonymous in town that I visited for lunch. I had to ask if someone could wait on me even though I was sitting at the bar and three wait staff were standing in front of me!

Source: Google

Kyle Jennings

★ 5

Best pizza around!!!

Source: Google

Tom Crist

★ 5

Great local spot!
We have been going there for the past 40 years and it has always been good. Miss the fish tank, but the remodel is nice!

Source: Google

Nicole Adams

★ 5

Really friendly service and great food!

Source: Google

Alex Talley

★ 5

The seafood pizza is the best pizza we have ever had. I highly recommend it.

Source: Google

Nancy Zalewski

★ 5

Amazing as always! Love the convenience of stopping to grab dinner.

Source: Google

Care Fletcher

★ 5

Service great, Chaz was awesome! Lots of seating, good pizza

Source: Google

Matt LaMotte

★ 5

Pizza was unexpectedly good. Crust was different than I've had before, but in a good way. BBQ chicken pizza was my favorite. Very flavorful. Standard cheese was solid as well. Great pizza spot in town.

Source: Google

Amy Page

★ 5

Always looking forward to visiting Coops! Great staff and food!

Source: Google

Dan Page

★ 5

The place has been around for years they have adjusted for the time but have not forgotten the old school ways the food is still great. It's a got to stop at whenever we get up here.

Source: Google

B Rad

★ 5

Nice salad bar and great pizza!

Source: Google

Cris Oelfke

★ 5

Source: Google

Liz Elm

★ 5

Waitresses were very good. Had salad bar, was great.

Source: Google

kayli kromrey

★ 5

Source: Google

Natasha Gossett

★ 4

Source: Google

Mark Ricker

★ 5

A wonderful lunch buffet!

Source: Google

Ken Ross

★ 5

Source: Google

Rita Lindstedt

★ 5

Frozen pizza to go is awesome to have on hand!

Source: Google

B Roberts

★ 5

Source: Google

Jake B

★ 5

Source: Google

Landrew Olson

★ 5

Source: Google

Troy Matanich

★ 5

The new owners really revamped the place and kept the same recipes we have grown to love over the years. Excellent atmosphere and the staff is excellent.

Source: Google

Juce Belle

★ 5

Source: Google

Martha Gibbons Krasean

★ 5

Source: Google

Kris Jenkins

★ 5

The chicken is simply the best. OMG!
Cole slaw is tasty and fresh.
The JoJo’s (potatoes) are tender and delicious. They k ow how to properly pour Guinness! What more can you ask for. We are coming back for sure.

Source: Google

David Easker

★ 5

My favorite Pizza Place near Hayward Wisconsin.

Source: Google

Stacy Bruska

★ 5

The lunch buffet was excellent and great service

Source: Google

James

★ 5

Source: Google

Amy Jacobson

★ 5

Source: Google

The Burger King

★ 5

I love coming to Coops as often as I come home to visit. Best pizza I have had anywhere!

Source: Google

Rachel Teschendorf

★ 5

Coops is a hometown favorite and the staff are always so friendly and smiling! Keep up the great work & even better pizza 🍕

Source: Google

Brittany Kowalczyk

★ 5

Definitely one of the best places and the absolute best pizzas if u don’t believe go check it out yourself me and the family will absolutely be making special trips to go there again

Source: Google

Liza Vitello

★ 5

Melody is the best

Source: Google

Shandelle Osgood

★ 5

Source: Google

Jeri Jacoby

★ 5

I've never had a bad meal at Coops! I love the lunch buffet. Everything that I want for my salad, different varieties of pizza, and garlic toast, too!

Source: Google

James Cole

★ 5

Great pizza

Source: Google

Karen Carvell Hutton

★ 5

Fun place and All you can eat, salad bar, soup, garlic bread and pizza 🍕 for $10.99

Source: Google

Marcie Funk

★ 5

We’ve been coming to Coop’s for over 30 years, and it’s as good as ever! The new owners have given the restaurant lots of TLC, with some welcome additions and updates, while the pizza is as delicious as always.
We always ask for Melody, our favorite server, who not only does an excellent job, but we also consider a friend. After months of being away, we saw her tonite, and before we even ordered, she brought our drinks just as she remembered. She’s a hard worker, kind as can be, and always makes us feel right at home.
Coop’s has been one of our all-time family favorites!
Clarence, Barb, Vince & Marcie

Source: Google

Carl Sattler

★ 5

What a terrific way to finish an elongated weekend. We met the owner who was dressing up the patio space with mulch and pride. It looks great! She was kind and welcoming.

Service was second to none. We had our young and relatively well-behaved Setter who was brought freshwater and courtesy as we enjoyed tap beers in frosty glasses.

Burgers were made to order and excellent. Not greasy, not dry. This is how I remember restaurants, a treat.

Keep doing what you are doing because you're doing it right. Thank you for making a good day a great day.

Carl, Sara, and Duchess

Source: Google

Crystal Belousek

★ 5

Source: Google

Jen

★ 5

Source: Google

angalee jacobs

★ 5

Sausage pizza bomb.com

Source: Google

Sheena Cain

★ 5

Source: Google

Kevin O May

★ 3

Just pizza

Source: Google

Trista Wiley

★ 5

The atmosphere is fantastic, the pizza is delicious, and the service is outstanding! Our kids love playing in the game room, and for our DIY event, the staff was incredibly accommodating. If you're in the Hayward area, this place comes highly recommended!

Source: Google

Scott loren

★ 5

We're else you want eat pizza

Source: Google

Sandra Vesel

★ 5

Salad bar was fresh and chicken was delicious

Source: Google

Chris Harris

★ 5

We eat there every Friday night with our grand daughter and it is always Awesome!!

Source: Google

Slime After Hours

★ 5

Top-notch service, friendly atmosphere, and fantastic food; you couldn't ask for a better place to go for a night out with the family in Hayward.

Source: Google

Sara Froemel

★ 5

Love the decorations when you walk in, greeted by staff right away, picked up a couple frozen pizzas very fast in and out

Source: Google

Greg Rosenberg

★ 5

Source: Google

Nathan Gall

★ 5

We always enjoy our family dinners at coops!

Source: Google

Bonnie Corbin

★ 4

Carly, our server was amazing. Absolutely amazing. Best service I've had since coops has been sold.

Source: Google

Erik Harning

★ 5

Source: Google

Matthew Garrity

★ 5

Best pizza in the area bar far.... highly recommend it

Source: Google

Jeff Szczerbinski

★ 5

Loved the AYCE pizza salad bar

Source: Google

Mona R

★ 3

Source: Google

C L

★ 5

Our hockey team had a reservation here for all the kids plus family, and the staff was very accommodating. Food is good, servers were friendly and cleverly handled the divided bills for our massive group by using the kids jersey numbers, which I feel was brilliant. Kids loved the games/arcade room.

Source: Google

Andrea Rasmussen

★ 5

Source: Google

Jesse Sinkel

★ 5

Really good pizza and salad bar! Service is great very friendly and accommodating staff. Decor is very cool you can see alot of time has been invested in attention to detail. We like to sit by the warm fireplace on a cold winter day. This place is awesome for a date night or bring the whole family. Our new go to place anytime we are in Hayward.

Source: Google

Melissa Rebholz

★ 5

Source: Google

Dominic

★ 5

Good pizza place

Source: Google

Michael F. Bulgrin

★ 5

Source: Google

Jeff C

★ 5

A quick stop during our travels. Came specifically for the pretzel and left VERY happy.

Source: Google

Rachel Pietruszewski (TheRachelPie)

★ 5

Best holiday decorations, cozy and family fun atmosphere. Best Gluten-free pizza I've ever had, at the whole thing to myself! Bar had phone charging options. Game room for kids as well as darts and pull tabs available.

Source: Google

Rick Beane

★ 5

Source: Google

Olivia Kriens

★ 5

Source: Google

peter gall

★ 5

Source: Google

Mason Fredette

★ 1

Coop's Pizza in Hayward, WI has been a cherished annual stop during a cabin trip I make with college friends. Over the years, we've witnessed countless changes—the removal of the fish tank, updates to the entrance, the opening up of the bar space, and, most devastatingly, the elimination of shredded lettuce from the salad bar. While I can accept change as a part of life, it comes with an expectation of integrity and flexibility.

The shredded lettuce was iconic—an unsung hero of the salad bar. Its absence left a void, one that I sought to fill during last year's visit after confirming its availability over the phone. I was promised that a plate of shredded lettuce could be provided, a beacon of leafy hope. Yet, upon arrival, I was greeted not with lettuce but with scoffs and indifference from the staff. A disappointment, to be sure, but I held out hope for redemption.

This year, I approached with caution but optimism. Another phone call, another sympathetic employee who assured me that my request could be met. This time, my hopes soared when I saw the taco pizza on the menu—surely they had shredded lettuce in the kitchen! But alas, history repeated itself. My polite inquiry was met with a palpable air of annoyance, and I was directed to the salad bar's uninspiring, leaf-layered alternative.

Let me be clear: this review isn't about the shredded lettuce itself. It's about broken promises, dismissive attitudes, and an unwillingness to go the extra mile for a customer. A simple plate of shredded lettuce—something they clearly have on hand—could have turned a disappointing visit into a memorable one.

Coop's, I loved you once, but your lack of care and follow-through has soured that affection. Until I see a return to the integrity and customer-first mentality that once defined you, I will be forced to reminisce about better days every time I drive past.

Source: Google

Loren Mustache

★ 5

Loved the atmosphere good experience I'd suggest try this place out

Source: Google

Dustin Olson

★ 5

Some of the better pizza I've had in my life. Light and crispy crust with some great toppings

Source: Google

M J

★ 5

Great pizza, salad bar and service.

Source: Google

Rob Nord

★ 2

Salad bar was at par. Pizza was my least favorite I’ve ever had - salteen cracker with toppings. Good spot to have a group. Easy going and nice service!

Source: Google

Kayti Forsell

★ 5

So friendly

Source: Google

Jerry Popp

★ 5

Very nice staff. Pizza delish.

Source: Google

Mandy Thayer

★ 5

Source: Google

Matthew “Bubba” Ford

★ 4

The food was amazing service was jus a little slow, for how busy it was.

Source: Google

Jackie Todd

★ 3

The food especially the broasted chicken was really good. Service was terrible. Server didn’t bother pouring drinks, picking up extra plates, napkins after a spill. Even the other servers who asked about our meal didn’t bother to help clean up table or offer assistance during a spill. I didn’t realize we should say we needed help after a spill, I thought it was obvious.

Source: Google

psphhh

★ 3

Source: Google

Stephanie Mallak

★ 5

We were all entertained until our food came! The kids played games, the adults gambled and we checked out the merch store! The restaurant and bathrooms were very clean. The service was great!
Oh, and the food was delicious 😋 I'm glad we have leftovers for tomorrow!

Source: Google

Peter B

★ 4

Source: Google

Jeremy Henning

★ 5

Fantastic, a must visit

Source: Google

Evie Walker

★ 5

The experience was very nice and welcoming. Our server, Amber, was very nice and checked in with us often but not so often that it was overbearing. The atmosphere was also very nice and clean and the food was very tasty and affordable. Overall our dining experience was very pleasant and enjoyable, definitely recommend and will return!

Source: Google

Otto Harrington

★ 2

Great atmosphere and service. Pizza was a lot to desire. Rather bland and little to no taste.

Source: Google

Dana Behling

★ 5

Source: Google

Dennis Johnson

★ 4

Source: Google

John Behanna

★ 4

Great experience whenever I eat at Coops.
Especially enjoy the service by Melody.

Source: Google

Pat Davis

★ 5

Source: Google

Ann Brodersen

★ 5

Source: Google

954Mike

★ 5

Their bone in Buffalo wings are the bomb. If they had a wing Wednesday lookout 🙏 wings are huge and cooked perfectly. Was really impressed

Source: Google

kari aderman

★ 5

Salad bar is excellent-so many options! Love the gluten-free chicken strips & the seafood pizza is the bomb!

Source: Google

Jason Carden

★ 5

Great lunch buffet and very good service.

Source: Google

Cheryl Gallo

★ 2

I just really didn't like the flavor of the pizza. It tasted very much like tomatoes and not a flavorful sauce at all. I liked the style of it though. Needs more zest.

Source: Google

chad nicks

★ 5

Source: Google

paul fackler

★ 3

Pizza place with log cabin, antlers, and stuffed heads decor. Food was fine. easy parking. Good service

Source: Google

zpoppe

★ 1

Source: Google

Dave Busch

★ 5

Source: Google

Shawn McCoy

★ 5

Incredible service and food!!

Source: Google

Michael Giesler

★ 5

Best Pizza in the area. Grew up coming to Coops. Also great cheese curds. Wish they were open later but it's a small town hard to find help. Very cozy atmosphere

Source: Google

Jason Brooks

★ 4

Place is awesome

Source: Google

Paul Swanson

★ 5

When in Hayward a must stop and eat at! Delicious food, great staff!
Love the cheese burger sub!!

Source: Google

Bob Beuc

★ 5

Source: Google

Ryan Cook

★ 5

Source: Google

Amber Whereatt

★ 5

We had a wonderful and delicious lunch at Coops. We each ordered a meal and added the salad bar onto it.

We ordered the corn bites appetizers and they were amazing.
Service was great! We'll certainly be back!

Source: Google

TRENT JOHNSON

★ 5

Source: Google

sabrina DeWine

★ 5

I really enjoyed the pizza from here. The corn nuggets were delicious. Never had them before until then. The server Carley was so sweet and very attentive. Definitely try!

Source: Google

Steve Wittorp

★ 4

Source: Google

Laurie Gucinski

★ 5

Great buffet!

Source: Google

Sunshine On a Cloudy Day

★ 5

Great food, nice ambiance, and plenty of seating make this a solid choice if you want to eat with two people or larger size groups. The food is fresh, hot, and really good, especially the pizza. The only thing I marked low was the service, but not because it was bad. The staff was working very, very hard, but they just don't have enough for the few times I went there this summer. I get it, and I didn't want to give the restaurant a lower mark, but I don't want people to get the wrong impression. It is really hard to get staff, and those people working were stretched. So you may have to wait, be understanding, the buffet (pizza) doesn't fill quickly, etc. But the staff is working hard, they are friendly, and doing everything to make your experience a great one. Honestly, the best thing you can do for this place is to give more, tip generously, acknowledge the hard work the staff is putting in, because if you want more & better service, you're going to need more people. The only way to get more people is word of mouth by the current staff, telling their friends how well they are doing in tips, so they come work there. Sorry, but that's the truth.

Source: Google

William Bartholomew (Will)

★ 3

Visited 5 years ago with an awesome experience, came back this weekend and was very disappointed. Service was amazing and the place was as great as I remember but what happened to the pizza? When it reached the table there was quite the pond of grease occupying the entire top of the pizza, was going to say something as even our waitress had a surprised/confused expression on her face bringing it over but we were starving - came a long way out and waited all morning for Coop's to open remembering how great it was last time. Anywho, the pizza was somehow so greasy that the sauce wouldn't even stick to the dough so EVERY piece we picked up the entire topping slid right off so we try cutting it and the dough of almost every piece shattered like a potato chip when stabbed with a fork. And with no topping holding it together we were forced to shovel it into our mouths like undercooked lasagna 😕 I was starving or that would have been my first time ever sending food back, well after getting home we tried reheating our take-homes since we wiped all the grease off before boxing it up. Sadly that wasn't good enough either, tasted worse, still fell apart, and now not feeling well afterwards......

I gotta say your mozzarella sticks are to die for, I'd pay for those again in a heartbeat but that $30 pizza was the worst we've ever had. Sorry guys but we won't be returning

Source: Google

Mary Niemeyer

★ 5

Chicken Alfredo pizza with onions mushrooms and bacon. Its was amazing! Had Bloody Mary and fresh fruit bar. My husband had pistachio ale.

Source: Google

Emily Freiburg

★ 5

Super cool little place, super friendly staff. Great food!

Source: Google

Madyson Egan

★ 5

Better than I even remember back in highschool. <3

Source: Google

James Wirth

★ 5

Sticky tables....

Source: Google

Scott Anderegg

★ 5

We spent the weekend up there and we're happy to find a place where we could bring our dogs. Excellent pizza and a relaxing atmosphere!

Source: Google

Kim Becker

★ 5

Fun place. People are great. Food is fabulous. Melody gives terrific customer service!

Source: Google

Traci Johnson

★ 5

Stopped in for a bite to eat and this place is really nice! Our waiter was top notch! Very professional and courteous and made sure everything was perfect. We shared a basket of onion rings and had the meat lovers pizza. The inside of the restaurant was very clean and decorated in a northern Wisconsin theme. Definitely will stop in here next time we’re in Hayward.

Source: Google

Music2Forever

★ 5

The buffet was surprisingly really good! Great salad bar selection! Pizzas were changing out and had half and half on some for more variety. There were even soups and garlic bread. I was impressed. Their iced tea tasted very fresh too.

Source: Google

Eric Lemon

★ 5

Very good place to go to eat

Source: Google

Amy LaBreche

★ 4

Source: Google

Raquel Harrigan

★ 5

BEST pizza! Thank you!

Source: Google

Dave Oman

★ 5

Source: Google

Irate Incel

★ 5

Always phenomenal

Source: Google

Michael Leipold

★ 5

Source: Google

Sara Jilek

★ 5

We have loved everything we have ordered but plan on allowing plenty of time. Orders take a while to get. (Worth the wait)

Source: Google

David Nuckels

★ 5

Source: Google

Danielle

★ 3

Source: Google

T RICE

★ 5

Source: Google

Kaiti Magdzas

★ 5

I love their AYCE lunch buffet. Their ranch is the bomb. I always buy a round for the staff for $5. Whenever we are in Hayward we love stopping at this place.

Source: Google

S K

★ 3

Food is expensive with not much flavor to it. Otherwise it was a good experience.

Source: Google

Anna Hagner

★ 4

Source: Google

James Stoll

★ 5

Source: Google

Robert Nielsen

★ 5

Best Pizza I have had

Source: Google

Emily Zei

★ 5

The pizza is always fantastic. The service is always quick and nice. The vibe is really fun and the kids love it. Plus the bloody mary's are delicious.

Source: Google

Curtis Johnson

★ 5

Source: Google

Mark G

★ 5

Even under new ownership, the pizza is still amazing... every time!! Love the new decor (miss the big fish tank but having more serving areas makes sense)

Source: Google

Betty Karas

★ 5

Great food and salad bar

Source: Google