Cousins Subs

Menomonee Falls, Pilgrim Rd Unit D, Menomonee Falls, WI 53051, United States | ★ 4.1 (160 Review)

📞 +1 262-252-3373

Last Search

Category

Sandwich shop Restaurant

Description

Cousins Subs is a Wisconsin-based, family-owned, sub shop established in 1972. Cousins Subs and its franchisees operate over 90 restaurants in Wisconsin and Indiana, providing guests with quality deli-fresh and made to order grilled subs using only the freshest ingredients on its signature bread baked daily.

Photos

 Cousins Subs
 Cousins Subs
 Cousins Subs
 Cousins Subs
 Cousins Subs
 Cousins Subs
 Cousins Subs
 Cousins Subs

Leave a Review

Reviews

Jean Baron

★ 4

Sandwiches were ok. Big turn off with the newish cashier with over built nails covered in rhinestones.

Source: Google

Kenneth Swedlund

★ 4

Source: Google

Hue Xiong

★ 5

Source: Google

Nickie Krysiak

★ 5

Source: Google

mike r

★ 4

Source: Google

Steve Blockel

★ 4

Source: Google

Dee Dee

★ 3

Both the employees the black one and the white one had no acknowledgement didnt really say anything The place was clean and the order took about 10 minutes. No hi no byes nothing.

Source: Google

Iryna Lebedyeva

★ 5

Source: Google

Tyler Hoell

★ 5

We order here often for pick up, nice you can still order thru a phone call, but the app offers more benefits and points and stuff so tryna switch.. idk my family been ordering from this place since I was like 10yrs yrs old. And it’s improving lately big time again and idk good job. Thank y’all

Source: Google

Ken Rose

★ 5

Source: Google

Robert Turfle

★ 5

Source: Google

Rick Schmid

★ 5

Source: Google

Bob Lindert

★ 1

Oregano does not belong on a sub. I specifically said "no Oregano". Got home, guess what, it had Oregano on it. Tossed in the garbage. Still hungry.

Source: Google

Jutta Hartlaub

★ 5

Source: Google

Amanda Day

★ 5

My boyfriend and I dined at Cousins Subs on 2/28/25, and we had a great experience! The customer service was excellent—everyone was pleasant, kind, and attentive. Our meal was made exactly as ordered, despite several special requests. Huge thanks to Tati, Ontaria, and Leasha for their outstanding service! Store #1160.

Source: Google

Erik Stabl

★ 1

It's pretty cool that Google is so nice to delete your negative reviews. The way I see it, I got screwed out of two free subs. The app is a scam. Double points on Thursdays. I fell for this garbage. The more you buy, the more you get screwed. I have been a loyal customer since 1982. That ended because of the app scam. Feel free to have Google delete this review too. I'll repost again and again.

Source: Google

Drew Kusick

★ 5

This was awesome,nice cashier, Loretta, and a real good job by the cute young grill cook, we both ordered the chipotle cheese steak and they were really good!! The only change I would make is a little bit less a bit too much but now I know, be careful how you are with jalapeno peppers, these were medium heat I believe and she didn't skimp, a very hearty Sandy, real nice job grill queen, you did real proper, will be back, thanks to a nice group of employees that day, 9/7/24! From 2 loyal customers, keep up the good work, cousins number 1!better bread, better subs! The twins

Source: Google

Ann Miller

★ 5

Source: Google

Kernel Jackson Van Blorch (King Nickels)

★ 4

Some of the better subs in the area, with fantastic fried cheese curds. Avoid this location during the lunch rush: the crew is good but the sandwich prep is slow and the counter area gets chaotic. Cousins still has good food, but rapidly increasing prices have decreased the value.

Source: Google

Andy Reed

★ 5

Now this is a REAL Cousins (only missing a drive thru) Staff is awesome the food is always perfect. Great experience every time I come here.

Source: Google

Drew Rusnak

★ 5

Source: Google

Bryan Radke

★ 4

Source: Google

Galilea Garnica

★ 1

Source: Google

Ziggy H

★ 5

Source: Google

Melville The Money Maker

★ 1

Employees don’t listen I specifically said I want in my sandwich Cut in half and it wasn’t done and it was clearly on a ticket and still wasn’t done. Employees walking around hair nappy not combing uniforms dirty lack of professionalism. Employees on cells phones with gloves on . Sandwich was good but service was terrible

Source: Google

Adam Phothisene

★ 5

Always clean location. Korina E was really helpful and very nice.

Source: Google

J Yang

★ 4

Source: Google

Joel Nazaretian

★ 5

Great subs and service!

Source: Google

Kathryn Johnson

★ 5

Source: Google

Luanne Burg

★ 4

Wish they still had the seafood sub.

Source: Google

Brenna Schultz

★ 1

Listened to them about there messed up orders and they proceeded to give me the wrong order.. if you want the wrong food. Come here.

Source: Google

Ryan Derry

★ 5

Source: Google

Everett

★ 5

I work nearby, quick food and very yummy yummy food yum awesome, I often get cheese curds or a 7in sub. Workers are very nice and quick!

Source: Google

Greg Eggold

★ 5

I love Cousins subs!!

Source: Google

Veronica Willis

★ 5

Source: Google

Sarah Boese

★ 5

Always delicious with fresh bread. Lobby clean and good customer service 👌.

Source: Google

David Seehaver

★ 5

Source: Google

Meka W

★ 5

My favorite sandwich spot, always fresh and this location was immaculate, even the bathroom was spotless! Kudos 👏🏽

Source: Google

Dale Kusick

★ 5

This cousins location and the employees never failed me! Great job!!

Source: Google

Antoinette Kirk

★ 1

Disgusting! STAY AWAY

Source: Google

kris duchrow

★ 3

Source: Google

Mark Kline

★ 5

It's Cousins! Of course it's delicious. 😁
This is a nice location and very clean.

Source: Google

Cori E

★ 4

Source: Google

Chandler Blomquist

★ 4

Source: Google

Dann Schaefer

★ 5

Only place I get subs.

Source: Google

Fabiola Huerta

★ 4

Source: Google

Teresa Thomas

★ 5

Source: Google

Joe Wendelberger

★ 4

Good service. Good food.

Source: Google

David Kingan

★ 4

Source: Google

Shamat Sheik

★ 5

Awesome experience, amazing subs,great taste..yummy!

Source: Google

Alex (AlexanderKole)

★ 4

Source: Google

steven campanelli

★ 5

Always a great sandwich.

Source: Google

Paul Sprtel

★ 4

Source: Google

Paul Marshall

★ 5

Good sandwiches!

Source: Google

Jerry Wick

★ 5

Ordered a italian caprese with chips. Was made fast and seemed to be prepared just fine as it tasted great. Clean store. Staff was friendly.

Source: Google

Renee shafer

★ 1

A bunch of teenagers that obviously don’t care.
I was overcharged for another sub and I only ordered 1.
The fries I ordered were inedible , I think the ridiculous salt that was put on them was done intentionally .

Source: Google

Kay

★ 4

Source: Google

Tom Turowski

★ 4

Source: Google

Tim Voelzke

★ 5

Source: Google

troy liebau

★ 1

Apparently this is the only cousins where they grill up your sandwich and wait till they package it before they cook the fries. So you wait extra long to get your items. This is why I usually drive past this location to go to a different one.

Update this is the worst location around. According to the owners comment below, they are working on problem. I went back there tonight, they didn't make my subs correctly and I called just to get attitude from manager. Claim want to fix problem but don't want to learn what is wrong. Afterthey remake the messed up subs, will be going across street to Jimmy John's where they know what they are doing.

Source: Google

Kristin Scherbel

★ 5

Cousins subs always top notch

Source: Google

Ellen de Gail

★ 5

Source: Google

Brent D Franke

★ 4

Great sandwiches.

Source: Google

Paul S (Paul)

★ 4

Source: Google

MrsTao 30

★ 2

Not the most friendly staff. Not very accurate either. But we still go back.

Source: Google

Sheree Hendricks

★ 5

Source: Google

Patrick Schwenkner

★ 5

Source: Google

Mike Hagen

★ 4

Good subs and friendly service. The cheese curds are the bomb

Source: Google

Randy Gilmore

★ 5

Fast lunch service

Source: Google

Robert Burgess

★ 5

Source: Google

Ken Wesley

★ 3

Normally very good, poor customer service. I guess I shouldnt expect it, but it wouldnt take much to say thank you, and how may I help you. To say nothing is a bad impression. I am a long time customer of Cousins. Most locations are great. Manners are not taught much anymore, but can go a long way.

Source: Google

C Novak

★ 4

Source: Google

Timothy Harvey

★ 5

Great place for a quick bite

Source: Google

Dana Zeniecki

★ 4

Source: Google

Jason Kroeplin

★ 1

Service sucked

Source: Google

David Schiffer

★ 4

Source: Google

Michelle Hoeppner

★ 3

Source: Google

Tory

★ 2

Source: Google

Caleb Chmielewski (Chimmy)

★ 5

Source: Google

Greg Zelt

★ 3

Source: Google

Alonzo

★ 4

Steak and cheese and on-time pick up

Source: Google

Ramona Griffin

★ 4

Source: Google

jerry valley

★ 4

Source: Google

Steven Johnson

★ 5

I don't get out here often as my house is gluten free. It still is a good value sandwich shop.--- review edited guess what subs are now available as bowls. I have not tried them yet but that is a huge plus for my celiac family.

Source: Google

Michelle Hoeppner (Bean)

★ 4

Source: Google

Steve

★ 5

Good food, good service

Source: Google

Claire Banks

★ 5

One of my favorite cousins. The staff is really friendly and efficient. The restaurant is always clean.

Source: Google

David B

★ 5

Source: Google

Laura Banaszak

★ 3

Source: Google

Dennis Arndt (Love-Riter DrWho001)

★ 5

Source: Google

Josh Kroeninger

★ 5

Best sub shop in town. Excellent food and service!

Source: Google

Brooke Schulz

★ 1

Source: Google

camouflage 4 the diverse guy

★ 5

Very friendly service young energetic group real clean

Source: Google

Diana Ortiz

★ 5

Love this place I like that they open early before I go to work!! Very clean and food is always fast and on point ♥️👍

Source: Google

A Google User

★ 5

Source: Google

Crystal Goodwill

★ 5

Source: Google

Michael Zeman

★ 5

Fast and got the order right !!

Source: Google

Daniel Tobias

★ 4

Source: Google

Brian Bayer

★ 3

Source: Google

Zach Fritsch

★ 5

Very fast service, the place is very clean and the food is great.

Source: Google

Laura Dailey

★ 1

20 minutes for 2 cold subs. I asked for no mayo, I double checked. I triple checked and it had mayo all over it. How difficult is it to make a ham and cheese sandwich? Ham and cheese people! Save yourself the headache and just go to Subway.

Source: Google

Tameka Mcknight

★ 3

Source: Google

Melissa

★ 3

Food tasted like cousins sub, good. The spinach was rotten. They forgot my chips which was probably a blessing in disguise. haha They were kind and put the extras on the sub as I requested. Pictured is the ad for the sub and the actual. Could of used more cheese regardless I ordered extra just seemed to get lost so order triple cheese.

Source: Google

Randy A

★ 4

Source: Google

Laurie Zimmerman

★ 2

Extremely slow service, waited 15 minutes for three subs. Cashier had no personality, not even a smile. Unlikely to go back to this location.

Source: Google

Rob Pfeffer

★ 2

Source: Google

Danielle Petty-Baker

★ 4

Hot & fresh food. I enjoyed it!

Source: Google

Barbara J. Rhea, Rehm

★ 4

Slow service the food is great

Source: Google

Gloria Kinney

★ 3

Good tasting sub but had to spit out gristle with almost every bite. Good service

Source: Google

Maureen Meer

★ 3

Source: Google

terry musich

★ 5

Source: Google

colleen radtke

★ 5

Source: Google

James Barber

★ 5

Subs come out very quickly and this location is always very clean. Today my lunch was a double cheesesteak, and they nailed it. Fantastic.

Source: Google

CH

★ 5

It's not Subway!

Source: Google

Kay Hogan

★ 5

Clean and quiet.

Source: Google

Uncle Jeffie

★ 4

Source: Google

Gary Gerard

★ 5

Sub was good!

Source: Google

Jacob Unger

★ 4

Source: Google

Steven Halverson

★ 5

Fast friendly service - clean location

Source: Google

Dylan Watkins

★ 5

Source: Google

William Mahnke Jr

★ 4

Source: Google

John Warnecke

★ 5

Source: Google

Vincent Smith

★ 2

Source: Google

Bonnie Maletz

★ 5

Source: Google

Dale Phillips

★ 5

Just the Best sub shop in the area

Source: Google

Dale Phillips

★ 5

Very effient had several coupons and they used them all...🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

Source: Google

Karyn Kraft

★ 5

Source: Google

sigmone julien

★ 5

Source: Google

Jonathan Lampe

★ 4

This is one of the recently remodeled Cousins and it's nice. The cheese steaks aren't quite as decedent as they were twenty years ago (and the fries in the combo are stingy) but really: it's quite filling and no one needs that much food for lunch anyway. They have a multi-drink machine but keep it pretty clean. Sandwiches are made to order and take a while but it's an expected wait. Bathrooms are OK until the wastebasket overflows (should probably just get a bigger container for lunch crowd). Table seating is clean and there are multiple places for up to four to sit in chairs (which is getting rare in remodels which often expect you to sit alone at a barstool). All in all, a pleasant surprise of a Cousins: I'll probably come back here a few times a year.

Source: Google

Justine K

★ 5

Source: Google

Karen Wagner-Mendelsohn

★ 5

Very professional, courteous and organized.

Source: Google

Bj Schmid

★ 5

Source: Google

Justin Anderson

★ 5

The subs are always make to the quality I expect from Cousins. The staff are friendly and will modify your order if you want something special.

Source: Google

Dawn Bardele

★ 4

Always good.

Source: Google

Gary Moilanen

★ 4

Source: Google

julie schmidt

★ 5

Source: Google

Krista Pykett

★ 5

Great vegetarian sub

Source: Google

nik

★ 5

Not much to say! It's one of the best Cousin's subs in the area

Source: Google

Andy Johnson

★ 5

Source: Google

Jon Streier

★ 5

Really good fries

Source: Google

micaela stevens

★ 5

Always have such nice staff and they never fail to perfect my sandwich!

Source: Google

Bob Wallner

★ 2

Food apparently came up for pickup and was Givin to another party that was waiting for cheese nuggets for the rest of their order. The other customer said this does not look like my order. A girl with purple hair looked andcsaid, yes that is yours. 5 min later the customer returned and said to counter this was not his order, girl was untesponsive. Customer asked if it was mine or another parties. I said, that sounds like mine. I asked the girl if it was mine, she did not even look in the bag, just said...yeah that's yours and went back to making sandwiches. No apology, no offer to remake the now cold fries or opening sandwiches. Very disappointing. On a positive the sandwiches themselves tasted good. The fries were a little light and a bit cold...maybe other customer try ed them . Not sure I want to think about it.

Source: Google

Sam Sobczak

★ 3

Source: Google

Jean Lauterbach

★ 5

Fast service. Quiet. Phone ahead or order online for take out. Senior discount. Single story, no elevator needed. Outdoor seating seasonally.

Source: Google

Mary Ziesemer

★ 5

Source: Google

Matt Wieckowicz

★ 4

Source: Google

Ryan Ziegler

★ 5

Recently remodeled

Source: Google

Ariel

★ 3

Service was slow and not really prepared for lunch rush but staff was still friendly.

Source: Google

Gina Johnson

★ 5

Great friendly and fast

Source: Google

Michael Darr

★ 5

Good sandwich, reasonable priced. Fast service.

Source: Google

K D

★ 5

Great service late on a Friday night

Source: Google

Charlie Wilson

★ 5

Came from cousins on hwy 100 and silver spring and they were a little busy not really but passing out wrong orders and woman wouldn't leave register until she received her meal... So I decided to come to pilgrem and silver spring and quiet quick friendly helpful establishment people working were GREAT this will be my go to cousins from now on f*** the other ratchet bogus a** one I mentioned thank you

Source: Google

joe speth

★ 1

Staff is very very rude, took forever to get my food and there were 7 employees standing around doing nothing, talking and laughing while customers were lining up i would never go to this location sad very sad!!!!!

Source: Google

Suzie Schroepfer

★ 3

Source: Google

Nella Bene

★ 4

Quick and fast, takes coupons from all over

Source: Google

Nichelle Hopkins

★ 1

Source: Google

Josh Eide

★ 5

I stop here often after work. It is a great cousins!

Source: Google

Kevin Kallinger

★ 1

I have gone to this cousins multiple times a month and it has progressively gotten worse and worse quality. The past few times I've ordered a meatball sub and that's all I've gotten just meatballs. No marinara no cheese just meatballs. now again I'm sitting here with this highly disappointing sub and called to complain. the manager just blew me off not offering anything giving a bs reason that its not possible and I'm lieing. I'll drive the extra time to go to a different one from now on

Source: Google

Tyler Hoell

★ 2

Well usually good, don't know why chick said they close at 830, when I'm pretty sure its 9... didn't feel like making another sandwich?

Source: Google

Rob Wellens

★ 1

I ordered a Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich. It arrived and was covered in Marinara Sauce. I thought that was strange and killed the taste of the cheese steak. They insisted that that's how a Philly Cheese Steak is supposed to be served. The manager came out and in a loud voice said that she heard the server tell me it would have the marinara sauce. I didn't know how to respond to an obvious lie. She never mentioned the sauce (I ordered from the board which doesn't list marinara (in fairness the printed menu does)). The manager then carried on further until (no doubt thinking herself 'Joan of Arc') dramatically offered me a new sandwich. I got the new sandwich. I found a hair in it on the second bite and perhaps coincidentally have a stomach ache now 12 hours later prompting this review.

Source: Google