Fireside Supper Club

Rhinelander, 6012 County K, Rhinelander, WI 54501, United States | ★ 4.4 (506 Review)

📞 +1 715-369-4717

Last Search

Category

Restaurant American restaurant Bar Fine dining restaurant Seafood restaurant Steak house

Description

Fireside Supper Club provides warm and friendly full-service dining that overlooks beautiful Townline Lake (1/2 mile west of Rhinelander WI on County Highway K). Specializing in steaks, seafood, ribs, poultry, and more. Offering a diverse menu, Friday fish fry, and Saturday prime rib.

Photos

 Fireside Supper Club
 Fireside Supper Club
 Fireside Supper Club
 Fireside Supper Club
 Fireside Supper Club
 Fireside Supper Club
 Fireside Supper Club
 Fireside Supper Club

Leave a Review

Reviews

Mary Louwsma

★ 5

Source: Google

Jon Bowers

★ 5

Thoroughly enjoyed this experience. Great view, great food and excellent drinks. All supper club style like Wisconsin does so well.

Source: Google

judy thomas

★ 5

This is what supper clubs are all about. Wonderful food, perfect old fashions and knowledgeable and friendly staff. Fantastic!

Source: Google

Toga Party

★ 5

What a beautiful place!
We found this on Google maps browsing restaurants in the area.
Kelly was our server. She was terrific!
Great customer service. We very much appreciated her checking on us and taking plates away. Not a plate sat at our table that we were done with.
Delicious food!

Looking forward to next time!

Source: Google

Nick Toth

★ 2

Be prepared to wait a long time and pay a lot for mediocre food.

Source: Google

Josh Rustan

★ 3

Source: Google

Tom Charapata

★ 4

Source: Google

Z

★ 3

It's a lovely location, but the food was rather meh for the price and hype. I ordered the french onion soup with cheese on the top and it was alright. Was hoping for a less goupy cheese than what I'm sure was American; it didn't help the texture. I ordered duck which I don't think supper clubs have any business cooking, but I had hope with it listed under 'Fireside Favorites'. There was no brine done beforehand; just an overcooked and dry but substantially meaty half bird with orange marmalade on the side. The marmalade tasted rather saccharine and one note which makes me think it was from a jar. It was plenty of food and marmalade and duck do pair is about all I can say positively. My wife got filet mignon which she liked just fine which brought the 2 stars to 3. I ended with a brandy old fashioned like you do and it wasn't really noteworthy or bad. Just meh.

Source: Google

Sharon Boldt

★ 5

Salmon maple bourbon sauce was great! Salmon was a bit overcooked. Great atmosphere and sertvice!

Source: Google

Dawn Miller

★ 5

Source: Google

Frank Teller

★ 1

We paid a high price for food that was sub-par. Service was poor. I ordered Italian dressing and got French. We ordered clam chowder and recieved some kind of brown beef and potatoe soup which tasted old. Waitress spoke very fast during ordering. I had trouble understanding her. My wife ordered a daiquiri with her meal and it arrived after the meal. We were seated too close the bar and repeatedly disturbed by other customers coming and going. Certainly not worth $114.00!

Source: Google

Kurt Mutter

★ 5

Very nice in place. Located in the shoreline of Townline Lake. Beautiful views. The service staff were excellent. The best chowder I ever ate. Our only complaint was my wife's baked potato was bad, the center had a black spot on it.

Source: Google

Deborah A. Elverson

★ 3

We had 6 people, 1 an eighteen month old, they sat us right away, but it was just opening. Three of our group had chicken noodle soup, all 3 said it was way too salty. One had the French onion soup, with croutons and cheese, she said it was excellent. Two of our group had ribs and chicken, the ribs were fall-off-the-bone good, lots of food, the wild rice was bland. It wasn't near as good as it used to be, and the prices have gotten way too expensive. And the sign said that they were short staffed so be patient with them.

Source: Google

Willow Adventures

★ 5

Dinner was delicious & filling! Ribeye steak and the peanut butter pie for dessert…to go!

Source: Google

Alex Christenson

★ 1

They can take the reservation, they can't keep the reservation. Food is usually great but service terrible. Covid ended 5 years ago.

Source: Google

Liara Jane

★ 4

Kinda pricey. Plates are priced at levels you'd expect fancy dining, but its a lil shabby garage of a place with low celings and poor lighting. Nice view of the lake if you can get by a window.

Food and drinks taste good. The service was ok, a lil "fakey" but that's probably just our particular waitress.

Source: Google

Frank Ventrice

★ 5

Owner Jen was great set up tables for 20 we all had a great meal. Thanks do much Jen all the golfers

Source: Google

Chris Hawkinson

★ 5

We went for our wedding anniversary, and everything was perfect. We even had leftovers for later in the week

Source: Google

Jules

★ 1

It was a Wednesday evening 5pm. Not greeted, just asked if have reservations, no, we were from out of town and were not aware. Hostess said it would be over an hour wait. She did not offer the bar for drinks or anything, just stood there. 🤔 We were turned off and left, went to Wally's Supper Club on Hwy 17 and had the BEST meal and drinks!!

Source: Google

Sharon Schmeckel

★ 5

Everything was great except the twice-baked potato. Mot much taste, think it was a frozen food-service thing. Definitely not worth the $2 upcharge.

Source: Google

Madison Johannes

★ 5

We got a table right when we walked in. We got out soup and salads right away as well. The soup was so good. The service was amazing. The fish and the coconut shrimp were great. I would recommend this to anyone who is looking for a good supper club to go to with their family.

Source: Google

Ashley Kalbus

★ 5

Great experience and friendly service. Food was amazing

Source: Google

Connie Hudzinski

★ 5

This was our first experience at Fireside. We made reservations in advance and were seated immediately. Our waitress was amazing and we didn't wait for anything. The food was spectacular. We will most definitely return again.

Source: Google

Jim Coursolle

★ 5

A great Northwoods atmosphere with exceptional food!

Source: Google

Gregory Beucher

★ 4

Source: Google

Janelle Fitzpatrick

★ 5

Source: Google

Ron Andrews

★ 5

Source: Google

Trish Crockett

★ 5

Source: Google

N Bruzan

★ 5

Best old fashioned in Rhinelander. Amazing food with attentive service. Can't go wrong! Do yourself a favor and bring the whole family!! (Always a good idea to make a reservation)

Source: Google

Bryan Putnam

★ 2

My wife and I stopped here for dinner the other night and we were disappointed in the food. We started with a couple of cocktails at the bar, the drinks were good and the service was too. We were then seated and were impressed with the menu and what was to be included with dinner. Each meal comes with both soup and salad, along with rolls and a mini muffin. The salad was a supper club salad, exactly what we expected. But from there it went down hill. We both love french onion soup and were excited to try it and didn’t mind the $2 up charge, until it came out. When it was presented we both looked at it a little confused. They brought out French onion soup with a white American cheese slice on it! The cheese proceeded to disintegrate into the soup tainting the rest of it with that processed cheese taste. For my main course I ordered the prime rib, which came out and looked good, cooked to rare which is how I ordered it, but they must have gotten a pretty tough rib roast. Biting into it, it was surprisingly flavorless and chewy. I also ordered the scallops on the side which for $15, they were pretty small for that cost in my opinion, they were just alright. I also had ordered the twice backed potato for a $2 up charge, I was shocked that they were able to change the color to an orange potato but also not add any flavor. My wife ordered the roasted duck, which came out incredibly over cooked. The duck had an orange glaze sauce on the side which was cold, which was a confusing choice we thought. The staff was nice enough and the ambiance fit the north woods supper club esthetic. Over all a disappointment, I would recommend going to Wally’s South 17 or Lizzy T’s instead

Source: Google

Deborah Becker

★ 4

Source: Google

Kyrie Kleinfelter

★ 5

Very attentive service! Nice atmosphere and view of the lake. Good food at decent prices. All in all a classic supper club.

Source: Google

Jeananne Takala

★ 4

Source: Google

Steve Rish

★ 4

Source: Google

E J

★ 5

Food was pretty good,we had the sea food platter and the prime rib. Made reservations and got seated right away with great service.

Source: Google

Mary Caya

★ 5

Source: Google

Renee Lieburn

★ 5

Reserved their downstairs party room for my mom's 80th birthday party. Eric and Jan were incredibly helpful, went above and beyond what they had to for renting their party room! I would highly recommend this venue for any of your party needs! Also has a lovely restaurant upstairs, great food, & a cozy lakeside atmosphere!

Source: Google

Andrew Schlei

★ 3

Food is average at best.

Source: Google

Andrew Moser

★ 5

Source: Google

mark hertich

★ 5

Source: Google

Lawrence F Ramos

★ 5

Service was wonderful
Broiled perch was excellent

Source: Google

Diane Liberto

★ 5

Loved it! Comfy atmosphere. Food was great!

Source: Google

Nidhi Johnson

★ 5

Super cozy cabin style supper club. All dinner entrees come with a ton of side dishes so it’s definitely going to fill you up. I got the wall eye fried fish and it was one of the best fried fish I’ve ever had. The batter was so light and crispy and the fish was tender and cooked to perfection. Highly recommend it! Be sure to call in advance to make a reservation.

Source: Google

Dawn Pitlik

★ 5

Amazing food and great service! Highly recommend.

Source: Google

alexis thull

★ 5

We'll be back!!

Source: Google

Tina Polzin

★ 5

Source: Google

Tristan Turner

★ 5

If you're looking for a nice five course meal in the Rhinelander area this is it. Love the ribeye. They also serve a variety of frozen icecream cocktails and sell their own Old Fashioned mix!

Source: Google

Diane Goethel

★ 5

Fabulous service, food and old fashioneds!

Source: Google

BloominRidgeFarm

★ 3

Have probably been here a half dozen times over the past 2 years, and have always been pleasantly impressed, until recently. The menu and staff have changed. The salmon and chicken were dry and bland. The BBQ ribs were dry and chewy with horrible sauce. So it seems that ownership/management/kitchen staff has changed? Sad. We've really enjoyed having our special occasion dinners there. Not worth the high prices anymore!!!

Source: Google

Robert Stolzman

★ 5

Source: Google

Nancy Lietzau

★ 5

Friendly ppl
Really good food
Reasonable prices
We love Fireside!!!

Source: Google

Paul Reilly

★ 5

Lakeside! Great up North atmosphere. Reservations recommended. Decent size bar. Service is excellent.

Source: Google

Beth Shampo

★ 5

Great dinner every time! Service is fantastic! We'll always go back there!

Source: Google

Rita Lemmens

★ 5

The food, drinks and service was the best!
Everything was delicious. Highly recommend

Source: Google

Donald Steffes

★ 5

Fantastic food! They give you so much food for your money. Beautiful view!

Source: Google

pastor lou

★ 4

Really good food, drinks and service. Lovely view of the lake. Recommend it highly!

Source: Google

Kim Duffeck

★ 5

Source: Google

Jerrod Boos

★ 5

Came in just 30 minutes before closing without a reservation and they had no problem seating and serving us a full dinner. The staff were extremely friendly and welcoming. The food was great and came out in a timely manner. This is the old fashioned supper club experience where you get lots of extras with your entree so come hungry! Also had great cocktails! Will absolutely be back again soon when we are in the area again!

Source: Google

Sam Spencer

★ 5

Everything was amazing. I had the duck and the orange sauce and crispy skin were delicious.

Source: Google

Glenn Woods

★ 4

Source: Google

Thomas Tushoski

★ 5

Source: Google

Ken Albridge Jr

★ 4

Source: Google

janet hoyne

★ 3

Had surf & turf and hubby had ribs. Food was good but not great. Very good drinks and service but probably won't return.

Source: Google

Lisa Howe

★ 5

Source: Google

Lori Hext

★ 5

Love going here! We went for my husband’s birthday. Great food, great service! Very attentive bartender and waitress. Food was delicious! Tried the garlic cheese curds for the first time, they were really good, not too garlicy. I had a ribeye, my husband had the NY strip, both were cooked to perfection (even though they had a sign up stating that they were training new kitchen staff). The onion soup was great! All staff that we encountered were super friendly. They even brought out a cake for my husband for his birthday. We will definitely be back again and again!

Source: Google

Vickey Schramke

★ 5

Beyond wonderful dining experience for me and my family. The food was fantastic, as was our server.

Source: Google

Ryan Thomas

★ 5

Great experience at Fireside. The view of the water was calming and pretty. The service and food were both an A+. The old fashioneds were awesome. Thank you Joyce!

Source: Google

EZ Dealers

★ 5

Great food!! Awesome atmosphere, great service.

Source: Google

Bob Thomaschek

★ 4

Very nice supper club on the water in northern Wisconsin!

Source: Google

Jeffrey Dries

★ 5

Awesome Northwoods supper club. The food was excellent, prices were fair, service was EXCELLENT!!!
A go-to for any North Woods vacation, date night, or anytime experience!

Source: Google

LB

★ 5

Great NY strip, cooked to a perfect medium rare. Delicious. Mixed vegetables hot and not overcooked. Great quiet atmosphere, knowledgeable bartender.

Source: Google

Chris T

★ 5

Traditional Northwoods supper club. I had the fish fry, but they got a lot of good stuff on the menu.

Source: Google

Christopher Lee

★ 5

Just stayed the night in Rhineland and found this great supper club. Get the French onion soup baked, the duck bacon wontons, the brandy old fashioned, the cheese curds. We got the surf and turf filet with scallops and the broiled perch for mains. Both were great. Would definitely come back.

Source: Google

Mark Berglund

★ 5

The bartender was great, super busy but didn't miss a thing. The waitstaff was also great, friendly, attentive, thorough on keeping us up to date on our order. Food quality was outstanding. Atmosphere was also great, knotty pine kind of a cabin feeling overlooking the lake. If you want an old time supper club kind of experience in Hodag country? This is your stop.

Source: Google

Rob Clark

★ 4

Source: Google

Dave Branstiter

★ 5

Source: Google

Richelle Beene

★ 5

The best fish fry and excellent staff. Hostess was awesome and had our table waiting for us!

Source: Google

Chris Kiefer

★ 5

Food was delicious, made a reservation before had and got there about 45 mins before hand for a few old fashioneds and the hostess made sure to check in on us as they had seats open early. Service was fantastic. Definitely somewhere to visit.

Source: Google

shirley gesick

★ 4

Service was excellent! My "king cut" prime rib was a bit small and excessively fatty. The wife's filet wasn't the greatest cut either. Dining area is noisy.

Source: Google

Jennifer Moss

★ 5

Source: Google

John bauknecht

★ 5

Best place in town to eat period and the owners are amazing thanks Jen and eric for being the people you are amazing people they are there for the people not just the business

Source: Google

Badskull15

★ 1

Source: Google

Matt Funk

★ 3

The prices are not equivalent to the food or atmosphere. The food did not have any seasoning and was very bland. My filet was average. The people are nice very nice. The steak was cooked properly.

Source: Google

Amanda Borcovan

★ 5

The best frog legs I've had in years!

Source: Google

Jerry McGinnis

★ 4

Decent small town country restaurant with a wide menu variety. Salmon had by otherS at the table was very over cooked. Fried walleye was good but vegetables tasted as if previously frozen. OK, but not great.

Source: Google

Adam Bates

★ 5

My wife and I came for dinner for our anniversary. We made a reservation and noted it was our anniversary dinner. They recognized that when we came and sat us at the best table in the house overlooking the lake.

We had the garlic cheese curds as an appetizer and they were delicious. I love French Onion Soup, have had it at least in 30 different restaurants and their soup was the best I’ve had by a mile.

We both had seafood and it was delicious as well. Our waitress was polite, attentive, but not overbearing. Would highly recommend and we will come again next time we’re in town. Thank you for a great evening!

Source: Google

Michelle Schultz

★ 5

Beautiful supper club in the lake. Great atmosphere & wonderful staff. Food was amazing, definitely going back!

Source: Google

janet krahenbuhl

★ 2

WAY OVERPRICED! Stuffed shrimp were very small and only 6 and maybe about 1/2 tsp of "stuffing" on top of each one. Rice underneath was literally swimming and drenched in way too much butter, which made it unappealing. I was still hungry, so I filled up on the cold bland roll and Ritz crackers. Watch out for upcharges on twice baked potato (+$2) and small cup of French onion soup (+$2).

Source: Google

Family Crosbie

★ 5

Great service, walleye, and view.

Source: Google

Kev Kah

★ 5

Difficult to pry a five star rating from me, but not this fine restaurant!! View great, staff great, food great. Classic Northwoods feel, superior food and service. I'll stop here Everytime I'm in Rhinelander!!! Thanks guys.

Source: Google

Rowen Pendragon

★ 4

Source: Google

Joanne Holzer

★ 5

Went for dinner and it was absolutely delicious!! Lots of food, fantastic friendly staff and wonderful atmosphere. Will definitely return again!!

Source: Google

Maureen Deisinger

★ 4

Source: Google

McKenya Haring

★ 5

Amazing steaks and very friendly service

Source: Google

nyc 2255

★ 5

My friend and I had an absolutely incredible experience at the Fireside Supper Club. We were attending a cross country ski event at the Northwoods Golf Course, and took a Thursday night venture over to Fireside. From start to finish all was spot on. Great ambiance, wonderful drinks, creative appetizer dishes, and absolutely fantastic Perch dinner entre. For as wonderful as the food was - the service was even better. We had a wonderful server, absolutely top notch attentive, professional, and great personality. Couldn't recommend this place higher, just GO!!!
Thank you Fireside Supper Club!

Source: Google

Xerxes Griffen

★ 5

Source: Google

Breleigh Robinson

★ 1

We were there for a half hour and I didn't even get my drink and the server was rude and I didn't even get food mind you we had a reservation

Source: Google

B Reichert

★ 5

Very cozy! Great service!

Source: Google

Deanna Longrie

★ 3

Source: Google

Geoff ShanesDrywall

★ 5

Always a great meal and great service. I love that it hasn't changed over the years. Love that you get breadstick/cracker basket, soup & salad with your meal. 5 stars for keeping it an original supper club.

Source: Google

William Zimmers

★ 5

Lots cool, like a cabin. Food = Food. A little pricey. Waitresses were nice and helpful.

Source: Google

Barbara Albright

★ 5

Source: Google

Sue Amundson

★ 5

Source: Google

Emma

★ 4

Great Northwoods supper club experience. The french onion soup is so good. Eating appetizers at the bar is good, too if you wanted to just drop in.

Source: Google

Bradley Kubiak

★ 2

Source: Google

Eric Cerkas

★ 5

Source: Google

Amanda fortney

★ 5

Source: Google

Pat Mueller

★ 5

Great fish fry.

Source: Google

Jim Schindelholz

★ 3

Too expensive

Source: Google

christine paul

★ 5

Source: Google

T Wagner

★ 5

Great to enjoy the supper club experience

Source: Google

Sam Gatzlaff

★ 4

Source: Google

Carol Wilhelm

★ 2

Source: Google

Kyle Backes

★ 2

I thought drinks were good and the place had a nice feel. However when the steak I had came it was very blackened on yhe outside but cook fairly close to right. Both my wife's and mine were like this. Sort of a disappointment.

Source: Google

Jillian

★ 5

Always good food!

Source: Google

Penny Antell

★ 3

Heard so many good things about this place. The view of the water was peaceful, restaurant was clean, Old Fashioned was great, and the waitress was friendly. I had the fisherman’s plate. My perch tasted fishy, frog legs lacked flavor but were tender. Scallops were very good and stuffed shrimp was fine. My husband’s lamb chops were as much bone as meat and were gristly but the flavor was quite good. The Baked French Onion soup was disappointing. The processed cheese on the top was melted but not browned at all. I scraped the cheese off as it ruined the soup fixed the way it was. Overall disappointing meal. Sorry to say, I won’t be hurrying back.

Source: Google

Tom Vespa

★ 5

Good quality fish fry. One of the best Saturday prime ribs dinners around. Good apps. MAKE A RESERVATION.

Source: Google

Reva McNamara

★ 5

Great to have a place that is still an old supper club. Great food, and service.
Always make a reservation.

Source: Google

Wayne Bennett

★ 2

Nothing special about this place. The owner is well intentioned and may think he has cooking abilities. The lasagna, chicken, and meatballs that I tasted were rather bland . Options are limited in Rhinelander, so this, in some ways, is one of the best of what is available, which is not saying much.

Source: Google

Madelynn Johnson

★ 4

Was over charged. Ordered petite prime prime rib got charged for a petite fillet. 4 tiny half slab? Ribs. $24 ???

Source: Google

Tim Brunette

★ 3

Source: Google

R S

★ 1

Source: Google

Jeremy Meives

★ 3

Source: Google

Alexander Schewe

★ 5

Source: Google

Kianna Meyers

★ 5

The food is always great, and the owners are very nice people. This is our favorite restaurant for family nights!

Source: Google

Nicol Ardito

★ 3

A bit disappointed. The French onion soup had a processed creamy cheese on it. Not what you would expect. The twice baked potatoes were a bit dry. Walleye (broiled) was good. Just not what I expected based on the reviews.

Source: Google

John Kerr

★ 5

Source: Google

Caryn I-Schwall

★ 3

We went for the Prime Rib dinner. Soup was the best part of it. The meat we ask for medium rare we got medium well and the ours we ask for medium well was rare. The cut sizes were way off from the size portions we asked for. They Kings were more like Queen size and the Queen was like the smallest size they offered. I wouldn’t go here again for the prime rib dinner again. The service was great but the food was not worth the price.

Source: Google

Rich Free

★ 5

Iconic Northwoods Supper Club! Food and service was excellent! Next time I make my way north I’m definitely coming back.

Source: Google

Justin Lewis

★ 5

Source: Google

Mary Hansen

★ 5

Love the prime rib. Always a delicious dining experience!

Source: Google

Arthur Suhajda

★ 5

Source: Google

Andrea Swoboda

★ 5

My parents had their rehearsal dinner here in 1962. Been a family favorite ever since.

Source: Google

Dave Brogli

★ 4

Ordered steak and it was overcooked. Sent it back and overcooked again

Source: Google

Erica Sauer

★ 5

Amazing as always!!!!

Source: Google

Michelle Rapacz

★ 5

An unpretentious supper club with a lovely lake setting, delicious food, and a great staff.

Source: Google

Nicole Russell

★ 5

Source: Google

Leah Lech

★ 5

Source: Google

BRANDON CAREY

★ 5

One of the only places around that has good fish any day other than Friday. Everything was excellent!

Source: Google

veronica higgins

★ 5

Amy was the BEST server and was well supported by the other staff. They all worked together to provide a great experience! Thank you.
Veronica

Source: Google

Deborah Lund

★ 5

It's a traditional supper club experience. I think the food has improved since pre covid. Enjoyed an evening with friends.

Source: Google

lori hoban

★ 5

Food was excellent. Friendly staff. Prime rib, baked potatoe, onion soup, salad horrs devours, carrot cake, and enjoyable time full of laughter and good conversation with my sister Sue and her hubby Rick. It was a bit noisy but everyone was having a good time there. Left with lots of take home for the next day. Nice view of the river where we sat watching geese and boats float by. Very busy place on a Saturday evening but the wait staff handled it well.

Source: Google

Lori Hoban

★ 5

Great food. Celebrating our 52nd anniversary with my sister Sue and her hubby Rick. Service was excellent. Very very busy tonight, a Saturday. But the staff handled it with a smile and quick attention to all details.

Source: Google

Roy Heilmeier

★ 5

Source: Google

John Ranieri

★ 5

Source: Google

Rosemary Dreessen

★ 5

You HAVE to go! Great service! Great food!

Source: Google

Leslie Hoffman

★ 5

Source: Google

Michele M

★ 5

Everything was absolutely wonderful, from the Lemon Drop Martini and the bread basket with mini Carrot Muffins, to the Broiled Fish Platter entree, to the after dinner Grasshopper! Plus, sitting by the window, we were able to watch a Loon swim & dive in the lake.

Source: Google

Jeremy Ekalo

★ 5

Went in right as it got dark so I got a short glimpse of the beautiful view out the window. Ordered the Seafood platter (scallops, jumbo shrimp and haddock) and accompanied it with a draft Johnny Blood Red Ale... delicious. It came with butter over a candle so it was warm and melted during the entire meal🤤which I thought was a wonderfully small benefit that went a long way. The seafood was fresh and tasty; the seasoning could have been of a better variety but it worked.

The service was friendly and experienced with the menu which really enhanced the experience. Inside had a cool lodge vibe with some great tunes on the speakers that made the atmosphere that much more enjoyable. I really want to try the steak next....go check it out.
{You get more than pictured, I ate one of each before realizing I should take a picture 😁}

Source: Google

Kathie Halvorsen

★ 4

Loud atmosphere

Source: Google

Anne Fenske

★ 2

Overall meal was ok. Mixed vegetables were terrible. French fries were not crisp. Broasted chicken was most likely fried, not broasted. Dessert was great. Being asked to leave was not pleasant. We had no sooner finished our food when we were asked to move to the bar. It would have been nice to have a cup of coffee. Plastic tablecloths take away from the ambiance

Source: Google

Thomas Quandt Jr

★ 5

Source: Google

Jess J

★ 5

Source: Google

Aaron Hoffman

★ 5

Went there for our 25 wedding anniversary bwoderful staff excellent food

Source: Google

Kt Grulke

★ 5

Source: Google

Stu Xfile

★ 4

Friendly people very good food

Source: Google

Linda Helmick

★ 4

Source: Google

Andrew Johnson

★ 5

Source: Google

John Milks

★ 5

Source: Google

Bob Baur

★ 4

Source: Google

We Catch Fish

★ 5

Great service from Amy. Prime rib was good, added the four large fried shrimp to the dinner. I also enjoyed a Manhattan from the bar. Will be back for sure.

Source: Google

Robert Timmer

★ 5

The Fireside is one of our favorite Supper Clubs. Always an enjoyable evening. Go and enjoy!!!

Source: Google

Kathy Bruhnke

★ 5

Delicious fish fry!!! Wow! Even better than some in the big city of Milwaukee! It was fantastic! So light and flaky! Thanks Fireside for a wonderful dinner up in the Northwoods! Glad to be home!

Source: Google

Dawn Spurgeon

★ 5

We have eaten here a couple of times. The food is pretty good. I am always full and often have a take home container. Staff was friendly and attentive. But what impressed me the most was the women's bathroom. It has to be one of the cleanest, most up to date public bathrooms I have seen in the Northwoods. I mean checkout any other bar, supper club, gas station anywhere and you will know what I mean. I hope that they will put in that extra effort to keep it looking this clean.

Source: Google

Joel Laumann

★ 5

Source: Google

Chad Olson

★ 5

Make a reservation on a Saturday for prime rib

Source: Google

Francesca Solis

★ 4

Source: Google

Lori Barber

★ 3

We just walked in on a busy night, our regular place was closed. We were seated immediately, and orders were taken. Drinks great, service great. But the food was not the greatest. We ordered the petite prime rib. It was mostly fat and it appeared to be just some shaved pieces of meat.might have been just an off night, but I probably won’t go back.

Source: Google

Bob Flammia

★ 5

Cozy with good comfort food

Source: Google

Ted Pittman

★ 5

Fun first visit with friends. Enjoyed the intimate atmosphere, definitely be back in the summer to check out the views of the lake. Food was delicious and Tina took great care of us.

Source: Google

Juan Michael

★ 5

The place, the people and of course the food are wonderful. If you're looking for a good old-fashioned supper club in the northwoods, look no further.

Source: Google

Caleb Reed

★ 4

Source: Google

G H

★ 1

Messed up the reservation of our large party, we had to find another venue.

Source: Google

Ron Wiza

★ 5

Source: Google

Angie Knapp

★ 5

Source: Google

Frank Cook

★ 5

Source: Google

Cynthia & Jerry Buffinton

★ 5

Source: Google

Jake Moore

★ 4

I've been here several times. Food has been excellent every time. Best french onion soup in the northwoods. Great atmosphere, especially cozy next to the fireplace on a cold winter's eve.

Source: Google

Caleb Meyer

★ 5

Great food! french onion soup and you can't go wrong with prime rib

Source: Google

James Thompson

★ 5

Went for dinner. Had reservations in advance. 5 ppl in our party. Waitress was amazing, got all our drink orders out quickly. I ordered the ribeye and it was cooked exactly to my liking. I think our total bill for 5 with bar tab was $200. Very reasonable prices. I enjoyed it and would definitely recommend the place.

Source: Google

Karen zettler

★ 5

Best evening ever!

Source: Google

Derek Thorpe

★ 5

Extremely good and prompt service, waters always refilled, very courteous staff!

Source: Google

Connor Showalter

★ 4

Source: Google

Ben Marquardt

★ 1

To begin, I worked as a chef for many years, I may be picky. However, my hash browns were cold, steak barely warm, and quite possibly the worst ribeye I have ever had. The baked french onion soup has processed cheese, ruined the whole cup.

Source: Google

Joann Wales

★ 5

Great experience! Food was great, lots of ambiance, and our waitress was topnotch. Prices were very reasonable too. Very friendly staff. Definitely will return.

Source: Google

Sherry Piraino

★ 5

Great food, views and service.. thank you

Source: Google

Erin Givens

★ 5

We had a great prime rib dinner at the Fireside! Called to make a reservation and we were told they were full but would put us on the list if someone cancelled. They called back a few hours later after a reservation opened up, and got us in!

The food was great, and you get all of the sides with your prime rib (rolls, salad, soup, potato, and a mini muffin)! More than worth the cost of the meal.

Beautiful view of the lake as well.

Source: Google

Dick & Sandy Skalitzky

★ 5

We really enjoy this place. It's close, cozy, great food and fantastic staff. Never been disappointed,

Source: Google

Gregory “Greg” Peterson

★ 4

Typical country supper club. Good food and good portions. Service was good and very accommodating. Facility is dated but functional.

Source: Google

Amy Jo Baker

★ 5

Source: Google

Lori Crites

★ 5

Source: Google

Don Allen

★ 5

Exceptional in every possible way. Drinks, French onion soup, seafood, ambience, view of the lake, service…

Don’t miss this place. But be sure to make reservations!

Source: Google

Dustin Ratliff

★ 5

Fast, clean, and located on a beautiful lake...

Source: Google

Spencer Kriplean

★ 5

Source: Google

Hannah Smith

★ 5

Best supper club in Wisconsin- real history. My boyfriends family has been coming for 3 generations. Great value for the food quality and amount. Friendly service, great atmosphere. Other supper clubs imitate and fail- this is the real deal. Would go every night.

Source: Google

Kelley Werner

★ 5

Was a nice place, friendly staff, had the porterhouse 24 Oz steak, was delicious, my family also had steak, so as far as steaks went, we all enjoyed are meals, will definitely be going back for sure, maybe on the pricey side for some, but saves me a drive to wausau, very good service and the food was good, had to bring food home, all of us, i recommend this for sea food and steak so far, if you go enjoy, and let them know Kelley sent you, enjoy also make sure to get a reservation, place is always full.

Source: Google

Mary Gauden

★ 5

First time here and won't be the last. Food and service were awesome!

Source: Google

Ronald Gauthier

★ 5

Great food and service

Source: Google

Wilma Tushoski

★ 5

Stopped in last Saturday night with my Daughter and her Boyfriend. It was a very busy night, and they were Totally Booked for the Evening,
" ALWAYS " a good sign !!
We were seated promptly, assigned a very tentative Waitress who took our orders, brought our meals to us, and checked to see if everything was what we expected. EVERYTHING WAS DELICIOUS !! Would HIGHLY recommend this Supper Club to Anyone !! Great Portions, Competitive Prices, and a Quaint Atmosphere that makes you feel Relaxed and oh So Comfortable.

Source: Google

John Collins

★ 4

Wonderful dinner. My wife had the NY strip and I the Fillet and Lobster Tail. Both were perfect. We had the Duck appetizers which we sent back for being undercooked but Wonderful experience.

Source: Google