Category
Fast food restaurant American restaurant Hamburger restaurant Hot dog restaurant Hot dog stand RestaurantDescription
Your nearby Five Guys at 2500 N. Mayfair Road in Wauwatosa is ready to offer you a classic take on burgers, hot dogs, fries, milkshakes and more! Whether it's using fresh ground beef (there are no freezers in our restaurants), double-cooking our fries in 100 percent peanut oil, hand-preparing fresh ingredients every morning or serving peanuts while you wait, we strive to provide the best experience each and every time you visit. With more than 250,000 ways to customize your burger and 1,000+ milkshake combinations, satisfying your craving is just a click away!
Photos
Leave a Review
Reviews
Laughing Man
★ 2
No burger alone is worth 20$ the food isn't that good enough for outrageous prices. I'm never going back.
Source: Google
Nicole Brown
★ 3
Source: Google
Kamila Schulz
★ 5
Source: Google
Quinsanity
★ 5
Never in my life have I eaten an entire bag of Five Guys fries, until today. Wow. Delicious, friendly, clean!
Source: Google
Kim Grossmann
★ 4
Source: Google
Matt Thompson
★ 5
By far the best 5 guys I’ve been to. Service is always great. Staff is awesome. Food out at reasonable times. Restaurant is always clean. Can’t ask for much more.
Source: Google
Tasha
★ 3
Overpriced. Its okay.
Source: Google
enderbrineloxxy
★ 5
the service is always amazing, and they make the most of the mall. always come back for fries and hot dogs. everyone who works there is so friendly and professional!
Source: Google
R B.
★ 5
Source: Google
Quinn Elliott
★ 5
Always a solid burger choice! Never disappointed!
Source: Google
Deangelo Gains Galore
★ 5
Source: Google
Alesia Hawkins
★ 5
Maybe upgrade the decor with a fresh look.
Source: Google
Sara Dahlberg
★ 5
Source: Google
Scott Lopas
★ 5
These are artists who carefully craft your burger from start to finish. The problem is once you experience 5 Guys, the bar is set so high that it's difficult for anyone else to come close. Then there are the fries that just puts them over the top. The staff seemed genuinely concerned that we loved our burgers as we were leaving. The response was a resounding "YES"!!
Source: Google
Kim Marie
★ 5
I ordered a patty melt, fries with drink. Food was fresh and tasty! I was pleased with their friendly, tidy and fast service. I noticed when preparing food they worn gloves. Thank you so much!!!😊❤
Source: Google
Ernie Pyle
★ 5
Source: Google
Maggie Ley
★ 5
Great staff! Friendly and helpful. Great burger and fries! Place was very clean including rest rooms. (Chairs although of very high quality were solid wood and a bit uncomfortable.)
Source: Google
Tony Galecki
★ 5
Best place on the planet with the best burgers and a fantastic GM
Source: Google
S B
★ 4
Source: Google
Kathy Crabtree-Brown
★ 4
Good burger & fries, the value meal was perfect
Source: Google
David M
★ 5
Source: Google
Beautiful Shabazz
★ 1
Too expensive 🫰
Source: Google
Mark Kastner
★ 5
Source: Google
Jose Flores
★ 5
Very good food.
I love the fries, is home made
Source: Google
Michael Prinz
★ 5
Was great everyone was nice
Source: Google
Mayra Chavez
★ 5
Source: Google
Sheronica McIntyre
★ 5
Food was good, service was excellent 👌. The ladies working were all clean and polite. When I peeked in the cooking area it was also clean. People like myself pay attention to these things. I attended the five guys in Mayfair Mall in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin.
Source: Google
Mauricio Tello
★ 5
Source: Google
Donte Jones
★ 5
Source: Google
Chehan
★ 5
Source: Google
Justin
★ 1
Go some where else. If you put in an order on the app, they will take your money and give you no food.
Source: Google
Carnika Reed
★ 4
Food was 🔥fries just had a little too much Cajun seasoning on them, couldn’t finish them
Source: Google
4SiteStudios
★ 5
Food was fast, fresh and gone in 60 seconds like Nicholas Cage. Good customer service and clean atmosphere. 10/10 this time. Special thank you to Avery G and who else was working.
I tried to take a picture but it was gone too fast!
Source: Google
Chris D
★ 3
I like the food here but not for the high price. We ordered 2 "Little" Cheeseburgers (which means a single patty) at $9.19 ea, 1 Little Fry for 5.19, and two small/regular cokes for 2.99 each. All of this came to $32. That is just too high a price for me when I can get the same cheeseburger meal for two elsewhere for under $15. Having said this, I did like the flavor of the burger, and the fries are tasty but not crispy. I understand this is their style, which has good taste, but they are too greasy for me. There are salted peanuts for you to grab while you wait for your order, and these are yummy.
The location is in Mayfair Mall, with an outside entrance which is nice. There are several tables of different sizes and the young man at the counter was very friendly and nice.
Source: Google
B G
★ 5
Love the personalities working! Don't forget the smiles, thanks.
Source: Google
T WILL
★ 5
5 guys Mayfair employees, kudos! I wanna let you know you did a great job. I ordered a classic combo meal, but it was far from ordinary. The fries were Real potatoes freshly cut and fried to perfection. They were very lightly seasoned, but the malt vinegar put them over the top. (they gave an abundant amount) We left none. I almost couldn't stop eating my fries to start on my burger, which was a decent size for a single, but it was so juicy and flavorful it blew my taste buds away. I added bacon and all the free toppings I desired; lettuce, fried onions, pickle, mushroom, mayo & mustard. We completely enjoyed it, even the peanuts were good &the raspberry iced tea also. I hadn't been in a while, but you best believe, we'll be back soon. Keep doing what you're doing!
Source: Google
Suzanne P.
★ 5
We consistently receive great food and service at this location. Their burgers and fries are the best! Their fries are the only fries I've had that still taste really good, even after they've gone cold (weird but true observation lol) Great job, Five Guys at Mayfair 😀
Source: Google
Elizabeth Aldrich
★ 2
So let's just open 10 to 15 minutes late because we feel like it....
Source: Google
Heather Nanke
★ 5
Source: Google
Na Maya
★ 5
Gave me my large drink as compliment for a slight wait. Very helpful staff and quick location.
Source: Google
James Giggar
★ 4
Excellent place to get a bite to eat
Source: Google
Tessa Brannon
★ 5
After an error in our to go order that resulted in us having to return to this location, the team at Mayfair went above and beyond to make it right and correct our order. Easily the best experience we’ve ever had at a five guys! Compliments to the management staff that was on duty today between 6pm and 8pm in their handling of the situation and their customer service! Will definitely go back to this location. Thanks for a great dining experience!
Source: Google
Alan Dempsey
★ 5
The staff there are great
Source: Google
Eddie Estacio
★ 5
Source: Google
Shell Baker
★ 5
Source: Google
Jessica Mastenbrook
★ 5
Source: Google
paramjeet kharag
★ 5
Source: Google
Tata2forgone
★ 4
Source: Google
Randall Prochnow
★ 1
Be careful they up sell very easily me and my bud went in ordered bacon cheeseburger each with fries. 41 bucks later found out they were doubles and not a lot of fun to eat
Source: Google
Julie Simon
★ 5
Went today about 1:45pm for lunch. Was greeted by cook when came in and the server that took our order was friendly and helpful. Love seeing workers smile. We ordered 2 cheeseburgers, large fry, 2 shakes. Bill was about $44.00. A little steep but it was very delicious. Yes, I would do it again.
Source: Google
Krysten Rhoades
★ 3
Source: Google
Stephanie Decker
★ 5
Source: Google
Jaime Olave
★ 5
Source: Google
Joel Levison
★ 4
Source: Google
Steven LeBre
★ 5
Awesome all around!
Source: Google
Maryan Pelland
★ 5
Source: Google
Bobby Langston
★ 4
Source: Google
Itzel Rodriguez
★ 5
Las hamburguesas están muy ricas, puedes tomar cacahuates sin problemas, son deliciosos!
Source: Google
Joe Haselwander
★ 5
Source: Google
Kelly Marchese
★ 5
Source: Google
Travis Hartwig
★ 5
Source: Google
Max Starr
★ 5
This was a great five guys experience. The store was on point, and everything seemed to be super dialed in. Edwin was super friendly and went above and beyond with my kids. Found my new favorite location!
Source: Google
chloe staubin
★ 5
Great food and service! Avery helped take care of us and the rest of the staff was awesome as well! Definitely recommend the strawberry Oreo shake!
Source: Google
ctarmijo34
★ 5
They were super amazing and the staff was extremely nice! Definitely gonna have to come back here very soon again. The atmosphere was super fun!
Source: Google
Alesia Hawkins
★ 5
Source: Google
Luke
★ 5
Source: Google
Carol Ann Brookshire
★ 3
Source: Google
Emily
★ 3
Food is good but prices are out of control. Over $7 for a small grilled cheese. No way Milwaukee should be higher priced than the Five Guys in Dubai. On top of sky high prices for being fast food, they ask for a tip. Just not worth the price anymore.
Source: Google
Angie Andre
★ 5
Soooo many crispy fries! And that bacon cheeseburger is yummy! (A little pricey fyi)
Source: Google
Adam Morgan
★ 5
Source: Google
Surasack Bounmy
★ 5
Great burger combinations
Source: Google
Amy Nielsen
★ 5
Love this place! Excellent food and always friendly staff!
Source: Google
Charles Switala
★ 3
Source: Google
Mary Whitaker
★ 5
Source: Google
robert rob
★ 5
Good customer service good job.
Source: Google
Eugene Vitavskiy
★ 1
Source: Google
Jose Nunez
★ 2
Source: Google
Gary Raleigh
★ 5
Best 5 guys I have ever been to.
Source: Google
Marcelo De La Cruz
★ 1
2 d*** expensive.
Source: Google
Tru East
★ 5
Source: Google
E
★ 4
Source: Google
Tramacia McMurtry
★ 5
Source: Google
Stefan Hauge
★ 4
Great burger, no shortage of fries, they just needed a reminder that I ordered them
Source: Google
Stephanie Caldwell
★ 5
Burgers are greasy but really good.
Source: Google
mario hawkins
★ 5
Good 👍
Source: Google
Claire
★ 5
Great service!
Source: Google
kameron Taylor (Kam)
★ 5
Source: Google
Clifton Thomas
★ 4
Was put on to getting a grilled cheese w/patty!! 🤯👌🏾⚡
Source: Google
Amy H
★ 4
Babyyyyyyy when I tell you 5 guys is high as giraffe pu55y I mean it. $46 for three burgers, three sodas and a fry...crazy! Service was great and so was the food. The price had me thinking we should have ate cereal at home.
Source: Google
travis martinez
★ 4
Source: Google
James Johnson (Jammer Z28)
★ 5
Hamburgers and cheese burgers are amazing, not to mention the French fries that are incredible. They give you a lot of fries even if you order a small!
Source: Google
paul montoya
★ 5
Source: Google
Mark Haleen
★ 4
Source: Google
Sayem Ahmed
★ 5
Delicious burgers
Source: Google
Nabeel Beg
★ 5
Source: Google
Jey Laster
★ 5
Source: Google
Armani Henderson
★ 5
Fast service
Source: Google
Alice Parrish
★ 5
Source: Google
Tierra Wigley-Boyd
★ 5
Best Burgers Ever!
Source: Google
peedanie
★ 4
Source: Google
EB
★ 5
Over priced for a burger but a pretty good burger
Source: Google
Kelly MacDaniel
★ 1
Got my fingers burned because they dumped hot Fries from a 360° fryer on top of the burger in the same bag. Paid $25 dollars to get burned and be told "that's how corporate wants it done."
Source: Google
Antonio Medina Jr (Accreditedlion83)
★ 1
Don't pay for this
Source: Google
Kathie Halvorsen
★ 4
Source: Google
Duke Ketchell
★ 4
Fresh every thing every time
Source: Google
Sonia KILAMA
★ 5
Source: Google
A Wand
★ 5
Source: Google
Kayla Matusinec
★ 5
Source: Google
shalanna121
★ 3
There burger was okay not out of this world, like an average burger to me.
Source: Google
Jessica St Louis
★ 2
So greasy
Source: Google
db4l bully family
★ 5
Source: Google
Jenny Logan
★ 4
Source: Google
Brian Matha
★ 4
Very delicious burgers, but 40 bucks for 2 people, come on really. Probably won't go again
Source: Google
Mary Provance
★ 3
Too expensive
Source: Google
SpideyBog
★ 5
Source: Google
Andrew Reichel
★ 5
This place is really popular and is always busy. The burgers are always a pleasant experience because there are multiple combinations to choose from for your taste buds. I recommend 5 Guys to everyone who wants the best burger in the city!
Source: Google
Dunsy Haynes
★ 3
Source: Google
Haitian Dru
★ 4
Source: Google
Kiryu Kazama
★ 4
Source: Google
Rhonda R
★ 4
Employees were nice but the food was just ok and overpriced so I won't be back for a while
Source: Google
Michael Leibundgut
★ 5
Yum
Source: Google
Robin
★ 5
This place dipped in quality for a while but I was impressed this time around. The price is still more than we can afford frequently but this trip felt worth it.
Source: Google
Ronald McChristy
★ 5
You can make a meal for two out of one large French fry.
Source: Google
tessa even
★ 5
The cajun fries are the best. The burgers are good.
Source: Google
Lily Robinson
★ 5
Source: Google
alex blaszczyk
★ 5
Good all the time Cheeseburgers are outstanding So many fries.
Source: Google
Jennifer Burkett
★ 4
Source: Google
Michael Wielebski
★ 1
Found a piece of a plastic bag in my burger! So gross. This was done maliciously by one of the three workers. The employees were snickering at us because one of us is Trans! Felt very uncomfortable and should have listened to our instincts and not have even ordered because we felt unwelcome from the start. I will say the the shift supervisor was apologetic and gave us our money back, she was the only good employee!
Source: Google
Brandy Hanold
★ 1
Gross
Source: Google
Sgdc Ffdgd
★ 1
Put a piece of plastic in my partners burger after making snickering comments towards me.
I'm transgender and it's pretty Frick obvious. I watched them the whole time while they mumbled and snickered about what they were doing.
We have videos and pictures.
Oh yeah!!!
We called the police department.
Source: Google
Immanuel Sostre
★ 5
Source: Google
Rob Forsman
★ 5
Source: Google
Jay bone
★ 1
There prices is to high. 15 bucks for a double cheeseburger. McDonald's big Mac's better
Source: Google
Christine Jenkins
★ 2
Food is not worth the price
Source: Google
Brenda Sykes
★ 5
The burgers are great!
Source: Google
Gary Lancina
★ 4
Source: Google
R C
★ 5
Source: Google
Bob Kedz
★ 4
Had the fries, Great! I have CeliC Desease, so I need dedicated gluten-free fryers.
Source: Google
Evie Danecki
★ 1
Source: Google
Belinda Robinson
★ 5
Source: Google
Sourabh K
★ 4
Source: Google
IShell Baker
★ 5
Source: Google
Terrell
★ 5
Source: Google
RAVEN
★ 3
Food is ok
Source: Google
Wendy Washington
★ 5
Source: Google
Ignacio Carbajal
★ 5
Source: Google
Larry S
★ 5
The manager at this location (guy with blonde hair) is absolutely amazing and does a great job! Excellent customer service and always keeps a clean and tidy store!!!!
Source: Google
milset Rhodes
★ 5
I love this restaurant very clean good food and good service
Source: Google
Heather Kottke
★ 4
Fries are amazing. Burgers are okay, just need to try a couple times before I give it a five star
Source: Google
Brittany Williams
★ 5
Source: Google
Maria Garza
★ 5
Source: Google
Talara Hartman
★ 3
The burger was OK at best, The fries were strangely undercooked, soggy, and burnt. 6 pm ish most tables are unoccupied and dirty. Waited about 15 minutes no one came out to clean tables down. Lots of talking & phone activity behind the counter.
Source: Google
Maria Morales
★ 4
Source: Google
Baron Walker
★ 3
Source: Google
Bridget Bartleson
★ 4
Source: Google
machined horizons
★ 4
👍 👍 thumbss
Source: Google
pacman kells
★ 5
Food is good and customer service on point. I just feel the burger and food I bought was worth $18 though lol.
Source: Google
A M
★ 3
The bacon burger I had was good enough, but the prices are quite high. Even Kopps burgers are tastier but less expensive (and bigger) than Five Guys. The Cajun fries were fire 🔥 though so at least they have that going for them
Source: Google
daniel ketterhagen
★ 1
Source: Google
Dylan Congelosi
★ 5
Source: Google
scotty moore
★ 4
Source: Google
kimberly carrington-fields
★ 4
My first time there
Source: Google
NikNak S.
★ 5
Source: Google
Nathaniel Iler
★ 5
Source: Google
Mary Ly
★ 4
Food was great but that was all
Source: Google
Andrea Sluss
★ 4
Source: Google
Otha Washington
★ 3
Source: Google
Coretta Jones
★ 3
Source: Google
Rob Forrest
★ 4
The burgers and fries were good. The service was fast and friendly. Very noisy inside.
Source: Google
Jerailyn Jones
★ 5
Source: Google
Michael Fischer
★ 5
I know it is a burger chain but it is the best burger around.
Source: Google
Kim Swille
★ 5
Source: Google
Ralph Bellamy Jr
★ 5
Source: Google
Todd Potter
★ 3
Not the huge.and loaded burger I remember when it first opened. Oh well.
Source: Google
The Reel Joseph
★ 4
Good burgers..a lil greasy...the chocolate shake is very good
Source: Google
Bruce Sturman
★ 5
Source: Google
Ismael Mercado
★ 5
Source: Google
Karly Smith
★ 5
Good is good. Love there milk shakes.
Source: Google
Louie Salads
★ 4
Source: Google
William komorowski
★ 4
Source: Google
bk
★ 3
Source: Google
Nathan
★ 3
Good food but damn... this place got ghetto fast
Source: Google
Julie Dudzik
★ 5
Source: Google
Vic
★ 3
Source: Google
Anthony Jackson
★ 3
Source: Google
Colleen Beisbier
★ 3
Food was good, cheeseburger was very big. I wasn't expecting 2 patties on a standard order. Next time I would get one patty. FF were hot and I ordered a small, but my bag was FULL of fries. I threw most of them away since I was dining alone. Too much food. The small fry order appeared like it should fill a small paper cup for $5. That's too much $$$. But $5 for the amount of fries I got was good had I been with my family. I'm not sure that's typical though. My meal was over $20 for cheeseburger, FF, and a drink. That's too rich for me. It was good, but at that price I won't go back. The restaurant was near the big mall entererance and it was very cold in there. I took my food to go. Too cold to eat in.
Source: Google
Eduardo Vega
★ 5
Source: Google
Kim Zagar
★ 5
Source: Google
Matt Chasco
★ 5
Source: Google
Sindi Mejia
★ 5
Source: Google
Randy Warren (Ghostrider)
★ 4
I love their food. It's filling yet tastes good. You can get your burgers practically any way you want it dressed with any number of condiments or toppings. On my way home from the doctor's office on January 30, I picked up some lunch from there. Double Pattie bacon burger( no cheese) , A-1 steak sauce, grilled onions, and sweet relish with the fries that taste better than where I work, which is McDonald's!
Source: Google
Diana Rosado
★ 5
Food was good, staff was fast and clean. Good when you don't want to eat in a regular fast food.
Source: Google
The Melanie Moments
★ 4
Food was good, but this guy cleaning kept getting in my way twice, I had my tray set by the soda fountain and starts to clean as I was trying to get my drink, and when I was getting ready to sit down with my tray already on the table he started to get in my way more and started to clean as I was starving and ready to eat. Please don’t clean while others are trying to sit or get their stuff ready!
Source: Google
Moe 8732
★ 5
Source: Google
Alex Gooding
★ 5
Source: Google
Jessica Byron
★ 5
Source: Google
Linda Stevens
★ 1
Everything was so greasy Cheeseburgers tasted like the grillThe Fry's was soaking with grease and nothing but Cajun It cost me $25 Just to get there so $75 for nothing
Source: Google
Ecallio Calloway
★ 5
Price it up there but good quality food
Source: Google
Caleb Gepner (Lyrical_Caleb)
★ 1
Got food poisoning after eating five guys, it was good burger but not a good first time at all.
Source: Google
J Foodie “J Foodie”
★ 5
The fries are the best, burgers are delicious as always.
Source: Google