Grill 164

Oconomowoc, 164 E Wisconsin Ave, Oconomowoc, WI 53066, United States | ★ 4.3 (368 Review)

📞 +1 262-567-6023

Last Search

Category

Bar & grill Fine dining restaurant Restaurant

Photos

 Grill 164
 Grill 164
 Grill 164
 Grill 164
 Grill 164
 Grill 164

Leave a Review

Reviews

S G

★ 5

Source: Google

Olivia

★ 4

The food is amazing at lunch, and the waitress is amazing! I went for dinner once on my birthday and my food was greasy, but it's usually a great place to go!

Source: Google

Sue Riemer

★ 4

Source: Google

Sheree Hendricks

★ 5

Loved the prime rib!

Source: Google

Jim Luty

★ 3

I ordered the Fried Clam Appetizer and was probably the worse ever, portion size was OK, but if not for the sprinkled parmesan on top lacked any flavor and over hall were no larger than a cherry pit. And probably left 1/4 on the plate to be thrown out. I did mention my disappointment and she to sell me something in addition to what I had ordered. I would NOT recommend coming there with a reservation.

Source: Google

Arlen Brunsvold

★ 5

Very friendly staff with excellent food!

Source: Google

Dan Wilhelm

★ 1

To be 100% honest… didn’t even get to try the food. I took my father, son and a friend and as we entered immediately sat at the bar. My first impression was clean and positive. Ordered drinks and food and as we waited I tossed some money in a gambling machine. Within 5 mins I won $100 bucks and I returned to the bar to collect… NO BIG WINNER OR LOSER. The bar tender immediately became combative and accused me of both not following directions and lying over a hundred dollars… OK. I literally told her at that point to “get out of my presence” after accusing me of lying… I was so offended I got up and walked out!!!! Very weird experience!!!!!! They must need money apparently? Sad

Source: Google

Laira Bell

★ 5

Source: Google

Wendy Quinn

★ 4

Good baked fish

Source: Google

John Thompson

★ 5

WOW!!! What a positive lunch experience. Stopped to eat and was welcomed by the hostess/ bartender with big smiles.
EXCELLENT menu. A real porkchop sandwitch for 9.00!!! Great burgers starting for 8.00. With drinks and 20% tip 4 guys got out for 15.00 each.
We will be backhand you should stop in.

Source: Google

alida morales

★ 5

Source: Google

Lori Stange

★ 4

Source: Google

Tim Krause

★ 5

Had take out from Grill 164, first time eating there. The perch was excellent and the add-on piece of cod was very good as well. The wife liked her burger, too. Food was ready well before the time I was given, which was greatly appreciated. While waiting, noticed a very good selection of bourbon & whiskey behind the bar. We will be back!

Source: Google

Paul Heller

★ 5

The pan fried lake perch was delicious. Service was prompt and on prompt and on point. Will have to stop in again and try something other than the fish fry.

Source: Google

j2mutch

★ 5

Packed for a Tuesday evening.
The service was challenged but successfully rose to the occasion!
The bartender and manager tended to the full bar as well as serving all tables!

Source: Google

Mike F

★ 5

Source: Google

Kory Garbelman

★ 1

They don’t honor reservations online. Booked for a group and called an hour before arrival and they said they couldn’t accommodate our party.

Source: Google

Tara S

★ 5

Love this place and their curds! Decor is a little outdated but doesn't matter

Source: Google

Lori Hughes

★ 4

love the salmon dinner!

Source: Google

Donna Subotnik

★ 4

Little dark on the non bar side if restaurant. Could use some music piped in, you could hear conversations from other tables. Food was excellent on New Year's Eve with their special menu.

Source: Google

Scott Campbell

★ 5

Great food and wonderful servers!!

Source: Google

Brian Meyer

★ 5

I just checked my timeline and saw that I have visited Grill 164 thirty times, and I haven't had a bad experience yet. I really love the staff, and Todd the owner is an outstanding restaurateur. Prices are so reasonable and the food preparation is a always excellent. There are a ton of dining options in the lake country area, but this is one of those spots where the locals go and you can really tell that they are appreciated. I look forward to my next visit.

Source: Google

Chris Radloff

★ 4

Source: Google

Nick Gibson

★ 5

Source: Google

Todd

★ 5

We really enjoyed this bar and grill!

The battered mushrooms are the best I’ve had. Order them. Eat them. Go back and order them again!

The burger was very good! The club sandwich’s chicken was a little thin, but tasty!

Also, Home to one of the best fish fries in the area! Arrive early on frost Fridays…or better yet, plan to have a drink or two while you wait.

Source: Google

Bob Reyant

★ 4

To start with I should say that having been a Chef I am somewhat picky.

I have eaten at Grill 164 five times over the past two months. During those visits they have become one of my top 10 restaurants in the Waukesha to Oconomowoc area.
During our visits we have enjoyed the half pound char-grilled Black Angus burgers, perfectly cooked to medium with a full-bodied taste served with homemade chips, Hay stack onions (thin sliced breaded fried onions), lightly battered and golden brown with very little salt taste, Mozzarella Sticks wrapped in an eggroll fashion served with marinara sauce and perfectly browned, char-grilled Beef Tenderloin Sandwich served medium rare to medium with potato salad.

However, our favorite meals have been on Fridays. They have a Friday fish fry that offers something for every fish lover. They have fried or baked Cod, fried Lake Perch, fried Bluegill, Pan seared Walleye and Jumbo Shrimp. For those who have a big appetite they offer an AYCE fish fry. The fried cod is pure white, lightly hand battered, fried to golden brown and is moist, and flaky. The coleslaw is creamy and has a slight smokey undertone that I have only ever enjoyed before at a few restaurants in the deep south. The lemon pepper and butter Baked Cod was pure white filets, moist and flaky served with drawn butter. The Fish Fries are all fish fries are served with coleslaw, potato salad, rye bread and choice of French Fries or Homemade Potato Pancake.

While the food is the star of this restaurant/Pub the service is very good and the atmosphere is that of a small-town family grill.

The one thing that may upset some people is that they are often so busy that you may have a 40-minute wait for a table. However, I have found that if you do a little planning, you can either arrive early (3:30pm) or make a reservation.

Therefore, if you find yourself getting hungry and you are in the Oconomowoc WI area I recommend that you try Grill 164!

Source: Google

Dave Mc Mahon

★ 4

Very nice and friendly

Source: Google

Debbie Kemper

★ 5

Source: Google

Lisa Marie Holstad

★ 4

Source: Google

Nicole M

★ 4

Food is outstanding

Source: Google

Diane Sebion

★ 5

Fun place, we would highly recommend.

Source: Google

Mike Schabow

★ 5

Source: Google

Lady Di

★ 1

Very rarely do I comment or leave a review. This place was awful! Owner was a nice bartender/Server, which is ‘why.’ I’m giving the 3 stars. Probably another business owner struggling (with Bidenomics)! Noooo Wisconsin craft beer offered. Really? The food was absolutely disgusting! Frozen cheese curds… in Wisconsin?! The caprese salad will get forgiveness, only because it is not an Italian restaurant — soggy soaked bread, with old tomatoes. Egads! Being in Wisconsin, one would expect a big juicy burger. Ugh. Yuck. I pretended I ate it. They’ll find it stuffed on the side of the outdated booth, wrapped in a napkin. Old lettuce accompanied with a thin sliced tomato, no onion offered, not mustard! The Cole slaw and potato salad was probably bargain stuff from a grocery store. Daysssss old. Diet coke was flat, too. Nope! Nope! Nope! The restrooms were disgustingly dirty, too. Paper towel out of use.

Source: Google

R Antonczyk

★ 5

The food here is fantastic! I had the jumbo shrimp and it was great. The batter was light and crispy, not greasy at all, allowing me to really taste the shrimp.

The clam chowder was nice and fresh, the base was lighter, not such a heavy cream. You can taste the clams in every spoonful.

And everyone was so nice. The bartender greeted us as we walked in the door, and the service at our table was attentive without interrupting too often.

We look forward to dining here again at Grill 164.

Source: Google

Jim Peters

★ 5

Great staff

Source: Google

Mike Miller

★ 5

Fabulous fish fry. Crowded but service was awesome.

Source: Google

R S

★ 3

Source: Google

Peggy Anderson

★ 4

food was great, long wait for service waited was very friendly just very slow. We were not in a hurry so it was fine but if you're in a hurry choose to sit at the bar. There is a cute display of OZ outside. Worth a visit

Source: Google

Tim Karth

★ 4

Oconomowoc belongs in Door County! Place was very busy and low on servers. Food was fine, not exceptional, but good, common bar food menu with the exception of some higher end selections like prime rib. We were jammed in a corner table next to a party of 10, server had a hard time getting around us to get to the large group. But despite being super busy and low on help, food came to the table fast and prepared well, and the servers did a fantastic job with this. It was unclear where to check in or where the hostess station was when you first enter, signage would help that. Took a while to get the check but not a big deal. Overall a good experience and would go back.

Source: Google

Cathy Windish

★ 5

Source: Google

Luke Bull

★ 5

Source: Google

Kara Holm

★ 5

Was highly recommended for the best Old fashion in town. Not the best I’ve had honestly. Food and service was great though

Source: Google

Motobyte

★ 5

Bartender is friendly. Food was good. Nice supper club atmosphere.

Source: Google

Colleen Logan

★ 4

Source: Google

Jack Kaczmarek

★ 4

The burgers are great , their whole menu is terrific

Source: Google

Glenn Myers

★ 4

Source: Google

christopher wallace

★ 1

Worst steak I’ve ever had. Had a sour smell. Not much flavor.

Source: Google

Justin Harvey

★ 5

Great night out to try the prime rib special. The meat was done right and the veggies were buttery. Fast and friendly service too.

Source: Google

Virginia Kendziora

★ 5

Good very good,waitress attentive and friendly. Good consistent.

Source: Google

Lisa

★ 5

Awesome food!!!!

Source: Google

Sattler

★ 5

Very good food!

Source: Google

Matt Hoof

★ 4

Bit of a wait, but food was tasty.

Source: Google

Ted Brock

★ 5

This was our first visit to Grill 164 and we will definitely be back. We ate at the bar and we were given these cool wooden trays that make the bar surface level and it easier to dine. Supper club vibe full of mostly local folks. Friendly and prompt service. I love the fact that they have Franziskaner bier on tap. It was a perfect complement to the pork schnitzel. With a squeeze of lemon on top, it's good night nurse! Very reasonably priced and the next night we stopped in for a quick drink prior to the Christmas parade. Again, good service despite the place was totally poppin' off. I can't wait to get back.

Source: Google

Jeffrey Bykowski

★ 5

The Open Faced Prime Rib sandwich was absolutely phenomenal! A huge portion for a value price! The Taco Salad was HUGE! And delicious! What an incredible value. I will definitely return here! Outstanding dinner!

Source: Google

mmff7

★ 2

Source: Google

Paul Carpente

★ 4

Friendly people, clean restaurant and good home town meal at an affordable price.

Source: Google

Robin Mcgraw

★ 4

Source: Google

Peter Kaczmarek

★ 4

Good food and service. Very pleasant wait staff.

Source: Google

MJ Kasprzak

★ 5

I had their scrumptious blue gill fish fry. The cod was good & the pan-fried perch very good. Not enough vegetarian options though.

Source: Google

Jeff Gratton

★ 5

Source: Google

Bruce Danek

★ 5

Great food. The prime rib was done just right. Awesome cooked vegetables too

Source: Google

Charles Acheson

★ 5

Fish fry is always fantastic! Service is always spectacular.

Source: Google

Andrew Wolfgram

★ 5

Source: Google

Gerald Osborne

★ 5

Source: Google

Peter Holmes

★ 3

Source: Google

Kleigh

★ 5

Source: Google

Duane Kerbel

★ 5

Source: Google

Samantha Timmer

★ 5

Best place and really close to other fun places

Source: Google

Lisa H

★ 5

Fish Fry was Amazing! 🤩
Waitress was super helpful
Food and price was on point (minus the mozzarella sticks it wasn’t my vibe but the rest of my party like them)
Check them out!

Source: Google

Chad Goodman

★ 2

Soda was flat, prime rib sandwich with au jus was disgusting, rubbery and chewy. Wife's patty melt was came out undercooked. Mozzarella sticks were ok. I wouldn't recommend

Source: Google

Angie Muniz

★ 5

First time for here and honestly 100% recommend to everyone comen and eat delicious food, nice place humble people

Source: Google

Julia Starbuck

★ 2

I read the reviews and I thought perhaps they were just a bad day. NOPE. The review said the clams were burnt. About 25% were cooked right. But the other 75%: They are still burnt! Dark brown, rock hard. I bought TWO orders. I asked for tartar sauce and I had it but the lids were not on the containers! It spilled all over the inside. The room was dark and smell of a old hotel. Im glad I carried out. I was disappointed. My first and last visit.

Source: Google

Hannah Meyers

★ 5

The burger was delicious!

Source: Google

Robert

★ 3

Stopped in for fish tonight after our walk around town. How can a fish-fry type place get themselves out of bread? 2nd time this has happened to us here. Food just okay, nothing special. 2 fairly small pieces of fish, and 3-2"x 3" potato pancakes. Salads are good. Waiter brought back wrong change, - in their favor. Warm day in July, not much for AC.
Disappointed.

Source: Google

Lynda G

★ 5

Source: Google

Mark Ell

★ 5

Source: Google

Mark Mosher

★ 5

Great pub in a beautiful neighborhood. Food was excellent and had a very enjoyable atmosphere.

Source: Google

Laurie Ann Mosher

★ 5

The shrimp po boy is amazing! It’s a hidden gem of a place. So glad we stumbled on it. Great taste and great value.

Source: Google

Jaykov Pooter

★ 1

Bar tender was less then personable, food even less impressive, fryer oil needs to be changed. Fish was sub par and the charbroil steak even worse, veggies no seasoning or butter.. Everything lacked in flavor and the grill marks is all you can taste. Two beers one cocktail and two dinners for 58 dollars. I could've stayed home and had a better time. First and last time I'll be going here.

Source: Google

will Dougherty

★ 5

An awesome Fish Fry and atmosphere. Our Server Talia truly made our experience awesome and would strongly recommend anyone in the area to try out Grill 164.

Source: Google

Steve Ropers

★ 5

Source: Google

JoAnn Braun

★ 3

Hard to find parking small if busy will wait. Limited liquor, more of beer joint.

Source: Google

Vince Purpero

★ 5

Source: Google

Craig Heinze

★ 4

Good food for the money. All you eat ribs were great.

Source: Google

Ryan Swanson

★ 3

Went for prime rib, quality meat, food was served cold, highly recommend a plate warmer. Short staffed, but understand the labor shortage, review was because food served cold.

Source: Google

Curt Rydzik

★ 5

Great fish fry

Source: Google

Laurie Mattice

★ 5

The good is excellent. The staff is wonderful. I love going here, I always feel like I’m seeing old friends.

Source: Google

Thomas C

★ 5

Saturday evening prime rib is fabulous.

Source: Google

James Cook

★ 5

You're going to love the supper club vibe. Food is awesome and very reasonable prices.

Source: Google

Rich Wagner

★ 5

Great place for a good meal. Food was excelent.

Source: Google

ObstnateOstrich

★ 5

Source: Google

dale saeger

★ 5

Source: Google

Don Bebee

★ 5

Source: Google

Wayne Keller

★ 5

We live outside the Madison area and was in the area on our way home and was looking for a place to get something to eat??? We searched and saw grill 164 in oconomowoc and decided to order food from there. We called in an order and a lady answered the phone and was very pleasant. Once we ordered we drove there to pickup our order. I walked in to get our order and a women greeted me was so nice. and rang up my order. Found out while paying my bill her name was mary. I told her i wasn't from the area just was looking for something to eat?? After paying my bill she told me to drive safe. If ever we are in the area again we will be eating at grill 164. And want mary to be our waitress..... Thanks alot wayne

Source: Google

Anita McAlpin

★ 3

Service, great. Atmosphere, great. Food, not so much. My party of 3 had bluegill & and cod, all of which seemed like the crust had sweated. It was not crisp & crunchy. Potato pancakes were fair. The potato salad was ok, the slaw was not good... had way too much onion- overpowering the slaw. The bread was great. French onion soup & mozzarella sticks were the star of our meal, which is the reason for 3-stars on the food. Sweet old fashion was good.

Source: Google

jacob thurloff

★ 5

Source: Google

debbie schramm

★ 5

Excellent food

Source: Google

Mike Jewson

★ 4

Fish fry was amazing, had the lake perch and gf had the blue gill. Good portions, coleslaw was really good. Service was average, waitress only checked on us once, didn't get 2nd drink until we were done eating. Fish fry was worth the wait, excellent food!

Source: Google

RP M

★ 5

Source: Google

Ashten P

★ 5

Source: Google

Robert Heslinga (Bob)

★ 5

Source: Google

Mark Emken

★ 5

It was a great meal. Mary was very attentive! 😊

Source: Google

Thomas Smith

★ 4

It doesn't look like much inside, but they have great. long bar is nice if you dont a table or both.

Source: Google

Zach LaMarca

★ 4

Source: Google

Jennifer Burch

★ 5

Best fish fry!

Source: Google

Sid Wegener

★ 5

Nice, quiet bar. Friendly staff. Good food.

Source: Google

Karen Daley

★ 5

A large party made it loud but we always enjoy the atmosphere and the food.

Source: Google

Charles Russell

★ 5

Source: Google

Tryg Aasen

★ 3

Very busy, fish fry ok not great.

Source: Google

Timikca R Widener

★ 3

Source: Google

Linda Dabrowski

★ 5

Very friendly staff and clientele.
Food is excellent and priced very reasonably.

Source: Google

Ron Ingram

★ 5

Always a good time with Mary!

Source: Google

Daleen Pommerel

★ 3

Lovely venue, with good food but extremely rude management

Source: Google

John Sopina

★ 4

The food was really good! Service was okay, but I would still go back to give it another try!

Source: Google

Chrys Gregoire

★ 5

Great place to eat, want at sure at first since you walk into a bar at first. The food was awesome and friendly people

Source: Google

Glen Keddie

★ 5

We had a grouper fish fry, it was fabulous! We asked for cajun seasoning, and they complied even though it was not on the menu. The service was great. The owner came by to talk to us when we had a question about an ingredient. It was a very fun overall experience.

Source: Google

kathleen eckhardt

★ 5

Source: Google

Paul Hypki

★ 4

Source: Google

Aaron Koykkari

★ 5

Source: Google

Josef Locke Klein

★ 5

Really good! The fried mushrooms were great! Quality service and a great place to watch a game!

Source: Google

James Ganiere

★ 5

I stopped here with a friend on Monday night. Very tasty and generous 1/2 lb burger. The cheese on the burger was good and worth mentioning. Very friendly waitress. It was my first time there and I enjoyed it. I will definitely go there again.

Source: Google

Rob

★ 1

Source: Google

Ms.Z

★ 5

Very reasonable prices . We all tried the king cut as it was only 25 dollars or so. My stepdad had the grouper for about 20 dollars . All pretty tasty. I preferred mine the next day as the flavor was better.

Source: Google

Eric Paulsen

★ 4

Grill 164 is a cozy old school bar and restaurant, it's had other names and incarnations going back decades. The bar is pretty much like it was on the 1970s, just with better TVs behind it now. The food hadn't always been highly regarded, but I believe there was a recent re-tooling because several visits lately ended up being very, very good for both drinks and food, with good price points. Friendly place, too. If you haven't been there in a while, give it a go!

Source: Google

Jeff J

★ 5

Great food, wonderful staff. Be sure to meet Mary, the waitress queen and Pudge the Friday night Social Chemist. Todd has had a great place for 20 years, and it gets better every time I go back

Source: Google

James Newton

★ 5

Todd handles his restaurant like a boss. The fish fry is great and so is the service. This is our favorite fish fry spot in oconomowoc. The waitstaff is always friendly.

Source: Google

Carol Nuernberger

★ 5

Steak was very tender.

Source: Google

Nicholas Carlson

★ 5

Hands down the best place to eat. Come by on Saturday night, the prime rib is to die for.

Source: Google

Mike Dalton

★ 4

All you care to eat ribs on Tuesday nights, the French onion soup... and reasonably priced.

Source: Google

Rita Scudder

★ 5

Source: Google

Bill LeMere

★ 5

Source: Google

Terry McKee

★ 4

We were looking for a new place for steaks after our favorite supper club closed. The staff and service were great. The food was delicious. We will be going back frequently!

Source: Google

Laura Dietrick

★ 5

Really awesome place. Great food and staff

Source: Google

Sharon Evers

★ 5

Source: Google

David Opine

★ 5

Good food......fair prices......the fish fry was delicious !!!

Source: Google

Dan Helbing

★ 5

Source: Google

Will Silvers

★ 5

Source: Google

Anita Sheats

★ 4

As always very good.

Source: Google

Michael L

★ 1

Wasn't that busy but I felt invisible in this place. Walked in and wasn't sure if I should seat myself or wait for a hostess. After waiting for a bit we were finally seated. Waited about 35 minutes, and the hostess/waitresses just walked around saying our waitress would be right with us. We ended up leaving before we were even offered glasses of water.

Source: Google

Jim

★ 5

Source: Google

Jody Orchel

★ 5

Delicious Dishes, Had Filet and a Walleye dinner with steamed vegetables and choice of Potatoes YUMMY 😋....

Source: Google

David Hyndiuk

★ 5

We've been there several times. Today was as expected...nothing short of fantastic. First time having the haystack onion rings and it turns out they are the best I've ever had. The half pound Angus burger was delicious too! The fish fry with potato pancakes is one of the best in Wisconsin.

Source: Google

Rick Bobrofsky

★ 5

Service is wonderful. Cuisine is AWESOME!! My friend and my new fave restaurant! 2 weeks in a row! Will be back often.

Source: Google

JAMES MERTEN

★ 4

Source: Google

Karen Seguin

★ 5

Faulous

Source: Google

P

★ 5

Ive been here three times and the food, service, employees and customers are ALWAYS amazing! I think their fish fry is the freshest and best tasting around. The place reminds me of cheers!

Source: Google

Dean Rudoll

★ 5

Very nice place. Been there a couple of times now and the food was fantastic. Only downside was the Bloody Mary

Source: Google

Linda S

★ 5

Their walleye is awesome! Plus the regular fish fry is super good too.

Source: Google

Brylo Betto

★ 5

Friendly service and good food.

Source: Google

Sean McGee Hicks

★ 4

Very friendly atmosphere and a great fish fry.

Source: Google

Paul Kopydlowski

★ 5

Great Fish Fry! Reasonable.

Source: Google

Rita Norek

★ 5

Everyone loved everything. Ate way too much, nap time😊Definitely will go back. Great staff even tho short staffed.

Source: Google

Tom Stehlik

★ 5

Nice downtown bar and restaurant. Went for Friday fish fry. It was excellent. Great choice of fish on menu.

Source: Google

John Keller

★ 5

Great food. Great service

Source: Google

Jeff Ziemann

★ 4

Source: Google

Penny Kindler

★ 4

Friendly place with good food

Source: Google

R H

★ 5

Went here for Friday fish with friends place was busy but we got a high table in the bar area which was fine. Service was excellent as it has been in the past. Our waitress was Mary she's a trip and a great waitress. If you get Mary as your server she will take good care of you. I was the only one of our party of 4 to get an appetizer which was a bowl of clam chowder which was hot and very tasty and made in house im told although the clams were just a bit chewy but thats a small thing and can happen very easily so I take nothing off for that as it was hot and had great flavor. We all got the fish equally divided between fried and baked with different choices of potato there's something for everyone. 3 of us got fries 1 got a kind of potato pancake everyone's fish was very good and the fries were great the potato pancake thing was not well received by my companion who said it really wasn't that great. The meals came with slices of rye bread with butter and Cole slaw and potato salad for the table to share all of these are made in house and were excellent. Over all was an excellent meal with exception of the potato pancake thing which didn't detract from the meal and ambiance and great service. Have eaten here before and will again.

Source: Google

Vince Z (vincez)

★ 5

Great food and service at reasonable prices. Staff is friendly and makes you feel welcome. Will definitely be returning.

Source: Google

John and Kathy Fox

★ 4

Source: Google

Nichole Dixon

★ 4

Source: Google

James Carlson

★ 5

Love the quality of food, the attentive service and the great atmosphere. Never a bad time at Todd's Grill 164!!

Source: Google

jarosław kurzac (BrzyD41)

★ 5

Source: Google

Ryan Mueller

★ 5

Love everything about this place. Todd is one of the hardest working owners I've ever met. He'll jump behind the bar, jump in the kitchen, run some food, do the dishes. I'll go here just to support him.

Source: Google

paffer67

★ 2

Worst fish fry I have had in memory. Backbone of Walleye still in fish. Prep made for a very soggy mushy fillet. Clam strips practically burnt and over breaded. All four in my party were disappointed and left half their meal. Waitstaff and bartenders were good, which resulted in a two vs one star

Source: Google

Crystal Jezdimirovic

★ 3

Everyone was very nice, but the food wasn't the best. When the check came we were shocked $$$$$$ for not great food not like Oconomowoc.

Source: Google

Sally Butcher

★ 5

Service was excellent. The food was good too..

Source: Google

Eric Maas

★ 4

Menu has quite a selection. The food was definitely worth the visit and if I am in the area would go back again. I would recommend this establishment. Just remember that the main area is a bar. A little dark inside but it's a bar.

Source: Google

Dana Steen

★ 3

The food was good, but I wasn't impressed with the facility itself. When my husband and I were about to be seated, we opted not to eat in the dining room; it was awkwardly quiet even with other couples there, and we didn't feel like we could have a private convo without them eavesdropping. Sounds weird maybe, but I like my privacy. Any sort of white noise would have sufficed. We did enjoy our mealsand drinks though! I ordered the vegetable Primavera and my husband ordered a juicy burger!

Source: Google

Mary Maas

★ 4

Excellent food and the service was great. They had a good stay if food

Source: Google

Tim Sanders

★ 5

Love the food and service

Source: Google

Mary Wood

★ 4

Amy was wonderful as was the entire staff. Great food, reasonable prices, pleasant atmosphere. Will definitely go back when in town.

Source: Google

Deb

★ 5

Looking for the "towny" bar pub experience? Grill 164 is among the best. Friendly service, customers always seem to be enjoying themselves. In my top 5 for hamburgers, fish fry and bloody marys. I prefer to eat in the bar when possible to enjoy the experience. Lots of competition for your restaurant dollar in Oconomowoc lately...but give this small bar a try and feel like a local!

Source: Google

Robert Carsella

★ 5

Really good food and drinks, and actually a fun place, as long as you get along with the rich crowd. Lol... which I'm not. Still lol

Source: Google

Chris Robertson

★ 5

Meal was very good rite along with the waitress

Source: Google

Neil Pommerel

★ 5

Source: Google

Jim Gauerke

★ 5

Service and food is outstanding! The schnitzel and tenderloin salad are the best!

Source: Google

Alan Boothby

★ 5

The food is always very good.

Source: Google

Ken Pannier

★ 5

Had duck wings and brueschetta for appetizers plus the chicken taco salad. All very good while eating outdoors behind 'Dorothy, Toto, the scarecrow, the Tinman and the Lion.
Great backdrop watching kids being photographed with the characters.

Source: Google

Andy Weber

★ 5

Great food and service, highly recommend !!

Source: Google

Lori Schultz

★ 5

Fabulous bartender...(Sara). Very good food! Owner involved and super friendly.

Source: Google

Ann Churches

★ 5

Source: Google

Kelly Previte (Animosity)

★ 5

My hubby and I were recommended here by our good friend for Walleye fish fry, because it had been awhile since we had it because we were visiting from the south where you cannot get it.

The place is hoppin' on a Friday night but for a good reason. Staff was more than on top of things and seated us quickly and got in our order and drinks fast. It was amazing how quick and promptly the food came out which I would have waited longer. Walleye dinner there was tasty with big portions. The staff were always checking in to see if we needed anything. The whole experience was amazing. 10/10 recommend.

Source: Google

Kate Moreland

★ 2

Source: Google

R Parodo

★ 5

My wife and I have been coming here for years. The prices are more than fair, the food is good and the atmosphere is classic WI bar / supper club. If you have not tried Grill 164, you are missing out.

Source: Google

Martin Hughes

★ 4

Classic Wisconsin Tavern. I often go for lunch, especially on Fridays for fish fhy. The pan fried perch is my favorite, but the bluegill is a solid choice as well. The burgers are delicious too!

Source: Google

Mr Tina

★ 4

Food was very good and our server Mary was exceptional. My dad is incredibly picky with his manhattans and he had zero complaints. We'll be stopping back

Source: Google

Robert Bischoff

★ 5

Great fish fry

Source: Google

Stephanie Bobot

★ 5

Source: Google

Karla Sheats

★ 5

Source: Google

Ken Sheats

★ 5

Excellent food and great service....

Source: Google

B HE

★ 5

Had a fantastic fishfry, had the combo fishfry, Nice to see same faces working, Mary, Pudge and Todd was working the place also, will be back!!!

Source: Google

Tim Esser

★ 5

Good food, Great service

Source: Google

Shane Warder

★ 1

Source: Google

Jason Janicsek

★ 1

Ordered the schnitzel after asking waitress what was better that or fish fry and she couldn't decide. The schnitzel was 3 center cut pork chops dusted in flour and pan fried. I asked if that was really the schnitzel and waitress appeared confused alone with the rest of the employees. First and last time for Grill 164, not a good showing.

Source: Google

MARY PAT O'DONNELL

★ 5

Source: Google

DeAnn Johnson

★ 5

Great Wednesday night fish fry. Great staff

Source: Google

Ashlee Dziadosz

★ 5

Duck bites, oh yeah. Good drinks and our bartender was lovely.

Source: Google

Jennifer Jakubiak

★ 3

Source: Google

Don Wilks

★ 1

I have given this place multiple times hoping that the service would be better.
This place has not changed for the good even when it was Todd's.
It is to bad because this area could use another good place to eat.
Today service was less than poor, even had to flag the waitress for another refill even though they walked by several times looked at my cup and kept on going.
Most people do not carry cash, and if you pay with your debit card, credit card they charge you 3.99% in addition on your bill to run your card.
Obviously your lack of customers is reflected in this rediculas surge charge.
This was my last and final time I will ever come here again.

This place does not even deserve a single star.
Be aware!!!

Source: Google

Amy Larsen

★ 5

Adorable Great food amd amazing service!

Source: Google