Lake Street Cafe Inc

Elkhart Lake, 21 S Lake St, Elkhart Lake, WI 53020, United States | ★ 4.4 (569 Review)

📞 +1 920-876-2142

Last Search

Category

Restaurant

Description

A fun friendly atmosphere with a bit of an upscale feel. Our basic philosophy was to go back to “basics”, we make everything from scratch using all fresh ingredients, bake our own breads and desserts, and make all of our stocks. We pride ourselves on great food and friendly professional service.

Photos

 Lake Street Cafe Inc
 Lake Street Cafe Inc
 Lake Street Cafe Inc
 Lake Street Cafe Inc
 Lake Street Cafe Inc
 Lake Street Cafe Inc
 Lake Street Cafe Inc
 Lake Street Cafe Inc
 Lake Street Cafe Inc
 Lake Street Cafe Inc
 Lake Street Cafe Inc
 Lake Street Cafe Inc
 Lake Street Cafe Inc

Leave a Review

Reviews

Pastor Bill Te Winkle

★ 5

We have been here so often it feels like home. Excellent menu options. Try the pasta, pizza or Persistent Lou's Steak sandwich with fries. Yum!

Source: Google

Melvin Dillon

★ 5

Nice simple place,, good selection of beers and a good creme brulee.

Source: Google

Mario Pisano

★ 5

Source: Google

Be Hekate

★ 5

Stopped in for lunch while doing some construction in from out of town, left two of my employees to eat lunch while I ran a couple errands and got my food to go and not only did they treat my guys great but my food came out just at the perfect time for me to pick them up when they were done eating and everything came out just right and delicious! The gal did a great job and the restaurant was very comfortable and inviting! Can't wait to come for the next phase on my work project and have lunch again!

Source: Google

Gretchen Morris

★ 4

Nice stop right in town. Drinks and food always good. Bonus in the summer is the farmers market across the street. They have a nice patio too i just never make it past the bar

Source: Google

emmkros

★ 5

Source: Google

Luis Gonzalez

★ 5

Source: Google

HOWARD L SOFEN

★ 5

Source: Google

Melissa Grunow

★ 5

Source: Google

Fernando Gonzalez

★ 5

Source: Google

Luke Strenn

★ 3

This place is just ok. The food is very basic. The service was not that great. I think the only reason this place succeeds is it's one of the only shows in town

Source: Google

Brenda Beckmann

★ 5

Source: Google

Mike Hinze

★ 5

We went for dinner with two teenagers and a large dog. They have a very large grassy outdoor seating area in the lot next door and it was perfect. Umbrellas and some shade trees make it great. they even had a water bowl for our dog.

The food was even better than the atmosphere. We got the big tenderloin, a chicken sandwich, and I don't remember what else. It was all great. This was the best food we ate on the lake in a very relaxed environment. It looked like the indoor seating was a little fancier, but that is compared to being outside with a dog...

Source: Google

Stuart Long

★ 5

Source: Google

Ann Voigt

★ 5

Source: Google

Misha W

★ 1

Not sure how this place has any good reviews at all. If you want to wait an eternity for subpar food, then I guess this is your jam?

Source: Google

Marta

★ 5

I loved and enjoyed every minute of my time here at Lake Street Cafe in Elkhart! The atmosphere was bumpin’! The food was spectacular, and our waitress (Rachel) was insightful + delightful! Definitely will come back! Can’t wait to share this experience with my friends and family!

Source: Google

Kerry

★ 5

I have visited Lake Street Cafe many times over the years and the food and service has always been excellent.

Source: Google

Soph Faris

★ 3

My husband and I were so looking forward to having lunch here recently, We came hear a couple times years ago for both lunch and dinner and the food was excellent each time. But yesterday was a disappointment. The soy chile marinated flank stank was not edible. It tasted like drinking soy sauce straight out of the bottle. We also ordered pizza, which we ended up sharing and that was good. The ambiance was nice, we were seated right away, waitress was attentive and we received our food quickly. Not sure we would come again though. I've never had food that was completely inedible anywhere else.

Source: Google

Jessie Pesola

★ 5

Source: Google

Chuck Western

★ 5

My burger was grilled to perfection. The best burger I've had in years. The staff was fun, informative, and talkative without being intrusive. We sat at the bar, and I found the bar stool to be hard to get into. Once I was seated, I was very comfortable. I am not sure if the seating issue was my problem or the bar stool's problem. (Most likely my issue).

Source: Google

Patrick Conness

★ 4

A nice spot right downtown with great food!

Source: Google

Karen Menne-Jacobsen

★ 5

Source: Google

Chris Walker

★ 5

Source: Google

James Lee

★ 5

Excellent food, excellent service, excellent atmosphere. 8.8

Source: Google

Bruce Griffin

★ 5

Great steaks, pizza and more.

Source: Google

Natasha Virrueta

★ 5

GREAT food! The inside is older and more bar like, but the food honestly could go head to head with a supper club/steakhouse. Highly recommend the tenderloin and scallops - AMAZING!

Source: Google

McKenzie Oberstadt

★ 4

Great atmosphere! As an out of tower who stopped in solo for lunch, I was well taken care of and the food was great. Shoutout to Mara for being an excellent and courteous bartender!

Source: Google

Judy Caruso

★ 5

The food!! Excellent
Definitely have to go back to try everything on that amazing menu.
Had a great Brandy Old Fashion too

Source: Google

J Schneider

★ 5

We had a really nice time and good food! Very comfortable place.

Source: Google

Tim Rodgers

★ 1

Source: Google

Ken Pannier

★ 5

Source: Google

Jeffrey Yogurtian

★ 5

Source: Google

James Hoelzel

★ 2

Disappointed to be writing this review after such a great experience around a year ago. The fresh bread never arrived and we kept being told it’s almost done. It was bizarre. Maybe just ask the kitchen? Bread is pretty standard and when you serve fresh bread all the time you know how long it’s going to take… The steak and potatoes were room temperature when they finally arrived. They offered to warm them up but who wants a twice cooked steak and rewarmed sides? The appetizer we ordered didn’t come before our entrees so we cancelled it per the waitresses recommendation, then it was still on the bill. Start to finish we were at a table for an hour and thirty minutes and spent $130 on a mediocre meal and mediocre service.

Frustrating to spend money on a nice meal and have it go this way to say the least. The bartender was great. She made an excellent Paloma and was friendly and conversational.

Source: Google

Gabriel Albouras

★ 5

Source: Google

James Bohn

★ 4

Steak was absolutely delicious. The service was extremely slow. Nearly an hour to get our food. Potatoes were cold. Great place but slow.

Source: Google

jackie scheidt

★ 5

Very delicious and freshly made food. Casual dining experience. Personable staff. Very reasonable prices. Roomy and has a home feel to it. A little chilly at times, but worth the stop.

Source: Google

Dan Walsdorf

★ 4

Source: Google

Tom R

★ 4

I went with a group and loved the service they gave us. The fish fry was so good they ran out before I could try it. My burger was really good.

Source: Google

Eric Jacobson

★ 5

Source: Google

Celeste Godsey

★ 5

Source: Google

Jan te Pas

★ 4

Disappointed to learn they don’t take American Express cards after an excellent business lunch

Source: Google

R Lucy

★ 5

Had a delicious meal tonight! Super friendly staff too! Marley and Emily were so fun and knowledgeable about menu.
Wyatt was very friendly at the bar and great at suggesting wines.Great cocktails!
Wonderful steak and roasted brussel sprouts!
We will spread the word and be back soon!

Source: Google

Paul Eggers

★ 4

Source: Google

Amanda

★ 1

The waitress we had was very rude and unprofessional! My family was there before my husband and I arrived and the waitress who was taking there food and drink order did not knowledge us and did not tell us that the kitchens closes at 9pm. So half of the party got food and the other half didn't! We had to go to the bar to get drinks since she ignored us! I will never return to this place again nor will my family!!

Source: Google

Melissa Thomas

★ 5

Wow. The filet was amazing. Attentive service and great meal and drinks. Very happy. ❤️

Source: Google

Outlaw

★ 4

Food was awesome... would highly recommend.

Source: Google

Denise Trastek

★ 1

Have been coming to Lake Street for years, who ever the chef is - need a new one- had Uncle Louie’s sandwich- was so over cooked couldn’t eat it- won’t be back!

Source: Google

Ryanne Cloyd

★ 5

Very chill atmosphere. Friendly service. The food was phenomenal. Will definitely return.

Source: Google

S B

★ 5

Good food, different. Our server was so nice. A very relaxing time.

Source: Google

Cary Johannes

★ 5

Source: Google

Brian Kilar

★ 1

I’ll preface this with I barely ever post reviews on restaurants. We went tonight with our kids and we’ve been here probably 5-6 times over the years while at the Ostoff on vacation and have always had a great experience. It was 1 hour, 10 minutes from the time we ordered until it was delivered (with tired hungry kids). It wasn’t our servers fault as I could tell she was overwhelmed as things were backed up (and she did a good job). The table behind us had meals scattered over different times and they said their food was cold. Not once did I see a manager come around to apologize or even to offer to comp a drink while we waited with restless kids. Once the food arrived, it was mediocre at best. I doubt we’ll return.

Source: Google

Michael Kraig Beeck

★ 5

Source: Google

Mark King

★ 4

Source: Google

josh hutchinson

★ 2

Friendly service, unique and fun atmosphere. But food took a long time to come out. When it arrived, the fries were cold and hard, the burger and grilled chicken were overdone. This should have never made it to our table.

Source: Google

Bob Doll

★ 5

You can’t go wrong excellent food great service good atmosphere

Source: Google

Jenna C

★ 5

Stopped in for lunch, and Elise was our server. She was kind, patient, and knowledgeable. The atmosphere was laid back with really awesome decor. The food was delicious and flavorful. The focaccia was absolutely amazing, and wanted to take some home with us. If you are camping at Plymouth Rock, I definitely recommend stopping in.

Source: Google

Adele

★ 5

Great pizza, sandwiches, and drinks! The service is friendly and the food is delicious. There is outdoor seating.

Source: Google

Thomas Fritz

★ 5

The food was delicious; and the staff was friendly, helpful, and professional. A perfect experience. Thank you!!!

Source: Google

Al Iverson

★ 5

Always good food, service there!

Source: Google

Paul Fenrich

★ 5

We went to Lake Street Cafe for dinner this last weekend and had a great time. The tenderloin was cooked perfectly. The staff was polite and on top of everything.

Source: Google

Boundless Obsession

★ 5

Had the home made pizza and it was delicious. Highly recommend 👌

Source: Google

Gary Myers

★ 5

I had the orechetti, which was delicious. It has Italian sausage, beef ragu, pasta, with a great sauce. My wife had the shitake chicken served airplane style with an amazing sauce. Today, I had the sauger fish entre, which was boneless served with a panko breading. Great flavor.

Source: Google

Diane Strey

★ 5

Love the fresh food and atmosphere!!

Source: Google

Ted Keneklis

★ 5

Great place for food and old fashioned

Source: Google

Marilyn D

★ 5

The food is so delicious..we had a party of 7 and everyone enjoyed their dinner!! Chicken dish was outstanding and the shrimp was also excellent... Loved loved loved it

Source: Google

Fenix Home improvement

★ 5

Source: Google

Mystique Burke

★ 5

I've not only loved consistently dining at this restaurant with my husband and in-laws, but have also felt very supported and valued as a server here. The chefs truly do a fantastic job creating tasty and quality dishes, and the array of options on the menu makes for a unique experience every time. Lynn was a wonderful manager to work for, and a wonderful hostess to my family whenever we've dined, always treating us with kindness and respect. She truly cares about all of her customers and employees, and you can really feel that with how delicious the food is!

10/10 recommend!

Source: Google

Dave Greene

★ 5

Best place to eat in Elkhart Lake! Love this place.

Source: Google

Ed S

★ 5

Source: Google

Phill Ulmen

★ 5

Source: Google

Dan Posthuma

★ 5

Source: Google

Rich Ruth

★ 4

Source: Google

Bex

★ 1

I don't understand how this place stays in business at all. I have to assume it's because it's one of like two or three choices in the whole area. Some of the food is ok, the wait is ALWAYS ridicuously, unbelievably long with terrible service, and the owner is aggressive and belligerent. Saw other reviews talking about her gaslighting and nastiness. All very true. All of her responses to negative (and accurate) reviews are either a fake "sorry, email us" which go straight into a black hole or else you see she can't help herself with rude, petty trolling remarks. Yikes. Would love to see this spot replaced with a decent restaurant.

Source: Google

Garry Wicka

★ 5

Great choice for dinner for the whole family. The kids love the thin crust pizzas. Good variety of appetizers - highly recommend the seared tuna. When you get to the main entrees I really like that they usually have something fun to try- this past visit they had a fried octopus with chimichurri, it was fantastic and definitely not something I would expect to find in a small restaurant in Elkhart Lake.

Source: Google

Zach Fine

★ 1

We waited over an hour and when we complained about our wait time the manager gas lighted us about how we hadn’t waited that long and how we were wrong. Also it took them 30 minutes to send our order to the kitchen. Also our table was forgotten about for 30 minutes without water or refils on our drinks. My own mother had to personally go up to the bar and reorder our drinks. Overall if u want to dine at a place and wait most likely over an hour this is the place. Also to add on to this my food wasn’t close to warm

Source: Google

Steve Oplatek

★ 5

Great sandwiches, staff is great. Highly recommend you stop in for lunch or dinner!

Source: Google

Wayne Fleischmann

★ 3

Took over an hour to get our food, waitress was indifferent when we told her that the Paninni sandwich had a sour smell to it. She said it was the cheese. Took almost 10 minutes to get second beer. We noticed other patrons also complaining about their food. Never again.

Source: Google

Mark Anderson

★ 5

Source: Google

Kevin Bethke

★ 5

Normally when we go to Road America race track. We try to make at least one night of eating out dinner in town here.

Source: Google

Guy Reffett

★ 5

I had the shiraz petite filet, and I have to say it was the finest and most delicious steak I have had in my entire life!! If I could give it and our server Emily a hundred stars, I would!

Source: Google

Jim Bilello

★ 5

Courtney was an amazing server. This place has my highest recommendation and it epitomizes fine dining in a casual setting

Source: Google

Mark Hasenberg

★ 5

Food is always good here, great sandwiches and entrees.
Very busy tonight and the service was still good

Source: Google

Dimitri Angelopoulos

★ 5

Source: Google

Nicole Kafkas

★ 4

Source: Google

Jeff Klunke

★ 5

Great place with great service

Source: Google

Alan Arlan

★ 5

Great food and friendly service!

Source: Google

Mark Dillon

★ 5

Great food and great people!

Source: Google

Mike Damrow

★ 1

Quite possibly the rudest & worst bartender ever. Saturday 9/30/23 2pm(ish)
If you don’t like people or your job move on.

Source: Google

Nicole Wierzbicki

★ 3

We were looking forward to a nice girls weekend dinner. Problem #1 was it was Homecoming you can't really hold this against the restaurant however it's been my experience in the past service is not optimal which unfortunately was our experience. Our waitress was clearly frazzled and running around serving large groups. She was very apologetic for her lack of attention to us. We asked her about wine choices which she didn't know had to ask bartender. It was very loud and poor acoustics. The food was good and came out quickly. The peach cobbler dessert is oddly served in a small cocktail glass which was rather hard to eat without getting crumble all over the table. May want to consider a bowl. The pictures online were a bit misleading as it's not as quaint and quiet as I would have hoped it would have been.

Source: Google

Nick Pizzolato

★ 5

Source: Google

Connie ONeill

★ 5

Source: Google

JL P

★ 4

Source: Google

Chris Barker

★ 5

Pricey good food.there was one person taking care of customers..she was even helping in kitchen .Had to wait a while to get food and bill.

Source: Google

Josh B

★ 5

Source: Google

paul ounoutha

★ 3

Source: Google

Roger Eaton

★ 5

Source: Google

Paige Turner

★ 4

Went for dinner. Ordered the sea bass. Very nice could have been a little tastier. Beware that soda is not free refills. 🤔 Prices are fine dine prices, however the atmosphere is more eclectic pizza joint vibe. Outside seating is on a gravel and matted grass area. The chairs are plastic and could be more comfortable.

Source: Google

Allen Collen

★ 5

Source: Google

Rachael Pullin Averill

★ 5

Food was great. Want to go back soon, so I can try something else because everything on the menu sounded great.

Source: Google

John Van Engen

★ 4

Good food but it is loud inside.

Source: Google

Tina Schmidt

★ 5

We had a delicious scallop appetizer! It's flavors were explosive. Then shared a pear pizza, which was delicious. The crust was crisp and the toppings were perfectly spread out. We also shared the salmon sandwich. It was served open faced and done with cream cheese and greens. I would highly recommend this location for lunch or dinner! Also, try the specialty drinks!

Source: Google

Mootown Properties

★ 4

Ate there tonight 8/18. Had Paige as a server. 5 stars for her. On going issue at the Cafe is how loud it is. Some sound deadening baffles on wall and ceiling might allow you to not have to yell.

Source: Google

Michael Stahowiak

★ 5

Source: Google

Wes Nemec

★ 4

Really enjoyed the lake Street Cafe, hate to deduct an entire star for slow service, but it was noticeably slow. Our server was super nice, we were seated immediately, and the food was good, but it took a while between visits to take orders, and then it took a very long time for the food to arrive. And not like we ordered something fancy or complicated, me and my companion both ordered sandwiches and it took what felt like 45 minutes for them to come out. We sat outside, not sure if that had something to do with it but overall a very nice experience other than just taking a while.

Source: Google

Jacob Hoover

★ 1

The food was good but the service was terrible. We waited 2 hours for food and watched 4 plus tables get served before us and the staff could have cared less and it's a shame this place is normally good.

Source: Google

Alex Wendt

★ 5

This is a great place to stop in Elkhart Lake! The food is great and the staff is super friendly.

Source: Google

Brandon Polhemus

★ 5

Unbelievably good. The complimentary bread is OUT OF THIS WORLD. They bake it themselves and is worth the price of admission. I never would have dreamed that this level of dining would be available in such a small, quaint town. (Which by the way is equally amazing) Jasmine (sp?) is an excellent server and made sure to make our time as exquisite as possible. If 6 stars was an option, Lake Street Cafe deserves it.

Source: Google

Elkhart Lake Outfitters

★ 5

Lakestreet cafe is the best! Their food is amazing, waitstaff and bartenders are top notch. We eat at Lakestreet regularly and will continue to visit any chance we get. Love!

Source: Google

rj weyer

★ 5

Source: Google

Cali Simes

★ 5

We ate here on 4th of July this past holiday. It was packed but everyone was KIND and FRIENDLY and the food was delicious and the staff was great
We came in with our 5 kids, 2 of them are newborn twins in a double stroller which is probably scary for restaurants to see all these kids come in
But the owner was the kindest sweetest woman who came over and was so sweet and happy and talkative and made us feel like family !! My kids loved it, food was great as always and the owner was the best part. She literally made the night so special . Brought tears to my eyes feeling so welcomed by her into her establishment

Source: Google

Renee Thiede

★ 4

Good food. Had a mule made with super flat ginger beer…. Let them know. Made a new one… much better. Must have been a flat can on the first one. Ended up charging us for both anyway. Just pay attention to your bill

Source: Google

Lauren Topel

★ 4

Fun atmosphere inside and outdoors. Inside there is a big mural of the beer founders. They need way more staff. Crazy wait times even when we came at 5. No leftovers because it was good food but also not huge portions.

Source: Google

Spencer Strong

★ 5

Source: Google

Tom Aldridge

★ 5

Source: Google

Teri Rietbrock

★ 5

Source: Google

Al Schafer

★ 5

The foof & table service were great. A problem occured in that we were double billed. The restaurant would not issue a credit, but told us to take it up with our CC provider. We did so & were told it would take 3 business days. Seems to us it should have been handled with a refund by the vendor.

Source: Google

Keith Oliver

★ 5

Lake Street Cafe is phenomenal. Every time we attend races at Road America we find an evening to have supper here. I try a new item every time I’m there and I’ve never been disappointed. Service is fantastic. Definitely recommend!

Source: Google

Chris Pielich

★ 5

Source: Google

Dustin Zanin

★ 4

Service was excellent and not crowded when we arrived. The sandwich was delicious, the chips could have used something, fairly bland. Overall a great place to go for a sit down lunch or dinner.

Source: Google

Beth Ewerdt

★ 5

Source: Google

Dave Carini

★ 5

Source: Google

Diane Schwaller

★ 5

Excellent Food.
Excellent Service!

Source: Google

Leigh Auerswald

★ 5

Source: Google

The AdventuriST

★ 5

Always a good time downtown Elkhart Lake!! !

Source: Google

Kelsey Daggett

★ 4

Food amazing! Friendly staff. Would give 5 stars if there drinks had more than a splash of alcohol. This is wisconsin and their drinks are pricey for the lack of liquor. Tuna is awesome. Good pizzas, recommend the pear (get extra pear). Salads good as well.

Source: Google

Mary ZMeyer

★ 5

Wow!! We were a large noisy unruly group and the staff handled all of us with poise and kindness. The food was fantastic the ambiance and service outstanding. Thank you Lynn and your entire staff.

Source: Google

Brandon Ancil

★ 5

Great food nice people really like the out side seating good service I've had the burgers and the pizza both were great headed for a entrée next time

Source: Google

Dr Kathy Pollard

★ 3

THE REALITY OF OUR VISIT AND EXPERIENCE:
After a weekend of being in conference, we wanted to step outside of the Conference Retreat Resort area to explore other food establishments.

Slow service was our experience at a time when the restaurant was not full at all.
Even asked for hot tea while we patiencely waited and given lukewarm water.
Waitress seemed apprehensive while receiving our orders. Was also very SLOW, somewhat arrogant and condescending when taking our orders.

Sadly, NO repeat visit here nor recommendations for others to visit.

Source: Google

John Jensen

★ 5

Source: Google

Hans Neumann

★ 4

Food was good but the portions were small

Source: Google

Yvonne Slonaker

★ 5

Don’t pass this diamond in the rough. It’s not just a cafe. Cold beer, fresh baked bread, seared yellow fin tuna w/chili soy sauce and recently added to the menu life changing short ribs! #CustomerService
#ADefiniteStop

Source: Google

Seth Kuhn

★ 2

Used to work here and we slang out banger food a decade ago. But the orch at least has gone way downhill, which is disappointing being one of the cheapest main courses (cost wise) you can put on your menu. Tasted like hamburger helper with a HANDFUL of salt and an elf sized portion compared to what we used to put out. For 28 bucks, the portion and quality was insanely low for a pasta dish. Only think that slightly saved it was that the flank was still good. Hope you get back to the quality we used to do, the customers will come for the goods no matter the cost.

Source: Google

Jim Schade

★ 5

Source: Google

Lorin Blowers

★ 5

Great food and service.

Source: Google

ch sch

★ 5

Great dinner destination. Food is top notch with a wide selection. The ambiance is perfect.

Source: Google

Bill Stanton

★ 5

Great tenderloin Sandwich as well as the Entree.

Source: Google

Gino Montoya

★ 3

Food was all very good but seemed like they skimped on the good part in every dish and for the price that didn’t seem fair. Buratta only four half slices of toast and an overflowing plate of greens. Abura only about 8 pieces of octopus(although the fried kale was good, overflowing with kale). Orecchiette Con Carne maybe 4 pieces of sausage. Everyone else at my table had the same gripe, too sparing with the good stuff.

Source: Google

Ed Templin

★ 5

The flank steak is exceptional!!

Source: Google

Rebecca Kiefer

★ 5

Great food and friendly service. Pizza and salad made for a tasty lunch.

Source: Google

Tx Tx

★ 5

Source: Google

Maximillian Olmsted

★ 5

Absolutely delicious food at affordable prices. Highly recommend.

Source: Google

MadsSing

★ 5

Source: Google

Pam Gaines

★ 5

Sat in the dining side. Nice place to go for an elevated dining experience. You get what you pay for!

Source: Google

Andy Kovarik

★ 4

Very comfortable bar. Good service.

Source: Google

southern chickie

★ 5

Source: Google

mike white

★ 5

Great sub.

Source: Google

Ross MacPherson

★ 5

Source: Google

Sean O'Donnell

★ 5

Source: Google

Lynsie Bernier

★ 5

We were in Elkhart Lake for a dog show and loved the menu options. This was definitely a win! Plentiful vegetarian and gluten free friendly options. Each bite was clearly created with thought and passion for food. We enjoyed our back to back nights in this eatery.

Source: Google

Kelly Snell

★ 5

Awesome customer service and delicious, original food!

Source: Google

Tim Hogan

★ 5

Great place don't tell anybody.

Source: Google

Beth Novicki

★ 5

Race weekend! Crowded,BUT wait staff is remarkable! The food was very nice. Third time here. Was not disappointed.

Source: Google

J S

★ 1

Paying customers should be treated with kindness and respect! Don't try to blame them when you run your business poorly!

Source: Google

Sammy Smith

★ 5

Every time I’ve been to Lake Street, my meal has been wonderful and the staff has been great. But I’m also patient and kind. I was on their Google page to check their hours and saw the family that recently posted a bunch of 1-star reviews. It should be obvious by now, but people leaving 1-star reviews like that definitely put themselves in a situation by being rude, impatient and hostile. I have never witnessed any hostility or attitude, even in the slightest, by the owner or staff. Even when there was a simple mixup on one of my entrees, they were quick to correct it and very nice about it.
So if you’re reading those reviews, realize they’re more a reflection of the hostility and bad attitude of that table and not the lovely people that work here. People like them are why it is hard to find staff in restaurants these days.

Source: Google

Garrett Keefe

★ 4

Awesome

Source: Google

Vanessa Ortiz

★ 1

Awful, awful experience. Not sure if the manager understands that her whole entire job is to resolve issues not escalate the situation. She spelled her name out to make sure we got it right for this review, L-Y-N-N. Well, here you go, Lynn. Nice job making the little children with our dinner cry. You're a disgusting person. I hope people avoid this place and avoid you. I know we will.

Source: Google

Alan Dodds

★ 5

Source: Google

Audrey Krolicki

★ 1

We had been here in the past for several years and had enjoyed the food. Please note that other recent reviews have been complaining about terrible service and extremely rude owner, Lynn! Our family waited over 1.5 hours for food. When I asked the owner why our food was delayed she was extremely sarcastic and said ‘she’d look into it’ When our food came 5-10 min later she intentionally antagonized us claiming that we didn’t wait as long as we had said and accused us of changing our order (which we did not!). She continued to be argumentative and antagonistic. This is not the kind of experience we were looking for on vacation. Unfortunately, they have lost another patron. This place it not worth the headache and poor service when we’re just looking for a fun family friendly place for dinner.

Source: Google

W Janssen

★ 4

Cute place, nothing extraordinary, but decent and not overpriced, which is great for a tourist town. I did find a long hair in my salad.....

Source: Google

John Berst

★ 5

Good lunch menu.

Source: Google

Chris Moore

★ 5

Source: Google

Rodney Baumgart

★ 5

Source: Google

Andrea

★ 5

Source: Google

Mike Ruffing

★ 4

Large outdoor eating area. Wisconsin casual tables/chairs. My wife had the best pillowy pita bread I've ever shared. Wonderful pasta/sausage dish too. Staff nice, but a few small things keep this a 4 not a 5. Price very reasonable for the high quality food. Would def go back again!

Source: Google

stephen Eifrid

★ 1

Rude, arrogant owner! Food is average at best! Spend your money somewhere that appreciates your business. There's better options.

Source: Google

steve heerdt

★ 5

Great place! friendly and informative staff and good food. thanks!

Source: Google

Bill Mueller

★ 5

Excellent menu and even better service.

Source: Google

David Manzey

★ 5

Source: Google

Paul Thai

★ 5

We had an awesome experience tonight! We had an expanding number of people coming and the staff were super nice getting us all together. Thank you so much for such awesome service! The food the done perfectly and everyone loved their dish. Above our expectations! Thank you!!!

Source: Google

Pam L

★ 3

We ate outside. They had plenty of staff buy they didn't seem to be in a hurry to do much. Waited for menus..Waited for order to be taken...but the most disappointing was french fries were cold by the time they were servdd

Source: Google

Sean Kaat

★ 4

I had a $15 burger which was pretty good, but also too salty. The other 3 people I was with got 10oz tenderloins for $40 each, which they enjoyed

Source: Google

Christopher Wright

★ 5

Friendly staff, cozy interior and tasty food! Had the open faced skirt steak sandwich and it was well marinated and very tender =d

Source: Google

Charlie Sharp

★ 5

Came here for a late lunch, can recommend the Italian panini and the burger. The homemade sweet potato chips were excellent.

Source: Google

cesar cardiel

★ 5

Source: Google

Kaylen Derouin

★ 5

The food is always so great! I had the Lake Street Pizza and it was very delicious. The French fries are a must too! The waitress was very nice and helpful! I always enjoy eating here.

Source: Google

ks15821

★ 5

Great food!

Source: Google

Michael Arendt

★ 5

It’s a goofy juxtaposition of classic bar visuals and top notch food. I just had the Petite Shiraz Tenderloin, and it was without question the best steak I’ve ever had! I generally don’t review places unless I’m floored. I knew after the first bite, this place deserved the highest praise, and beyond the food, my server Emma was genuine, attentive, and all-around pleasant. I’ll absolutely be back.

Source: Google

andrea novak

★ 5

Very good. Service was as goodas the food. Will be back😊

Source: Google

James Augustine

★ 5

Source: Google

Sue Pinto

★ 5

Source: Google

Jamie Eick

★ 4

Source: Google

Patti Burkart

★ 5

Stopped for lunch after Shop n Sip, Elkhart Lake. Good food & service.

Source: Google

Mary Schaefer

★ 3

Disappointed in the pizza this time. Caesar salad was not good as the lettuce was old and the dressing had too strong anchovy flavor for my tastes.

Source: Google

M Larson

★ 5

Very personable wait staff and Cody hometown atmosphere.

Source: Google

Gary Frankowski

★ 5

Source: Google

Alisa Krizan

★ 5

Fabulous food and service is outstanding. Great Moscow Mule’s

Source: Google

Debbie Millen

★ 5

Shared a sausage pizza with my husband. It was very tasty and good. Medium sized but we just wanted something to tide us over for a few hours. I would eat there again.

Source: Google

Peggy Kornetzke

★ 5

Food was excellent, and our waitress was friendly and fun.

Source: Google

Zachary Griesbach

★ 5

Very cool place to sit and have a lunch or early dinner. Fun vibes, good menu, great food and service

Source: Google

Pat Grimes

★ 4

Very good food and service as expected. Food prices were up a bit also as expected, the drink prices went up a little more than expected.
Will still be back.

Source: Google

Thomas Runningen

★ 5

Bartender was awesome! Beautiful setting, all nice ppl.
we had contact with.

Source: Google

John Schoerner

★ 5

Friendly staff, GREAT service and FOOD!!!

Source: Google

Lenora Stuckmann

★ 5

Cute little Cafe, delicious food.

Source: Google

Debra Tracy

★ 5

Excellent food. Fast service

Source: Google

Sharon Reeder

★ 5

Nice experience

Source: Google

Mike Niemann

★ 5

Nice place to relax and just take your mind off of everything

Source: Google

Scott VandenElzen

★ 5

Great coffee, great service, and tasty treats ♥️

Source: Google

Mike Schaub

★ 4

Not alot of options but great food amd service

Source: Google

Judy OBrien

★ 5

Sat at Bar and ordered Brick over Pizza. Great service very good menu. Next time I'll try the Flank Steak! Pizza was good too.

Source: Google