Mary Cody's Restaurant

Onalaska, 205 Main St, Onalaska, WI 54650, United States | ★ 4.5 (337 Review)

📞 +1 608-519-2200

Last Search

Category

Restaurant

Description

Classic American fare is served from morning until night at this homey spot with a relaxed ambiance.

Photos

 Mary Cody's Restaurant
 Mary Cody's Restaurant
 Mary Cody's Restaurant
 Mary Cody's Restaurant
 Mary Cody's Restaurant

Leave a Review

Reviews

Floyd

★ 3

Source: Google

Terri Einer

★ 1

Wow. What happened to Mary Cody's?? We just had the worst experience. Dined there a month ago and it was excellent. Tonight, hour and 1/2 wait for food. Kitchen didn't inform staff about reason for the delay and after the long wait, food was delivered cold. Very disappointing.

Source: Google

Max F

★ 5

The best biscuits and gravy I have ever had.

Source: Google

Curtis Rosales

★ 5

Great atmosphere. Food was good. Servers were attentive. Good place to have breakfast!

Source: Google

Katie hampel (Elfgirl2892)

★ 4

Great service from our server. Food was good. Only thing is that I ordered a skillet with sausage and my boyfriend ordered a different skillet with bacon and they mixed up the meats. Im not a huge fan of bacon. Other then that, was great.

Source: Google

Kalab Miller

★ 5

The best drinks in Wisconsin hands down

Source: Google

Daniel Alexander

★ 5

Great breakfast spot! Calm atmosphere. Very cozy and inviting.

Source: Google

John Willger

★ 5

Excellent breakfast!

Source: Google

Amy Wiemerslage

★ 4

Source: Google

Jennifer Piwarski

★ 5

Very beautiful restaurant, my bf and I were greeted right away, It was a calm atmosphere with live music. Food was absolutely delicious and our waitress was super sweet! Definitely going back

Source: Google

Dee McConnell

★ 5

Excellent Atmosphere, Great Waitress=Angie/Bartender/Colin/ Jim= Our Dinner was Excellent. 5 Stars. Thank you Maggies/Mary Codys

Source: Google

Alexander Bartsch

★ 5

Stopped in for breakfast and was very impressed. Amazing atmosphere. Loved the live plants across the ceiling.
The Bloody Mary's were great followed by a perfect breakfast. Great portions and even better flavors!
Service was very nice and welcoming!

Source: Google

David Padesky

★ 5

Nancy and I stumbled across this place after our original plan directly to the south was closed.
Upon entering we immediately loved the ambiance and sophisticated vibe we felt. The very personable tender of the bar made us feel very welcome and took care of our hydration needs posthaste. What followed was a wonderful late morning breakfast coupled with a very interesting conversation with our intelligence and engaging mixologist/server. Rest assured we shall participate in a reiteration of this feting experience.

Source: Google

Christina Nelson

★ 2

Service was okay. Food tasted freeze dried, not fresh. My mixed drink was excellent. Will go back for the drinks, not the food.

Source: Google

Candy S

★ 4

Went for breakfast. Wish cooks knew how to cook eggs to order. Made it pretty clear I don't like runny yolks. But I got runny yolks. Hash browns were under done. Always wonder how a simple meal like breakfast is so hard to cook? My husband had the caprese skillet and said it was pretty good. Generous servings and service was good.

Source: Google

Chris Galewski

★ 5

I had bacon blue skillet and it was fabulous. Emily was an awesome waitress.

Source: Google

Matt Hastings

★ 5

Very welcoming place with excellent service. Had an amazing breakfast, both meals had us stunned cooked to perfection. Love the positive atmosphere.

Source: Google

Patrick Mulrain

★ 1

Was there this morning. There was one table of six, and two singles.Waited to be seated. Saw the waitress twice. I was never acknowledged. Left after waiting too long.

Source: Google

Jacob Wood

★ 5

Source: Google

Michael Drury

★ 5

Great service, great people, good food, lots of fun, and excellent music on Thursday Nights

Source: Google

Tracy Walton

★ 1

Source: Google

Jay Twite

★ 5

This is Onalaska's hidden gem. Great fresh food and welcoming staff
Highly recommend
Jay Onalaska

Source: Google

Becca Heye

★ 3

Source: Google

Daniel Walters

★ 5

Went for Sunday breakfast. We were lucky and one of the tables near the window was open. The waitress was accommodating to my dietary restrictions, going so far as to ask clarifying questions. The Caprese skillet was flavorful with an ample portion. Noting it's Italian flavor profile, I think it'd be better with the sausage. I do recommend, if you're looking for a new savory breakfast to try.

Source: Google

Hillary Yanzer

★ 5

They try to pack too many people into a small space for mothers day. It didn't feel very special.

Source: Google

Donna Cooper

★ 5

So love this place, food is excellent and the service is great … it’s like being with family ❤️
Donna Cooper

Source: Google

Kate Sahnow

★ 5

Source: Google

Danielle Blakely

★ 5

The food was amazing! We loved everything we ordered. The server was cheerful, friendly and very accommodating. Excellent food, excellent service, we will definitely return!

Source: Google

Jon Thometz

★ 5

Source: Google

Brandi Davis

★ 5

This is probably some of the BEST breakfast you can get in lacrosse in my opinion and we’ve tried most of the options around because we’re big breakfast people. Everything was hot and fresh when we got it and their coffee is nice and strong not watered down like some places. I wish we came here sooner now that we’re about to move out of town. If you’re in town I highly recommend! And it’s CHEAP, $26 for two people!

Source: Google

John John

★ 1

Source: Google

Kori Jon

★ 5

First time customer
Had pork chop dinner and fish dinner
Is was awesome!.. Service was fast and very friendly .
Great atmosphere..

Source: Google

Nancy Gaulke

★ 4

The Mother's Day brunch was absolutely delicious! There was a wide variety of food and I tried a little of almost everything. Everything was excellent! It was extremely busy and we did not get anything to drink until we had been there over a half hour. We had to ask several times before they finally came with water and asked for our drink order. They did comp our bill without us even having to ask which definitely showed us they felt bad about the service. We will definitely go again next year.

Source: Google

Teresa Hankey

★ 5

Caleb and the rest of the staff are great!

Source: Google

Brit

★ 5

Love it here!!!! Everyone is so kind and friendly. Food is great, drinks are great!!! Highly recommend

Source: Google

Jason Frentzel

★ 3

Granted it was Easter,but I had a 1:30 reservation for three,but waited until almost 2 before we got seated at a table placed right in the middle of the men's and women's bathroom right by the front door. It was a lunch buffet,fairly basic,but tasted good.excellent deserts.but $66 for two people is more than a bit much.

Source: Google

Kelly Lee

★ 5

Source: Google

Heidi Wilson

★ 5

They have great food. Caleb runs a nice restaurant. It is a very homey atmosphere.

Source: Google

scott mellington

★ 3

Food was good. Kinda spendy for portion size. We went for fish and you get two sides. Our friend asked if they could get double steamed vegetables and waitress says yes then they got charged extra for them even though they only got two sides. Thought that was unfair or should have been told they would be charged more

Source: Google

James Kremmer

★ 5

Upon walking into Mary Cody's, you're treated with a nice replica of what would be an Irish pub. It's a great environment, nice and cozy for great conversation.

This being my first visit, I'm sure I had that face of "What am I doing here, I need help!" I was quickly greeted and had the cream of the crop for eating locations, I took saddle at the bar.

Looking at the limited menu for breakfast, everything was tempting. I took the following: Meat Lover's Skillet, Eggs Benedict, Biscuits and Homemade Sausage Gravy, and Buttermilk Pancakes.

Meat Lovers Skillet
It was expected. Well executed. I didn't need to season the dish. Came out fresh. Nothing to write home about, but their take on the Meat Lovers Skillet is solid. Let's be honest, can be purchased anywhere in the area.

Eggs Benedict
Eggs were runny and perfect. I'd happily buy again.

Biscuits and Homemade Sausage Gravy
HANDS DOWN, the best sit-down biscuits and gravy in the area! Most restaurant have Chef Mic(rowave) in the back, nuking biscuits and gravy. Not here! You can tell that this dish is made from scratch. I'd love to take an IV direct into my vein and just pipe the gravy into my bloodstream. *Chef's Kiss*

Buttermilk Pancakes
Pancakes are hearty and filling. I'd have no problems recommending the pancakes here.

If you're looking for value and QUANTITY, go somewhere else. If you're looking for a true under the radar breakfast place, with great and quick service, friendly atmosphere, and all the dishes coming out perfect and fresh. It's worth the money. Easily a top 10 hidden gem breakfast spot in the LaCrosse/Onalaska area.

Biscuits and gravy, BEST IN THE AREA.

Source: Google

Hollie Wyman

★ 5

Excellent Staff, Excellent Food, Friendly People, Nice Ambiance & Atmosphere, ThankYou Sincerely & See You Very Soon, Hollie

Source: Google

Andrew McElroy

★ 3

My burger only came with cheese (no toppings other than bottles of mustard and ketchup) and the patty was un-/underseasoned. Surprised to get corn-on-the-cob as a side, but sadly it tasted bland. Girlfriend’s baked cod was also a little bland. French fries were perfect but skimpy due to sharing the plate with a corn cob.

Source: Google

Stephanie Coorough

★ 5

Source: Google

Kaila Langrehr

★ 5

My only go to for live music when at home.....love love love

Source: Google

John Evans

★ 5

Great food and drinks. Cozy space

Source: Google

Denise Ryan

★ 5

Cozy atmosphere with excellent food

Source: Google

Jordan Linders

★ 2

Heard great things about this place for Friday Fish. Got it for takeout, but the food was mashed together in the container. I'll have to give them another shot, because the fish that I could eat was good.

Source: Google

Audrey Edberg

★ 4

Source: Google

Emylee Walker

★ 5

Last night after calling multiple places just to find out their kitchen was closed, I came across Mary Cody’s. Despite their kitchen already being closed, the cook opened back up just for us to be able to place an order. We ended up ordering burgers and fries, which were amazing. The burgers were huge and the buns we soft and tasted so good. I highly recommend and we will definitely be back!

Source: Google

Judith Skifton

★ 4

Good food lots of it! Excellent waitress and not too expensive. We will be back! The only downside is limited parking but the short walk in the rain was worth it!😋

Source: Google

Ryan Capwell

★ 5

Some plans changed for a Mother's Day event and we ended up pivoting to trying Mary Cody's. Their Mother's Day brunch was a reservation only and on my first attempt to see if we could get in, we were advised to call back in about 30 minutes to see if they could fit us in. When we called back 30 minutes we were told they would be able to squeeze us in between some other reservations. We were seated right away, albeit at a high top, and with a young child the table wasn't ideal. Once a table cleared, Caleb (one of their staff members) immediately cleaned off a low top and offered us to move to the low top. We were able to enjoy an amazing Mother's Day brunch in such a last minute decision. A few hours later I received a call from Caleb saying "Hey I believe you left your diaper bag at our restaurant and we will be here for another hour if you want to come pick it up." It was unknown to either myself, or my wife, that we had left the diaper bag behind. The entire Mary Cody's staff, especially Caleb, went above and beyond to provide us a great experience. You won't find a more accommodating place, with excellent service, and amazing food in the area than you will find at Mary Cody's!

Source: Google

Leanne Stokes

★ 5

Source: Google

Michelle Wilcox

★ 5

First time visit. Service was prompt and welcoming. Food was delicious. Will be my new go-to place for fish!

Source: Google

Lisa Grinde

★ 5

On top of my list of favorites! Wonderful food and drink, friendly caring service, cozy atmosphere with the perfect touch of elegance.

Source: Google

Dave Heilman

★ 4

Very good Friday night fish. Friendly and prompt service. I would recommend.

Source: Google

Dale Brott

★ 5

Best fish

Source: Google

Joy Propp

★ 1

Was very disappointed as it was not open at 9 am on a Tuesday even though it was listed as open on its website and times listed on door. We had only a couple hours to spend so it seriously cost us an outing.

Source: Google

Abigail Parr

★ 5

Mary Cody and her catering staff were phenomenal. Not only was the food delicious, but it was presented and displayed in a deliciously inviting way. We had so many compliments from our guests on how wonderful the food was. Mary Cody met with us multiple times to create a menu that was exactly what we were looking for, and that we were excited to share with our guests. She was also very conscientious of costs and made suggestions to help us save money where we could, while still ensuring great quality.

Source: Google

Casey Discovers Food

★ 5

I think I enjoy the atmosphere more than anything. It’s just a decent little place to sit down and I’ve been here multiple times. Took my partner and mother-in-law here this time. My favorite time to stop in is definitely during breakfast. Their prices could be better on certain things, but their food has yet to disappoint. Hope to visit again soon!!

Source: Google

Mary Claire Sutherland

★ 5

Really enjoyed Easter brunch with family.

Source: Google

Victoria Beeman Spencer

★ 5

Long wait for you food.

Source: Google

Nathaniel Wolfe

★ 5

I literally had to stop eating to share this review today. I have been all over this planet, and this is the best breakfast and one of the best places to eat I have ever encountered! The food is at gourmet level flavor yet has that homemade appeal. But wait, there's more!
The atmosphere and epic-level friendly home style service is among the best I've ever encountered.
Highly recommended for special occasions and cozy days.
Just amazing!

Source: Google

Lisa Welsh

★ 5

The food was very good and our waitress was amazing!!

Source: Google

Stephanie Andresen

★ 5

A cute little Onalaska staple with great specials.

Source: Google

Wendy Sheehan

★ 5

Source: Google

Jim Hillstrom

★ 5

Great breakfast and great service!

Source: Google

Liz Hauge

★ 5

very friendly. great atmosphere

Source: Google

Randy Schroeder

★ 5

Very friendly staff!! Food was good and the prices were reasonable.

Source: Google

Jennifer Hund

★ 1

Waited well over an hour for lunch. Was one of the worst dining experiences I've ever had. Only saving grace was they comped our food (as they should have). We won't be back anytime soon.

Source: Google

Arlen Brandt

★ 4

Source: Google

Jade Cumberland

★ 5

Great food and service, and reasonable prices

Source: Google

Benjamin Johnson

★ 5

Very good breakfast place and a nice atmosphere. Only negative is that it is quite expensive.

Source: Google

Deb Horstman

★ 5

Food is amazing! Staff was wonderful.

Source: Google

Michael Moscatello

★ 5

The staff is perfection

Source: Google

Mike Hoppens

★ 5

Source: Google

Jeremy Arms

★ 5

Have never been disappointed at Mary's restaurant, whether for dinner or breakfast. Quality food, great atmosphere, fair prices. Service has always been excellent too.

Source: Google

Ron Bendel

★ 5

Love the food !!!

Source: Google

MicroCosEm

★ 5

This place was such an amazing choice to start our morning! The service wasn't terribly fast, but man was it worth it! Great staff, the man who served us was lovely and did an amazing job at accommodating us, even though it was a busy morning (I believe his name was Caleb, I'm terrible with names, I'm sorry!), definitely worth the visit! The decor was cozy, warm and very cute. A great start to the day.

Source: Google

garrett flagg

★ 5

Super cute little place with great food, great service, and great pricing. Definitely worth a visit

Source: Google

Bill Calogero

★ 5

Cozy, local place. Great breakfast, friendly staff.

Source: Google

Ann Thill

★ 5

Source: Google

Donna Jaeger

★ 2

Source: Google

Kelsey Goke

★ 5

Source: Google

Michele Oostdyk

★ 5

Excellent food, excellent wait staff!

Source: Google

Kiernan Baskerville

★ 5

Source: Google

Eduardo Montiel

★ 5

El sabor en el platillo que me sirvieron degustar me encantó y el café delicioso.

Source: Google

Nikita Koehn

★ 5

Source: Google

Schmitt House Catering

★ 5

Best food around , calib is the best manager

Source: Google

Nicole Groth

★ 5

Loved their breakfast. Pretty good bloodymary too !

Source: Google

Tyler Herricks

★ 5

Awesome food at a shockingly great price.

Source: Google

Tina Williamson

★ 5

I found this place randomly. Walking in I noticed right away how quaint it was. Very clean and very laid back. The staff was very attentive and friendly. The food was delicious. I had breakfast there and everything tasted and looked homemade. I will definitely recommend and continue to dine here.

Source: Google

Jerry Anderson

★ 5

Great food and friendly atmosphere!

Source: Google

Aimee Smith

★ 5

Source: Google

Katie Gilmore

★ 5

Source: Google

Ruth Benzing

★ 5

Delicious Atlantic cod fish sandwich and fries for lunch.

Source: Google

Dave Gallager

★ 5

The food and drinks are always very good. Exceptional service last night on the bar area. we had the 3 different versions of the fish special and all were excellent.

Source: Google

Mindy Wescott

★ 5

Source: Google

Karina Joholski

★ 4

Source: Google

vickie evenson

★ 5

Source: Google

Jackie Maloney

★ 5

Excellent food and service!

Source: Google

Lynne Donnelly

★ 5

Great place. Yummy food- deluxe french toast was light &crispy with berries. Bacon bleu skillet had well balanced flavors. Great flavors. Good portions & prices. Coffee is Fabulous! Even made me decaf. Friendly staff. Interior is classy not like a diner or basic restaurant that I was expecting. Definitely going back before vacation ends. Might even have to check out lunch!

Source: Google

Will Bohnefeld

★ 5

Excellent food and great service. Highly recommended. Very relaxing Atmosphere and friendly people.

Source: Google

Justin Cavanaugh

★ 4

Source: Google

Elvin M. Morales Rivera

★ 5

Great food, best place to have breakfast in Wisconsin.

Highly recommended

Source: Google

Taylor Meives

★ 5

Best place to grab a bite to food and drinks in Onalaska. Food is amazing and at a great price. Ask for the expresso martini, you won't be disappointed.

Source: Google

Jason Krautkramer

★ 5

Source: Google

das guru

★ 5

One of the better burgers I've had in La Crosse. Very nice place to eat.

Source: Google

Laura Villand

★ 4

Source: Google

david mason

★ 5

Really good Friday fish. Good service.

Source: Google

Greg Bell

★ 5

Nice people good food music top notch

Source: Google

Amanda Davis

★ 3

Food is ALWAYS amazing. Service has gotten pretty terrible. Been here an hour, so far have water.

Source: Google

Brandon Leske

★ 5

Was our first time dining here, and it was excellent. Great service and delicious food. The atmosphere was nice and intimate even with a 7 year old. I recommend 100% and definitely going back to enjoy other items on their menu.

Source: Google

Louis Fortier

★ 5

Their food is delicious and served to you hot and fresh ! The staff has welcoming personalities. A nice place to eat !!!!

Source: Google

Alexis Hagedorn

★ 5

Source: Google

Shannon Runge

★ 5

Was very good!

Source: Google

Robert Allen

★ 5

The Easter brunch was fantastic. Swedish meatballs and French toast stood out. Great wait staff too!

Source: Google

Jonathan Gonzalez

★ 5

Whatever they put on your plate is holy

Source: Google

Kathy Scheck

★ 4

Was nice. Good food. Good service. Look forward to going again!

Source: Google

Iris Jara

★ 5

Amazing food and the waitress, is very lovely. Thank you so much:)

Source: Google

Thomas “TJ” Wenger

★ 4

Great fish fry!

Source: Google

Amy Xiong

★ 5

Staff is wondering and food is amazing and super affordable! My daughter and I both love this place!

Source: Google

Luna Sabrosa

★ 3

Food was great, but a little spendy. Quick service. If I was hungry and nearby again, I'd definitely go back.

Source: Google

cassert anderstead

★ 4

Super cozy and decorated for Christmas. Small but straightforward breakfast menu. Good food and service. A lot of the appeal is setting and atmosphere. Haven't been for supper yet.

Source: Google

Michael Brown

★ 5

Source: Google

Lawrence Leis

★ 5

Great service
Awesome Old Fashions

Source: Google

jackie fuller

★ 4

Source: Google

Allison Mader

★ 5

Delicious!

Source: Google

Rich Halverson

★ 5

The food was great and at reasonable price

Source: Google

Tracy Wavra

★ 5

Love Mary Cody's for breakfast. So friendly.

Source: Google

Jacob Barlow

★ 5

Great breakfast!

Source: Google

Jash Thakkar

★ 5

What a place! Delicious food. Amazing ambience. Friendly staff. Highly recommend this small restaurant.

Source: Google

Matt Howard

★ 5

Source: Google

Polly Pappadopoulos

★ 5

Source: Google

Mattchu Millha

★ 5

Source: Google

Kristen Clauson

★ 5

Source: Google

Walter Wolowicz

★ 1

Death as a result of less than a couple hrs there. Anyone hear about this?

Source: Google

Mike Symicek

★ 5

Great food and friendly staff

Source: Google

Gene Burkhalter

★ 5

Always have a wonderful time there! Fun and funny staff and some of the customers are always fun and a pleasure to meet and be around! We always feel loved and welcome when visiting and the food is fabulous and delicious always!

Source: Google

Todd Waldenberger

★ 5

Source: Google

Charlie Johnson

★ 5

Caleb makes an awesome coffee martini!!

Source: Google

Anne Caulum

★ 5

Source: Google

Jessica Bassett

★ 5

Source: Google

丹dbรђell

★ 5

Source: Google

Ron White

★ 5

Source: Google

Vernon dooyen

★ 5

Great place for food and drinks. I got the prime rib skillet, super good and just the right size. Paired great with a bloody Mary.

Source: Google

Kevin Helseth

★ 5

Source: Google

Tim Benson (Midwest Design)

★ 5

Amazing food. Best chicken noodle soup ever!!!

Source: Google

Angela M Zitzner Karwoski

★ 5

Divine coctails! Try the peach cobbler shot or perhaps a martini!

Source: Google

Matt Woychek

★ 5

I recently moved to the area and ate at Mary Cody’s for the 1st time last night. I had the Fish Fry. It was fantastic and one of the best I’ve ever had. Sarah the bartender was terrific. If you live in or around La Crosse this is a “must go to” place. I will be back many more times.

Source: Google

Dennis Herricks

★ 4

Source: Google

Melissa Streeck

★ 4

Source: Google

Aaron Stoen

★ 4

Best biscuits and gravy!!!

Source: Google

Roxane Herricks

★ 4

Source: Google

erin jones

★ 5

Source: Google

Nathan McFarlane

★ 5

Source: Google

Alia Ebbert

★ 5

We love eating here for breakfast! They have lots of options, sweet and savory. I love the scrambles. We often have the same server, and she's very friendly and memorized our orders! We get the same thing every time. It's always fast service and delicious food!

Source: Google

Jameson Russell

★ 5

Excellent food.

Source: Google

Danielle Wilke

★ 4

Source: Google

joanna lema

★ 5

Very friendly staff and delicious food.

Source: Google

Mary Hilleshiem

★ 5

Source: Google

Penny Szobody

★ 4

Love the cranberry chicken salad on marble rye! Good hamburgers too.

Source: Google

Jeffrey Hankey

★ 5

Great food, great people, really nice laid- back feel.

Source: Google

Casey Tooke

★ 5

Great Friday night fish, ask for Tami, she is super friendly!

Source: Google

Joel Davis

★ 5

Best lunch ever. Staff was knowledgeable and polite. Restaurant was very clean and inviting

Source: Google

Erin Gomez

★ 5

Source: Google

Doug Hubbard

★ 4

Source: Google

kimberly marshall

★ 5

Source: Google

Steve Miceli

★ 5

Nice breakfast priced competitive. Good service. Breakfast was good quality

Source: Google

Mark n Kelly Turner

★ 5

Source: Google

Linda Szydel

★ 5

Source: Google

Ariel Plumhoff

★ 5

Source: Google

Kim Nimmo

★ 5

Source: Google

Darren Casperson

★ 5

Source: Google

Lorrie

★ 2

I really wanted to like it. I heard good reviews of the food. We sat there for 15 minutes and had to flag someone down and ask if we could get waited on. There were only 3 other tables and 2 of them were eating. Food was dropped at table and server flew away. The french toast was COLD. I had eggs benedict and there was maybe a teaspoon of sauce. Had to flag server down again and asked for more sauce. She brought about a teaspoon or less. Didn't matter, sauce had no taste and eggs were hard boiled no yolks at all. Not a good meal. Server never asked us how food was but she remembered to come back to bring bill. Hoping this was a bad food day for them, but I won't rush back to find out.

Source: Google

Denise Mills

★ 5

It was amazing

Source: Google

casuelita de tamarindo

★ 5

Awesome place to have any of the classic American signature comfort food dishes. I recommend, Mack&cheese, triple BLT super toasted or the chicken noodle soup will infuse some new energy to your day.

Source: Google

Garrett Wehner

★ 5

Source: Google

Virginia Mashak

★ 5

Great place to eat with a wide variety to choose from and just plain yummy food, it’s so good!

Source: Google

Rachel Kast

★ 5

Source: Google

Heeter 311

★ 4

Source: Google

Dag Roppe

★ 5

Source: Google

Carl Morse

★ 5

Source: Google

annie goldman

★ 4

Good food..good service..

Source: Google

Mark Millis

★ 5

Foods was good, atmosphere was amazing really nice place. Will be back.

Source: Google

Paul Molling

★ 4

Good food

Source: Google

Jesse Mckinney

★ 1

I ate at Mary Cody's for the first time on Saturday. I was excited to try a new place. The atmosphere was nice, and the waitress seemed friendly when we first arrived. There was only one other table with people, so we were excited to have the place mostly to ourselves. We had a family party of 12 as we were celebrating my niece's 17th birthday.

To say I was disappointed and upset is an understatement. We ordered our food and had to wait OVER an hour and a half for it! There was no rush, no other people to serve. We found out later, after we inquired, that there was no staff in the kitchen. A no show to work maybe? So, they just didn't start our food for the first hour? The waitress that we had asked as she passed by actually seemed annoyed with US and told us our food would be out when it was done and ready... There were so many other things that went wrong besides the MAJOR fact that our food took so long:

-We had to continually ask for refills or bring our glasses up to the bar.
-Most of our dishes came out with mistakes when they finally came (white bun instead of WW bread, no guacamole, cheese when we asked for none due to an allergy, missing salads, fries when they didn't order fries, no extra ranch, and MANY MORE).
-We asked for our bills (split checks), and it took her 3 tries to get them finally right. After all that waiting for our food, we had to wait another 30 minutes just to pay and leave.
-The food was advertised differently than it came out (JUMBO mushroom caps were 5 tiny regular mushroom tops for $11, etc.).
-The table that came in an hour after us got their food before we got anything, including our dinner salads.

I honestly can't think of a place that's had worse food or worse service. The most shocking part of this whole experience is that never, not once, did ANY single person apologize to our table for this experience. We didn't know what happened in the kitchen. We weren't told that they were without cooks. We weren't warned that it would be a while. No one came up and offered us anything while waiting. It was like a silent secret. We had told her that we were splitting the check and how before we ever ordered. When finally given our bills, we were told that we would EACH be given a $10 gift certificate for a future visit. What she actually gave us was a $10 gift certificate for each bill. Most of us had four people on each check, so we basically each got a $2.50 future credit which doesn't begin to compensate for the horrible experience we had. Our food should have been compensated right then and there! We all should have had 50% or more taken off our bill. A manager should have come over and apologized. We will not be using those $10 gift cards, as not a single one of us 12 will ever be returning to this establishment again. What an incredible disappointment this restaurant was!

Source: Google

Candace Maxwell

★ 1

Our extended family of ten went for lunch on Saturday at 2:30 pm. Server was very cheerful and welcoming at first. Then there was a long wait to order. By the time the food came 1 hour and 40 minutes later we were all cross and some of us needed to leave for other appointments. We had tried to inquire as to why it was taking so long and received a grumpy response and no apology. Several of our orders were wrong such as white bun when requested wheat, cheese on the bean burger of the girl allergic to cheese, no "homemade" guacamole when it was supposed to come with a meal and not homemade at all, "jumbo" mushroom caps just normal size mushrooms, wrong salad, burned bean burgers..... We were afraid to send anything back for fear it would be another hour an a half wait. A couple who came in 30 minutes after us were served right away. There was another half hour wait for a check. We were promised a gift card "for each of you" to compensate and received one gift certificate per check- some checks covered 4 people. Another 15 minutes to get our credit cards back....the gift certificates will go in the trash because we are 10 people who are never going to eat here again!

Source: Google

Jesse Dressel

★ 2

We waited about 2 hours for our food. They got most of our food orders wrong. We told the waiter and they got so defensive. The soda was really watery. the waiter came around every 30 min. The food was good though.

Source: Google

John Every

★ 5

Great

Source: Google

Brienne Shaker

★ 4

Source: Google

Amanda Walker

★ 1

There was a wait for seating on a Sunday morning which wasn't bad, about 25 minutes. When we were seated, our waitress waited to take our order for about 30 minutes since the kitchen was "backed up". Once we did place our order, it took another hour to get our food which wasnt even good. The waitress was not attentive at all. Never going back.

Source: Google

Nathan Peplinski

★ 5

Great little place with excellent service and super tasty food! Reasonable prices also, especially for the romantic environment.

Source: Google

Lori Karlin

★ 5

Source: Google

Evan Newman

★ 5

Source: Google

Melissa Berberich (Moeberb)

★ 4

This is a nice little place for an intimate meal. Not loud, great staff, good food. My favorite breakfast spot

Source: Google

Lyn Simms

★ 5

Absolutely delicious! Try the bacon wrapped chicken bites. Mmmm!

Source: Google

Melody McGowen

★ 5

Delicious breakfast skillets.

Source: Google

Jerry Cody

★ 5

excellent

Source: Google

Barrett Hanson

★ 5

Source: Google

Julie Cummings

★ 2

Source: Google