Category
Pizza restaurant RestaurantDescription
At MOD Pizza Edwards Boulevard, pizza is personal. Create your perfect pizza or salad with unlimited toppings for one set price at your local MOD Pizza in Lake Geneva, WI! Choose from over 40 fresh toppings, 8 finishing sauces, and 8 dressings to build exactly what you're craving. We also offer gluten-friendly and cauliflower crusts, vegan options, and delicious desserts to round out your meal. Order online or through the MOD app for pizza delivery or carryout today, or stop by 281 N Edwards Blvd , Lake Geneva, WI to watch our amazing MOD Squad handcraft your perfect pizza. MOD Pizza Edwards Boulevard is proud to support local causes and give back to the Lake Geneva community.
Photos
Leave a Review
Reviews
Lee King
★ 5
Source: Google
Stephanie
★ 5
MOD Pizza is a Great place for a quality salad or pizza "your way" without breaking the bank; look no further!
Source: Google
Chris Tipton
★ 5
Ok, I left a negative comment a couple of years ago abouts and employee being sarcastically reluctant to put the amount of toppings that I requested.
Today, I received PERFECT SERVICE by a young lady (I didn't catch her name) who wore a long brown, braided ponytail, glasses,a few tattoos on her arms , white hat and a t-shirt with the peace sing on it.
THANKYOU. You would be significantly increasing the quality of your already quality business by hiring more employees like her and even promoting her.
Source: Google
David Klyzub
★ 5
Source: Google
Jackson Slayton
★ 1
Extreme wait
Source: Google
dan blink
★ 5
Surprisingly good value. And the pizza pretty darn good.
Source: Google
Up Town
★ 4
The wife and I enjoy a good Pizza in an open fire. And that's exactly what it was. You choose your Pizza. You can either get one crust or double crust. My wife got the one cross. I got the double crust. It just makes it a little thicker. The bottom got nice and toasty, but the top not too much. I should ask then we'll leave it in a little longer. But that's so that's on me. So make sure you give them directions an info and they will oblige other than that. It was a good meal.
And I got, I ordered the Tristan. It doesn't come with any meat, but you can add me with a little bit of pesto. Come on.
Source: Google
Dan M
★ 5
Everything came out perfect, staff was super nice and the portions are great. Favorite pizza place in the area
Source: Google
Dadof2many
★ 1
Made me wait forever for a finished order, sat there letting it get cold while other pizzas came n went.
Yeah i gave em attitude, cuz i was there 20 min n the pizza was ready before i got there, no reason to wait that long .
Source: Google
Aggie Maciejowski
★ 3
Quite surprised, I did not like MOD pizza at the other places, I chose Greek salad imagining it will be plain basic lettuce with perhaps one olive. And it was pleasantly full of all veggies with great portion of feta. Bravo!
Source: Google
Kevin Jones
★ 5
I do enjoy MOD Pizza! Garrett is an amazing employee! He paid great attention to detail and happily answered all of my questions!
Source: Google
Kyle Wiemer
★ 5
Clean and friendly staff
Source: Google
charles Roy
★ 5
Been there 2 times food was delicious and service was great
Source: Google
Wendy Kang
★ 5
Delicious food! Friendly staff!
Source: Google
Lisa Orlowski
★ 5
Source: Google
jugdish wackerly
★ 2
Never had Mod Pizza before and won’t again. See my photo…. Almost no cheese and sausage tasted like meatballs from spaghetti O’s. Very disappointing for the $17 it cost.
Source: Google
Young Richter
★ 5
Em and Crystal make it how I want I always ask for extra and they don’t complain about it.
Source: Google
Devon H
★ 5
Each person in our family got their own pizza and picked what they wanted on it so we were all happy! What a great concept with just one price no matter the toppings! And they even had veggie sausage with no extra charge. So good! Will come back next time we're in the area
Source: Google
Connor Lindloff
★ 1
It took over 40 minutes to get our food.
Source: Google
Raymond Gillett
★ 3
Last year only open until 6:00pm at Lake Geneva location. This year 10-11pm. The pizza is awesome but the app sucks. My order is never ready when it says it is. Also every location has banana peppers but it's not a option on the app. In the notes I always say please add banana peppers and not once they get right. So now I'm waiting for my pizza to come out without banana peppers. They offer to make a new one but I'm in a hurry so I just ask to get it on the side. I wish they would just read the ticket.
Source: Google
Rose Hallenberg
★ 5
I love the small, thin pepperoni pizza. Great taste, but not a huge amount of calories. Friendly staff.
Source: Google
James Jay Boyle
★ 3
Source: Google
Elise Dale
★ 1
I recently got a pizza and it had no sausage on it so I called the manager 4 times to complain *no answer* so I asked for the general managers number *they don’t know the GMs number* so never going there again!
*Lake Geneva Mod pizza*
Source: Google
teddy
★ 5
The new management of the restaurant has made this place 1000x better than what it was just a year ago. so good.
Source: Google
Jeffrey Clark
★ 5
Source: Google
Nicole Petrie (npetrie01)
★ 1
Please train your staff to pay attention to orders if you offer vegan and vegetarian options. People don’t eat meat and dairy for so many reasons (religious, moral, health, etc.). It’s SO important to serve exactly what the customer orders.
Source: Google
Dawn E
★ 4
Pizza was good but could have cooked a bit more.
Source: Google
Gina Vargas
★ 1
A few months ago, I started going to this Mod pizza location, and unfortunately, I’ve had a consistently frustrating experience. The listed hours on Google and Maps say they’re open until a certain time, but they regularly close 3 to 4 hours earlier without notice. Every time I’ve tried to stop by during their posted hours, the doors are locked, and the staff either ignores me, refuses to open the door, or simply says, “These are our hours,” with no explanation or concern.
Today, I decided to call ahead to make sure they were actually open before wasting another trip. Someone answered the phone, and when I asked to confirm the store was open, she said, “Let me ask,” and then hung up on me.
It’s incredibly unprofessional to operate a business like this, ignoring posted hours and treating customers as if their time doesn’t matter. I hope management takes this seriously and makes some changes, because this has been an ongoing issue that makes MOD Pizza Lake Geneva feel unreliable and dismissive of the community.
Source: Google
Tia B
★ 1
Ordered delivery and received a Burnt pizza. I am not too sure who made this and thought it was ok to send out?
Source: Google
Erika
★ 5
Source: Google
Alycia Gonzalez
★ 5
Stopped in tonight! I had a great customer service experience! Crystal and Krista were running the whole place and slaying! They should get a raise! Great food! Thanks ladies
Source: Google
Aaron Mulkey
★ 4
Source: Google
Amanda Andrew
★ 3
The food was good, nothing unique. There weren't any plates, so we used napkins. The cheesy sticks had a lot of oil. The cakes were divine though!
Source: Google
Seth Pratz
★ 5
Always great pizza! Emma was really nice and friendly, one of my favorite pizza places! Everyone is goated.
Source: Google
Christopher
★ 3
Pretty good. Staff was friendly and helpful
Source: Google
Katie Smith
★ 5
Great pizza!! We love Mod!
Source: Google
Joey Aiello
★ 4
Source: Google
James Myres
★ 5
Good food and good prices
Source: Google
Annika
★ 5
Wanted to leave this review to exclaim how brilliant of an experience I had at this location. Great employees, especially Crystal. Light hearted and truly conversational. I would recommend to anyone even before considering the food.
Source: Google
Willie Brown
★ 5
Source: Google
Diane Martin
★ 4
Source: Google
Molly Lichtfuss
★ 5
I love that they offer gluten free crust! This is my fav pizza place in Madison. If you like lots of choices & like spicy options- this place is for you! Definitely try the different lemonades too!!
Source: Google
David Rocco
★ 5
Source: Google
Jim Rea
★ 4
Source: Google
Nicole O'Doniel
★ 5
Source: Google
Holly Swenney
★ 1
It said open 10:30-10 and nobody was there. There wasn’t a note or anything. The doors were locked.It says open on the app so it’s a really big inconvenience for people going all the way there just to see it’s closed.
Source: Google
Yanna Preston
★ 5
We love the staff at MOD Pizza! Chris, she was such a delight while preparing our pie, and Crystal was so nice when she served it to us! Will definitely be coming back for another piece of the pie!!! 🫶🏾🫶🏾
Source: Google
Joey Balocca
★ 5
Wow!
My first MOD Pizza, and I loved the fact you get to see it being created in front of you!
Great service at this location as well.
Crystal and Chris were great! Super nice smiles and welcoming.
Source: Google
Catalin Vacaru
★ 5
Source: Google
Hebah Abbadi
★ 5
Source: Google
K F
★ 5
I love that you can order as many toppings as you want for no extra charge, and pizza is made fast and fresh. The staff is really friendly and upbeat. The only thing I would like to see is that they could give you plates for your pizza. Unless they do offer that, and I missed something. Otherwise, it was a great experience, and the food was great as well.
Source: Google
Stesha Nell
★ 5
Source: Google
Chelsea Schopper
★ 5
Source: Google
Mr. Hibb
★ 4
Watch them, hook you up with your order.
Source: Google
Ilir Mustabelli
★ 5
Source: Google
Brandon hennings
★ 5
Great food great staff
Source: Google
Lynda
★ 4
Source: Google
Steven Zlatic
★ 5
Loved the food, atmosphere, and service.
FOOD
we had Dominic pizza and put balsamic glaze and pesto sauceon it… Excellent. Our kids really enjoyed the Maddy cheese pizza. The crust is crunchy and thin and very tasty. There are lots of options to create your own pizza. The ingredients seemed very fresh and tasty.
SERVICE
The crew working were really solid. They were knowledgeable about the menu and options, they were patient and knowledgeable and they were engaging in conversations. I think they really enjoyed their job and atmosphere they were creating for everyone.
ATMOSPHERE
The vibe is kind of trendy and fun. There’s lots of different seating options. There’s a bit of music going on and some nice decorations. I find that having some big highboy tables is a great addition that allows for larger gatherings of people.
Source: Google
IThoughtof Googleplexfirst
★ 3
Have been here for ever
Source: Google
Jay Smith
★ 4
Source: Google
Jonny T
★ 4
Long wait but was around dinner time in a Friday so just be prepared to wait a good 15 mins at least in line to order. Friendly workers, and of course a lot of different options to choose from.
Source: Google
Merlin Nacho
★ 5
The candy I got from that old man in the parking lot was good I don't remember much else than that beside the pizza being good. Also my cheeks hurt afterwards. Nice place.
Source: Google
Tiffany Oplinger
★ 4
It was our first time trying MOD it was delicious! Really shocked how good it was. I'm funny about pizza and I definitely will be coming back. I like all the toppings you can pick. I was a little disappointed with the Italian chopped salad, the lettuce seemed a bit wilted and brownish. Shocked they served it. And it was lacking in flavor but the pizza made up for it. Service was great, everyone was friendly! The cheese bread was so good, and so was the tea drinks. I hope MOD near Chicago are just as delicious. I can't wait to return! If you haven't tried MOD yet GO!
Source: Google
Kris G
★ 5
Source: Google
Madison Mabin
★ 5
Whoever was working on 6/20/24 around 7pm needs a raise. This crew was obviously slammed with online and in-store orders, and they STILL delivered fantastic service and positivity. For how busy they were, I felt they moved quickly and efficiently, with positive attitudes. The guy who made our pizza was super friendly, and so were the girls behind the counter. Applause for this team! It’s so rare to find such wonderful service with a fantastic end product. Based on tonight we look forward to coming back to this location!
Source: Google
W
★ 5
First time here and yeah it was good. Lots of choices and it's nice to be able to customize your pizza and not have to pay separately for each topping. We'll be back for sure
Source: Google
Derek Entringer
★ 4
Source: Google
Adrianne “Petee” King
★ 5
Love this place food is great, and service is exceptional. Worked in the industry for 20+ years. It's hard to find good help. I would hire any of these employees. Fast, friendly and helpful, always with a smile. Great job! Oh and I'm obsessed with the pear tea.
Source: Google
Mike Pinter
★ 5
Fast friendly service with great pizza (and salads). I recommend the Jasper plus salami, spinach and garlic.
Source: Google
Joni S
★ 5
Source: Google
Alice Troken
★ 4
Source: Google
Tony Harris
★ 5
Source: Google
Genuinely Humble
★ 5
The variety of options to add to your pizza is a nice touch. Plus they prepare the pizza fresh right in front of you. The staff is very friendly and nice. Highly recommend!
Source: Google
April Keilback
★ 2
We were told we had to get our pizza to go. It was just after 9 pm. Didnt close till 10. Pizza was cold by the time we got home.
Source: Google
Ferris Buehler
★ 4
Source: Google
Scott Stilin
★ 5
I love building my own pizza with such a variety of vegetables and meats, plus sardines for some added saltiness! Great tasting crust too. Never disappointed.
Source: Google
Lucille N
★ 5
Source: Google
Heather Kuehn
★ 3
My dough seemed old... made my pizza burn on the outside
Source: Google
Dennis Dougherty
★ 5
Great service and great food.
Source: Google
Rene L Cordon
★ 5
I love this food !!
Source: Google
Joe Baratta
★ 4
Source: Google
Lynn K
★ 5
Yum, the closest to my favorite pizza in Nevada.
Source: Google
Eyan H
★ 5
Source: Google
Valerie Sikkila
★ 5
Delicious meal
Source: Google
Cindy Holmes
★ 5
Stopped in after work. Always get my pizza well done! Wasn’t too busy a little after 5 pm on a Friday. Pizza was delicious! Staff friendly and quick!
Source: Google
Jose Alfonso Hernandez Ortiz
★ 5
Source: Google
alvie stout
★ 3
It's gas station pizza actually had better at gas stations
Source: Google
Brianna Kenowski
★ 5
Pizza was super good I did the build your own jalapeño bacon one! Crust was nice and crispy! Would eat here again!
Source: Google
Krasimir Mihaylov
★ 5
Source: Google
Mansoor Ahmad
★ 5
Great people and tasty pizza
Source: Google
Zach Pease
★ 1
Unprofessional with how there service was from the start of the order to the end. Workers were all rude and didn’t care to help do what there being paid to do. Also gave wrong drink sizes and didn’t even give us what we asked for. Would’ve asked for them to fix it but they rushed us off and had attitudes. If you’re hungry and looking for a quick bite after work you’re better off somewhere else.
Source: Google
Yana
★ 5
I don't think you can go wrong with build your own pizzas. I love the fresh taste, the sauce and ingredient options you can add. I went on a weekday and there was no wait time. Service was nice. Pizzas came out fast. Big parking lot, and plenty seating space.
Source: Google
Lisa Locke
★ 5
Love it here. You get to build your own pizza anyway you like and they cook it on the wood fire grill. They don't charge you more for more toppings, either. Everything is fresh and delicious. Service is quick and the place is always clean. Great food for a great price.
Source: Google
Michael P
★ 1
Wish I could comment on the food but I can't because after waiting 28 minutes in line we still didn't get our order taken so we walked out. It's a Friday night I understand a wait but to wait 28 minutes to even order when there was only a couple and one person ahead of us is a little ridiculous. There was a family of five that walked out before us, so that's seven people lost out on right there including us. The workers that were working you could tell they were lost, didn't know what they were doing, because they had a worried deer in the headlights look in their eyes and facial reactions. Regardless won't be returning to this location because mod pizza definitely isn't "superfast" here
Source: Google
David Nelson
★ 3
Source: Google
Mike Keon
★ 4
Source: Google
Patrick Last
★ 1
Unable to dine at this establishment because they only service online orders. You cannot dine in
Source: Google
Kimberly Migazzi
★ 5
Source: Google
Gage bochniak
★ 1
The absolute worst mod I’ve ever been to. All the topping are cross contaminated with each other, the store itself is filthy, the workers are rude, especially the general manager they have there, she has absolutely no idea what she’s doing, she has to GO. I wouldn’t recommend this place to my worst enemy
Source: Google
Luv Fit
★ 1
They've been beyond stingy with toppings for whatever reason and I left with a supposed pizza that looked more like a giant cracker with some sauce not even close to the edge and a few sporadic toppings
Source: Google
Luvenia Anderson
★ 5
Perfect for getting a personal pizza with stuff you want on it
Source: Google
Tina Pirofalo
★ 5
Love going here .. family friendly atmosphere and the pizzas are delicious 😋
Source: Google
FISHINGTHECHAIN 1
★ 5
Source: Google
Jeff Abel
★ 4
Source: Google
Christie Pederson
★ 5
Love the dairy free and low carb options!!!
Source: Google
Rene Leonardo Cordon Salazar
★ 5
Source: Google
Stephen Daniel
★ 4
Source: Google
Robert K
★ 4
Fast and convenient pizza.
Source: Google
Fabb Iltail
★ 1
Terrible hours, terrible toilet
Source: Google
Nunya B
★ 5
This place SLAPS, I just don’t like ppl and there’s too many of them in there sometimes, go eat at home losers
Source: Google
Peter L
★ 5
Great people and food. Really nice to stop in after a full day and you just want some good pizza.
Source: Google
Dean Devore
★ 5
Always a great experience.
Source: Google
Megan Pierce
★ 1
Unfortunately it's been a repeating issue of odd hours, rude staff, and long wait times. I can't believe they say they're short staffed while having 5 employees in the back folding boxes. We waited a total of 35 minutes from the moment we walked in to when we eventually got our food. The manager is highly disrespectful to customers in regards to their last minue closings.
Source: Google
Lauren H
★ 4
Source: Google
Angela Knight
★ 5
Love this place super clean staff are super friendly
Source: Google
Alexys Hall
★ 5
YUM! I love how customizable the pizzas are!
Source: Google
Emilie Smith
★ 4
Employees always make it a pleasure to order at this location.
Source: Google
Brian Christopher Perkins
★ 5
Source: Google
Shilo R
★ 5
Was a last minute decision to try this place while on vacation. It was amazing! So good it definitely had me look for one close to home!!
Source: Google
Juan Guzman
★ 5
Source: Google
Jose Diaz
★ 4
Source: Google
Geetha Fisher
★ 5
How can this not be everyone's fav fast food pizza place?! You get what you want, flexible sizes, incredible variety of toppings . And super fast affordable. Also quality of ingredients always 👌
Depending on time and individuals on duty, service can be hit or miss. But never a lack of trying.
Source: Google
Jorge Reyes
★ 1
We were ordering and the girl working was being rude towards my girlfriend and her sister she yelled at them asking if they wanted any meat and was shaking her head for everything they wanted on their pizza. I wouldn’t have people like her working here. I spent money to get treated like that. Then we asked for sauce she was going to pour it on the pizza and we asked on the side and she had an attitude about it. I should’ve took my money else where if i knew i was going to get treated like this. Worst experience. But shout out to the guy that recommended me to put corn on my pizza. Good decision my boi!
Source: Google
SAIJE Foster
★ 5
Source: Google
Sarah Armbrust
★ 1
The staff here is so rude! I have never ever been treated so poorly by anyone in a restaurant before.
Source: Google
Joe Downey
★ 3
Please update the hours on your website and the mobile app. I have tried a few times in the past 2 months to place orders, only to get to the end to find out the store cannot take the order, or is closed. This is 2 to 3 hours prior to the listed hours.
Source: Google
David Bettes
★ 5
The pizza was awesome though a little pricey. Cheese sticks could have used more rosemary, but technically it was not their fault that I like rosemary, next time I will ask for more and pay attention. Oh, the pear tea was so very good!!!!
Source: Google
Kevin Trudeau
★ 5
Make your own pizza like subway for pizza pick your topping and load it up how you want no extra charge 😉
Source: Google
Josh Weber
★ 5
Love that you can get beer with a meal!
Source: Google
Brian Klisz
★ 3
Source: Google
rodney whetlow
★ 1
This the the 2nd time my family and I have tried to go to this restaurant and what kind of restaurant in a tourist town closes at 6pm on a weekend? No dinner hours?
Source: Google
Mindy Lindholm
★ 5
They were really busy but the service was still good as was the food.
Source: Google
Randy Meadows
★ 1
How do you have a pizza place and close at 6 pm. Friday night?
Source: Google
Samantha
★ 2
This pizza is great! HOWEVER. Maybe they should try being open more. Their phone messages says S-Th until 10 pm and Friday and Saturday until 11pm.. however it's Thursday and they closed at 6.. such a disappointment. Everytime we try to go there it's always closed.. probably call first before you make the trip out.
Source: Google
Anthony Patty
★ 5
Source: Google
Jeff Barteldt
★ 5
Source: Google
Renee Freyburger
★ 1
So, we walked into MOD and we were RUDELY spoken to and said” WE ARE NOT TAKING ANY MORE ORDERS”!!!! Really this is the way you treat your customers,WOW!!!! I get there is a shortage of help but there were at least 6 people working behind the counter at least and it wasn’t 6pm! Terrible Service and the saddest part about is All of the Customers THAT WERE IN LINE HEARD EVERYTHING!!!!!
Source: Google
Michael James
★ 1
How hard is it to open on time? I placed an order for pick up, showed up despite saying the store was open. Nobody had even started working until AFTER my order was to be picked up. I love the food but the hours need to reflect what time the store actually opens.
Source: Google
Derek Kratochwill
★ 1
Never open on time and always having issues
Source: Google
Laura Kinerk
★ 5
The place closes at 7:00 on a Friday night. And I think they close even earlier during the week. I think they're missing out on a lot of dinner business.
Source: Google
Cody Crouse
★ 1
Terrible hours with bad customer service. This is the only MOD pizza within 100 miles that closes at 7PM on the weekends and 6PM during the week. I went there at 6:58PM and the door was locked with another customer still in line and patrons dining outside. I tried opening the door and while the employees looked up, nobody had the decency to come over and explain they were closed.
Source: Google
Jason Meckler
★ 1
This Mod only caters to the business crowd and the Summer rentals.
As a local, I've gone there 3 times in the last 6 month and been turned away 3 times because they close at 6:30pm during the week. That is usually when I'm looking to eat dinner after a long day at work. I'm hoping that they close down and we get a Blaze instead.
Source: Google
Jesse Johnston
★ 5
Really impressed. All around good experience. People were nice, prices are good, and the pizza was better than expected. Will definitely go back.
Source: Google
Aaron Quillo
★ 5
Very tasty BBQ Chicken pizza.
Source: Google
Brendhan Sears
★ 5
MOD is great. Staff was super friendly and it was really clean inside.
Source: Google
Jon Muska
★ 5
Best pizza we have ever had!
Source: Google
Lisa Heichelbech
★ 5
Source: Google
Casey Prather
★ 2
Decent pizza but closes at 6. Even on the weekends....
Source: Google
Steven Halverson
★ 5
Source: Google
Stacie Erdman
★ 5
Just had another great pizza at MOD. The crew at this location is so chill. Our pizza was dropped and they needed to remake it. They didn’t get stressed, no manager was freaking out…mistakes happen and it wasn’t a big deal for us or for them. I’ve seen other reviews complain about inconsistent hours. That happens sometimes in food service due to staffing. Also unreliable online ordering…yeah that happens too if a restaurant is getting slammed then they shut it off because their first priority becomes in person customers. Overall we have always been pleased with the quality of the pizza and fresh ingredients, and friendly staff. Keep up the great service, MOD!!
Source: Google
Diana Bulnes
★ 5
Split an 11" pizza. Plenty of food to fill both of us with leftover. The iced tea is yummy! 😁
Source: Google
Joe Stonestreet
★ 5
Nice and friendly staff great food definitely going back again and again
Source: Google
JM G
★ 5
Good pizza. Unique experience for a pizza place
Source: Google
Clay Hall (linnmole)
★ 5
Order ready friendly staff
Source: Google
Melinda Sparks
★ 5
I always love the pizza. The service has always been friendly.
Source: Google
Vivek Babbar
★ 5
Amazing pizza in a very low price.
Recommendation: Order a Build Your Own 11" Pizza. You can pretty much put anything on it as a topping. Its only for $10. The crust is really good. You can choose your own base sauce and your toppings. And, in the end you get the option to add more sauce on the top (variety) or get it on the side.
I really like their pizza. I hightly recommend this place. Good Decor, Friendly Staff.
Source: Google
Kyle Myerson
★ 5
Love the pizza as always! Staff is always groovy! Just keep doing what you're doing!
Source: Google
KIM D
★ 5
Second time visiting, this time with young grandkids. Excellent pizzas and the crusts were very thin and unique.
Source: Google
Nick Clasen
★ 4
Source: Google
Randal Forret (Randy)
★ 4
Source: Google
Scott Badtke
★ 5
Always quick and tasty!
Source: Google
Slaterson
★ 3
Tuesday, 12/20 closed at 6 instead of 7. Sign in the door said they’re hiring, so that’s probably why. I was going to edit the hours, but it looked like someone published special holiday hours that I don’t want to override.
Source: Google
Igor Zapadinsky
★ 5
Faster by app! Awesome 😎👍🏻 overall!!
Source: Google
Travis Northern
★ 1
Normally I enjoy this place, but its quality has declined significantly, and I just had a terrible experience with them today, which is reflective of my rating. My wife stopped to grab pizzas around 5:20pm, only to find out the store was not accepting in-person orders, and they close at 6:00. I tried to place an order online around 5:30, and the website would ‘t allow it, saying an error had occurred. So we called to place an order over the phone, and our call was redirected three times before we finally got in touch with someone. The person who picked up, Ken, the manager, first told me that the online orders “are working fine,” and said I must be doing something wrong. When I confirmed I did everything right, he declined to take an order over the phone, saying it just couldn’t be done, and it was too much work. He then proceeded to yell at me when I asked to confirm that this was actually the case; that trying to order 40 minutes ahead of time in 3 different ways would not be acceptable. I remained cordial the entire time, but this is unbelievable. An overall dreadful customer service experience, stacked on top of spotty hours. This was incredibly disappointing, considering how much I used to love this place.
Source: Google
juan perezj
★ 5
Source: Google
Katie Robl
★ 4
Source: Google
Ann Tremmel
★ 4
Source: Google
De Lany J
★ 5
“Best service” my son said! This crew is insanely cool and we can’t help but yuck it up with them all when we are in there. We even got a photo with everyone! Please keep these people around! Thank you for treating us so well
Source: Google
Rose Perron
★ 4
It's fast food but I think the staff does a great job making your pizza the way you want it
Source: Google
Marcus Webber
★ 3
If your ok paying $65 dollars for a family of 3 to get 3 personal pizzas then you will have one of the best pizzas in your life. If that amount seems absurd the steer clear...
Source: Google
Tom Do Yoon Kim
★ 5
My favorite pizza spot in Lake Geneva! The sauces are really yummy, and all the options you can choose from are great!
While the pizza still tastes great when you order take out, the pizza is really wonderful when you dine in and enjoy it hot and crispy!
When the weather is nice, they have a patio with umbrellas.
The service here has always been great!
They accidentally forget a few items on our pizza and they gave us a free pizza.
Source: Google
SVP
★ 5
Hands down the staff working today did amazing job dealing with rude customers. Friendly staff and great experience. Delicious pizza.
Source: Google
Charley w. Ross jr.
★ 5
Source: Google
juan Guerrero
★ 5
My fav.. can pick watever i want for same prize..
Source: Google
Mary Thorn
★ 5
So yummy!!!! They are very good at what they do.
Source: Google
Gail Bockwoldt
★ 2
Sign should tell you what each topping is as well as sauce toppings.
Source: Google
Brian Wagner
★ 1
Worst customer service ever!
I have the app and it says Lake Geneva's open till 10 PM. Did an online order just after 7 and the app said they were closed. I called and they said they were up until 8 PM but online ordering ended at 6 PM
Went to store and tried to order the online special and was told I could not order that in store, nor was online currently open, I could order the same pizza at over $4 more.
The very unfriendly manager addressed my issue By saying it was a staffing issue, although I could still order the same pizza from one of the other 6 employees behind the counter.
Never, never again , fool me once...
Source: Google
Lisa Timmers
★ 4
Source: Google
April McCorkhill
★ 1
They close at 7 PM... 7 PM!!!
Source: Google
Jennings Wells
★ 5
Amazing new take on delicious pizza at an extremely reasonable price! Amazing staff always friendly! And if you're a DoorDasher you get free complimentary drinks at ANY of the MOD locations! /TIP\ although it is better if you eat in the store instead of taking it home
Source: Google
carol mcdonald
★ 5
Lots of variety in toppings
Great service
Really liked crust.
Source: Google
Dee M
★ 5
I built my own Mod and it was on POINT!! THANKS FOR LOADING me up and not skipping out on the ingredients.
Source: Google
Cary Janssen
★ 5
Good food good place to eat
Source: Google
Juliana Holder
★ 5
Friendly, courteous staff, quick service. Great tasting pizza.
Source: Google
Marie
★ 5
Source: Google
gina theesfield
★ 3
We love MOD pizza. But the hours are unreliable. Even if Google says it's open til 11pm and updated recently, it's best to call. They aren't always open very late. I witnessed one employee yell at his manager. Because the staff is ever changing, sometimes the pizzas are delicious, sometimes they are a bit undercooked. But when they are good, they are quite wonderful!
Source: Google
Allen Gollnick
★ 5
Source: Google
M G
★ 5
Source: Google
Jensine Bottlemy
★ 1
Never consistent with their hours.
Source: Google
Laura Grenier
★ 5
Source: Google
Megan Miller
★ 5
Source: Google
Cassidy Bucholtz
★ 4
Source: Google
Doris Rodman
★ 5
Source: Google
Kari Spaeth
★ 5
Source: Google
Lexi Haines
★ 1
What pizza place closes at 7 PM on Friday night?! These hours are ridiculous! Second time coming here where you guys are closing super early.
Source: Google
Mleo F
★ 5
I like their pizzas! They taste really good!! The only advice I'll give is, that can you please cook more the pizza, last two times the ingredients were raw, and mushy.
Source: Google
Nycki Willemsen
★ 5
So delicious every single time!!!
Source: Google
Paulette Washay
★ 5
Source: Google
Teri Fruin
★ 5
Shout out to a gracious staff allowing some late team players join the rest of the hangry boys, after the posted closing time! They were super nice and accommodating!! The 13 U Beloit Bomber baseball team THANK YOU!!
Source: Google
Tamie Everson
★ 5
A HUGE SHOUTOUT to the staff for staying open and accommodating our very HUNGRY baseball team! Thank You, Thank You, Thank You!!! You hit it out of the park⚾️
Source: Google