North Star American Bistro

Shorewood, 4518 N Oakland Ave, Shorewood, WI 53211, United States | β˜… 4.3 (172 Review)

πŸ“ž +1 414-964-4663

Last Search

Category

Restaurant American restaurant

Description

Under new ownership

Photos

 North Star American Bistro
 North Star American Bistro
 North Star American Bistro
 North Star American Bistro
 North Star American Bistro

Leave a Review

Reviews

Nathan Nicolaisen

β˜… 5

Source: Google

David Corblin

β˜… 5

Un brunch de qualitΓ©.
Big up pour la possibilitΓ© de concocter nos propres Bloody Mary !

Source: Google

LJP

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Yelena Wu

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Dania Stachiw-Hietpas

β˜… 5

Source: Google

B. Booth

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Larry Haynes

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Kim Hirsch

β˜… 2

Source: Google

Peter Buccowich

β˜… 3

The atmosphere was on the nicer end, but not formal by any means. The service was great and the staff were helpful and friendly. The food was alright and the serving size for the meal I got (bourbon salmon) was a little small for the price paid. That, paired with a staff who was over aggressive with plate clearing brings this restaurant down to 3 stars.

Source: Google

Erik Hockstad

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Nancie Cotter

β˜… 5

The scallops special tonight was delicious. They were crispy on the ooutside, and tender inside. The sweet potato puree was also tasty. It was the perfect combination of flavors. Barb, our wait person did a fabulous job serving us, returning just when we needed her, for more water, coffee, and dessert. Lovely evening.

Source: Google

Kyle Kaliebe

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Paul Erixson

β˜… 5

Drinks and appetizers were fabulous. Eggplant & zucchini!!!

Source: Google

Popper ZoltΓ‘n

β˜… 5

Finom Γ©telek, kedves kiszolgΓ‘lΓ‘s, korekt Γ‘rak

Source: Google

Gordon Phillips

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Yuri Zobachev

β˜… 3

Source: Google

Chicott Table Tennis

β˜… 5

Wonderful menu. Steak au Poivre is awesome.

Source: Google

Charles Chapell

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Dave Rusch

β˜… 3

We've eaten here many times in both the bar area and dining room. I thought the service was sub-par during our most recent visit.

Source: Google

Josie Matuszak

β˜… 5

Good place for a birthday dinner!

Source: Google

Mary Kleinschmidt

β˜… 5

Had a fabulous dinner! The new owner is really improving the place.Wonderful specials. I have some events I will be planning and will definitely consider North Star Bistro!

Source: Google

Mark Farrow

β˜… 5

Excellent food, professional and friendly staff.

Source: Google

Jon Wilkins

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Marni Pollack

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Prakhar Prakash

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Amanda Cooper

β˜… 5

Staff is very pleasant and professional . The food is very tasty and fresh. Definitely a from scratch kitchen. Ive eaten dinner and brunch there now and plan to go back often. Love that theres options to eat at the bar, inside. Or outside. I made the mistake of not getting their build your own bloody mary when i went for brunch on Sunday but heard a table near me loving theirs, so i will have to go back soon

Source: Google

Robert McMurray

β˜… 5

Excellent. Everything was good: from the greeting upon arrival, the craft beers the wine selection, to the food. Their carmalized salmon with asapagus was amazing!

Source: Google

Katie Purnell

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Rheanne Tibbits

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Mark Maxcy

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Peter Stachiw

β˜… 5

Nice place

Source: Google

David Herszenson

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Patrick Davies

β˜… 5

Lovely dining experience. Always great food. The rustic pizza was particularly good. Highly recommended.

Source: Google

Stephen Blanquie

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Pablo Corea

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Boran Katunarić

β˜… 4

Source: Google

James Jones

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Eric Thompson

β˜… 4

Loved my apple pie French toast.

Source: Google

Geneva Fowler

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Joey phalen

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Donelle Johnson

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Bai Whit

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Brad E

β˜… 3

This place has been inconsistent. Food's generally pretty good. Service has been average to "walk out" awful.

Source: Google

Fishing Milwaukee

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Andrew Lesbines

β˜… 2

Took forever to get served a giant glass of ice water with a couple tablespoons of bourbon.

Source: Google

Daniel Gonzalez

β˜… 5

Great atmosphere and great food.

Source: Google

Jeff Cherrington

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Cassie Dude

β˜… 5

Every aspect of my meal was perfect.

Source: Google

Mike Stone

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Pam L

β˜… 4

My husband new favorite fish fry

Source: Google

Thomas Pheister

β˜… 5

Love the children's dining room. Go there with extended family, kids can play while waiting for dinner.

Source: Google

Charles Huang

β˜… 5

Source: Google

John Hruska

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Logan Prasser

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Mitchell Horner

β˜… 4

The steak aup poivre was delicious, the staff was friendly and the space was comfortable and well lit.

Source: Google

Anna Schmidt

β˜… 5

Always good food and the truffle fries are awesome! Fish is always cooked perfectly.

Source: Google

Rafael Chavez C.

β˜… 5

Very good pizza and hamburgers. Excellent service. Nice do-your-own bloody Mary bar.

Source: Google

Lori Zindl

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Bethany Auble

β˜… 4

Source: Google

John Hill

β˜… 1

Waited 10 minutes and never was greeted or seated. When I left with my party a staff member thanked me for coming and I replied we were never served at which time she then said there was a table available. Need improvement on hospitality training.

Source: Google

Jeanne Schwartz

β˜… 5

This isn't Mom's meat loaf wrapped in bacon..its even better. Ambience..and good service.

Source: Google

Alex Rein

β˜… 5

Has a kids room with toys. Food is very good too.

Source: Google

Dan Ward

β˜… 5

Bar tender has awesome unique concoctions
On menu , two of which..r his, the only ones I tasted,
...r over the top!

Source: Google

Jackie Wachowski

β˜… 4

Good make your own bloody Mary's on Sunday. Menu limited but good. Service. Good. Quiet with a back room with toys for small children.

Source: Google

Eric Wilke

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Mike W

β˜… 1

Was here for someone's bday party who had booked a room/large table. I was able to see the bill and was shocked at how over-priced the food was. It was the longest wait for food we ever had. When it finally came, all food was average at best. The sliders were so overcooked and dry, they weren't even edible. Based on this experience, I would never eat here on my own, nor would I recommend it.

Source: Google

Christopher August

β˜… 4

Really cozy spot with solid food and a decent tap beer selection. Really enjoyed it and would come back. Recommend the pizzas.

Source: Google

Helen Wauck

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Jon

β˜… 4

Wonderful and delicious restaurant. Very comfort environment.

Source: Google

Christy Barden

β˜… 5

Source: Google

John H

β˜… 5

Lots of Shorewoodie women looking for men
πŸ‘πŸŽ…

Source: Google

Jim Timler

β˜… 5

Nice menu and atmosphere.

Source: Google

T Hvxley

β˜… 2

Tepid offerings

Source: Google

Stacey Meyer

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Steven Port

β˜… 4

The bistro is a pleasant place to eat and/or drink. There are 3 rooms with different purposes to meet different needs including a family oriented room. Staff is typically friendly and efficient. The service is good. The food is consistently good in all categories. The menu is stable with many "go to" options that have been on the menu for years. If I had any issue it would be the lack of experimentation with menu but I understand they have a good thing going.

Source: Google

Timothy Hyer-Devine

β˜… 5

Great meal! It was nice to be able to let our son run and play.

Source: Google

Deborah Bair

β˜… 4

Many different plates to chose from... beautifully presented...great service, very friendly staff.

Source: Google

Brian Jira

β˜… 5

Great food and drinks in a wonderful neighborhood!

Source: Google

Jeff Purnell

β˜… 5

Source: Google

jean kies

β˜… 4

Nice place for a meal!!

Source: Google

Joseph Cooper

β˜… 3

It's a ok place-lot of beer variety

Source: Google

Chris Olson

β˜… 5

Outstanding service and exceptional food!

Source: Google

BootoyouPlays MC

β˜… 2

The waitress was really nice, but the food is so average for the price I really can't recommend it at all.

Source: Google

Judith Pruim

β˜… 5

Great drinks, appetizer (happy hour 1/2 price) and entree. Service also was very good. Will be back.

Source: Google

Phyllis Olson

β˜… 5

Great food

Source: Google

Brandon Feil

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Amanda Barber

β˜… 4

We love the family dining area when going to brunch. The menu is rather limited but everything I've tried has been good. The kids menu is great and kids meals are free on Sundays.

Source: Google

Sharrieff Pope

β˜… 3

Looks great smells amazing

Source: Google

Chris Shallop

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Timothy Taylor

β˜… 5

Really enjoyed their fish fry here last Friday. Service is always great.

Source: Google

Jay Felstow

β˜… 4

A very nice place, with very good food and beverage selection. Our waiter was nervous, which we assumed because he was new. He was a bit slow to provide us good service, but polite and friendly.

Source: Google

Steve Newton

β˜… 4

Excellent food, unusual menu, a little pricey

Source: Google

Jennifer Farrell

β˜… 4

Great food, good service, solid drinks. It is pricey, though. But the food is really good. Cute minimalist interior. Clean.

Source: Google

Tim Chaplock

β˜… 4

Food was good and the service staff was very nice

Source: Google

Samantha Lobo

β˜… 4

I've been here for lunch a few times and I've always liked it, but this was our first time here for dinner and I was very impressed! We sat on the patio and it's a really nice atmosphere. I ordered the short rib and my husband ordered the salmon special with artichoke risotto - both were fabulous! The mushrooms with the short rib were a delicious addition and the red pepper sauce was the perfect accompaniment to the salmon. We also had the flourless chocolate cake with their vanilla ice cream instead of the raspberry and it was perfect! I'm giving 4 stars because there weren't enough servers so ours didn't have a chance to be very attentive.

Source: Google

Keely Kohrs-Herwig

β˜… 5

Source: Google

luke jeter

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Janet Konczal

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Don Kosovich

β˜… 5

Never a bad meal there

Source: Google

Linda Edmondson

β˜… 5

Excellent spinach salad with salmon
Attentive server.

Source: Google

Claudia Strehl

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Kelly Riley

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Matthew Manley-Browne

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Weston Wagner

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Marc Weiss

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Thomas Stuart

β˜… 5

Good food

Source: Google

Sid Kuo

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Smallbobcat08 O.G.

β˜… 4

Food was great, other customers were kind of snobs though

Source: Google

Larry S

β˜… 4

Nice resturant off Oakland on Eside. Went for Father's day meal. Good meal menu. Waiters/staff courteous. Was not crowded at afternoon mealtime. No shade at window seating.

Source: Google

pam Hodermann

β˜… 4

Good food, floor was sticky which was a distraction.

Source: Google

Robin Midgett

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Cristy Lozano

β˜… 5

DeliciousπŸ˜‹πŸ˜‹

Source: Google

Nicole Aiello

β˜… 4

Always great food. Bloody mary bar on Sundays is my favorite! Their offering of a family room is something I think more restaurants should consider (if they want to expand in the family market). I have to say something about their tables makes them always sticky though. Not sure if the resin/acrylic they coated them with is being dissolved with whatever they're cleaning them with or what.

Shout out to Henry for the excellent customer service!

Source: Google

Elle Govek

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Jordan Hendry

β˜… 1

Awful apathetic staff. One night in Shorewood looking for a place to eat the village was busy so we called and asked if we arrived in the next five minutes would we be able to get a table. Pierre who clearly has no idea what his job is for the restaurant, said yeah no problem and did not bother to ask for our name which would indicate they were not at all busy.

When we arrived Pierre himself would not seat us as β€œwe had some walk-ins” and there were no tables available. That is unacceptable and unfortunately not only will I never return but I will make sure to never mention this restaurant as a recommendation even going so far as to suggest other locations.

Go elsewhere. The lack of service will ruin your experience. There are plenty of other restaurants close by.

Source: Google

Kim Schmoldt

β˜… 5

Always a great meal. Love that they have a separate family room. Will go with or without the kiddo

Source: Google

Derek Riley

β˜… 5

Source: Google

James G. (DarthCepheus)

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Matt Hazeltine

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Dan Beauchamp

β˜… 5

Very good food. Good service. Incredible French Onion Soup.

Source: Google

Matt Pappas

β˜… 3

Source: Google

Lisa Potter

β˜… 5

Great family-friendly restaurant. Food is good; they have a dining area just for families with a play room, so adults can converse while kids get play time, without disturbing dining guests who are not with children.

Source: Google

dmblake9

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Nekko Strickland

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Mitch Nelles

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Zoey Brady

β˜… 5

Amazing food! Yummy!

Source: Google

Carmello Hernandez

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Nat Davauer

β˜… 3

Source: Google

S L

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Mary Mehn

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Sean Wiler

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Aaron Genualdi

β˜… 1

Source: Google

Carolyn Bakos

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Leonard P. Levine

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Mary Byrne

β˜… 4

Source: Google

LenTasks Levine

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Mark Jacobs

β˜… 5

Great for everyone. Separate room for kids to play

Source: Google

Michael Berndt

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Michael Paprocki

β˜… 4

Good food. Pls kids eat free on Sundays.

Source: Google

Andrea V

β˜… 2

Source: Google

N Gleason

β˜… 4

Nice breakfast and lunch menu (and tap beer) with attentive waitstaff.

Source: Google

Tyler Tushkowski

β˜… 5

Food was amazing and had a nice original touch that separated it from your typical place. Will DEFINITELY be back!

Source: Google

Patrick Wilson

β˜… 5

Excellent upscale menu and great wine selection

Source: Google

Christopher S.

β˜… 4

Very Good food and service consistently.

Source: Google

M B

β˜… 5

Great food laid back vibe

Source: Google

Gaye Kiel

β˜… 5

Delicious seafood, appetizers, wine. Friendly staff. Good pricing.

Source: Google

Andrew Meyer

β˜… 5

Pricey but worth it.

Source: Google

Erica Rodenbeck

β˜… 3

The food here is good, but a bit pricey. I also wish that they had a few more vegetarian options. They've had the same few (margarita pizza, mushroom veg sandwich, and two entree salads) for years now. I get that it's important to have 'the classics', but we've honestly stopped going because we got tired of those choices. It might be an issue of demographics though; most of the clientele seems older, so it's possible that this is what they want.

Source: Google

Jasna Coralic

β˜… 2

Source: Google

Mike Krivsky

β˜… 5

Maura did such a great job on our rehearsal dinner this last Friday. Everyone thought the food was great and the ambiance of the room was just right for us. Your staff and servers were awesome and the flow of food was well planned out the whole night. The play area inside the room was a wonderful touch for the kids as well.
We appreciated so much that you were so willing to work with us on our many dietary requests. Gluten Free, Dairy free, Egg free!

Thanks
Mike&Juliana

Source: Google

Joe Gilliland-Lloyd

β˜… 4

Source: Google

Deedra T

β˜… 3

Source: Google

P.&F. Holloway

β˜… 5

We were in large group in children's area and were handled great! We had two little ones who were also taken care off😊 They were fed quickly with smiles. Thank you so much☘☘

Source: Google

Pierre Aterianus

β˜… 5

Source: Google

rod Wilson

β˜… 1

We have eaten here before and found food reasonable. For father's day I ordered chicken and waffles to try something new. The meal was way below expectations for this restaurant - dried out chicken bits and tiny dry toaster waffles - tasteless. Should have turned the meal back but didn't want to ruin our father's day meal. Should be taken off menu.
Break fast skillet seemed a better choice if I dare return.
My overall impression is that the quality has changed.

Source: Google

JOHN FISHBONE

β˜… 5

Superb eggs benedict, great coffee and service

Source: Google

Melissa Wilkerson

β˜… 5

We love this spot for breakfast! Very tasty. If you have little kids they have a family room with a bunch of toys so you can enjoy your meal while they play. Great service too

Source: Google

Tom Pappas

β˜… 4

great happy hour plates and drink specials. nice Sunday buffet

Source: Google

Bob Christian

β˜… 5

Great food and drinks, definitely enjoy dining there.

Source: Google

John Aiello

β˜… 5

Source: Google

Taylor

β˜… 4

Source: Google

James Barber

β˜… 5

Always a fantastic brunch. They have a kid area where your children can play while you eat or wait for the food. The bloody mary bar is excellent (as long as you don't get there late).

Source: Google

Jon Stein

β˜… 4

Our party of 10 was served quite quickly, good food, great service.

Source: Google

Kevin Ziegler

β˜… 4

Very good food, and family friendly

Source: Google

Thomas Story

β˜… 3

Toys in kids are completely busted and/or totally grimy. Asked about chalk, waitress said look in the toys- none. Food is pretty tasty for price, but expect $100+ for 4 people. Lastly, atmosphere- sign on door to men's bathroom said, "Mr. Plumber, urinal will not flush, and second stall leaking.." A handle was busted off one of the sinks. Not something you see at a place that is $100 for 4.

Source: Google

Scott Giese

β˜… 5

Great brunch! Affordable & kids ate free on a Sunday!

Source: Google

sadie barnes

β˜… 3

The Yello Fin Tuna was fantastic, however the interior could have been..way better. The service was great. But it wasn't the type of place that left a memorable experience in your memory. For being a bistro, I had expected the menu to be more "fancy" than it was.

Source: Google

Jaime Meyer

β˜… 3

They don't offer much by way of vegetarian food, but you can order plates without meat on it and hope it is not made with chicken stock.My butternut squash ravioli without the scallops was average, although the white sauce it was smothered in was tasty. My fiance, on the other hand, was very impressed with his Steak Au Poivre.

Source: Google

Wisconny Johnny

β˜… 3

Thursday happy hour, that is all, if you want the retired community feel

Source: Google

Foxynique27

β˜… 5

The food was good nice romantic place

Source: Google

Jeremy Ampe

β˜… 5

Source: Google

C. M.

β˜… 3

I have been back to the North Star American Bistro four times.
Each time I am hoping for a better experience.
Sadly it seems each time there is always one or more short comings that you would not expect.
It is like a student that is capable of an A grade but for some reason cannot achieve any higher than a C.

I will start with the things that are constant yet very weird and annoying.
There is a bread person walking around whose job it seems is to make you feel special because you received a single thin slice of bread.
Should I ask for more bread? Give me a break, provide a table basket with variety and be done with it.
Then there is an individual who walks (does laps) around the restaurant not providing eye contact with any customers.
Are the employees told to look busy?

My last visit was the evening of 2/14/13. The restaurant was busy and we had a waiter who could not seem to get things right for us. Wrong drink ect.
Then all of a sudden he was gone (MIA) and someone else shows up, to whom I re-stated my previous requests.

It really seems beyond employee training this restaurant should really get a grasp of hospitality.

This is one of few restaurants that accepts reservations.
I have arrived (dined) with and without reservations.

The food is a pleasant surprise in variety and taste. Portions average to small.
Good bar atmosphere. Happy hour I believe yet have not attended.
The bottom line is if I return, it would be for the food.

Source: Google