Category
Bar & grill Bar RestaurantDescription
Off Broadway Drafthouse is a historical neighborhood gathering spot that friends tell friends about. A hidden gem with quality beverages and thoughtfully sourced food are what sets us apart. Our friendly, experienced staff and relaxed atmosphere will keep you coming back for more. We offer 24 brews on tap representing a constantly rotating selection with many seasonal options including an assortment of non-alcoholic options. Our full-service bar also offers standard mixed drinks, several signature cocktails and a hand-picked selection of specialty wines. We offer a full menu with a traditional Friday Fish Fry and our amazing Saturday and Sunday BBQ Ribs! We have the most unique dining experience in all of the greater Madison area...
Photos
Leave a Review
Reviews
Jiho Kim
★ 5
fish fry가 맛있다고 해서 금욜에 찾아갔는데 생선이 부들부들하니 간도 맞고 잘 먹었다. battered deep fry 보다 그냥 구운 생선이 더 맛있긴했다. 야외 패티오가 분위기가 아늑하니 괜찮았다.
Source: Google
Shannon Dias, CPC
★ 5
Great cocktails and a good mix of options. The service was great.
Source: Google
Adam Singleton
★ 5
This place is next level. The beer is cold. Food is amazing. Get the cod and chips. The pretzel burger was awesome too. Big shout out to Isa, Jordan, and the hostesses. I came in after getting off a plane from Tampa and they instantly make you feel like a long lost friend. If I am back in wisconsin I am stopping at Off Broadway!
Source: Google
Sumeet Vats
★ 5
Really enjoyed our meal here. Warm and friendly service, tasty food, and a great selection of drinks! Too many interesting looking items on the menu, so need to come back again!
Source: Google
John C Shea
★ 5
Source: Google
Joline Dye
★ 5
The burgers and the Chicken Parmesan were very, very good.
Source: Google
Steven Dye
★ 5
Great atmosphere, awesome service, and the food was amazing!! Would highly recommend.
Source: Google
Adam Danz
★ 4
Amazing food cooked well, timing was slightly off with how everything came out and the soup needed to be rewarmed because of it but most of us enjoyed ourselves immensely.
Source: Google
Denise Nelson
★ 5
The food was delicious and the portions were generous. My steak was cooked just as I ordered it, was tender, and seasoned to perfection. I tried a local IPA (the Mosiac?) and it was great. It was too chilly for us to enjoy the outdoor seating section and garden but you could tell that someone put a lot of thought and effort into it. Overall, this was a satisfying dining experience and we will be back!
Source: Google
Jeremiah Brod
★ 5
Best burger and best fries period. We drive all the way from Oshkosh just to have their burger and fries. Friendly and efficient waitstaff. The place is always clean.
Source: Google
Jeff Collins
★ 5
Been waiting to try Off Broadway, and it absolutely did not disappoint. Unique menu, great execution and wonderful wait staff. Absolutely delicious, we will return! We also loved reading the history, and had no idea there used to be an airport on the south side of Madison... really cool!
Source: Google
Natalie L
★ 4
Great service and lively Saturday atmosphere. The sandwiches were abnormally small for the price.
Source: Google
A Wycklendt
★ 4
Source: Google
Kelly Carpe
★ 5
Source: Google
Carol Bunk
★ 5
Loved the food. Loved the service. Drinks were great. The mussels and Volcano Shrimp are fabulous. Will definitely come again!
Source: Google
Reanna Nelson
★ 5
Source: Google
Scott Hartman
★ 5
First time visiting, we really enjoyed the atmosphere and menu selection. The service was great for our party of 6 (no reservation, but we arrive fairly early), and all of our entres looked delicious. We will definitely be back!
Source: Google
chris thurston
★ 4
Source: Google
Jason Daniels
★ 5
Great food and appetizers. Friendly service. We will definitely be back often. Lots of other places have been slipping on food quality and lost our business.
Source: Google
shawn geino
★ 5
Loved everything about this place. Each member of our party ordered something different from the menu, and each raved how good it was. Loved the gluten-free buns. They did not fall apart and were delicious! Great tap and cocktail list. Will be back.
Source: Google
Abdulahi Mohamud
★ 5
Source: Google
Scott Pulvermacher
★ 5
Source: Google
Brian Gillman
★ 5
Came for the fish fry! Good food, service was good but the place was busy and sat with empty drinks a couple of times for a while. Fairly crowded but overall cool place and good food!
Source: Google
Lacey Powell
★ 4
Source: Google
Alan Schauer
★ 4
We sat outside on a beautiful Sunday afternoon and really enjoyed the wonderful atmosphere — it’s a great spot to relax. The prices are very reasonable for Madison, which is a big plus. My only critique is that the ahi tuna and mashed potatoes were a bit underwhelming. That said, this place has a lot going for it, and I’ll definitely be back to explore more of the menu. It’s absolutely worth checking out!
Source: Google
Ashley Brown
★ 5
Source: Google
Lance Green
★ 5
Wonderful seared walley! Tasty Chicken Diablo in tomato-basil wrap. And...... PECAN PIE CHEESECAKE!!!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Source: Google
Cathy
★ 5
Source: Google
ARA OF MADISON Casey
★ 5
Very attentive service persons, the kitchen produces excellent tasty food very quickly, the place is immaculate. we will be back.
Source: Google
Jon Robb
★ 5
Great food...great service...great atmosphere
Source: Google
Barbara Boushon
★ 4
Source: Google
Creig Zook
★ 5
Great American pub with good food and drinks and atmosphere. Great beer selection, lots of TVs, good service, good prices.
Source: Google
Th KCK
★ 5
Die Küche ist ausgezeichnet!
Source: Google
Mary Polebitski
★ 5
Excellent food and service!
Source: Google
Ryan Ramp
★ 5
Tasty food.
Source: Google
Darryl Goodman
★ 5
Really good food and fast service!!!
Source: Google
Jon Farris
★ 5
Terrific 24-beer-tap bar with indoor and outdoor seating. Food is unique and always excellent. Friendly staff. Highly recommended.
Source: Google
Carl Schock
★ 5
Good food and drinks at reasonable prices. We enjoyed it. The service is excellent.
Source: Google
Beth Schumann
★ 5
Source: Google
Drew Leja
★ 5
Nicely crafted menu items and a generous beer selection plus cocktails. Very nice outdoor seating and wonderful staff. The fried chicken is quite good!
Source: Google
Alaraya Holmberg
★ 4
Sit at the bar for good service. 5 Stars at the bar. Cant recommend table service. Can not recommend bringing kids. Certain staff is rude, like others have mentioned. Some food is great, some is okay.
Source: Google
Sandy Randall
★ 5
Amazing fish fry and drinks.
Source: Google
Glen Link
★ 4
I liked everything about this place except for one thing. The tables that were for 4 people were too small. We could barely fit our plates on the table and having space for appetizers was not possible. The food and service was great.
Source: Google
J Beaumont
★ 5
a hidden gem, everything great about Wisconsin. Good food, great beer, and a unique and welcoming atmosphere!
Source: Google
Andy Hughes
★ 5
Source: Google
Simon Crapo
★ 5
Great food. Great drinks. Great service. We are from out of town and I saw this online. They have great food. I had their Korean tacos which were very tasty. I wish that the tacos came with a side as I still felt a little hungry after so I ordered some of the coconut shrimp. Those are very good!
Source: Google
R
★ 5
It was a busy place but we got in right away. We say by the bar. The server was very helpful and attentive. We wish we were hungrier but what we ate was delicious. (apps & burger) Will try again.
Source: Google
Jesse Sharp
★ 5
Great burgers. Outdoor patio was very nice. Inside was quite loud.
Source: Google
holly larson
★ 5
Loved everything! We got sat by the kitchen so the kids could watch the chefs cook.
Source: Google
David Harris (Nightstick)
★ 5
Great custom service and dog friendly 🐶 patio A+
Source: Google
Mitch Mcnaughton
★ 5
Really a nice a place to eat. Good food that was liked by all 5 at our table. My portion was a little small not enough to bumb off of 5 stars. Wait staff was good. Wide variety of things to try.
Source: Google
Larry Stark
★ 4
The food was good. The wait person was not so good. We asked if our 90 minute stay could start when one of our party was late, she flat out said no.
Source: Google
Todd Arner
★ 5
Source: Google
arnoud hassett
★ 5
Such kind staff.
Source: Google
Alanna Keegan
★ 5
The food was amazing here! We got the drafthouse muscles, mushroom risotto, and fried chicken and everything was excellent. Staff was also great and very friendly.
Source: Google
Chuck Mahon
★ 5
A pleasant surprise. A delicious menu paired with craft cocktails and a selection of craft brews ... All in a comfortable, clean, relaxed setting with attentive and friendly service. I'll be back. This is a well run restaurant.
Source: Google
Gabe Whipple
★ 3
We had a tough time with parking, got seated right away though but felt rushed and they even have signs stating there is a 90 minute time limit, which isnt a big deal but adds to the rushed feeling. Everything came very quick and was on track for a perfect service, then, the waiter just disappeared for 15 to 20 minutes when we were finished and waiting for a check. All the food and drinks were fine but not great. The menu looks very exciting but fell a little short. We had burgers which they pride as a specialty with the local beef being promoted on the menu. They were OK. The ahi tuna was done just right and was quite good. The specialty drinks were decent as well. I would say the drinks are the highlight and they even have a good section for alcohol removed and na drinks. Overall an ok place to eat every once in a while. I suspect they would knock it out of the park when not busy. We were there on a Friday for lunch.
Source: Google
Jane D
★ 5
Fish fry was great. Outdoor garden seating is very nice.
Source: Google
Bob Christian
★ 5
We have been here before and it has been great every time. But there are new menu items and it was better than ever. Definitely a must try!
Source: Google
Steven Bloy
★ 4
Source: Google
Don Magill
★ 5
Source: Google
Ro W
★ 5
Source: Google
Sabrina Orloff
★ 5
😍🤤
Went to Off Broadway Drafthouse in Monona today, and it was SOOO good!
We got a couple appies to try; coconut shrimp 10/10, curds 8/10, and frites 7/10! All soo good, though I expected more of a crunch from the frites based on the way they were described to me.
To drink my husband had an old fashioned— 10/10
I have an infused pineapple mango mojito — 10/10
My husband and uncle ordered their burgers, and loved them.
Our girls ordered BLTs—can’t go wrong with those!
I ordered the Birria Melt, with frites (no onion, I have a texture thing) and that was INCREDIBLE! An absolute 10/10. There was so much flavor in the birria meat, the chipotle aïoli was a nice kick to it and I love a good saucy sandwich.
Overall we had a great experience, we sat out side and the atmosphere was nice and we had a beautiful day. The staff was friendly and welcoming, and on top of things! We got our drinks and appies promptly, dirty dishes were cleared away quickly, they continued to check and make sure we had everything we needed and kept smiles on their faces.
We will absolutely be back, to show our friends and family this place for sure!😎🥰
Source: Google
Melissa Wilkerson
★ 5
Went here yesterday , what delicious food, drinks and service. Thank you Griffin for great service very appreciated.
Source: Google
ᗪOᗯᑎTOᗯᑎ ᗪᗩᗪ
★ 5
Cozy and comfortable with excellent food, drinks and service. Nice sunny indoor dining area, and good outdoor seating for warmer months.
Competent and friendly service every time. Cucumber lemonade is wonderful. Friday fish fry all day. 2 patios and dogs welcome on 1 of the patios. Highly recommended!
Source: Google
Scott Kipp
★ 2
Risotto tasted microwaved and the only options for burgers were grass fed, which seriously lack flavor. Was OK, but in no hurry to return.
Source: Google
Moco Dulce
★ 3
I was in Madison visiting and some friends suggested going to this place for drinks. We did not order food. Had never been to this place before so I was not familiar with their drinks. Upon entering that had 2 TV screens with what I thought were different beers but it turned our most were mixed cocktails on tap, which I had never seen before. Turned out it was mostly cocktails and not many beers to choose from. A bit pricey too but I gave in out of curiosity. They had Jalapeño Margarita which was ok that came in a small glass jar. I ordered another drink but different and then we did a shot of Tequila to honor some that had passed. Although the taps on all the drinks you can get are labeled they don't tell you right off that they are cocktails on tap but it's a different place to go and try out. Can't say anything about the food as we did not order any.
Source: Google
Scott V
★ 5
Source: Google
Federico Sossai
★ 5
Source: Google
Didier Robin
★ 4
Super accueil.. cocktail sans alcool au top
Source: Google
Jeff Ruedinger
★ 5
Source: Google
Sam Havey
★ 5
They open early! They're highly accommodating. Good vibes, a menu for everybody--and highly professional
Thank you, Ashley!
Source: Google
John Migas
★ 5
Enjoyed our fish fry, although we all ordered perch, received Cod instead. It was still very tasty- and did not raise the issue.
Source: Google
J U
★ 5
The food was so good. Highly recommend.
Source: Google
Zari az
★ 5
Lost track of time after a murpheys law type of day for our anniversary. [9:46pm]
Greg gave us his burrito which was the best thing I ever ate on his way out (cooks were done for the night) .
Only ones there..[wasnt rushed 2leave]
Midwest never felt so good.
Yes.yep
ope....love this place.
Source: Google
Reanna Salona
★ 5
Source: Google
Camille Cole
★ 5
Source: Google
Kelly Kozar
★ 5
Great food, Great prices and wonderful outdoor seating!
Source: Google
Jeff Szczerbinski
★ 5
Source: Google
Charles Sackett
★ 4
Excellent place. Great service and a very good menu. I wish that you had ALL of the posts at the end of the parking lot clearly visible with a pylon on top of them, not just SOME of the posts. My lunch is now going to be very expensive because of those low sitting posts without clear visibility from the driver's seat.
Edit: That lunch cost me $1300 because of the hard-to-see posts at the back edge of the parking lot. The owner of the body shop told me that he's seen several cars with damage from this parking lot. Still very unhappy about this.
Source: Google
Ryan Gilbert
★ 5
Atmosphere is great. A step up from bar food but nothing fancy, the food is always good though.
Source: Google
Fern Luciana
★ 4
Source: Google
Badger Fan
★ 5
I had a great lunch at Off Broadway!
Source: Google
Tom Warfield
★ 5
This restaurant was close to my hotel and had good ratings, so I decided to try it. The place was packed at 6 pm on a Wednesday night. We had to wait 30 minutes for a table.
The only disappointing aspect was they were out of a lot of items on the menu. We shared the salmon main dish. It was very tasty.
Parking was very limited. More cars were on the side streets than the actual parking lot. Easy parking though, it was a very short walk.
Source: Google
Todd Porter
★ 3
Sat on the patio, which might explain why we seldom saw our server. My meal (pork chop) wasn't edible, and by the time she came back around (nearly 20 mins) I wasn't in the mood to wait for something else. They took it off my bill without issue.
Source: Google
Blythe Robbins
★ 4
Source: Google
Matt Martin
★ 4
Source: Google
Shahla Werner
★ 5
Great mussels and perch fish fry. Delicious cider. Special place!
Source: Google
John Galetka
★ 5
I was advised to eat here. Typically, I’ve been steered wrong. However, the Off Broadway was a pleasant surprise. The wait staff were really nice and informative. The menu had some excellent choices. I had a very difficult time deciding. I settled on the Friday Fish Fry. I went with the Cod and it turned out to be a great choice. It was the best fish fry I’ve ever had. I’ve been to many fish fries. The fish was crispy and light at the same time. The tartar sauce was perfect. The frites were hand cut and they were excellent. Overall, I was thoroughly impressed with the restaurant. My brother had a seafood melody. I can’t remember the name of the dish. He loved the meal and it was gone in 5 minutes. I will definitely be back for more!
Source: Google
Heidi Carvin
★ 5
Love eating outside. Great food.
Source: Google
Demian Mireles
★ 5
Source: Google
Nate Freesemann
★ 5
I have never had a bad meal here. Get the "everyday fried chicken" its super delicious. The only downside I see about this place is the limited indoor seating, which can make waits longer.
Source: Google
Amy Akright
★ 3
Source: Google
Greg
★ 5
Great food, great service, definitely will return
Source: Google
Andrea Perce
★ 5
My husband and I went for the first time because we kept forgetting to go there. We can’t wait to go back!! The drink selection is great! Husband had the pub burger. His only recommendation for that was there could’ve been more sauce. I had the Cajun pasta dish. (I can’t remember the name of it but it started with a T) Had blackened chicken and shrimp! That sauce was amazing! Husband said it’s some of the best pasta he’s ever had! Glad I was able to bring some home!! Great portion size! Service was great as they were super busy. We ate at the bar (as we tend to do anyways) and shout out to Nate! Can’t wait to go back!
Source: Google
Ryan Wykle
★ 5
Source: Google
Antonio Martinez
★ 5
Cheese curds and cuban sandwich was delicious! Good selection of whiskey. Ate outside on the deck which had a beautiful view of the lake.
Source: Google
Lori Brattset
★ 5
One of my favorite places...great atmosphere and food
Source: Google
Ted Block
★ 5
Source: Google
Pam Kaufman
★ 5
Great service, food, and drinks! Dessert was delicious will defiantly be coming back! Only an hour and 15 from Rockford IL and worth the drive!
Source: Google
Carmelo Ticali
★ 5
Source: Google
Brian Sullivan
★ 5
I've been here numerous times and my most recent visit didn't disappoint! They have a great menu with lots of different options, but I tried the new Birria melt and it was the bomb! I've never had a bad experience here and I highly recommend it...it's a hidden gem in Madison!
Source: Google
Kel Brooks
★ 5
Cute, tasty, period.
Source: Google
Sue Schneider
★ 5
Source: Google
Quincy Sandbank
★ 5
Source: Google
Wendy Schneider
★ 5
Source: Google
Alexis Frerks
★ 5
Very good food and very sweet waiter!! Thank you Griffin R for serving with a smile & being awesome!!
Source: Google
Denise Buckley
★ 4
We went for lunch on a Thursday, and the place was packed! We ate inside, but there is a nice outdoor seating area. Indoor decor was too. The food was tasty and fresh. Serving sizes were small, and I left not quite satisfied.
Source: Google
Brett Rayer
★ 5
Source: Google
Leah King
★ 5
Source: Google
Carmelo Ticali
★ 5
Source: Google
Dave Jones
★ 5
Source: Google
Matthew Rydzak
★ 5
Great food, very nice bartenders. There aren't a ton of taps, but there are excellent choices for all tastes.
Source: Google
Daniel Anderzon
★ 5
Good place to have a beer 🍺
Source: Google
Kaylee Hennes
★ 5
Source: Google
Kari Clemens
★ 1
A bit miffed at a bit rudely being told they had a 90 minute limit and that we needed to leave. We had been ordering drinks and apps continuously in the afternoon before they had gotten busy, and were about to order a early dinner when we were told our time was up. The table next to us had eaten dinner and was eating and drinking, continuously spending money and was also abruptly given the same message, told to finish their drinks and get out. First and likely last visit to this place for me. Unfortunate as the drinks and apps were decent and I wanted to like this place, but that ending definitely ruined our visit.
Source: Google
Steve Hanks
★ 1
Wouldn't recommend! Very rude staff!!! Got so upset that after spending over $200, we left before dinner and went down the street to Buck & Honey's for dinner. Won't be back -- and Off Broadway doesn't care as long as there is another customer to take my place. Won't be back!!
Source: Google
Walt Collier
★ 4
Source: Google
Abrey McIntosh
★ 3
Source: Google
Walt Collier
★ 4
Source: Google
Bradley Jensen
★ 5
Source: Google
Joshua K
★ 5
Great fish fry!
Source: Google
Josh Schuetz
★ 5
While they may be "Off Broadway," they are certainly ON point with the excellent service, amazing food, and inviting atmosphere. I was given a gift card, and that was a smart move! I will definitely be back. Thanks you!
Source: Google
Jessica Gomez Scott
★ 5
Everything we ordered was delicious. My mother-in-law and I agreed that this was the best mushroom risotto we have ever tasted. The portions are very generous, and there are lots of options for all dietary preferences. We wish it had been warmer so we could sit in the outdoor seating area-- it was so unique and pretty. We will definitely go back to this one the next time we are in town!
Source: Google
Tina Savoy
★ 5
Source: Google
Lindsy Anderson
★ 3
Source: Google
Kathy Murphy
★ 5
Source: Google
Scott M.
★ 5
Excellent steak and friendly service
Source: Google
Preston Smith
★ 5
Source: Google
Blair Elizabeth
★ 3
Source: Google
Sue Mcintosh
★ 5
We had Deanna as our waitress and our bartender. She kept everything moving swiftly and made sure our drinks were full. Not sure how this place would run without her wearing so many hats! Thank you Deanna!!
Source: Google
Darren Thiel
★ 4
Great food, don't let the good drinks distract you, nice neighborhood bar, very nice service as well.
Source: Google
Ben Johnson
★ 5
Food was excellent and atmosphere was great. Lots of options and great cocktails. Vegan friendly with multiple options.
Source: Google
James Knaack
★ 5
Always a great place for diner and drinks when in the Madison area.
Source: Google
Daniel Rogers III
★ 4
OBD was great. They have some great beers on tap. I had the broken bat, and it was perfect. I had the Just chicken, and it was flavorful, moist with crispy skin, and that buttermilk sauce was perfect with it. The fries were good, I would suggest they make a little seasoning on the fries.
Source: Google
Timikca R Widener
★ 2
I wasn't sure if I wanted to review this place but it hasn't sat right since. We can on 4-4-25 at 5pm. It was busy and we wanted ot wait so we went to the bar. A customer was before us. When they were done I was standing up and the bartender went right over me and I'm a tall lady so it not hard to see me so I said excuse me and he said I'm helping someone! Even one lady said that was rude!!!! I said right. I'm of mixed race and not to many of in there so. NOT COOL.
Source: Google
Liz B
★ 5
Source: Google
Bonnie Lueckenotto
★ 5
Source: Google
Aaron F
★ 4
Source: Google
Margi Foley
★ 5
Source: Google
Jennifer Denson
★ 5
We all had a really, really great time ! ❤️
Source: Google
Rachael Buss
★ 5
Fast, friendly service with excellent food! Highly recommend.
Source: Google
Daniel Smith
★ 5
Source: Google
Mary Lu Anderson
★ 5
Somewhat noisy
Source: Google
Beata Nichols
★ 5
Source: Google
Maria Vasys
★ 5
Great bar food. Very popular - make reservations!
Source: Google
Benjamin Smith
★ 5
This is one of my favorite places in Monona. The food is outstanding and always consistent. Great beer selection, cocktails and cocktails.
Source: Google
TimFrank Ryan
★ 5
The food is always so good at Off Broadway. Great service also.
Source: Google
Lesley Palmer
★ 5
Great Beer and good food in a convivial atmosphere. It was lovely that they did 5oz glasses so you could make your own beer flight. The beers were served perfectly
Source: Google
Kathleen Nelson
★ 5
Excellent food and service, noisy on Friday and busy.
Source: Google
Jared Toothed
★ 5
Love this place!
Source: Google
Julia
★ 5
Source: Google
Andrew Carver
★ 4
We always find the apps and drinks to be better consistent quality than the main dishes. It's unfortunate to be charged not only a credit card fee but a $2 takeout fee and not be told that over the phone. Nominal all things consider but still crummy.
Source: Google
Doug Grabarczyk
★ 4
Source: Google
Tracy Sundell
★ 5
Everyone was very nice. Food was good! Wasn't loud. We could carry on a conversation!
Source: Google
Ashley Nethery
★ 4
Source: Google
Gary So
★ 5
Source: Google
Robert Stonestreet
★ 5
Source: Google
Thomas Visintainer
★ 5
Awesome food, fast service, and awesome atmosphere. Definitely a must if you want a great burger.
Source: Google
Bill Loulousis
★ 5
Source: Google
David Heberling
★ 5
Source: Google
Debbie Fields
★ 5
Source: Google
Alec Brown
★ 5
Best chicken ever!!!
Source: Google
Danielle Baudhuin
★ 4
Came here for dinner with friends. Our waitress was very nice and comped some drinks that some of our group did not end up enjoying. She also was very knowledgeable on the menu. Food was fine; burger was smaller than expected and average flavor wise, but it was fine. Dessert was a red velvet Oreo masterpiece and that saved the whole dinner.
Source: Google
Lindsey Hayes
★ 5
I enjoyed the NY strip, grilled shrimp, asparagus and garlic mashed potatoes. Amazing! We also had cheese curds and chili for apps. Wonderful date night!
Source: Google
Jeff Wagner
★ 5
I've always had a great experience here.
Source: Google
Kai Thompson
★ 5
Source: Google
Dave G
★ 5
This is a really nice place!
Source: Google
Forrest Stevens
★ 5
It's a nice place. It'd go back for sure
Source: Google
fatty1569
★ 5
Source: Google
Ken Vander Heiden
★ 4
Great atmosphere for a local establishment. A good but not great craft beer list the pork belly poke bowl was very salty and a very large and tasty cheese cake. Waitresses was very friendly and informative.
Source: Google
Abby Landgraf
★ 5
Source: Google
Sandra lee
★ 4
Place was very busy . Our sever Margie was the BEST . Very friendly
Source: Google
Wendy Faith
★ 5
Source: Google
Beaner CPA
★ 5
Excellent food! We've been there several times and the food and service are excellent every time.
Source: Google
Ted Christman
★ 5
Great place, wonderful decor. The history is well displayed. Good food!
Source: Google
Jeff Monson
★ 5
Source: Google
Anne Niendorf
★ 5
My first time there was for fish fry Friday and had the perch. It was some of the best fish I've ever had. I appreciate how many different fish options there are (bluegill, walleye, cod and perch). Excellent place for a traditional Wisconsin fish fry Friday experience.
Source: Google
Brian Robinson
★ 5
First time eating there and was probably the best fish fry I've had. Went with father-in-law and we had the cod and bluegill. Definitely coming back not just for fish, but to also try the rest of their menu. Great service and even though it was busy, didn't take long to get our food.
Source: Google
Elizabeth Sauer
★ 5
Consistently good food and service. Seriously love this place. If you need a warm, friendly, fun place to meet up with friends or a date night location, go HERE!!!!
Source: Google
Linda Caradori
★ 5
They don’t serve brunch anymore.
They open at 11 for lunch.
Source: Google
Keri Ferguson
★ 4
Place is cute. Staff are nice.
Fish fry:
Fried cod - mom said "pretty good."
Blackened walleye - 3.5 stars. Moist, but smidge bland. Needed more blackening. Good price, only a few bones, decent size.
Boiled cod - moist but bland, give us extra butter sauce in a cup! 3.5 stars.
Bread - really good, but cold?
Coleslaw - has an apple component, unique.
Parking lot - small, but street parking close
Beers - great selection
Source: Google
Philip Costley
★ 2
Stick to the burgers. Trust me. Ordered grilled salmon one time. Cooked well but no seasoning. Mashed potatoes was cold, green beans were tough. Stick to the bar food there. Wasn't worth the menu price imo. The meal and two drinks were $50.
Source: Google
Carl Hampton
★ 5
Source: Google
Sarah Bish
★ 5
While in Madison for an event we stumbled upon this amazing little eatery! The atmosphere is very warm and inviting, the service was top notch and the food was absolutely amazing! Locally raised grass fed beef was a big deal for us, so seeing that on the menu reassured me that we had made a good choice stopping to eat here. The waitress made an appetizer suggestion of the goat cheese, when she said she doesn't usually like goat cheese, but loves this, that caught my attention, because I don't like it either, so of course we had to order it. She was sooo right, it was absolutely delightful, I will order this every time I come! This visit I had their version of the patty melt and a salad and it was all very good. That day they had a chocolate peppermint cheesecake on the menu, and since cheesecake is my weakness, I of course had to try that too. It was very good and obviously homemade. It had layers of chocolate cake between the peppermint cheesecake layers and it was truly divine. Definitely enough for 2 people to share! Later that evening we actually ended up going back for dinner with some friends and this time I tried the battered chicken thighs which are butterflied and boneless. They were the best chicken thighs I've ever had, the breading was perfect and the meat was of good quality. I had the loaded mashed potatoes on the side, and those were very flavorful and well made as well. We live about 2 hours away, but I've told many people about this place and will definitely go back again when we are in the area! I highly recommend Off Broadway Drafthouse ♡
Source: Google
Rebekah Mayhew
★ 5
Here during and extremely busy fundraiser. The staff were stellar and the regulars were very accepting. I loved it. If I lived closer I’d be a regular in a second
Source: Google
Pamela S.
★ 5
Had 1/2 Rack Of ribs. They were good but would of liked a different BBQ sauce.
Source: Google
Penny Hazeltine
★ 5
Source: Google
Mera Rothfelder
★ 3
The waitress and server were lovely and everything looked great. Unfortunately the food was very bland. There was no seasoning on my dish besides a small sprinkling of parsley over the steak. I was very disappointed to see such a nice cut of steak, cooked perfectly medium rare and bite into unseasoned meat.
Source: Google
Thomas Kasl
★ 5
Blackened walleye fish fry 8/10, Buffalo Chicken dip 9/10, Prospector mocktail 10/10, spicy dry rub wings 6/10. Staff was super nice.
Source: Google
Carrie Mess
★ 5
Food was solid. I'd like to come back and try more menu items. Great beer selection. We were there during a game and it was packed so lots of grace given, but our server was pretty forgetful and that was not fun with thirsty kids.
Source: Google
Justin Wall
★ 5
Source: Google
Barry H
★ 2
More of the modern beer menu, heavy on the IPAs and light beers with 0 stouts.
Source: Google
Colin Piaskowski (HTA Colin)
★ 5
Very busy when we went but got a table fairly quickly. Risotto, and BLT were super tasty. Our pork chop was a little well done but was still juicy. Drinks and beers were delicious. We were kinda in a rush and they helped us get it and out quickly.... Even with it being busy
Source: Google
Jessica Christenson
★ 4
The juiciest and most flavorful wings I've ever had! The burger was a little dry but was great dipped in their homemade blue cheese dressing. We will definitely be back.
Source: Google
Darrin Neuendorf
★ 5
Source: Google
Dan C
★ 5
A tourist visiting and loved it. Relaxed, clean, quick and good service with a local and friendly vibe. Even the fries had skin and felt homemade.
Source: Google
Ryan Jacobsmeyer
★ 5
Very unassuming, but well worth a visit! Bartender was super attentive, food was great, and has a great vibe. Highly recommend you check it out
Source: Google
Rex Hovey
★ 5
Source: Google
Sarah S
★ 5
Source: Google