Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Green Bay, 2495 S Oneida St, Green Bay, WI 54304, United States | ★ 4 (1463 Review)

📞 +1 920-884-1112

Last Search

Category

Pizza restaurant Bar Bar & grill Family restaurant Gluten-free restaurant Lunch restaurant Takeout Restaurant New American restaurant Restaurant Traditional American restaurant

Description

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom is where the neighborhood gathers with friends we call guests, our legendary pizza and our curated selection of local and popular crafts + taps.

Photos

 Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
 Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
 Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
 Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
 Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
 Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
 Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
 Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
 Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
 Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
 Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
 Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Leave a Review

Reviews

Jonathan Kichaven

★ 3

Source: Google

jason flaig

★ 4

First time there, nice place. The pizza is good but little pricey . Bathroom floors are very sticky.

Source: Google

Rick Kummers

★ 5

What a great place! Coldest tap beer I’ve ever had!

Source: Google

Kimmy Robinson

★ 5

Top favorite pizza in Green Bay when I lived there moved back home in 2018. Tomorrow I am coming to Green Bay to see one of my old besties and you guest it we are having Old Chicago. My friend and her husband have lived there for over 15 years and I have never tried it so I talked them into it.

Part two we did make it for dinner last night brought lots of leftovers.it was a little on the pricey side. But definitely a delicious hot spot. Our waiter was nice however only checked on us once after served, so my friend and I had no drink remaining the rest of our meal. Other than that definitely still recommended.

Source: Google

Cooltwguy Gaming (TW)

★ 2

Source: Google

Lynn W

★ 5

Source: Google

Gregg Bonti

★ 5

I order from this location every time I'm in Green Bay. At first it was for the Pepperoni Rolls ... And it still is! But now it's also because of the bartender. I wish I could remember his name and I'll add it to this review next time I'm in the area. This guy is the reason Old Chicago Green Bay is still open when all the other locations have closed. Great attitude, great service and just a genuinely nice person.

Source: Google

Chris Stearns

★ 5

Exceptional food and services. With a wide variety of beer and microbrews

Source: Google

leader ship

★ 4

Neat vibe, cold drinks, good food!

Source: Google

Kevin Stanelle

★ 5

Waistaff is always excellent and friendly.

Source: Google

Caitlin T

★ 2

Source: Google

Jorden

★ 2

Slow slow service. Food was not the best for price. Their chips were awful. it might be a good drinking place, but we just went for dinner and I don’t recommend it just for dinner.

Source: Google

marchi L

★ 5

Source: Google

Jess Bartels

★ 4

Source: Google

Angela Drewery Behnke

★ 5

Source: Google

Kathy Zernach

★ 5

Really good food but you get a lot! The spinach and artichoke dip with their own chips was delicious! The chips were light and crispy, never had chips like that but delicious. Made a mistake to order a large pan pizza, way too much food for two people but was very good. Would go back next time in town.

Source: Google

Sydney S

★ 5

Always good service and fun, bright atmosphere. I thought the chop salad was not so chopped this last time. Still decent but not like I like it.

Source: Google

Bill Woods

★ 3

Source: Google

Jim Moeschberger

★ 4

Nice place with a large tap selection

Source: Google

Tom Evertsen

★ 5

Source: Google

Struggle Bunny

★ 1

With an absolute empty dining room they still can’t figure out how to get pizza out on time. Very slow location with very rude management.

Source: Google

Richard Kramer

★ 5

Source: Google

Emelia Miles

★ 5

the food is great and the wait time is pretty average. If you're looking for a good spot to dine with your family this would be it.

Source: Google

Gregg Christopherson

★ 4

Source: Google

Tyler Barclay

★ 5

Great food and best service possible! I love the Chicago 7 pizza, especially with the hand-tossed crust. Such a quality place to go to for either lunch or dinner.

Source: Google

Jowanna Young

★ 4

Source: Google

sage

★ 5

taylor was a very pleasant server & the food was great as always, it was a bit cold inside but still a good experience

Source: Google

380 Amaro

★ 1

Terrible choice for a spot to eat. Just spent $16 on an order of “Tall boneless wings”. I received 8 tiny wings. For $16. And the “Jamaican jerk” seasoning, is nowhere close to a Jamaican jerk. They taste like paprika wings. Terrible. Sicilian rolls also halved in size since I last ordered. Wouldn’t recommend this place, it seems greed is taking over and quality is going out the door. Support local restaurants and bars instead, better quality for a better price.

Source: Google

AMC guy

★ 1

Not even close to a Chicago style deep dish pizza!

Source: Google

kim warden

★ 5

Source: Google

Kennedy DeSilvis

★ 1

$33 for an incredibly small mediocre pizza. Yikes. The “pizza cookie” is also completely laughable. Small, cold, gas station cookie. lol.

Source: Google

Emily Nelson

★ 2

Really disappointed. Spent $33 on a pizza and couldn’t even eat all of it because there were huge bubbles which led to no toppings on several pieces. The insides of these pieces were completely hollow. Bubbles happen but for a $33 pizza and to have at least 25% of it inedible is kinda ridiculous. The fried pickles looked sloppy. Some pickles had a mountain of seasoning and some had none. The chips for our nachos were burnt and so was the kids pizza. Donut bites were chewy almost like they were stale. We ordered a ton of food and spent a good bit of money just to feel like they took all the food that wasn’t good enough for the dine in people.

Source: Google

Kit Nemetz

★ 5

I eat here very often and have noticed that on the weekends I feel like the pizzas are even a little better. They have very consistent toppings and the appearance of the pizzas is even a little better. Great food every time and a fun atmosphere. A must stop!! 🍕

Source: Google

Catherine GOETZ

★ 5

One of my favorite places to eat after shopping at Bay Park Square. Good food,excelent service

Source: Google

Ed Sarrazin

★ 5

Great deep dish pizza

Source: Google

Jan Czaja

★ 5

Source: Google

Shelli Menke

★ 3

Understaffed and slow food service, but the server was very nice under the circumstances. He was the bar tender, food runner, and server all in one.

Source: Google

Dave

★ 2

Stopped in for lunch on Friday afternoon. Was not busy at all and we were seated in what felt like the back corner booth. Right away we were moving the table around just to be able for all of us to sit comfortably, mind you it seemed it was missing some screws as it was also very loose and wobbly.

Our server walked up casually to just tell us he would be back in a few minutes to take our drink order, odd but OK. When he did arrive back it was a bit uncomfortable as he seemed very laid back, care free and not very welcoming.

We ordered pizza, pizza rolls and a chicken sandwich. The pizza related items were ok for pizza, not awesome but not terrible either. The chicken sandwich came out stacked tall like it was a show piece, bun chicken lettuce bun. The chicken was over breaded over cooked and the portion was small. I get that it's the crispy chicken sandwich but it was all breading.

Our concern for the sandwich was passed onto the server who apologized and said its usually a popular sandwich and we thought that was it, another odd interaction but we waited for our tab. Shortly after a woman approached our table asking about the sandwich and what we felt was wrong with it. No idea if it was the cook, a manager or what. In our opinion she then became almost defensive calling out the weight of the portion prior to breading it. It was an uncomfortable situation but she did offer to remove it from the tab which was nice.

Overall our meal was alright, unsure if we would return in the future as there was not much appeal to make us do so.

Source: Google

Christine Czarneski

★ 4

I ordered off of grubhub about a month ago and my order was incorrect. I ordered the veggie pizza add chicken and only got chicken. I called and the Manager told me they were going to send me a voucher. Never got it. Recently added, Thank you for sending the vouchers. I really do like your pizza and etc.

Source: Google

Barbara Landowski

★ 5

Surprisingly good pizza.

Source: Google

Josh Heggs

★ 5

Source: Google

Karl Riedner

★ 5

Enjoy coming here, food is excellent, service on par!

Source: Google

Trisha Hatter

★ 4

Source: Google

Chris Dutch

★ 4

Updated this review because the service has drastically improved in the past couple years.

Source: Google

Michael Helzer

★ 5

Good was amazing, service was good, atmosphere was appropriate

Source: Google

Bryan J Martin

★ 2

Expensive and I don't know why because it's just not very good.

Source: Google

Ann Christopherson

★ 3

Source: Google

chris costanza

★ 1

Pizza was absolutely terrible. Undercooked. Soggy.

Source: Google

Tami Bethel

★ 5

We each had the 4 slice personal pizza. We tried the beer, hand tossed crust. We loved it.

I had chicken, skin bursted tomatoes, garlic, topped with fresh spinach with a delicious lemon dressing on top of the pizza. Excellent.

My husband had the meatball, Italian sausage. His pizza was also delicious.

Took only 10 minutes to get it.

Source: Google

Jeff Main

★ 5

Stopped in just to kill time and decided to try the pizza and have a beer. This Double Deckeroni pizza was the best I have had in quite a long time. I sure wish there was one here in Appleton.

Source: Google

Cody White LDPF

★ 5

Amazing spot. My company paced quite the order here and the staff was incredibly kind, patient, and efficient with the order. The best part is the food was DELICIOUS! Highly recommend, and will absolutely be back

Source: Google

Greg

★ 5

Great food, great service, definitely will return

Source: Google

jon K

★ 5

Really good food and really nice staff would definitely recommend

Source: Google

James Alan

★ 5

My wife and I stopped in at this establishment last week. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza to share. The food was excellent, tasty, and made to perfection! The server did a good job of cleaning up the tables. Jennifer, the Manager stopped at our table. Jennifer was super friendly, smiling, dressed nicely, attentive to our needs, and not bad on the eyes... Jennifer was very professional and made us feel like family. We will return to this establishment again.

Source: Google

Twisted River

★ 3

Source: Google

Nickole Faustina-Anne AKA Cupcake

★ 5

This was our first time here and definitely will not be our last! Our waiter Hunter recommended the queso dip for our appetizer and it was amazing! Hunter was the best waiter we ever had... He catered to our every need and beyond. Come visit this wonderful place and say hi to Hunter 🙂

Source: Google

FA DR KING IAN March 3-1 Andrew19 Smith72

★ 5

Source: Google

Gus Barlament

★ 5

Source: Google

Aerwyn Davis

★ 5

Source: Google

Marv Cischke

★ 4

Source: Google

Atticus

★ 1

Waiters were slow we waited 20 min and server did not come

Source: Google

Sunnie Matta

★ 5

Our Server Alexanndera was absolutely amazing. Her tables were full but she was on time with everything. The manager even came to our table and spoke a few kind words and tipped us as the customers! Everything we ate was delicious!!!

Source: Google

S R

★ 4

buffalo chicken rolls keep me coming back, seems understaffed sometimes though

Source: Google

June Ziebarth

★ 5

We love this restaurant! The pizzas are amazing! The staff is courteous and attentive. And the best thing,they have DARK BEER available! Best selection of beers to choose from. Highly recommend!!

Source: Google

Matt Towns

★ 5

Mine and my wife's first time to any Old Chicago location.
We loved the atmosphere and food. She had a cider on tap, we had the pepperoni rolls and the Farmer's Daughter pizza. All excellent!

Source: Google

Luke Cahak

★ 5

Source: Google

kathy senn

★ 3

Ordered a chopped salad. Please check out Portillos chopped salad. Your salad was just a tossed salad that the lettuce was still too large and the other ingredients were minimal. Service was good.

Source: Google

Jose Olmeda

★ 4

Everything was very good the waitress was awesome

Source: Google

sue lebich

★ 5

Went to have a Cpl beers & tried the chicken pizza with the hot honey sauce & was amazing 🤩👏 great choice

Source: Google

Katie Nunya

★ 1

This place is trash..told me they were closed and they werent. Dont ever go here.

Source: Google

Lisa Brownell

★ 3

Was ok, nothing special. We had pasta dishes, maybe their pizza is what makes them good, I'm not sure

Source: Google

Paul Bulko

★ 5

My family and I finally went to this place to eat and everything was perfect. It was honestly the best experience I've had out to eat in a while. We always drove past there and just never went, but I'm glad we finally did. For everything we got for five people including drinks and two appetizers to be under $100 was great. We were even given a free dessert.

Source: Google

Sapphire Zarling

★ 5

Source: Google

Kimberly Anderson

★ 5

Our food was delicious!
Our waitress was extremely nice and knowledgeable for menu items!
All around nice experience!

Source: Google

Mike Bostedt

★ 1

Waited over 20mins to be seated while there were close to 20 tables open. Once seated no one came around for another 20mins. So we left.

Source: Google

Lydia Kelnhofer

★ 2

Wait staff was incredibly rude, and they were out of several items on the menu. Food we had wasn't anything amazing. Was disappointed both times I've been here.

Source: Google

Sharon Gust

★ 1

Ordered the chicken caprese sandwich. First of all, it is a simple sandwich, the restaurant was not busy at all, tons of open tables, it took 25 minutes from the time we ordered until it came.
When the sandwich arrived, I already saw the withered arugulas hanging out from the sandwich and the worst is when I opened the sandwich, the arugula are rotted!

The manager was emphasizing they are not rotted, it is from the balsamic vinegar and they are grilled! Come On! They are so obvious, are rotted. The vinegar will only coat on the surface of the leaves, will not make the leaves turn BLACK. The manager also stated the grilled make the arugula black. The truth is: the arugula go on top of grilled chicken, the whole sandwich include the arugula does not get grilled!

Don’t lie through your teeth, JUST ADMITTED IT’S ROTTED, Mr. Manager!

Very disappointed, will never go back!

Source: Google

Georgia Zoglman

★ 5

Source: Google

Abby Kaczynski

★ 5

The staff here is very friendly. The bartender was very knowledgeable about beer, cocktails, and sports. Very enjoyable experience; I will definitely come again.

Source: Google

Rosie Fuller

★ 1

If you want food like this go there first chicken sandwich was more burnt then this they will never get my hard earned money again

Source: Google

Molly Love

★ 3

The food was good, we ordered a pizza so pretty hard to mess that up lol. But while we were there, there was a BABY in a ‘bouncer’ alone ON the table. No idea whose it was because we didn’t see anyone approach the poor baby!! So nerve wrecking we had to leave asap!

Source: Google

Ilya

★ 5

Source: Google

Denise Wartgow

★ 5

Source: Google

Terri “CocoanNCream” W

★ 1

Out of small deep dish crust at 140 on a Sunday afternoon.
Poor preparation.
Could’ve cut down a large crust for a small.
Instead I sat while my family ate.
Poor service in that regard.

Our server herself however was apologetic and kind.

Source: Google

Daniel Rauens

★ 3

Pizza is frequently undercooked but the service is friendly.

Source: Google

Jon Matthies

★ 5

Source: Google

Local Delivery

★ 1

Unprofessional.

Source: Google

Dan Burnett

★ 4

Dined here on a Saturday at 7 PM and it wasn’t too busy. I was seated right away and my Cole, the server, checked in right away. I was able to put in my order within 10 minutes, and the wings and pizza were table side in about 15 minutes.

Cole was great and checked in often without being intrusive, was friendly, and helpful.

The Memphis style wings were cooked well, and decent. The Chicago 7 pizza with hand tossed crust was pretty good flavor wise; perhaps heavy on the cheese for my preference. The crust was great. It is a softer-chewy crust as described which can make it harder to handle, but it’s worth it.

They have a decent beer list with a lot of national brands. People looking for craft beer may have a few options in each style.

Overall pretty decent, and would go back.

Source: Google

Multileege Adendum (Multai)

★ 3

Food was okay. Service girl wasn't very attentive but I think she was just out of training? It's a nice place. Wouldn't go out of my way to eat there, but I'd definitely go back.

Source: Google

Paul Pinkoski

★ 5

Amazing tap beer selection! Great pizza, love the andoule sausage on the meat pizza. Deep dish and Tavern style pizza!

Source: Google

NaNa Schiefelbein

★ 1

For starters the food was terrible my gf and my cousins food was cold the meatballs weren’t even cooked all the way. SECOND the service was absolutely terrible we were sitting for 20 minutes before the server even came by us she seen us walk in we literally made eye contact and she didn’t even say anything she gave us our menus and just lefted. Let me just put this out there, they weren’t even busy when we got there. I’ll give it to them the place was pretty clean but that was literally only the good thing about that place…the manger also wasn’t the greatest to talk to he was just making excuses and acting like he didn’t even care.

Source: Google

Thomas Czekala

★ 5

Source: Google

Elliot Wiegerling

★ 2

Came in for lunch and really didn’t have the best experience. Restaurant was not busy and seemed to have plenty of servers yet still waited over an hour for food. Order the pretzels with cheese and the beer cheese was cold and didn’t taste the best. After waiting for 45 minutes I got told that they didn’t have the pizza crust I ordered and then had to order a different kind of pizza and when it finally came it was pretty sub-par. Honestly would not come back.

Source: Google

Alayna

★ 5

The food was delicious and the service was amazing , it was me and my family’s first time ever and we will definitely be back

Source: Google

Lyle

★ 5

First timer and will be back. Thank you. Have been back numerous times.

Source: Google

Alberto Bobadilla

★ 5

Source: Google

BRETT KRIPLEAN

★ 5

Source: Google

Trisha Kohel

★ 2

Source: Google

Dominick Horvath

★ 5

Source: Google

Tim Benz

★ 1

Source: Google

Dominic Bilotti

★ 3

The food was okay, the service was not that great. Very slow, only one round of refills while we were there for an hour and a half. The restaurant wasn't even that busy, maybe four other tables while we were there. Probably won't be coming back.

Source: Google

Brad Fischer

★ 4

Source: Google

Amanda Kruse

★ 3

Source: Google

trever spence

★ 5

Great pizza great price awesome service from day time bartender.

Source: Google

Cassandra georgel

★ 3

Source: Google

Stephanie Borgstrand

★ 2

Staff great, food good but not clean in bar area or bathroom fyi.

Source: Google

Ronald Stouten

★ 5

Everything was good

Source: Google

Becky Bell

★ 5

We are here from Flordia visiting friends. This is the first place my husband wanted to go as soon as we landed ! Delicious food, great drinks and atmosphere. Now I see why he’s always asking why isn’t there one near us. So the question is when will y’all build one in Melbourne Florida !!!!!!!!

Source: Google

Adam Francois

★ 2

Old Chicago used to have the best fried pickles in town, just ate there last night and sadly now they have the exact same fried pickles as everyone in town. I really can't express how disappointed I am about that. I specifically come here for their fried pickles and now that they've cheaped out and switched to the same crappy cheap ones everyone has, I have no reason to come back anymore. I'm sure it probably has something to do with being cheaper and blah blah blah well I hope saving money on your fried pickles is worth losing customers.

Source: Google

DJ Abracadabra A.K.A Abby

★ 4

Source: Google

Sandy Gutting

★ 5

Great pizza 🍕

Source: Google

Torland Cornelius-Adkins

★ 2

The pizza was just okay grade C-. The garden side salad A. The strawberry drink A. I will not be back.

Source: Google

Adam Simpson

★ 4

Slow service then ok once it arrived.. Probably understaffed. Food was ok.

Source: Google

Chris Salter

★ 3

I really enjoy the chicago style pizza here. I travel to packer games 4 to 5 times a year, and always try to stop in here for lunch. I can say that the service is not good. Everytime I go in there, I feel it's understaffed. The food is why I come back, just plan 2 hours instead of a normal hour to eat.

Source: Google

Sean Wilkinson

★ 5

Source: Google

Sherrie Zeni

★ 5

Source: Google

B T

★ 5

Local favorite... 😀

Source: Google

Vickie Boehnlein

★ 1

Haven't even been seated, restaurant is more than half empty an they would seat us or let us sit in the bar area because "the kitchen is backed up". There are many high top tables in the bar open but they won't let us sit there to get a drink while we wait. I have never experienced anything this ridiculous.

Source: Google

Jaime V.

★ 1

They sat us and never came to wait on us. People that came in after us were waited immediately. Not one waitress acknowledged us so we got up and left.

Source: Google

Mya Glez

★ 4

First time eating at this place. We thought the place was nice, good food, the restaurant was clean and good service. Reasonable prices.

Source: Google

Aubrey Heape

★ 5

We always stop when in Green Bay.

Source: Google

Niurka De jesus

★ 5

Source: Google

Anika Howard

★ 4

Source: Google

Shon Velasquez

★ 4

Overall had a pleasant time returning to the establishment. Just two constructive critiques. For your lemon pepper hot honey you need to add more lemon pepper either before or after you prepare the wings. When I got mine they tasted simply like a sweet buffalo sauce couldn’t even tell if they had any to begin with. (Love the ranch btw tho keep that!!). Secondly I ordered a 4 slice deep dish pizza but I received more crust than anything which was kinda disappointing but it’s all good.

Source: Google

Amber Wiese

★ 4

Source: Google

Mark Johnson

★ 4

Food was good. Only wondering if 7 frys is the standard for ordering the Sausage Sandwich? Yes 7 fresh. I will not order that again. Love the pizza.

Source: Google

Jacqueline Robinson

★ 5

Source: Google

Carlos Lara

★ 4

Source: Google

Dale Danko

★ 5

Source: Google

Trine Sluth Jønsen

★ 4

They didn’t have the pizza or beer we wanted, so we ordered something else. The pizza we got was good. The service was all good. We would return sometime 👌

Source: Google

Ann Ess

★ 5

The chicken bacon ranch pizza was life changing. Seriously so good. The cheese and pepperoni were good too!

Source: Google

Keith Dearborn

★ 5

Source: Google

Jamie McCorkle

★ 5

Always love the food at OC! Amazing and definitely filling! Accommodating with kids and family friendly!

Source: Google

Jonny Richard

★ 5

Recently had lunch with a colleague. The service was fast & friendly, and the pizza was delicious! I needed to come back to the restaurant later that evening because I forgot a few things, and the host/manager (Dan) was exceptionally helpful. I’ll definitely come back!

Source: Google

Chad Anderson

★ 5

Had a hankering for pizza and beer. We ordered 3 pizza which were great. The pan style was the best. Reminded us of the pan pizza from our childhood. When it tasted great. Had the thin also. Was surprised by the hot sauce on the peperoni but it made it very interesting. Bartender was great and they had a great selection of tap beer to choose from.

Source: Google

Brooke Barfield

★ 5

Wonderful service! Tasty pizza.

Source: Google

D Gehling

★ 4

Source: Google

Mostaph Ali

★ 1

Source: Google

Stephanie Fox

★ 3

The service was, what i'd describe as, awkward. The food was relatively tasty, but made incorrectly and later messed with my stomach.
Not a place i'd visit again.

Source: Google

Ami Cleary

★ 3

Source: Google

Mer Little

★ 1

Wait time over an hr and kids spaghetti and meat balls came frozen. When we complained and said that we were just going to leave. The waitress yelled back good don’t come back. How rude. Disrespectful with our kids in aww wondering why and what had happened. So disappointed.

Source: Google

Amy Austin

★ 3

To get service was slow. But once we had service it was good. .the food was okay. The best part I would say is the cheese dip sauce to the pretzel bead sticks.
The pizza wasn't the best. But still came out on a nice timely manner.
Bartender didn't know how to make cocktails, very well.

Source: Google

Bryndahl Weston

★ 4

Good food and a friendly server. The happy hour menu is the best bang for your buck.

Source: Google

Ramari Bess

★ 3

Source: Google

Julie Jarmus

★ 5

I’ve been coming here for years and am surprised by some of the negative reviews. We have always been well cared for by the people here. We stopped by today and our server was wonderful, when I ordered my pizza she explained they had a lunch special that was cheaper, which is much appreciated. Everyone at my table was happy! The Italian nachos were our favorite!

Source: Google

Brenda Beckmann

★ 5

Source: Google

Danny Redden

★ 5

Pizza is really good. Great appetizers as well. Really like thier pizza sauce.

Source: Google

Conner Redden

★ 5

Brilliant Pizza! Definitely reaches my top 10 of places to eat. Quick, right, and delicious. If I'm ever back, I will be eating here again!

Source: Google

Dean Vaillancourt

★ 3

Source: Google

Jason St. Peter

★ 5

Its been many years since I been there. We got pizza with thin crust which just stole the show. It felt like that pan pizza fry crust with with out as much dough.

Source: Google

Dalton Lee

★ 2

I wasn't impressed with the food. But the service was good. The bathroom was atrocious.

Source: Google

HollynBrad Lehman

★ 5

Source: Google

Pamela Blahnik

★ 5

Source: Google

Tony Litt

★ 4

Mondays not busy. Good za.

Source: Google

Steven Siudzinski

★ 5

Great food at a fair price.

Source: Google

Tabby N

★ 1

I asked a very clear question. Is the pizza 9.99 without any toppings or do you get one topping. I didn't think cheese that is normally comes one a pizza would count as a topping. Also I was ignore my whole meal because I was one person. Guess my money isn't any good compared to a bigger party

Source: Google

Dominic Morris

★ 4

Source: Google

Natalija York

★ 5

Source: Google

Mike Ravet

★ 5

Very nice place

Source: Google

Sara Bella

★ 5

Source: Google

Oh Daddy

★ 4

Source: Google

Jeffrey Italiano

★ 4

Atmosphere was pleasant, like an upscale pub, but it isn't upscale. The service was decent enough, but the food was less then good. My wife ordered a cheese steak that was inedible. My salad was very disappointing.

Source: Google

David Gallagher

★ 5

Past two experiences here have been great! Always get the calzone and am not disappointed! This past time we sat at a booth in the bar area and the service was excellent there.

Source: Google

Erik Woll

★ 5

Exactly what you've come to know and love about old chicago! Great beer selection, awesome bartenders and servers and a tvs with every sport imaginable on.

Source: Google

Matthew Lenzen

★ 5

Source: Google

Jane Thompson

★ 3

Source: Google

Mary Collar

★ 1

Don't even know where to start with this review because the service and food was beyond awful. Met my family who came from out of town there for lunch. My brother in law ordered the Italian meatball sub (it was on the menu) My sister ordered the nachos (also on the menu) I ordered some Mac n cheese dish. Food came and my food was cold and noodles were over cooked and tasteless. When my sister asked for guacamole and sour creme for the nachos we were told they do not have either of those items anymore just salsa. They then told my brother in law they no longer have his Italian meatball sub but just Italian beef sub. He tried to eat it but it was awful. Waitress asked if he liked it and he said no he did not. Her response was oh that's too bad took his plate and walked away. Save the trip and the money and do not eat at this establishment. I normally do not even bother to take the time to write a review but this was so bad I just had to.

Source: Google

Jeffrey Schaufel

★ 5

Over 2 years ago I gave this place only 1 star (see my review) Now everytime I am in GB I stop by and it is awesome. I think they were just having a bad day! Best pizza in Green Bay!

Source: Google

Griselle Wolski

★ 1

This was the worst pizza I had ever had I'm from Chicago.This was an insult 😤 to the people of Chicago. I only took a bit and threw the rest of a large pizza in the garbage. Horrible I will never!!

Source: Google

Kirk Thompson

★ 5

The wings were huge and cooked to perfection.

Source: Google

Pattie Michalek

★ 5

Source: Google

Fadrian Andrew Smith

★ 5

Source: Google

Joshua Lingg

★ 5

The food or the beer, I cannot tell which one is better 😜.

Source: Google

anghelo hernandez

★ 5

Very nice ! Cool beer and excellent pizza !!

Source: Google

Riley Romenesko

★ 5

Source: Google

Steven Frey

★ 5

Source: Google

jonah morales

★ 5

Great spot to watch the games and got some good food at a decent price. Manager even dropped us off some extra appetizers on the house. He was nice guy and made us feel welcome. Would recommend.

Source: Google

Jessica Loch

★ 1

honestly. it was a wreck. i went today around 7pm and left at nearly 7:30. i got half of my order then had to wait still. i was worried about my job for doordash. i got there and saw another girl waiting for her order with no service. so i checked the receipts and asked her the name of order and handed her a bag just sitting at the front. it was pretty ridiculous to say the least. nobody was helpful AT ALL other than a redhead girl working her a$$ off to get everything done and etc. i felt horrible for her. it was not busy. i had multiple servers walked right past me and then going on their phones… i was super disappointed. this place has gone so down hill. back in highschool i used to love this place, but in the past 7 years it’s gone very down hill. i felt ignored. and disrespected. a costumer even ASKED if i could get attended to before them. if you cannot handle doordash/uber eats don’t put your place up on there. bad service. bad and rude employees. one bigger guy behind the bar on his phone. brunette with glasses looked at me multiple times then ignored me, one guy checked a receipt then played with the marker? and then finally my savior red head came and at least helped me. that place should hire more people like her. she’s a keeper. but like i said very disappointed. been going for years back then and now never again, especially never going to accept another dash order for there.never a good thing to hear “goodluck in there” from multiple delivery people back and forth. the people i delivered to even apologized because they know it’s an insane experience there with ever delivery driver “dont worry it’s usually always pretty late”

Source: Google

BAM 22

★ 5

Source: Google

Ben Foster

★ 5

This Old Chicago is awesome! They have great beers and great eats! Most of all, they have outstanding service, the staff is always happy and friendly. I stop here every time I’m in Green Bay.

Source: Google

Kirby Johnson

★ 5

I'm trying to go gluten free and their cauliflower crust pizza was excellent. Great service too

Source: Google

Jeff Cevaal

★ 5

Source: Google

dan920

★ 2

Food always good for a late night place. Bartender was pretty bad tho lol wasn’t busy at all but it was hard to get his attention. Gave us our check without saying thank you or good bye (weird) and regret leaving dude a pretty good tip. Ugh we’ll be back but probably get a table if homie behind the bar.

Source: Google

David Jones

★ 5

Some of the best pizza I've ever had. Great selection of tap brews. Bartender was awesome! Wish I could remember his name...

Source: Google

Ryan

★ 1

We tried to eat here on 2/22/24. Sat ourselves at a high top in the bar area around 1:30pm since there was no hostess. There were approximately 6-8 people eating in the bar area. The bartender/server didn’t acknowledge us for over 10 minutes. She made eye contact with us multiple times but did not even say “I’ll be right with you.” She was mingling with a few people at the bar and made sure to collect her tips from the 2 booths she had served. No drinks, menus, or even hello. We walked out. Worst service (or lack thereof) we’ve had at any place in a very long time. Won’t be back.

Source: Google

Beth Wickert

★ 2

Pizza was over cooked. Not enough sauce. It was a Chicago style pan pizza.

Source: Google

Kendra Suring

★ 1

We were there (2/17) and our waitress was extremely rude! She was very snarky and when one person wasn’t sure what they wanted she very rudely said “well it sounds like we’re not ready to order so I will come back later” even though she already started taking our order. Needless to say we will not be going back because of her. The food was good but the service was terrible.

Source: Google

Greg

★ 2

Maybe an off night. But service was poor with maybe 16 people in the restaurant and most at one table. Food was missed on the ticket (which they did catch and let us know), all of the calzones ordered at the table were raw and doughy. Pastas were dry (it’s ok to use sauce). The quality has seemed to do a deep dive here. If you want a $27 large Little Caesar’s pizza - be my guest, but I doubt I will return.

Source: Google

Giwk

★ 2

Not only was I served the wrong food but the service was quite slow for it being dead. My bacon tasted more burnt than “peppered”. The bun was hard and stale. I counted out 14 fries on my side which is crazy. Only reason I’m giving a 2 star is being the pizza was pretty good.

Source: Google

Grace

★ 2

Cookie was super super oily, and ice cream had some weird stuff in it.

Source: Google

Jimmy Willing

★ 3

Source: Google

Shawn Robak

★ 4

Source: Google

Beach Please No Snow

★ 3

Party of 2, date night, no reservations, plenty of seating arrived approximately 6pm. Hostess kind and quick to help, we choose a table in bar area. Plenty of TVs with many different sports. Large menu, food around us looked great. But then.....our server swung by to say be with you soon.....a long time after she returned...we ordered drinks and a water....bartender quickly made our drinks and I watched the drinks sit at the bar with our server nowhere in sight....over 15 minutes the drinks sat..upon arrival server stated sorry I'm really busy...drinks were watered down...more than 1/2 the tables were empty....oh and no water yet...that sat at the bar over 30 minutes 😳. Food arrived with a very pleasant runner..2 different pizzas...tasty but warm...not hot...and still no water....server swung by to say hows your food oh do you need another drink...no I would like my water....oh yes sorry I'm really busy....she brought my BF another drink and forgot the water again. Maybe just an off night but to many other choices to return here anytime soon. Food mediocre. Service horrible.

Source: Google

Adam McWey

★ 2

Took our family of 5 there Jan 13th 2024. Server didn't write down the orders and I didn't get served food until we were ready to go. Two orders were colder than room temp and our apology from the manager had as much effort as the kitchen put into microwaving the kid's meals. They credited about 20% of our bill, we will never go back. It's not worth paying even $35 to leave with three out of the five in our party still hungry.

Source: Google

Palin Spangle

★ 5

Stopped here because I wanted to sit down and have great pizza, and I got it. The server was a kind lady as well.

Source: Google

Robert Aho

★ 3

Source: Google

Laurie Strano

★ 4

Last minute stop after thr big game. It took a bit for our server to greet us at our table. She was nice but wasn't too familiar with the beer options. We later found the type of beer we wanted on a table menu. Food was served promptly and was very good. We enjoyed our pizza and Buffalo chicken rolls. We'll be back for more goo eats.

Source: Google

Mona Brendalen

★ 5

Source: Google

Mary Munisteri

★ 3

The server was inattentive and slow. Food took a while and was only warm.

Source: Google

Karen C

★ 3

I enjoy their pizzas and their opening hours are convenient but my sister had a gluten reaction to their gluten free pizza most likely due to cross-contamination.

Source: Google