Category
Bowling alley RestaurantDescription
Great homemade pizza, pub style sandwiches, delicious burgers, great wraps, panini sandwiches, Sunday breakfasts, and more are all on the menu at Old Settler’s. The food is what sets us apart from most other bowling centers.
We specialize in kids and adult birthday parties both on the bowling lanes and in the bar. we have 16 modern bowling lanes with automatic scoring and bumpers for the little ones, an indoor golf simulator, volleyball courts, horseshoe pits, pool table and dart board, delicious drinks and great food all with a comfortable family atmosphere. We have hosted parties from 6 people to over 300 people.
You can’t go wrong with holding your next party or special occasion at Old Settler’s.
Photos
Leave a Review
Reviews
Matt Clifford
★ 5
Great place to bowl.
Source: Google
Sandy Clifford
★ 5
Source: Google
Chris Endicott
★ 5
Just wanted to say that our bartender Brett was amazing!!!! I would definitely recommend going to this place. The service is great. I'm not even from the area and would come there again.
Source: Google
Booger Bear
★ 5
Nice bowling alley. Good food. Nice atmosphere!!
Source: Google
Soya
★ 5
Great bartenders, foods wonderful.
Source: Google
Cynthia Mara
★ 5
Italian Beef Panini was amazing! Place was spotless! Staff were warm and friendly!
Source: Google
Raymond J Fern III
★ 5
Nice poker tournament.
Source: Google
Dee Jackson
★ 5
Source: Google
Les
★ 5
The best service the staff is great
Source: Google
Jamie Edgerly
★ 5
Love coming to eat or bowl here, or both!
Source: Google
Tim Lindquist
★ 5
Source: Google
Ron Brown
★ 5
Good food friendly atmosphere
Source: Google
Wyatt Uttech
★ 5
Had my sisters 40th birthday was a nice venue decent prices kids had a blast if you have a family definitely recommend
Source: Google
Daniel Unsinn
★ 5
Great atmosphere with great and helpful employees definitely a go to spot for weekend bowling
Source: Google
Kenneth Boatman
★ 3
Source: Google
Lori Loomis
★ 5
Source: Google
Kris Kolb
★ 5
Source: Google
keith carpentier
★ 5
Food is great, atmosphere is immaculate, service is just as good. bar tenders were extremely nice, huge shoutout to Austin on the bowling side really quick to get us a lane and shoes and he has great taste in music.. will definitely be returning.
Source: Google
Collin Klaus
★ 5
Source: Google
Adam peterson
★ 5
They make a great brandy old fashioned and home made Bloody Mary's. The pizza is great too
Source: Google
Scott Babcock
★ 5
Source: Google
Nicholas Kubera
★ 5
Great food great environment friendly helpful staff fun for the family never disappointed when I leave this place always have a great time!
Source: Google
Elizaiah Rodriguez
★ 5
Source: Google
Luke Jarumbo
★ 5
Source: Google
John Badtke
★ 5
Good food good price
Source: Google
Dave Michel
★ 4
Source: Google
Kelsey Jane
★ 5
Source: Google
Twyla McConnell
★ 5
Source: Google
Stacy Quickstad
★ 5
Held our company Christmas party there tonight. Holly was amazing and so were the bartenders not to mention the food was fresh and tasty. I think we've found next year's venue too. Keep up the great service. We all really enjoyed ourselves. Merry Christmas Old Settlers. ☃️
Source: Google
casey reid
★ 1
Waited an hour for our food only to be told they didn’t even put my mom’s order in and she had to wait another 20 minutes on top of the hour we already waited. Absolutely unacceptable.
Source: Google
Laurie Hardwick
★ 5
Excellent fish fry and service!
Source: Google
Matt Glasgow
★ 4
Source: Google
Erica D
★ 5
Source: Google
Anna Ertl
★ 5
We arranged my husband's 50th school reunion. Food was great. It wasn't loud.
Source: Google
JohnTaylor Pelletier
★ 5
Always amazing and accommodating staff, excellent food and never disappointed 🙌
Source: Google
A
★ 5
Nice place to take kids and bowl a few games. Food is good bar food. Family goes frequently. Kids love it.
Source: Google
Lee Toll
★ 5
We used their event space for a class reunion. There were about 65 of us with ample space to gather and eat.
Source: Google
Johnson Family
★ 5
Source: Google
Mary
★ 5
We had the Friday Fish Fry and it was excellent. A very clean facility with amazing servers! Will definitely come back again!
Source: Google
Kevin Kerr
★ 5
Stopped in for dinner to try their fish fry, it was pretty good. I'll be back.
Source: Google
Rob Luce
★ 5
Source: Google
Nicole Benedict
★ 5
We love old settlers inn. That's our home bar. We live in the Grove. The food is amazing. The drinks are great. The staff is wonderful .
Source: Google
Schmitt
★ 5
Source: Google
Scott “Rooster” Sloan
★ 5
Great! 1st time here.
Source: Google
Bella Serrano
★ 5
Source: Google
david wise
★ 4
Bartender was awesome.
Source: Google
Judy Miller
★ 5
Source: Google
Alex Moenssen
★ 5
Source: Google
sally merriman
★ 5
Always top notch!! Especially butch and Brenda
Source: Google
Phyllis and Peter Beaver
★ 5
Source: Google
Chris Isaacson
★ 5
Great staff and eats.
Source: Google
showboardguy
★ 5
Our group goes there twice a week for lunch because their sandwiches are so good and, their loaded baked potatoe and portobello mushroom soups are very good but, the Cheesy Broccoli is Devine! The staff is polite and friendly. I would give more than 5 stars if I could!
Source: Google
tony schwartz
★ 5
Me and the kids love this place. Kid friendly, and everyone was very polite-from the guy on the bowling side, to the waitress staff. We will be coming back!
Source: Google
Melissa Mason
★ 5
Source: Google
Rodney Hawkins III
★ 5
Great place. Great experiences. Golf bowling great food what more than you can ask for!
Source: Google
Morgan McCauley
★ 5
Source: Google
Brian Myers
★ 5
Source: Google
joey Lyons
★ 4
Great place.
Good prices.
Good food.
Source: Google
Notta Mouse (Jesk)
★ 5
Didn't make it in time for bowling but had a couple amazing sandwiches!
Source: Google
Lawrence Oberbruner
★ 5
Source: Google
Paul Breece
★ 5
Source: Google
Jim Dakota
★ 4
Haven't been there for a while. The bartender was very good and friendly. We got 2 menus and mine was covered with BBQ sauce. She took it back and gave me a different one. She also gave me a wet napkin for my hands . Food was really good but the mustard bottle was dirty with one mustard. Yuk. We would still go back for the food.
Source: Google
Joe Dallia
★ 4
Source: Google
Carly Rondeau
★ 5
We love this place so much. Fun bowling. Great fun. Super nice staff.
Source: Google
William Klitzkie
★ 5
Source: Google
Asch Hawthorn
★ 4
Source: Google
Nicole Lapoint
★ 5
Source: Google
Ann Routhraux
★ 5
Source: Google
Ellie Blair
★ 5
Source: Google
Faith Ou
★ 3
Source: Google
Renee Jung
★ 5
Source: Google
Alex Vlk
★ 4
Source: Google
Harry Miller
★ 5
Source: Google
Jason K
★ 2
Showed up to bowl on a Friday at 9 and all the lights were shut off but the door was unlocked
Source: Google
Danielle Shircel
★ 2
My family and I come here to bowl. Our just us adults. We came here shortly after 7 pm one night and they were pushing they wanted to close. They only allowed one game of bowling, wouldn’t take a food order, and forced us to close a tab after one drink…. Worst customer service I’ve seen. We would of had more then one drink each and probable at lest $60 in food. On top of it they were 8 people in the bar and they turned away 4 people to bowl.. Lost our service for sure. Not sure why they wouldn’t want all the business they had available to them.
Source: Google
Kevin Stevens
★ 5
Source: Google
Denise Marubio
★ 2
This is the signature blue cheese burger.....???? Good thing I had blue cheese at home to add
Source: Google
Jennifer Andersen
★ 5
Love the food
Source: Google
Bill
★ 5
This place is very clean (including bathrooms), and the staff are all awesome. We get the pizza every time we go and are never disappointed.
Source: Google
Nicole “Niki” Benzow
★ 5
Clean, kid friendly, awesome place to have fun and just relax. My kids airways have a boat whenever they are there and they have a program where kids can bowl for free all summer long.
Source: Google
Charrie Ferguson
★ 5
My daughter attended her friends birthday party and they had a great time. Staff was super friendly and the alley seems to be very well taken care of.
Source: Google
Pete Terry
★ 4
Source: Google
Bryan Thompson
★ 5
Source: Google
Shawn Ryan
★ 5
Source: Google
Michael Reichert
★ 3
Source: Google
DIANA RIVERA
★ 5
Bowling and the food is good 👍
Source: Google
Cathy Myszkewicz
★ 5
Always a good time, being with grandkids on a Saturday morning or Thursday night shooting pool league and anywhere in between! Staff are friendly and welcoming
Source: Google
Charles Arnold
★ 3
Source: Google
Vern Tuinstra
★ 5
Source: Google
Joe Stonestreet
★ 5
Good food great atmosphere fun times for everyone.
Source: Google
Phil Rush
★ 4
Place is great, always making upgrades. Friendly staff. Good food. Moonlight bowling.
Source: Google
Melissa baranek
★ 5
Nicole is the best!
Source: Google
Scott Cannady
★ 1
Source: Google
Lynne Howard
★ 5
Great burgers!
Source: Google
Jeremy Cowick
★ 5
Source: Google
Thomas Behrens
★ 5
Great place it's like going to a family reunion when I go there. Friendly atmosphere good food and drinks. Awesome pizza all around good place.
Source: Google
anna Marie
★ 4
I like the burger. It was made the right way. It was a very large meal between the burger and fries. It was nice just to relax after a long week with a drink and a meal.
Source: Google
Stacy Boldt
★ 5
Source: Google
peter the lesser
★ 5
Very nice atmosphere. Looks like newly remodeled. Friendly workers. Deep-fried fingerer food is great. The alley has bumpers for children which keeps the bowling ball from going into the gutter.😁
Source: Google
Katy Johnson
★ 5
This is a perfect family place. The food is great. Pizza is a perfect thing to order while bowling. The mozzarella wontons and are just amazing!
Source: Google
tomas Magnuson
★ 5
Very small bowling alley but very big hearts great food only place you can get chippers which are FANTASTIC if you are all going to union Grove looking for something to do definitely go to old settlers
Source: Google
Heidi Coy
★ 2
Even after bowling leagues were done, Noone would leave their.lanes to allow open bowling.
Source: Google
M. J.
★ 4
Fun family friendly place , to have fun with the kids.
Source: Google
heidi mueller
★ 5
Great place for chillin and having fun! Fun bartenders! Amazing Food selection! Great place for Packer Games and Superbowl party. Sweet Owner! Butch Schoenfuss!
Source: Google
brett geerdts
★ 5
Old Settlers is definitely a place for everyone The food is amazing and they have so much for everyone to do Bowling,Golf simulator, host events and more
Source: Google
Katrina Taylor
★ 5
Source: Google
Jonni Hahn
★ 5
Extraordinary space for a large party we attended on Saturday 26 Nov 22. There is a full bar plus a ton of seating area. In addition, it is a bowling center and the younger attendees of said party were quite pleased with the option to bowl. You bet we are coming back! So glad to revisit this good ole staple I hadn't been in years. Looking forward to their fish fry. 😉
Source: Google
Denise Engelhardt
★ 5
Great place to host a party!
Source: Google
Cheryl Welter
★ 5
Everyone so friendly, Butch the owner has a very nice place and food was great
Source: Google
H P
★ 5
Great pizza and staff. Been going here for years
Source: Google
Serene Rismeyer Schroeder
★ 5
Source: Google
Vincent Candido, Sr.
★ 5
Food is always good here!
Source: Google
Michael Hubbard
★ 5
Our first time in for lunch. Menu has good selection I had the Philly Cheese Steak and was delicious. My wife had a burger she loved it as well. We didn’t realize they were open for lunch and dinner. Not to mention the bowling alley. I highly recommend you stop in.
Source: Google
Janell Sievert
★ 5
10/28/2022.... our family who has lived in the area for six years finally ordered sandwiches from Old Settlers. All sandwiches were delicious!! The Turkey, Bacon, Ranch Panini is a must try!! I am angry at myself for not ordering sooner, but will be ordering in the near future!
Source: Google
June Fuhrman
★ 5
We had great time there too,
Source: Google
Steve S
★ 4
I don't usually go there cause it's Far from my House I live in Milwaukee and it's all the way out in Union Grove !! I usually go on Card game day Nights they hold out there .. Which are always Fun !!
Source: Google
Dave Tianen
★ 3
Disappointed. Haven’t ordered a pizza in a while. Ordered one tonight that included sausage. What I got was a cut up bratwurst put on my pizza not Italian sausage. So disappointed. Will certainly ask more questions before ordering again. If I do.
Source: Google
Dawn L
★ 5
The owners are friendly, there are many bowling leagues for all ages and skill levels.
Newly remodeled and is a fun place to spend some time.
Source: Google
Renda Ramsey
★ 5
Source: Google
nlane211
★ 5
Source: Google
Jeffrey Lundberg
★ 5
Wonderful food, especially the burgers, great place to bowl!
Source: Google
Wayne Chapman
★ 5
Source: Google
mr RJL
★ 5
Their balls are black and blue !!
Source: Google
Heather Medina
★ 1
By far the worst service I have ever had at a bowling alley especially on a Sunday.. if your only going to have one bartender taking all the drink orders, food orders, phone calls, etc. Should have one that has a sense of urgency and taking care of all paying customers rather then her friends/ looks to be coworker at the end of the bar.. shame on the owners for not jumping in to help her while 5 ir more people are waiting for service
Source: Google
Jackie Garcia
★ 5
Absolutely fantastic!!! Been a long time since I went here. Will definitely be going back!!!!
Source: Google
Amalie Axelsen
★ 5
Source: Google
Sue A
★ 5
Combo basket is the best here and so is the service!
Source: Google
noslow50ford
★ 5
Really good food, great bartenders, the owner is a super nice guy. Level pool table too.
Source: Google
Hope Anderson
★ 5
Source: Google
Kat Janis
★ 5
Source: Google
Chrystal Gotta
★ 5
Source: Google
Candyce Guenzler
★ 5
Perfect as usual for themt
Source: Google
Kurt Sholly
★ 5
Great food, good bowling and terrific service!!
Source: Google
William Pietkauskis
★ 5
Source: Google
Malcolm Young
★ 4
Source: Google
Patti Heer
★ 4
Source: Google
Scott Hurtienne
★ 4
Source: Google
Peter Upson
★ 5
Source: Google
L G
★ 3
Good fish fry for the price if you don't mind waiting a long time. There is only one server for the whole dining area. I've been here numerous times over the last 6 months and there has never been more than one server. The last time I went I waited for a table for 45 minutes even though 3 were empty but they just don't have the staff. I ended up leaving.
Source: Google
Donald Tjader
★ 5
Montana burger all day
Source: Google
Jesse Nelson
★ 5
Source: Google
Steven Jacobs
★ 5
Smaller house, great service and good food
Source: Google
Alan Stried
★ 5
Source: Google
Tony Stephens
★ 5
New to the area. First time trying here. Pizza was very good and well worth the price. Wish I had tried this place before trying two other places that were either not good or over priced.
Source: Google
Jim Flees
★ 5
Source: Google
Robert Benedict
★ 5
Very good food here great staff very pleasant atmosphere you feel like your welcome all the time we eat here at least once a week i would have to say if i could give more stars it would a ten for sure. And i do have to say its the best place in town to eat for your money.
Source: Google
Alaina Michelle Karpinski-Breuckman
★ 5
The cod fish two piece dinner, the clam chowder, and salad bar was great to eat.
Source: Google
Tatine Nielsen
★ 4
Nice friendly people, clean, good food
Source: Google
Crystal Czajkowski
★ 4
Source: Google
Josh Powell
★ 5
Great atmosphere, nice people and fun games.
Source: Google
aaron payuk
★ 4
Source: Google
Chula QuietWolf
★ 5
Marcy is the absolute BEST!!!!!
Source: Google
Andrew Massie
★ 4
Source: Google
Ron Fitzgerald
★ 5
Great time bowling. Friendly staff. Recommend
Source: Google
Hector Duarte
★ 5
Bro the food is fire 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
The staff are so nice and generous
Treated me with love Everytime ❤️
Great place for friends night out or family night out.
Source: Google
Susan Goldsmith
★ 4
Dill pickle chips were the best we have ever had !
Did not realize they have such a big menu. Food was great..
Source: Google
Brenda Griffey
★ 5
Birthday party. Food is excellent
Source: Google
James Maki
★ 5
Source: Google
Laura Dietrick
★ 5
Source: Google
Roni Pasch
★ 5
Source: Google
Michelle Scheifen
★ 5
Great food. Friendly staff!
Source: Google
Travis Bushley
★ 5
Looking really good with the new carpet and flooring. Slowly bringing it back to new. Friendly environment an great food all round
Source: Google
Julie
★ 3
Never go on a friday. Made that mistake. Couldn't even bowl that night. Everyone was amazing though and kind. And make sure to call ahead to find out when they are actually open. Went during the open bowl hours that is listed directly on the website just to find out they have been closing early.
Source: Google
Carolyn Talbert
★ 4
Food is good and reasonably priced.
Source: Google
Lynn Stardy
★ 5
Source: Google
Nanci Hogue
★ 4
Food was amazing! Had the Montana Burger it was very good. Their naked wings are good too !!
Source: Google
Juan Becerra
★ 4
Great place to go and relax with friends and family have a few drinks and some nice conversation it just awesome👍.
Source: Google
Tammy Stardy
★ 5
Source: Google
Jason Ryan
★ 4
Source: Google
Erin Pearson
★ 5
Blue cheese burger was amazing. Mozzarella sticks also good.
Source: Google
Lloyd Schoen
★ 4
Food was pretty good.
Source: Google
John Brewington
★ 5
Great night of poker starting at 6:45 on every Monday evening. Good people, great service. Nice place
Source: Google
Tanner Matthews
★ 5
This place has the best Philly cheese sandwiches I have came across yet. Great people and a great atmosphere
Source: Google
Zakman 1955
★ 4
Nice place, nice crowd and good food. Very reasonable prices. Been there a long time so they are doing it right
Source: Google
Joe Marubio
★ 1
Source: Google
Marlene Daniels
★ 5
Source: Google
Scott Anderson
★ 5
Great place!
Source: Google
Sandra Beta
★ 5
Source: Google
Autumn H.
★ 4
Source: Google
Brandon BoltZilla
★ 4
Source: Google
Dennis Rodefer
★ 5
Great place to STRIKE up a conversation relax and toss around a ball or 2. While you relax u will be SPARED the hussle and bussle of the daily grind. Make yr APPROACH with the kids and have a fun FILLED day or night. Just watch while the TURKEYS fly by.
Source: Google
Ed Daniels
★ 5
A fabulous place to relax and just enjoy your day. The food is amazing.
Source: Google
BobbiSue Mutter
★ 5
Great prices, good food, clean environment and wonderful service!
Source: Google
renee martin
★ 5
Source: Google
Linda Taylor
★ 5
Love the food and best pizza
Source: Google
Kelly Koszyczarek
★ 5
Source: Google
michael mika
★ 5
Source: Google
double A Ron
★ 4
Source: Google
Joanna Williams
★ 5
Source: Google
galopagos395
★ 1
Terrible dining room experience. We were greeted by the "hostess" she said "sit wherever you like" we took a seat in the booth. 10 minutes passed before she came back and said "I am unable to take your order I'm just filling in for somebody" she didn't take a drink order or even offer us a glass of water. Finally after a long wait the server arrived. The 3 of us ordered Friday Fish specials. After nearly an hour wait the food arrived in 2 separate rounds. The fish was cold and rubbery. Coleslaw looked a week old and was watery and smelled rotten. Fries were cold also. Server never followed up to make sure food was good. Overall disappointing experience. Will never return
Source: Google
Jason V
★ 5
This place is great! Staff is awesome and super friendly, amazing pizza, good drinks, and great bowling. Definitely recommend! Will be a go-to place for me, my family, and friends!
Source: Google
bob rodgers
★ 5
Source: Google
Ted Johnson
★ 4
Source: Google
Melissa Wandrey
★ 1
We ordered food on Thursday and my boyfriend got worst case of food poisoning he's ever had from a portobello chicken sandwich. We have had some issues here before with burned food, cold food, and messed up orders. We tried to give them multiple chances, however we will never do it again.
Source: Google
Beth Peterson
★ 5
Source: Google
Lillyhona Hasting
★ 5
Source: Google
Shawn Czerwinski
★ 5
Source: Google
Mary JO Szczerba
★ 5
Source: Google
Shelbi Gunderson
★ 5
Source: Google
Kim Ouwerkerk
★ 4
Source: Google