Olive Tree Café

Oak Creek, 3570 E Puetz Rd, Oak Creek, WI 53154 | ★ 4.3 (317 Review)

📞 +1 414-762-6222

Last Search

Category

Restaurant

Description

New ownership, and new management. A friendly and clean atmosphere, tv's, full service bar, break fast, lunch, and dinner.
Best food in town and banquet hall up to 120 people. (Opening Soon, December 1st)

Photos

 Olive Tree Café
 Olive Tree Café
 Olive Tree Café
 Olive Tree Café
 Olive Tree Café
 Olive Tree Café
 Olive Tree Café

Leave a Review

Reviews

Julia Gard

★ 3

We Go there every Sunday, but this Sunday I couldn’t believe how filthy their carpets were. Please get your carpet cleaned. If you don’t mind people seeing that then what does the rest of your place look like?

Source: Google

Ralph Pawelski

★ 4

Good, solid breakfast. Fair pricing.

Source: Google

John Schauer

★ 2

Source: Google

Lauren S

★ 3

Very average place, nothing to write home about. It was our first time here and the service was good. The food was just meh or not good. Everything seemed frozen or canned and heated in the microwave. We had the cod fish fry and baked fish. Lettuce on salad seemed frozen and thawed, still wet; corn on cob was too hot and mushy; I could go on but you get the idea. It seemed like dessert would be good there but they didn’t have any gluten free options so we didn’t order. They played oldies on a radio station too. I don’t mind oldies but listening to commercials while dining is not relaxing. Can do that at home.

Source: Google

Angie Perez

★ 5

Food was delicious, although we were hoping for lunch food and chicken dumpling soup but was only given a breakfast menu, waitress wasn't very helpful offering or giving us information, it was our first time there,(and the only customers) but also wasn't rude or mean. Although I didn't get my drink refilled at all and we were there for awhile. I'd try it again though.

Source: Google

Jerry Schaff

★ 5

Source: Google

Patti Dale

★ 3

Source: Google

John Millan

★ 5

Source: Google

Pat Prout

★ 5

Met our best friends for breakfast. We had breakfast with eggs and pancakes too. Everything was hot, tasty and reasonably priced. Our waitress, Sheila, was super attentive and friendly. She even tolerated my husband's teasing. We come here often and they never disappoint. We wish them much success.

Source: Google

Chris Lee Aries

★ 5

Stopped here for dinner with the family. The inside was a usual cozy diner with booths and tables. I ordered the Athenian chicken, it was good, the gravy that came with it was allright, not lemony and herbal enough. It was more like a chicken gravy then Athenian but I still ate it all cause I love chicken. The baked tater was a usual easy to cook one in the oven, our server was a beautiful blonde woman, she was a pretty good server. If we are in the Oak Creek area again I will ask them if we could go to Olive Tree again!

Source: Google

kate a

★ 2

Source: Google

Karen Thayer

★ 1

Nasty. Taco salad had I chopped lettuce from the core of the head. Meat was very greasy. Mediterranean salad had an inch of water in the container. Gyro meat was way overdone.

Source: Google

MaryPat Odeja

★ 1

Food and diner prices ok. When we took it in the wallet was when we ordered 3 pcs of pie to take with us. Menu said pie with diner add $2 the three of us spent $60 on 3 diners than they charged us $18 for 3 pcs of pie.won’t be going back very untrustworthy owners

Source: Google

Mary Kay Kais

★ 4

Source: Google

Mary M

★ 5

Very warm and friendly environment. The front staff are always nice to me. It feels very family oriented. Love it. 10 stars. I come here as a delivery driver mostly but great atmosphere

Source: Google

Lori

★ 1

Was in last week been here a few times now I can definitely say I will not return! Our waitress was SO RUDE! I think her name was Fela.I sat with a empty cup of what woulda have been coffee could she came around more then 1 time the entire visit then when I asked her for coffee she acted like it was a chore. She was more worried about getting more tables,vs. taking care of the ones she had. I never felt so unwelcome in a restraunt in my life. That lady should definitely not be in the service industry what makes it worse is the food was pretty good . Definitely not the service!

Source: Google

Alyssa LaRoi

★ 5

Our first time dining and we wish we came sooner! Food was great and service was amazing. A huge shoutout to our waitress, Sheila, who really made our first meal absolutely wonderful! We will definitely be coming back more often!!!

Source: Google

Mike N

★ 5

We discovered this place about a year ago. It is an amazing breakfast spot! Inspite of inflation, they have kept their prices very reasonable. The food is fresh and nothing seems to come out of a can. Servers are very friendly. Our new favorite place for breakfast!

Source: Google

Randy Rick

★ 5

This is great place to eat! From the time me and my sister and I walked in was greated very friendly and the food was amazing and great portions I have the liver and onions was very tender I recommend that a wrap she enjoyed my compliments to the cook and the amazing staff!😁

Source: Google

Karen Nesbit

★ 5

Source: Google

Aaron Kelly

★ 2

1 Bacon cheeseburger and 1 hamburger (ordered nothing else) costs a total of $32.00 and tip. Let that sink in

Source: Google

Venessa “Nesser Lynn” Medina

★ 5

I have a bunch of sick boys on my hands, I called ahead to see if they had soup, they did! Chicken dumpling. The person who answered the phone told me they had 32oz togo containers. I asked for two. He said of course and told me it would be ready when I arrived and it was. I asked for one more when I arrived and explained that my boys are sick. They helped pack me up and sent me on my way. When I got home my boys were being picky but once they tasted it we went through all 3 of the 32 oz of chicken dumpling soup. It was in the words of Roman (6) "phenomenal". I would highly recommend this place. After eating the soup we will be going back to try breakfast as soon as my boys are better!

Source: Google

Christine Sutherland

★ 5

Source: Google

Ken Nowak

★ 4

Good breakfast and for dinner great broasted chicken

Source: Google

Chuck Nelson

★ 2

Old looking. Out of date tables and decor. Food was subpar and small portions.

Source: Google

Paula

★ 5

Great food, and a great selection for every diet/ palate. Friendly waitresses (hi Kathy!) And an awesome experience every time we visit!

Source: Google

brad chappel

★ 2

Honestly I liked going here. We've been in multiple times( good service and the food is good. Better then most diners). Now here's the part that puts a bad taste in my mouth. You go online to order to-go and they charge the normal price for an omelette as if I was sitting in the restaurant. You get an omelette and potatoes. Now online they charge the normal price only for the omelette and want 4 to 5 dollars more for potatoes. I know for a fact the ham and cheese omelette is not $17 dollars on the menu. Very disappointed. Will probably stop going to eat here over this overreach of money. I'll spend money on a good product but don't screw me because I want to pick it up instead of sitting down

Source: Google

Wayne Landmeier

★ 5

Source: Google

Larry Collier

★ 5

One of the best breakfast I had in a long time.

Source: Google

Sonya Goodwin

★ 4

Good food very friendly waitress, I only have one problem. The card reader was out so we had to pay cash and luckily, I had cash on me because I usually don’t carry cash.

Source: Google

Stuart Salerno

★ 5

Source: Google

Jeffery Philleo

★ 4

Good food portion where Good size

Source: Google

JaNell Prasalowicz

★ 5

Source: Google

John Parker

★ 5

I passed this place everyday for years on my way to work. Today I decided to try it.

The food was amazing, the prices were great!

I can’t wait to go back!

Source: Google

Ulysses Butler

★ 5

It was a laid-back experience

Source: Google

Laura Trick

★ 5

Source: Google

Rosemary Ekstowicz

★ 5

Source: Google

Kelli Kratt MS, RD, CD

★ 1

We have frequented this cafe many times, as it was a deceased family members favorite restaurant. We have come in as a large group a handful of times. This time, we made a reservation 30 days in advance, for a group of 25 at an off peak time (3pm on a Sunday). There was no information given about added fees or special menus. We arrived to find a small, "Sunday Dinner" menu on the table. It limited our entrée selection greatly. Several family members have allergies/diet restrictions. As a result, about 6 of us were left without options, as we planned to eat from the regular menu (that other people in the restaurant at the same time could order from). The wait staff was very gracious and tried to give us a couple options which we appreciated, until the bill came. We were charged a flat rate that included a hall rental fee but we didn't rent a hall. We sat in the restaurant. This flat fee meant that I paid ~$30 for a grilled cheese & fries ($8.99 on the regular menu) and a soda plus gratuity. Absolutely ridiculous.
The restaurant should practice transparency - let those booking reservations know ALL the added fees/restrictions that come along with a booking. Had we known ahead of time, there would have been no unpleasant surprises or we could have chosen to go elsewhere. This restaurant just lost 25 customers.

Source: Google

Laurie Dobrzynski

★ 1

We made a reservation for 25 people. Was not told up front that it would be $30 a person regardless of what was ordered! Given a limited menu with prices on it( that were not $30). Some had only water and a bowl of soup. Two people didn't eat. We were charged $500 for food. $115 for soda and $130 for gratuity. RIPOFF!!! Was this even legal?? We will never return!!

Source: Google

Kari Kratt

★ 1

It’s old people food, it’s fine. Service was fine.

We came here as a family get together because it was the one year anniversary of my grandpa’s passing, we’ve occasionally done large dinners here the whole family, as it was my grandpa’s favorite restaurant. There was 25 of us, in the past we all just order from the menu, on one bill, no big deal, we took care of splitting it up. I moved out of the area and haven’t been back since grandpa passed, today we had this big dinner and they charged us like we had it catered, gave us a limited menu and charged us like it was $40 a person. The bill was $800, we felt completely taken advantage of because none of this was talked about when we called to see if there was a good time in the day to accommodate a party of 25.

Source: Google

Melanie H

★ 1

While our waitresses were kind and helpful, Olive Tree should be ashamed of themselves! My family made a 25-person reservation to be together on the one year anniversary of my grandfather’s death. This was his favorite restaurant. When the reservation was made, we had the option to book a hall or not, and decided on a large table in the restaurant (not a hall) during their least busy time of day (confirmed by staff member). The decision to decline the hall was understood by the staff member on the phone. This reservation was made a month in advance. When we arrived, we were sat at a large table in the dining room, not in a rentable hall. Each family member was given a menu with prices next to each item. We were absolutely appalled when a single bill arrived at the end of our meal for a flat rate of $800. Several people just had a drink, or a bowl of soup and salad. Even if every single person in our party got the most expensive dish on the menu- our bill wouldn’t have been CLOSE to $800! When the restaurant was questioned why we didn’t get an itemized check, and how they came to the bill of $800, they said they had to “figure it out”. When we finally got a “revised” bill, it was $700 including a “hall rental fee” for a hall we did not inhabit. They could not tell us why we were charged $28 per person and not the amount stated on the menu provided to us, or why they couldn’t remove the hall rental fee. 18% gratuity is standard on a large party meal, but $700 isn’t our meals plus 18% gratuity! If we didn’t question why our bill was $800, would they have charged us an extra $100 simply because they could? What a lovely way to treat a grieving family! Olive Tree should be ashamed of themselves. It is unbelievable they have the audacity to behave this way to loyal, paying customers.

Source: Google

Josh Hughes

★ 1

First off let me state that the service was great, no fault of the wait staff. However, a reservation for a party of 25 was made a month in advance for my family and I to meet on the one year anniversary of my grandfather in laws passing. This being his favorite spot to eat, it felt right. At no point during the making of this reservation was a "hall rental fee" or flat rate food pricing mentioned. Upon arriving we were sat in the regular dining room at a combined table and each given a menu with individual item pricing. However, when finished, we were handed one bill with a single price tag equating to $32/person. I had the chicken fried steak for $14.99 and my wife had a soda. Another in our party only had a bowl of soup. When asked about this we were told there was a hall rental fee added (Okay, why were we not placed in a hall then?) and given no explanation as to why we were handed menus with prices just to be charged an exorbitant amount of money for a standard meal. But fear not, they took $100 off! Hooray, now it was only $28/person! How reasonable! This is disgusting and deceptive business practice and should have been discussed up front when the reservation was made. Added gratuity for a large party is an acceptable practice, not flat out lying to our faces about meals being individually priced. I will most certainly not be returning or recommending anyone go here.

Source: Google

Robin Cunningham

★ 5

Absolutely the most awesome cream of chicken soup! Fresh corned beef. Crab stir fry to die for!

Source: Google

sam dade

★ 4

Source: Google

Janice weaver

★ 1

They always get my order wrong… do not ask to substitute anything as they will not do it. I am so sad as I like their food but they never get it right. So sad.

Source: Google

Deborah Langley

★ 4

Owner and (Fila) the waitress are awesome. Atmosphere is pretty basic, but clean and inviting. Good prices as well.

Source: Google

Laurie Hardwick

★ 5

Everything was excellent!

Source: Google

Dale Ryan

★ 5

Nice place clean and friendly staff good food everything is so good here I recommend coming to this place a 5 star rating

Source: Google

Adrianna Cole

★ 5

Source: Google

Rowan

★ 1

First and last time I will go. Walking in here it was a cross between a retirement home, 1983, and not sure why there’s TV’s AND gambling machines?
The food was less than remarkable. Absolutely flavorless omelette, stuffed with veggies and not cooked properly once folded over. (runny yolk and undercooked)
Bacon tasted reheated, hash browns were not cooked enough and tasted like a freezer.
The coffee has NO flavor and was literally like drinking a hot cup of coffee water. Not worth $50.00 at all. Please please remodel and get some proper chefs that understand breakfast. This was utterly disappointing since there’s not much between oak creek and S. Milwaukee.

Source: Google

Joan Liempeck

★ 5

Source: Google

Linda Montana

★ 5

Food is great and hospitality is awesome. My first time there today and I will be going back soon. My compliments to the Chef.

Source: Google

Diane Meir

★ 5

#1 for us. Love it
Home style food!
Highly recommended

Source: Google

Kristina Griz

★ 5

It's a great little café with plenty of seating and a wide variety of food. The size of the menu is surprising, from breakfast to dinner, they have everything. It's like a café you go to when you're little with the fridge of cakes, paying up front, and experienced staff. The best way to describe it is charming. It might just become a weekly place for my family. 5/5 would highly recommend.

Source: Google

Dean Stoner

★ 5

The Veggie Panni was excellent, some of the best fries around.

Source: Google

Sheila Ritzow

★ 5

The best food and waitresses

Source: Google

JOHN MATTHEWS

★ 5

Everything was wonderful.

Source: Google

Cris Lee

★ 5

Such a great place to eat, what a wonderful find! From the atmosphere to the menu and staff, all excellent. Fresh and delicious food. Awesome owner, works hard and keeps the restaurant so nice. Enjoyable all around!

Source: Google

Lisa Girmscheid

★ 4

Source: Google

Hank Wu

★ 1

One of the worst service I’ve ever had, the lady not sure her origin comes to our table with angry face without a hello or any greeting just asked “what can I get for you ? “ when she brought our food she literally throw the plate onto the table randomly without saying anything or ask if we need anything else right away and just took off, the next time we see her anywhere near our table is right before we finished our food she yelled across the table next to us”how’s everything” conveniently while she is cleaning up other table. Yet consistently she smiles chatted and greeted every other tables she waited and we are the only table getting different treatment. My other is visiting from Asia and I thought would be nice to take her out to eat and this is what she experienced

Source: Google

Dan Berlinski

★ 5

Great prices! Old school diner with huge portions and the food was good too

Source: Google

Roger Schlink

★ 4

Typical breakfast lunch place. Good food and prices.

Source: Google

Dianne “Evansbikergrama”

★ 5

I do not post many reviews however this experience is noteworthy. I ordered a 16 piece bucket of chicken for pickup at a certain time. It was ready as requested and I have to say it was beyond delicious. I had never ordered from here since the new owners and had questions. All were answered with polite understanding. We will be going back often.

Source: Google

Sue Krzyzanowski

★ 5

Source: Google

Eric J

★ 5

Source: Google

Summer2021

★ 5

Source: Google

Joshua Meyer

★ 5

Sheila is the absolute best! Her personality pairs incredibly well with the restaurant style, and food!

Source: Google

Christine Noelle

★ 2

Source: Google

Stacy Wenthur

★ 1

What a joke. We got there at 740pm and was told the place was closed. Over it. Never going back there. Service has gone down hill just like their chicken dumping soup.

Source: Google

KC Streich

★ 5

Wonderful eatery at the head of a charming little town of shops and spas. From the bread, to soup of the day (chx dumpling, some of the best dumplings I've ever had), to the beef liver and onions I ordered- everything was superb. Feels like a hidden gem ❤️

Source: Google

Brian Scott

★ 3

great friendly service, nice atmosphere, food was delicious but very small portions except bread and salad. Especially for a $14 fishfry, fish was like a fidhstick

Source: Google

Randy Overmyer

★ 3

Source: Google

Dustin Holzman

★ 2

food was not good...place was dirty abd defiently hadnt been dusted in a long time. windows were dirty....the whole place. if i hadnt been with my dad abd grandma i woukd have left without ordering.

Source: Google

V Taylor

★ 5

A hidden gem!! From the greeting at the door to the fair well when we were done it was superb! 4 of us ate there and all the of us got more food then we could eat. And all our meals were delicious. The service was excellent. Would definitely recommend!’n

Source: Google

MajikMan747

★ 5

What a great find. Our server Jen is so sweet, the food is fabulous and the prices were well worth what we got. We'll definitely be back.

Source: Google

william geiger

★ 5

Source: Google

L Bru

★ 5

Friendly family atmosphere. Sheila was so nice and took great care of our table. The food was fresh and delicious! The Med and Village salads were very generous portions. Good soups too. We’ll definitely be back.

Source: Google

Sqrlbite

★ 5

Great clam chowder and homemade rye bread. Also had a baked potatoe!! Great service and atmosphere!!

Source: Google

Desiree Bundalo

★ 5

Source: Google

Mark Lubecke

★ 5

Totally enjoyed a dine in breakfast with some of the family, very good service,
good food.

Source: Google

Laurie Maney

★ 5

Food was very good and the service was excellent.

Source: Google

Justine Filapek

★ 5

Olive Tree Cafe is a family restaurant catering to families - of course. Although everyone is welcome. Not an imposing or distracting style of decor, just a casual place for a casual meal.

Our server was excellent. Friendly, relaxed, ready to help us enjoy our meal. Ya know. I am bad with the asking of the names, but THIS time she actually TOLD it to us without me needing to ask, and I STILL don't remember it. I am the WORST with this. She was just lovely. Made us feel right at home and as if we were regular customers - even though this was our first visit.

The food is great. From simple cereals and eggs, soups and salads, sandwiches and burgers, on up to steak and seafood, a wide variety to choose from if your group can't decide on a cuisine. I had the Monterey Chicken, Mom had the Roasted Turkey and Avocado, and we had the Appetizer Combo to share. The combo had just a few pieces of several items which was perfect to share. We only ate half of it to save room for the rest as each sandwich comes with fries and a cup of soup. The Chicken dumpling is very tasty, has lots of flavor in the broth. Mom thoroughly enjoyed the half of her Roasted Turkey and Avocado she could finish, and likewise the Monterey Chicken half that I ate was delicious. Lots of grilled onions so it was really slippery inside and kept falling apart on me. Don't get me wrong, it was delicious. I just switched to eating it with a knife and fork so I didn't end up looking like a toddler just learning how to use utensils. We each took home half of the remaining half of the app combo, half our sandwiches, and half our fries. I also grabbed a piece of chocolate cake to go on the way out. Scrumptious. Very moist with a rich, creamy chocolate icing. Mmmmm.

Source: Google

sandra switalski

★ 3

I was in there on Wednesday and the owner is very rude and has no tack. The way he was treating the blonde waitress and the way he talked to her was rude and very disrespectful. I won't be back again.

Source: Google

Kerry Baker

★ 4

Good food..nice portions. Good service.

Source: Google

David Burrows

★ 5

Source: Google

Karen Karshna

★ 5

Awesome fiod

Source: Google

Butch Schlueter

★ 3

Nothing special

Source: Google

Glen Worgull

★ 5

Friendly family restaurant with great food.

Source: Google

Sheila Semrou

★ 5

Delicious food & exceptional service!! Greek dishes. Greek family owned 😊 🇬🇷. Quite a few Veggie and Pescatarian dishes! 🐟

Source: Google

Anti Johnny

★ 4

the food is always good here, and the staff is very friendly. Excellent value for the cost.

Source: Google

Peter Trick (Speedypetey)

★ 5

Source: Google

Marie Kelly

★ 4

Source: Google

Ric Villegas

★ 5

We've been here four times in less than a month - great meals every time. Daily homemade bread, delicious hot soups ( cheesy enchilada pictured ). Above par staff & great music playing too ! Cozy surroundings & clean. I can't say enough about this family run hidden gem !

Source: Google

Michael Wittman

★ 3

Source: Google

A Maria

★ 5

Best customer service in the state! Food was great and reasonably priced. Would come back again.

Source: Google

Sharon Kreuzpaintner

★ 5

Staff very attentive. Food very good ,a little $$$.

Source: Google

Atheer Abbas

★ 5

Source: Google

Gina Schollars

★ 1

Source: Google

Thumper Diekow

★ 5

Mine and my daughter's favorite restaurant to eat in the neighborhood!

Source: Google

Michael Thompson

★ 4

Food and service is good.

Source: Google

Finn Rogers

★ 4

Great place, Staff is very nice and friendly, and the atmosphere is great. It feels exactly like an old diner, which I like. However, it took about 45 minutes to get our food, the cooks messed up our order, and the burger needed to be seasoned. But other than that, it's a good restaurant, and I will probably be back.

Source: Google

Joe Drezdon

★ 5

Source: Google

John Dunbar

★ 5

Walking in, greeted by a gentleman with a smile who led us to a comfy boother. Feels like a big family working together (it def is). pink booths & pastel ocean breeze 90s vibes u can see, feel, smell and taste. The menu is a never ending story and I heard Elvis nights are coming soon.

Source: Google

Cheryl Witkofski

★ 4

Source: Google

Lonán Rufa

★ 5

This place rules!! Staff is kind & attentive, Dana gave me some homemade chicken and dumpling soup to try, warmed my heart. 🥹 so good. Breakfast all day, lots of options to try from the whole menu.
Classic cozy Greek diner interior, booths & tables, stairs & ramp to get into the building. Lots of parking. True neighborhood spot. bring your friends you will not be disappointed.

Source: Google

Robert Lawrence

★ 5

Excellent tasting food, of which you get a decent amount. You get your meals served in a short amount of time. Everybody working there is very friendly. The waitresses are incredible, the best I've ever had. I hate to go home and wish I could go there every night. And the desserts are out of this world. When you go, ask for Monique!!!

Source: Google

ted boyd

★ 4

Broasted chicken is the real deal! Very good. Great salad, lots of variety (several kinds of lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onion, croutons-impressive) Service was great, very friendly host, waitress and bus girl. Atmosphere- very clean, a little too bright for me, as it got busier, it was quite noisy. Reasonable prices.

Source: Google

Dennis G.

★ 3

New name, same below average food. Basic ho hum Cafe. Feels like it's always on its last gasp of life. The senior center next door probably keeps it in business.

Source: Google

Jamie Kralicek

★ 5

Source: Google

Gabby Blondy

★ 1

Source: Google

Andrea

★ 5

Source: Google

Daniel Bruce jr.

★ 5

Source: Google

pedro gonzalez

★ 5

Absolutely enjoy dining here.Food,Atmosphere and service by employees and owners is beyond expectations. Fish Fry’s are really good also Baked Cod is very good. I have had other dinner plates and never disappointed. Homemade soups are delicious(clam chowder)I have yet to try breakfast but heard very good things.

Source: Google

Mark Schmitt

★ 4

Source: Google

Mike Ottmann

★ 4

Source: Google

Jackie D

★ 5

Source: Google

Ed Carney

★ 5

I love this place. I eat the soup and ask for a doggy bag

Source: Google

Kathy Wojtysiak

★ 5

My first time there with a large family gathering after church. The waitress was excellent with all we put her thru and extra staff was there to help. Food was delicious, eye appealing and came quickly. A few of my family members go there often after mass and have not been disappointed. Was a lovely evening!

Source: Google

tammy johnson

★ 3

It was a nice place to have breakfast. The serving size was large ( 3 egg omlet) but nothing you couldn't make at home. It was average overall. I think there was no deco change( even the pictures on the wall) are the same from prior owners

Source: Google

angela schoenung

★ 2

Food was not good

Source: Google

S S

★ 5

Great place. Very friendly and good food. Had the chicken sandwich, it was really tasty, also had the ruben it was delicious.

Source: Google

Patrick Ruffino

★ 5

Consistently good quality food. My wife and I go here a few times a month, usually for breakfast. Prices are absolutely reasonable for what you get.

Source: Google

Michael Olszewski

★ 4

Have the tomato pasta soup very good and great taste.

Source: Google

Gary Miller

★ 5

Great place and food is awesome 👌

Source: Google

Dana G

★ 5

Thank you for hosting the Oak Creek Lionettes! We all enjoyed our dinners and our waitress Dana! She did an excellent job!

Source: Google

linda ortlieb

★ 5

Source: Google

Tinamaria Adams

★ 4

Waitress almost charged the wrong price but it was caught in time. Otherwise everything was fine

Source: Google

Vanessa Miller

★ 5

Sheila was absolutely amazing! Had a great service with wonderful food! The ham and cheese omelette was wonderful.

Source: Google

Tammi Navis

★ 5

Upon entering the restaurant, we are always greeted warmly and seated promptly. All staff are friendly and accommodating. Olive Tree Cafe has an abundance of food choices for all ages and palates. Lots of natural light.

Source: Google

Jessica Schroeder

★ 5

Sheila was our waitress on this past sunday...I never go online for review but I have 2 for this 1!!! She was absolutely AMAZING!!!! If you want a great experience & a waitress that will talk to as a family member & truly care for your experience 2 matter then come here!! So sheila...thank u so very much for the 1st time experience!!! It was amazing!!

Source: Google

Janet Lecus

★ 1

Source: Google

Leanne Miksa

★ 5

Wonderful service 👏 great food

Source: Google

WS JK

★ 3

Of the 5 of us 3 ordered a gyro. It was good. Plenty of food on the plate. It looked as though it wasn't open, but was assured that is where we were gathering for lunch. The exterior of the restaurant looks shabby and un maintained. Needs painting and the landscaping needs to be freshened up. Our table was very dirty. Patches of dried remnants from previous dinners. Even with that said the server was friendly and efficient. It wouldn't be my first next time around.

Source: Google

Julie Frank

★ 5

Source: Google

Sherry Gac

★ 5

We found this restaurant by 'accident', in the pouring rain, when we were in need of a dry place and some food. It was great!!! Food was delicious. Server was wonderful. Restaurant was clean. We will be back!!! Really loved it!!!

Source: Google

carl duffy

★ 4

Source: Google

Kathy Butcher

★ 5

Source: Google

Good morning Bestie!

★ 5

Yummy gyro skillet with pancakes 😋🥞!!

Source: Google

Wayne Szczepanski

★ 5

Source: Google

Patrick Semski

★ 5

Good food at good prices.

Source: Google

Thomas Massie

★ 5

It a long. an well established restraint. they been in the bissnes. 45 years

Source: Google

Marybeth Pfeffer

★ 5

Source: Google

steven parrett

★ 5

Waitress was awesome

Source: Google

Christian lovato

★ 5

Source: Google

Chuck Weber

★ 5

Staff was very helpful and service was great

Source: Google

James Elterman

★ 4

Nice family diner. In addition to the typical American diner breakfast and lunch options, they also have some Greek options such as gyro and chicken. Our group had a variety and everything was good.

Source: Google

Royal Syn

★ 5

Awesome place, friendly staff. Recommend the blueberry pancakes and the Olive Tree omelette.

Source: Google

M Feller

★ 5

Source: Google

Auther Kuenstler

★ 5

Service was good food excellent

Source: Google

Pat Kuenstler

★ 5

Good menu, tasty food
Give it a try!

Source: Google

Chris Zanger

★ 5

Source: Google

Catalina C

★ 5

They make you feel like family. Large portions.

Source: Google

Frank Cichon

★ 5

Great food, fast service and friendly people.

Source: Google

Jo Anna Larson

★ 5

Source: Google

Instructions Not Included

★ 5

Dine in a couple of times, small Mom and pop restaurant great for off the beaten path breakfast.

Source: Google

Jeanie raz

★ 3

Broasted chicken was fantastic. Huge down side was the $6 Coors Light beer not on the menu. I ordered two having zero clue how expensive it was. Unfortunately we won’t be back.

Source: Google

Todd Gray

★ 4

Definitely good food and excellent service.

Source: Google

Bert Arndt

★ 4

Source: Google

Danielle Cooke

★ 5

Source: Google

Jenny Moy

★ 5

Great service!

Source: Google

Mark Forster

★ 5

I ordered takeout and all of the food was hot and made to order when I picked it up. Staff I interacted with were very genuine and kind. I'd definitely go back.

Source: Google

Sandi Landowski

★ 5

Spur of the moment, stop for dinner. The food was good and the staff were very friendly. Reasonable prices and good portions. Delicious desserts. Music from the 50s and 60s not blaring, which was nice.

Source: Google

Lyle Naldood

★ 2

Only come if you have plenty of time, not a great lunch spot. They are extremely slow

Source: Google

Cassandra McCormick

★ 4

Pretty typical family restaurant...big variety menu, decent food, nice servers. Drinks went dry with no refills, but not a deal-breaker. The music coming over the speakers was loud and a fuzzy/distorted radio station. We asked the staff to please tune it in and/or turn it down. They explained there was a "short in the wire," and did turn it down a notch, but then the owner or manager turned up a T.V. that was in the dining room. Even-though we sat next to each other, conversation was difficult due to these droning noises. Good place to catch a quick breakfast or lunch...alone. 😉

Source: Google

Jenn Ring

★ 5

Good food and very caring staff

Source: Google

Kim Shaw Cable

★ 1

place is dirty! Staff picks and chooses who they want to wait on! Had to count on other waitress to get us napkins and such. Our waitress was to busy taking care of another couple that came in after us! Apparently she knew them! Never checked on drinks food or extra napkins! Won't go back!

Source: Google

David Sumner

★ 5

Great food and great service

Source: Google

Mike Casper

★ 5

Very good and modest price

Source: Google

Justin Murray

★ 2

Source: Google

Chris Barutha

★ 4

Source: Google

Steven R Taft Jr

★ 4

Source: Google

Mary Grove

★ 3

Source: Google

Diane Mier

★ 5

Clean and friendly
Food EXCELLENT.
OverEasy eggs are to runny. But good.

Source: Google

Adam Paul

★ 4

Source: Google

Jim Dunham

★ 4

Source: Google

Christine Hypki-senzig

★ 4

We were shocked at many choices they offered on their menu and at reasonable prices. The food was good and quantity was fair . And we had a wonderful waitress.

Source: Google

Ann

★ 4

Good food and service

Source: Google

silverio narvaez

★ 5

Source: Google

Jane Waldoch

★ 1

Doesn't deserve one star the food was disgusting had meatloaf and gravy and potatoes the meatloaf was hard and dry ordered a Gyros sandwich picked it up and grease poured out of it, Still paid $33 for 3 drinks a lasagna dinner A salad and a cup of soup. Thought I was going to a nice family restaurant.

Source: Google

Chef Robert Klemm

★ 5

Source: Google

Teresa Klockow

★ 4

Source: Google

Dawn Finger

★ 5

Food always good.

Source: Google

Gina Mackowiak

★ 4

Source: Google

Mindy Konkel

★ 3

Food was good, liked our waitress.
Fat comments and joke, not good. Host kept pointing out one of my party members and how he tried to get us a table when he "saw him coming." He ended our trip with saying he felt bad for the dog since we didn't take a doggie bag for this person's meal. (Mind you we had 2 full contrainers of food we didn't eat). It's funny once but not really.

Source: Google

Brittney

★ 4

Service was good. Got our food on time and warm! Nothing super special about the food but it still tasted good.
Would go here again especially bc it’s family owned and the waitress have worked there for a long time!

Source: Google

Jim Cesarz

★ 4

Source: Google

Eugene Wachowiak

★ 5

Source: Google

Tammy Walczak

★ 5

Wonderful service & a huge menu full of great food- will definitely be going back for more!!

Source: Google

Lisa S

★ 5

Source: Google

noelsgdaddyr

★ 4

One of Oak Creeks diamonds in the rough, everyone was very pleasant, the owner is there and brings good conversations before you get your meal

Source: Google

Jade Lovelien

★ 3

1/17/23
My grandmother and I came for breakfast around 9am on a Tuesday morning. Was pretty slow, and the food came out pretty quick. The food was pretty good. Our waitress didn't check on us after the fact and I had to go up to the front to request to go containers.

•French Toast w/ Strawberry & Banana
•Pancakes w/ Honey & Banana

Source: Google

Dale Check

★ 2

The silverware was dirty, (and was replaced) the coffee creamer had chunks of curds in it, the restaurant itself was somewhat run-down, and didn't have much atmosphere.

The food was just okay, the portions were slightly generous, but the prices were very high for the quality of the food provided.

The waitress was modestly polite, but generally inattentive. By the the end of the meal I simply walked to the server station to get my own to to boxes as I couldn't find an employee for several minutes, and they never asked when they gave us the bill.

This restaurant was terrible with the previous ownership, and it looks like this ownership hasn't improved on much. The quality of the food has improved, but is only comparable to a George Webs at best. This is the worst sit down restaurant I have been to in a long time.

Source: Google

Margaret Coonan

★ 5

Fast service, huge selection of entrees

Source: Google

Tanya Sidello

★ 5

Cute Diner

Source: Google

Alan Radke (ARad)

★ 5

Great food and service

Source: Google

Elijah Rhines

★ 4

Source: Google

alan grabow (ALnG Culinary)

★ 5

Love this place, we go at least 3 visits a month!

Source: Google

Aimee Jahns

★ 5

Source: Google

Angel Diaz

★ 5

Source: Google

adoramann

★ 4

A decade since I have been here, when it was Marhet place.
Service was great, Jenny is the best!

Source: Google