Olive's Pizza and Sandwiches

Green Bay, 516 Greene Ave, Green Bay, WI 54301, United States | ★ 4.7 (234 Review)

📞 +1 920-492-0732

Last Search

Category

Pizza restaurant Restaurant Sandwich shop

Description

Whether you’d prefer to keep it simple with a traditional pepperoni or be adventurous and try our balsamic chicken and arugula pizza, everyone will find something they love. Our pizzas are cooked in a stone deck oven, making them perfectly crispy on the bottom yet still soft and chewy. What pairs better with pizzas than subs and sandwiches? We start with freshly baked bread and pile on meat, cheese, and veggies. Plenty of variety to keep the whole family happy!

Photos

 Olive's Pizza and Sandwiches
 Olive's Pizza and Sandwiches
 Olive's Pizza and Sandwiches
 Olive's Pizza and Sandwiches
 Olive's Pizza and Sandwiches
 Olive's Pizza and Sandwiches
 Olive's Pizza and Sandwiches
 Olive's Pizza and Sandwiches
 Olive's Pizza and Sandwiches

Leave a Review

Reviews

Felicia Souza (Vienola)

★ 5

Great Pizza. They had an option for a cauliflower crust, which is hard to find. The crust wasn’t gross like some can be. Atmosphere was very relaxed and wasn’t loud.

Source: Google

Debra Dancker

★ 5

My friend Julie & I especially enjoyed the Olive's Salad - so fresh and delicious. The staff is friendly and attentive. They came to our table to see if we liked the food, or needed more to drink, twice while we were there for lunch.

Source: Google

Jay Milkowski

★ 5

This place ROCKS! Carried out pizza and Olives Special garlic bread tonight. Compliments to counter gals and Chef!!

Source: Google

Edgar Guzmán

★ 5

The food was great and the service was quick! Had the chicken Tilly with some curly fries and the sandwich was fantastic, me and my friend will def be stopping by again.

Source: Google

Michael McDermot

★ 5

Probably one of the best pizzas I've had in a long time!

Source: Google

Abraham Lopez Artero

★ 5

Source: Google

Jean Assenzo

★ 5

We love Olives.
The owner and staff are always friendly and helpful.
The food is awesome. Our favorites are the spinach artichoke dip and Ollie's pizza. But we like everything else we've had there.

Source: Google

Chad Hedtke

★ 5

The mozzarella sticks were truly magical! I think they made me levitate a little! The gluten free
pizza was also supercalifragilisticexpialidocious!

Source: Google

Andrew Fifield

★ 5

Source: Google

Jason vanegeren

★ 5

Source: Google

Jessica Mouford

★ 5

Source: Google

David Farley

★ 5

Excellent experience for our family

Source: Google

Laura S

★ 5

This was a great find! Very spacious nice atmosphere. Staff was amazing food was 10/10

Source: Google

Tanner Schultz

★ 5

Source: Google

1 2

★ 5

Source: Google

Matthew Kaster

★ 5

Great sandwiches. Fresh ingredients. Much better than a chain restaurant. Friendly service and the prices aren't too bad. Glad they're in Allouez.

Source: Google

Steve Schilz

★ 5

Great food and bread!

Source: Google

Monica S

★ 5

Clean and convenient place for pizza or sandwiches. Our 1st time here. Everything was hot and good. Cheese curds delicious. Salad could've had the spring greens cut a little smaller for easier eating. Hand tossed extra pepperoni, extra cheese was delicious.

Source: Google

Kay Walder

★ 5

Food was excellent. Service was great.

Source: Google

Jaramey Plager

★ 5

Polite and helpful staff. Good sandwich and pizza options. Good quality food with moderate portions. To my liking

Source: Google

Richard Parma

★ 5

Source: Google

Russ Schisel

★ 5

Delicious!

Source: Google

Courtney J

★ 5

What a gem! Have never been here before. Came after softball; the Tilly sub was amazing! Will be back.

Source: Google

Red Vanrite

★ 5

Source: Google

Jessica H

★ 5

The food is made fresh to order, and everything I tasted was excellent. The fried ravioli is stuffed with creamy goodness, and the marinara sauce was on point! The flatbread pizza was crispy, full of flavor, and had fresh ingredients. I also enjoyed a bloody mary from their alcohol menu. I highly recommend it, and I will be returning for more!

Source: Google

Amara Wheelock

★ 5

Food and service was absolutely amazing!!! You have to try the Ryder jalapeño popper pizza.

Source: Google

Will Weerts

★ 5

Source: Google

Andrea H

★ 5

Found this place because we were looking for a somewhere close by with subs after football practice at Webster Park. The subs were really good! We ordered a tuna, chicken bacon ranch, and club subs. I would highly recommend and will definitely return 👌

Source: Google

Patti Schisel

★ 5

The pizza was great! I liked the crust was thick and not soggy. The owner was wonderful. Overall a great dinner. Will be back soon!

Source: Google

Kirsten Price

★ 5

The food and service is excellent! Everything is made carefully and the restaurant interior is immaculate. Highly recommend!

Source: Google

amber hendricks

★ 5

Source: Google

Steve Maccoux

★ 5

Source: Google

Jeanne G

★ 5

Source: Google

Scott kupsky

★ 4

Their hand tossed is maybe the best crust in Green Bay. Staff is super friendly and attentive. We live across town but this is still one of our top spots when we go out. The Italian Sub is top notch as well.

Source: Google

Brenda Brisinte

★ 5

Source: Google

Chelsea Johnson

★ 5

Incredible food, great staff, I cannot wait to visit again! Hidden away but should be well known because of how wonderful it is!

Source: Google

Thepowers Thatbe

★ 5

Stopped in fairly late. Everything was good. Friendly and quick. Reasonably priced. Beer battered cheese cubes were good, don't see those everywhere. Like cheese curds with a fluffy airy beer batter coating. I got a simple turkey and provolone toasted sub, my brother had a meatball sub. Both were very good. I personally like the crusty toasty roll. Saw some pizzas coming out of the oven, they looked delicious. Will return.

Source: Google

Laura Rossner

★ 5

Amazing food, very friendly service, and what a great menu!!! Can’t wait to go back and try everything on the menu over several visits. 🤤

Source: Google

Frank Schmechel

★ 5

Source: Google

Alexandria Kreie

★ 5

Source: Google

John Kruse

★ 5

Fantastic sub sandwiches and superb customer service! Plus fun wine list and excellent cocktails

Source: Google

Mary

★ 5

Everything about Olives is wonderful! Great pizza, subs, salads, appetizers, and loved the ravioli, cornbread, and cheese cube appetizers. After many visits it never disappoints. The younger counter workers and cooks are very friendly and helpful. Definitely recommend.

Source: Google

Andrew Pietzner

★ 4

Pizza sauce is a bit bland. Toppings are generous.

Source: Google

Josh F

★ 5

Fantastic pizza and sub shop. I highly recommend it. Super friendly staff too!

Source: Google

Benjamin Fredericksen

★ 2

The service was fine, but the food left much to be desired. The pizza was slightly burnt on the outside and undercooked on the inside. Additionally, the churros we ordered were extremely hard and flavorless, more like eating a cracker. The atmosphere also felt like a work breakroom.

Source: Google

Zach

★ 3

Had a franks sandwich twas good friend had pizza a little over and under cooked and rock hard curious

Stick with cold items they seem to have a tendency to run the heat higher to ensure speedy service

Source: Google

B K

★ 5

BEST PIZZA IN GREENBAY> HANDS DOWN!!

Source: Google

MissMarvelous_1

★ 5

Pizza was amazing, cheesy bread amazing, staff beyond amazing. We will definitely come back next time we visit!

Source: Google

Tony Coppo

★ 5

Source: Google

Josh Quivey

★ 5

Absolutely wonderful!! The workers were nice and attentive, the food was delicious!! The whole restaurant was so nice and organized and very clean. Would definitely eat here again

Source: Google

Greg

★ 5

Bravo! Well done. Olives is a wonderful little hidden gem. Great sandwiches, fresh baked bread, and wonderful pizza. This was my first time here - and I’m a little disappointed I don’t live closer. Stop here - you won’t regret it

Source: Google

Kimberly T

★ 2

Source: Google

Meghan Keyes

★ 5

I’ve had Olive’s twice now and every visit has not disappointed! I had a build your own flatbread on my first visit and a pizza sub on my second visit + a side salad. Super tasty + very fresh ingredients + excellent, fast service. Highly recommend!!

Source: Google

Josh Bennett

★ 5

Source: Google

Peter Sandoval

★ 5

Must try great place to grab a bite and drink.

Source: Google

Stephanie Schmitt

★ 5

The best hidden pizza/sandwich place in the city! We have eaten here numerous times. Dine in and carry out. Always fantastic service, prompt, accommodating, friendly. Everything tastes amazing. Hands down THE best pizza!!! If you haven’t tried Olive’s you have been missing out.

Source: Google

Stevie

★ 4

Source: Google

Paul K

★ 5

Ordered for delivery. Hot and fresh sandwich. Hit the spot.

Source: Google

Jim Warden

★ 5

Great pizza & sandwiches

Source: Google

Tanya

★ 5

Source: Google

Kaytie Myers

★ 1

The pizza was awful and both times I ordered it arrived an hour to 1.5 hours later than expected! The cheesecake was amazing but it's not an in house thing. It's through a local bakery that I will definitely be checking out. This place overall was an expensive disappointment.

Source: Google

Suzanne Blumberg

★ 5

Source: Google

Nathan Bergman

★ 5

We picked this place at random, and we were absolutely overjoyed.. When you first walk in you are met with wonderful food smells, and the staff was incredibly polite.. we ordered appetizers and pizza and the food was perfect.. The pizza dough had a touch of saltiness, the toppings were plentiful and it was cooked to perfection.. I would absolutely recommend this place..

Source: Google

Steven Siudzinski

★ 5

Very nice restaurant nice decor and great service. Food is very tasty.

Source: Google

Janna Fameree

★ 5

Went to Olives for dinner tonight and I am in love with this place. The atmosphere, food, and service were all great! I will be back.

Source: Google

Erin F.

★ 5

Source: Google

Jamie Gavin

★ 5

The best bread and food and food the best around. And I vote the best in greenbay

Source: Google

Chris Sigler

★ 5

Source: Google

Kristin Nelson

★ 2

Pizza and appetizers were very good, but the service was not, specifically from the owner. We came for a painting night. As we walked in, no one gave us directions about where to go or what to do. We just gathered awkwardly in the painting area. Some of us went to the Olive's counter to order. Carrie, the owner, was impatient as we looked at the menu. Instead of welcoming us and asking if we'd been there before, she was bothered by the fact that it was taking us a minute to decide what to order. As we were painting, she came out and asked if we wanted more to drink. My friend asked for water. Fifteen minutes later, Carrie brought the water. I said, "There's your water!" to my friend. Carrie told us we could have come to the counter if we wanted water. I jokingly said we were busy painting. She said, "We're busy too. It's almost like it's a restaurant or something." Just plain rude. If you don't want to bring water, simply tell us and we'll go get it ourselves. At the end of the night, a staff member was ready to take a picture of us, but one of our group was in the bathroom and Carrie passive aggressively told her worker that he needed to do his work and not wait for us. The food was excellent, but I won't give this place my business again.

Source: Google

Jason Davies

★ 5

Stopped by for lunch as I have been curious about Olive’s. Totally worth trying out and the food was great. A bonus is that they have a “what to expect” at the door for us introverted-types that don’t like to feel awkward. Totally made the experience better! The turkey sub was amazing and I for certain will return.

Source: Google

Mary Ann Hoffman

★ 5

Had an errand to run in GB, which ended up taking us into supper time. I wanted pizza & being from the Appleton area, I decided to search for pizza places as I wanted to try something different. It was also 7 pm, and some of the other places were closing in 1 hour, and we didn't want to be rushed. Olive's was open until 9, and based upon other Google reviews, we decided to give it a try. Totally unexpected location, but we're glad we chose it. Ordered mozzarella sticks, which were very good and came out quick. We ordered the deluxe thin crust pizza (my husband is boring and doesn't like to try different things, so basic combo pizza it was lol) it was a great choice though. Crust was baked perfectly, and the right amount of toppings, no skimping! Very friendly upon entering and excellent service! Good wine selection as well. Will definitely go again when in Green Bay and wanting pizza.

Source: Google

Hannah Cook

★ 5

Source: Google

Casey Diedrick

★ 5

Awesome bread, sandwich and pizza!

Source: Google

Brenda Carpenter

★ 5

Source: Google

Kim McLaughlin

★ 4

Source: Google

Heather McCracken

★ 5

10 out of 10 would highly recommend!!! Ollie pizza is our fav!!

Source: Google

Kayla McElrone

★ 5

Everything about Olive's is wonderful! Great food, great service, the owner is incredible!! And try the churros!

Source: Google

Eric Martinez

★ 5

Source: Google

Adriana A

★ 5

Source: Google

Patricia Ugaz-Wichman

★ 5

The food we ordered was great 👍🏻 I recommend it.

Source: Google

Ren

★ 5

Cheesy bread sticks and pizza were awesome. Will be back!

Source: Google

Cameron Wunut

★ 2

Idk how such a promising looking pizza could taste so flavorless, when the pizza came to the table it looked great but a few bites in I realized I genuinely couldn't taste anything. It's got no salt, no seasoning, and half of the veggies were uncooked somehow. Payed up front for the pizzas, but on the way out I was asked in a sorta mean tone if I had paid for my food... bbbyyyy the person who did the transaction in the first place 🤔
Idk, maybe it was a bad day at the ol' pizza shack, but yeah I probably wont be getting giddy if someone suggests it next time

Source: Google

Jenny Knutson

★ 5

The cutest little place with delicious sandwiches and a clean, modern atmosphere

Source: Google

Randy Sincoular

★ 5

Great local pizza joint. Friendly owner with super tasty pizza on a thin crust. Tried one deluxe and one sausage mushroom. Both were excellent. They bake their own sub buns, so we will try one next time.

Source: Google

Elissa Gaetzke

★ 5

Source: Google

Tyler A

★ 4

Highly recommend, food is very good haven't had any complaints.

Source: Google

Kaddy Ro

★ 5

Super cute diner set up, amazing pizza and Tilly sandwich! Very nice kids running the show, lived our evening.

Source: Google

Genuine Review

★ 5

Just flew into GB 2/13 and was looking for a good place for flat bread pizza. Read the reviews and was not disappointed!! Very clean, nice atmosphere. A gem in a little plaza.

Source: Google

Dave Sumwalt

★ 5

Food and service were outstanding! Just a great little sandwich and pizza joint.

Source: Google

Steve Lapacz

★ 5

Very Good Pizza and the people working there were very friendly. Loved it all. We will be back.

Source: Google

Jen

★ 3

Spent a few days in Green Bay and had this delivered to our hotel. We got a pizza with pepperoni, bacon, and mushrooms plus the cheese bread. The pizza was on the thicker side for hand tossed and was quite good except the crust was burnt. The cheese bread was also over cooked but very disappointing - bland and dry. You'd expect garlic butter or something with flavor on them but we ate one each and threw them away. Our food total (not including tax, delivery fee, or tip) was $31 ($43.21 after all of that) and was definitely not worth it. I would try the pizza again if it wasn't burnt.

Source: Google

Kallista Baebler

★ 5

Wow! I got the Ollie Pizza and Cheesy Breadsticks and was blown away. The crust was so good. The perfect amount of fluffiness to make you say, one more slice couldn’t hurt. And the toppings made the Ollie Pizza the perfect savory treat. The whole menu sounds great and I can’t wait to keep going back.

Source: Google

Sarah F

★ 5

I’m so glad I gave this place a try. I now order carry out from here once a week, at least. Their food tastes excellent and is healthier than many options in the area. Get the thin crust pizza or fish sandwich!! 10/10.

Source: Google

Brooke Barfield

★ 4

I got Chicky's sandwich. It was pretty good. The service wasn't that great, just not very friendly at the counter when I went. It's close to my new job so I tried it. Not sure about going back.

Source: Google

Alysha Vassallo

★ 5

Source: Google

Tim Salzman

★ 4

Pizza was excellent unfortunately the meatball sub only had 3 meatballs and could have used a few more to fill the sandwich better to get a meatball in every bite. Not a complaint but just a suggestion.

Source: Google

Filipe Borges

★ 5

Source: Google

Molly

★ 5

Love their sandwiches the Italian is dynamite and our favorite we always order. Pizzas are great and have had nothing but good food consistently delivered or in house

Source: Google

Melissa H

★ 4

The spinach artichoke dip is addicting. The flat bread pizza is tasty n toasty. The Wisconsin Za w cheeses curds sounds cheesy but is also VERY tasty. The boys in our party that normally want traditional only pizza have placed the Wisconsin pizza at Olives at top of their must eat list! Eat at olives cute cozy restaurant you won't be sorry!

12-17-23
SOOOOOOO DISAPPOINTED
This is what 50$ bought us tonight.

After an hour wait for delivery I called. I was calling after the pick up time.
My bad. I had accidentally clicked on pick up.
An employee told me they would remake them. They did not. These are cold. nasty n disgusting. These obviously sat for over an hour.

When we arrived to pick up pizza an employee was arguing w a different customer about an order.
With raised voices on the employees part.

It was an hour before closing time when we picked up....it was apparent that employees were just trying to get er done so they could close. Late customers were an inconvenience.

Olives You may want to check on your closing employees.

Source: Google

Matt A

★ 5

Really good food, very friendly folks!

Source: Google

Ashley Beyer

★ 5

Do yourself a favor and check out Olive’s! I’m so glad we discovered this gem in our neighborhood. We’ve gotten takeout probably a dozen times over the past six months or so, and we’ve never been disappointed. The staff is always friendly and welcoming, and you can tell they really care about the restaurant and food they’re preparing. Pizza is phenomenal, but I usually go with a sandwich. The bread is just so melt-in-your-mouth delicious. They also have a little bar with wine, beer, and specialty cocktails.

Source: Google

Liz Doro

★ 2

I hate to have to leave a bad review for a new and small business, but at the same time I think it’s important feedback. We ordered a half and half pizza. Half Wisconsin pizza and half sausage and pepperoni. Well the most expensive side( the Wisconsin) we barely even got to eat because two of the four slices were bubbled with no toppings . It was just bubbled and burnt with nothing on it.

Source: Google

Barbara menne

★ 5

Last night was our first time ordering from Olive's. We ordered a pizza and a couple sandwiches. It was awesome. We will most definitely be repeat customers. It is expensive to eat anywhere these days and it was really nice to have it be absolutely worth it last night!

Source: Google

Amanda Jagodinski

★ 5

Service was fantastic. Pizza was delicious. Will definitely be back!

Source: Google

Sydney W

★ 5

Source: Google

G Roberts

★ 3

Solid OK pizza and breadsticks. Service on the day I went was not good. I ordered carry out and was told my food wasn't ready and it was actually sitting under the counter. I asked again 20 minutes later, and tada they pulled it out.

Source: Google

Jackson Schultz-Tilot

★ 5

When I walked in I was surprised on how nice it looked, the service was amazing, and the food was good, so I will rate this place a five star.

Source: Google

Carolyn McCarthy (Seven)

★ 5

This little gem gave me the best hoagie I've ever had! They went above and beyond and gave us really great service. When they asked if I wanted their loyalty program, and I said that we lived in Milwaukee and wouldn't be back anytime soon... but as I left, I asked for it again just so I could plan my return. So so so good. Highly recommend.

Source: Google

Kathleen Weber

★ 5

Source: Google

Melissa T

★ 5

Truly love this place. Great addition to Green Bay’s restaurants. The bread was amazing and its nice to go somewhere that has veggie options that are full of flavor. Its a cute little place, and everyone was super nice. The employees are proud of the menu, and what they’ve built, and it shows. Try the garlic cheese bread!

Source: Google

Rob Allen

★ 5

What a great find. Owner was super friendly and the food was tasty. For the prices, I can't see going to any "fast food" joint when for under twenty you can get two sandwiches there. Do yourself a favor and hit this place when you're in the mood for same good eats.

Source: Google

Trish Konop

★ 5

Source: Google

K Ducat

★ 5

Last minute hunt for. A pizza place to accomodate 16 people on a Sunday night resulted in an amazing experience. We made. The reservation Saturday night. When we arrived about 4:00, about 30 minutes ahead of our entire group, our table was nicely arranged, ordering the pizza was easy with staff suggestions, the pizzas were ready for our guests by 4:30. Cole explained each pizza when he brought them to our table, and was always there to assist with getting more pizza and drinks. He was super attentive.

Source: Google

Sue Gerlach

★ 4

Cute place that has great food at a decent price. Some wines there too. Neat art area as well. Got to try it out if you haven't done so.

Source: Google

Isreal Hill

★ 5

Great everything love the food

Source: Google

Jocelyn Hawtrey

★ 5

This place is very cute inside. We were surprised to see a bar. Very fun touch. The service was great. Super friendly. Just not very fast. But they work hard, so just make sure you aren’t expecting a fast in/out sub shop. Nice place to bring the family. There’s plenty of seating inside.

Source: Google

Mary Gillespie

★ 5

Enjoyed two delicious hand tossed pizzas with our kids and two small children. No one was put off by the toddlers, and we all enjoyed our conversations and food.

Source: Google

J W

★ 2

Ordered for take out, when I came to pick up sandwiches I confirmed they should both be toasted. When I received them, they were not hot but top was slightly warm but definitely not toasted. One sub was supposed to have no onions and there were lots of onions on it, small diced and too many to pick off. Called to see what they could do and was told “sorry but my supervisor said there is nothing we can do and next time ask for extra toasty”. Not worth $20 or the drive to pick them up!

Source: Google

isreal hill

★ 5

Just wanted to say there food is amazing workers are amazing I highly recommend there food there tilly sub really good and there pizza best in town
Hands down thank you for the service and food.

Source: Google

Lauren Prost

★ 5

Loved my pizza, I have been wanting to try olive’s for a while and it was great!

Source: Google

Grace Hess

★ 3

Nothing to write home about

Source: Google

Clair Rudolph

★ 5

Nice Clean Place, Friendly Staff, & delicious pizza!

Source: Google

Kevin O'Hair

★ 5

Source: Google

Andrew Robbins

★ 5

Absolutely awesome pizza!

Source: Google

David Riebe II

★ 5

Source: Google

Mathew Lehmann

★ 5

Awesome pizza and subs!! highly recommend!

Source: Google

S Korny

★ 5

Love this place! The owner has the kindest heart and truly is wonderful! The food is amazing here! You can’t go wrong!

Source: Google

Steve Ness

★ 5

Excellent service. Such a nice and relaxing place to catch a late afternoon pizza! Love the look and feel of the place. Fits in well with your neighbors. Will definitely be back.

Source: Google

Tim McGue

★ 5

Great pizza with superb crust. Got great service while here. Mac and cheese pizza was a win!

Source: Google

Leslie De Bauche

★ 3

Food is ok, service was good, atmosphere is ok. Nice enough place.

Source: Google

Adam Lupa

★ 5

Service was friendly and fast, sandwiches were awesome, had the Tilly, loved it@

Source: Google

Shea

★ 4

A hideaway with very good subs and pizza.

Source: Google

Darek Whiting

★ 5

Our daughter recommended this place and she was right the food is excellent and with great service. They have a very nice selection of specialty pizzas also a nice beer and wine selection we did not try the sandwiches but will definitely be back to give it a try.

Source: Google

Lloyd Zepka

★ 5

Clean restaurant and tables. Staff was super friendly. Food was delicious

Source: Google

Liz Krumwiede

★ 5

Source: Google

Theodore Malvitz

★ 2

We had a pizza card for a free one topping large pizza so we asked to pay for some additional toppings. The rude response was that is not how it works and no you cannot add toppings. So I guess you don't want to upsell. Sat down the place is very clean. Not very busy. It only took 20 minutes for the cheese and sausage pizza. Pizza was okay, but I have had better frozen pizza for less. The Miller Lite beer was expired by 27 days. When we told them, they said it is probably a born on date. No sorry Miller Lite has an expiration date. Never again. We will not be back!

Source: Google

J AA

★ 1

I called at 12:30pm on May 18, 2023 to ask about a pizza delivery for a large group. The lady responded “you do understand I’m in the middle of a lunch rush now, right? I don’t have time to talk to you about your group”. That was beyond rude and she set the tone for mt first impression of this place. I’ll be taking my business elsewhere.

Source: Google

Angie Peters

★ 5

Source: Google

Stephen Borley

★ 5

Source: Google

N W

★ 5

Got the Chicky’s sandwich and added chicken. It was one of the best sandwiches I’ve had!

Source: Google

Donna Schuld

★ 5

We just tried Olive's tonight and thought it was excellent. I had the "Tilly" sandwich and I thought it was delicious. A hint of spice and very good ingredients. Service was great. Can't wait to try the pizza.

Source: Google

Nathaniel Fredricks

★ 5

Amazing food and service.

Source: Google

Blaise &Jean

★ 5

Source: Google

Sheri Ward

★ 5

Source: Google

Jeremy Foust

★ 5

Steak sandwich, curly fries and curds. A meal to cure all that ails. Delicious.

Source: Google

adam Johnson

★ 5

Source: Google

Carol Pamperin

★ 5

Source: Google

Ron Jonet

★ 4

Pizza was just ok, the sauce is more like tomato sauce than pizza sauce. The restaurant was nice and the specialty sandwiches are very good.

Source: Google

Ben Gunderson

★ 5

DO NOT ORDER DELIVERY!
$40 for a medium thin crust.

Get sandwiches and dine in or pickup.

Source: Google

Tim and Brenda Stanton

★ 4

Source: Google

Mary Capelle

★ 5

Really good pizzas and the sandwiches and Flatbread pizzas look really good too. You can get wine and beer as well and they have a small area to have a glass of wine too. Wonderful service and welcoming atmosphere. Prices fair. This is my new go to pizza place and will be going back to try the sandwiches. Highly recommend.

Source: Google

Lauren Kiefer

★ 5

Source: Google

Eileen Johnson

★ 5

Love the fresh decor and friendly staff. Menu has a nice variety and everything is beautifully served and delicious.

Source: Google

Emily Smet

★ 5

My boyfriend introduced me to this place 8 months ago and I’ve been a regular ever since! Prices are fair, food is stellar, employees are sociable and the atmosphere is welcoming without looking like it’s your grandmas shop. My go to sandwich costs $9, which is LESS than my go to at subway. It’s a no brainer!!! Have yet to try something we didn’t like, 10/10

Source: Google

B stan

★ 5

Source: Google

Alex Young

★ 5

Always a great stop and having gluten free options as well is wonderful!

Source: Google

Josh Rouse

★ 5

Great pizza! We will definitely be back! Wife loved her sandwich too!

Source: Google

Nonnie Martin

★ 5

I’ve had there pizza and sandwiches
Very good food
Cute little spot

Source: Google

Jewels

★ 5

Good food, handmade cocktails, and great fun painting

Source: Google

Jake

★ 5

Source: Google

Kate Bodart

★ 5

This has quickly become our favorite pizza place! Great pizzas

Source: Google

Anna Ergish

★ 5

This cute little sub and pizza shop is such a hidden jem! The first time I walked in they were pulling the sub buns right out of the oven! It's delicious and fresh and I haven't had a single thing off the menu that I haven't liked!

Source: Google

Birdman1506

★ 5

Really enjoyed this pizza. It was cooked perfectly, the hand tossed crust was airy and chewy. Highly recommend

Source: Google

Josh

★ 5

Source: Google

Vicki Jobling

★ 5

Stopped here for sandwiches while passing through town. Delicious sandwiches, exceeded our expectations. Would definitely come here again to try the pizza!

Source: Google

PressStart Arcade

★ 5

Source: Google

nastassia tappa

★ 5

We absolutely love the pizza!! The quality is fantastic and it is nice fast service

Source: Google

Emily Stewart

★ 5

I had one of the best sandwiches of my life here. A great choice for a meal! It was also a very pleasant environment - clean and comfortable.

Source: Google

Tyler Cameron

★ 5

Over the last decade, I believe I’ve tried all pizza in the Green Bay area. Olives may have just taken the crown. We’ve tried the hand tossed and the thin, and both were cooked to perfection and absolutely delicious. If you haven’t tried Olive’s yet, do it!

Source: Google

Sydney

★ 5

Tried olives for the first time and wow, fantastic!

We ordered a pizza and had a couple beers. Drink prices are unbeatable and the pizza was amazing. Hand tossed crust, delicious sauce and made with such care. Super fast service. The staff were over the top friendly and attentive.

Will be back soon to try the sandwiches!

Source: Google

Ashley M

★ 5

Nice new place! Great service, the food came out fast and was delicious. We’ll be back!

Source: Google

Sandy H

★ 5

Source: Google

Tamra Koehler

★ 5

Just happened upon this place and I'm so glad I did! We had pizzas and flatbread and they were delicious. The sauce is just right. They serve a nice selection of subs and sandwiches as well that I'm eager to try

Source: Google

Mark Elsenheimer

★ 5

Every time we go, we love it. We really should go more often to support a local, woman-owned and operated business! Fresh food from a wide selection, made to order with love. Sandwiches, wraps, pizza, appetizers, and spiked coffee. Yum!

Source: Google

Sky Scanner

★ 5

It was so so soooo goood! The staff are also very nice.

Source: Google

Zendeeno

★ 5

Eaten here a few times now.
Great tasty food! Subs are what I mostly got, but they have pizzas and such.

Source: Google

Ross Van Enkevort

★ 5

So we found olive based on looking for sub shops on google. Decided we would go and try it and all I have to say is WOW! The fiancé and I both order the Tilly sandwich (pictured with review) and it’s flavor is amazing! Similar to a cheesesteak but she adds a few other things to make it stand out. She is gluten friendly with pizzas and sandwich wraps which is awesome for some in our family. I would highly recommend trying out the subs. If anything the owner definitely made us feel welcomed and definitely made the experience!

Source: Google

William Fishman

★ 5

Top notch!!! First off the Sandwiches were absolutely amazing you can tell they bake fresh!!!! The pizza was fantastic we got the cheesesteak pizza and can’t wait to go back and try others!!!

Source: Google

Carrie Frank

★ 5

Great place for lunch with a little something for everyone. We have a classic Italian sub, Olive’s Bread and the Olive Flatbread. Everything was super fresh and tasted delicious.

Source: Google

Sam Neeley

★ 4

Great place for pizza's and sub's!

Source: Google

Stacy Shephard

★ 5

Amazing food and drinks. Fun place to hang out with foodies and music on Wednesday nights!!

Source: Google

Seth Reed

★ 5

Source: Google

U.S.S. Wisconsin

★ 5

Source: Google

Tanner Budz

★ 5

I absolutely love this place. The food is amazing, and staff is extremely friendly! Favorite place in town

Source: Google

Tyler Alberts

★ 5

Source: Google

Kalee

★ 5

The owner is fabulous and the pizza was superb! We had the deluxe and CBR, both amazing! The cheesy breadsticks are so yummy! Will be going back!

Source: Google

Michael LaCrosse

★ 5

Inside is tastefully decorated. Staff very pleasant. Our pizza was very good.

Source: Google

Dawn Ambrosius

★ 5

Such a cute little place with good food and good friendly service. The Tuna sandwich was so good the first time I had it, I needed another 3 days later. Do check out this sweet place.

Source: Google

scott laplante

★ 4

Great sandwich and pizza place. Has a small bar with drinks.

Source: Google

Keith Leiterman

★ 4

Fried ravioli as a the appetizer was really good with the excellent marinara sauce.
We had the chicken bacon ranch Pizza with the garlic parm sauce 😋

Source: Google

Wendi Dejardin

★ 5

Very good food! The service was great and everyone was very friendly. The Flatbread and sandwiches we had were all very tasty. Would recommend to anyone looking to try to try a new pizza/sandwich shop.

Source: Google

Kristin

★ 5

A work group of us ordered from Olives yesterday. We were all impressed!! So so good. Some got sandwiches and others flatbreads. Everything was fresh and delicious. I got the PPP flatbread which is pepperoni, pineapple, and jalapeño. Wow, so yummy. The flatbreads are thin and crispy and the toppings fresh and flavorful. I also had stopped in a few weeks prior and got a spinach and artichoke sandwich. Basically spinach and artichoke dip as a grilled cheese. Insanely good. The staff working are super nice and friendly. Will definitely be back!!

Source: Google

John Dierberg

★ 5

Tons of options, enjoyed my sub! will go back to give the pizza a shot!

Source: Google

Bob Kapla

★ 5

Great pizza (and flatbread if you're looking for a smaller portion)! Wide variety of craft beer as well. A neighborhood jewel worth your time! :-)

Source: Google

Josh Friberg

★ 5

The BLTA is great. I highly recommend the gluten free pizza crust as well.

Source: Google

Karl Kilian

★ 5

Excellent pizza and friendly staff. I'll have to try their sandwiches next time.

Source: Google

Reese Van Pay

★ 5

Source: Google

Shaun Photo

★ 5

Warning: Eating at Olive's Pizza and Sandwiches is addicting. From the zesty sauce on the pizza to the mouth watering ingredients in their flavorful sandwiches, Olive's knows the way to your heart is through your stomach. Try the Tilly!

Source: Google

ben steel

★ 5

Source: Google

Karla LeClair

★ 5

Kudos to the staff extremely helpful
& nice.
Food very good.
Restaurant clean & tidy.

Source: Google