Category
RestaurantDescription
Come join Paulie and the team for Breakfast, Lunch, or Dinner. Paulie has been in the food industry for 24+ years and wants nothing more than to make you smile with a meal you'd come back for again and again! It's about time Pittsville got the "Homemade Connection" it deserves. Welcome home!
Photos
Leave a Review
Reviews
Michelle Hanson
★ 5
Friendly atmosphere!
Source: Google
Christina Schunke
★ 5
Our family just had the most amazing breakfast here! Everything was flavorful and delicious!!! The portions are very generous also, almost enough for two meals in one, and the pricing was still super reasonable! Our waitress was super friendly, and carried such positive energy that was enjoyable to be around. The atmosphere was small-town, and carried a family like feel; with local hunters, elderly and friendly conversations warming the room.
Source: Google
Gary
★ 5
Home cooking, great service
Source: Google
Jeannie D
★ 5
We had amazing omelette’s and other breakfast items here and the homemade bread was so good. I is a small restaurant but we got a table right away. Pleasant service and our family of 7 left very happy!
Source: Google
Cece Kski
★ 5
Source: Google
Ashley R.
★ 5
Source: Google
Terrie Brown
★ 5
Dilly burger was awesome!!!
Source: Google
Charles Anderson
★ 5
Local restaurant in Pittsville, WI. Go there for fish fry on Friday nights. Other good food there also.
Source: Google
Jim
★ 5
Food is good service was quick, and price was decent
Source: Google
Lacey Katherine
★ 5
There isn't enough words to describe how amazing it is here.
Source: Google
John Sorlie
★ 5
Source: Google
Tonya Kummer
★ 1
My mom and I stopped here at 10:30 am waited 10 min for menu, tried ordering lunch at 10:45 she strictly and rudely said you can't have lunch till after 12. She walked away. I got her attention to tell her we will go elsewhere due to wanting lunch. My mom and I come here often and I've got lunch at 10am. She said well u have to pay for sodas that we didn't even touch. 6.25 for 2 sodas. We are the 2 ladies that tip a 50.00 bill Everytime no matter the bill price because we always got warm welcoming employees. Sad to say we will now only go to Babcock Cafe to eat.
Source: Google
Steven Grillo
★ 5
Source: Google
Robert Groskinsky Sr.
★ 4
Very busy not enough wait staff and I never got a coffee refill but I had the fish fry and it was excellent when it came.
Source: Google
Kate Taylor
★ 5
Source: Google
Andrew Jadczak
★ 4
Solid breakfast. Lucky to be in town and go on a Sunday with all you can eat pancakes. I liked the regular ones over the potato ones which were more like huge hash brown patties over a latke style like I was expecting. Will be coming back for breakfast next time in the area.
Source: Google
David Capling
★ 5
Small town friendly. Great food, plenty of it, and reasonable prices. You won't leave hungry.
Source: Google
Scott Hopperdietzel
★ 5
Best corned beef hash, I have ever had. It has become my go to when I order here.
Great small town atmosphere, they use several local suppliers to provide great food.
Proud supporters of their community.
If you are looking for a great meal stop by Paulie's Diner.
Source: Google
Courtany Schwanebeck
★ 5
Source: Google
Sophie Rozar
★ 2
Usually when my boyfriend and I come here on our Friday’s, the service is wonderful! Tonight, on the other hand, was a different story. I did not even get the girls name because of how short she was with me. I felt very judged by her attitude, along with feeling disappointed by the lack of service she gave us. When I asked for lemons, she didn’t say anything and slid them on the table and walked away. I’ve had a few conversations with Paulie, and this was not the service I expected. Paulie is a wonderful guy, and so are most of the servers. Being that it was a Friday night was no excuse for the attitude, no “you’re welcome” “have a good night” or anything. When talking to his wife about the situation I heard a different girl yell “What’d they say?” followed by her response “I’ll tell you later”. Disappointing. I would love to know the girls name so I can include it in here…
Source: Google
Tony Kaminski
★ 4
Source: Google
Bernard Lager
★ 5
My wife ordered an omelet and I ordered the chicken fried steak with sausage gravy. The omelet was marvelous as the wife gave me bites and still had some to take home. The chicken fried steak was without a doubt a culinary award winning combination. I cleaned the plate short of licking it. If you ever get to Pittsville Paulie will leave you with a life long impression with his gravy.
Source: Google
Dan Konrardy
★ 5
Source: Google
Kathy Charlesworth
★ 5
This is a cute hometown restaurant run by husband and wife. Great service and good food. I had the lasagna special and my husband had the mushroom burger, both were excellent. We will be back
Source: Google
Jim Dakota
★ 5
It's a very layed back country restaurant. Excellent food and service and atmosphere. We always go there when we are camping at Dexter County campground.
Source: Google
Tom Bauer
★ 5
drove by there many times but couldn't pass it up today.!!...excellent service, mouth watering menu, clean, clean bathrooms..great atmosphere for relaxing while eating my meal..
Source: Google
Ben Yetter
★ 5
Source: Google
Jill Max
★ 5
Food and service were outstanding. Will be back.
Source: Google
Bobbie Doucette
★ 5
We were celebrating my dad's 2nd heavenly birthday and the food was wonderful and service is great! My son does chicken tender reviews and take a look!
https://youtu.be/ESg59jAgc-o?si=gP1k2kXvJFh4y45g
Thank you for making it a good day for us.
Source: Google
MJ Krey
★ 5
Source: Google
Albert Fredette
★ 5
Source: Google
Dawn Zaborowski
★ 5
I heard about their fluffy omelettes and had to try…so glad I did.
Source: Google
Cale Cumberland
★ 5
Great small town diner with good specials and the Ruben was delicious.
Source: Google
Rick Irwin
★ 1
Source: Google
Kim Becker
★ 5
Source: Google
Sam Schwanebeck
★ 5
Source: Google
Mark Stoflet
★ 5
Very clean and friendly service
Source: Google
Philip Mundt
★ 4
Formerly known as Laura's Corner Cafe. Friday Night fish options.
Source: Google
Louann Draeger
★ 3
Source: Google
Mike G
★ 5
Source: Google
John Brookhart
★ 5
Source: Google
ian heller
★ 5
Had the country skillet. Was absolutely amazing!!! Their sausage gravy is among the top 2 I have ever had. Just oder it you won't be disappointed.
Source: Google
Virgil Schwake
★ 4
Small town diner, decent selection of food.
Source: Google
Gloria Wegner
★ 1
Source: Google
Elsie Punke
★ 5
Source: Google
Diana Ludtke
★ 5
Source: Google
07emMaNueL28
★ 5
Source: Google
Angela Hughes
★ 4
Other than a really long wait, was very pleased.. Nice little diner. ;-)
Source: Google
David Hughes
★ 4
Food was excellent. Service was slow. Took almost a hour to get 2 sandwiches.
Source: Google
Ryan O
★ 5
Delightful!
Source: Google
John Keuffer
★ 5
Food and services are good. I would recommend this place to anyone that wants a good meal and down to earth people
Source: Google
Amanda Fischer
★ 1
Was just here. Waited an hour, didn't get our food yet. My husband had coffee, waitress never refilled after his initial cup, chunk of hair floating in my chocolate milk. Absolutely disgusted! We up and left because of the poor service! 2 waitresses standing around doing nothing.
Source: Google
Todd Hanson
★ 5
Stopped for Friday fish fry
Wasn't disappointed very good reasonable price. A true small town cafe with at home service.
Source: Google
deborah fifield
★ 1
Wow. Don't be fooled by all the good food you see in the pictures. They have none of it. What you see on the menu in reviews , is what they have! Husband and I went there for lunch yesterday and I ordered a patty melt. It was so greasy you could squeeze the grease out of it. Husband ordered a reuben and fries. The reuben was chopped up pieces mixed with kraut, the fries were frozen crinkle cuts, my pattymelt burger didn't cover the bread. They cut it in half and one half was ok the other half had a little strip of burger on it. Don't waste time going there!
Source: Google
Christopher Parker
★ 5
Had Lunch 2 days in a row here, food was great! Had a burger the first day, the sauce was incredible!! Had the Friday fish fry the next day, and wow the cook really knows what he’s doing!! Friendly and knowledgeable servers. Real chill small town vibe, definitely recommend to and locals or people passing through!!
Source: Google
Sally
★ 5
Met a friend there for lunch. Good food, pleasant staff, reasonable prices. Didn't push us to leave as we visited for quite awhile. Will definitely go there again.
Source: Google
David Lamoureux
★ 5
Very friendly diner. Good food.
Source: Google
Jessica Brucker
★ 5
Source: Google
Titus Miller
★ 5
Source: Google
Ethan Neuenschwander
★ 5
Source: Google
Wesley Halm
★ 5
I had the "Carnivore Skillet"! It was really good, a lot of meat on the plate! Just the right amount of salty and savory, would definitely have again!
Source: Google
Andy wuethrich
★ 5
Source: Google
Michaela Senoner
★ 5
Great
Source: Google
Peter Mussner
★ 5
Thanks all perfekt😀😀😀🇺🇲
Source: Google
carlos aguilar
★ 5
Source: Google
carlos aguilar
★ 5
Good service
Source: Google
Becky Carlson
★ 5
Loved the fish fry!
Source: Google
Anna Johnson
★ 5
Fantastic fish fry, we'll definitely be back!
Source: Google
Dan Mohler
★ 4
Source: Google
Josiah Hamin
★ 5
Great breakfast! Paulie and his staff are very courteous. Fantastic food to boot!
Source: Google
Michael Timm
★ 4
Great little place! Unfortunately we stopped for breakfast but missed the cut off and had to settle for lunch. Food was good. Great prices!
Source: Google
Wally wegner
★ 5
It is definitely a small town eye opener ,the food , service and costumes are all top notch, it's definitely a place I will come back too !
Source: Google
Kimberly Winer
★ 5
Source: Google