Penny's Erin Restaurant & Motel

Hartford, 911 WI-83, Hartford, WI 53027, United States | ★ 4.7 (175 Review)

📞 +1 262-966-1050

Last Search

Category

Restaurant

Photos

 Penny's Erin Restaurant & Motel
 Penny's Erin Restaurant & Motel
 Penny's Erin Restaurant & Motel
 Penny's Erin Restaurant & Motel

Leave a Review

Reviews

Marion Campbell

★ 1

Run down, rude staff (complaining about customers in front of other customers), and you're going to need a bathroom ASAP after eating in their "restaurant".

Source: Google

Amanda Imse

★ 5

Source: Google

sarah serfling

★ 5

Source: Google

Johnny Hrabik

★ 5

Source: Google

Lenny Salentine

★ 5

Wet there for breakfast with a friend good old fashioned hotel diner excellent food best pancakes. I probably ever ate really good old fashioned food and a good price definitely will be coming back.

Source: Google

Red Madirish

★ 5

Source: Google

Chuck Wiggy

★ 5

Small local cafe, great people and good food.

Source: Google

Joe o

★ 5

Source: Google

Chrissy B

★ 5

Cute area. We stopped for the food. Great size portions for super cheap prices. Good food

Source: Google

Steven Feltes

★ 5

Great place for breakfast.

Source: Google

Victoria Nelson-Hubbard

★ 5

This place is Grand in a small hidden area..Food is Fabulous and Staff is so friendly..I have to go and enjoy breakfast there. .every time I am in Town...Thankyou!!!

Source: Google

Mark Malzahn

★ 4

Food was good

Source: Google

Grajek Grajek

★ 5

Przyjeżdżam tam od wielu lat . Pyszne domowe śniadania . Wspaniali ludzie . Przemiła obsługa . Klimat prawdziwej Ameryki z przed lat .

Source: Google

Duck Dad

★ 5

Source: Google

Jim

★ 5

Source: Google

Ed Strommen

★ 5

Stopped here for a local breakfast. Small place with great home cooking. Cash only so be prepared for that.

Source: Google

Tee Pridemore

★ 5

My husband’s favorite place for breakfast. Great pancakes.

Source: Google

Susy R.R.

★ 5

Source: Google

S J

★ 5

Great food, fast service & at a great price.

Source: Google

Mitch Worth

★ 5

Source: Google

Mark Schiesl

★ 5

Awesome breakfast, good food and excellent service!! Affordable prices. You leave feeling satisfied! 👍

Source: Google

Chris D

★ 3

Stopped for breakfast Sunday, food was great. Noticed that the lady cooking spent alot of time being frustrated and yelling out "it will be an hour to get your food" seemed frustrated they had so much business and all the customers I looked at had a look on there face like an episode of Seinfeld where if you don't order correctly the owner screams at you and kicks you out. Overall, wouldn't go back because they clearly don't want the business as they have plenty.

Source: Google

Harvey Bentrup

★ 5

Best place for good eats this side of anywhere. Plain old fashioned homecooked food with friendly people. Best place bar none for breakfast.
No credit cards and I love that too, great way to pass on savings to customers.
Keep it up Penny and crew 👍🇺🇸

Source: Google

Don Thomas

★ 5

Simply the best

Source: Google

Charlie Goersch

★ 5

Absolutely one of our new breakfast places anywhere in the state. The staff as well as the food are both over the top. Prices are also very wallet friendly. We would highly recommend you try it out! Went today to try the lunch portion of the menu and we were not disappointed! WOW, lunch is just as delicious as breakfast. So basically you can stop any time they are open and yiu will enjoy a delicious meal and outstanding service!!! Please do yourself a favor and stop in!!!!! You must try the biscuits and gravy. A much lighter and still as tasty version!!!

Source: Google

Mark S

★ 5

Stopped in Friday morning for the first time with a friend. We each had the pancakes and sausage patties. Very good service, fast and friendly. Will definitely be back to try more on the menu.

Source: Google

Michael Krause

★ 5

Came in by myself for an early breakfast, sat at the bar and ordered a coffee, two eggs, hashbrown and bacon along with a pancake on the side. Everything came out really fast, and the pancake with the crispy edges flapping over the side of the plate was amazing. The prices were very reasonable as well . Will be back again.

Source: Google

Scott Lopas

★ 5

Always delicious with down home friendly flavor and service. Loved the pancake, hung over the edge of my plate! Barely needs syrup it's so flavorful. An iconic stop along that stretch of Hwy 83 south of Hartford.

Source: Google

scott gramling

★ 5

Best breakfast in Erin

Source: Google

Sandra Hornada

★ 5

Source: Google

Charles Schulz

★ 5

Source: Google

Jleigh G

★ 4

Source: Google

Bill

★ 5

Source: Google

Andrew Turek

★ 5

Awesome

Source: Google

Linda Beckman

★ 5

Burgers all ways good!

Source: Google

Roger Ellis

★ 5

Source: Google

Gerald Witkowski

★ 4

Food was great along with the service, we will be back.

Source: Google

Jon Zindler

★ 5

Always good

Source: Google

Sally Lou Bennett

★ 5

Best little eatery

Source: Google

Erik Rossing

★ 5

Amazing food for an amazing price!

Source: Google

Chris Krause

★ 5

Great Mom and pop place!

Source: Google

kelly kobs

★ 5

Great food and fast service coffee cup is allways full. We talk with the cook as she works .Shes has some good storys to tell. Pennys is our go to Restaurant . Sat.or sun .fills up fast so dont procrastinate !!!! Sitll good .

Source: Google

Mike Nichols

★ 5

Source: Google

Michael Palmer

★ 5

Great spot.

Source: Google

ocliw carr

★ 5

Source: Google

Emily Morrissette

★ 5

The cutest, homiest, small town feel! The best food!

Source: Google

Sam

★ 1

I would give zero stars if I would. We came in after church at 1:15 not knowing what time they close. My family and I walked in and right away the 3 lady's at the counter all looked at the clock and said "we close in 15 minutes" not in a nice way but just attacking us saying we are closing in 15 minutes. The ladys where making rude faces and rolling their eyes. Then the one lady said "Okay, I'll babysit them." Even customers in the restaurant heard and they looked in shock how they talked to us. So we just left. It was very disturbing how they just attacked us and where not kind at all. We will never go back and never recommend this business again and tell this story to people.

Source: Google

Kris Hagen

★ 5

Source: Google

Cindy Donnelly

★ 5

Source: Google

Randy TG1

★ 5

Now here's a family run restaurant that has great home cooking. Don't let the exterior fool you. Great prices.
I was a little disappointed today, I went in and waitress ask me to move to a smaller table because the table I went to was for 6.
Well low and behold a big party never came in, the backroom was almost empty.
It really didn't matter as I was only with 3, one person didn't show.
But really ask a customer to move because a bigger party might come in...
That waitress is not the friendliness person either. But still go there. Everything else is great

Source: Google

Trevor Millikin

★ 5

Source: Google

Michael Kretschmer

★ 4

Great breakfast!

Source: Google

Lori Goersch

★ 5

Never stayed at motel but have been there many times for breakfast and it is absolutely delicious!!

Source: Google

lisa kosmond

★ 5

This is by far one of the most delicious and friendliest local places. The people who work there are kind and the food is out of this world! Love the Omelettes & French Toast.

Source: Google

Ken Kartman

★ 5

If you're looking for a friendly, clean, country cafe, this is the place! Penny is great ...and so is her staff. Best pancakes ever!

Source: Google

Richard Jurewicz

★ 5

If you're ever in the area and you want a great breakfast at very reasonable prices, stop at Penny's. Fridays are 1/2 price pancake day, they're huge, cooked perfectly and delicious. Like many have mentioned, the staff is very friendly, Penny stopped by our table and chatted for a few minutes, a very sweet lady. Keep your eyes open or you might drive right past it thinking it's just a Motel. Stop in, you won't be disappointed. Cash only.

Source: Google

Vincent DiCarlo

★ 5

This is my all-time favorite breakfast and burger place. It is like something from the past emerging out of the mist of time. Wonderful informal atmosphere. Low prices. Friendly efficient and attentive service. A place where local people come to chat with each other and with the staff, which consists of the owner, her family, and one or two others who expertly work the grill behind the counter. The burgers are amazing. Just the right amount of fresh beef on a delicious grilled soft bun. When I ordered a burger with mushrooms, Swiss cheese, fried onions, and bacon, more of the extras fell out as I was eating it than the whole amount that comes with most burgers. When I came back a couple of days later for an egg burger, the sunny side up egg I asked for was perfectly done. The chicken noodle soup was also excellent. I only wish I didn't live 2,000 miles away from the place. I will miss it.

Source: Google

Courtney Wiegmann

★ 5

Well worth the scenic drive on an autumn Saturday morning. We both got a little of everything and it was delicious! We will be back.

Source: Google

Rebecca Huggins

★ 5

My wife Googled diners near me and Penny's Erin came up. We said why not. Glad we did the food was great. So was the owner her daughter who cooked and her granddaughter. We recommend going and having a bite to eat. Will have to try the pancakes next time!!

Source: Google

Bobarron

★ 5

Best freaking pancakes in the whole world! We drive 30 min just for pancakes!!
Reasonable, wholesome mom & pop hole in the wall, lovely drive. CASH only.

Source: Google

Jeff Ganis

★ 4

Been going there for years. Great breakfast. The pancakes are huge and light and fluffy. Awesome!

Source: Google

Larry Donnelly

★ 4

Good neighborhood resturaunt.

Source: Google

Scott Roethke

★ 5

Source: Google

S Kirchen

★ 5

Great food and service!

Source: Google

Todd Pedersen

★ 5

Great little place for Breakfast or lunch!

Source: Google

Slade Noreen

★ 5

Food was awesome atmosphere is great great people great food

Source: Google

Giwargiz Rashid

★ 5

Source: Google

Warren Cresca

★ 5

Very clean rooms. And very hard to find good Ole home cooked food.

Source: Google

Tom Turowski

★ 5

Source: Google

Richard Neils

★ 5

Great fresh cooked food.
Friendly service, and fellow customers

Source: Google

Tracy Kratz

★ 5

Source: Google

Tony Agnello

★ 5

Great spot for breakfast.
Never disappoints!

Source: Google

Nikki Krause

★ 1

We used to eat breakfast at the Erin Motel a couple times a month, the food is ok however once having a kid, every time we go in we are asked to sit in the back seat away from the other customers. Unfortunately I've heard the same thing from other families.

Source: Google

Austin Wunderlich

★ 5

There is not a better place for breakfast. These ladies have it perfected.

Source: Google

Kiana Werner

★ 5

Source: Google

Michael Wadsworth

★ 5

Good food and service

Source: Google

Ian Niemi

★ 5

Source: Google

Geri Leiske

★ 5

Source: Google

Gregory Lohr

★ 5

Great food. Sassy personnel

Source: Google

Karla Krohn

★ 5

Source: Google

John Marschke

★ 5

Definitely my go-to place for breakfast always have a good time lots of smiles

Source: Google

Sophie

★ 5

Source: Google

Lisa Reardon

★ 5

Source: Google

Todd Gillis

★ 5

Great food

Source: Google

Brian Hanson

★ 5

Source: Google

Paul Wold

★ 5

Excellent pancakes

Source: Google

Eric Fox

★ 5

Source: Google

Bradley Ferks

★ 5

Great breakfast and lunch. CA$H ONLY

Source: Google

Nic

★ 2

Okay food but zero covid safety

Source: Google

sylvan stommel

★ 5

Source: Google

FarmerRoss

★ 5

The food is awesome and the people are down-to-earth

Source: Google

Dustin Collins

★ 5

Source: Google

Fredrick Shult

★ 5

We love the place. It's our favorite
restaurant.

Source: Google

Anita Walther

★ 5

Quiet,friendly and clean 👍

Source: Google

Kimberly Priesgen

★ 5

My favorite pancakes in the world! Even burps after are 5- star!

Source: Google

Chester Harvey

★ 4

I've been there MANY times for breakfast. Good food, Good service and very inexpensive! Highly recommended!!!

Source: Google

Carter Forseth

★ 5

Source: Google

Virgie Komp

★ 4

Great breakfasts

Source: Google

Kelly Dessart

★ 5

Source: Google

bill bauer

★ 4

Source: Google

joe de stefano

★ 5

Source: Google

Tracy Sankbeil

★ 5

Nice hometown breakfasts!

Source: Google

Paul Hammerberg

★ 5

Source: Google

Rick Wright

★ 5

Very nice place to go for a good breakfast.

Source: Google

Tom Haase

★ 2

Source: Google

Corey Delaney

★ 4

Quaint little breakfast diner. Font speed past or you'll miss it!

Source: Google

Johanna Rusch

★ 5

We love to go on Friday's for half price pancake day. Their prices are the best in the area. It's an older style diner. The staff is friendly. Some of their dishes are served family style. Plus they have some of the better tasting coffee. Don't judge a book by it's cover. Our new favorite breakfast joint.

Source: Google

Corine Feltes

★ 5

Love their pancakes

Source: Google

michael reinemann

★ 3

Source: Google

Joshua James

★ 5

Very nice cafe and motel. Small and quaint. Open style kitchen where you can see your food being prepared.
Friendly environment, fast service just small seating area.

Source: Google

John Doll

★ 5

Great breakfast

Source: Google

Valerie Konkel

★ 5

Source: Google

Robert Christopherson

★ 5

Awesome food

Source: Google

Ryan Lauersdorf

★ 5

Source: Google

Trevor Shirriffs

★ 5

By far my favorite breakfast stop. Food and the staff are always top notch. Feels like an up north cafe. Also, BURGERS ARE AMAZING!

Source: Google

Clyde Peschl

★ 4

Very good food, only open until 2, quaint

Source: Google

Edward Meunier

★ 5

Source: Google

jnyrokit s

★ 5

We found out after placing our order for breakfast that they don't accept credit cards. They were incredibly understanding. They let us eat our delicious omelets and said " next time you're out this way, you can stop in and pay us". The owner herself came by and was so genuine. She even gave us some homemade cookies for the road. We made our waxy to the nearest ATM after eating and headed back to pay. Needless to say, yep, we will definitely be back!

Source: Google

Stephan Regenfuss

★ 5

Great breakfast! Simple yet delicious.

Source: Google

Tom Sowinski

★ 5

Source: Google

Marvin Harris

★ 5

Great breakfast

Source: Google

Doug Hoffman

★ 5

Great food nice people!

Source: Google

Jason Marsh

★ 5

Great stop for a good old fashioned breakfast !

Source: Google

Amanda Martin

★ 5

Source: Google

Kerri Wissbroecker

★ 5

Great homestyle breakfast. The eggs were possibly the best I've ever had and the hashbrowns were slightly crispy but not dry.

Source: Google

Robert Altmayer

★ 5

Excellent food and service

Source: Google

Kira Rolbiecki

★ 5

Source: Google

Jen Herro

★ 5

We love the Erin Motel restaurant. So happy, sassy and fun. The food is super!

Source: Google

Lynn Barthel

★ 5

Always good food 👌

Source: Google

steve altmayer

★ 5

Source: Google

Jamie Weinhammer

★ 4

Source: Google

Ron Geis

★ 5

Best breakfast and service! Wonderful home atmosphere! A true gem of Erin and Washington county!

Source: Google

Steve Schwendtner

★ 5

Source: Google

Jody Ovrid

★ 5

Source: Google

Billy M

★ 5

Source: Google

Cori Adams

★ 5

Excellent service and food!

Source: Google

Zac Schaefer

★ 5

Pancakes so filling you may not need seconds but so good you'll want them.

Source: Google

John Christenson

★ 5

The best polish sausage and the American Fries are to die for

Source: Google

Chris McGinnis

★ 5

Best breakfast around! Pancakes are a must try!

Source: Google

Jason Bates

★ 5

Best food in Erin. Expect a long wait but it's well worth it. Sit at the counter to watch some good cooking.

Source: Google

Vivian Brault

★ 5

Good food & fun time!!

Source: Google

Marie F

★ 5

Don't overlook this small, unassuming restaurant as you drive by and see the lodging. The small team work seamlessly together to make a great experience with *fantastic* food for breakfast or lunch. These ladies are amazing, remembering customers, details about their lives, and even knowing who you are if you call for takeout simply from the order if you are a creature of habit. Sadly, they don't serve dinner (they close a 2PM). Also, make sure to have cash as they do not accept credit. But should you forget, they do have an ATM on site.

Source: Google

Brent Sue Smith

★ 5

Source: Google

chris szczerbinski

★ 4

Went for breakfast on a Saturday morning. Service was good, food served hot. Flavors were good.

Source: Google

Jeff Szczerbinski

★ 5

Bring a hearty appetite

Source: Google

Gloria Witt

★ 5

We have been coming here for breakfast for years. It is so charming and fabulous. You know your breakfast will always be perfect snd the staff is so nice.

Source: Google

gbla100

★ 5

Food is great and Penny is just wonderful it's a great place to eat

Source: Google

Wrye Oliver

★ 5

Source: Google

Allen Kosidowski

★ 4

Source: Google

Vivian Brault

★ 5

Excellent food. Fun place! !!

Source: Google

John Wright

★ 5

Source: Google

Mike Brown

★ 4

Source: Google

Eric Chapman

★ 4

Source: Google

Dorthy T

★ 5

We love it there. Great place great food. Your treated like family.

Source: Google

Marilyn Smith

★ 5

Our favorite place for breakfast always great food and super friendly people.....

Source: Google

Gregory Maier

★ 5

Omg a diamond in the rough.If you haven't eaten here yet your missing out on some awesome home cooking.They will tell us they love to use real butter. Omg,the breakfast are the best.They make pancakes that are old fashion and to die for.Friday's you get 1 big pancake for 1.50 .Penney the owner is so sweet and her daughter the cook is a blast.Its all family running this hotspot.nicest people around.you will be back for more.Guaranteed. we love this cute place so much.

Source: Google

Paula Weimer

★ 5

Source: Google

Charles Farley

★ 5

Can't speak for the motel portion but the foods girls crank out for breakfast and lunch is great Limited hours

Source: Google

Steven Frey

★ 5

Best place for breakfast in the area

Source: Google

DeAnna Greulich

★ 5

We love their pancakes and such a great deal on Fridays! We take guests there. Great for breakfast!

Source: Google

Todd Grissman

★ 5

Always good.

Source: Google

Benjamin Brossard

★ 5

Breakfast was great. Never would have thought this place had such good breakfast food.

Source: Google

Alan Whipple

★ 5

Source: Google

Lee Christopherson

★ 5

Great food.

Source: Google

Patrick Hennecke

★ 5

Hands down my favorite breakfast spot. Have been, and will continue to go here.

Source: Google

Angela R

★ 4

Good stop for a chicken sandwich, sloppy Joe special and simple inexpensive quick eats! it's a nostalgic sort of place run full force by family! For being out on the middle of nowhere it's definetly a local gathering place! Stop on in and give it a try!

Source: Google

Jason Perrine

★ 5

Source: Google

Katie Kluskens

★ 1

I just called for rates and the person I talked to was not pleasant.

Source: Google

Kristi George

★ 5

Great food and great prices!

Source: Google

Huck Ehrlich

★ 1

Stopped for breakfast, I won't eat here again.

Source: Google

Brock Held

★ 3

Nice people work here and it's homy but you can tell that they go cheap on the food budget

Source: Google

Amanda S. Imse

★ 5

Yummy yummy!!! Very quaint, small, but TOTALLY delicious!!!!!!

Source: Google

Terry Schwefel

★ 5

My husband and I went here from breakfast and what an adorable place. Food was great! Have been telling family and friends about it already. A MUST SEE!

Source: Google

TERESA JACK

★ 5

Source: Google

Brenda Beauleau

★ 5

Cute, quaint, clean and reasonable priced. I am a businessman and wish I could find an Erin's Motel everywhere I go. Thank you.

Source: Google