Category
Pizza restaurant RestaurantDescription
No-frills local chain known for pizza by the slice, plus extra-large pies & specialty toppings.
Photos
Leave a Review
Reviews
Samantha Hodge
★ 5
Source: Google
Andrew Burton
★ 4
Source: Google
Jessica Kamradt
★ 5
Source: Google
david cotterill
★ 5
I love the lunch deal
Source: Google
Mandy Suess
★ 4
Source: Google
David Miller
★ 5
Great pizza! Great service and atmosphere. Good prices too. Clean.
Source: Google
Steve Stark
★ 4
Source: Google
Jenell Hanko
★ 3
Source: Google
Beck Bartels
★ 5
Source: Google
Tessa Gregoire
★ 5
Source: Google
Mindy Nasi
★ 5
Best pizza in town and great staff highly recommend. The guy that waited on me I believe his name was Seth was fantastic and should get a raise
Source: Google
JIRSHTIN 115
★ 3
Great food for the price as usual, but the staff was not as polite and approachable as other locations. At times the staff seemed quite rude, kinda of douchey to customers. When a group of what look like base baseball players walked in, a staff member told them to “got to toppers” like they weren’t paying customers
Source: Google
Nikky Klauck
★ 5
Really great food and really great staff. They are so kind and helpful. Amazing service!!! Love politos!!
Source: Google
Tom Blair
★ 5
Great slices! Perfect college town pizza joint. Friendly service, fast hot food.
Source: Google
Nicole Lynn
★ 5
Source: Google
Kuldeep Kang
★ 5
Great food and great staff that make politics go
Source: Google
Tyler Kroll
★ 1
Great food, terrible service. I asked for a box to go and guy got really upset and threw the box at me
Source: Google
Amy Schwab
★ 5
Source: Google
Travis Rewalt
★ 5
Random late night stop turned out to be a gem! Great pizza and an inviting environment. One person in our group said it reminded them of the pizza from the classic ninja turtles movies 😆
Source: Google
Tanner Segor
★ 5
Source: Google
Jason Anklam
★ 4
Great lunch specials
Source: Google
Dustin Ogilvie
★ 5
Source: Google
Luis Garcia
★ 5
Source: Google
George Burke
★ 5
Pizza was great. Wish I didn't live 90 miles away. One of my new favorites.
Source: Google
Bruce Williams
★ 1
I am trying to figure out why they cut my pizza in squares. I was so disappointed see them cut it that way.
Source: Google
A H
★ 5
Decent Pizza. I am not a pizza fan, but my family is and this is one place I will order it from because it is always good!
Source: Google
Will Whitson
★ 5
Source: Google
Paul B. Apfel
★ 5
I often eat at the La Crosse Politos but held up to expectations here just fine.
Source: Google
Charles Hussel
★ 4
Source: Google
Eleanor Brinsko
★ 4
Source: Google
Renna
★ 4
Source: Google
Arjen
★ 4
Garlic knots were a little burnt but the pizza was great
Source: Google
Jamie Re-Watson
★ 5
Source: Google
bean5824
★ 5
So far good
Source: Google
modelX 400 (modelX400)
★ 5
Source: Google
Timothy Husketh
★ 5
Best pizza hands down. Don't believe me? Stop lying.
Source: Google
Joshua Ammeter
★ 5
Source: Google
Charles Barbola
★ 5
Exactly wjat you'd expect from a by-the-slice pizza place just off of of campus. Great friendly service. Garlic knots are awesome. Best either late on the weekend after a night out, or during lunch.
Source: Google
Kyle Hotvedt
★ 5
Everytime I go to politos it gets better and better, great pizza!
Source: Google
Eddie S
★ 4
Quick pizza by the slice place. Pizza is very good.
Source: Google
Charles Rollins III
★ 5
I always order takeout when ordering from here. The pizza is delicious and great service. Their garlic knots are mouth-watering! 🤤
Source: Google
Eric Arsiniega
★ 5
Haven’t had this since I was in Stevens Point, so good!
Source: Google
Holley Wolke
★ 5
Source: Google
Kathyrn Madary
★ 5
Great price for good food and friendly staff
Source: Google
Mark Habeck
★ 5
Great 'za, low prices, and huge slices!
Source: Google
Red Johnson
★ 5
Source: Google
Nicholas Brown
★ 5
Beat pizza in town ever!!
Source: Google
molly m
★ 5
Source: Google
Randy Schuh
★ 2
Specialty pizza is advertised as xl 20" $24.50... actually priced $27.50... 14" specialty pizza , advertised price...$18.75 actual price, $22.50... after 10 pm price goes up even on a slice that's dry and been sitting out for an hour
Source: Google
Cory Schoonover
★ 5
Source: Google
David Isenhower
★ 4
Source: Google
Jacye
★ 5
So good and best priced pizza I've had in years that tasted like it was gourmet
Thanks guys
Source: Google
Laura Schoonover
★ 5
Source: Google
Hans Pollock
★ 5
Great Pizza for the price and the quality is good. Hardly no wait time on a 4 pizza order last minute. Staff was friendly and funny.
Source: Google
sergio valentin
★ 5
Para mi! Las mejores pizzas 💪🏽💪🏽
Source: Google
Aaron Brechlin
★ 3
Pizza was not as hot as I would’ve like. But it was ok. Might be because I came at a slow time.
Source: Google
Kiro Chen
★ 5
This place has pretty similar pizza quality to nyc pizzeria! Staff is also real nice 👌
Source: Google
Sara Beth
★ 5
Source: Google
Ismael “El Mayo” Zambada
★ 5
Satisfies. Every time.
Source: Google
Cynthia M. Schmiedel-Madl
★ 4
Source: Google
christopher thao
★ 4
Source: Google
Kevin Walsh
★ 5
Great pizza in a classic setting
Source: Google
Jacob Souza
★ 1
Source: Google
Brandon Hursh
★ 1
I wanted to try Polito's for the first time today, but they didn't have any of the pizza that I wanted and they were also not willing to honor my request of no onions on the BBQ chicken pizza. What's the point of being a pizza place if you don't have what your customers want at 1:30 in the afternoon on a Saturday and don't allow for customizations? Looks like I'll never try their pizza as they have just lost my business forever as a potential first time customer.
Source: Google
J Walk
★ 4
Source: Google
Jenni Feltus
★ 5
Hands down the best pizza we've had in Oshkosh!!
Source: Google
Pat Geigel
★ 5
Source: Google
Peter Ersland
★ 5
I've ate here 3 times now and it's been fantastic every time. Nice workers, foods done in a timely manner, it's delicious, and its fairly priced. Would highly recommend.
Source: Google
Judy Prince
★ 3
Average pizza for college area
Source: Google
Bruce Rayden
★ 5
The pizza mimics a favorite back home in Pennsylvania. Staff are east to talk with. My family had a restaurant there, so we exchanged good memories. We will be back!
Source: Google
Benjamin L
★ 5
Source: Google
Marion A Dickie II
★ 5
Source: Google
dylan valdes
★ 5
Source: Google
Pam Weber
★ 5
Source: Google
Dee
★ 5
Best pizza in town
Source: Google
Sabrina Na
★ 5
My favorite pizza place in Wisconsin. Garlic bread is on point!
Source: Google
Carrie Pok
★ 5
Really good pizza and garlic knots to die for. The place could use a cleaning but will overlook it for good pizza.
Source: Google
Bobbie Fink
★ 5
Awesome people to serve amazing pizza. Thank you
Source: Google
C Martin
★ 5
Source: Google
Joshua Bonafede
★ 4
Source: Google
Evan Telindert
★ 5
Super good and huge slices
Source: Google
David Weddig
★ 5
Source: Google
Russ Rieben
★ 5
Good pizza and prices
Source: Google
Teresa Fischer
★ 5
The BEST New York style pizza in town.
Source: Google
Benjamin Pribel
★ 4
Source: Google
Josh Mesick
★ 5
Best pizza and employees Politos is the best
Source: Google
Rukus Tattoo
★ 5
The best pizza joint on earth
Source: Google
Hannah Mydland
★ 5
Source: Google
Diane Lammers
★ 5
Their chicken bacon ranch pizza is awesome!
Source: Google
John Bechle
★ 5
Awesome pizza and garlic knots. $20 goes a long way
Source: Google
Kristina Taylor
★ 5
Source: Google
Deanna Schaffer
★ 5
Best pizza in town.
Source: Google
K
★ 5
Source: Google
Nick Vavrik
★ 1
Refused to serve me. Used to be great but has gone downhill. Bye new management!!
Source: Google
Michael Duke
★ 5
The pizza reminds me of Aniello's Pizzeria in Corning, NY without the ambiance of Anniello cussing out his staff in Italian. Sure miss Aniello’s! Glad I found Polito’s.
Source: Google
Brooke Vasquez
★ 5
Source: Google
Elizabeth Christopher
★ 5
Source: Google
Brian
★ 5
I used to live in New York and this is the best pizza in Oshkosh!
Source: Google
Sergio Miranda
★ 5
Source: Google
Jon Gibson
★ 5
Best pizza. Love it.
Source: Google
Angela Quattrochi
★ 5
Great pizza and knots... We got spinach and feta 20" added bacon... It was delicious...😋💕😁
✌🏼❤️😁🌎
Source: Google
Tim Canziani
★ 5
Great place for a slice!
Source: Google
Kevin Andrasko M.D.
★ 5
I stutter,so got ddddouble cheese!
Source: Google
Aaron Hazel (G-mail)
★ 5
Source: Google
Sara Andre
★ 5
Very nice place very good pizza 🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕
Source: Google
Marquis Perkins
★ 4
Source: Google
Norma Kumm
★ 4
Grandson got food to go & a lot of college kids in front of him, but he got his food very quickly & said it was good 👍
Source: Google
Jason Lasee
★ 4
Source: Google
Christine Heuser
★ 5
Source: Google
meanderriver
★ 4
Source: Google
A.F. I.
★ 5
Everybody only wants to come here when they’re drunk, however it is good midday as well. Just like a solid pizza by the slice option. Also the cannoli is my favorite I’ve ever had.
Source: Google
Rachel Chapin
★ 5
Crispy hot and inexpensive. Been meaning to come for a while and now Im going to make excuses to ve back. I got a slice of the chicken bacon ranch and I need to order a whole pie now. Thank you!
Source: Google
Josh Fisher
★ 5
Big slices and a huge 20inch pizza should you choose. College friendly and busy during bar time. Price are reasonable.
Source: Google
Eric
★ 5
Very good pizza. NY style so they’ll heat up anything by the slice or make a whole pizza fresh if you’re feeding a group. Very willing to customize for the customer. Excellent and chill couple of guys working there.
Source: Google
Yinbo Li
★ 5
Excellent pizza excellent price!
Source: Google
Candace Applebee
★ 5
Love love love!!!!
Source: Google
Eli Voss
★ 5
Source: Google
Jon Gibson
★ 5
Large slice pizza is always so damn good
Source: Google
Stephen Adams
★ 5
Source: Google
Max Friederichs
★ 5
Source: Google
Tasha Pointer
★ 4
Source: Google
geoffrey kimber
★ 4
Very good New York style pizza.
Source: Google
Jean Deniger
★ 5
Hands down best pizza on earth 🌎
Source: Google
Scott LaPlante
★ 5
Very filling pizza
Source: Google
Hope Fenrich
★ 5
Source: Google
Isaac Janness
★ 4
Source: Google
Ryan Ratajczak
★ 5
i ordered a barbeque sauced pizza with mozzarella cheese sliced chicken bacon and green peppers and it was amazing. might buy a 20 inch next time
Source: Google
Lee Evans
★ 5
Source: Google
dale mcpherson
★ 5
Great selection, garlic knots were awesome, Mac n cheese pizza was delicious, Tuesday special was good deal
Source: Google
Betty Karas
★ 1
Source: Google
Dani Marie
★ 4
The pictures are of a veggie Spinach Feta 20" pizza and a box of some garlic knots with garlic butter. So salty, cheesey, and greasy with goodness. Sauce is sparse, but I don't mind. Great proximity for hungry college students to get a well priced, quick snack or meal. Check their specials! Tuesday $6 double slices with a drank!
Source: Google
John Hueller
★ 5
Source: Google
bladesrnm1
★ 5
Source: Google
Jason Kleinschmidt
★ 4
Source: Google
Mich M
★ 5
Source: Google
james vienola
★ 5
Kids love this place
Source: Google
Joseph Campshure
★ 5
Truly delicious pizza!!
Source: Google
Tony Stark
★ 5
Source: Google
Da Albino Mexican
★ 4
Great Selection Of Pizza! Mac N Cheese & BBQ Hawaiian Are Great!
Source: Google
David
★ 5
Politos is the best in oshkosh
Source: Google
KADE
★ 5
Source: Google
Ethan Free
★ 5
I grew up with Politos, always eating it when I was little, and my brother and sister worked there and talked about it, so there's a little bit of nostalgia whenever i go there. The pizza slices are very big, and are really cheap despite how delicious they are. You can get 2 slices of pizza and a t-shirt for $10 which is a pretty good deal. They have arcade games and claw machines for a little entertainment while you wait for your pizza to be made. One complaint that i have (and I'm really nitpicking here) is that the atmosphere is just a little bit empty and boring, but other than that just about every aspect is good. I would definitely recommend this restaurant, and would rate it a 9/10.
Source: Google
Colin Caldwell Jr
★ 5
Source: Google
Savage MolonLabe
★ 5
BBQ steak and fry is the best!! Favorite pizza place ever!!!
Source: Google
Claudia Duval
★ 5
this is by far the best pizza and service in oshkosh! all of the workers were super helpful in making sure i got a slice that i would like would recommend to anyone!
Source: Google
Sam Bauer
★ 5
Best pizza I have ever had!!!! Amazing service. Talked to corporate the other day and they were extremely helpful! Everyone who works there is amazing!!!!
Source: Google
Heather Kubera
★ 1
The worst service in a long time....no fresh pizzas were made, got hung up on when calling to ask for a manager. Was told that there was no manager and that the events in town come before the customers. Also was told it is a family business that there was no cooperate number I could have. Hope the family that owns this place treats it's customers better than their employees do! They just lost a loyal customer coming for many many years over poor employees.
Source: Google
h&J kubera
★ 1
Worst service ever go in there and there’s two slices of old pepperoni pizza and three cheese on a New Year’s New Year’s Eve how does that work you asked a lady for a corporate she has no explanation
Source: Google
JB THREAT (JB THREAT)
★ 4
Source: Google
Byron Burk
★ 5
We went for a weekend with the grandsons for a weekend getaway to Wisconsin Rapids. We decided to order a pizza on our first night there. We could have ordered from any of the standards like Rockys, Papa Murphys and many others, but decided to try a local place and something unfamiliar to us. We ordered from Politos and were thrilled! The pizza was fantastic! It was a hit with all of us. Cheesy, great sausage and pepperoni and great flavor. Also, it was the biggest pizza I’ve ever seen, 20”. Just delicious, I highly recommend.
Source: Google
Bradyn Hertel
★ 5
Got the chicken quesadilla pizza it's phenomenal absolutely loved it
Source: Google
Jamie Smith
★ 5
Pizza Pizza Pizza!!!! Always a great experience!!! Thanks guys and gals!
Source: Google
Paul Mort
★ 5
Source: Google
david lee Visser
★ 5
N/A
Source: Google
Anissa williams
★ 5
Source: Google
Milagros Rios
★ 5
Me encanta la más parecida que e encontrado en sabor y calidad. Al estilo New York como la de mi bella isla Puerto Rico. El personal humildad, profesionalismo de verdad saben ganarse al cliente. Voy frecuente ya que la más cercana es en Oshkosh pero vale la pena el viaje se los aseguro. Solo espero que el día que contraiga nupcias también me regalen la 🍕. De verdad eso les quedó bien fueron empáticos con la pareja que llegaron con hambre todos los allí testigos aplaudimos su buen gesto bendito la novia se emociono mucho la hicieron llorar. Por eso todo el que lea esto les recomiendo mucho buena pizza a buen precio. POLITOS gracias por existir.
Source: Google
Nicholas Crisler
★ 5
Gyro meat is a must
Source: Google
Brett Burks
★ 5
Great all the way around
Source: Google
Put Out Receivable Energy
★ 5
One slice makes me burst with happiness 😊
Source: Google
Michelle Dotterer
★ 4
Source: Google
Kim McLaughlin
★ 1
Only 3rd party delivery. Will not use any 3rd party.
Source: Google
Jill A
★ 5
Source: Google
Yamil Rivera
★ 5
Up standing pizza, great service. 100% very good
Source: Google
Jill Hammond
★ 5
Love there pizza
Source: Google
Patrick O'Connell
★ 4
Should have been given a plastic take out bag to put food in as my backpack got all full of grease from cardboard box and garlic butter. Food was worth the mess though.
Source: Google
Mark A. Smith
★ 4
Source: Google
Cole Spickler
★ 5
Source: Google
TiEshia Mitchell
★ 4
Source: Google
Johanna Velders
★ 5
Great pizza! Love this place for lunch when I want some comfort food :)
Source: Google
Kelsie Oestreich
★ 5
Source: Google
Thomas S.
★ 1
Do NOT order from Polito’s! I was told twenty minutes to pick-up. After forty-plus minutes of waiting, they had NOT even started assembling my pizzas. Save your money and time plus get better pizza ANYWHERE else.
Source: Google
Ed Mulroy
★ 5
POLITOS IS THE PIZZA IN WISCONSIN. IT'S THE ONLY REAL NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA MY WIFE AND I CAN FIND HERE. WE LIVE IN THE DELLS AND WE DRIVE 2 HOURS FOR IT. WE ARE FROM NY SO WE HAVE TO HAVE THE REAL THING.
Source: Google
Michael Hetzel
★ 4
Source: Google
Raymond peters (thebroskie1999)
★ 5
Source: Google
Michael Orth
★ 5
Source: Google
Brittany McKenzie
★ 1
I went around bar-close so it was absolutely jam packed. The line was long and did not appear to move for the 10 minutes I waited and then I decided to leave. It did not appear that they were restricting the amount of people in there, there was no social distancing whatsoever, and no one wearing masks, literally not a single person. I would be interested in trying their food in the future so I can hopefully leave a better review but until they take COVID seriously, that will not happen.
Source: Google
Mark Allermann
★ 4
Source: Google
Thomas Bowman
★ 4
Great food but, Politos does NOT do delivery even though the website says they do.
Source: Google
Crystal Davis
★ 5
Best pizza in Oshkosh!!!
Source: Google
Bob Leake
★ 5
Very friendly and helpful staff!!
Source: Google
Abbie Ninedorf
★ 4
Source: Google
Lina Mohr
★ 5
Politos is always amazing.
Source: Google
Pam Keller
★ 5
Great prices, huge pizzas.
Source: Google
Brant Goeking
★ 5
Good food good prices
Source: Google
Jennel Erickson
★ 5
Great pizza. I am forever on the search for Jersey pizza. This is the best.
Source: Google
Justin Lietz
★ 5
My favorite pizza place so far!
Source: Google
Jake Jones
★ 5
I love you terry.
Source: Google
B V
★ 5
Source: Google
Michael Rhoades
★ 5
Source: Google
Rose Linder
★ 1
Too bad their employees don't all wear masks and they don't enforce the mandate at all.
Source: Google
Terence Killilea
★ 1
Slow service
Source: Google
David Felten
★ 5
Source: Google
CRACKEDsash Gaming
★ 5
great pizza at an amazing price. bring an appetite
Source: Google
trumpetjoe40
★ 3
Price is right, the pizza? Well....ehhh. It’s fast and by the slice but not that good. Had to napkin off the grease which had pooled on the slices. Ok for what it is, the place looks like an abandoned VFW hall.
Source: Google
Kathy Kramer
★ 4
I love this place best pizza around!!!
Source: Google
Joshua Klein
★ 5
Always good to get a slice! A great tasting slice! I heart pizza
Source: Google
Brennan Bockin
★ 5
Source: Google
Jason Ballard
★ 2
Pretty bad and I love all pizza
Source: Google
Mark Thoreson
★ 5
Love the pizza
Source: Google
Jay Taylor
★ 5
Source: Google