Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Green Bay, 2161 S Oneida St, Green Bay, WI 54304, United States | ★ 4.5 (1738 Review)

📞 +1 920-499-6644

Last Search

Category

Pizza restaurant Italian restaurant Restaurant

Description

Discover a taste of tradition at Sammy's Pizza of Green Bay, a family-owned Italian restaurant serving the community since 1958. Our beloved hometown spot offers a delectable array of pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches. Our timeless recipes and handcrafted approach ensure an authentic experience. Enjoy 14 specialty pizzas, 30 toppings, and the finest Wisconsin-made mozzarella cheese. Join us for a memorable meal where each bite reflects our passion for quality. Visit us today at Sammy's Pizza of Green Bay.

Photos

 Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
 Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
 Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
 Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
 Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
 Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
 Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
 Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
 Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
 Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
 Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
 Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
 Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
 Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Leave a Review

Reviews

Dan C.

★ 5

Excellent across the board food, service and price.

Source: Google

Mark Wedder

★ 5

Source: Google

Beth Janssen

★ 5

Every time we're in GB we stop. We love this place. Friendly staff. Our gentlemen waiter was outstanding.

Source: Google

doug

★ 5

Excellent flavors and very well made. Bit pricey at $30 with tip for a 12 inch

Source: Google

Linda KUBITZ

★ 5

Authentic Italian. Hadn't been here for 10 years & it will become a regular stop!
Comfortable and great pricing also.

Source: Google

Maria A Sanchez Rosado

★ 4

We had a family of 8 for a special celebration dinner. The staff was attentive, the atmosphere was pleasant, teamwork was good, and the food was fresh.

Cons: Was super busy, therefore noisy. The wait for both a table and the food was a little long, and they don't accept reservations. I got a salad with shrimp, but I was unaware that the shrimp would be raw. I didn't like that or the lack of warning about it. Raw shrimp aside, literally, the salad itself was fantastic.

Source: Google

Karen B

★ 5

Delicious homemade Italian comfort food! Meatballs and sausage A++ From 2 Italians, this is just like grandma made! Highly recommend, also very reasonably priced, we both had pasta. Didn't have the pizza, that's for next time!

Source: Google

Benjamin Biancini

★ 5

My family is from Hibbing and this is legit

Source: Google

Leigh Drossart

★ 5

Source: Google

Barbara Walley

★ 5

Source: Google

Jeff Gates

★ 4

Source: Google

David Marthenze

★ 5

Excellent service, nice atmosphere. Pizza was fantastic, perfectly cooked and served steaming hot! We ordered the garlic cheese bread appetizer as well. Soft and gooey on top and crispy on the bottom. Perfect. I would highly recommend dining here!!

Source: Google

Lisa Herman

★ 5

We ordered pick up and our Penne pasta was missing the chicken. We had started eating (it was delicious) and then questioned, wasn't there supposed to be chicken? I called them and they very politely and efficiently offered to remake our 2 orders of the garlic basil penne pasta . I happily accepted . Great customer service and the pasta was so good! We also got the chicken Alfredo and it was excellent! I highly recommend Sammy's!

Source: Google

Jerry Rieder

★ 5

Overall good food/experience.

Source: Google

C

★ 5

Party of (2) We ordered the gnocchi and an order of pappardelle bolognese. Both were very good. One with meatballs and the other with homemade Italian sausage. The meatballs were simply ok, my grandfather's recipe is actually better. However, the Italian sausage was excellent. We split an order of tiramasu for dessert. I've eaten tiramasu all over the United States including the Little Italy's in New York as well as San Diego. This tiramasu was the best I've eaten hands down. Would totally recommend and will for sure come back to eat here.

Source: Google

Steve Frank

★ 4

Source: Google

Andrew Sallmann

★ 5

As soon as we walked in the atmosphere felt so warm and inviting. The service was beyond exceptional. The pizza tasted as if it was baked in a wood fire oven of yore. The pasta was cooked so well that it would have made Chef Boyardi weep.

Source: Google

Cory Bielski

★ 5

Sammy's Pizza is classic and delicious. We take our family with 6 kids here every year after a trip to Bay Beach. The pizza is piping hot and perfect crust. The toppings, especially the sausage, peppers and onions are perfect. Service is always wonderful and the atmosphere is perfect Green Bay Wisconsinites and family enjoying each other over great pizza 🍕. An additional plus is that it sits in the shadows of Labeau Field, so you feel close to the Packers.

Source: Google

Theresa Bartman

★ 5

Very nice place

Source: Google

Josh Hayden

★ 5

Source: Google

Deborah Parrett

★ 5

Source: Google

Michael Culver

★ 5

Great pizza and friendly staff.

Source: Google

Todd Jessogne

★ 5

It's like they get better at it every time I go

Source: Google

Chris Marquardt

★ 5

I have known about Sammy's pizza for years. This is the first time there. The food is excellent, service is great and the atmosphere is wonderful. I will return

Source: Google

Jed Swiecichowski

★ 5

Back visiting and picked up lunch.
The pizza was fantastic.

Source: Google

Jodee Liedtke

★ 5

Great pizza and antipasto salad.

Source: Google

BILL WOS

★ 5

Always good

Source: Google

Letitia Couden

★ 5

Food is so good..freindly family environment

Source: Google

DizzyGnome

★ 4

Source: Google

Pat Clusman

★ 5

Sammy's has been serving the best pizza for many years. They serve other Italian dishes as well. Friendly and very attentive staff. Ample parking. Easy access off Oneida street.

Source: Google

Tonya Trimberger

★ 1

Had a horribly salty pizza tonight. Manager tried to tell us it was from the asiago cheeses and lunch meat on the pizza. Lunch meat on the pizza I'm gonna say I didn't know we were getting lunch meat on our pizza. We didn't even take our leftovers home. Salty enough to burn our lips and huge garlic chunks on the pizza , not even an offered discount. Will not Return.

Source: Google

Charlie Wittchow

★ 5

Amazing pizza and great service. I can't wait to go back and try some pasta. This is my new go to.pizza place.

Source: Google

Cailin O'Connor

★ 5

Great place to park and eat before it after a Packer game. Super friendly service, and good food!

Source: Google

André Anderson

★ 5

Amazing. Favorite pizza place in the area. Pasta and pizzas to die for. Highly recommend getting the Crazy Italian.

Source: Google

Kevin Eaton

★ 5

Great first time experience. One of my favorites now in the fox valley!

Source: Google

Jamie Dolan

★ 5

Source: Google

Adam Fleisner

★ 5

Source: Google

Ryan Carroll

★ 1

...closed at 830 on a Sat night...? Has to be a joke

Source: Google

Rafet Jammali

★ 4

Source: Google

Laura Hanson

★ 5

Source: Google

Sara Dietzen

★ 5

Sammy's has been my favorite pizza restaurant since I moved to Green Bay in 2007. The staff is always friendly and accommodating. The pizza is fantastic - plenty of toppings, great sauce and a nice thin crispy crust. Cheesy garlic is so delicious 😋 They have a nice variety of home made Italian food too. It is a very family friendly restaurant. Highly recommend Sammy's Pizza!

Source: Google

4ort nite20

★ 5

The Pizza Here is sooooooo AMAZING 🤩 they have Alot more than pizza 🍕😋 I loved it so much I ended up getting a job

Source: Google

Steve Buchanan

★ 5

Source: Google

Andrew Brolin

★ 5

Source: Google

DJ Home Juice

★ 4

Pizza

Source: Google

Chuck Howard

★ 5

My son and I stopped in here for a pizza on our way home to Detroit after a weekend spent at the AirVenture show in Oshkosh. So glad we did. The bread sticks and dipping sauce were amazing. The pizza was delicious as well. Thin, crispy, and super flavorful. Our server was attentive and super friendly. And the hostess who I believe may have been the manager or owner was so freaking cool. Nice to my son, positive attitude and genuinely friendly.

Source: Google

Jodi Skewis

★ 5

Source: Google

Shamus Mann

★ 5

100 percent recommend. Prices were fairly reasonable but the quality was above and beyond. The pizza is fantastic 10/10

Source: Google

Sam Davis

★ 5

How I've never reviewed this place is beyond me! My son is obsessed with this place. Pizza with black olives is asked for almost every night!

Source: Google

John Huss

★ 5

Love you pizza thank you from Johnnys lock

Source: Google

Rick White

★ 5

Had supper here twice during my travels through Green Bay in June 2025. Outstanding Service and Delicious Food. The owner suggested several meals on the menu and I experienced a pizza recommendation and a pasta recommendation, which were both amazing. Excellent portions at a fair price. The teamwork concept of all servers helping each other was unique and exceptional. Definitely will eat here again!

Source: Google

Danielle Clarke

★ 5

Source: Google

Jill Baldwin

★ 3

Source: Google

Brenda M Caelwaerts

★ 5

This is a great family-owned pizza place. Great pasta also

Source: Google

Noel Crosslan

★ 5

Source: Google

Common Queue

★ 5

One of the best kept secrets about Green Bay is that it has two of the best authentic thin crust pizza places anywhere in the country (the other rhymes with Franky's). There is a reason this place has been around for decades and we always make a Sammy's stop (usually multiple) whenever we are in town. The gf pizza also stands up as one of the best and the spaghetti is also amazing.

Source: Google

Amy Proveaux

★ 5

We were in town for a tournament and many families recommended this restaurant. We came on our last day and thankful or my famliy would have been here everyday.
The food and service was AMAZING!
The homemade sausage and pizza are delicious!
Well worth every penny!!!

Source: Google

Scott Northway

★ 4

Great old-school Italian restaurant. Pizza and pasta was very good and the service was friendly and attentive. We will definitely be back next time we’re in Green Bay.

Source: Google

Espionne Russe

★ 5

Source: Google

Tony A. Hernandez

★ 4

If u want a great pizza this is the place. Price is a bit more than average yet I can say I'd definitely have another lunch stop here.

Source: Google

Scott Pasch

★ 3

Fantastic Pizzas. And they have alot of other stuff on the menu.

Source: Google

Donna Hall

★ 5

The service was great! The pizza was hot, fresh and delicious!

Source: Google

Michael Italia

★ 5

Source: Google

Rob Lovig

★ 5

Always a favorite stop!

Source: Google

Kelly Austin

★ 5

This place is great! I always love to try local restaurants when I travel, and Sammy's did not disappoint! Their pizza is fantastic!

Source: Google

Christy Hassinger

★ 4

Everything was pretty tasty, but the pricing of $10-20 per person is…quite off. My husband and I shared an app, he had a personal sized pizza, and I had a plate of gnocchi. We also had a desert to go. It was roughly $85 total after tax, tip, etc.

Source: Google

Tom Schweitzer

★ 5

Spectacular! We had a large House Pizza, spicy garlic marinara and baked penne and it was all fantastic. Even the salads were excellent. We will definitely eat there again.

Source: Google

Kathleen Blozinski

★ 3

I’ve enjoyed your pizza for 50 years but you’ve changed your crust recipe! We were told of this by others but wanted to see for ourselves. Please go back to the “old” crunchy thin crust recipe!

Source: Google

Jen and Damian Hilgendorf

★ 5

Very good pizza. Ordered it to go and it was ready fast and was very tasty. Employees were all very nice.

Source: Google

Kathleen Teal

★ 4

Source: Google

Toni Swinehart

★ 3

Waitress was nice, but the food was just okayyy.

Source: Google

Nathan Swinehart

★ 3

Source: Google

Aundra Green

★ 5

Source: Google

Rean Julian

★ 5

everything was super good and i just wish they have a grilled octopus

Source: Google

Torrey Kistler

★ 5

Great vintage feel restaurant. Will definitely make it a regular stop in my travels

Source: Google

Lightning prods

★ 5

Cinnamon sticks are awesome

Source: Google

jaybee n

★ 4

Really great itallian food, they do homemade meatballs and have key staple Italian toppings including anchovies. Enjoy their pizzas and pastas! Service could have refilled drinks to make it better.

Source: Google

Joshua Stencil

★ 5

Source: Google

David Martin

★ 5

Holy Cow! Best Pizzia i've had in a long time! Wonderful staff!

Source: Google

Devin Fisher

★ 4

The food was delicious. We had their Sausage Lovers pizza with double their perfectly spiced family recipe sausage and added black olives. We also tried their house made gnocchi and sauce with their house sausage and home made meatball. Everything we delicious and well worth any wait. Next time we’re in town, we’ll be back.

Source: Google

John Reynders

★ 5

Great pizza, thin crust with good sauce and great mushrooms

Source: Google

Christopher Greene

★ 5

I was in town for four days and we tried Sammy’s on the first night and ended up coming back two more times. The chicken Caesar salad was above average. The spaghetti and meatballs were excellent, as was the meatball sub. Their sauce is great.

Source: Google

Gary

★ 4

A favorite pizza place in Green Bay

Source: Google

Carleen Mansfield

★ 5

Source: Google

danielle Holtry

★ 5

Great pizza

Source: Google

D. M.

★ 2

Service was great! Sadly, the food was not. When you walk in you can tell this is a local favorite because of the crowd. Nevertheless, if you’ve traveled anywhere and had delicious Italian food, you’ll be disappointed with this restaurant. The portions are huge but don’t have that rich Italian flavor. My bolognese sauce tasted like a Chef boyardee can and my wife got sick from the sausage she ordered with her meal. The Cesar salad dressing had a weird flavor that didn’t taste like what you would expect. Maybe it was an off night for the business?

Source: Google

Shannon Winkler

★ 5

Source: Google

Patty Kubetz

★ 5

Genuine Italian Food! Prices were reasonable. Food (pizza) was amazing! The Cheesy Garlic Bread was awesome. The marinara sauce was perfectly balanced--not too spicy, tomato-y, or sour. The cheese was Wisconsin perfection, sausage was seasoned very well.

Great menu of baked pastas, sandwiches and pizza. Staff was attentive without hovering, friendly and courteous.

Source: Google

Samuel Shipley

★ 5

I literally travel once a year to Green Bay from Seattle WA to eat here as many times as I can (okay, and see family also). I've been a fan of Sammy's since bite zero. Summers spent in Green Bay as a kid, going with grandma and grandpa to eat at my favorite place. The pizza is heavenly with the thinnest crust, the best quality toppings, and yummy salads. Like I cannot say enough. Will forever love Sammy's, and its not just because my name either.

Source: Google

Kim Johnson

★ 4

Source: Google

Jake Lardner

★ 5

Source: Google

Allen Hentz

★ 5

The good here was very Good. The price and portion size was surprisingly economical. There was a enough food easily for two meals.

Source: Google

T H

★ 4

Service was great and we were able to get in during a busy evening. Bruschetta and breadsticks were delicious. The main entrees ordered were good but a little bland. Would be willing to try again and the pizzas looked really good!

Source: Google

Elijah Morgan

★ 5

This place has fantastic pizza, we got the Crazy Italian, if we didn’t have a full day ahead of us we wouldn’t have left with any left. And the Tiramisu? To die for, light and fluffy without being too overwhelming. I will be back.

Source: Google

Rob Meisenburg

★ 4

Was a decent place. Got seated right away. Food was pretty good. Prices ok. Service pretty good too

Source: Google

DaLaina Holliman

★ 5

Source: Google

kathygail shandor

★ 1

I ordered chicken Alfredo, I I opened up the box and looked at it. There was no sauce on it., Confused, I called, The manager was very rude and tried to tell me they put the Alfredo on there , I told him I would come down and show him the plate , He told me if I came down there and made a scene , he will call the police. I have a picture of this. I’m hoping I can find a place to put it on here because I put it on Facebook and nobody can see any Alfredo or chicken.! I just think they forgot, And he don’t want to admit it. And it was actually the only orders they had at the time!

Source: Google

Kevin V.

★ 5

Best pizza in Green Bay!Always great food and customer service!

Source: Google

Timothy Lohmiller

★ 5

Source: Google

Kay Moore

★ 5

Source: Google

Denise Chernoff

★ 4

Good Italian that is not a chain. We had the margarita pizza and soup.

Source: Google

Kevin Brewster

★ 4

Group of three for dinner service . I had the house sale with grilled chicken , it was fantastic with all fresh ingredients and good size for the price. I also had the sausage soup which was disappointing. The vegetables were overly cooked and mushy . The Italian sausage itself was tasty but didn’t go well with the over cooked vegetables. The other two shared a pizza and they said it was a tasty thin crust tavern style . I would come back for pizza and salad

Source: Google

Lori Bankson

★ 5

Carry out for a veggie pizza and a pepperoni to meet friends at a local brewery. The pizza and staff were phenomenal!! The veggie pizza was excellent and the crust was very well done.

Source: Google

Christopher Weems

★ 5

1st time here, i come from Wausau Wisconsin for the NFL Draft! I had a great experience and a great lunch! Great job!

Source: Google

LUIS MARTINEZ

★ 5

Close to the Stadium, best Italian Beef & Pizza in Green Bay. Waitstaff are quick and very friendly.

Source: Google

John Mendez

★ 5

Best place to get food in Green Bay

Source: Google

Andrew Hall

★ 5

Sandwiches are great.

Source: Google

Scott Brkich

★ 4

Source: Google

Matt Begley

★ 5

First off Liah and the staff were fantastic. Everything that we ordered came out great. The pizza the folks around us ordered look great and smelled great. We will definitely be back! Is this the best restaurant in Green Bay?…. probably so.

Source: Google

Jason Leiberg

★ 5

Source: Google

Michael Dade

★ 5

Great pizza, must try! Service was awesome.
Looking for an excuse to go back again

Source: Google

Mod Squad

★ 5

Love their pizza.

Source: Google

Paul Elertson

★ 5

Great place. I recommend the crazy Italian pizza!

Source: Google

Jim Klein

★ 5

Been driving by this place for years and today was the day. I feel foolish for not getting there sooner in my life. The pizza was great, perfectly cooked cheese of optimal amount. The sauce had flavor, wasn’t too thin, wasn’t too thick. My wife said the Alfredo was delicious and the sheer mass of the meatball made my child squeal. Would definitely go again.

Source: Google

Mixed Technologies LLC

★ 5

Source: Google

Deb H

★ 5

Source: Google

Andrea Elliott

★ 2

Went in with my daughter this week. The server was really nice but the kitchen messed up my pizza, so they tried to quickly redo it. An hour after I went home I got hit with a massive case of food poisoning that lasted 2 days. The pizza looked different than in the past, so I don’t know what it was but I couldn’t move once it hit me. In their rush to fix their mistake I can only assume that they undercooked it. Not willing to go through that again!

Source: Google

Haley Clausen

★ 5

Source: Google

Phillip Hamilton

★ 5

Seriously, awesome place, food was authentic and fantastic. You can tell the recipes were made with love. Will go back again the next time we are in the area. My boys loved the pizza and said it was on the next level. Service was extremely good and the place was spotless. Highly recommend.

Source: Google

Colin Piaskowski (HTA Colin)

★ 5

Having been coming to this place since I was a kid. Great pizza and cheesy garlic bread. The staff is courteous and hard working. The restaurant is clean and smells delicious at all times. Not very far from Lambeau but doesn't get the massive crowds that the sports bars in the area get. Not a place to "watch the game" but worth checking out if in the area

Source: Google

Ilain Vassilev

★ 5

Source: Google

James Cwiak

★ 5

Very good food and friendly service, would definitely recommend this place

Source: Google

Dedi Love

★ 5

Great pizza with fast and friendly service . Go pack go.

Source: Google

B K

★ 1

This has to be the worst Pizza in GB… just avoid it.

Source: Google

Krista Berg

★ 5

Source: Google

Kristin

★ 4

Appetizer was okay. The pizza was good (love the sausage). The tiramisu was outstanding. I would go back just for that.

Source: Google

Jacob Waldera

★ 5

Source: Google

Wop Thegreat

★ 1

Would not put crab raggoons on my pizza

Source: Google

Glenn Steeber

★ 5

Our pizza, salad, and drinks were tasty and arrived shortly after ordering. Waitress was friendly and kept checking up on us regularly. We will definitely return again.

Source: Google

Cindy LeClair

★ 5

Sammy's never disappoints

Source: Google

Steve Lapacz

★ 4

They charge different between cash and credit card. Though good, I may not be back.

Source: Google

Mike Davis

★ 5

Source: Google

Kirk Thompson

★ 4

Refreshing to have a different style of pizza. Not the style I prefer but I'm sure there is a loyal following.The side salad was really good and the service was great. One of the cleanest restaurants I have experienced.

Source: Google

Tim Thompson

★ 5

Best pizza i've ever ate.

Source: Google

Jacob Krawczyk

★ 5

Family owned and awesome food. The staff is very friendly and on top of their game. The food is very very good!!

Source: Google

Olina Ku'uwaki

★ 5

Food and service was great as always

Source: Google

Draz amataz

★ 5

Source: Google

JULIE KRUEGER

★ 4

First time to Sammy's. Very tasty pizza. Pricing is comparable to other pizzeria's in the area.. Welcoming atmosphere and ambiance.

Source: Google

Robert Nabak

★ 5

Excellent food and service. If you love Italian food this is a must place to visit. Pizza is also delicious,
But fair warning, this place gets busy so you might experience a wait to get a seat.

Source: Google

Cal

★ 1

This is my 3 time purchasing from Sammie’s.The pasta was good my first 2 visits.But yesterday I decided to try something different.So I purchased a takeout pizza and it was Very salty and didn’t have much cheese on it.It’s was a 16in sausage and cheese pizza.I strongly don’t don’t recommend they pizza.I Wasted $30.

Source: Google

David Deuel

★ 5

Just in town for a couple days. Had a delicious margarita, Caesar salad, and an Italian sausage, onion, fresh mushroom, and black olive pizza; it was great. Erika was my server and she did a terrific job. Comfortable atmosphere. I would definitely return.

Source: Google

Kevin Dean

★ 4

Source: Google

Nikola Nikitovic

★ 1

Very bad pizza. It is American restaurant 100%, no any similarities to Italy :)

Source: Google

Sabrina Oliver

★ 2

Typically when we go the pizza is great! The last few times were a disappointment. When ordering a pizza we typically like a slice of pizza… not 50 bite size soggy pizza pieces. Not sure if this is the new way of cutting their pizza? Or someone got cut happy, but definitely was disappointed for the money we spent.

Source: Google

Clarke Sanders

★ 5

Yummy food at a very reasonable price.

Source: Google

June Bugg

★ 1

Every one that was in the kitchen area was coughing and serving food place is disgusting. Also place is to expensive ordered a large pizza with some extra toppings it ended up costing $50 no way will I be back to this place

Source: Google

Matt Kerscher

★ 4

Pizza is good just not crispy enough for me. The rest of the food was very good and the service was excellent

Source: Google

Derek Dorr

★ 3

I have to say the food is excellent when they get it right. Would say 50% of the time when I get home with the food we find out the order is wrong. Problem is I live in Appleton so it’s not like I can run right back over there for them to fix it. They are sending me a gift card for the food that was wrong, but that doesn’t cover the gas that I used to get there. Also now I have to go and pay for other food to replace the food messed up.

Source: Google

Craig B

★ 5

Source: Google

Rick Y

★ 5

Our family goes to Sammy's for most of our special celebrations.

Source: Google

Patrick Rice

★ 5

First time there, pizza was pretty good the service was slow and the atmosphere was gloomy because of the slow survice

Source: Google

Noel Quinones

★ 5

Source: Google

Nick Brosz

★ 3

Very good pizza. Staff was great.

Source: Google

Jason Anatole

★ 5

Super nice staff. Great food. You won't be disappointed dining here.

Source: Google

Terri Williams

★ 5

Source: Google

Jason Berryman

★ 4

Ordered a large two topping pizza and even though it was very pricey, it was well worth it. Absolutely phenomenal flavor and baked to perfection!

Source: Google

tomTom

★ 5

Amazing food amazing service!

Source: Google

Barbara Boldt

★ 5

Source: Google

Matt Campbell

★ 5

Phenomenal pizza, friendly attentive staff. I think I’ve found my new Green Bay favorite restaurant.

Source: Google

Zach Dobson

★ 5

Parked here for the packer game paid $20 for parking. Received a $20 voucher for a meal after the game it was the perfect place to eat afterwards. Excellent pizza and their marinara and garlic bread is something that you have to order I will definitely be going back

Source: Google

Megan Greely

★ 5

Source: Google

Cora Meyer

★ 5

Source: Google

Cm 34

★ 3

Beautiful nice ambience clean, we order cheese garlic bread for an appetizer which was wonderful, I had chicken Alfredo which was honestly just okay definitely not seasoned enough the flavor on that was really plain, we also ordered pizza and so did our dinner guests we arrived with, we had sausage and mushroom the pizza really didn't have flavor to it either like it should and they cut our pizza in squares which is okay but some pieces were cut small enough for a baby, if your going to cut squares cut evenly please, otherwise the customer service was wonderful and the experience was overall nice.

Source: Google

Tyler Berenz

★ 5

Always Fantastic!!!! Walk in and they greet you with a smile and great service!!!! 10-10!!!

Source: Google

Jon Sturdevant

★ 5

We went to Sammy’s for dinner on a Friday night and the restaurant was really busy. They keep things moving and got everyone who was waiting seated in a surprisingly short amount of time. The great service continued after we sat down. Friendly and super fast all night!

We had the penne pesto pasta and the crazy Italian pizza. Both were delicious! We’re excited to try more of the pizza and pasta options.

Great Italian food with excellent service! Definitely a 5 star restaurant.

Source: Google

Sherri Schwefel

★ 5

Friendly staff and amazing pizza! The bruchetta was also very good.

Source: Google

Erik Schwarz

★ 5

Ordered the carnivore pizza for take out and it was very good. I would try this pizza spot again if I was in the area.

Source: Google

Wim vanderGraaf

★ 1

Misunderstanding handled poorly by owner.
I purchased a parking ticket for a packer game one Sunday at Sammy's and at the point of purchase I was given the impression that if you bring your parking ticket back you can park for a second time, so we went back to park there for a second game. We showed our ticket to the lady who was handling ticket purchases and proceeded to go park. The owner then stormed up to our car scowling and told us we had to purchase a ticket, I showed him we had a ticket tried to explain my previous understanding and inquire as to where the mix up came in, sadly the only explanation I received was snide remark about how he cant let people park for 10 games a year for 20 dollars(I only ever thought it was 2 games total). I would have been happy to purchase another ticket and chalk things up to the fact that I must have misunderstood, if he had just treaded me respectfully. I can not speak for the quality of food, but what I can say is that the owner is far from a pleasant person in my experience.

Photo for clarification that it does not say anywhere that it is one time use. And explicitly states that it does not expire till next August.

Source: Google

Christian Millhiser

★ 5

Source: Google

Louie Baez

★ 5

Source: Google

Ryan Braulick

★ 5

Love it at Sammy's

Source: Google

Jay Damkoehler

★ 5

A very good option for pizza and Italian cuisine. House made sauces and pasta. Family operated for generations. Friendly & attentive staff providing outstanding service. (I enjoyed their pizza as a teen and still enjoy dining there as a senior.)

Source: Google

Clive Holmes

★ 5

Got there late just before closing after a packers game and they were fantastic. Very accommodating and dinner was fabulous. What a great spot .

Source: Google

Darlene K

★ 5

This place was a great surprise. We chose it because It was right on the way to the Resch Center/Lambeau Field. So glad we did. The food was great! I was impressed with the serving size and great seasoning of each dish! The food was so tasty. Even chicken alfredo had some pizzazz!! (Finally a place that knows how to use seasoning. ) I liked the atmosphere, as it was clean, cozy but there was lots of room. Wait staff was efficient, and cordial and it was b u s y! We definitely will return ! Oh. After the concert, we returned for great tirimisu!!

Source: Google

Peter Sandoval

★ 5

Very friendly and helpful staff.

Source: Google

Shelby Engeron

★ 5

Source: Google

Raven Ortolan

★ 5

Went in for lunch with 2 young children. It was fairly busy for a weekday, but the service was great! Very friendly staff and food came out quickly. I can easily say this place has the best pizza we've had in Green Bay!

Source: Google

Barb Makoski

★ 5

Source: Google

Gabe Joshua

★ 5

From out of town stopped in for dinner and they have the best pizza ever. Amazing experience, would recommend 100%. Will be back soon.

Source: Google

Amanda S

★ 2

Ordered a pizza and salad. Got the salad after a few minutes. It was drenched in dressing. Looked more like a clear soup with a few lettuce leaves and cheese floating in it. No one came to see how it was so I couldn’t ask them to remake it with dressing on the side. Took almost 90 minutes for the one pizza to be brought out. It was raw in the middle and burnt on the edges. At least 5 tables were served and left before we got our food. They also sat us at a table in the hall. The entire night people kept kicking my chair. One time I was pushed into the table by a server who told me to get out her way. We won’t be returning.

EDIT: Yes, it is hard when, how did Sammy's put it "things don’t go as expected." Especially when we received uneatable food, no service, and injuries from being kicked multiple times by employees and patrons. It was hands down the worst experience at any restaurant we've been to. And no, I couldn't move my chair to another location since the only open chairs were on that side of the table and I didn't want my small child to experience the kicking and injuries.

Source: Google

Bob Strieter

★ 5

Source: Google

Tami Bethel

★ 5

Source: Google

Terryjo Rogers

★ 5

Best pizza in green bay

Source: Google

James Rice

★ 4

Source: Google

Sarah Jane Dannenberg

★ 5

Source: Google

Paula Fuge

★ 5

Source: Google

Kim Capwell

★ 5

Source: Google

Michael Murray

★ 5

Did was delicious. Got the gnocchi and it was the best I’ve had

Source: Google

Tracy Burke

★ 5

Source: Google

Christine Marusiak

★ 5

Pizza was great! Best ever tiramisu!!!!!!

Source: Google

Matt Cambray

★ 5

The best pizza in Wisconsin!

Source: Google

Janet Keough

★ 5

Always a great time and great pizza!! Have been going there for over 30 years!

Source: Google

Tyler Turner

★ 5

We were seated really fast and food only took 15 minutes even though they were super busy. The food was spectacular. And so was the waitstaff

Source: Google

Scott Bjergo

★ 5

This place is a must visit if your in Greenbay

Source: Google

Terry Ellis

★ 5

Source: Google

Anthony Ciaramitaro

★ 5

Source: Google

Todd Hoskins

★ 5

Food was great.

Source: Google

Sindy Reid

★ 5

Staff we're incredibly helpful and nice! 👍 Ordered an antipasto salad, and my husband actually ate it! The kids loved the pizza and so did I. Would come again 😋🥰

Source: Google

Tony K

★ 1

Source: Google

Robyn Koehler

★ 5

Excellent dinner last night! So glad you are open in Green Bay. I miss the Appleton location!! Best pizza ever 😋 One of my first job's was at Sammy's Pizza in Appleton.

Source: Google