Category
Restaurant Frozen food manufacturerDescription
Sheboygan Pasty Co. is a pasty shop operating within Ranieri's Four of a Kind Bar & Grill at 811 Indiana Avenue in Sheboygan! We feature hand made, from scratch pasties available hot and fresh Wednesday through Sunday. Our Products are now available in grocery stores around the Midwest! Stop in and visit us in the Wisconsin Products Pavilion at State Fair July 31-August 10, 2025 and try our State Fair EXCLUSIVE Peach & Blueberry Dessert Pasty! Our retail location will be closed during State Fair, however Ranieri's Four of a Kind will be OPEN with Frozen Pasties & Deep Fried Mini Pasties available!
Photos
Leave a Review
Reviews
Mark Wissmueller
★ 4
Who would have thought of a bratwurst pasty? Sheboygan Pasty Company of course. In a word, DELICIOUS!
Source: Google
Florence
★ 5
At the Wisconsin State Fair, I got a massive Sheboygan Pasty from their table and it was love at first flaky buttery bite! Inside was bratwurst, potato, onion, and cheese with zero empty space. Even after a whole day of fair food, I still made room for it and I'd do the same on my deathbed!
NOTES/TIPS:
**Super friendly staff
**In the Expo Center at the fair
Source: Google
Phil Lewis
★ 5
Source: Google
David Rindfleisch
★ 5
Source: Google
Elizabeth Pope
★ 5
Loved my Thanksgiving Pasty ! Got the last 2 for me and my Husband on our way to Greenbay for tomorrow’s game. Loved the lady who prepared them. She made sure we got gravy on the side to go. We scarfed them while we charged up at the nearby Tesla station. Tasty treats, great comfort food.Fresh food, clean bathrooms.
Source: Google
Richard Bontempo
★ 5
Wasn’t there bought pasties at Woodmans. Delicious.
Source: Google
Dennis Gazzana
★ 1
Bt far the worst pasty I've ever tasted.
Source: Google
David Finkel
★ 5
Very good Pasties...delicious desert pasties...they have Trenary toast....thimbleberry jam....great service. This place is a little piece of heaven/ home.
Source: Google
MistahZ
★ 5
Finally decided to get an order from Sheboygan Pasty Company and I was glad I did! Can't comment on the building or service as I got a delivery order, though the delivery driver was quick and polite! As for the food, I liked it all! Chilli and smaller pasties were very good! The main pasties were scrumptious and filled me up quick! Dessert items were good! My only complaints were the main pasties I got had a texture I did not like and the fudge was not that good but, that's it! Try The Pasty Company, I liked it!
Pictures and video are of the food I got!
Source: Google
Ted Keneklis
★ 4
Slow service
Source: Google
Audrey Harrison
★ 3
Usually these pasties are very good. Today I had one from my local grocery store and I was disappointed. Because there was so much meat, the juice from it ran out from it when I cut into it. And the bottom crust was soggy. Ones I have purchased before have been flatter, really good. This one was very rounded.
Source: Google
Randy Popp
★ 4
Source: Google
Richard Waldbauer
★ 5
Source: Google
Joy Vangalis
★ 4
Source: Google
James Paige
★ 5
Great crew of bartenders love going their when I'm in town.
Source: Google
chocolate nightmare
★ 5
Great service
Source: Google
Steven
★ 5
Source: Google
Jerome Duenk
★ 5
Source: Google
Duane Fischer
★ 4
No pasties but we each got a Mr. T steak sammy which is always delicious 😋
Source: Google
Vincent Reh
★ 5
As I write this, I’m eating a Mexican chorizo pasty that I picked up at the Piggly Wiggly in Oak Creek. It’s excellent!
Source: Google
Ryan DenDekker
★ 4
Source: Google
Linda Diedrich
★ 5
Source: Google
Jaime Berndt
★ 5
Source: Google
Mike Niemann
★ 5
Source: Google
T J
★ 4
The traditional was not as good as the one I got when I was in the UP, what was still pretty good
The Raspberry Nutella one was exceptional though
Source: Google
Erick Kivi
★ 4
Great pasty, almost as good as back home in the UP I come up from Milwaukee for these and it’s definitely worth the trip
Source: Google
Josh Bailie
★ 5
Very tasty pasty! If only they had steak!
Source: Google
Jack Kosmoski
★ 5
OMG - really good pastys. The best I’ve had. We’re going to go back and buy a bunch to bring home too.
Source: Google
Julie Dudzik
★ 5
Their breakfast pasty is yummy
Source: Google
Dawn Cee
★ 5
We bought their Pasty from Piggly Wiggly Sunday. Just had it tonight. OMG, it is delicious 😋 😍
Italian Sausage Pasty.
Try it!
Source: Google
Jenny Floria
★ 5
Some of the best authentic U.P. pasties you can get south of Marinette, MI. The Sheboygan pasty made w brats and cheddar is also a special treat. I ordered online and they were still warm when I picked them up. Yum!!!
Source: Google
Karen Fischer
★ 5
Source: Google
Fran Brion
★ 4
Good place.
Source: Google
Qadgop the Mercotan
★ 4
pretty decent pasties
Source: Google
Trevor Barnes
★ 5
Like your pasties, this is the place.
Source: Google
Jim Koehler
★ 4
Great food
Source: Google
mark miller
★ 5
Bought the take home frozen pasties. Traditional U.P. ones were amazing.
Source: Google
Bridget H
★ 4
I found this on google maps when searching for some interesting local food. I got the traditional u.p. pasty with beef, rutabaga, carrots and onions. It was exceptional and cooked to perfection. The crust is perfect, it's flavorful and tender without being doughy. With or without gravy, it's delectable. You can also get frozen ones to bake at home. I haven't tried the breakfast pasty yet but, I feel certain that I won't be disappointed. The chocolate "pasty" they sell is made elsewhere but, yummy. The employees offer service with a smile. I only gave it 4 stars because there is no atmosphere. I recommend ordering ahead and getting curbside delivery.
Source: Google
Andy
★ 5
Source: Google
John Michaels
★ 5
I had the Sheboygan. Great job! Really, REALLY GOOD! I loved the gravy as well!
But.... very salty, just the way I like it but maybe not for most.
Source: Google
Jessi F
★ 5
These pasties are delicious! I always loved Rainier’s 4 of a kind, so they continued their good food with the pasties! I will be back! Photos are of the Traditional with gravy.
Source: Google
Deb Streier
★ 5
Super friendly people. Prices were great.
Source: Google
David Rindfleisch
★ 5
Great Uper Food
Source: Google
Caleb Olson
★ 5
Source: Google
thisis hybrid
★ 5
Great flavour and generous sizes. A very hearty meal that reminds me of home.
Small prices and worth the trip. Found inside a dive bar at the very back hiding away is this special place.
Source: Google
Kyle Sterkenburg
★ 5
These Pasties are amazing!!
The Ternary Toast is awesome
Source: Google
Kurt Russell
★ 5
Source: Google
Beth Trotta
★ 5
Quick and friendly.
Source: Google
Richard Seidemann
★ 5
First time I tried their pasty. I was very satisfied. It had ground beef potatoes onions and rutabaga in it . Crust tasted like traditional pasty crust. Price very reasonable. If you like pasty I highly recommend sheboygan Pasty. I plan to go again.
Source: Google
Rachelle Margenau
★ 5
Source: Google
Wayne Sather
★ 5
I bought pasties for takeout. I grew up in Northern Minnesota and pasties baked by my mom were a fantastic staple. These are the best I have since my mom's. So glad to find a pasty almost as good as mom's.
Highly recommend.
Source: Google
Sandra Swatek
★ 5
Just had a bratwurst pasty with gravy, it was wonderful...I'll be back
Source: Google
Carl Diederichs
★ 5
Source: Google
Arlen Brunsvold
★ 4
Pretty local good pasties. Located inside Ranieris Four if a Kind bar.
Source: Google
jed tinkle
★ 5
Source: Google
charlie D
★ 3
Pasty crust was not flakey. Potatoes did not have much taste. No whipped cream on Pumpkin cheesecake as pictured.
Source: Google
Steven Burkey
★ 5
Best pasty ever!!!
Source: Google
Robert V Sarah Sr
★ 5
Source: Google
Ken Roelse
★ 5
Great pasties
Source: Google
David Curry
★ 5
Very good pasty. Tried the traditional and Italian. Fantastic! Also enjoyed the apple filled pssty for desert. Great priced meal and served quick. I will return!
Source: Google
Jay Janssen
★ 2
Source: Google
Andrew Netzloff
★ 4
Source: Google
Anthony Freeman
★ 5
True pasty bliss. We tried 3 of the 6 and all of them were incredible, perfectly cooked, and served within minutes of ordering. As if that wasn’t enough, they were also very reasonably priced. Go here
Source: Google
Joe Dunn
★ 5
Source: Google
Thomas H
★ 5
I can not tell you how much craftsmanship goes into each individual pasty. Hats off to the head chef for making these possible! Amazing flavors, really can’t go wrong with any of the selections.
Source: Google
Paul Steinmetz
★ 5
Excellent food I highly recommend this place .We usually will get our pasties from Ironwood Michigan we'll be going to Sheboygan now!
Source: Google
Bob Scidmore
★ 5
Excellent. Really good gravy too. Will certainly stop again.
Source: Google
Monica Thomas
★ 5
Stopped in and ordered pasties to take along on a picnic lunch. Pleased that there was a good variety of hot ones to choose from, including veggie and GF. Placed our order at the corner door by the pool tables. Service was fast and friendly and the food was phenomenal. Gravy was excellent too. The pasties are good sized and stuffed pretty full, so don't expect to be able to pick them up and eat them like a sandwich, especially if you want to add the gravy, you're gonna need a plate.
Source: Google
Dean Weiner
★ 5
Absolutely the best pasty's I've ever had, moist flavorful fillings with light pastry like bread. 10/10.
Source: Google
Keith Jacks
★ 5
Great to see Pasties in Sheboygan. So good. Tried a Raspberry Nutella desert pasty. WOW.
Source: Google
Randal Schmidt
★ 5
These were by far the Best Pasty's I have ever eaten
I can't wait to have them again!
Source: Google
Benji
★ 5
The pasties were delicious! As a fairly new company the variety of pasty is limited at this time. If you give them a call 24-48 hours ahead of time they can do some personalization if you don't like a specific ingredient inside.
Source: Google
John Beauvais
★ 5
Ordered an Italian and a Sheboygan and amazed how great they were. My dad came from Escanaba and we would always grab pasties while in the UP. I will say these were even better! Glad a 💎 like this was brought to Sheboygan. Highly recommended!
Source: Google
Mike Wollner
★ 5
Tried the reuben, the traditional, the breakfast, and the dessert pasties, and they were all OUTSTANDING! We also loved the extra gravy and sauce you can get to go with them. Loved the flaky crust, they are made to perfection! The staff was wonderful and friendly to talk to. We will definitely be back....would probably be their #1 customer if we didn't live so far away. We are pasty loving people!
Source: Google
Helen powers
★ 5
We had the original pasties. They were perfect! Keep up the great work!
Source: Google
Theresa Amundson
★ 5
Amazing! The traditional pasty is so delicious! Closed my eyes and for a moment, thought I was in St. Ignace, Michigan! The spicy Italian is really good, too! I will be back to try the rest of the menu! Thank you for the fantastic meal.
Source: Google
Clinton Lade
★ 5
As good or better than any I've had in the UP.
Source: Google
Dave Assmann
★ 5
I grew up eating pasties made locally in Southeastern Wisconsin. I truly like those, but they don't hold a candle to real UP pasties. The pasties here are authentic incredible UP pasties. I recommend this place to anyone. Brought my family up while visiting Sheboygan and the food and prices were awesome! We will be back(maybe tonight)!
Source: Google
Michael Finney
★ 5
Tried the brat and the traditional. Highly recommend both. A heads up though, these things are huge so bring a big appetite. They didn't chince on the meat either like some do. It was pretty awesome!
Source: Google