Category
Restaurant Bar Bar & grill Pizza restaurant Seafood restaurantDescription
Smitty's Overtime Inn in Tomah, WI, is the premier dining destination for Monroe County and surrounding areas. Our menu features mouthwatering fish fry, tender prime rib, juicy ribs, crispy chicken, fresh seafood, and handcrafted burgers—all made to satisfy your cravings. Don't forget to try our homemade pizza, served fresh until the bar closes! Whether you're stopping in for a hearty meal or a late-night bite, Smitty’s Overtime Inn is your top choice. Call us at 608-372-5499 to place an order or reserve your table today!
Photos
Leave a Review
Reviews
Jay Roberts
★ 4
Source: Google
Joyce Gaulke
★ 5
Our waitress was great in helping us make decisions on what to order.
Source: Google
David Foucault
★ 4
Source: Google
Michelle Humburg
★ 5
Nice, local, down to earth place. Delicious food!
Source: Google
L M
★ 5
Nice place
Source: Google
Rick Eagen
★ 5
Great place for food
Source: Google
Kelly West
★ 4
Source: Google
Tom Palmateer
★ 5
Source: Google
Donna Comens
★ 5
Well worth getting off the highway for!!! Great service and food!! Definitely be back!!!
Source: Google
Daryl Haack
★ 5
Source: Google
Wendy Baumgart
★ 5
The Fish dinner was very good! Waitress was very friendly and prompt with bringing the food to our table.
Source: Google
Mike Noha
★ 3
Source: Google
Timothy Jones Sr
★ 5
Great service and great food.
Source: Google
Brad D
★ 5
Source: Google
Bill Gardner
★ 3
Was a whole lot better last year... Last year 5 stars. Seems to have gone down a bit...
Source: Google
Tara Winter
★ 2
Very nice staff, food is not as good as we hoped for with the prices. Had a beer on tap and it tasted like a muggy basement, so not sure about the taps and how clean they might be.
Source: Google
Jim Steele
★ 5
Good meal
Source: Google
Aaron Waggoner
★ 5
Great bar except the salad bar compressor hummed so loud it hurt my ears
Source: Google
Marci Ward
★ 5
We came to town for the Badger Nationals. We have friends who live in Tomah. I wanted a fish fry. They suggested we go here. Fast service, nice salad bar, great food!! We loved it so much, we came back on Saturday night for the prime rib. It did not disappoint!! Reasonable prices on both nights. My bf said if we lived here we would be coming once a week. We now have an excuse to go visit our friends more often just so we can come eat here!!
Source: Google
jazmine jensen
★ 5
Super friendly staff! Lots of activities for kiddos. The bartenders and servers are so nice and helpful. The patio is perfect for keeping everyone entertained!
Source: Google
Richelle Walenton
★ 5
Got the house burger... then ordered a second one to go! SO!👏 MUCH!👏FLAVOR!👏
Source: Google
Steinbox82
★ 4
Quick, solid service. Great menu and very tasty food. Would definitely recommend. Daily specials and options for the whole family.
Source: Google
Scarrlet Harris
★ 5
Source: Google
Katherine Crawford
★ 5
My first time at Smitty's, and I have to say . It is the best atmosphere . And the ladies bathroom is decorated so cute decorated in Coca-Cola memorabilia. Our bartender was the best ! I recommend if you're in the area , or if you're not. try going to Smitty's you will not be disappointed.
Source: Google
Melissa Salmon
★ 5
Overall we love Smitty’s. Our family has been visiting for years. Amazing wings and pizza.
Source: Google
Jerri Marvin
★ 4
Source: Google
penny treanor
★ 5
Source: Google
Jason The Doodler
★ 3
Source: Google
Christine Morrow
★ 5
Source: Google
Ted H.
★ 5
We meet here once a month and have lunch. The food is good and the service is exceptional. Nancy takes care of it every time and knows exactly what we drink and what we usually order. She's fast, friendly and efficient she is a big part of why we keep returning.
Source: Google
Michelle
★ 5
Nancy was our waitress. She is outstanding! I had the steak sandwich with homemade batter dipped onion rings. My friend had the Philly cheesesteak. Best sandwiches we’ve had in a very long time.
Source: Google
Samuel Hilpertshauser
★ 5
Source: Google
Michael Clark
★ 4
Source: Google
Jessica Merkel
★ 5
Very kind & attentive staff, delicious salad bar, and steaks were cooked as ordered (good flavor too!).
Source: Google
J NELSON
★ 5
Go to place for a good steak and excellent service when I’m at Ft. McCoy
Source: Google
Kindra Georgeson
★ 5
Source: Google
Mike Dow
★ 5
Source: Google
Brett Haydin
★ 5
Excellent country bar and food. Best onion rings in Wisconsin!
Source: Google
Bourbon Fanatic
★ 2
Food was so-so. Service was good until shift change and a different bartender came in. The new bartender kept talking to a customer friend for 10 mins straight while my drink was empty
Source: Google
wesley schar
★ 1
A bit out dated. Food has gone way down hill. Feels more like an old bar. A bit dingy.
Source: Google
Janna Yahnke
★ 5
Source: Google
Shane Collins
★ 5
Great place for noon lunch
Source: Google
Sandra Bass
★ 5
We stopped to try somewhere new and they did not disappoint. Great food, reasonably priced and fast service. Great homemade onion rings too!
Source: Google
Kim Benson
★ 5
Source: Google
Wesley Lemke
★ 4
Source: Google
Steven Ray
★ 4
Source: Google
Jeff Lindley
★ 5
Great owner and bartenders. Food is really good, and has a salad bar.
Source: Google
Nate Kling
★ 5
Great burgers and onion rings, prompt service!
Source: Google
Mark Kwiatkowski
★ 4
It was a busier than normal Saturday evening. The wait staff was fantastic, they immediately conveyed there may be a delay in our order , which we knew and expected. Food was good, and actually came in a reasonable amount of time, considering there were two very large parties that ordered just before us. I will be back there again in the future.
Source: Google
Joshua Schulte
★ 5
Source: Google
Trisha Smith
★ 1
The food was probably some of the worst food I've paid for in a long time. It was fatty and had very little meat. (Ordered beef tips) the salad bar was sub par and was out of many things that we were told that they would not be restocking. (This was a Saturday night) dressings were watered down. Neither rof us ate our meals. Only good thing was the soups. Service was crappy as was the attitudes of the employees. Employees seemed overwhelmed with the 2 tables that were there. Wanted to like it but we won't be back.
Source: Google
SimplyNej
★ 5
Source: Google
Adam Aufdermauer
★ 5
Very friendly place and they really put effort into making food well.
Source: Google
Cheryl Hart
★ 4
Great food!
Source: Google
jim platt
★ 3
Source: Google
Brad Spoo
★ 4
Source: Google
Grace Kelly
★ 5
Fish Fry on Friday night! Rated #1 in Tomah..
Source: Google
Michael Winters
★ 5
Source: Google
Rose Bongiovani
★ 5
The food was amazing! LOVED the prime rib sandwich. Melted in yr mouth. The burgers were awesome. Best bloodys! Nancy the bartender/waitress treated us like royalty. Owner thanked us for coming. Prices can't be beat. A must go place.
Source: Google
Aleta Ramirez
★ 5
Source: Google
Mark Thomas
★ 5
Food was excellent. Table seating was pretty close to each other. Very noisy environment.
Source: Google
david swiatly
★ 5
Good was great service was good
Source: Google
Jack Pennoyer
★ 5
Immediately could tell this place was a local favorite with the number of people here when we showed up. I can't remember her name, but our hostess was friendly and made a good beer recommendation that I took her up on. Our waitress, Laura, was honestly holding down the fort and killing it out there! Extremely charismatic and warm even while working super hard serving my dad and I as well as several other much larger groups. Cheese curds were great, which says something being in the heart of a paradise for cheese curd lovers. The salad bar was well stocked and great, soup was clearly home made and hearty, and the pizza I got (rising crust) tasted incredibly fresh with the ingredients used. I would come back here much more often if I lived anywhere around, it's clear they got a lot of heart and great people working here.
Source: Google
Joe Castro
★ 5
They got great food good service really fun place to have dinner ✌️😎🇺🇸
Source: Google
Richard Morse
★ 1
The Pub is clean and bright and makes a good appearance when you walk into the place, I ordered the broiled scallops and was warned that they were small, but when my plate arrived, the size of the scollops brought new meaning to the word "small". It took 4 scollops on my fork just to make a small mouthful. They were rubery and in no way represented what scollops should taste like. My meal included a very skimpy amount of tatertots and the salad bar. The price of the meal was $22.99. I mentioned my dissatisfaction to the server and was told that I could "go down south and pay twoce as much". I also commented that for what I paid for the meal I shouldn't be leaving the place still hungry and was told that I should just eat more salad and soup. Salad and soup is not what I was paying for, scollops was what I was paying for. I would highly recommend that Smitty's Overtime Inn either take scollops off their menu or buy a product that is a real scollop. I would also recommend that the server be spoken to about her flippant attitude toward customers. I didn't leave the place as a happy customer.
Source: Google
Eric Schierl
★ 5
Service and food was outstanding !
Source: Google
US
★ 5
Source: Google
Denise Holt
★ 5
Food was great, friendly efficient service. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone!
Source: Google
Barb Eirschele
★ 5
Very good food, had the supreme Pizza last night it was amazing, love seeing Nancy bartend and Connie cooking, great place
Source: Google
Matthew Kelzenberg
★ 5
Source: Google
Yvonne Mccaffery
★ 5
Source: Google
Erik Hannigan
★ 5
Great little bar, the old fashioned were great and the burger I had for lunch was really good too. I would definitely go back
Source: Google
Gregory Boyer
★ 5
This is another down-home Wisconsin bar that happens to serve great food, The atmosphere is very cozy & outdoor themed with all types of mounts on the walls. Cannot say enough about their walleye for fish fry Fridays. You probably should call for a reservation on Fridays.
Source: Google
Bird
★ 5
Very clean, spacious and great vibes!
Source: Google
melissa dyer
★ 5
Traveling from ohio to South dakota and saw the advertisement in the hotel. This place couldn't be any more friendly! The waitress was kind and helpful (we forgot our readers) and the dining room is clean. It is a bar that serves food. Great Experience!
Source: Google
Janice Fleming
★ 5
Great food good prices good service
Source: Google
Sam Dooley
★ 5
Source: Google
Jes Myren
★ 4
Moms day Buffet was ok, nothing fabulous. The desserts were absolutely amazing though!
Staff/Service were amazing: prompt, involved, kind, friendly and welcoming.
Source: Google
Lynn Miller
★ 4
Source: Google
Megan Erickson
★ 5
Source: Google
Eric Gunn
★ 5
Great Friday Night Fish Fry
Source: Google
Andy Wahl
★ 5
I'm totally surprised at the good service. Place is off the beaten path and was blown away with the quality and quantity of It's food, and Alexis needs more help-Did an awesome job tending the bar, and the only waitress, hope they pay her double for tonight's turnout. Finally found good fried chicken in the Tomah area. Katie Rocks!!!!!! We would like to see WiFi as an availability.
Source: Google
Todd Jacoby
★ 5
Source: Google
Bryan Grefsheim
★ 5
Source: Google
PaulReilly Company
★ 5
Loaded Bloody mary was me and my wife's lunch
Source: Google
Bryon Hembd
★ 5
Source: Google
Ian C
★ 5
Fantastic food! Seriously where did they find this chef! Great service from staff, and well kept atmosphere. Worth the detour to check out!
Source: Google
Ryan Schecky
★ 5
Amazing hidden gem.
Source: Google
Diana Metz
★ 5
Source: Google
J
★ 5
Awesome place great food. We came in late but very friendly fast and great food!! Steak and shrimp were great!
Source: Google
Jeff Townsend
★ 5
Great food...
Source: Google
Tom Dietz
★ 5
Love this place! Great food, service and atmosphere. Always eat here when in the Tomah area. Highly recommend!
Source: Google
Andrea Z
★ 5
We went for Friday night fish. The only reason 4 stars were given instead of 5 on atmosphere is only because there were so many people in a fairly small space. Other than that, the restaurant was clean and the fish was amazing!
Source: Google
Jennifer Arsenault
★ 5
Source: Google
Greta Gearing
★ 5
Source: Google
Donnie Urban Jr
★ 4
Source: Google
Toni Boals
★ 1
Have been here before and the quality of food and service is poor now!
Source: Google
Jami Oleksy
★ 5
Hostess was incredibly sweet and helpful. All staff was amazing! Will definitely be back! Food was GREAT!
Source: Google
Andy Truscott
★ 4
Source: Google
Jim Germain
★ 5
Outstanding burger and friendly staff
Source: Google
Danielle J Hesselberg
★ 5
Source: Google
Pat Kieltyka
★ 3
Pretty nice place. Went there after the cranberry festival. Would go back. Very friendly nice people there. Atmosphere is excellent if you like heads of animals on the walls lol
Source: Google
dawn hitchings
★ 4
Source: Google
Randall Ellison
★ 5
Source: Google
Brian Martin
★ 5
Went to visit family in Wisconsin first time here ever the ribs were fall off the bone awesome.
Source: Google
Yuriy Prikhodko
★ 5
Delicious food at good price. Came out fast and really hot. Potatoes just tasted fresh like they just came out of the farm. I really enjoyed the chilly soup as well so highly recommend that. Has a nice kick of black pepper.
Plenty of space for semi truck to park so if you are a trucker it's worth coming here if you are in the area.
Source: Google
Janice DeJ
★ 4
Local dive bar but the food and friendly staff will surprise you
Source: Google
Teresa Dahl
★ 5
Source: Google
mitch boettcher
★ 5
Top tier for a small town eatery and bar. Very impressive it still has a salad bar and entrées from simple to above average. The service is great and I have always been welcomed by the locals. Definitely would tell a friend to try it out.
Source: Google
Dave 'Jr'
★ 5
Stopped in on a Sunday late around 7pm, just the time when most restaurants kick ya mediocre food and send you on your way. Can't remember our waitress' name but she was a godsend. Told us she was filling in due to a call off and had been there all day. She was phenomenal. Took care of us and two other packed tables who both arrived same time as us.
Food is awesome, drinks are strong, the place is really clean and had a good atmosphere. Definitely worth driving off the highway for.
We had the loaded tater tots for an app, highly suggest them.
Source: Google
Jacob St. Peter
★ 5
Source: Google
Justin Schultz
★ 5
Great food
Source: Google
Brent S
★ 5
Source: Google
Chris Heffel
★ 5
Source: Google
T F
★ 5
Source: Google
Madge Waege
★ 5
Good food. Excellent service
Source: Google
Roxanne
★ 5
The food was delightful, Had the prime rib queen cut. We shared one, perfect amount of food between two people, with an extra salad purchased... And the onion rings were delicious! The waitress was attentive, friendly and helpful. Will be back! Even the other diners were friendly.
Source: Google
John Laflamme
★ 4
Source: Google
Debbie Dooley
★ 5
Source: Google
Bret M
★ 5
Source: Google
Wilma
★ 5
Didn't eat, just had drinks, but food did look good.
Source: Google
Dale Hepp
★ 4
Source: Google
Heaven Sent Pet Cremation
★ 5
Always great food
Source: Google
Made in America The Rabolds
★ 2
Went here this morning, wanting their Sunday buffet. Guess what, no buffet anymore. I was so bummed. I just got a grilled cheese, ate and left. The bartender was very nice but this is more of a local hangout than a option to eat something different.
Source: Google
Haley McCormick
★ 5
Fun local restaurant. Staff is always friendly. There is a Bar area and dining area. Food is so freaking awesome. Fish fry is to die for. Burgers are supremely yummy 😋. You gotta try this place.
Source: Google
Jessalyn J
★ 5
Source: Google
Seth Johnson
★ 3
It's 50 50. Here, food is usually good but getting service can be a challenge. Multiple times my party has left after 10 plus minutes of not being seated. But everyone is great and i understand the challenges of today.
Source: Google
Deanna Syverson
★ 5
My son said "mom this is the best food ever" ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Source: Google
Betsy Koenig
★ 5
Great food, no waiting, friendly staff.
Source: Google
Gayle Holbrooks
★ 5
Source: Google
emmah nesja
★ 4
the shrimp is pretty good ngl
Source: Google
Dane Bezemek
★ 5
Source: Google
S Schulze
★ 5
Clean local joint, great service.
Source: Google
Garrett Crandall
★ 1
Steak was overdone and my wifes ribs were very dry. Not very good and service was awful as well. Second time to try this place but it was a better atmosphere than the first time at least.
Source: Google
Sherry Mitchell
★ 5
Source: Google
Douglas Price
★ 5
Off the beaten path but worth the drive
Source: Google
Donovan Dolph
★ 5
Amazing place, can't say enough good about it. Menu, service, price, people, all Amazing
Source: Google
Dean Hull
★ 5
Source: Google
Doc Coleman
★ 5
Very comfortable, the keeper made you feel right at home,,🤓doc, 🍎
Source: Google
Paul Mashak
★ 4
Very good food and service. When working in Tomah, I go there almost nightly for supper. Cheaper options for food as well as higher end foods. Very friendly waitresses.
Source: Google
Jeri Kraus
★ 4
Source: Google
Kenneth Lobenstein
★ 4
Entree was good, but the soup and salad bar could have used some help.
Source: Google
Mitch Marohl
★ 4
They were very efficient for the friday crowd of deer season. Fish was good as well especially for the value!
Source: Google
Al Stern
★ 5
Source: Google
Jason
★ 5
Source: Google
C Cr (Topher's)
★ 5
Great place for food
Source: Google
Duane Rich
★ 5
Great food at a reasonable price, atmosphere is lots of fun, owner and employees are really neat
Source: Google
Patrick Zeczycki
★ 4
The 2 piece cod dinner came with choice of tater and soup/salad bar. Clam chowder was good, lasagna soup was very nice. Salad bar was fresh, had normal toppings and plain fix'ns. Cod was broil or deep fried. got fried. yum for all. the baked potato was the size of a small melon.
Source: Google
Jim Cozad
★ 4
Definitely a locals hangout. We went in for dinner. Overall, no one in our group was overly impressed. I had the special of the day sirloin tips with mashed potatoes and gravy. The mashed potatoes were good, definitely homemade as was the gravy. Sirloin was pretty dry and not much of it. For the price it I would have liked more. The bartender was very attentive considering we weren't locals. Sure the atmosphere is better if this is your hangout.
Source: Google
Leroy Nofsinger
★ 3
Source: Google
Tim Rowe
★ 5
Source: Google
Melonie Lamb
★ 5
We love this place ❤️
Source: Google
Daniel
★ 5
Good pizza with lots of cheese!
Source: Google
Crystal Wagner
★ 5
The food was awesome
Source: Google
WARREN G
★ 1
I was in Wisconsin on business and the group wanted to go out and eat, let me remind you I'm in shootem up neck of the woods. We walk in they look at me like "BOY do you know where you at"! Enough said so I played it a safe with a burger 👀
Source: Google
Aaron Ruland
★ 5
Had a couple of drinks here. The beer was ice cold! The food menu looks good will have to stop by and try it out sometime.
Source: Google
Beth DeFilippo
★ 5
Great food and service is good. But sporatic
Source: Google
Sam Olson
★ 3
Great service but my burger was not very good
Source: Google
Jason Young
★ 5
Good food but no vegetarian burger options. Tap list was small but the best I found in Tomah. Wait staff was talented and personable
Source: Google
Mark Hall
★ 2
Source: Google
Philip Doherty
★ 4
Great walleye and cod, service rocked! Salad bar impressive except buns were super dry. We survived, actually enjoyed it and will be back!!
Source: Google
Patricia koebel
★ 2
Source: Google
Eric Panora
★ 4
Source: Google
Kendra Weigen
★ 4
Source: Google
Vanessa Pooler
★ 2
Menu not up to date and fish fry special doesn’t start til 4p. Had gyro (had tomato, pepper, onions on it) and prime ribs sandwich (had nothing on it but meat) with au ju sauce. Taste more bread then sandwich. Waffles fries are not seasoned. Jalapeño poppers were good.
Source: Google
Jeffery Pels
★ 3
Source: Google
Les Millard
★ 5
Great food and service.
The cranberry old fashioned was awesome.
Source: Google
JQUEST
★ 4
Nice out of the way spot. Service was friendly and parking can be tight on a busy night. Food was good.
Source: Google
P Nussbaumer
★ 5
Wonderful food and service
Source: Google
Billy K
★ 4
Source: Google
Paul Muehlberg
★ 3
Source: Google
Josh Muehlberg
★ 5
Source: Google
John Carlson
★ 5
Great food and service
Source: Google
Kim McCarty
★ 4
Good food and friendly people
Source: Google
Duwayne Sime
★ 5
Great food and great people who work there.
Source: Google
Peyton
★ 5
If I could add more stars I would
Source: Google
Patrick Schacht
★ 5
Fabulous Food whether stopping for a Fish Fry or other succulent specials such as Prime Rib or Chicken 🐔 !!
Source: Google
josh a
★ 5
Best prime rib!
Source: Google
Cindy Evans
★ 5
Philly cheese steak with au juice for dipping and fries,crispy not greasy.
Source: Google
Joan Anderson
★ 5
Had the blue cheese wrap, excellent. Bartender/Server was great!
Source: Google
Nadia Kira
★ 5
We had pulled pork sandwiches and a kids grilled cheese and kids chicken tenders with my family of 4. Great food, great prices. Our hostess was amazing, friendly and kind. Felt very comfortable with my two young kids there.
Source: Google
Jeff Turinske
★ 4
Great food and service minimal wait times great drinks.
Source: Google
David Lappier
★ 5
Smitty,s Rocks!!! Stop in and have a Drink a Bite to eat and enjoy the awesome Staff plus the Exellent company like Grace and I have done. We Will Be Back!!!
Source: Google
M
★ 5
The food was excellent, staff was very friendly. Highly recommend stopping for a great meal and drinks! We will definitely be back!
Source: Google
Naomi McMullen
★ 5
The Friday fish fry is great
Source: Google
Valerie Hanson
★ 5
Source: Google
Jess Hutzler
★ 5
great place. good variety of tasty food. by the way the staff is very friendly.
Source: Google
justin piggott
★ 5
New place for me. Was great burger with prim rib on top. Wow. Definitely going back.
Source: Google
Nick Dobberpuhl
★ 5
Source: Google
Lexx L
★ 2
Had great service. 2nd time my daughter and I got diarrhea after eating here. Will never be back.
Source: Google
Mistie Baldwin
★ 5
Dinner was good. service was great. I enjoyed the fish.
Source: Google
Jess A
★ 5
A little off the normal route but so glad we made the decision to stop. Food was great, prices fair and the staff were very pleasant! Excited to go back again and try something besides the salmon and prime rib. The soup and salad bar was a nice appetizer.
Source: Google
Karla Oitzman
★ 4
Amazing prime rib dinner on saturday nights
Source: Google
Julie Leis
★ 5
Source: Google
Phyllis Carlson
★ 5
Very good lunch, nice place.
Source: Google
Lori Schmidt
★ 5
Awesome fish fry, great waitress !! Huge beers!!!
Source: Google
Denise Brabham
★ 5
Source: Google
Brittany Hample
★ 5
Source: Google
Melissa Boon
★ 5
Yummy food, great atmosphere!
Source: Google
Brittney Cossette
★ 5
Owner is very Nice seafood platter is delicious Alfredo is to die for beer cheese soup was amazing and salad bar was great I highly recommend everyone to check them out if your looking for great food for a reasonable price. Also you get alot of food for a decent reasonable price. Super delicious we will return for more of your yummy food.
Source: Google