★

From beginning to end, our meal and service was very good. Prompt, efficient and friendly staff, good ingredients, happy to make accommodations. While I would have preferred a cocktail, they are waiting on their liquor license and had a wide variety of beer, wine and fun other options including sake and cocktails made with champagne or involved NA cocktails. The caesar was very good (dressing on the side) and the pizza we had was a very good sourdough crust that was perfect for folding, Neapolitan style. So good!

Source: Tripadvisor

★ 5

We had a lovely overnight stay at the St. James Social. Brand new rooms and space. The public use sauna was a wonderful perk of the stay, and we were also able to enjoy the rooftop outdoor lounge area before the thunderstorm rolled in. Rooms are small but cozy, and little touches like a turntable and vinyl records made the experience feel special. For those who aren't tech savvy, the check in process is completely remote and registration was necessary before arrival. Although it was nice to be able to have access early, I did miss not having an actual person to talk to when we arrived. I would certainly stay at the SJS again in the future.

Source: Google

★ 5

Exceptional accommodations! Loved the rooftop patio. The morning coffee bar/English style breakfast perfect way to start the day. The homemade pizza in the restaurant was incredible. We wished we could have experienced another meal there…next time :)

Source: Google

★ 5

Went there for eats after our son's wedding. Good food and atmosphere.

Source: Google

★ 4

Room furniture arrangement could be better for casual seating. Coffee maker was confusing and did not create a good cup Ii f coffee. Place was super clean . Rooftop patio was a very nice ammenity.

Source: Google

★ 5

Wonderful! It was a bit uncomfortable at first to have contactless check-in but it ended up being no problem at all. The space is extremely well done with amazing attention to detail ! The food at the restaurant is exceptional AND DO NOT MISS the roof top lounge!

Source: Google

★ 5

Wonderful stay at St James Social. The hotel room was clean, comfortable and well appointed. The rooftop patio was beautiful, the sauna was a relaxing feature and the restaurant downstairs was delicious. We really had a nice time here.

Source: Google

★ 3

Source: Google

★ 5

Great stay ..excellent service .. loved it

Source: Google

★ 5

What a lovely place! We greatly enjoyed the wonderful hospitality, quaint feel and the charcuterie-like breakfast. The two that owns SJS even left a little treat for our celebration! We enjoyed the sauna both nights and the rooftop space - both wonderful.
We also loved the food! Amazing flavors and the right amount of portions.

We asked for a new sheets because it looked like dog hair was still on them. The owner seemed upset over the phone, but it was taken care of - so I went with 5 stars.

Would 10/10 recommend!

Source: Google

★

Atmosphere was great, they really did a good job with decor. The vision of the restaurant is great, food was good but mediocre- service was a bit slow too. If the food stood out a little more and the service was quicker I’d give it a 4 or 5. They have some work to do.

Source: Tripadvisor

★

Nice restaurant centrally located in downtown Bayfield - great space with good size bar area. Small hotel located above. We went on a Tuesday (pizza night). Drink menu is beer, cider, wine and THC beverages. No hard liquors, but cocktails were pretty and inventive. Plenty of NA options. Menu was limited to salads and pizzas and unfortunately the kitchen couldn't keep up with the dining room. If the waitstaff had acknowledged the long wait time when we sat down and offered a complimentary appetizer or beverage it would have made a difference. The wait for 2 good (not great) pizzas was close to an hour. Service while friendly, was understaffed. Would try again on a "regular" menu night...

Source: Tripadvisor

★

The bar and restaurant were hopping on a Saturday night. We didn’t have reservations so we sat at the bar. The very personable and attentive staff made us feel welcome. The owner made a special effort to make us feel welcome. We loved the contemporary ambiance and background music. We had attended music on the waterfront and were looking for a lighter bite. We split the house Caesar salad and the el pastor tacos. The Caesar is probably the best one I’ve ever had. The tacos were meticulously crafted and oozed flavor in every bite. When I return to Bayfield I will return to the St. James Social. Wonderful experience from start to finish.

Source: Tripadvisor

★ 5

Bayfield has held a piece of my heart since the first time I visited — it’s a place full of nature, art, and community treasures. Saint James Social is a perfect new addition to that spirit.

Our retreat group had the joy of dining here, and the hospitality from the family who runs it was truly special. The pizza was incredible, the space was welcoming, and it was clear that so much care has gone into creating this experience.

I’m already looking forward to coming back — next time to stay in their beautiful hotel. Grateful for this new gathering place in one of my favorite towns.

Source: Google

★ 5

Our stay at St. James Social was restful, indulgent, and inspiring. We enjoyed the delicious European-style breakfast, beautiful rooftop views, and luxurious amenities. A family trip to Bayfield was made extra special thanks to St. James Social!

Source: Google

★ 5

A delightful spot in the quintessential charming town of Bayfield. The owners did an extraordinary job renovating this historic property. If you want a modern, hip inn and restaurant with a cool vibe, the St. James is the place to be!

Source: Google

★ 5

Staying at this hotel is like staying with friends in the best possible way. You just feel so welcome and like you’re at home.

The rooms are gorgeous really tastefully designed. the bed is gigantic and so comfortable sometimes I didn’t wanna get out of it!

But it was worth it to get up because every morning there was also a beautiful spread of food from local producers. Every morning delicious.

The location is amazing. Bayfield is beautiful. There’s plenty of parking but honestly, you’re probably gonna want to eat and drink at the restaurant downstairs for every meal.

This was an incredible, restful, friendly experience, and I would come back every time I’m in Bayfield.

Source: Google

★ 5

Absolutely the ONLY place anyone should even consider staying at if you're visiting the beautiful Bayfield Wisconsin. The building is beautiful and cozy, and it compliments the cozy charm of the town as well. But, what really sets it apart are the owners. Genuinely some of the kindest people people ive had the pleasure of meeting.

My wife and I chose SJS to celebrate a deeply meaningful milestone - her successful fight with breast cancer. Having recently completed chemotherapy and radiation, we needed somewhere to go to decompress and reflect and just reconnect with each other - without the ever-looming presence of her illness, which was our life for the last year. Truly the most difficult chapter of our lives. My wife saw Bayfield and knew it was the perfect choice for us. Best. Decision. Ever. The owners were prompt and gracious for anything that we needed and the quality of everything was just MILES above anything some big chain hotel could ever offer. We loved our stay.

Even with one mishap on our part (our sweet but, unfortunately anxious, rescue dog chewed up their really nice/comfy duvet) - the owners were so gracious and understanding, they told us we didnt have to pay for the replacement despite us being fully willing to cover the damage. They were extremely compassionate and gracious, especially to our pup, and it made an impression on us. We are extremely grateful.

To the owners: Thank you. You made a real difference for us during a time when we finally had the chance to decompress and gather ourselves back up and, for that, I am truly grateful. Our trip was perfect! My wife and I truly wish you all the success in the world and hope that your establishment is around for many, many years to come because we will be back! (But, maybe we will leave the pup with a dog 'sitter next time! 😅😅)

Thanks again.

Source: Google

★ 5

Good place for dinner.

Source: Google

★ 5

So glad we chose to stay here. Walking distance to everything you’ll need for a 3 day weekend

Source: Google

★ 5

Absolutely loved our stay at St James Social! Can’t wait to return

Source: Google

★ 5

Fabulously designed, quite beautiful and incredibly run. The owners are fantastic, they care so much and it shows. Eat at the restaurant too! Highly recommend.

Source: Google

★ 5

What an amazing experience. Rooms were a great blend of design and technology. The "food to table" restauarant not only has a great vibe but creativity rules. Grilled Bone Marrow! Really! Wines were well chosen as are the beers and cider. The European style breakfast was a favorite with well sourced cheeses, charcuterie and more. My final accolade is to the staff. Genuine caring hospitality. And a great location.

Source: Google

★ 5

Fully enjoyed my stay. The rooms are quietly luxurious with comfortable beds and lovely appointments. Location is excellent, being the heart of downtown Bayfield with access to everything.

Source: Google

★ 5

This beautiful, historic gem is a must-see when visiting Bayfield, WI.

Steeped in rich history and vintage charm, it welcomes you the moment you walk in—evoking a sense of nostalgia and appreciation for the past. Thoughtfully updated with modern touches, it strikes the perfect balance between timeless style and contemporary comfort, all while preserving the architectural soul of the building.

Whether you're sipping a glass of wine or enjoying a memorable dinner with a friend, the experience is nothing short of magical.

Source: Google

★

We loved our visit! It's a beautiful place, with a very good restaurant, a great sauna, and a comfortable room. The breakfasts were perfect, and we had a fine meal one night at the restaurant. We'll be back! Even with chilly weather, we enjoyed the rooftop deck. It's a handy location for everything in Bayfield.

Source: Tripadvisor

★ 5

Spent two nights here--divine! Beautiful place with a great sauna, rooftop deck, and a lovely room. Prompt, helpful service. No hesitations about recommending it.

Source: Google

★ 5

An exceptional experience! The St. James Social goes above & beyond to create elevated hospitality from every level - from gorgeous design to creature comforts. I will absolutely return there and recommend it to anyone visiting Bayfield.

Source: Google

★ 5

This is a review for the bar only. What an absolutely beautiful space and great example of adaptive reuse. Whilst we didn’t eat the menu looks incredible with something for everyone. Loved that they had a thoughtfully curated NA menu.

Source: Google

★ 5

Absolutely incredible stay at the St. James. The space is wonderful, has great history, and the modernization of the building was well thought out. Can't say enough good things about it, and will recommend it to anyone going to Bayfield area.

Source: Google

★ 5

Everything about St. James social is perfect and lovely! From the personal welcome, attention to detail, delicious food, and gorgeous rooms… we could not have had a better stay! Our favorite things included the spa style bathroom, the N.A. cocktail menu, and the sauna!

The location is excellent- walking distance to restaurants, coffee shops, the water etc. Easy parking (even during a surprise snow storm!)- the owners are so incredibly welcoming and kind. We can’t wait to return!

Source: Google

★ 5

We had an amazing stay; the location, the accommodations, THE FOOD, were all spectacular! St. James Social, set a beautiful stage and made my proposal/engagement that much more magical. Eternal thanks and we WILL be staying here every time we visit Bayfield!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Didn’t stay here but went to the restaurant and oh my.. it’s a slam dunk. The staff are incredibly intentional and friendly. The food was fresh and flavorful. Specifically, the gluten free sourdough pizza crust was truly one of the best crusts I’ve ever had. The vibe offers a special, unique setting and the record player is a nice touch. And I can only imagine if the restaurant was this good, staying here would surely be a highlight as well. Highly recommend this spot during your visit to Bayfield!

Source: Google

★ 5

We had the best cozy get-away for our mini honeymoon at the St. James Social, and cannot recommend it highly enough! Rooms are trendy, cozy, and immaculate, with thoughtful little touches and details. The sauna was a highlight, as well as the coffee bar, and delicious European-style continental breakfast, and the soaking tub in our bathroom. It was just what we needed for relaxation and refreshment, and we enjoyed meeting the owners at the pizza restaurant on the main level too - they are so kind! We will be back!

Source: Google

★ 5

This was the perfect getaway spot. The room was very comfortable and stylish. The morning snacks were so thoughtful and delicious. The restaurant was also great! We went there for dinner 2 nights in a row. We will definitely be back!

Source: Google

★ 5

Although the room was small, it was well-appointed. The decor is modern, chic, and simply classic. We enjoyed listening to Christmas music on the turn table and looking out at magical Bayfield as it snowed.

Source: Google

★ 5

Fantastic stay in this beautiful boutique hotel in central Bayfield. Close to everything in a great location to explore the shoreline of the Apostle Islands National Shoreline Park and Madeline Island. Communication from the owners was excellent making self check-in a breeze.

Source: Google

★ 5

Such a special and quaint place to stay! The bedding, decor and hospitality are outstanding!

Source: Google

★ 5

Spent a night during shoulder season with my husband and we had an amazing time♥️. The hotel owners are clearly passionate about delivering a truly unique experience for guests staying at their meticulously restored hotel in Bayfield. Food, design, community, rooftop deck, and SAUNA to boot. This place is THE place to stay when visiting! Give the winter a try, it will not disappoint 🙌🏻

Source: Google

★ 5

The St. James Social was an amazing weekend getaway! We cannot wait to visit again. This is now our go to whenever we visit the Bayfield area.

The Check-In & Check-Out process was super smooth for it’s all done through their online portal. The owner does an amazing job replying and accommodating to any special requests.

We had dinner at the restaurant and it was AMAZING. Gluten free options made my dinner one to remember, and I was so excited when I heard they offer gluten free pizza.

The European continental breakfast alongside with the coffee bar was a convenient and healthy start to our mornings!

Lastly, the rooftop had amazing views of Lake Superior and the sauna is the perfect spot to relax after a long day of hiking.

Source: Google

★ 3

My husband and I visited Bayfield for our 40th wedding anniversary - we had honeymooned there. We chose this hotel because we wanted something less stodgy than the Rittenhouse, but still in Bayfield proper. I waited several weeks to share a review to see if our initial impression of our stay changed with some distance. Ultimately, our initial reaction remained: It may be a good fit for some, but for us, it was a disappointing $400/night decision that felt more like an Airbnb than a boutique hotel. We had a two night, midweek stay.

The pros: the location is close to ideal. It’s a short walk to the shore and the shops are close at hand. Off-street parking is available, albeit across the street in a grassy lot that was twice blocked by
delivery trucks. We were fortunate to have good weather and our luggage (and us) stayed dry and warm on our walks to and from the hotel. There is an elevator. The room was clean and there was a mini-fridge. Although we could occasionally hear the elevator, there was no guest noise from the hallway or adjacent room. The bed was comfortable. There was a decent WiFi connection. We appreciated that the exterior appearance of the original building was largely maintained.

The cons: I think we had the smallest room; it was the smallest hotel room we’d ever had. This probably influenced our satisfaction quite a bit. There was no closet or luggage rack, just a freestanding metal rack next to the bed for clothes that required hanging. The queen size bed and credenza took up most of the space; a small boudoir-size chair was the only seating other than the bed. Every noise from the bathroom could be heard. The absence of a human at check in and throughout the stay felt off putting - the text messages with the check-in code and stay updates contributed to the Airbnb feel. It was not clear prior to arrival that we would need to rely on our phone for check in details via text or email. We did wonder how a low or no-tech traveler, or one with a dead phone or no signal, would manage. If we had needed assistance with our luggage, there did not appear to be a luggage cart or other assistance available.

The neutrals:: the Parachute bedding and towels were fine, but not noticeably different. The LP player is probably a novelty for many, but we have one. We ate one meal at the in-house restaurant, which was fine, but we were disappointed to learn that it only serves beer and wine. The rooftop space was pleasant, but smaller than I expected from the photographs. We opted not to use the sauna but from a quick look inside, it seemed clean and well maintained. The recommended temp of 165 is lower than what we prefer but is probably a realistic recommendation for many guests.

Conclusion: this fits a niche for some people, but for us and our lodging expectations, it was a disappointment. It could be a fun place for a group of friends or couples who would be more inclined to use the sauna and rooftop as common spaces. The supply of lodging options in Bayfield proper is limited, and room rates obviously will reflect that.

Source: Google

★ 5

The Pizza was excellent. Very friendly staff. Highly recommend.

Source: Google

★ 5

I had dinner at St. James Social and I had the best genuine experience from the owners themselves. They are very customer focused, ensuring that you have an enjoyable experience and that everything is to your satisfaction. They put people first and because of that, St. James Social will have a long and successful future in my opinion!

Source: Google

★ 5

Outstanding taste and service! Definitely the best of Bayfield! Annalisa is an inspiration and represents the best and future of this community! 💞 🥂 ✨

Source: Google

★ 5

St. James Social made a lovely time in Bayfield even better.

Source: Google

★ 5

Absolutely loved St.James Social! It was a perfect place to stay for some time away as a couple. The rooms are gorgeous. All of the details in this building are beautiful. We also thoroughly enjoyed our food at the restaurant. We were fortunate enough to meet the owners while they were both working behind the bar in the evening. Really enjoyed hearing about the history of the building. We will definitely recommend this to our friends and would love to come back again soon. Thank you!

Source: Google

★ 5

We stayed at St. James Social for our honeymoon last weekend and had a wonderful time. You can tell an incredible amount of thought, care, and attention to detail went into the renovation. The hotel is comfortable, clean, and modern while maintaining a classic charm. The owners and staff are friendly and very helpful. So cool that it’s a family-run business! Plus, they surprised us with champagne to celebrate our honeymoon. Everything about our stay was perfect. And you can’t beat this location! Amazing view from the rooftop.

Source: Google

★ 5

Worth the splurge! Perfect location, loved the sauna and rooftop deck.

Source: Google

★ 5

What a gem! Beautiful renovation, very peaceful vibe with curated touches...the sauna, the rooftop deck. Steps from the marina in Bayfield, they have their own restaurant for dinners but you are close to everything. So relaxing after kayaking, sailing, hiking and just enjoying the area!

Source: Google

★ 5

The horel is beautiful and the food was excellent. It is in a perfect location. The staff were great. Would definitely stay again!!!

Source: Google

★ 5

I cannot remember the last time I've loved a place so much that I booked my next stay before leaving but Saint James Social made me do it! If you love historic charm, luxury finishes, refined but relaxed design and sincerely warm hospitality you need to quickly book one of the eight rooms here! Our room was so inviting that it was hard to leave - muted colors, blonde woods, antique brass finishes, a bed layered in beautiful Parachute bedding, a record player with vintage albums, a large marble and zellige tile bathroom and dimmer switches for days to create the perfect atmosphere. The scale of the hotel made our stay feel more like being in a friend's huge, opulent home than being in a hotel. All the rooms are on one spacious floor and at the end of the hall there's a very well outfitted and stocked coffee bar with a traditional coffee maker, several French presses, Antler coffee and Rishi teas. I loved padding down the hall early, making coffee and taking it back to our room. The downstairs bar/lounge and restaurant is so beautiful and delicious and the owners, Annalisa & Cody, so kind and welcoming that we went there both nights, which we would normally not do. We also used the heavenly sauna and carried breakfast up to the spacious rooftop deck to enjoy a view of Lake Superior one morning. Perfection across the board. We're already looking forward to our visit next August!

Source: Google

★

We loved this restaurant! Eclectic and tasteful furnishings, lovely ambience (no loud music), wonderful service. Though the menu is simple, the food is artfully prepared and so delicious. The service is ultra friendly and efficient. Highly recommended.

Source: Tripadvisor

★

My wife and I and another couple decided to try St. James Social for an evening meal and none of us came away disappointed. By offering three or four entrees, and changing them frequently, the chef's originality and concentration on quality comes through. Two in our party ordered the tenderloin filet, which the chef prepares using the sous vide (soo-VEED) method, and each declared it to be the best tasting tenderloin filet she's ever had. The wine selection is small, but of very high quality. (My glass of malbec was superb.). We'd award four out of four stars for this restaurant.

Source: Tripadvisor

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Great stay at the St James. It is a beautiful space - elegant and at the same time warm, welcoming, and comfortable. Super clean. The rooftop deck is a huge asset - loved hanging out early in the morning for coffee and in the evening after dinner. Responsive and friendly staff. The Margherita pizza is one of the best we’ve ever had! (In their first floor restaurant.). Location is ideal. Would stay there again for sure! Pretty quiet on Sunday/Monday - all contactless process for check in and communication.

Source: Google

★ 5

Best coffee ever!!!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Well done renovation of the building! We only had dinner and did not stay at the boutique hotel. Food was well presented and we enjoyed wine, a charcuterie and a chateaubriand. Dessert at the bar. Nice evening. $$$$

Source: Google

★ 5

Beautiful hotel with wonderful staff! We loved our time here. It is close to everything. The staff is friendly and goes above and beyond to help make your stay enjoyable. The restaurant had great food and a great atmosphere. We definitely will be back!

Source: Google

★ 5

Our new favorite place to stay in Bayfield. The building is close to everything! It’s been redone so beautifully. The room was beautifully appointed and so peaceful. The rooftop space is the best for coffee, reading, listening to the live music at the marina. Could not recommend it more.

Source: Google

★ 5

The St James Social is BEAUTIFUL! You can tell the owners put their heart and soul into the renovation. The finishes are stunning and the decor and design was lovely. We loved the Parachute towels and linens!

The location was perfect! It was so nice to be close to everything. We enjoyed the restaurant one night and had delicious pizza. We loved the rooftop deck, especially for morning coffee :)

We would recommend the St James Social to anyone visiting Bayfield!

Source: Google

★ 5

Great hotel! Amazing building design and decor! Perfect location! The most comfortable bed ever!

Source: Google

★ 5

What a cool hotel and a great location! Would highly recommend this hotel to others!

Source: Google

★ 5

Very nice place! The buildout is amazing, the food amazing and the hospitality was great! Will definitely come back another time. Also had a great time talking with the owners to top it off!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Loved St James Social! We went on Thursday and had the appetizer special of the evening Blackened Trout Tacos with a roasted potato salad (local trout from Lake Superior), the Socialite Pizza, and sorbet for dessert. I cannot praise enough about the experience, everything was so delicious and perfect for two to share, our server Jen was a sweetie and the aesthetic of the place was so modern and gorgeous. Can’t wait to go back!!

Source: Google

★ 4

We stopped in had drinks and dinner. The pizza was delicious, drinks were first rate, The Trout tacos were a let down more cabbage than meat. The potato salad was nice on the pallet.

Source: Google

★ 5

Stayed for 2-nights in May and revisited the cocktail bar in June. The owners and staff are very invested in providing a great experience for their guests. The interior designs and furnishings of the rooms are extremely tasteful and high quality. Great option for those that want to lean into the outdoor adventures around Bayfield but stay in more upscale and modern accommodations.

Source: Google

★ 5

Their boutique hotel is adorable, we loved our night stay. The rooftop view was beautiful. The sauna was toasty. And the food at their restaurant was so tasty!!
Stop there if you make it that way!!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Had an amazing stay, the room was beautiful and clean, exactly as pictured. Bed was very comfortable and we enjoyed using the sauna and playing cards on the rooftop. The food at the restaurant was excellent! The house made gelato and chipotle infused cherries are a must try.

Source: Google

★ 5

Had drinks here one night, came back for dinner the next. Staff is amazing, very friendly. Food was absolutely amazing! Prices are great as well. Favorite place in town.

Source: Google

★ 5

I can’t say enough about this place. I road-tripped to Bayfield recently in hopes of catching the Northern Lights. I stumbled upon the SJS Hotel website and gave them a call. They had availability and enthusiastically welcomed me to stay. Co-owners, Cory and Annalisa, suggested viewing the lights from their rooftop terrace and mentioned a sauna on the second floor. You had me at availability, I thought, intrigued by such 5-star amenities and service in a small town. Annalisa texted me check-in details and info on parking and the roof terrace. I arrived late but everything was crystal clear. The room was impeccable...clean, modern, cozy...plus a turntable (respect!). The rooftop terrace was amazing, offering a front-row seat to Northern Lights on full display! In the morning, I poured a fresh coffee and hit the sauna down the hall with windows overlooking Lake Superior! I enjoyed a delicious cinnamon roll in the gorgeous restaurant/bar on the main floor. I had an opportunity to chat with Cory and Annalisa (super friendly!) and shared pics and stories of the Northern Lights. These guys clearly love what they do...and they’re doing it right! Kudos! Can’t wait to return!

Source: Google

★ 5

Great location, great staff, great food, great cocktails and love the rooms! There was even a record player to add to the charm. Make sure you check out the views from the rooftop and make time to have a latte or coffee in the restaurant.

Source: Google

★ 5

My wife and i stayed here over mother's day weekend and fell in love with the place. The bed and bedding were so comfortable and welcoming after a long day of travel and sight seeing. The meals prepared in the restaurant were unique and so so delicious. The location is perfect for enjoying this beautiful little town. Seeing the northern lights from the rooftop patio was icing on the cake.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

This is a gorgeous rehab of an historic hotel. It is absolutely stunning inside!

Source: Google

★ 5

My husband and I just stayed at the St. James Social for our first anniversary, and it was truly the best hospitality experience we have ever had! I absolutely loved the design of our room, the restaurant and the entire building. It was aesthetically pleasing and visually comforting. I could tell that so much care and thought went into the amenities like the sauna, coffee bar, soaker tub, Parachute robes, towels and bedding, Grown Alchemist and Beautycounter products, having the letter of James in the room, having little cookies waiting upon our arrival, and I could go on and on! We were also amazed by the service at the restaurant! I didn't even remember putting on our dinner reservation that it was our anniversary, but four different people working in the restaurant wished us a happy anniversary! That is unheard of! The food was amazing and we were surprised with two free desserts for our anniversary! We got to interact with both of the owners during our stay and they were both incredibly kind, helpful and welcoming. Many locals asked us where we were staying and we were proud to say we were staying at St. James Social! There is nowhere else we would have rather stayed in Bayfield. We are in awe of the experience they provided and we will definitely be back! I truly cannot say enough about this place!

Source: Google

★ 5

If you are looking for a weekend getaway place....this is it. The rooms are nice and large and well appointed. Dogs are welcome. Sauna is first rate. Rooftop affords views of harbor and islands. The food and service downstairs are first rate.

Source: Google

★ 5

Beautiful rooms and public spaces, very comfortable beds and overall stay. Everything was clean and in excellent shape. The owners were on hand, attentive, friendly, and clearly care about the St. James Social. Plus, the sauna was clean, beautiful, and hot! What's not to like?

Source: Google

★ 5

St. James puts the emphasis on ‘Social’. ☺️ Such a delightful place to stay! Our room was cozy and well appointed, nourishing and beautifully crafted food & cocktails, and a sauna just for hotel guests. The owners and staff are happy to help in any way - we had a great weekend. Thank you!

Source: Google

★ 5

Finally had a chance to have dinner here, and I'm so impressed! The food was wonderfully prepared and more creative than anything I've ever had in Bayfield. Don't skip dessert, again some really fun and delicious takes on classics. The space is modern but still cozy - a perfect hangout. My husband and I will be frequent visitors. St James really elevates the Bayfield experience!

Source: Google

★ 5

My husband and came here for a one night get away. All of the staff and owners were extremely friendly and accommodating. The room had everything we needed, and the food was amazing. We were so so happy with our experience!

Source: Google

★ 4

We have visited St. James Social in the morning for delicious coffee, in the afternoon for a glass of wine, and twice for their Tuesday Pizza nights - wood-fired and the best in Bayfield. Great vibe and friendly staff, and I will be back!

Source: Google

★ 5

Birthday Dinner party. The dining area was handsome and spacious. The food, Appetizers, Dinner and dessert, were delicious and presented beautifully. The service was friendly and efficient.

Source: Google

★ 5

Had a nice stay! The room was beautifully designed. Coffee bar was fabulous and the sauna with rooftop access to cool off was a perfect touch on a winter stay. Wonderful hosts!

Source: Google

★ 5

Visited St James Social to explore Bayfield in the Winter with a friend and we couldn't have picked a better place to stay! While our goal was to hit the trails and have a fun place to come back to after, we ended up ditching our second planned hike for sauna time at St. James and to enjoy the food & atmosphere!

The rooms themselves are really beautiful and thoughtfully designed, clean and comfortable and an excellent deal for the price, especially midweek in the winter. Just outside you can find a coffee bar and sauna, complete with a cold plunge shower directly inside the sauna (easily one of my favorite sauna experiences in the Midwest!). The rooftop lounge was closed for the winter, but I'd bet that's fantastic in the summer as well.

We were around on wood fired pizza night and got "the socialite", a mozzarella, arugula, asiago, sourdough (made with starter from local Bayfield apples I'm told!) drizzled with balsamic. The menu might be small, but St James Social more than makes up for it with quality.

Despite a small staff the service was excellent and everyone was extremely friendly and helpful! St James Social does a really excellent job of creating an environment that feels upscale and fancy without feeling pretentious, all while staying true to its Northwoods roots; you really get the feeling that all are welcome here, and we didn't feel out of place in our hiking clothes.

St James Social is walking distance to pretty much all of downtown Bayfield (which is really just a few blocks!) and the perfect basecamp for winter adventures. If you're planning on visiting in the off-season, I recommend snowshoeing/hiking the Meyers Beach Sea Caves trail above the ice caves (accessible year round whether or not the caves are frozen), Adventure Club Brewing for brews in an igloo, and hitting Mt. Ashwabay for skiing, and detouring to Washburn to Cafe Coco for breakfast.

Overall this was a really awesome stay and experience, and I would highly recommend it to couples or girls trips as a basecamp for exploring Bayfield!

Source: Google

★ 4

We didn't stay we came in for drinks. The owners were running the bar and were very friendly.

Just note that it's not a full bar, it's wine, beer/cider, and THC drinks. Note most of the Cocktail offerings were THC based and they did show what the mg were which is probably nice. As someone who can't use THC it was a bit disappointing that there were so few other options. Over all a nice upscale but chill vibe.

Source: Google

★ 5

I had morning coffee and dinner at the restaurant (did not stay in the hotel).. so I'll review that:
Very nice atmosphere and the food was amazing.. (the menu changes daily for dinner)

Coffees are all espresso based, with a small daily pastry selection.

Source: Google

★ 5

One of a kind stay in the heart of town. Highly recommend!

The rooms are gorgeous with comfortable beds and linens, and the owners have thought of all the small touches. Cozy robes and a state of the art sauna, coffee bar, roof deck, and easy access to online check-in and keyless entry. It’s a memorable stay in one of our favorite towns. After our third stay, we will definitely be back!

Source: Google

★ 5

This place is exactly what Bayfield needs. We stayed here over Thanksgiving and were blown away by how beautiful the space is, and the thoughtful touches that went into everything. It’s clearly a labor of love. We had a large family dinner in the restaurant, which was delicious and left everyone feeling very taken care of. Don’t hesitate to book the St James for your next visit to Bayfield.

Source: Google

★ 5

A wonderful boutique hotel!

Source: Google

★ 5

What a fantastic, beautiful place! Annalisa was the perfect hostess. You have to experience the view from the rooftop and the sauna was so relaxing. Can’t wait to go back:)

Source: Google

★ 5

My wife and I had a wonderful stay at the St. James Social this past weekend! We stayed there for our babymoon and were absolutely blown away by how nice of a job Annalisa did with the building. The decor and furnishings all felt very up-scale and looked beautiful. The linens were all Parachute brand which added to the high-end feel. The large sauna was amazing. Rooms were quiet. We did pay for the reserved parking, but ended up not using it because we were able to find free parking on S 2nd St even closer than the reserved parking would have been. We would highly recommend booking a stay here if you are in Bayfield!

Source: Google

★ 5

This place is STUNNING! I am someone who absolutely cares about where I stay; the ambiance, and comfort at St. James Social is truly unmatched. Being in the heart of downtown Bayfield, you’re steps away from cafes, restaurants, and the boat docks. The beds are incredibly comfortable, the rooftop deck is gorgeous, and I loved being able to enjoy French press coffee in the morning. Checking in and checking out was seamless, all from your phone. The host was available via text or call and they responded quickly to any questions we had. I cannot wait to come back and check out their social lounge! I’m so glad we found our go-to place to stay in Bayfield.

Source: Google

★ 5

Our anniversary getaway to Bayfield and St. James Social was absolutely perfect. The hosts were so helpful and accommodating. Our suite was quiet, cozy, and luxurious from design choices to the provided linens and toiletries. We also enjoyed the sauna and rooftop lounge. St. James Social is in a fantastic location for enjoying all that Bayfield has to offer and every detail has been thoughtfully put together. We look forward to seeing it once all construction is complete and will undoubtedly be back!

Source: Google

★ 5

We breathed a sigh of relief on travel day 6 as we checked in to this NEW and tastefully detailed lodging. Sparkling clean, smartly designed, quiet, comfortable (a top-notch bed!) and friendly. We enjoyed 2 evenings relaxing on the upper deck and easy walks to every restaurant and the waterfront. No question: we will return!

Source: Google

★ 5

What a very special place! I have been coming to Bayfield for years, stay just once in awhile. Had a chance to stay here this week and I was just wowed! The rooftop patio is so very special, the rooms are well-appointed and the coffee and tea service in the morning was a very special touch! Will certainly stay again!

Source: Google

★ 5

Incredible experience across the board at St James Social. Wonderful owners/hosts, lovely guests, beautiful accommodations and location is very convenient. The sauna was an extra perk. Modern minimalist with every detail thought through, you can tell this hotel was created with experience in mind. Stay if you haven’t 🤍

Source: Google

★ 5

We had a great time staying at St. James Social in Bayfield. The location was perfect, right in the heart of town. The bed was incredibly comfortable, like sleeping on a cloud. And I couldn't help but admire the beautiful artwork throughout the property. Truly a delightful experience!

Source: Google

★ 5

If you are looking for somewhere to stay in Bayfield, WI, look no further!!! The St. James Social is in the heart of downtown Bayfield and within walking distance to restaurants, shops and the Madeline Island Ferry. Upon arriving at this beautiful boutique hotel we were greeted by the owner who shared the story of the hotel and why it was so special to her. She took the time to give us a tour and shared about the hotels amenities including the sauna, coffee bar and rooftop patio, all of which were amazing! Each of the rooms was unique, the beds were coziest hotel beds I have ever slept in, and the shower and toiletries were luxurious. I can't wait to see what the lobby bar looks like when it is complete. We will definitely be back to stay again!

Source: Google

★ 5

Soft opening so there wasn't much in the way of common areas but the rooftop deck had a great view, people seemed to be using the beautiful sauna and the coffee counter was great and coffee top notch! So glad for the elevator, which is quite rare in Bayfield!!

Source: Google

★ 5

Amazing experience here!! Very thorough attention to detail, very prompt and friendly communication with questions/concerns, and the location can't be beat. The kind of place that will leave you not wanting to stay anywhere else in Bayfield. One note, do keep in mind of the 'Social' in the name of the place-things like the coffee bar, sauna, rooftop terrace are communal and may require you to interact with strangers the old fashioned way!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

I’d have to echo everything Heidi said in their review. This place is a beautiful gem in the heart of Bayfield. I can’t wait to see the fully finished product. Would highly recommend a stay here while in town!

Source: Google

★ 5

This place is amazing. The owners thought through each detail. The rooms are very spacious and spotless. They have even a vinyl record player, which brings you to the romantic mood right away. The location is perfect 5 min walking distance to everything.

The have a very cozy rooftop and sauna.

This hotel is a real gem.

Source: Google

★ 5

We absolutely loved our stay! Very comfortable, amazing bedding and location!

Source: Google

★ 5

Quaint boutique hotel in the heart of Bayfield, WI. Our King Deluxe fit our family of four comfortably. Even though it's still under construction, the place was spotless. I can't wait to go back and see it all completed. Nice sauna. Record player in the room was a perfect touch. Highly recommend!

Source: Google

★ 5

St James Social is a premier lodging experience. From the moment you set foot in the building, you are immersed in luxury and surrounded with thoughtful touches. The rooftop patio has views of Lake Superior that will complete your vacation…magical!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

The St. James Social experience was far beyond a 10 score. The check in is easy, the hotel is exquisitely designed, with impeccable workmanship. I know many folks may not notice the detail but we do and we did notice every little detail of beautiful furnishings with lovely linens and a very very comfortable bed with thick, full and luxurious king size pillows , fabulous flooring, sophisticated colors that please the eye and soothe the soul. The sauna, coffee/tea bar and rooftop lounge area are spectacular features and so appreciated in a hotel stay!!! The rooftop not only provided a beautiful panoramic view of Lake Superior but a fresh, clean and relaxing social space to enjoy. The entry point is securely coded with ample room for entry with luggage. There are a couple other delightful and nostalgic surprises that I did not reveal-enjoy! We are already planning our next stay and look so forward to enjoying the main level lounge as well. Thank you for the great service and attention to detail provided!

Source: Google

★ 5

Stunning personal details to the property. This place is great, we really enjoyed the rooftop patio, unique coffee and tea bar, and we can't wait for the lounge to open!

Source: Google

★ 5

Amazing property run by amazing people! Great location in Bayfield. Hard to find a better place to stay.

Source: Google

★ 5

Beautiful new space, very thoughtfully restored, with every detail considered. The sauna is an oasis in the heart of downtown. Can’t wait for the community and visitors to experience this new local gem!

Source: Google

★ 5

Beautiful new hotel in the heart of downtown Bayfield. Amazing sauna & private roof top patio!

Source: Google