STAGS Tavern

Germantown, W187N12793 Fond du Lac Ave, Germantown, WI 53022, United States | ★ 4.7 (167 Review)

📞 +1 262-677-1994

Last Search

Category

Restaurant

Description

Welcome to Stags Tavern! We take pride in our menu, offering a delectable selection of food that will satisfy any appetite.
Check out our impressive drink menu. Including craft beers, wines, and signature cocktails. Whether you're looking for a casual lunch, an after-work drink, or a place to celebrate a special occasion, Stags Tavern is the perfect destination. Let us transport you to the world where great food, great drinks, and great company come together.

Photos

 STAGS Tavern
 STAGS Tavern
 STAGS Tavern
 STAGS Tavern
 STAGS Tavern
 STAGS Tavern
 STAGS Tavern

Leave a Review

Reviews

Melissa

★ 5

Source: Google

chili monroe

★ 5

Source: Google

Sue Yourich

★ 5

Source: Google

Mark J Steinberg

★ 5

Source: Google

Dawn Jaquith

★ 5

Source: Google

luis sosa

★ 1

Stopped in for the first time ever for lunch. Bartender was good. Was there for over 40 min got a drink and did not get my food while several other people that had ordered after me got their food and they where done eating. Finally had to tell the bartender that i just needed food to go.

Source: Google

Dave Sauter

★ 4

Philly cheese steak!!!! Excellent 👌

Source: Google

Pat Haunfelder

★ 5

I can see why they have a great rating. The food is excellent. We will be back!

Get the homemade chips and onion dip! Yum

Source: Google

tm3389

★ 5

Hidden gem. Place is plenty big, great outdoor area and the food is fantastic. Wings, pizza, chili, fries, burgers are all good. Very nice bloody Mary also.

Source: Google

Rick D

★ 5

Source: Google

Steve

★ 5

Source: Google

Marc J

★ 5

Good service, great food. Only suggestion is better sound dampening. It can echo a bit when it's loud.

Source: Google

Craig Walker

★ 5

We have visited twice and enjoyed both visits. Good tap selection at a reasonable price, mostly mainstream beers. Food has been good both times. Wings are sizable with many sauce options. Philly cheesesteak was excellent, and I lived for a while outside of Philly, so I have a reference. Highly recommend Stags if you’re looking for a high-value dining experience.

Source: Google

George Goetz

★ 5

Source: Google

Kristie Wolff

★ 3

Source: Google

Jerry Grosenick

★ 5

Best Cheeseburger I have ever had!! Friends wanted to come here and I am glad they did. Delicious and good service.

Source: Google

Bryanna Stahmann

★ 5

Food was delicious definitely worth the price

Source: Google

Nate Pratt

★ 5

We were out of towners stopping in for lunch, and this place did not disappoint! Our server was the only one in the restaurant and she still took care of everything and the food was fantastic! Would absolutely go back anytime I’m in Germantown!

Source: Google

Rick “Eric” Miller

★ 5

Source: Google

jay geiger

★ 4

Sunday afternoon/evening…. Late lunch/early dinner. Pizza special was great, Greek salad was amazing. Bartender (guy) unfortunately didn’t catch his name was awesome! This place is a solid bar for good food, service and atmosphere.

Source: Google

Chris Coggins

★ 5

Source: Google

Leeanne Munyon

★ 5

I dont live in Wisconsin anymore, this fish fry and Brady Old Fashions were the best. Potato pancakes with applesauce!

Source: Google

Andrew Loescher

★ 5

Source: Google

aaron semrow

★ 5

Source: Google

Steve Potter

★ 5

They know what they are doing in the kitchen! Great food

Source: Google

Darrell Sontag

★ 5

A busy, fun upbeat energy - volleyball was rocking! The food was delightful. Service was on point and iur server was very pleasant. The outdoor searting was relaxing and great conversation space.

Source: Google

Heidi Zoesch

★ 5

Our waitress was so friendly and helpful, not to mention the service was fast. She anticipated menus for our young boys and took care of our special requests. We've been here before, and we will be back.

Source: Google

ellyn harrer

★ 5

We were there tonight with a party of 6
Ashley was our waitress
She was awesome
Catered to our every need. 🍸 were super reasonable and the food was excellent
Everyone was friendly
Will definitely return
And they take reservations

Source: Google

steve schuette

★ 3

Source: Google

Martin Piagentini

★ 5

Source: Google

Todd

★ 4

The food was very good here!

Source: Google

Maxwell Wilson

★ 5

Source: Google

Robin Sherman

★ 5

Best baked cod and BEST potato pancake anywhere! Great value for your money. No frills and laid back atmosphere.

Source: Google

Robert Duchow

★ 4

Feel bad as they were training a waitress!! We waited a while....long while to order. Was not busy but we will give them another shot. Food and drinks were good. Nice cozy neighborhood bar. First part of stop not good, second half a good recovery!! We will try again. I know staffing is an issue everywhere!!

Source: Google

Derek Fell

★ 4

Source: Google

Maureen Ramsey

★ 5

Ashley was an excellent server. Bonus points for putting up with my husband's humor!!! 😅 Both are of us had baked cod, very good! Huge portions. Good fries, good potato pancakes.

Source: Google

Cynthia Maree

★ 5

Source: Google

RAYMO5509

★ 5

Source: Google

Mike F

★ 5

Source: Google

Dave Fleegel

★ 5

Source: Google

Raymond Raske

★ 5

Source: Google

avcchris

★ 5

Wasn't too sure after some negative reviews. I think some people complain too much today, lol. When we walked in, we were greeted right away. It was just my daughter and I, and we got seated almost right away. Waitress was at a table right next to us, so whispered she'd be over in a minute. We ordered drinks and a clam chowder. We then ordered fish fries. The clam chowder was very different, almost a little spicy but very good. The fish and potato pancakes were excellent, as was the service! We definitely will go back.

Source: Google

kim scheel

★ 5

Have been there multiple times. Everytime I've tried something different on the menu. Their food is delicious. Would recommend Stags to everyone if you want Great food, Service, and Everything, you won't be disappointed!

Source: Google

Andrew

★ 3

That was funny I called and asked if their fish was wild caught or farm raised and the girl just stood there on the phone and never thought of asking someone since she didn’t know. Then she hung up when I asked if anyone in the world would know. 😅🤣

Source: Google

John Bublitz

★ 5

Great experience and the fish fry was good! Will definitely be back

Source: Google

CPG Young G

★ 5

First time was welcoming ill be back

Source: Google

Wayne Hendricks

★ 5

Source: Google

Mark Beck

★ 4

We stopped to check this place out and were pleased we did. There was an app special going on so we ordered a number of different apps and all were great. Great place to stop for a few beers and a bite to eat.

Source: Google

Bailey Hutchings

★ 5

The fried chicken is absolutely delicious, with tons of seasoning, and the sides are amazing. Service is always amazing and the drinks are delicious. Always a must try when you're in the area!

Source: Google

Kevin Daywalt

★ 2

We continue to read good reviews from Stags and the Food we have had was good.
Service is a different story; I have been there with other people three times, two for lunch and once for diner, and each time the service was not good. The final one was last night. We arrived about 6 o'clock and the hostess stated it would be a little wait. No big deal, even though it was busy we found two seats at the bar for a drink while we waited. Bartender was wonderful and we got drinks quickly even though the bar was busy. After about 15 minutes we were notified that our table was ready. Walked up and the host seemed un-prepared for us even though we were notified the table was ready. She proceeded to seat us in the back room where there was a group of about 20 people who had not ordered yet. There was also a table of two next to us and a table of about 6 behind us. Both servers in the area repeatedly visit the other tables while we sat there for over 15 minutes without being acknowledged. The one server then started taking the order for the table of 20. We left. That was our final straw for this place. Three strikes and you're out.
There were other tables of 4 available in the bar area but apparently saving those for groups of 4 is more important than providing good service.

Source: Google

Jermaine Wright

★ 5

Stopped in from Savannah Ga and had an amazing time, and the food was great and the service was amazing
👍🏾 👍🏾

Source: Google

Thomas Monahan

★ 4

Great place for food in a classic Wisconsin tavern setting. The bartender greeted us behind the the moment we walked in. Saturday afternoon on the way home from West Bend looking for a new place to grab a bite. It looked she was handling the entire bar by herself but didn't stop her from quickly getting us drinks and ordered food.
Ordered appetizer Onion Rings with Spicy Aoli. Breading was light and crisp. Ordered a small pizza for entre. Quickly served food and we were on our way.

Source: Google

Jennifer F

★ 5

Our server, Tabitha was awesome!

Source: Google

Pamela Nourse

★ 5

We went in to try the food and ended up getting the pizza because it was on special. We had the large pepperoni and sausage with the original crust. The crust was just right, with a little crunch on the edges. It had the right amount of cheese and toppings! Great pizza! The atmosphere was nice, and there were several tvs and other fun things to do, like darts. We'll definitely come back again!

Source: Google

Chuck

★ 4

My wife and I both have fish. She had perch and I had the sea food platter. All the fish and fries was good except for the clam chowder, it was very watery. I'm going to try other food before I decide to stop eating there.

Source: Google

Paul Braun

★ 5

Food and atmosphere great. Our server, Talia was awesome.

Source: Google

Brian Wiese

★ 5

Source: Google

gary behrendt

★ 5

Best fish I've ever had! It's been a long time to find this place.

Source: Google

Todd Ruedt

★ 5

Source: Google

Nakia Jackson

★ 2

Placed a pick up order and half of it was incorrect ie ordered bone-in wings got boneless, missing wing sauces, etc. Please do a better job of double checking orders before they leave the kitchen.

Source: Google

Linda Day

★ 5

Source: Google

Michelle Lucchesi

★ 5

Source: Google

Chris N

★ 4

Source: Google

Scott Olson

★ 5

Source: Google

Jack Dixon

★ 5

Source: Google

Jennifer Passig

★ 5

Stopped in for a Fish Fry. It was delicious, the potato pancakes are just like my mom’s! My husband had baked cod and potato pancakes, I had the shrimp and potato pancakes, both meals were shared and we both agree it was delicious! I am not kidding it’s better than the any restaurant in Washington Cty. Highly recommend! OUR WAITRESS WAS SO SWEET as well!

Source: Google

Samantha Alvey

★ 5

Awesome food, awesome service!

Source: Google

My G

★ 5

Been to Stags a couple times now. It can be very busy, be patient they do their best. Burgers and Italian beef and very good.

Source: Google

Belle T.

★ 3

Went mid afternoon (3:30) so there weren't too many people. It was a quiet atmosphere ... No loud music or tvs. We got service right away. The waitress didn't know what the specials were or if they were still going on so we just ordered from the menu. Food was fast and hot but seriously under seasoned. We ordered the bacon jalapeno wraps, 2 flavors of wings and the cheesesteak. Everything needed more flavor. We talked about dessert but were so disappointed in the meal that we decided not to bother.

Source: Google

Mark Pinter

★ 5

Bone in wings are big and delicious.

Source: Google

Lanae Weyer

★ 4

Source: Google

Martin Skills Academy

★ 5

Source: Google

Douglas Riepel

★ 4

Source: Google

Gregory

★ 5

Great fish fry. One of the best I've had in a while. Waitress was very nice and $5.00 old fashions on Friday sweet.

Source: Google

Wally Wolter

★ 5

Source: Google

Marie Antoinette

★ 5

Source: Google

Mary Grams

★ 5

Source: Google

Tambi Hammerich

★ 5

Went on a Tuesday and was busy around 1:30. Bartender was very friendly. Ordered a smash burger which was the best burger I've had in forever. Will recommend to friends. Nice atmosphere! Will definitely be a repeat customer 👌

Source: Google

Mary Zimmerman

★ 5

Source: Google

Dan Brefja

★ 5

Source: Google

William Bird

★ 5

Grat wings!

Source: Google

Michael hugg

★ 5

Source: Google

Richard Doberstein

★ 5

Relaxing

Source: Google

Sherry Stemper

★ 5

I got the cheese steak and cheese. My socks flew off it was soooo good.

Source: Google

John Brandstatter

★ 5

Great food that comes quick, nice sized portions reasonably priced. Fun place

Source: Google

Charlie Goersch

★ 5

Absolutely one of our new local favorites.

Source: Google

Dawn Luko

★ 5

Friendly workers and customers.

Source: Google

David Kamine

★ 5

Great staff, the food is fantastic!

Source: Google

Ron Wickert

★ 5

Really good perch dinner

Source: Google

Katrina S

★ 5

Awesome time Monday one of the only places open. One bartender, but that’s fine. Most people were closed. We appreciate them being open. Food was amazing!!!

Source: Google

Sutton Skodras

★ 5

Great place. Went in there Sunday super busy. Most likely because it’s a holiday weekend and not many were open. We had to wait a little longer, but the food was still amazing!

Source: Google

Amber Gonzalez

★ 5

When the waitress says the nachos are huge…it is the understatement of the year!!! What a cool little spot with great food and the coolest vibe!!!

Source: Google

Michelle Schneider

★ 5

Quickly becoming our new favorite!! Friendly and efficient staff!! Every meal has been amazing and leaves us craving our next visit!!

Source: Google

Kimberly Sorheim

★ 5

Cool place! Great food, very good service!

Source: Google

Deborah Nice

★ 4

Chicken breast a bit dry, Fish Fry's have always been good tho

Source: Google

angie P

★ 5

Not our first time ordering from Stag, always a great experience. Order the pizza!! Best crust!!

Source: Google

Deb Miller

★ 5

What a great place!!! My husband and I had the thin crust pizza and it was fantastic. The bartender was amazing and the atmosphere was welcoming. I recommend and we will definitely be back.

Source: Google

Jim Buetow

★ 5

Good fish-(cod&perch) Great potatoe pancakes and clam chowder! The service was very fast. Chef walking the dining room (cuz he cares) I don't know how they get so much help when everyone else struggles to do that. It's kind of loud in there, cover the ceiling with sound absorbtion maybe???

Source: Google

Kat Props

★ 5

🍔 Kitchen closes at 10 🍔
Bar open later, we stopped in for a drink around midnight - can’t wait to go back to try the food!! Really extensive menu, they were sweet enough to sell us a couple ciabatta rolls for the hot dogs we had in our cooler to cook while camping.

Source: Google

Donna Krider

★ 5

Amazing! Food and drink options are great! Gotta have the haystack o-rings and bourbon burger and you have got to try the Keto Cooler - my new fav!

Source: Google

Dave Bort

★ 5

Food was good again. Smash burger and chicken sandwich was really good.

Source: Google

Vaishali Godhani

★ 5

Excellent 👍

Source: Google

S and S Textile Printing

★ 5

We Love this place. It's the new go to place for us!

Source: Google

Ryan S

★ 3

Standard bar & pub food for the area. Not a bad choice, for an evening dinner at a pub. Nothing stuck out regarding the food; based on ordering/sharing a bit of everything amongst our group - pizza, several apps, wings, burgers, etc. Must have been an anomaly, since every other review so far says that all of the food is nothing short of amazing. 3.5-4 stars for the general vicinity.

Source: Google

Daniel Grunewald

★ 5

I love what the new owners have done to the place! It's awesome to see Bobby still here, and Katie was awesome as our server today! I had the Thursday taco special along with their hottest sauce, and I'll tell ya, it's to the moon in heat! The tacos were also very good. I'll definitely be back many more times!

Source: Google

peter kallas

★ 5

The food is really good. Best burgers by far for any pub in the area. Highly recommend the Stagover Burger and the Nachos. Somebody told me they are adding more items to the menu very soon so cant wait to come back to try again!

Source: Google

Jimmy Gardner

★ 5

The food is excellent, priced right, and service is great. Our new favorite place to grab dinner out.

Source: Google

Scott Zimmermann

★ 5

Fantastic food.

Source: Google

Kurt Heilgendorf

★ 5

Source: Google

Calvin Sporer

★ 5

Source: Google

Heather McCutchin

★ 5

We sat in the bar, which was a little loud, but the music was really good and the staff was very friendly. Food was fantastic.

Source: Google

Cory McCutchin

★ 5

Source: Google

Jeff Potter

★ 5

Source: Google

mordecai castro

★ 5

Food was amazing, good portions, flavorful and fresh! Ordered online and was ready when picked up!

Source: Google

Sheri Veley

★ 5

Source: Google

Scott Sauer

★ 5

Great job on the renovation! Food is a plus and the wait staff is excellent! We love Bobbi!!

Source: Google

Kevin “Brewcitykev” Heintzman

★ 5

Service was great. Smash burger slaps. Good music, sports on the tvs. Great experience! Easily just became one of my favorite spots. 🤙

Source: Google

Seth

★ 5

Excellent food and service. 1st time I went and was impressed with the food, taste, quality, service. I'll definitely be back

Source: Google

Valerie Belmore

★ 5

Been here twice now, both on a Saturday and have had a good time, with fantastic food both times. The Nacho Your Average Nachos is the app to get for sure. Not only is it huge and can feed a party of 4, easily, it's fantastic. Also, had the The Boss Sandwich and it did not disappoint. The bartender was the same both times and she is a gem. Super nice and doesn't miss a beat. Will be going back for sure to eventually try everything on the menu.

Source: Google

Maranda Stavely

★ 5

Love this place! The remodel is amazing! They turned this place into a 5 star bar/restaurant. Also the food is great! It's high quality and the portions are huge. You will most likely leave with to-go box! Try it our, you'll thank me.

Source: Google

Mike A

★ 5

Ordered pizza, was fantastic got a thin crust extra pepperoni and it's not on the menu but we had them add garlic. Hard to find good thin crust pizza and will definitely be ordering again.

Source: Google

Mitch Worth

★ 5

Source: Google

dave bouchard

★ 4

Source: Google

T T

★ 5

Source: Google

Mike Lutz

★ 5

The food was incredible. My wife had the Philly and I had the Boss. The meat on both sandwiches was incredibly tender. The fries were very good but they could save themselves some money by not giving so many fries. The reason a 4 for service and atmosphere was because we had to get our own menus and get the attention of the waitress. They were very kind people serving us. The atmosphere is that it is a bar and very loud. I would still highly recommend eating there.

Source: Google

Hunter Warner

★ 5

Coldest drinks in the Midwest, Some of the best customer service around!

Source: Google

Ryan Mcconnell

★ 5

Source: Google

Luke

★ 5

The only downside that my wife and I experienced was it took a while for a waitress to come to our table. With that being said, our food and drinks were outstanding!! That place was pretty busy, and maybe they weren't staffed properly. We could easily call this place a new staple for us going forward. Absolutely worth checking out.

Source: Google

Kellie Wollmer

★ 5

Source: Google

Kim Wollmer

★ 5

Source: Google

Mayson Taylor

★ 5

Tabitha is a great bartender and server, the drinks and food were top notch for a great price!

Source: Google

Roberta Von Asten

★ 5

It's a great place to go..... Meet new friends and connect with the old. Food is great!

Source: Google

Kevin Schmidt

★ 4

Bobbi is the reason i come here. Wing deal on Wednesday night. Chef cody makes amazing sauce. Ask him to spice it up

Source: Google

Karter Busse

★ 5

Source: Google

Tabitha milczarek

★ 5

Source: Google

Kody Bartel

★ 5

Source: Google

Lisa Weiss

★ 5

Went to Stags for a drink with some friends and ended up ordering a pizza and some apps! We were all quite please! The food was delish! And they have half priced apps on Saturday! How can you go wrong? Also Becky our bartender was AMAZING! She hustles, cleans, bartends and waits on tables. She is definitely a keeper!

Source: Google

Becky Waldron

★ 5

Love the pizza, Monday’s Fried Chicken is amazing! I’ve tried a lot of the food, haven’t had a bad meal yet!

Source: Google

sandy SKODRAS

★ 5

Great place , good atmosphere and love the food

Source: Google

David Burdick

★ 5

For our first time here, we were not expecting the food or service we received. The food and our server Jessica exceeded our expectations and were amazing! We will definitely be back again!

Source: Google

Denise Anderson

★ 5

Excellent burger on a brioche bun!! Server was amazing polite and very friendly 😊
I’ve been there before, they didn’t disappoint will definitely be back!

Source: Google

Fibroman

★ 4

Good food. Slow on service.

Source: Google

Jamie Budaic

★ 5

After a long Monday, I did not want to cook. I pass this place every day and saw it was a new name & new ownership. Tonight we thought we'd check it out. Totally impressed! We ordered pizza, boneless chicken and sour cream & chive fries. The pizza was absolutely amazing, the food was fantastic!!!

I'm so excited to have a place where the food Is great and a place to hang out with my girlfriends & its close...I am so happy.

This place was remodeled. the food is so good, definitely check it out!!!

Source: Google

roham71987 rob

★ 5

Source: Google

Ken Kosidowski

★ 4

Source: Google

Keith Schneider

★ 3

We didn't have food just stopped by to check it out. Good service decent drinks reasonably priced. Menu looks like typical bar food burgers, wings other people were eating and it smelled good

Source: Google

Erika Lauson

★ 4

Source: Google

Daniel Karwowski

★ 1

I was here to watch the NASCAR race and unfortunately it had a new owner that remodeled it it away from the NASCAR thing which sucks! The remodeling job was great first class though
The downside was I was in and purchased $62 worth of drinks for the people in there because I spread my money around. When the tab came due I laid down 4 20s to pay the bill and did not any change back of course and I brought it up with the person working there a female and she refused she told me she gave me my money back which was a lie! So I don't give bad reviews very often I would stay away from this place until they get rid of that female bartender

Source: Google

Pete Jurcek

★ 4

Just stopped in for a beer but didn't eat. We wanted to check out the new place. Vastly improved from the last establishment. What I saw of food looked quite appetizing. They changed the outlay of the bar (better from my perspective)and made the place brighter and more appealing. Will definitely be back.

Source: Google

Randy Christianson

★ 4

Great sandwiches, hot all the way thru.
Fantastic service, and the remodeling is great. Next time we are going to have a Fish Fry.

Source: Google

Steve Ramminger

★ 5

Source: Google

Donna Wargolet

★ 5

Great food, great drinks and very nice good service.

Source: Google

M

★ 5

Great food and service!

Source: Google

Mike Gariepy

★ 5

Friendly staff.

Source: Google

Maddie Maaske

★ 5

Source: Google

Nicole Peelman

★ 5

Love that this place has new owners, a face-lift, and such friendly service! What a change from before! Bravo! I have to say, the new staff makes all the difference. We haven't tried the full menu, but haven't been disappointed, yet. We like to play the machines and I have to say, they are tight. Lol I won't hold that against the place, just an observation. Then again, we take the risk! 🫣 All else is fantastic and the pricing on drinks and food, is a bonus. Feels like a place you can afford to swing into on any given day.

Source: Google

Stevenbm

★ 4

Source: Google

Brianna Vail

★ 5

Source: Google

Fred K

★ 5

Source: Google

Jacob Kaltz

★ 5

Source: Google

Nick Hicks

★ 5

Wings are GAS!!! .75 cent wednesdays, cant go wrong.

Source: Google

Sarah

★ 2

The service was awful, just drinking at the bar and waiting for a refill took forever. We left after a couple

Source: Google

Megan Ramminger

★ 5

Source: Google

BILL WOS

★ 5

Friendly staff / great food

Source: Google

Mel Laubenstein

★ 5

Source: Google

Carli Skodras

★ 5

Recently Remodeled! Great place to eat and watch sports!

Source: Google

Sara Cook

★ 5

Stopped in for lunch today. My husband and I both got fried chicken Sammy’s tossed in different sauces. Very good and the fries were fresh and crispy. Inside is clean and just remodeled. We will be back again.

Source: Google