Subway

Fort Atkinson, 1550 Madison Ave, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538, United States | ★ 3.8 (190 Review)

📞 +1 920-691-0021

Last Search

Category

Sandwich shop Caterer Fast food restaurant Takeout Restaurant Restaurant

Description

Your local Fort Atkinson Subway® Restaurant, located at 1550 Madison Ave brings new bold flavors along with old favorites to satisfied guests every day. We deliver these mouth-watering flavors with our famous Footlongs, 6” sandwiches, wraps and salads. And we offer a variety of ways to order—quick and easy in the app or online, convenient delivery, come into your neighborhood shop for an in-restaurant meal, or pick up curbside. We’re proud to offer a change from same old fast food with fresh cut veggies and toppings with protein choices, fresh-baked bread and let’s not forget cookies! And we’re happy to help you with any catering needs as well. All Subway® Restaurants are independently owned and operated by business owners who employ tal...

Photos

 Subway
 Subway
 Subway
 Subway
 Subway
 Subway
 Subway
 Subway

Leave a Review

Reviews

ramon verduzco

★ 3

Source: Google

Dogged-Solo

★ 5

Clean as advertised.

Source: Google

Trevor Finn

★ 5

Great service with fresh ingredients. Even when busy the team does an awesome job finishing orders without backing up the line. Of all the locations I’ve visited this is one of the best!

Source: Google

Kiara Anderson

★ 1

Source: Google

RedLaser

★ 5

New crew in there. loving it, fast, friend food taste great Tiffany the store manager has turn this place around 😀😀

Source: Google

Debra Macnaughton

★ 5

Source: Google

C D

★ 5

I had to give a positive review because my daughter spilled her full soda all over the table, and the staff was so kind. She came out and helped clean the table and then washed it down so it wouldn't be sticky. Top notch service. Definitely will stop there again.

Source: Google

Jeff Margenau

★ 5

Great food, great staff!

Source: Google

Annalise Williams

★ 1

I ordered three sandwiches and one came filled to the brim with straight mustard, and a sandwich that was ordered with double meat, my order shows me that i put double. The last one was a wrap that came on flat bread, I understand if thats the way they do it now but she got super snippy. When i called and i felt super bad for even calling because i work in the food industry. The manager wasn’t friendly at all and did not doing anything to fix my order or refund any of the money that just got wasted on their poor customer service. I will not be order from this store again.

Source: Google

Javier Alcantara Jose

★ 5

Source: Google

Cheryl Montiel

★ 5

Source: Google

Amber Villagran Ramirez

★ 5

I went in last night for a Sub. The restaurant was clean, and the girls were changing their gloves in between using the register and making subs. Everyone was polite, and smiling. There were 2 girls making the subs and They got slammed after I went in! They continued with a positive attitude and smiles, asked the customers if they would like anything else, a bag, receipt, and said thank you. I recommend this Subway.

Source: Google

StunnaGurl

★ 1

The employees were nice. But the subs are half the size they use to be and they majorly skimp on the ingredients. We had a coupon and won't ever be going back. I paid $6 for bread!!!!!

Source: Google

Tyler Floerke

★ 1

Online says they are open til 9pm weekly, unless they changed their hours and told nobody then they should stay open to their posted time. 4 cars pulled up to this Subway today and all had to go home bc they were told they closed. Change the hours if you keep closing early. I suggest people go to Jimmy John’s after 7pm because this Subway closes early.

Source: Google

Jorge Lambarri

★ 1

Por primera vez horrible pedí un subway grande con salami y cuando pedí olivas negras me pusieron lo que agarraron con la punta de los dedos cuando pedí más me negaron el servicio por que era la póliza de subway me ofrecí apagar un extra por más olivas negras y de una forma grosera me lo negaron. Pagas casi $11.50 por un Subway que ni me gustó y tiré a la basura

Source: Google

Dakota Stone

★ 1

I ordered a protein bowl. Is supposed to have lots of meat and little veggies. I got 3 pieces of turkey and 2 pieces of cheese. The bowl wasn’t full and the bill was 12 dollars. Go to the Jefferson subway. This one sucks!!! The workers are horrible. Too busy chit chatting. I waited for 5 min just for them to go by me and at first they kept walking past. GO TO JEFFERSON SUBWAY. Actually worth it and prices are better and you get more food! They load you up in Jefferson

Source: Google

Susan Jobst

★ 3

I picked up my sandwich and when I got back to where we were eating and opened up sandwich I saw it was mostly bread and mayo. I ordered online and chose “more black olives” and I only got a few. I felt like I was eating only bread half the time. Usually I can barely hold my sandwich together but with this place my bread could close EASILY where it looked like it was just bread with a little filling.

Source: Google

chester Schroeder

★ 5

Source: Google

Lisa Zimmerman

★ 1

Most awful subway I've ever been to. The steak and cheese flatbread was hard and small, maybe a tbls of meat. The currio was awful, a stick would have been softer. I will never eat at this subway again, I have to go home and eat aPB and J, still hungry

Source: Google

Randy

★ 5

Source: Google

Alaina Johnston

★ 5

Accessibility, cleanliness, service, it was all a 10/10. Cleanest and nicest subway i’ve ever been in. Had great holiday decorations as well. Super nice people. I’d rate this over 5 stars if possible.

Source: Google

Jeff Margenau

★ 3

The person that waited on me was obviously stressed, and that happens, I understand, so this may not be fair, but the service wasn't given with a smile even though I was the only customer at the time.

Source: Google

Tyler Phillips

★ 5

Source: Google

Mike Rodriguez

★ 4

Ok value, and service.

Source: Google

Andrew Burnett

★ 4

Source: Google

Hailey Markee

★ 3

This subway no longer accepts corporate subway coupons; there’s a sign up that says they experience losses when they accept them, and that falls on the location, rather than corporate. Kind of disappointing, but I get it. Normal subway sandwiches and atmosphere: Mid.

Source: Google

Phone fixer

★ 5

Source: Google

Janet Metzker

★ 5

Source: Google

Mike Bianco

★ 1

Didn't care for the place never will go back to that place we'll go to the next place down the road about two or three miles on a right hand side of the road this guy over here they tell you you can add what you want to make the sandwich the way you'd like it and my wife went in there get a sandwich and I told her she wanted a little extra condiments on there and the guy he put some condiments on then he said he was going to have to charge extra to put a few extra onions on there I told her you should say to the guy hey is this the way then you eat it and walk out the door it's a joke it is it's a joke these people there was nobody in the place the place was dead and you can't even make the sandwich the way you like it who's you're paying for it but they want to be scrimpy they think that I don't know what they think but I'm never going back to that place I wanted to walk into place and tell the guy something but it was too hot outside so I just so I just got in the car stay in the car and left I'll never go back to that place again you want to go there fine go there and aunt and have him make the sandwich the way he likes it and you're supposed to be it's a privilege for you to go in there and spend your money the way he likes to make a sandwich okay fine

Source: Google

Rodney Rogers

★ 2

Source: Google

Beth Wendt

★ 5

Source: Google

Ethan Pendergast

★ 3

Source: Google

Jennifer Slak

★ 3

I gave it 3 stars because the prices are TOO high for sandwiches! And this location doesn't take coupons any longer. Awesome staff and food though. We just can't go a lot.

Source: Google

Jeffrey Simonis

★ 3

Super expensive! $12 for a foot long? You kidding me? Sub preparer all business and not very personable. Don't accept Subway coupons. Gouging the customer.

Source: Google

lori asmussen

★ 3

Source: Google

Ben Hrobsky

★ 3

Source: Google

Daniel Buttkiss

★ 5

Can't really get a 5 dollar foot long anymore but their sandwiches taste great!

Source: Google

Andy Sawyer

★ 1

Guy refused me service because I didn’t want my flatbread toasted. I have came to this location the last 2 days and didn’t get my flatbread toasted and wasn’t refused service. The manager said it was up to the employee if they wanted to not toast the flatbread. I asked manager how I could make a complaint to owner she said she was the manager they didn’t have a corporate. I’ve went to subways all over the us and never been refused service because I didn’t want my bread toasted.

Source: Google

Mask

★ 5

Source: Google

Curt Allen

★ 5

Source: Google

Patricia Schwartz

★ 1

How much does it cost to say , "Hello, we'll be with you in a moment."? The cost is my patronage! If I enter your food establishment, the least you could do is greet me. Yes, I know you are busy. But actively ignoring the customer in front of you while you make the food for the drive thru customer is just really rude!

Source: Google

Peggy Schmidt

★ 2

Bread was so dry & hard. I asked for the sandwich BLT toasted.The girl barely cooked my bacon.. Bacon was raw. I brought it home & cooked it more before eating.

Source: Google

Mark Jonas

★ 5

Nice new menu/ love the great garlic chicken

Source: Google

Rosemarie Lewandowski

★ 5

Just tried one of their new sandwiches with the turkey, avocado and bacon. Delicious.

Source: Google

Lupis Arizmendi

★ 5

Great customer service.Great Staff

Source: Google

Andy White

★ 5

These gals/guys rock. They usually know my order for the kid right away it's great!!!!

Source: Google

Gabrielle Kirley

★ 5

Source: Google

tanner buttke

★ 1

Pretty typical for fast food here in Fort, close half hour or hour early to posted times pull up during holiday hours half hour before posted time and store is cleared out and locked common theme around here.

Source: Google

Rob Knapp

★ 5

Polite and quick associates making sandwichs. Great experience!

Source: Google

Timothy Wulf

★ 5

Despite being extremely busy, the staff were friendly and on point. Food was delicious as always.

Source: Google

darlene meador

★ 5

Source: Google

Art Faber Swails

★ 5

Source: Google

Kyli Morgan

★ 2

There was meat mixed in with other stuff which makes me worry about allergies with people. Talk about cross contamination my goodness. There was an online order receipt that was thrown in the steak. Veggies were taken off of our sandwiches and thrown back into the bain. Decent service but idk. Makes me worry.

Source: Google

Joe Chernauskas

★ 5

Food was delicious, staff was quick and attentive.

Source: Google

Triston I

★ 2

Source: Google

Stacey Bowman

★ 3

Staff is friendly

Source: Google

Sarah Murphy

★ 3

Source: Google

Andrew Marnocha

★ 5

Source: Google

Teri

★ 4

Source: Google

Gilberto “Pelon” Moreno

★ 3

I spent 30 dollar in sandwiches but the place don't take fifty dollar bills?!?!?!. Next time jimmy John's it is

Source: Google

Chris Wagner

★ 2

Source: Google

Judith

★ 5

Source: Google

Cynthia Skaar

★ 4

Was great Turkey on Italian bread chips soda

Source: Google

Josh Anderson

★ 5

Source: Google

Thea Reeves

★ 2

Order a salad and received one that is about 1/2 the size in terms of lettuce that I usually get.

Source: Google

Don Face

★ 4

Source: Google

Cindi

★ 5

Source: Google

Anthony Esquerra

★ 5

Source: Google

Lyndon Samuel

★ 4

Friendly staff

Source: Google

Casey Ellis

★ 4

Source: Google

Merek Pankow

★ 2

Not fresh at all…isn’t that their slogan?

Source: Google

megan cis

★ 1

Just got off the phone with the rude manager. Picked my sandwich up and noticed it tasted kind of bland and was missing flavor? Basic CCC Italian herb and cheese, with cheese, lettuce Mayo, toasted, etc. I took a bite and noticed something was wrong. Put the sandwich down opened it up and didnt see cheese on it (at first) and it didn’t look toasted. Called subway and as I’m on the phone noticed it’s not even on the correct bread. Was suppose to be Italian herb and cheese got regular Italian. So anyways, manager was out for a minute so I left my name and call back number. As I’m waiting for a call I start pulling apart the sandwich more and come to find out there is cheese but wasn’t in the first bite. Right as I’m washing my hands the manager calls back, seemed annoyed and immediately states that the sandwich does in fact have cheese and was toasted. I responded and told her yes it did have cheese, I actually found it after I got off the phone. It wasn’t in the first bite. But that the bread did not look toasted and it was still not the correct bread anyways. I live in whitewater, 18 minutes from THAT subway and would be like a refund for the incorrect sandwich. As I’m not driving 18 minutes for a $7 sandwich (apparently it was $8 and she rudely let me know I said the wrong price based off the tone of her voice) She became completely rude and said it was toasted and with cheese and we can’t zoom our camera into the sandwich to see what bread was used. I offered to email a picture of the sandwich to her. She again rudely responded with yeah you can do that and we can bring it to the owners and see how they want to handle this. I will not be refunding you $8 for a sandwich just because the bread was wrong when everything else was correct. We had exchanged a few more words. She was rude most of the phone call. Told her I will give my business to a better subway and hung up on her. Problem did not get resolved instead the sandwich has now gone into the garbage.

Call me crazy but doesn’t the bread MAKE the sandwich??? Like it’s not the correct sandwich if the breads not what was asked for. It gives the sandwich a completely different flavor… the breads that are asked for MAKE the sandwich for that person. Apparently the customer isnt always right, even when it comes to THEIR OWN FOOD. Smh. Poor serve, don’t recommend, go to a better subway.

Source: Google

Hannah Fiene

★ 4

Source: Google

Kim Mitchell

★ 5

Source: Google

alixura ʚɞ

★ 4

Source: Google

Mel T

★ 4

Source: Google

Tru Freedom

★ 4

Source: Google

melissa billings

★ 4

Source: Google

Christi Enright

★ 5

Very efficient

Source: Google

Racheal Coy

★ 3

Messed up my sandwich completely.

Source: Google

Marcus Neumann

★ 5

Quick service and great tasting food.

Source: Google

Tony M.

★ 3

I typically rate Subway as a 4 but I want to share my opinion on something. I'm happy that the mask mandate has been lifted however I feel that all food prep employees should continue to wear a mask while preparing food. I am bringing this up in my Subway review since it was most apparent to me during my recent visit. When a subway employee is preparing your food they are standing directly over it and all of the toppings. They need to ask you questions while preparing it and in doing so may express saliva while talking, especially when aspirating the letter T. Hold your hand in front of your mouth and say the word Topping or just the T sound. Do you feel that? So, while I am happy to see people's smiling faces again and it's comforting to know that many people have been vaccinated, I do not like the idea of someone's spittle falling on the food I'm ordering. This isn't just a Covid thing, but any germs and viruses that may cause illness I would prefer to avoid. Food prep workers used to have to wear hair nets or even beard nets. Yes, it's a bit gross to find a hair in your food but only because you can see it. Now think about all the things you can't see from someone's saliva. Please, consider having food prep workers wear a mask while preparing the food we eat.

Source: Google

michael fleming

★ 3

Source: Google

Joshua Phillips

★ 5

Source: Google

Me

★ 1

I got the ham melt ,well that is what I ordered but got ham and cheese microwaved .

Source: Google

Rick E

★ 5

Upon entering the business I was struck by the cleanliness and attention to covid prevention
We were greeted promptly by by each employee and didnt feel rushed to make a selection.
The ingredients and bread were very fresh and appetizing. I noticed that this was a franchise location which speaks highly of the owner and his dedication to the company. I wish more Subway locations I have visited were of the caliber as this ...Great job

Source: Google

Beth K Powell

★ 2

Took forever to pay for food

Source: Google

Sophia Ciuffo

★ 5

Source: Google

Jennifer D

★ 4

Typically always good, once in when I order online my order isn't made right, but hey, it happens.

Source: Google

Monique

★ 5

One of the best subway restaurants in Jefferson County. Clean, takes precautions for covid seriously and they know how to make a sandwich! I've visited others in Jefferson County and let me tell ya, the bread is often hard enough to cut in croutons. Not to mention the others often skimp on the meats whereas this subway gives the correct amounts. Keep up the great work 👍

Source: Google

C S

★ 5

Source: Google

Courtney Fleischmann

★ 4

Source: Google

Becky Schulz

★ 3

Source: Google

Owen Provenzano

★ 5

People are kind and nice here

Source: Google

Richard Lewitzke

★ 5

Fast friendly clean and professional

Source: Google

Yolanda Schultz

★ 1

The worst service ever. Went to your store about and hour ago. The employees were rude and didn't seem like they wanted to be there or didn't want us there. My boyfriend stood for almost 5 minutes waiting for someone to come from the back,so he could get a new cup for a refill. No ever came out to help him. He went to open the door to make it ding,still no one came out. Sitting in back on there phones.

Source: Google

Melissa “BeyondBitchhh” Bevan

★ 4

Source: Google

Veronica Fernandez

★ 1

My mother went yesterday, October 10, 2020, telling me how uncomfortable she was while getting service at this subway. The lady who was helping her gave her attitude while my mother gave her order, would be rude gestures and left to go at the back to stop giving her service while her other coworkers gave my mother proper respect. Do something with your disrespectful staff.

Source: Google

Angie Cox

★ 4

Source: Google

Dan Deegan

★ 5

Great staff, favorite fast food in fort.

Source: Google

Alicia O'Connor

★ 2

I went through the drive through and it took 25 minutes for 4 meatball subs!

Source: Google

Tiffeny Koebernick

★ 2

Subs/sliders should be made how customer likes it. Very disappointing

Source: Google

Debbie Heelein

★ 5

Source: Google

Eugene Sonnenberg

★ 4

Source: Google

Richard S Kucken

★ 4

Source: Google

Tracy Fiege

★ 4

Source: Google

Jessie

★ 4

Source: Google

Clotiel Kirk

★ 4

Had a great sandwich and service. They are the only place that serves my favorite chips , Ms. Vickie's jalapeno flavor chips, it always is a good experience

Source: Google

Daniel Lewis

★ 4

Source: Google

Brandon Weide

★ 5

Source: Google

Tirri Goodrich

★ 2

Source: Google

Carlyn Tamborini

★ 5

Source: Google

SRT WORKS

★ 5

Clean, friendly and fresh food.

Source: Google

Adyn G.

★ 4

Nice atmosphere

Source: Google

Kimby Behling

★ 5

Source: Google

Lisa Boswell

★ 5

Great place, very yummy and great staff

Source: Google

Susan Wood

★ 5

Source: Google

Ann Moran

★ 4

Source: Google

Stanley Rockwood

★ 5

Love it

Source: Google

James King

★ 5

Source: Google

Tammy Studzinski

★ 5

Source: Google

Nate Klement

★ 5

Source: Google

ryan hughes

★ 5

Source: Google

Randi Stockwell

★ 5

Source: Google

christian baker

★ 3

Source: Google

Jean Allen

★ 4

Source: Google

Russ Arnold

★ 3

It's still good it just gets a little boaring. They should have a different "Featured sub" monthly and if demand is there then keep it. Maybe low carb bread keep it healthy.

Source: Google

Jake Wipp

★ 5

Source: Google

Georgette Swenson

★ 2

Source: Google

John Batz

★ 5

This stop was fast and friendly. Great service too the wife said

Source: Google

Scott Galston

★ 4

Source: Google

Dinyel Walrath

★ 5

Source: Google

John Wegner

★ 1

Just gross sub was soaked in sauce and even after being toasted by the time I sat down to eat it I couldn't even eat half of it because it had turned to mush

Source: Google

Deanna Orchard

★ 5

Great food

Source: Google

Samantha Hernandez

★ 1

No greeting, & when they did greet it was like they are forced to. Rude customer service. A young kid looked & sounded like she didn’t even want to be here. At least food was good.

Source: Google

Estefania Martinez

★ 5

Source: Google

Marilyn Gill

★ 5

Source: Google

David L

★ 4

It's your average subway. The girl working the counter was nice.

Source: Google

Black Mamba, have cane will travel 4.0

★ 4

Could definitely be cheaper for a footlong

Source: Google

John Robins-Wells

★ 4

Source: Google

Aaron

★ 5

Good service good food

Source: Google

John Webster

★ 2

Worst Subway I've ever been to. The staff is rude. Went in one week ago and ordered three salads. The guy was swearing under his breath the whole time. It was such an uncomfortable situation I really didn't want to go back and when we did I was going to get something easy for them to make just to not have to go through that situation again. This week we went in and the drink machine was over watering the lemonade.The cashier refused to refund my money for the drink and argued about the drink being over watered. Go to the Subway across from the Fireside Theater, it's much cleaner and the service is always good.

Source: Google

Judi Burow

★ 4

The right place to go for a quick meal, with value. Every thing is always clean and well maintained, and the servers are very accommodating. Go see for yourself!!

Source: Google

Heather Leikness

★ 5

Source: Google

Syed Hussaini

★ 5

Very nice staff and very clean and fresh.

Source: Google

Spencer Thoni

★ 4

Source: Google

Jake Brock

★ 5

Rockin the morning

Source: Google

Angelyn Jensen

★ 2

Hate the squawk box, lacks human intreaction

Source: Google

kimmy mack

★ 5

Source: Google

Lynda Schmidt

★ 3

Source: Google

Jessie Krebs

★ 5

Source: Google

Boanerges 57

★ 4

Always clean and fast service

Source: Google

Finn Mertens

★ 4

A normal Subway. They have a drive-through but the staff say they do not like it as much as when people come in. I've not used the drive through because I like to see the portions and how it is made before buying it.
Someone wrote that the high-school girls that work here ruined it, but I'd rather have a cheap sandwich with known good ingredients instead of marginally better service at a higher price.

Source: Google

Robert Laffredi

★ 5

Lil pricey

Source: Google

Laurie Klade-braund

★ 4

Very good service and staff but not much seating otherwise it would be 5 stars

Source: Google

Michael Clifton

★ 4

Source: Google

Wayne Oscor

★ 1

13 people in line. Only 2 people working, one using a walker. Really?? @12:30 lunchtime. Wasting time on job lunch. Hire some help for lunches

Source: Google

Bobbie Jean

★ 5

Source: Google

Amanda Therese

★ 2

Source: Google

Kiara Bostwick

★ 5

Source: Google

Mitch Martin

★ 1

Source: Google

Lee Hurley

★ 5

Source: Google

Jan Davis

★ 5

Source: Google

Kurt Schoenwetter

★ 5

Great lunch.

Source: Google

Laura May

★ 3

High school kids destroyed the bread and sandwiches. More interested in talking to each other than doing their job

Source: Google

Only Mctruth

★ 5

Very nice employee, Thank you

Source: Google

Jim Meacham

★ 4

Source: Google

Logan Nordness

★ 4

Source: Google

Richard Troon

★ 4

Source: Google

Jeffery Bartelt

★ 2

Source: Google

TJ Miller

★ 3

Source: Google

Ethan Heagney

★ 1

Source: Google

Brian Jung

★ 4

Source: Google

Michael ODaniel

★ 3

Source: Google

Sandy Stevens

★ 4

Source: Google

Nikkie Pokk

★ 4

Source: Google

Brett Wenzel

★ 5

Source: Google

Ann Bigelow

★ 4

Love the personal pizzas, but the wait can be kind of long sometimes

Source: Google

Justin Christian

★ 4

Source: Google

Jay Strese

★ 4

Food is always good and fresh. Service can sometimes be a little spotty but it's almost always great.

Source: Google

Randall Whicker

★ 5

Source: Google

Josef Locke Klein

★ 4

Source: Google

Debra Schoenike

★ 3

Great food. Server kept us waiting while she was serving the drive thru and answering the phone. I was very disgusted.

Source: Google

Alexa Martinez

★ 4

Source: Google

Mike Jones

★ 4

Source: Google

Phil Cloute

★ 5

Good workers

Source: Google

Mason Becker

★ 5

Source: Google

Robert Roser

★ 1

Source: Google

Mitch Brock

★ 3

Next time you say you open at 7:00 A.M. And have the open sign on make sure the employees actually unlock the door.

Source: Google

Raynie M

★ 5

I love subway its my top fav!!!

Source: Google