Category
Sandwich shop Caterer Fast food restaurant Takeout restaurant RestaurantDescription
Your local Poynette Subway® Restaurant, located at W9195 County Rd Cs brings new bold flavors along with old favorites to satisfied guests every day. We deliver these mouth-watering flavors with our famous Footlongs, 6” sandwiches, wraps and salads. And we offer a variety of ways to order—quick and easy in the app or online, convenient delivery, come into your neighborhood shop for an in-restaurant meal, or pick up curbside. We’re proud to offer a change from same old fast food with fresh cut veggies and toppings with protein choices, fresh-baked bread and let’s not forget cookies! And we’re happy to help you with any catering needs as well. All Subway® Restaurants are independently owned and operated by business owners who employ talent...
Photos
Leave a Review
Reviews
Balbir Singh
★ 5
Source: Google
PAV MAL
★ 5
The best, Delicious, fresh food!!!
Source: Google
Luke Tischler
★ 5
This Subway makes an Excellent sandwitch! and Local people Dont Appreciate it..
The staff here is Always so accommodating and polite despite all the snotty nitpicky people that come in from Lake Wisconsin.
Eating in here often, I Listen to how the customers talk to the staff and its very upsetting to me, I Couldnt do what they do..
so I always tip them well because people in that area Dont know how good they got it, I Travel for work, and this is Thee very Best Subway on my route 100%
Source: Google
Jane Voelker
★ 3
Prompt service and good food for a Subway. Bathrooms and dining area were both visibly dirty, garbage cans were full, and napkin dispenser was empty.
Source: Google
No estoy Yo aqui Que soy tu Madre
★ 5
Well ir was raining and we stop to eat, while the little storm passed and it was good the experience
Source: Google
Bill Degenhardt
★ 5
Source: Google
Georgii
★ 5
Классное место, ребята которые готовят сендвичи потрясающие. Самый вкусный сендвич за всю мою жизнь был тут! 25 мая:)
Source: Google
Eleonora Mikhutova
★ 5
Source: Google
JaredPlayz JP Hebel
★ 5
Source: Google
Tom Von Neefe
★ 5
Lobby looks clean and parking lot accommodates semi trucks too!
Source: Google
Alexis Seisser
★ 5
The two young men who waited in us were incredibly polite and kind!!
Source: Google
CJ Postawa
★ 5
This Subway is the most consistent in quality I may have ever seen. It’s perfect every time I stop. The extraordinary thing is, I have only seen high school age young women working there. Well done!!
Source: Google
Joseph Alcorta
★ 4
Source: Google
Tim Zuehlke
★ 5
Very friendly staff and quick service
Source: Google
Kim Christians
★ 4
Consistently good food. New look inside very clean...
Source: Google
Thomas Reynolds
★ 5
Source: Google
Nehul Patel
★ 5
Source: Google
Oneida Rosa Rojas
★ 5
Buena calidad
Source: Google
Andrew Martin
★ 5
Ate here 5/22 around 5 pm by far the best subway sandwich I have ever eaten and being a trucker I been to alot of subways! got the beast with double meat think they put triple meat on it there was so much on it extra pickle and black olives were the same way loaded right down staff was awesome when I picked up my moblie order 100 % recommend this subway there truly is a sandwich artist here 😀 will be back 100%
Also check online app for deals ordered the beast for me and the wife got the bogo deal and got her sub free !
Source: Google
Linda Malone
★ 5
I wish they still had the thin wraps. My thick wrap was good, but not as good as the thinner wraps.
Source: Google
Ashlyn
★ 5
Source: Google
matthew hart
★ 5
Been to this location many times without an issue but if you see 2 young men working that look like they could be brothers consider going else where. Lots of credit to the young lady working with these 2 on 5/12. One of them got bested by a bag of lettuce and forgot to put the steak on a steak and cheese sub. Couldn't figure out the difference between a ham and turkey sub for a to go order. It was a dumpster fire to say the least. Again lots of credit to the young lady working she had her handful with those 2.
Source: Google
Matthew Lannoye
★ 5
I love coming to a place where everyone knows your name and if they don't know it the first time they'll know it for the second. I always ask for Aiden or Dylan!
Source: Google
Lisa and Frank Mueller
★ 5
Source: Google
Denise Wacek
★ 5
Food and service was excellent!
Source: Google
Mike Manthe
★ 5
Source: Google
Gabe M
★ 5
Source: Google
BET- PoppyT
★ 5
Good location. Friendly employees that remember you.
Source: Google
Abigail Ford
★ 5
Source: Google
Hannah Striley
★ 3
Source: Google
Islam
★ 5
there is a place where you can park the truck so you can eat in peace and not rush🙃
Source: Google
Allie Capone
★ 5
Source: Google
Harmeet Singh
★ 5
The food was great very friendly staff. Staff is also good 😊
🫡🫡
Source: Google
Mica Nordquist
★ 5
Traveling through and both the prices and sandwiches here are just better! Nice work!
Source: Google
Sandro Kusch
★ 5
Great subway to stop at when traveling on I-90/I-94
Source: Google
Ken
★ 5
Source: Google
Aaron Merrill
★ 4
Friendly staff.
Source: Google
Jorge garcia
★ 5
super busy at the time we where there but service was quick friendly staff
Source: Google
Greg Batz
★ 5
Source: Google
teresa Steele
★ 5
Source: Google
Haspreet Singh
★ 5
They have semi parking
Source: Google
Chris McBride
★ 5
Friendly Fast & Clean! Good work 2nd Shift of 03/02/2023 at 3:14pm.
Source: Google
Christina Varela
★ 4
Lexy is my girl! She will get you figured out. She's always cool & pleasant to talk to.
Source: Google
Joel Nernberger
★ 5
Source: Google
Varun Mohan Kumar (Varun)
★ 4
Source: Google
Michelle Degenhardt
★ 5
Great customer service! Fast and efficient service as well.
Source: Google
Robert
★ 5
Source: Google
Jenea Lester Dulgar
★ 5
Ladies that waited on us they were exceptional they were great
Source: Google
Nick Dorshorst
★ 5
Great food. Good service.
Source: Google
Kevin Schmidt
★ 5
Source: Google
Mat Turner
★ 5
Great job by the kids today. I had the bacon and chicken wrap and it was great. Thanks
Source: Google
Marquiss Doud
★ 5
Don't forget you can ask for extra cheese 👌
Source: Google
R P
★ 5
Source: Google
Mani Waraich
★ 5
Excellent place with truck parking. Good clean restaurant with awesome SUBS
Source: Google
Jim Wittwer
★ 5
Source: Google
Anita Norton-Heil
★ 5
Clean place, off the path of travel but it was busy and good
Source: Google
Anna Schultz
★ 5
Source: Google
Mike Raemisch
★ 4
Source: Google
E T
★ 1
I don't care what your political views are, but bottom line, we are in the middle of a pandemic. I don't need a bunch of rude maskless teenage employees snickering at the fact I wore a mask I to your store. I wouldn't come back here if it was the only food left on this earth. I would rather die from starvation than give money to this inconsiderate business.
Source: Google
Joe Sorensen
★ 4
Source: Google
Dave Lyons
★ 5
Decent Subway with friendly staff.
Source: Google
Jeremy Burros
★ 5
Source: Google
Fortnite Faves
★ 5
Could eat here almost every day.
Source: Google
Jeff Blaser
★ 3
New steak sandwich was delicious
Source: Google
That Train Nerd Dave
★ 5
Awesome 👍🏻 they were very nice and speedy! Great service!
Source: Google
Spencer Spiewak
★ 5
Quality service, excellent staff. One of my favorite stops before visiting the Wisconsin River. Always a quality experience here highly recommend this location
Source: Google
G Wendland
★ 5
Easy highway access, and very quick. Correct orders!!!
Source: Google
Natalia
★ 5
Source: Google
Ron Simpson
★ 5
Source: Google
Tom Donaldson
★ 4
Source: Google
Versace Mane
★ 5
Best place to eat fast food in the area. I work right across the street and order subs from this subway multiple times a week. High recommended 👍
Source: Google
Ann Moran
★ 5
Source: Google
Dan Shackelford
★ 4
Source: Google
Tyler B
★ 5
Clean, fast, and friendly staff.
Source: Google
Leo Lion
★ 5
Source: Google
cj hoff
★ 4
Source: Google
Dane Brue
★ 3
Servis was good sandwich was good
Source: Google
Jacob Senior
★ 5
Sammich
Source: Google
Veronika Stine
★ 5
Yum
Source: Google
Tiffany Larrabee
★ 5
Best Subway I've had in a very long time- just passing through
Source: Google
bryan dibble
★ 5
Good 👍 subs
Source: Google
jill wilson
★ 5
Source: Google
Cynthia Blackburn
★ 5
Source: Google
Heather Evans
★ 5
Source: Google
Josephine Gordon
★ 5
Really great service!
Source: Google
Dave Matijevich
★ 5
Always good food. I'm always slow in picking my choices, and the employees are patient and polite.
Source: Google
John Canterbury
★ 4
Source: Google
Greg S.
★ 5
Great service. Good food. Currently take out only for the pandemic, but we just ate on the hood the car in the parking lot.
Source: Google
Jojo jojo
★ 5
Source: Google
Arne Olson
★ 5
Great service!!
Source: Google
Amanda Z
★ 5
Clean, everyone wearing gloves and masks properly, very courteous staff. Lovely establishment.
Source: Google
James Harris
★ 5
Sandwiches were great
Source: Google
Nick Brown
★ 5
Source: Google
Felicia Watkins
★ 5
Source: Google
Ron Hill
★ 5
Source: Google
Scott Stephens
★ 2
Ordered a salad. In times past, these salads were huge. Not anymore it appears. No meat in 5 or 6 inch square container half filled. I figured that if I ordered a foot long, I would have gotten that much tomato, cucumber and bell with half of the salad I received along with a toasted bun with meat and cheese. Methinks I will get salads elsewhere.
Source: Google
Steven Geesaman
★ 5
Source: Google
Rob Zacher
★ 5
Source: Google
Loretta Cole
★ 5
Source: Google
Rhonda Kisting
★ 5
Great Customer Service. Clean Business. Friendly Workers. Fresh Food.
Source: Google
Victor
★ 1
Source: Google
Edward Maranhao
★ 5
Source: Google
Helen Manke
★ 5
Always great.
Source: Google
Denver Morse
★ 1
Did online ordering and had the worst experience at this location. Would not ever order food from here online ever again. Didnt let me customize my subs and my meatball wasnt even toasted. The owner wouldnt even offer to fix my meal. So never going back to this location again.
Source: Google
Christine Troutman
★ 5
Sandwiches and service are always great!
Source: Google
Raymond Brereton
★ 4
Because I get to choice an order lunch and also I get to choose a birthday gift card for someone birthday.
Source: Google
Kenneth Webb
★ 5
Source: Google
Leo Zirbes
★ 5
Source: Google
Marcin Grabowski
★ 2
Source: Google
Tanya Rocky
★ 5
Source: Google
Chris Woodlock
★ 5
Source: Google
Scott Lysne
★ 4
Source: Google
Craig Gault
★ 5
Love the subs but not the speed they make them. Get a bit faster Subway!
Source: Google
Austin Deford
★ 4
Source: Google
BARRY OLLILA
★ 5
Source: Google
Jen Beckman
★ 4
Nice staff
Source: Google
Elizabeth Morse
★ 5
But temperature inside the building was perfect friendly service just a great experience once again. Poynette is great!!
Source: Google
Ann Moran
★ 5
Great sandwich ever visit ! We stop here often on our way north! Busy and efficient crew! We make a point of letting staff know we appreciate the job they're doing! We have judged MANY Subways by ordering the Italian BMT, for about 20 years!They are the best!
Source: Google
Kim Rosol
★ 5
This Subway location is top notch. Everything is fresh and the sandwiches are made with the perfect amount of veggies and dressings. The employees were very polite, friendly and all had smiles. I highly reccomend this Subway location.
Source: Google
mary yauch
★ 5
Good but priced kinda high for sub
Source: Google
Dawn Riske
★ 5
Quick, attentive, food was just right.
Source: Google
Auntie D
★ 4
Good food, good Service
Source: Google
Kaylin Shampo
★ 3
Source: Google
Marci Ward
★ 5
Excellent service! Great staff. Friendly environment!! Very fresh food. Really enjoyed the jalapeno cheddar bread.
Source: Google
Dustin Armitage
★ 5
Great atmosphere. Subs made Well!!
Source: Google
Yun-Cheng Chen
★ 5
Source: Google
Matt Forrest
★ 5
They R the only place that have spinach leafs.
Source: Google
Cindy Reigstad
★ 5
Source: Google
Paul Ethun
★ 4
Source: Google
Sherry Morse
★ 1
Ok
Source: Google
Tim Sellnow
★ 5
Source: Google
Marcia Hanson
★ 5
Love it!
Source: Google
Elisabeta Negrau
★ 5
Friend Service, good food
Source: Google
Julie Beth Kirtley
★ 5
Love their regular club sandwich!
Source: Google
Teresa
★ 4
Source: Google
Bill Eichenlaub
★ 5
Source: Google
Jack Strauss
★ 5
Great owners, and friendly staff
Source: Google
Ashley Polster
★ 5
Source: Google
Novie Newingham
★ 5
Source: Google
Craig Nelson
★ 3
Source: Google
Vladimir Leshchenko
★ 4
Source: Google
Matthew
★ 5
Source: Google
Christian Hawkins
★ 5
Source: Google
C H
★ 4
Source: Google
Pam Sauber
★ 5
Source: Google
dreaddy
★ 5
Love the service and food
Source: Google
Sandeep K.S
★ 5
Clean subway with quick service
Source: Google
Laura May
★ 5
Fast, quick service. Fresh food
Source: Google
Jassell Rondon
★ 3
Source: Google
SlimeGuy
★ 3
Source: Google
Tracy Zook
★ 1
Bathrooms were dirty (both) & we got slimy rotten apples! Never had this problem at another subway
Source: Google
Rocio I. Cabrera
★ 1
The lady that prepared our sandwich was rude. She interupted me and was rushing me even though I was the only person in the store. The cashier was normal though.
Source: Google
wisco girl
★ 1
This has got to be the rudest people I have ever had. Every time I've been in there it's like I'm interrupting their social hour. I get friendlier service from a Walmart greeter. If YOU Don't Like YOUR Job Get A New one.
Source: Google
Val McReath
★ 5
Very good food and service.
Source: Google
Kelly Petzold
★ 4
Great sandwich
Source: Google
Lisa Simek
★ 1
We experienced a very rude staff. Our Last sandwich was thrown at us. I thanked the girl.... She ignored me. So I said it again. She finally acknowledge me. Even the kids with us felt uncomfortable. I made a point to say 'no reason to be so rude' as I walked out. A woman heard me as she waited in line. She made aapoint to come up to our car and thank me for making a point to state that the staff was very rude. She said they are like that Everytime she goes in there.
The cashier was the only nice girl. The sandwiches were very good but with a staff like that..... McDonald's or Hardee's looks like our next choice while we pass through.
Source: Google
Ross Barnett (Beyond Earth Sudios)
★ 4
Good service.
Source: Google
Vineet Aggarwal (Vin)
★ 5
Source: Google
Rusty Shackleford
★ 5
Nicolas Leighty's review sounds accurate
Source: Google
Nicolas Leighty (DutchedUp)
★ 5
Seems like a solid operation. The staff were nice. Now when I went there, their computer system was down so they could only accept cash. The gentleman who started my order forgot to tell me that, and I did not have cash so they told me to take the meal for free. I hope the guy didn't get grilled for that, I've made on-the-job goofs (dare I say) worse than that, and I know what it's like dealing in the fast food op-human error is bound to happen.
Source: Google
Elizabeth Martinez (Betsy)
★ 4
Source: Google
Dougal
★ 5
Source: Google
My Son Shuttle Service
★ 5
Source: Google
Jesus Cegrestte
★ 4
Nice service
Source: Google
Scott Geiger
★ 5
Very efficient staff, sandwich nearly looks as good as in photos in store!
Source: Google
Guilibaldo Alvarez
★ 4
Source: Google
donald kilen
★ 5
Source: Google
Sharon Munro
★ 5
Filled up subs for the road.
Source: Google
Robin R. Skinner
★ 5
Source: Google
Shelley Peterson
★ 5
Customer service excellent, food extremely fresh veggies
Source: Google
Sergiu Popov
★ 5
Very nice place
Source: Google
David D.
★ 5
Usually stop in on Saturday mornings to get a Sub.
Staff at that time is extremely attentive and helpful. The staff at that particular time should be considered for promotion and/or flexibility in any hour/commute/benefits items that any worker faces.
As far as the quality of the food: the bread tastes better than that provided by the franchise store in Middleton. I appreciate it.
Feel free to respond with any questions and/or clarification.
Thank you,
David
Source: Google
sagar shrestha
★ 5
I love how simple and non expensive the subs are. Good costumer service
Source: Google
Patricia Christian
★ 5
Source: Google
Jessica McCracken
★ 5
Source: Google
Herb Zoellick
★ 4
Source: Google
Ben Snyder
★ 5
Good service and food
Source: Google
Neal Silbert
★ 5
a nice well run subway restaurant with good well prepared food.
Source: Google
karla kovacik
★ 5
Source: Google
Jack Locke
★ 5
Staff always nice ,good sandwich, and prices seem better than some other subways
Source: Google
Lynn Malone
★ 4
The 2 ladies that were working June 5 about 6pm....they work very well together. Good sammiches and good attitude!
Source: Google
Susan Wenger
★ 3
Delicious! Good service
Source: Google
Travis Williams
★ 3
A wonderful place to take the kids! Service was great and the food was okay for fast food. Parking was a bit squeezed. My experience overall was good aside from the couple in the back being touchy feely with each other which I think isn't very acceptable. I hope this matter can be resolved so I can take the kids back.
Source: Google
Wiley Allard
★ 4
Quick clean, and a pleasant place off the road to grab a bite. The parking a bit narrow, but that my only gripe.
Source: Google
John Gabbei
★ 4
Great service and good food.
Source: Google
David Williams
★ 4
Source: Google
Jess Anderson
★ 1
Source: Google
Baul Haque
★ 5
Great place, friendly staff!
Source: Google
Jon Esch
★ 4
Source: Google
Setul Patel
★ 4
Source: Google
Scott Wagner
★ 5
Friendly staff, convenient location for the area.
Source: Google
Jessi Reible
★ 2
Just in Subway in Poynette. The first guy, actually all the employees had some sort of issue. No smiling at all and everyone acted pissed off. Very uncomfortable feeling. The first sandwich artist was the worst. I'll have steak and cheese with American toasted. He puts the steak on and says "what kind of cheese". The next is a meatball sub with provolone. He puts on the meatballs on and says "what kind of cheese". Same thing for all 4 sandwiches...Seriously dude, do u have the memory of an ant?
Source: Google