Sunset Grill Pewaukee

Pewaukee, W278 N2315 Prospect Ave #200, Pewaukee, WI 53072, United States | ★ 4.2 (745 Review)

📞 +1 262-696-4578

Last Search

Category

Bar & grill Restaurant

Description

Laid-back hangout with a deck on Pewaukee Lake offering pizza, wings, beer & TVs for sports.

Photos

 Sunset Grill Pewaukee
 Sunset Grill Pewaukee
 Sunset Grill Pewaukee
 Sunset Grill Pewaukee
 Sunset Grill Pewaukee
 Sunset Grill Pewaukee
 Sunset Grill Pewaukee
 Sunset Grill Pewaukee

Leave a Review

Reviews

Cheryl Wersland

★ 5

Second time to visit this lakeside restaurant.
Both times atmosphere, service, and entrée were wonderful.

Source: Google

Jana Kegley

★ 5

Such a nice sunlighty place!

Source: Google

Vernon Lesner

★ 5

Source: Google

Angelica Willert Castillo

★ 5

Source: Google

chuck schultz

★ 5

Source: Google

Brian Bayer

★ 4

Good selection of appetizers and entrees. Blackened salmon was very good.

Source: Google

Michael Hoehnen

★ 5

Source: Google

Roger Parys

★ 4

Source: Google

Aleta Shumway

★ 4

Source: Google

bigpapaduck1

★ 3

Source: Google

Sporty Wiz

★ 5

Source: Google

Trevor Olive

★ 5

Source: Google

Bridget

★ 1

If you are going to have a food lead time of 1.5 hours on TOP of a 55 minute table wait, make sure your customers know about it. Additionally, if you’re going to have a 1.5 hour food wait, your servers should be table touching more often. We waited 30 minutes to order, 45 AFTER that minutes to be asked if we wanted drinks after being empty for 30 minutes and 30 more minutes before asking where our food was and being told it would be another 10 minutes. Which, turned into 25 minutes.

It may be an anomaly, but this was bad enough to warrant it being shared.

Source: Google

Debra Donnenfield

★ 5

Source: Google

david

★ 3

Great atmosphere, but way overpriced. Pretty much everything my group got was below average. If they weren’t on the lake, they’d be empty.

Source: Google

Barb Byczynski

★ 4

Source: Google

Nathan

★ 1

This is the only time in my entire life I did not leave a tip. My girlfriend and I sat at the bar to watch Michael Sean sing there. Robbie was suppose to be our server. He paid little to no attention to us the entire night. We tried multiple times to get his attention but he was more concerned with drinking behind the bar and the beer taps which were pouring out more head than beer. We eventually had to order from another server who wasn't bad. We ordered the fish fry and some cheese curds. The food took 43 minutes to get out to us. I was contemplating leaving because it took so long. The cheese curds were suppose to be appetizers. The curds came out the same time as the rest of our food. We had to order our drinks from another server too because of the lack of attention Robbie gave us. We saw, multiple times, the other bar tender(not sure of her name) who wore black and pink leopard shirt take shots and get drunk. We only ordered sprite and a pepsi for drinks. By the time our fish got to us, it was cold and the fries...to say the least...we would have gotten more fries by ordering a small fry at mcdonalds. We complained about the small portion, again, to another server because we couldn't get Robbie's attention, and she was nice enough to get us some more fries and agreed we were getting a "gipped" with such a small order or fries. This woman was the only person we could get any service from. She had buzzed-side-of-the-head hair cut so ALL props to her on making it just bearable enough for me to not just stiff the bill.

Curds were terrible, greasy, and were mostly air. It was an all you can eat fish(friday night) too. I waited for my server to come back and ask me if I wanted more fish. But alas, this did not happen. I had to, like a child, raise my hand and call him out to get his attention. I then ordered more fish which he then asked, how many do you want? I replied with 3. We waited 30 minutes...nothing. Robbie finally saw our drinks were empty and the remainder of our curds left and asked, "If we are done." I replied, "No, we are still waiting for our other food to come". He then goes to the kitchen...comes out and says..."Oh, someone must have eaten it. I forgot about", I replied with..."Forget it. I out of here. Just give me my damn check." I left hungry and thirsty. I looked on my bill and saw I was charged for 3 sodas. $2 each. Just because I wanted to get the hell out of there, I just paid the bill and left. No tip. Never going back again, and they can definitely believe I will never recommend that place to any other person again.

Service from my actual server: F Robbie was terrible
Food Temperature: D Cold
Food Quantity: D Small portions
Food Quality: B Tasted good(except for curds)
Ambiance: D Small, dirty
Pleasant Experience: F, Floor was slippery, A server told me she slipped and fell 4 times that day
Price: D Expensive for such small quantities

Source: Google

Bernie Dunne

★ 5

Source: Google

Kennedy Halliburton

★ 1

Noelle sucked. She barely came over and it took her 20+ minutes to grab my card. Food is great but will not be coming back.

Source: Google

Marty Meyer

★ 4

Source: Google

Kim Werner

★ 5

Source: Google

Annelise Worden

★ 1

We sat down and we waited 30 minutes. Waited for our food 15 minutes. The server did not check in on us at all. No one was nice. Very disappointed. Please respond

Source: Google

Joshua Watson

★ 4

Food is a bit overpriced for the quality but the atmosphere is what you're paying for. The music was great. Definitely a local spot, wouldn't make a trip just for a visit.

Source: Google

William Casper

★ 5

Source: Google

Kathie Beaumont

★ 4

Source: Google

Mike F

★ 5

Source: Google

Cindy L.

★ 5

Live music, delicious food and drinks on Pewaukee with friendly service = a perfect Sunday afternoon

Source: Google

Tom Lausten

★ 3

Source: Google

Ken Schinke

★ 5

Tracy was amazing!

Source: Google

Lisa Kurtz-Romano

★ 5

Source: Google

Speedy One

★ 4

Source: Google

Gavin Nedland

★ 5

Great time, great vibes. Bartender was awesome, took great care of us and made us feel welcome. I think he said his name was Cody!

Source: Google

ban9erang

★ 5

Hands down best bar in the area - Cody was my bartender and he made it a wonderful experience. Can’t recommend this place enough and will definitely be back!

Source: Google

Sean Allen

★ 4

Great food on the lake. Got a bit loud and a fun place.

Source: Google

Debbie Umentum

★ 2

We were there on a Wednesday. It took a very long time to get menus, drinks including waters and food . People around us were getting their orders taken before us even though they arrived after. It seemed we were forgotten. Due to taking an hour and a half to get our food, we had to box it immediately without eating and leave due to having three small children and having to return the boat to the dock . Service was horrible. We got our own drinks from the bar because it was taking so long. We will not be returning. Although the Food was good.

Source: Google

James Evans

★ 5

Elise is awesome! Great with kids- awesome food - easy boat parking! Can’t wait to come back

Source: Google

kathryn wegmann

★ 5

Great!!!!!!!

Source: Google

Trevor Olive

★ 5

Source: Google

Janette Marsh

★ 4

Very generous portions, loved the fried pickles. Never felt rushed, and the view of the lake was very nice!

Source: Google

chris mingari

★ 5

Great atmosphere

Source: Google

Steve Day

★ 4

Source: Google

Jay Fernandez

★ 5

Source: Google

Omayra Nieves

★ 5

Excellent service and places

Source: Google

Karen Kirkpatrick

★ 5

We sat on the patio overlooking the lake... We had a Caribbean chicken wrap sandwich with homemade potato chips... And a couple of specialty drinks... Everything was delicious The view was great and we're definitely coming back....

Source: Google

Barry Arnold

★ 3

Outside patio on shores of Pewaukee Lake.

Source: Google

Cassandra Zimmerman

★ 4

Source: Google

Jeffrey C. Van Calligan

★ 4

Source: Google

Betty Zimdars

★ 5

We went there with a party of 8 and they were so helpful and was so on point with everything. I'll definitely be going back. Worth the 1 hour drive

Source: Google

Jeff Geoff

★ 3

They did not have grapefruit juice. , 😔

Source: Google

Sam Cundari

★ 4

First time here. Food was decent and came out pretty fast. Very nice interior. They have a patio but we sat inside.

Will be back.

EDIT:

Came back! Was busier than last time but we were able to get a table for 3 with zero wait. Had the same server, too!

Everything we ordered came out hot and delicious.

Source: Google

Rick S.

★ 4

Fun place for music and has a couple bars, 1 right down by the water on Pewaukee Lake. Usually have live music on weekends in the summer! Fun Place!

Source: Google

Ross Jacomet

★ 4

Source: Google

Todd

★ 5

This is a great place to grab drinks and enjoy the Wisconsin summer weather! The lake view was gorgeous!

We sat on the back patio for some live music. The drinks were priced well.

We ate dinner and loved the food. The nachos were a monstrous portion and loaded with toppings! The brisket was a great choice! The cheese curds were above average.

The Mac and cheese really stood out! The salad was kind of mediocre, but perfectly fine.

Source: Google

Binder Johl

★ 5

Great place for a casual spring meal.

Source: Google

Dan Christenson

★ 5

Great atmosphere on the back deck overlooking Pewaukee Lake. Awesome service and really good food! Great dining in the Lake Country area.

Source: Google

Diana López

★ 4

Source: Google

Linda Remm

★ 5

The food is great and so is the service. Sometimes they have live music. We've been there many times for family gatherings and had a great time. One of our favorite restaurants!

Source: Google

Seth Hofstad

★ 4

Atmosphere is sound. Haven't tried much on the menu. Food is solid not outstanding

Source: Google

Sharon

★ 1

(I prefer NO stars, but that is not an option) HORRIBLE Experience! This place needs to get their act together. We were told it would be a 40 minute wait- miraculously in 10 minutes a young lady said to us, "you can go sit over there in the corner...the table is dirty, but someone will clean it." We waited by the table for 10 minutes or more. I made eye contact with the hostess, so she walked over with a bar towel from the hostess stand and "swished it" across the table. No sanitizer, spray, etc. - very sloppy and definitely not cleaned. We reluctantly sat down to look at the menu. But - NO ONE WAITED ON US!? After several minutes, we got up and walked out. Upon leaving I mentioned to the young lady at the hostess stand that we were leaving as no one came to our table. As I should have expected... she rolled her eyes and shrugged her shoulders as if "oh well".
I suggest anyone considering this place thinks twice. Obviously the customer is not very important. The dining area was infested with mosquitoes. I definitely should have taken advice from a diner who was leaving as we waited for a table. She commented the food was not very good ... we are probably lucky we missed the opportunity!

Source: Google

Fred Neve

★ 4

Source: Google

Michael Kretschmer

★ 4

Good wings!

Source: Google

Rafael Hidalgo

★ 5

First timers here. We came here after my graduation ceremony. Servers were pretty attentive and professional. The food was great and cooked the right way. Definitely loved the scenery around this restaurant. Totally coming back again.

Source: Google

jeff freed

★ 5

Nice find. Great view of the lake.

Source: Google

rich defrancesca

★ 5

Source: Google

E B-Zg

★ 4

Beautiful lakeside view perfect for a Spring lunch. Loved the fish dishes, cod was better than the perch. Nice and friendly service but wish there were more servers to help out. Highly recommend checking this place out and we definitely will come back next time we are in town.

Source: Google

Diana Mantz

★ 1

Our second time here. Two words—don’t bother. Best part? The lake view. Worst part? The food. Service is slow, you sit for awhile before they come over. The fish fry was horrible! Overcooked frozen fish, coleslaw without dressing or flavor, potato pancakes were incinerated. My husband ordered Ketel One, which was served in a plastic cup. Really? So sad! This place is always packed, and I don’t understand why—unless people go strictly for the view. It has great potential, but really doesn’t live up to expectations. We won’t be back.

Source: Google

Laurie Schade

★ 3

Source: Google

matthew wheeler

★ 5

Source: Google

Matt Thompson

★ 5

The food and service were superb!

Source: Google

Floyd Parker

★ 5

Source: Google

Bryce Becker

★ 1

This is a bar for old people who just got done with a round of golf and want a mediocre sandwich. The server I had was good, but I got the brisket sandwich, and it was dry beyond the word dry. It was a zero flavor at all. The BBQ sauce was terrible! Not to mention the massive piece of cabbage I pulled out from the "coleslaw" (I could barely tell it was on the sandwich) my girlfriend had the chicken bacon sandwich and the chicken tasted as if it was fried with fish and it was also DRY! If you like a bar with an identity crisis and dry food, this is the bar for you!

Source: Google

julie waln

★ 5

We visited this Establishment yesterday! Our waitress Marilyn was wonderful! She was super friendly and welcoming! She provided excellent customer service ! I make a point to recognize great employees and experiences! We will definitely will ask for Marilyn next time! Thanks so much for our nice experience! Shout to Marilyn for her great personality and work ethic!
The Hawaii couple!

Source: Google

Epicmineshafter Vlogs

★ 5

Great place! Our food was excellent (buffalo chicken wrap, patty melt, fries, motz sticks). The motz sticks were genuinely some of the best I've ever had. Great selection of various beers on tap and in bottles. Our server Garret was a nice guy, Great talking with him and fast service. Definitely worth coming in to give it a try.

Source: Google

scott conrad

★ 5

Source: Google

Matt Ron

★ 4

Source: Google

teresa beck

★ 4

I've tried many items on the menu over the last 8 yrs and just don't like it. Now in all fairness I think they got a new cook in the last year or 2? And have not tried them again. But it's a great place to go watch a game and have cocktails

Source: Google

Jason Schuepbach

★ 4

Source: Google

Scott Anderson

★ 5

Source: Google

Bob Ribar

★ 5

Source: Google

Jeff Rohloff

★ 5

Waitress was Cameron. Can't say enough about service, professionalism. Coconut shrimp was the best ever. Wife hand tenderloin sandwich. AAAAA. I had the haddock, best ever. Will be back and back.

Source: Google

Tracy Mazurek

★ 5

Source: Google

Christy Liss

★ 4

We arrived on a Friday night. We got on the list for a 15-20 minute wait about 6:30. It was very busy and loud with people at the bar waiting. We were sat after 20 minutes. Service was alright. We got a couple drinks and received an incorrect appetizer. Drinks were reasonably priced even for mixed options. Cheese curds were good. Boneless wings seemed over-cooked. Fish was plentiful serving size for the price. It was ok but not great. Fish tacos were not typical in that they seemed to be tacos with fish but didn't have the usual spicy slaw. Panini was ok as well.

Source: Google

Mick Rotta

★ 4

Source: Google

Shannon Wegner

★ 1

I come here to work while my son sails at the club around he corner. And while I might not be the typical bar rat for this establishment I do have money to spend and I tend to be a healthy tipper when treated with respect but ..... when I make eye contact with a server/tender and they walk way and ignore more than once..... I am over it. I will come. I will have my beverage, I will order my treats for the hungry boys after their practice and yes - I will leave a sub par tip.

Tips are earned not just given ... talk to me, be nice to me, follow up eye contact with a 'Need something love?'. More than anything, treat me like I am less than human and I simply can't.

PS - Your spinach artichoke dip is gross.

Source: Google

Bill Eder

★ 4

Source: Google

Jordyn Maki

★ 5

Source: Google

Derek Entringer

★ 5

Source: Google

Ian Dow

★ 5

Source: Google

Craig Redman

★ 4

Nachos were ok. After you get past the lack of steak, the gas station nacho cheese and the over abundance of chips it was just OK. View is incredible. Wait staff is great. Drinks, again are ok.

Source: Google

Jeremiah Mactzul

★ 2

You pay for the view.

Source: Google

Cindy Michel

★ 5

Source: Google

Cody Boys

★ 5

The waiter service was great

Source: Google

David Foldy

★ 5

Source: Google

Lynn Smith

★ 5

We had a lovely meal on the patio overlooking the lake. My steak was great- cooked just right and a good price, too.

Source: Google

Kelly Youngs

★ 5

Source: Google

Andrea Jendrzejek

★ 5

Last night was my second time and it was exactly what I needed. Good pizza, a drink, while the sun was setting. Perfect!

Source: Google

Joyce hill

★ 5

Source: Google

Jim Peters

★ 5

Source: Google

Alien Glass

★ 3

Meh

Source: Google

Denis Bond

★ 5

Great aftertaste.

Source: Google

Chantyl Shumaker

★ 5

My 1st time there was this past wknd on Saturday which happened to be the day b4 my Bday. Love it and will be back soon...

Source: Google

BP

★ 5

Great views, good food, good service. Did I mention great lake views?

Source: Google

Eduviges Mateo

★ 5

Source: Google

Kelly Detweiler

★ 4

Good service, beautiful view

Source: Google

Tiffany G

★ 4

Source: Google

Katie Seghers

★ 2

My party and I sat on the patio at an open table that wasnt bussed. After 10 mins or so, we finally just did it ourselves. No one acknowledged us and we watched people who sat after us have their orders taken. We flagged down a server and asked to see menus only for her to tell us “I’m not your server.” Ok then who is?

Our server finally came over and seemed annoyed, like we were bothering her. We put in our orders. When our food came, I started eating and noticed the ranch that was supposed to be included wasnt on the plate. I would’ve asked for it, but our server never came to check on us. So my wrap was dry.

When you go to pay, they stand over you which is awkward with the tip part. I didnt like that. And why is 18% the lowest? She didn’t deserve that. I’m normally a person who tips 20-25% too. I likely won’t be back. Lots of other places to choose from. It’s a shame because it’s a nice location.

Source: Google

Nadea Hefti

★ 5

Such a nice spot. We sat outside and enjoyed the weather and our food.

Source: Google

omar shaikh

★ 5

Source: Google

Dana Slottke

★ 5

Source: Google

Daniel Hefti

★ 5

Randomly stopped while heading west out of Milwaukee. Great find!

Source: Google

Dawn Johnson

★ 3

Website menu is not up to date. Ordered a tropical wrap which is on the smaller side. Came pressed/warm which I wasn't expecting for something tropical. Asked for more mango salsa which was supposed to be on it but found out they were out so guess it was never put on in the first place (?). Housemade chips were very bland and didn't eat them. Husband had the salmon w potatoes and veggies. Veggies looked like they were from a frozen food bag. If you eat inside, it can be very loud just with people talking. Probably nice to eat on deck when weather is nice. Waitress was nice and tried to be helpful but didn't seem to care that the chips were not good. Wrap was definitely overpriced for what I got.

Source: Google

Linda B-D

★ 2

Source: Google

Jessi R

★ 4

Ordered the Sunset club sandwich with housemade chips. The bread on the sandwich was so delicious, it was a great choice. Chips were decent, although I always like them on the lighter side. Soda was three dollars, and fun nonalcoholic drinks were five dollars. That was a little overpriced. But the food was reasonably priced. We sat outside on the patio and it was a beautiful Wisconsin summer evening, just above 70° and a beautiful sunset. Nice waitresses.

Source: Google

Kyle Hytry

★ 5

Source: Google

Dylan Cordero

★ 5

Food was great great people could have a better server

Source: Google

Marcia Wallschlaeger

★ 5

Good food, great music.
Drinks and ate on the patio by the water.

Source: Google

Darci Johnson

★ 5

Beautiful patio right on the lake. Great food, drinks, and service. Recommend checking them out.

Source: Google

Dan Muller

★ 4

Drinks are terrible. Don’t have a drink list if your bartenders can’t execute and worse yet inconsistent
So then we ask for a mai tai. One has grenadine one does not. This dude sucks and should stick to serving beer and white claw.
Well we thought we would try one more time. Here is the 3rd mai tai.

Source: Google

Phil Starck

★ 5

Source: Google

Kimberly

★ 5

Great food. Great patio to enjoy the lake.

Source: Google

Kelli Butenhof

★ 5

Great atmosphere and reasonable drinks. We will be back to try their food!

Source: Google

Robert Sexton

★ 5

Source: Google

Nicole Mariani

★ 5

I lived in Pewaukee for almost ten years and never paid this place a visit. Today I met up with a friend from my old neighborhood and I was pleasantly surprised by this place.
I am vegan and there was actually a menu item I could order without making changes. It was a delicious tropical wrap. Yum.
We sat outside and what a lovely view. Great atmosphere. Our dog was allowed with us at the table. I was impressed that the host came over with a bowl of water for our pup since we left ours in the car.
My husband had a panini and he loved it!!

We will be back and look forward to it.

Source: Google

Cloud C

★ 5

Food service was extremely slow but it was a very busy Friday

Source: Google

A L

★ 5

Source: Google

Holly Corso Fons

★ 5

Great vibe, great food !!

Source: Google

Mary Beth Medina

★ 5

Source: Google

Jerry Ewing

★ 5

Great place off the lake friendly people and reasonable prices as well.

Source: Google

Diane Rose-Deakin

★ 3

Source: Google

Tom Deakin

★ 2

Source: Google

Barbara Sem

★ 5

Source: Google

Kevan

★ 1

Hotter than all get out inside. Also what kind of bar/restaurant's in lake country closes its kitchen at 8pm on a beautiful Tuesday evening with a bar full of paying customers. They definitely do not expect patrons to want to eat food while they drink. The only saving grace for this place is the view, if they did not have that they would be out of business in a heartbeat. From previous experiences here they are slow for service, have over priced food, and parking is atrocious. I would recommend against this place.

Source: Google

Steve Michalski

★ 5

Wonderful atmosphere. A while back, this used to be a wonderful pizza place. Visited three times in a month. I think it's a serious leadership problem that ultimately causes MANY CURRENT ISSUES: 1) Uneven, often poor service. Failing to even ask if customer wants a re-fill or a drink, even after long waits. Repeated failing to give condiments, napkins, and silverware. 2) Slow delivery (45 minutes up to 1.5 hours) to get ANY food at table. 3) Substitutions. Using Liquid Cheddar, in place of real cheddar, on a pizza?. Using canned Salsa in place of FRESCO. 4) Delivering food that is burned(pizza), overcooked(under heat lamp?)-cheese running across entire plate on hamburger, with cooked lettuce. 5) DRINKS...Mixed Results, even on simple bar drinks. Probably best to stick to simple bottled beer, or water. I would usually think tap beer would be safe, but then i got very cloudy IPA served to me, too.

Update: September 1, 2020.... Visit #4, for the summer. Seems they may have seen and reacted. Had a great time and finally saw them routinely taking good care of customers. Bumped from one star to three star.

Source: Google

Leo Kos

★ 5

Source: Google

Siobhan Dittmer

★ 5

Came for a girls night with a couple friends and we had an absolutely amazing time! Rachel was our server and even though they were super busy she never failed to check on us and make sure we had everything we needed. She was also very friendly and did not make us feel like a bother at all. Exceptional service, definitely ask for Rachel to be your server!

Source: Google

love the music

★ 5

Very nice place right on the lake ,plenty of seating inside and outside ,food was awesome

Source: Google

Brett Liebau

★ 4

Source: Google

Michael Woelky

★ 2

Overall it is getting expensive. Go across the street for cheaper beer

Source: Google

Jason Wheeler

★ 5

Source: Google

Brian Hale

★ 5

Great waiter, very helpful. Excellent view of the water and sunset

Source: Google

Adam Clausen

★ 5

Source: Google

Jeremy Smith

★ 5

If you like wings, you need to come here. Wednesday nights after golf at western lakes I come here. The wings are huge compared to most bar and grills and 10 wings fills me up. Ashley served me at the bar and had my wings out to me in 10 minutes. I ate and drank well for like $11. Of course I had to tip Ashley for the phenomenal service.

Source: Google

Jon Tout

★ 4

Great outdoor seating. We went for lunch but would like to come back for a sunset.

Source: Google

Callie Bilodeau

★ 5

Really good food and a great view of the lake. Indoor and outdoor seating

Source: Google

Darnell Thomas

★ 4

Nice spot, great good. I like the live banks.

Source: Google

Michele Krause

★ 5

Monday. Ight Mexican specials. $18 nachos feed 5. Genius and delicious. Thin crust pizza was delicious too

Source: Google

Tom Rolfson

★ 5

Beautiful lakeside dining with a beach side vibe like many around the U.S. A perfect sunset dining location. While a wide variety on the menu, the Salmon is great!

Source: Google

Jan Plantier

★ 5

We were there for a wedding. Great outdoor dining and the food was fantastic.

Source: Google

Steve Hasler

★ 5

Source: Google

Todd Stephenson

★ 5

Source: Google

Brooke kowalski

★ 5

Source: Google

Baron von Sapphire

★ 5

You wanna kick, stretch and kick? Get the buffalo chicken sandwich.

Source: Google

Chris D

★ 5

Wow! It was a beautiful evening dining outside with 5 other friends on the lower patio. The umbrellas helped with the bright sun and the tables filled up quickly.
All 6 of us loved our meals: Margaritas, Mojitos, Crispy Chicken Sandwich, BBQ Pulled Pork, Tator Tots, Crab Cakes, Chicken Salad, Patty Melt, and the most incredible $15 Steak Special! There was not a misstep with the food.
But let me tell you the steak special was unexpectedly wonderful, and we still can't believe it was only $15 for the delicious steak, potatoes and veggies!
Although we have lived in the area for a few years we had never been here and now we find ourselves looking forward to coming back. The place opens for lunch and I think we will try that next time.
For all 6 of us the bill was $155 before the tip, which is very reasonable, especially since we had drinks also.
I find nothing to complain about. I do wish our server had been less busy, but she did just fine for us and we left feeling we had just had a great meal in a great atmosphere.

Source: Google

Doreen Kurkowski

★ 5

A friend and I enjoyed some appetizers instead of dinner. I had a Long Island Ice Tea and she had a lemonade. The Long Island was one of the best ones I’ve ever had.

A couple weeks ago I went with my family for a fish fry. The perch was amazing! The plate was generous with 3 extra large pieces with all the fixings! I shared with my dad and still packed up some food.
Oh I almost forgot the clam chowder was one of the best ones I’ve had.

Source: Google

Vince Struhar

★ 5

Source: Google

Sami Taylor

★ 5

They made my steak dry the first time but they fixed it quick and brought me a medium rare. Great vibe, lake views, great staff!

Source: Google

Jerry D. McCormick Jr.

★ 5

Source: Google

Vanesa Pesut

★ 1

Source: Google

Daniel

★ 1

If you want to be sat in a timely manner and actually wanna walk out of a restaurant full I wouldn’t recommend this place what so ever. First off there’s not a host in sight or anyone to greet you it’s pretty much a free ball game to sit wherever anywhere you sit 9/10 your table will be sticky and dirty. The servers here don’t explain anything about their food just pretty much order so they can be paid and tipped and get you out the way. If you want to save some money and actually enjoy some food look else where, they have to offer a free shot obviously because there service is so damn bad.

Source: Google

John Frye

★ 5

Source: Google

Ed Przyczkowski

★ 5

Source: Google

Jason Bell

★ 4

Source: Google

Roger Gollakner

★ 5

Source: Google

Christine Hart

★ 4

Our waitress was awesome. Food was OK. Bar was really loud (does saying that make me old?)

Source: Google

Daven Derendel

★ 5

Source: Google

dean rams

★ 4

Source: Google

Mike Boldon

★ 5

great experience

Source: Google

D S

★ 1

We ordered nachos to go with extra meat. The cheese was processed, cheap canned nacho cheese. The chips are a poor quality and there was not any extra meat . They’re okay with changing a carry out fee for this trash. Bernie needs to step it up here in lake county. Thumbs down

Source: Google

Adam O'Brien

★ 5

Source: Google

Johnathan Reddick

★ 5

Source: Google

Bikes Boats Boots WI

★ 4

A good bar with decent food. Enjoyed the grilled salmon with a nice heep of mashed potatoes with garlic butter sauce, side of grilled veggies. I ordered a grilled shrimp skewer add-on and got 5 medium shrimp for $14. That was a major disappointment.

Source: Google

Tim Haas

★ 4

Source: Google

S L

★ 5

Food was good service was excellent atmosphere was great. There were two of us, I had the tuna melt which was a little different with some red and green peppers but very tasty. The other person had pulled pork sandwich and a bloody mary. He said the bloody Mary was very good.

Source: Google

David Lonski

★ 5

Source: Google

Chris Czerwinski

★ 5

Source: Google

Kevin Golliher

★ 4

Great location right on Pewaukee Lake.

The food choices are way above basic bar food. I had a Gyro and my friend had a Chimichanga. The gyro was nice, not bad but nothing really special. My friend loved her Chimi.

We ate at the bar, the bartender was friendly and attentive.

We will definitely go back.

Source: Google

Diane Tompkins

★ 5

It's always clean,fun,great service.

Source: Google

Brian Wohlfeil

★ 5

Source: Google

Marie Schmidt

★ 4

Source: Google

Debbie Albrecht

★ 5

Source: Google

Oliver Pugh

★ 5

Great fish fry. Everyone enjoyed the night. Great service and drinks too. Will definitely return.

Source: Google

Troy Murray

★ 5

Family friendly. Feels homely even if it's your first time like it was ours tonight. Food is great, fairly priced, and came very quickly.

Source: Google

Laura Bierdemann

★ 5

Source: Google

Timothy Holloway

★ 4

Great atmosphere excellant service. A great place to visit with friends.

Source: Google

Jess Anderson

★ 5

We loved everything about this place! The blackened salmon was out of This world!

Source: Google

Brad Drefahl

★ 5

Great food and service with a nice atmosphere.

Source: Google

Frank Miller

★ 4

Great pub food. The bacon burger and tater tots were terrific. Never had an empty glass as the service was terrific.

Source: Google

Mike F

★ 5

Source: Google

Thomas Casanova

★ 5

Source: Google

Michael Mizman

★ 5

Source: Google

Judie Suleski

★ 5

Beautiful location on Pewaukee Lake. We were hoping to get a table on the patio, but all were taken. We went inside and sat at a table by the windows. It was perfect. Our waitress brought drinks, and we ordered the Thursday night steak special. For $15, we had a delicious steak, mashed potatoes, and vegetables. The steak was done perfectly, and everything was great. My only complaint was that they serve the drinks in plastic cups. When I eat inside, I want glass drink glasses.

Source: Google

Chad Birkholz

★ 5

Source: Google

Bryan Eduardo Rosado Duarte

★ 4

Source: Google

Daniel Doerr

★ 5

Always wonderfyl on the lake ar SG!

Thank you, Karli, for the great service‼️

Source: Google

Ramona Collins

★ 5

This is a great place to grab drinks and enjoy the Wisconsin summer weather!

Source: Google

Mike Redford

★ 5

Source: Google

Gerald Osborne

★ 2

Source: Google

Tommie Sabourin

★ 5

Source: Google

Caroline Arndt

★ 5

Sun Kind of Living enjoys spending time at Sunset Grill! From celebrating Cinco de Mayo in spring to boating over in summer to snow shoeing or taking a snow mobile over in winter the staff here is always ready to provide great hospitality. Thanks for being part of the Pewaukee Lake community!

Source: Google

Lora Cirillo

★ 2

First they were very busy. Service suffered. We would have had a 2nd round of drinks, but after food was served, our waitress ghosted us. We even witnessed a couple being seated, ignored , and then left. The food was decent. Atmosphere??? Uhm there isn't one unless you sit on patio.

Source: Google