Tally's Tap & Eatery

Waukesha, S31W24661 W Sunset Dr, Waukesha, WI 53189, United States | ★ 4.5 (1617 Review)

📞 +1 262-446-3153

Last Search

Category

Restaurant Bar & grill Gastropub Pub

Description

Tally’s Tap & Eatery, located in Waukesha, WI, has been a third generation family owned and operated restaurant and bar since 2013. We pride ourselves on our scratch cooking, craft cocktails, great happy hour and daily food specials. In addition, we offer curbside and pick up services for our guests. We are well known for our Sunday Meat Raffles, Karaoke, and seasonal sports specials and give-aways. We strive to support local businesses and have hosted many fundraisers in our 9 years as Tally’s Tap & Eatery. We are so grateful for our guests and look forward to many more years of servicing our community.

Photos

 Tally's Tap & Eatery
 Tally's Tap & Eatery
 Tally's Tap & Eatery
 Tally's Tap & Eatery
 Tally's Tap & Eatery
 Tally's Tap & Eatery
 Tally's Tap & Eatery
 Tally's Tap & Eatery
 Tally's Tap & Eatery
 Tally's Tap & Eatery
 Tally's Tap & Eatery
 Tally's Tap & Eatery
 Tally's Tap & Eatery
 Tally's Tap & Eatery
 Tally's Tap & Eatery

Leave a Review

Reviews

Ann Dielehner

★ 5

Source: Google

Candy Fiala

★ 5

Favorite, FAVORITE fish fry!
Did I happen to mention it's my favorite fish fry?! 🐟 and their potato pancakes...get in my belly! 😋

Source: Google

Thomas Walesa

★ 4

Source: Google

Anna Bach

★ 3

Source: Google

Susie Suane

★ 5

Food is always delicious! Staff is friendly and helpful. Fun atmosphere. No complaints ever! Love this place ❤️

Source: Google

Charles Ramos

★ 5

Source: Google

ECKHARD HOFFER

★ 5

Huge plates of food. Their sign says they will feed you. That was spot on. Took home a lot of leftovers. Was a very pleasant pleasurable experience.

Source: Google

Douglas Porchetta

★ 5

First time, and the boneless wings were really really good! Tender pieces of chicken with many different sauces to choose from. Highly recommend!! Huge menu!!

Source: Google

Seth Chipendale

★ 5

We are from out of town and decided to try somewhere local. Kendra was our server and i would 100% recommend asking for her. She was super personable and just very sweet. Hands down our favorite server we have ever had anywhere. 10/10.

Source: Google

Kris Moncel

★ 5

Source: Google

Jackie Peterson

★ 5

Went for a fish fry and we had the beer battered cod. It was wonderful. Soup or salad is included with warm bread. So worth the money. Will definitely be going back

Source: Google

Dennis Siebenaller

★ 5

Source: Google

Tricia Olson

★ 5

Only disappointing part was we got there at 6:30 on a Friday and they did not have any fish left. That was the reason we were going there. The food we did have was excellent

Source: Google

Eric Frank

★ 4

Tally's is a great local restaurant in Waukesha, WI. The food is consistently good, they've got a great beer selection including some craft beers, and they make a fine Bloody Mary! The service is great, too. My one complaint might be that the prices are a bit high for Waukesha.

Source: Google

Malia Comstock

★ 5

Source: Google

ps429

★ 5

The beer battered perch was outstanding along with the unique fries. The coleslaw unfortunately was not good. No one in our party liked it. Too much mustard, not a traditional mayonnaise recipe.

Source: Google

Crystal Parker

★ 5

Source: Google

Melissa McCaman

★ 5

Great wings and boneless wings! The sauces are outstanding!

Source: Google

Saralynne Fox

★ 5

Source: Google

Mike Daigle

★ 5

Never been disapointed. Great salads, good pizza, menu has nice variety. Amazing nachos.

Source: Google

Victoria Lusz

★ 5

Source: Google

Jim Luty

★ 2

Source: Google

Austin Miller

★ 5

Very busy and yet my service was fast and the food hot. Next time I'll be in on a Friday to make sure I can get the fish

Source: Google

Angela McLaughlin

★ 5

Pluto's great family friendly fun. Just an awesome place to eat and socialize. Wonderful staff.

Source: Google

Beth Kring

★ 5

This was our first time there, and we will definitely go back.

Source: Google

Jason DuVall

★ 5

Source: Google

Laura Norwood Toro

★ 4

Source: Google

Margo Stammers

★ 5

Source: Google

Debbie Pikula

★ 2

Lots of fun!

Source: Google

Lynn Timm

★ 5

Love this place. Food is awesome. Friendly and caring staff.

Source: Google

flugualbinder

★ 2

The food is good. Decent portions and good selection. The staff is…rough. In the later evening/night they are great but during the day, not so much.

I have dined in on multiple occasions during the day. And the hostess just kind of picks and chooses who she wants to seat instead of doing first come, first serve. Have even had other customers who were waiting correct her that I was there before them. And she seemed very upset either by the fact that she had to seat me or that she was corrected, maybe both. She also made a point to tell the server of this so then the server had an unpleasant attitude the whole time. And this has happened more than once. These are not people I know personally, so I’m not sure what the issue is.

Even years back when they did delivery services with third-parties, I witnessed them be very nasty to the delivery drivers who came in to pick up orders. As in the drivers would just walk into the building and the staff would start being very verbally aggressive, almost accusatory, towards driver. The driver hadn’t even had a chance to say anything yet. It was all very bizarre.

I don’t understand all this angry and aggressive attitude towards people who are just trying to work or patronize the business. I would think you would want people in your restaurant? But they don’t seem to feel that way for whatever reason.

And, on an unrelated but important note, the parking here is god-awful.

So if you do want to try this place out, I suggest going at night for the highest probability of a good experience and a parking spot.

Source: Google

Pat Krahn

★ 1

Do not go during local baseball season. The bar and restaurant was very noisy with the older players yelling at the bat.

Source: Google

Paul Gorzalski

★ 5

Always good food and service!

Source: Google

Kelly Trautman

★ 5

Server was excellent. Food was delicious.

Source: Google

Michael Massey

★ 5

Source: Google

Kyle Boone

★ 5

Source: Google

Brittney Schwerdtfeger

★ 5

This was a fun little spot. I really enjoyed the bloody mary and the family friendly environment however they did not have any baby changing tables in the ladies or the guys bathroom so I had to change my baby on the floor :/

Source: Google

Amy Brown

★ 5

Source: Google

Sean Eurick

★ 5

Source: Google

Jed Ryan

★ 5

Source: Google

SARAH COLE

★ 5

This was honestly the best-tasting food I've eaten from a restaurant in a while. Everything we ordered was flavorful and satisfying. Drinks were great. We had great service. This was the first place we ate at in Wisconsin and everywhere else we eat will have a lot to live up to, to compare.

Source: Google

Christian Short

★ 4

Very nice remodel and atmosphere. Specials every day and great selection of drinks and a very satisfying menu. Definitely, i am going back. I took my mom. But it is a good place to have a night out with friends

Source: Google

Bruce Juhl

★ 5

The food was fantastic, the service was kind, caring and attentive. Open concept and plenty of televisions.

Source: Google

Craig Weston

★ 5

One of the best places in Waukesha. Excellent staff and food!

Source: Google

Laurel Ellenson

★ 5

Totally enjoyed the 1/2 portion of nachos

Source: Google

missy bablick

★ 5

Source: Google

Michael Pluta

★ 4

Service was excellent, and the food was delicious. The atmosphere was quiet enough that you could actually hold a conversation.

Source: Google

Leonardo Capo

★ 5

Source: Google

Edward Kohnke

★ 5

Source: Google

James K

★ 5

Source: Google

Ryan Schmidt

★ 5

Source: Google

Joe Kane

★ 5

Good food. Good service

Source: Google

Kyle Schmelzer

★ 4

Bartender we had was great, food was solid albeit a bit simple. Place is very dated and could use a face lift.

Source: Google

Scott Kastner

★ 5

Source: Google

Angie Goodman

★ 5

Source: Google

Jason Alexander

★ 5

I strongly recommend the Wisco Burger, I got mine with onions, it's absolutely amazing, and I will be coming here again.
(Update) have since been here several times and I have yet to have something I do not like, the bartenders are great and always nice, the food is great, the beer cheese tally fries, the potato skins, the Korean taco appetizer, the wings, it's all good, I love coming here.

Source: Google

Justin Cottrill

★ 5

Great all around. Excellent value for food and drinks

Source: Google

Cheryl Williams

★ 4

Great food....nice people

Source: Google

Makala Roberson

★ 5

Source: Google

Steve Baas

★ 5

Source: Google

Madie Locke

★ 4

I would come back and recommend this to other people.

The atmosphere was welcoming, but where we sat it was very hot and suspected to be the porch area. I would suggest having an AC back there.

The service there was ok. It was packed so I would expect everything to be waited a lot longer. Our server, Tori, was very welcoming and very nice to us when they were packed.

The food was good. First time having Clam Chowder there wouldn’t be my last there. The fish was good and worth the wait. A very large portion of food, but still took some home so I could enjoy it again.

Like I said would recommend this to anyone.

Source: Google

Nikki Nelson

★ 5

Source: Google

Randy Rick

★ 5

Great place to eat and awesome amospere

Source: Google

George Beutel

★ 4

Source: Google

Don Edgecomb

★ 1

Whomever made this chowder should be arrested! Worst ever! It was pathetic!

Source: Google

Cheryl Rupp

★ 5

Great service. Waitress is amazing.

Source: Google

Kristina Griz

★ 5

My family stopped in because we were in town and this place was wonderful. It was fairly packed, but the seating is arranged so it isn't overly packed. Their fries are amazing as are their burgers and wraps. It's what you'd expect from a popular restaurant with attentive servers, good portions, and a great atmosphere. They have a very diverse menu with great quality for the price. If we end up here again, we'll definitely be stopping back. My father said their queso blanco burger was the best he's ever had and their chicken wraps are actually warm. Very impressive.

Source: Google

Fred Neve

★ 5

Very vibrant and tons of great food offerings, including stuffed pretzels and really generous fish fry. OMG the fish fry! You have to try.

Source: Google

Cameron Barnes

★ 5

Source: Google

Blondie

★ 5

Source: Google

Mike (Mike 'Nerds' Neldner)

★ 5

Tried Tally's out on a lunch break and was pleasantly surprised. They were busy but we're very prompt and awesome with service and the food was delicious.

Source: Google

TonyandBarb Grant

★ 5

Source: Google

Kevin Timm

★ 5

Source: Google

mike licata

★ 2

Went on a Thursday night. Service was horrible and food was mediocre. Best thing was the Old Fashioned. Not going to waste the time to go again.

Source: Google

Jeffery Leideritz

★ 5

Great Bloody Mary for $10. Huge order of nachos. Cuban sammich good stuff!

Source: Google

Randi Thomas Mundt

★ 4

Source: Google

Matt Steffen

★ 5

Source: Google

LaNita Elliott

★ 5

I've never been here before, but my daughter ordered from here. I will say, the food was awesome! It tasted fresh, even as a carry-out! I will most certainly recommend this place!

Source: Google

Jessy Dahms

★ 5

Source: Google

Kim Hummer

★ 5

So fresh and clean and delicious

Source: Google

Ashlee Bares

★ 4

Always have great service here!

Source: Google

Casey Fechter

★ 5

Always a great visit. The food, the staff, the prices, love coming here.

Source: Google

Ian Sutherland

★ 3

Source: Google

Lukasz Sieniawski

★ 5

Source: Google

Deangelo Williams

★ 5

Source: Google

Lukasz Sieniawski

★ 5

Source: Google

Joe Ignacio

★ 4

Source: Google

Terry J Bacon II

★ 4

Source: Google

Michael Waite

★ 5

I used to hear about this place in the now defunct 1250am sports radio advertised during "The Big Show." We happened to pass by a year ago and then recently and popped in. Sensational food! The Wisco Burger is divine. Great pizza and Italian beef are made there. The Tally's Fries, particularly the Garlic Parm, are not only unique in shape but also the best fries we've ever had, hands down. Staff are great. The place is always buzzing with patrons, and they have a great beer lineup. It's also a festive, welcoming place as well as fun to watch sports.

Source: Google

Chris Lokken

★ 5

Source: Google

S Kirchen

★ 4

It wasn't busy. Our server, Bridget, was innatentive & not very friendly. I love Tally's, but I took someone there for the first time, and he said the waitress was more concerned with socializing with co-workers than doing her job.

Source: Google

Brian LeCaire

★ 5

FANTASTIC! Every meal, every bit of service, every time!

Source: Google

Kelly Detweiler

★ 3

Fun place

Source: Google

Andrea Custode

★ 5

Source: Google

Debbie Hoffmann

★ 5

Source: Google

Bert

★ 1

Got a call about 5min before I got my order to tell me that they messed up my JUST cheese KIDS quesadilla and when I get home it’s full of onions and peppers. I have also never had sweet “Jerk” chicken before nor do I want to try it again. The garlic parm boneless chicken is a dry rub (grated parm with garlic salt.) edit: one of the containers had a melted out bottom. We got a side of melted styrofoam to-go container with our child’s mini corn dogs. Thank you so much!

Source: Google

Lawrence Oberbruner

★ 5

Always a great place to relax for a good lunch.

Source: Google

Sammy Hager

★ 5

Always a fun, delicious time had at Tally's. Incredible food that you WANT to savor. Staff are always fun and excited to be there.

Source: Google

Yuriy Zaderiy

★ 3

Service was ok, the food was terrible

Source: Google

Samantha Mcintosh

★ 5

Amazing customer service! Sometimes the servers are slow but the owners truly truly care and they are amazing people. Just got to keep in mind that they get swamped in there! Wings are amazing! Pretzels are amazing! Reuben rolls are amazing! Salads are huge!! Will always support this locally owned business

Source: Google

Robert Belmer

★ 5

Source: Google

Pete Duffy

★ 5

Food is all great and service is always outstanding. Thank you!

Source: Google

Lisa

★ 5

Fries were the best I ever had

Source: Google

Keoaeka Cager

★ 5

Source: Google

Peter Young

★ 4

It was a nice place. Wish they had a draft menu at the bar instead of relying on a tv that rotates specials. Fries were really good. The prime rib sandwich was decent.

Source: Google

Rose Renick

★ 1

Source: Google

Callie Bilodeau

★ 5

Source: Google

NickeL

★ 5

Great wings

Source: Google

Pat Molitor

★ 4

Source: Google

Lynn Czech

★ 5

Source: Google

Tony Hendrickson

★ 5

Great food, very friendly employees, with warm environment .

Source: Google

Chef Robert Klemm

★ 5

Absolutely phenomenal, always!

Source: Google

Lori Bankson

★ 4

Highly recommend the Tally fries!! Great place for a bite off campus. Was good variety on menu! Our group had jerk chicken wrap, shrimp, perch, burger, and bruschetta chicken sandwich. Fun drinks!

Source: Google

Michael Gengler

★ 5

Source: Google

Chris Reed

★ 5

Source: Google

Gayle W

★ 5

Excellent. We loved the food. Good fish fry and apps. Nothing bad yet. Bartenders are pretty decent also.

Source: Google

Kim Grunwald

★ 4

Food was delicious for the most part service was good but part of meal was forgotten so they brought it out in a bag to take home but other than that very friendly and attentive.

Source: Google

Edward Rekowski

★ 2

Source: Google

carolyn czysz

★ 5

Great fish fry. Awsome potato pancakes

Source: Google

First Aid

★ 4

Great food, tremendous service. Was immediately greeted at the for quick seating. We stopped for lunch. Our order arrived less than 10 minutes later.

Chicken tenders were extremely tender and hot out of the grill. Fries were more of a wedge style and good. The burger was cooked correctly to medium rare as requested.

Prices were in the correct range. We left satiated and happy.

Source: Google

Dean Calin

★ 3

My mother told me that if you can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all. That said, forewarned is forearmed. I met a friend here as she was quite fond of the place. Sports bars are not my target destination normally, but they're usually fine with a crowd looking for fun. However, the clientele here for my meeting was absolutely obnoxious. Foul-mouthed political talk at unnecessarily loud levels was a real turn-off. On the plus side, the house music was kept at a level that permitted conversation, which is unusual for sports bars, I find. The staff was extraordinarily friendly and well-spoken, which was admirable. For the food, and I am speaking strictly about one sandwich, not the entire menu: the Philly steak sandwich was disappointing. It was served with a minimal amount of beef and enough cheese to disguise that fact. And mysteriously, it was slathered in what looked like mayonnaise! I have never had it prepared this way in all of the years and locations that I've traveled to. The meat was overcooked, and the mystery condiment overpowered everything else.

I normally never give a bad review; I judge places by what they're trying to be and how close they come to their target. I was surprisingly disappointed in the food, which offset how nice the staff was. However, if you like raucous sports bars, this could be the place for you.

Source: Google

Matthew Grajczyk

★ 5

Very busy, but they got us seated quickly. There was a mix up with our pizza going to the wrong table, but they fired off a new one super fast and comped us some drinks. Mistakes happen, but great service. Also GREAT fish fry!

Source: Google

Daniel Provenzano

★ 5

Source: Google

Angel Fontanez

★ 4

Source: Google

Brad Milovich

★ 5

Source: Google

Justin

★ 5

Source: Google

Steve Nankin

★ 5

Source: Google

John Clavette

★ 5

Source: Google

Carl Disrud

★ 5

Source: Google

Kay

★ 5

The best fish fry! Served with delish soup and great fries (other choices too) excellent service.

Source: Google

Lisa Ridenour

★ 5

The al capone sandwich is to die for!
Pictured: al capone and jerk chicken wrap, boneless wings, chicken wrap and prime rib sandwich.

Source: Google

Erica Lopez

★ 5

Good see Graciela she is the best server in town!!! Homemade meals are always the best!

Source: Google

Terry Johnson

★ 4

Food was really good and the service was good.

Source: Google

Kristyn S

★ 5

Source: Google

Crystal Rogers

★ 5

Ate outside with our dogs. Beautiful atmosphere setting with the flower planters around the eating area. Delicious Philly!

Source: Google

Ariel Aceron

★ 5

If you like simple but done well, you’ll love this place! The menu has a fantastic selection of bar food dishes that are cooked just a couple of notches up. We enjoyed everything we tried. We only have good comments about the food. We've been going to this place time after time, the kitchen crew continuously pump out good food that are seasoned and cooked well. The plants in the patio are very pretty to make a tranquil area even with the busy traffic from the street and the train noises you get. Kudos to the green thumb that arranged and planted the plants. The service here is excellent. We were immediately greeted by a server just as we walked in. We asked if it is possible for us to sit in the patio. She said, let me check with the back bartender. While we wait at the host area, not exaggerating in the span of 20 seconds, we were greeted a 2nd and a 3rd time by two different people to make sure that we were being helped. That just shows the level of the attentiveness of the team at Tally's. Shortly after, I think her name is Amber (clear green glasses) asked us to pick a seat outside and she will be behind us with the menu. While we walked through the back I noticed that the bar was semi full of few four tops, couple of 2 tops, and a party of 12. I was worried that we would wait very long to be helped. No worries, the server that greeted us and sat us introduced herself the second we sat down and asked if she can get drinks for us. I'm sure we were not in her section and she was asked to serve us since the back bartender was a very busy. Her section was in thr diining room. We are grateful that she did that even though I'm sure that was a hassle for her. Our two little boys turns into monsters when they get hangry. Amber was a ninja! She put in our drink orders and the boys dinner immediately just like we asked. We didn't have to wait long at all after that to put in our dinner orders. Our server was attentive without being intrusive. She was very pleasant and personable without making it about herself. We didn't have to wait that long at all to get our food. The entire staff worked together to create a seamless dining experience for my family. We never had to ask anything twice. Thanks to the Tally's crew who continues to provide excellent service and top notch food and drinks. See you all soon! Come support this local gem!!!

Source: Google

Sharon LeCaire

★ 5

Source: Google

Jenny

★ 4

Source: Google

Brooke Joecks

★ 5

Source: Google

Nicolas Heddinger

★ 5

This place has like the BEST damn hot wings. They’re like crack, constantly thinking about them. Also they have unique fries which are a shape I’ve never seen before but they’re absolutely amazing.

Source: Google

Curt Hornada (Cousin Vinnie)

★ 5

Ate here a few times now and absolutely love it! The food is amazing and so is the service!!

Source: Google

Maureen Lange

★ 5

Had an impromptu gathering there last night and it was great. Clean, very attentive and accommodating service, excellent food and drink. Thanks Katie and Chad!!

Source: Google

Gael Boyd

★ 4

Source: Google

sara mittelsteadt

★ 5

Great place my Friend and I found by accident. Amazing Staff and Amazing food! Neither of us are from the area so this was a great find! Hope we can come back sometime!

Source: Google

Robert Niemczyk

★ 5

Source: Google

Benjamin Kartheiser

★ 5

Amazing as always. Everyone that works here is a pro

Source: Google

Karen Seeg

★ 5

First time I've been there, everything was a great experience. Good food, very friendly and pleasant gentleman that served us.

Source: Google

Bruce K

★ 5

I went there on Wednesday, July 31st at 4:00 p.m. I had ordered online and everything was perfect when I got there. In fact, they were just bringing the food out perfectly on time, but the most outstanding part of it was the service. There's a young lady who I don't know her name that came out and she took my bag because I was parked on the far side at the bottom of the ramp and a handicap spot and she took my bag. Walked me out through the back door. Took me down the ramp. Open my passenger door and placed the order on my seat. I thought that she went above and beyond what was required and if when I go back and I will. I am hoping that I get that same young lady because she was extremely courteous, helpful and had a great smile and a great attitude too

Source: Google

Sam Smith

★ 4

Food was great. Wonderful selection of beer and spirits. The bartender was awesome. I will be back.

Source: Google

David Steffen

★ 5

Stopped for a game and a bite before returning to Tn. Was very good. Had prime sanwich and soup

Source: Google

Lorelei Carroll-Rowe

★ 2

Everything we ordered was burned to a crisp which is such a shame bc other tables' orders looked way better and tastier. Having not eaten all day, we ate the food anyway. We mentioned our distaste to our server who promptly told the manager and the manager could have cared less, never approached us or talked to us about it. She made the server collect our burned food and return it to the kitchen to remake the one item that was left. Idk if id go back to eat there

Source: Google

Colleen Hamm

★ 5

The food was great. Fresh salad and really good burger. The waitress was nice and did a great job. My husband and I split a American burger and tally fries. I also added a side salad. Everything was great. We sat in the bar area which was a little loud considering the only sporting event on was golf. Haha. There were probably 15 tv screens in the area I could see. I imagine it gets pretty wild during packer games. Definitely the sports bar atmosphere. Clean with good food and good service.

Source: Google

Kathy Weidenbaum

★ 5

Great food and friendly service are the hallmark of Tally's! Very diverse menu has something for every taste. Try the giant stuffed pretzel or the nachos to share. You won't be sorry you did!

Source: Google

Joshua Baker

★ 5

Awesome place. It gives you the feeling of happiness. Only have had pizza and wings, so far, both pretty good.

Source: Google

Nick Dorshorst

★ 5

Good food, good service.

Source: Google

DJ Palm

★ 1

I ordered the baked fish. It was two very tiny pieces of fish. The drawn butter serving was the same size as a piece of fish! All for $20!! It was a joke. The dining atmosphere is extremely noisy. I’d compare it to eating at sports event with thousands of patrons. Our waitress was friendly, and the service was very good. I paid with a credit card & was very surprised that the tip was put thru separately so that the waitstaff also paid the merchants fee. This is not inflation it is greed.

Source: Google

Dennis Goratowski

★ 5

Source: Google

Ja Sh

★ 4

For a "tavern" food was very good, & plentiful. Price was good also. Very busy. I'll come back if in the vicinity.

Source: Google

Heidi Winzenried

★ 5

Source: Google

Greg Waniorek

★ 3

Carry out service was a little slow

Source: Google

Aaron Muchenberger

★ 5

Source: Google

Matthew Gladen

★ 1

Not family friendly. Seems like your treated like a king if your a regular, but not a place for infrequent family visits. The carry out food is good.

Source: Google

Michelle Kelley

★ 5

Love this place

Source: Google

Linda Eslinger

★ 5

Source: Google

Samantha Myatt

★ 5

Source: Google

Justin Lehrke

★ 1

Source: Google

Yohnny Seed

★ 5

Always excellent food. The food here is not second to the bar. My expectations are lowered at a bar serving food, which is not necessary here, especially Friday Fish Fry. Enjoy a healthy serving of fish always appears cooked in fresh oil not to greasy, light and flaky....enjoy. The potato pancakes can be served with applesauce or syrup, these are best eaten with light syrup, in my opinion. You can have their home made fries. They are excellent too. Comes with a salad, too. Lots of other good items on the menu seem to have large servings so take a little home.

Source: Google

Steve Rottmann, Jr

★ 4

Source: Google

Matthew Olen

★ 5

Source: Google

Sawyer Ellington

★ 5

Matt’s Guava Hot Lava is fantastic. Absolutely should be an edition to the menu!!!

Source: Google

Tom Fechter

★ 5

Always great food and beer at Tally's!

Source: Google

Deborah Bair

★ 5

Source: Google

Sherry Spellman

★ 5

Source: Google

Patrice Ridgley

★ 3

Yesterday went for lunch and nachos were tasty came back told all my coworkers today got a box full of chips the beef was very little to nonexistent also tasted old so I got cheese and chips for lunch also weird looks from the waitress… I was fooled to think I found a new lunch spot

Source: Google

Maryann Carlson

★ 5

Everything was delicious. I had the Philly cheese steak soup and a burger all very good, beer was cold and service was spot on. Very clean and good vibe

Source: Google

Jennifer B

★ 5

Been here twice both on Saturday evenings and so far and no complaints. Food, service, and atmosphere are all great. Family friendly so you can bring the kiddos. Food is flavorful with great portions. We even forgot out to go items and one of the waitresses ran them outside to us. We will be back again and will definitely recommend. Try the nachos and Wings.

Source: Google

Tracey Hassinger

★ 5

Great place for a drink, food and fun!!!

Source: Google

Kathy D

★ 5

My 1st time here. Very impressed. Food was delicious. People were friendly and attentive. Our waitress was amazing even followed her suggestions and she was spot-on. Everything was Outstanding. Thank you

Source: Google

Lauren Zache

★ 5

We moved to Waukesha a year ago and have tried numerous local places - this one is our go-to! It's a good sports bar to stop by if you have a chance. Staff is friendly and never had to wait a long time for a table or food. I personally don't like when places are super busy so if I see the parking lot full I turn around - I can't speak to ever waiting for a table for that reason.

We are there almost once a week to get drinks, apps, or full meals. I have tried something from every area of the menu.
Their salads are huge and all are very fresh with a lot of toppings/ingredients. Wings are a little pricey but I'm a sucker for their garlic parm! Very good wraps and burgers. Their pizzas are okay, but I'm not a thin crust fan.

Their pretzels of the week or any stuffed pretzel can be bought made and then you cook it at home - we have done this for a few parties and they were a hit!

Source: Google

271TBIRD

★ 4

Nice atmosphere, very friendly staff, and the food was delicious!!

Source: Google

Nick Derse

★ 5

Source: Google

Denise Manz

★ 5

The food & drinks are great. The staff is super friendly & helpful. They have different events throughout the month. The only "complaint" is that they're closed on Tuesdays. I love Tally's!

Source: Google

Nick Noeske

★ 1

Source: Google

Kenneth James

★ 5

Amazing place to eat and grab a drink!

Source: Google

Leon Moore

★ 5

Had the fish fry... It was perfect! And so was the service. Will definitely go back!

Source: Google

Iris Rios

★ 5

Yall tally’s never disappoints. Food, service, staff, everything is great! Our server Graciela was very helpful and friendly, constantly checking up on us and recommending me and my grandma some dishes. Love going here!

Source: Google

Theresa Cotton

★ 5

Excellent food and huge portions. Friendly service and great prices and food choices. Couldn't finish my burger it was so huge.

Source: Google

karen derome

★ 5

Great burger G.O.A.T.
Server was good. We enjoyed our meal

Source: Google

Michelle Lischka

★ 5

Food is always great. Service was awesome. Patrons were even super friendly. I miss these type of bars where I live. Love coming home to Waukesha and it still has great places to go.

Source: Google

Cassandra Anderson

★ 5

Seriously, THE BEST establishment in the area. Apart from the food and drinks being phenomenal, the owner is a gem. Does so much for the community! I have been here countless times and I've never had a bad experience...food and service alike.
I hate when prices enrage reviewers to leave a bad post, don't want to pay for drinks or food, stay at home and make it yourself. If you feel the economy in your pocket, just imagine how it feels to try to keep a family business running.

Source: Google

Tanya Silvernail

★ 5

Source: Google

brad matusiak

★ 5

Great food and service

Source: Google

Nicole Nick

★ 1

Overpriced mediocre at best bar food. Fish fry was promising but came ice cold to the table. All of our food was ice cold. My drink was even bad. Our server was terrible and clearly hates her job. Better places out there will not be back.

Source: Google

Travis Urban

★ 5

Source: Google

Sammie Gonzalez

★ 1

We have alway got take out for wings which are always great, So we thought we would try the fish fry. We were sat at a table on Friday night after the Busy fish fry. The table we sat at was shoulder to shoulder with the table next to us which was way too close and personable!! Super uncomfortable!! We could hear word to word conversation of the people next to us. Felt like we were sharing a tables with them. We sat ackward with no drink order taken, 15 mins went by and for our server to come over. We kindly asked another server if we could move since we had no server. Our Server finally did come over and noticed we moved, which i think mad her upset. Drink and food order was taken finally. We did order drinks from bar and asked for water took another 15 mins to get drinks. We ordered the perch fish fry which was amazing but food was cold when it arrived, which made our server even more mad, when we Kindly asked sever to make fresh , she rolled her eyes and said sure. No apology at all. Our Food came out 2nd time perfect, Server dropped our food, never came back. Nowhere to be found, Never to ask how everything was, no offer of drinks refilled, nothing!! Sad that a place with great food has awful service!!!!

Source: Google

D Peterson

★ 4

We were there on Fri. 3/22/2024 about 3:30pm. Ordered a burger and the shrimp. The food was excellent. My comment is, why is the music sooo loud. You need to yell to your table mates to be heard. There was a rather large group next to us that had a baby with them - maybe 2 months old. It's great they wanted to introduce the baby to all their friends. Felt sorry for the baby to be in that loud environment.

Source: Google

Marrianne H

★ 5

Great place. Awesome food. Very crowded on weekends so go early if you cant wait to eat or just order carry out. (We do that often) GREAT to go with friends & hang @ the bar... its jumpin on the weekends!

Source: Google

Michael Boroczk

★ 4

Super cool sports bar with good food and great beer selection. Lots of televisions for the sports enthusiasts

Source: Google

Michael Straka

★ 5

Source: Google

Rosie Baker

★ 5

Tally's is always a good choice for our family!

Source: Google