★ 5

I was disappointed tonight, went with friends for fish. We waited by the hostess station for 15 minutes and no one greeted us. The dining room was half full. Another couple said the hostess was preparing a table for them. The owner walked past us and didn't say anything. We asked the bartender and a waitress and they said someone will be with us. We waited a while longer and left. It will take some time before we decide to visit again.

Source: Google

★ 5

Had a wonderful meal with great service, the attention to details really makes The Broken Spur a great dining experience.

Source: Google

★ 1

Just wanted a bar burger. At bar not a full sit down meal

Source: Google

★ 1

What do you mean you can't have dinner at the bar anymore? That is absolutely lousy customer service. We should be able to choose where we would like to have dinner, not sure why you think you can.

Source: Google

★ 1

Did not have more than an hour to find out how the food was. Service just to greet us (4) took awhile. Placed a drink order and did not get back to the table for sometime. Then only received two of the four drinks and needed the waitress have to get ice-cream to help make the two drinks and only one needed ice-cream.
In the mean time another table had been seated ordered drinks,meals and received service of drinks and meals before we had been asked what we wanted to order for food.

Source: Google

★ 3

Food was very good. From soup and salad bar to fettuccine alfredo with chicken and a filet mignon.
Only complaint there was steak was pretty rare for ordering medium well. Not the end of the world though. It was fine.
The service from our waitress was excellent! Jennifer did an outstanding job!
My only complaint is with the establishment staffing I guess. They should definitely have a busboy or gal. All the waitresses were hopping and doing a great job. The problem is all the time they have to spend clearing tables while taking orders and serving people. Most places have someone to bus tables. It makes things go so much smoother in a restaurant.

Source: Google

★ 4

Service was good for a Friday night. The all you can eat salad bar was included with dinner. I had the fish fry and it did not disappoint.

Source: Google

★ 5

Great food and service!

Source: Google

★ 2

My husband and I decided to try the fish fry one night, we had never been there before. The fish was excellent, cooked perfectly. I had the cod battered and my husband had the seafood sampler. His was disappointing. The pieces of fish were so small, the fries looked like potato peels that were scraped off the floor. He tried the clam chowder and it had way too much dill. I also had a baked potato that wasn’t quite done. I am a coleslaw and tartar sauce connoisseur and both were horrible. Slaw was fluorescent green and tasted terrible and tartar sauce would choke you with dill. I think your chef needs help.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 3

The bar tender was amazing more observant then our waitress Jennifer.. I swear she got lost bringing me an ice tea so I asked the bar tender for one and she was happy to help and five min late Jennifer comes out with it and was like I almost forgot.. who forgets a patrons beverage.. it wasn’t busy and we saw the other server and bar tender more then our server honestly won’t be back just cause of that .. food was okay nothing to phenomenal honestly think their steak prices are way to high for this area but the dining room was amazing. But our waitress Jennifer was awol half the time and was never seen she was friendly but not very good at her Job..

Source: Google

★ 1

It's bad. Don't go here - trust me.

Source: Google

★ 5

Ribs were excellent, rest of table enjoyed their meal. Prices were reasonable.
Fireplace was too hot for people close

Source: Google

★ 5

This is a wonderful little restaurant with a great atmosphere and great service.

Source: Google

★ 1

The night held so much promise, only to be left with disappointment. We came to the Broken Spur as part of a rehearsal dinner. We unfortunately started the night by being shoved into a small room with not enough seats for our reservation. It continued with an agonizing wait to place our order and drinks. Even after waiting patiently, many of our drinks never even showed up. An hour and a half after placing our order our food finally showed up, cold and showing signs of sitting too long under a heat lamp. The salad bar remained bare and unstocked. I would advise avoiding at all costs, regardless of what apology might be offered.

Source: Google

★ 1

Food was not good, bread was doughy, small portions of food and the Alfredo was more like soup than pasta. The steak for the Alfredo was good. Place was nice and service was awesome. Food wasn't good at all and was heavily overpriced for the amount and quality received. The Shirley Temple also sucked

Source: Google

★ 1

If I could have gave a zero i would've. Had a reservation even and waited 2 hours almost to get my food. Then the food was cold and nasty service was horrible. I will never be back ever again

Source: Google

★ 5

The friday fish was very good and the steak was superb..

Source: Google

★ 2

Staff was great... food was not as expected. Had prime rib and there was no flavor. Husband had Ribeye and it was over salted. Not worth it.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 3

Our server was awful. My husband and I were seated at the same time as a table for 6. For some reason we were seated at a very small table when there were normal sized tables available.
Next- No one came to take our beverage for over a half hour. Meanwhile the table of 6 people has beverages, appetizers, and access to the salad bar.
At the 38 minute mark of sitting down our server comes and takes our beverage and dinner order. 25 minutes later my drink finally appears. At an hour and 20 minutes our food is finally served. I got a loaded baked potato and it wasn't all the way done and barely had any cheese, bacon and chives. The filet was done perfect.
Honestly I was so disappointed and this was my birthday dinner.

I just want to point out; the table of 6 is gone, long gone table bussed about 10 minutes before we got our food. The whole thing was ridiculous. Seriously you spend $100 on dinner and we were treated awful.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 1

My husband and I ate at this restaurant back in the summer and the food was amazing.
Unfortunately this time it was a different experience. I had the shrimp with ravioli. Some of the shrimp were undercooked and had a fishy taste and some were overcooked and dry. The ravioli stuffed with mushroom was good. My husband had lobster mac. His dish was very bland and soupy.
For the amount we paid we expected a far better dinner. We will not be going to this restaurant again.

Source: Google

★ 2

French onion and Tomato Soup all the time.What happened to the potato soup

Source: Google

★ 3

Disappointed in the quality of the food. It was one of my favorite supper clubs.

Source: Google

★ 5

Everything on the menu has been fantastic. Staff here really takes pride in everything. Great food and service.

Source: Google

★ 5

Prime rib is the best

Source: Google

★ 1

I do not normally write reviews like this, but feel I am obligated since our experience was absolutely TERRIBLE!! Last night was our first and LAST time we will be visiting The Broken Spur. We had a party of 4 and were seated at a table half the size of the booths, where they were only seating parties of 2. Once seated at our table we were handed menus and never asked if we wanted anything to drink. We had to ask our server if we could even order beverages. She did take our drink order and proceeded to take our dinner orders. My husband and I were given the option of soup or salad bar with our entrees, but the other 2 in our party were not. My husband and I were pretty much finished with our salads when the bartender finally arrived with our beverages. Our server was standing near our table when the beverages arrived so I asked if the other 2 individuals should have been given the option of soup or salad bar as well. She did not even respond, however the bartender did by saying YES. My husband and I both ordered the scallops with risotto, one individual ordered the herb encrusted walleye and the other ordered the seafood trilogy. Each entree was awful. The "herb encrusted" walleye was caked in oil soaked panko, the "creamy white wine butter sauce" seafood trilogy was so fishy the gnocchi was inedible, and the scallops with the “crackling’” sauce were nothing more than 4 scallops with a bunch of pork belly doused in a sweet BBQ sauce. When the "chef" came around to our table I mentioned to him I did not know this entree came with pork belly as I do not eat that. He simply responded stating the menu should be updated with a better description. That was it. Since I received that sort of response nobody else was even willing to waste their breath explaining why their entrees were unfit. My husband who normally does like pork belly stated it was so salty he couldn't even eat it. We were there for at least an hour and a half to 2 hours and were never asked if we wanted anything else to drink and after our entrees arrived to the table we had to ask our waitress if she could clear our dirty salad and appetizer dishes away just so we had room on our table. It's very unfortunate as we spent over $200 to celebrate 2 birthdays and it was a complete disappointment.

Source: Google

★ 5

Excellent Perch!! Atmosphere is great! Staff do a nice job serving! Could use some work on their coleslaw!

Source: Google

★ 1

When we arrived, someone was complaining to the hostess about the food. When he walked away, I asked her what the problem was, and she said that he said his food was undercooked, but he had no reason to complain that it was as just fine. Thought that was kinda strange to roll your eyes and basically say a customer was lying…

Anywho,… Ordered the baked fish, that came with coleslaw. The fish had absolutely no flavor to it.. I asked for melted butter… Which was definitely not melted butter… It was vegetable oil. My friend had the baked fish also and said that she had the same opinion… Absolutely no taste to it, and she also had the baked potato Which she said was cold. The salad bar was an up charge of four dollars… Which had lettuce, dressing, a plain tasting Generic cottage cheese, mushrooms… And that’s about it.

The waitress must be used to people complaining, because she Didn’t seem too surprised by it. Must’ve been the manager that came over then after her, this lady almost seemed offended that we did not like the baked fish. Asked if we wanted to talk to the cook.… ummmm I guess? But then when she went to get him, he had already left for the night…at 8:15pm and they’re open till 9…?

The whole thing was strange. The people at the table next to us said that the food used to be really really good and then something changed and now it’s rather disappointing. This was my first time going, but based on our experience, we would definitely not go back.

Source: Google

★ 2

We used to come to The Broken Spur ALL the time. It was THE BEST place! We went in tonight for my Fiancé birthday dinner, besides the bartender everything else after that was not so good. My food was cold, my steak was supposed to be medium well it was red, sweet potatoes were cold, lobster was cold, our waitress never came to our table with our drinks we had to get them ourselves. It wasn't good! We loved going there 2022, 2023 now is not worth the money so sad.

Source: Google

★ 4

Food was really good and came out very fast. Menu is limited but that is to be expected at a smaller hotel restaurant. Staff was super friendly and helpful. Would go there again or use it for a work event space for sure.

Source: Google

★ 5

I was amazed at the best tasting food I ever had there. This Chef is amazing I had prime rib,sweet potato mash and wonderful vegetables and don’t forget the homemade hazelnut cheesecake
The staff is great as well

Source: Google

★ 1

Slow service fried cod and perch were very salty, crab cakes were over cooked , soup was suppose to be clam chowder...it was spicy and possibly oregano and basil...tasted nothing like clam chowder...saw waitress taking away soup cause gentleman said it was too spicy and a plate of breaded jumbo shrimp was also taken back , kitchen was very loud, waited for our check , waited for second drink, came in at 5 pm ish and didn't get done until 7:00 pm ish....not very crowded at all this was Sept 6 th Friday...we will not be back or recommend..
Chef came out to speak to gentlman with the soup and stated I'm not sure what happened but I don't eat clam chowder so I will have to talk to sous chef.....a chef should know what everything taste like that's on the menu ...Was very disappointed

Source: Google

★ 3

First time eating at this place and was a little disappointed.
First off the service was slow, lots of running around but no one visited our table for 10 minutes. When we eventually ordered my drink took into the starter to get there. After we got the food, some of the food did not come like coleslaw and rye bread. Only to be told they don't do it anymore or not ready even though it lists it on the menu.
The fish was tasty and seasoned well. Sometimes too well as there was a whole garlic clove in the mashed potatoe.
We will not be doing here again, next time culvers for taste and better service. Where the menu does not lie.

Source: Google

★ 1

Food was okay but the service is the worse. We waited for over40 minutes to get a waitress, the hostess was nice and tried to get us taken care of after she noticed we were seated for over 20 minutes with no water, menu or waitress. When they did take our order the waitress said they were out of all seafood so we ordered a chicken sandwich and a steak. This took at least 45 minutes. We even had to ask for a check and had to wait for that. The chef can by after another waitress called him because we complained and said we were leaving a bad review. We were there for over two hours for and average meal. Will not go back and we live in the area.

Source: Google

★ 2

We have been coming here for a couple of years for fish fry. It used to be so good when Chef Tony was cooking. It was just right. Last night, it was overcooked and by the time we pulled all the excess batter off, there was very little fish. There is a new chef there now.

Source: Google

★ 1

Source: Google

★ 2

For the price. You should have some kind of flavor. Potatoes tasted like box Potatoes, grilled vegetables were cold in the middle and hard. Prime rib no flavor at all.

Source: Google

★ 2

Me and my wife came in July 27th 2024.
We normally order.
The shaved prime rib sandwich and
the Walleye dinner
Which we did again to our horror and let me explain.The shave beef sandwich was half the size or even smaller than that. Compared to when chef tony made it. My wife's bottom bun was so soggy that she couldn't eat it or pick it up.
And she found only 3 mushrooms on the whole thing and sadly enough she couldn't even find the cheese and I'm telling you the last ones, that we ordered, (many times)we always took a picture of our plates because we couldn't believe how big it was. And used to make a joke that they used a 1/2 a loaf of French bread to make it and the cheese was like on a pizza. Okay, the walleye we live in Wisconsin. Walleye is the best fish around second to perch. Normally, it was PAN fried, flaky, big and beautiful and I gotta tell you when we asked the waitress, which was a fabulous lady, what he did to the walleye, she said rolling her eyes that he grilled it and whatever seasoning and slime, which my. Wife called it, that he had on the walleye was terrible tasting. It was the worst fish I have ever tasted in my life. And I'm 64 years old. My brother is on the walleye national fishing competition circuit. So I eat a lot of Walleye fish, and it was terrible to the point that I asked for a to go box, and I left it on the table. I should have sent it back and ordered something new. The potato came out fine. The vegetables would've been fine, but they were cold. And the sampler used to have herring on it. We don't eat it that much, but I'm telling you. It was the best herring I've ever tasted.
We bragged about the quality and quantity of the meals. To our family to our friends to our church body and to Facebook. I will be calling the manager on Tuesday.
Or maybe Mr. Bruner, because I was cheated and it was the disgusting meal which we used to love coming there. If it continues. I would never go back there again. And?
We are locals from New lisbon. Jacob Ballering

Source: Google

★ 5

Always a great dining experience, healthy portions, usually split meals and apps...

Source: Google

★ 3

We have enjoyed the Friday fish fry a number of times but were disappointed the last time. The size of the baked cod was smaller and not as flavorful as previously. We also looked forward to the complimentary condiments of cheese curds, dip, crackers, and herring. Those little touches were what brought us back. Please bring this back.

Source: Google

★ 4

We have been regulars for the Friday fish fry along with many friends and neighbors. What happened to the cheese curds, herring, cheese spread and crackers they would bring to the table? Also, we would all get the perch dinner that include 6 nice pieces of perch. Don't know if we'll be back, because it was something we looked forward to. Especially the perch dinner.
Menu changes are OK, but sometimes you need to stick with what's been working.

Source: Google

★ 4

Amazing service and food. The only downside was dim lighting, i could hardly see where I was cutting my steak. Otherwise, I'd say 5 stars.

Source: Google

★ 1

We got in on Saturday at 20:30 and they told U.S the kitchen was closed for the night. On the google it showed the restaurant is open until 21:00 on Saturday.

Source: Google

★ 5

The food was delicious! Pleasantly surprised and we will come back again for the Prime Rib French dip. Yummy!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Had the prime rib. It was great. A half order of onion rings still takes up a full plate for $5.00

Source: Google

★ 5

The Broken Spur at the Lodge is probably the nicest place to eat in Mauston. It's a little expensive, but you get very good food served in generous portions. I recommend the steaks and the fish fry specials. The little plate of cheese curds, pickled herring, and crackers at the beginning of the meal is also appreciated.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 3

Went for a fish fry on 2/23 . My friend got the cod and I got the bkacken Mahi Mahi. First of all Wisconsin fish fries cones with coleslaw and rye bread not a terrible salad. Guess cod was ok. The Mahi was more than likely from frozen not light and fluffy texture as they should be.

Source: Google

★ 5

Frequently go here. Love Friday night fish fry perch is amazing!!! Only reason I couldn't provide five stars for this review is amazingly and very much so a non-typical experience I had to take my bill to the front desk to pay for it as I had already waited 10 minutes for my server to come after finishing our meal. We were in a hurry to get somewhere.

Source: Google

★ 5

Excellent food and friendly staff!!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Great Friday fish fry
A lot of appetizers so come hungry

Source: Google

★ 5

Very nice food

Source: Google

★ 5

Awesome food and our server Danielle was the very best

Source: Google

★ 4

Was 4 in my group dinner took 1 1/2 hrs to be served will go back though my steak was incredible

Source: Google

★ 5

I honestly say this, the food is very good, delicious at this point. Our service was absolutely perfect, the waiter was very kind, funny, respectful, she listened very well, I think it was Danielle, the best waiter I’ve had in a couple years. We had 4 burgers as a family, and soup, food was awesome. Place was clean, modern and very comfortable. I would DEFINITELY COME HERE!!!! 👍👍

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Awesome place. Great food and staff. On the pricey side but you get what you pay for. Make sure to try the cowgirl martini

Source: Google

★ 4

The prime rib was ok

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 4

Great place overall. Waitress was what you expect but not exceptional. Great layer back steak place. Prices a bit high but not unusually high. Was nice to see many wolines by the bottle at a reasonable price.

Source: Google

★ 5

Incredible experience and food. Table starters were garlic herb cheese, cheese curds, crackers and sardines. Also had pumpernickel bread. I got the burger which felt like half pound, the fries were excellent. Might have been the best French onion soup I've ever had, flavorful. The steaks aren't necessarily cheap but it was the best $14 burger I've ever had, and would have been happy paying $20.

The gentleman serving us had a great mood and was very friendly.

Source: Google

★ 5

Really amazed with this place. The atmosphere was incredible, low lit small dining room. The waiters were very polite and on top of their game.

Source: Google

★ 5

Prime rib was very good and everything was great 👍

Source: Google

★ 5

Hubby and I shared an anniversary dinner here this week. Found the restaurant in a "Dells Dining Guide" that is available at locations all over the Dells. So glad we stopped in. Bartender, hostess and server were all very friendly. Our Oscar Ribeyes were perfect! The signature drinks we chose were tasty! The decor inside was perfect! We checked out the hotel lobby (that the restaurant is attached to) after dinner and thought it reminded us of a hotel in the Yellowstone National Park, very cool!

Source: Google

★ 5

Wonderful food. Large portions and waitstaff were enthusiastic and knowledgeable. Will go back again.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Servings were very generous! Walleyes were very good as well as the cod. French dip was huge!

Source: Google

★ 3

There aren't a lot of decent sit-down restaurants in the area. This is one of the better ones, but that's not saying much. The place seemed a bit understaffed, and it took about 30 minutes for our group to get drinks. We had a larger table, so understandably, not all the food is going to come out at the same time, but some of the meals were sitting under the heat lamps a bit too long because a couple of us got burned by touching the plates. The food was ok, but it felt a bit overpriced for what you got. I ordered the boasted chicken (super dry) and ribs (those were alright).

Staff was very nice, but it wasn't the best experience.

Source: Google

★ 5

Great restaurant. Quality food and I love the design of the place.

Source: Google

★ 1

I ordered the filet mignon medium. My filet had almost no pink to it, severely over cooked, didn't get the correct side I ordered and never saw my waitress after food delivery until well after the meal was done. I would definitely not recommend for the high price and poor service!
My girlfriend didn't receive her vegetables with here dinner. At least 6 others of our 14 person group also had issues with the meals.

Source: Google

★ 5

The baby back ribs were so tender. It was like it melted in my mouth. The best rib's ever.

Source: Google

★ 5

I really enjoyed this Ribeye that is in the photo, probably one of my favorite Ribeyes I have ever had.

Source: Google

★ 5

Danielle was very informative & welcoming! Our food was perfect & we were very pleased we stumbled across this place while looking for somewhere to eat.

Source: Google

★ 5

Enjoyed "Happy Hour" with appetizers and drinks. Wife and I enjoyed it. Also tried a Yellowstone Bourbon on the rocks, tasty.
7-19-23, stopped by and had the Prime Rib Dip. It was great and more than I could eat. Wife had the Italian Chicken Sandwich and enjoyed it also.

Source: Google

★ 5

Great food and service. Very clean and family friendly. One of the best restaurants in Mauston.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 1

Food way over priced! Host was friendly server seemed grumpy. Atmosphere was EXTREMELY DARK!!! HARD TO SEE INSIDE.

Source: Google

★ 3

Wouldn't recommend getting the French onion soup to go, I was also surprised there was only like three onions in it and basically beef broth but the shrimp cocktail was good. Next time we'll order something different and go inside if we ever stop through again.

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 5

Drinks are cheaper than most in the area. Before the meal they brought out crackers, pickled herring, dip and cheese curds. I love all their included appetizers. We got bruschetta, which was about 6 small pieces of bread but was good for $10. I ordered walleye and it was wonderful with crispy breading and it barely even fit on my plate. Asparagus was well cooked. I’ve come here a few times and I’ve never had anything bad to say about it. Will be coming back again.

Source: Google

★ 5

We discovered this place tonight and we’ll definitely be returning! I think it’s probably the best food in the area! Also huge portions!

Source: Google

★ 5

Prim rib was awesome brought me back too my old chef days

Source: Google

★ 5

Dinner was fantastic. Rib eye was perfection. The scallop appetizer was divine.

Source: Google

★ 5

We are so glad this place is in Mauston. It's by far our favorite place to eat we think it's on par and better than Ishnala in some areas. The steak and Prime rib is amazing. Their fries are fabulous. We honestly haven't had a bad thing here. We always love the soups. Their bruschetta is amazing as is their cheese curds.
Our favorite waitress is Danielle she always makes our day. Try it you won't be disappointed best place to eat for miles around. Anyone rating this place below a 4.5 probably eats at McDonald's and has zero ability to discern what good food taste like.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Food in this restaurant is fabulous. Cooked and seasoned to perfection. The hostess made a great effort to get us a table as we didn't have a reservation. The bartender was excellent as we enjoyed a cocktail while we waited. Our server on the other hand not so good. She must have wanted to be somewhere else because she didn't seem care about our table. After delivering our meals never returned to check on anything. Had go to bar area and as bartender for 2 cocktails which she made and delivered to our table. When she did return with the check I asked what happened to shrimp cocktail I ordered she said she must have forgotten about it but would go get it. Hopefully if you go to dine there you get a different server because the food and atmosphere is fabulous.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 3

Source: Google

★ 5

My first experience here was with a group of 6 close friends and family. We went out on a very cold February Friday night, we were seated by the large fireplace and it was a perfect setting and warmed us up with delight. I mention the seating because the table was a perfect 6 seater. Not two wobbly tables pushed together and I appreciated that. In Wisconsin Friday night fish is almost a religion and their selection was surprising. As we sipped our real muddled Korbel Brandy Old Fashions mixed by Jill who is a delightful Mauston mixologist legend and sweetheart behind the bar. We reviewed the hard cover quality menus and prepared to order, just from the feel of the menu and the glance of the Scallop and Pork Belly apps I saw a couple enjoying at the bar on the way to our seat, I new we were in for a good time. Three ladies in our group had the beer battered Walleye filet special and it was a master piece! A huge and thick filet perfectly crispy breading sided with a sweet corn mix and potato and the unbelievably tasty crab corn chowder. Two in our group are a couple who shared a Ribeye and a large special salad. The steak was perfectly prepared and the presentation was on point! I had the Poor Man's Lobster special, a large piece of baked Cod with drawn butter and lemon prepared in a fashion I can only describe as YES PLEASE! We were all so pleased AND childishly giddy with the meal. I sound silly I know but it is such a happy moment to know I have a great restaurant in my town and don't have to travel to the Dells. If you can't tell I recommend a visit. I treated the group and paid the bill and have to say, I have spent more on just my wife and I at steakhouses in the Dells and not been this pleased. Our waitress Keri was an absolute pleasure and is a true professional. Definitely making this my go to spot in Mauston WI!

Source: Google

★ 4

Excellent service

Source: Google

★ 5

I tried the Prime Rib, and I must say it was fantastic. Cooked to absolute perfection and seasoned the same. I was so impressed, the next two trips there were to pickup to-go orders. Absolutely perfect, both times!! Definitely a must try restaurant !!!

Source: Google

★ 5

Highly recommend !!!

Source: Google

★ 5

Great food, not bad prices. Weekly specials are where it's at. The parm wings for $11 are awesome. Chef Anthony won't disappoint you.

Source: Google

★ 5

We celebrated our birthdays at The Broken Spur Steak and Seafood restaurant nestled inside The Lodge at Mauston for our second consecutive year and I think we might just need to make it a tradition come every December. Even though we arrived closer to the end of the night. we were still given a very hospitable experience. The restaurant has a relaxed, intimate vibe. The host, our waitress, and chef were all very personable, making rounds, and accommodations. A refreshing starter of cheese, crackers, & fish were complimentary provided; and although very delightful, we came ready to annihilate and ordered the Onion Rings as well. They were lightly fried, yet had a very nice crisp to them. Our entrees came with soup or salad and also dinner rolls. Off the menu, we selected the New York Strip, baked potato and side salad. And off the specials, we chose a cup of Clam Chowder to accompany the Pan-Seared Walleye with potatoes and asparagus. Everything was so savory and flavorful that we had to contain ourselves in order to have room for the decadent Chocolate Cake we ended with.

I cannot wait for our return.

Thank you for memorable night!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

We love it..., the food, the atmosphere, the people, the service, always a+

Source: Google

★ 1

As local people we try to patronize local establishments. Tonight was very disappointing and this makes two times in a row of a bad experience. Tonight we arrived and put our names in to be seated, went to the bar to wait. We were told 25-30 minutes. Then we noticed folks who came in after us seated. When we checked we were told that it would be another 20 minutes, making our wait for a table more than an hour,
while others were seated before us. I think an hour, in our area is quite a long wait. We did not stay and left to go elsewhere. Last time we were seated fairly quickly, but waited more than an hour for our food. Both on Saturday nights. Not sure if that’s the issue or something else, but clearly something needs adjusting. We also realize that finding help is tough right now.

Source: Google

★ 5

Great food and atmosphere!

Source: Google

★ 4

Food is really good and reasonable. They where very busy and having some computer issues. The bartender handled it very well. Will be back.

Source: Google

★ 2

We came here because this place made it in the "Best" of paper. However, this place was hardly that. The service was slow (I had to get up twice to get attention. One to order drinks and the other when we were ready to pay our bill). The crackers and variety of dips that come with the meal was not great. Ritz crackers and some disgusting smoked trout or something? The dinner rolls looked like something that came in a dinner roll bag from Walmart. We ordered the bruschetta (it was mediocre). Our dinner salads were good, but again nothing special. We ordered them with ranch dressing because that is the only one made in house. The other dressings are premade. We ordered a bloody mary and a cocktail off of the drink menu (that we also had to ask for). The cocktail was decent and the bloody mary wasn't. I ordered salmon for dinner and my husband ordered ribs. I could have cooked the salmon better myself at home. Hardly any flavor or seasoning. The carrots looked they were frozen baby carrots? My husband said that he didn't even want to finish the ribs. He ordered it with fingerlings and carrots. We left all the carrots on our plates. One taste of them was enough. Honestly, if this place were cheap I wouldn't have minded a wildly mediocre meal. However, if I am paying $100+ for dinner then I expect quality. We won't be back. Save your money and go to a place where the food quality matches the sticker price.

Source: Google

★ 3

I only gave 3 stars because the waiter was great! Some of the food was over and undercooked. The food had no seasoning at all! Wasted so much money!

Source: Google

★ 5

Went while visiting friends this place has a real quaint charm about it, started with all the good stuff on the table cheese spread was great put mine on my roll which elevated its flavor, got the bacon cheddar asparagus soup which I could have sat and had all night, if I hadn’t ordered the hands down best walleye I have ever eaten, our waitress Alexis was kind and courteous and quick to refill our drinks, excellent staff they really made you feel like they wanted you there. Thank you for a great experience, I really want to try the hotel now too.

Source: Google

★ 5

Great food and service. Really nice restaurant and bar.

Source: Google

★ 5

I travel in my work and I schedule my work in order to eat here and stay at the hotel that is attached to the restaurant. Great steak and seafood and deep fried cheese curds. Great staff as well. Do yourself a favor and take a trip and eat and stay here.

Source: Google

★ 5

The food was delicious. Our server was very friendly and attentive. We'll be back.

Source: Google

★ 5

Delicious!!!

Source: Google

★ 1

Source: Google

★ 1

2nd time got there at 7:45, 10 minutes later was told kitchen is closed. Done with this.

Source: Google

★ 1

4 of us for dinner. Prime rib was tough, crab legs over cooked and chewy. Walleye was good. Filet was small for price. Crab legs were the spe ial, I made the mistake thinking it would be a lower price. Wrong! $85. If o knew ahead of time I would not have ordered them. Place is small and dark
Our waitress was outstanding.

Source: Google

★ 5

The atmosphere, service and most importantly the food & drinks were excellent. Will be returning and would highly recommend to anyone.

Source: Google

★ 4

Waitress was excellent!!

Source: Google

★ 3

Decent steak, etc. Very expensive.

Source: Google

★ 5

Had an amazing time and pretty good dinner last night. This is definitely a place to go for location rather than actual food quality. The staff was AMAZING! Jill, Alexis and Carry (sorry if I misspelled any names) were all made sure we had the greatest time.

The onion soup was my absolute favorite part of the meal.

Source: Google

★ 5

Absolutely amazing steaks and lobster. Drinks were well poured. Fast and friendly service with a smile. Great teamwork amongst the staff. Tony even came to the table and spoke with my husband. We've now found our special date night place. We've been searching for one since moved here in late September of 21.
Will definitely return.

Source: Google

★ 5

Such a nice atmosphere with great service, and delicious food! (we've had the cod and bluegill)

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

The food was awesome and our server, Danielle was so great and thoughtful. My husband had the prime rib and jalapeño cheddar & cauliflower soup. All were excellent! I had the burger and chicken dumpling soup which were great as well. To add to it, this place was beautiful, clean and the service was great and quick!

Source: Google

★ 5

Clean, excellent service, Staff both friendly and prompt.
Great experience. Steak were unbelievabl.

Source: Google

★ 5

We have been the there a number of times. The food has always been very good. Likewise the service has been good. Great atmosphere.

Source: Google

★ 5

Excellent service and food, very clean.

Source: Google

★ 5

Every aspect of our meals was excellent and prepared to our specifications. The service was second to none and very pleasant.

Source: Google

★ 5

Good food with great service! What more could you ask for. I'll definitely eat here again anytime I'm in the area

Source: Google

★ 3

Disappointed with my steak. More grissle on my plate than what was edible. Not fat, grissle. Embarrassing to keep spitting it out on my spoon and putting it on my plate. Great flavor though. The rest of the meal was wonderful but I paid $$$ for the steak not the sides.

Source: Google

★ 5

Great food

Source: Google

★ 4

We are almost always lucky enough to get Tiffany as our waitress. She is so great and one of the reasons we keep going back. Would be 5 stars but the prices on some of the foods just aren't worth it but for the most part our family loves going to The Broken Spur on an almost weekly basis!

Source: Google

★ 4

Good food and service.

Source: Google

★ 5

One of the best meals in the area. The chef some fantastic unique meals. Scallops on pork belly appetizer is to die for. Have been there 6 times and never have been disappointed.

Source: Google

★ 5

Having a summer cottage in Mauston has been challenging as the area is a little short on cool bars and great restaurants... Our luck changed last weekend when we tried The Broken Spur not only on Friday evening but for a return visit on Saturday. The first night we arrived at 4:45 PM and were told there was an hour wait... Really at 4:45 PM?? We went to the bar and ordered cocktails from bartender Jill... Great drinks and when we shared our concern over the hour wait, Jill disappeared and returned with the hostess who seated us immediately... Yeah Jill!! The wait staff (Kiki) was very accommodating and had a great sense of humor. She delivered a small tray of local cheese /crackers and a few other goodies which along with our cocktails kept us busy until the dinners arrived (it was a bit of a wait but worth it). Over the two visits in two days, we had the chicken and ribs, the salmon and the prime rib and loved it all along with some great crab bisque soup and fresh salads. I hesitate to recommend the Broken Spur because we will never get a table once the word gets out.

Source: Google

★ 5

Very beautiful setting. Great scampi, au gratin potatoes, lobster.....and of course cheesecake!

Source: Google

★ 5

The food was amazing!!!

Source: Google

★ 5

Every time I go there they always have some amazing meals and reasonably priced

Source: Google

★ 5

Excellent food! Worth every penny! Very generous portions too!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

I do not give reviews very often, but today I believe The Broken Spur gave me a reason to. I thought the entire experience here was quite enjoyable and relaxing. However it did take a while to get seated. But that was because they seem short staffed tonight. It was quite impressive to see the waitress making rounds at all the other tables whilst keeping us well taken care of. The steaks were cooked to perfection! Exactly how I like it and very tender! Definately will be coming here again! Loved it 😁 Great job chefs, and our waitress Ashley was incredible! Thank you all so much!

Source: Google

★ 5

Best wings hands down! They have a special on Tuesdays for them, 50 cents. Try all the flavors but especially the blueberry bbq, can't stop eating them.

Source: Google

★ 5

Amazing food, hands down. There steaks were perfect and the twice baked potatoes were the best I’ve ever had. There was literally nothing to complain about. The environment is relaxed and has a country ranch feel to it. Will definitely be back soon.

Source: Google

★ 5

Excellent food, great atmosphere.

Source: Google

★ 5

Awesome food, great customer service prices are a little bit pricey but very awesome food oh, I will be going there again

Source: Google

★ 4

Very comfortable dining room with privacy booths. Excellent, friendly service. The food was very flavorful, nice-sized portions, and nice plating presentation and all very reasonably priced. All-around enjoyable experience; highly recommend!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

We had the Best Meal Ever right down to the excellent bartender to the excellent waitress all I can say is WOW and we will be back there to eat again Thank You so much

Source: Google

★ 1

Bad food. Worse service. Not worth it....shame

Source: Google

★ 1

Source: Google

★ 1

We showed up to have Dinner but the dining room was full, they were definitely over the 25% capacity. Decided to wait and have a drink while we waited, the Bartender was rude and inattentive, older lady. There were dirty glasses everywhere! I mean A LOT. We felt bad seeing the waitresses running back and forth trying to keep up with just a couple of them on duty... on a Saturday night. We ended up not eating there. Thought this place would have been better....

Source: Google

★ 5

The food was amazing. I had the baked french onion soup and the smoked ribs and my husband had the salad and the 14oz. ribeye steak. The soup on it's own is a meal and I would drive the 2.5 hour trip again just to eat that soup. The death by chocolate cake dessert is delicious. Our server, Kari, was friendly, had a good sense of humor, and made the meal worth every penny.

Source: Google

★ 4

Good fish fry great old fashions. Service was not an issue as others mentioned Tiffany was my waitress and had no issues. Will be back to try the steaks.

Source: Google

★ 1

Service was slow. They forgot the steak for the order and once it did come it was overdone and not 32oz. Waitress did not check in on us. Waited 20 minutes for the bill after finally asking for it. Would be a better experience with a different waitress who provides customer service.

Source: Google

★ 1

Service was extremely slow. We were treated as if we were peasants. They complete forgot about the "32oz" steak. When it finally came to the table it was over cooked and tasted like biting into a block of blue cheese. After we were done eating our waitress walked by our table over 20 times without any acknowledgement.

Source: Google

★ 3

Source: Google

★ 5

Loved the food and service

Source: Google

★ 4

We decided to give this place another shot and boy are we glad we did. Much more prompt service! The freaking bruschetta is THE best I've ever had! Definitely coming back for that! The prime was okay, a bit overseasoned but good. Salads were great, the dinner rolls are soooo good! Love the cheese n crackers too!! We were only able to eat half our meal, so we enjoyed prime n eggs for breakfast

Source: Google