★ 3

Decent meal. We went on a Friday night and were able to get a table fairly quickly. Prices are good. Most of us got the fish fry, which was a bit heavy on the breading for my liking. Our waitress was friendly. The atmosphere is similar to other Wisconsin supper clubs.

Source: Google

★ 4

Our seating was opposite of the bar near the entryway and the partition wall greatly isolated the bar racket. We ordered the NY strip and the slow roasted prime rib. Fries, scalloped potatoes, and chili were sides. The fries had been sitting long enough to be only warm, but I could tell when they were fresh they would have had a good subtle crisp. The scalloped potatoes and chili were great. The NY was seasoned well and was perfectly cooked to medium. The 24-hour slow roasted prime rib (Saturdays) was very tender, though the flavor could have been better. The aus jus saved it and was good. We decided to also order the desserts of a grasshopper (one of the best I've had) and cheesecake. This was house made pumpkin cheesecake and was of a generous portion. My wife and I would eat here again. We might have to come back sooner than expected for more chili! Keep an eye out for drunk townies. Some dude in his 60's with a group thought it was a good idea to quickly fake lunging out in front of my car as I was pulling in. It was 5pm. Bro, you gotta live long enough to get SSI and your AARP card. Be less stupid.

Source: Google

★ 5

Great supper club atmosphere with a very good fish fry and great service!

Source: Google

★ 5

Highly recommended

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 1

We were so excited to go and enjoy and unfortunately we were all disappointed with our meals. We had the prime rib, bbq ribs, relish tray, pork chop, and broasted chicken. So basically we tried a ton of different dishes and none of them were good and our waitress treated us like we were an annoyance to her. Unfortunately, we probably won’t go back. I hope you all have a different experience as we always want local businesses to thrive.

Source: Google

★ 4

Favorite prime rib I’ve had in quite a long time. Edge to edge medium rare, delicious wedge salad. Not a huge fan of the old fashioned but the blackberry old fashioned was tasty.

Source: Google

★ 5

I love this place. We were taking the back road from the north shore back to St. Paul and about the time we got hungry, we saw the Hilltop. Great burger with fries for lunch.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Typical Wisconsin supper club with a very well stocked salad bar, great atmosphere, and excellent food. The old fashioneds are great but the best draw are the cheese balls and crackers at the bar. So get there before your reservation time and have a cocktail at the bar!

Source: Google

★ 3

Food and waitstaff were excellent for a Wednesday night fish fry.
The bartender did nothing to make us feel welcome and we were the only ones at the bar and was actually downright rude when asked a simple question. Ruined an otherwise great evening.

Source: Google

★ 5

First time in a few years that i've been to a supper club and it was delightful with a couple friends of mine. Like going back in time. A delicious blackberry brandy old fashioned!

Source: Google

★ 3

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 3

Source: Google

★ 5

We ordered the king size prime rib and split it between the two of us (reasonable $5 split plate charge). The meat was cooked exactly to our order and was delicious. All the sides ( those that came with meal and the extras we ordered) were also very good. The bar drinks were well made. The desserts (a grasshopper and a crème brûlée) were scrumptious. The ambiance is a bit dated, but did not take away from the food, excellent attentive staff, or experience. We had reservations, but could have been quickly seated without them, but we came shortly after they opened and the parking lot was filling up by time we left. Highly recommend.

Source: Google

★ 5

Food, service and atmosphere was all fantastic!

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 4

Food was excellent, servers were excellent, but the bartenders were impolite. Only three words said/asked of me, on a 30$ bar bill.

Source: Google

★ 3

Stopped in on a Thursday night for dinner. Food was mediocre for the supper club pricing. Drinks were on the weak side.

Source: Google

★ 1

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Good old fashioned Wisconsin supper club. Even though they were packed on Saturday when we went the food and service was great!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

The hilltop has a fun and casual atmosphere. The customer service was excellent and the food was great. I had the fillet and shrimp with baked potato and side salad. All was fresh and expertly prepared. We will definitely go back again.

Source: Google

★ 5

very classic supper club. everything was good. nice experience.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 4

We stopped at the Hilltop Supper club for the first time last night. There is a nice bar off to the right when you walk in; the dining area is dimly lit (as a supper club should be.) They seated us right away. The service is polite and quick. Old fashioneds were good, the menu was a little limited and they have no salad bar...i hate that few supper clubs have them anymore. The soup was good, filet was very good, the prime had a lot of fat but was tender. We finished with a smores ice cream drink which we both enjoyed. All in all, I would definitely go back.

Source: Google

★ 5

One of our favorite supper clubs. Tonight we both did tenderloin with shrimp. Everything was delicious!

Source: Google

★ 5

I have gone to The Hilltop for yrs and I believe here closing out 2024 it's the best it's been. People talk about Green Acres or other supper clubs in the area but The Hilltop is 50% better than the others.

Source: Google

★ 5

Delicious food, great service and supper club vibes! The steak was phenomenal and the fish fry was very well done too!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 2

I guess all good things come to an end...

We have loved coming to Hilltop for prime rib since discovering it 5 years back. Fast forward to now. The last two times we came, the side dish was mediocre, and the prime rib was hit or miss (mine was mostly fat; my wife and daughter's were good cuts). However, this Saturday we made reservations two days prior for our daughter's 21st birthday, and brought her significant other. Upon arriving right on time for our reservation, we were told we would be seated soon. 30 minutes later, we finally get a seat. We then sat for another 20 minutes before our waitress came over, but whatever. We then ordered the Saturday special-four prime ribs, but the waitress comes over a few minutes later to let us know they were now out of prime rib. While I know this can happen, they should have informed us BEFORE we waited and then sat down. I would be more understanding if this was an odd night, or this restaurant was new or inexperienced, but Hilltop really has no excuse after all these years in business. We were recommended by another customer to go to Heritage Tavern in Cross Plains, and everything was 100% better. Our new go-to from now on.

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 2

very slow we had a reservation and still waited a good hour and a half

Source: Google

★ 5

Food was great!

Source: Google

★ 2

My husband and I ordered the prime rib and it was both cold and incredibly bland. My son ordered the broasted chicken (which was good) with a side of grilled shrimp that was again bland and charred. They have a relatively limited menu on Saturday so we hoped what they offered they did well - unfortunately that was not the case. Pretty disappointing for a first impression and for the price I’d hesitate to go back.

Source: Google

★ 5

Always an excellent meal and sercice.

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 4

When I think of Supper Clubs, this is place is exactly what comes to mind. Dont let the interior distract what lays in wait inside.
A wide range of entrees and drinks available.
I had the porterhouse pork chop which was good. You can get it anyway you'd like. I had mine medium well and it was done perfectly.

I will certainly come back if in the area.

Source: Google

★ 5

Great supper club. Great service. Great food. Chicken had a nicer lighter breading. Great atmosphere. Drinks a tad bit expensive. Prices with food good!

Source: Google

★ 3

Source: Google

★ 4

Confusion with our reservation resulted in a delay, but the wait is part of the experience for fish fry at a supper club. Our guest from Germany enjoyed it.

Source: Google

★ 5

Great place, super drink selection, outstanding menu, tasty food, excellent service.

Source: Google

★ 5

Great food, great service!

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 5

First visit last Friday and we liked Hilltop a lot. Arrived a little after 5:00 and it was already pretty lively. You might be put off by the unassuming exterior, but don’t be. We got a friendly welcome and great service. We enjoyed the fish fry and old fashioneds and look forward to a return visit when we’re in the vicinity.

Source: Google

★ 4

The fish fry was just so-so. The drinks & the service were very good.

Source: Google

★ 4

I had the 1/2 rack of ribs and they were delicious. The only thing that could have been a little better was the rhubarb dessert. Everything else was excellent.

Source: Google

★ 5

The food and drinks were perfect. The staff was very friendly and prompt. The environment was great. I’d highly recommend trying this place out. I thought the prices were in line for the quality we received. Our party of four all felt the same. We’ll be back!

Source: Google

★ 5

A true Supper Club!!! Great place to meet family and friends. Been there for Fish and Ribs and both were great! Friendly Staff and Good drinks as well!

Source: Google

★ 3

Food was tasty but pretty overpriced. The bartender had an attitude.

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 5

The Hilltop Restaurant in Cross Plains, WI offers a charming ambiance with scenic views. Their menu boasts delicious comfort food with a twist, served by friendly staff. Don't miss their signature dishes and desserts. A delightful dining experience worth revisiting!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Great place for Sunday Brunch

Source: Google

★ 5

We have been here twice and the food, service and atmosphere have been amazing each time. The Saturday prime rib melts in your mouth and the drinks go down easy. Oh and the CHEESEBALL?! If I could put the heart eyes emoji I would. Price is reasonable and fair for the amount of food you get. Staff and owners are hard workers and love the business. 10/10 recommend!

Source: Google

★ 1

Food was bland and mushy. (Prime rib and Walleye) Waitress was dismissive and forgetful.
They rushed us out of our table to get more people in when there was multiple other tables open. Felt very unwelcomed, will not be back.

Source: Google

★ 4

Good Food. Bloody Marys very spicy.

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 5

Traditional Wisconsin supper club with an excellent fish fry on Friday. Wonderful staff and owners.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

We were in Cross Plains and saw that this place had great reviews. They have great food too. So good that I forgot to take pictures. They serve you rolls with honey butter to start. We had side salads with homemade dressings. We shared a large piece of salmon with fries and a filet with au gratin potatoes. Everything was delicious. We had carrot cake for dessert. It was pretty good. I should have asked them to warm it up. It is always better that way.

Source: Google

★ 5

We had a great Saturday night dining experience here with friends. The Grouper and Walleye were fresh and cooked perfectly. Green beans were tasty, too! Prompt friendly service.

Source: Google

★ 4

Second time we visited food and service was great place was busy but we got in quickly

Source: Google

★ 4

Great old school supper club.

Source: Google

★ 4

Great supper club feel. Felt like you could drop this place up North and it would fit right in. The prime rib was perfect and the sides and appetizers were delicious.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Been by The Hilltop hundreds of times, should have stopped years ago. The service and atmosphere were amazing. You can't go wrong with the fried perch and au gratin potatoes. Delicious.

Source: Google

★ 5

Delicious Friday fish (baked cod) dinners, with great old fashioneds.

Source: Google

★ 2

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Made a one day visit to Madison, and decided to have dinner at a "Supper Club" and this did not disappoint!! Had a rustic vibe, but clean, well appointed and felt updated enough as well. We were informed that a group of 45 was ordering as we arrived, and the hostess let us know that we may have a longer wait, but if we odered quickly they might be able to sneak in our order ahead of thiers. They got our appetizer in(cheese curds omg so delightfully light and perfect) and our dinner order came out shortly after, so they really pulled it off. Our food was perfectly cooked(filet, and fish fry) and the service was attentive and welcoming.
I was impressed and enjoyed every minute of this quintessential Wisconsin experience. Only 10 or 15 minutes from the west area of Madison, we stayed at a hotel in the mall area. Check this place out!

Source: Google

★ 5

Great fish fry old-fashioned supper club

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

First time there everything was really good

Source: Google

★ 5

Great supper club experience. Prime rib was excellent!

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Justin was a amazing waiter, food came out hot. Beer could have colder.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Great service and food

Source: Google

★ 5

Great service and food. Great waitress she was super nice and friendly. Food was perfect 🥰.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Wonderful time!

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Great food. Great service

Source: Google

★ 5

Best prime rib I have had in a decade. broasted,chicken is awesome. service was great!

Source: Google

★ 4

It was a nice supper club with good food. But over priced.

Source: Google

★ 5

Better than all the restaurants Mount Horeb has to offer.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Excellent food and service at a classic supper club!! I highly recommend it!

Source: Google

★ 4

Dessert was kinda small :(

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Even on a busy Sat. Night we were seated quickly. We had a reservation (recommended) for a group of 7.

Source: Google

★ 5

First time here. Food was great. Crackers and cheese spread at the bar was excellent. Had the fish fry and it was great also. Next time we'll try the steak.

Source: Google

★ 5

Very wonderful food we will be back with more people, it was the best ever an services, an great place an very great

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Made The Hilltop our road trip Supper Club destination last weekend with friends. Great atmosphere and friendly staff. Food was the best! Cheeseball and crackersat the bar just like the old days at the supper club. Juicy, thick prime and yummy ice cream drinks for dessert. Highly recommend!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Great food..... everything I have had so far was not disappointing 😃

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 5

Always great food and perfectly done, the service has always been great, plan to go back often.

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 5

A terrific old school supper club spot. Service, atmosphere, and food were all great. Would recommend dynamite shrimp and prime rib, of course with old fashioneds. Definitely coming back again!

Source: Google

★ 3

Source: Google

★ 5

Wonderful service and the food was outstanding.

Source: Google

★ 4

Excellent service and fried shrimp Rocked! but seasoning on prime rib and au jus was less than desirable as in no seasoning. Also, I notice a dirty broken window. If I’m gonna spend 30-40 dollars on a steak or fish plate you’d expect the window at the front entrance to be fixed. Fancy prices should have fancy upkeep

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 4

Justin the server was awesome. Apologetic over the long wait which wasn't anything he had control over. Great fish fry

Source: Google

★ 5

Very good food and drinks

Source: Google

★ 2

While I can appreciate the dimming of lights in a dining room, if it’s too dark to read the menu, it’s going to be too dark to see what’s on your plate! Such was the case last night for our table of six. Three of us ordered prime rib. It was the most gristled cut of prime rib I’ve ever almost seen or tasted! Coupled with the dull, years-old lightweight steak knives, our choice of meat was disappointing, to say the least. One in our group ordered the baked salmon. Due to the darkness in the dining room, eventually he figured out that reason his salmon wasn’t hot is because it was raw and cold in the center. Excellent cheese ball at the bar, but you couldn’t give me all the cheese balls in the world to get me to try this tired supper club again.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Service was topnotch! Delicious meal amd dessert.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Always awesome. If you want consistently great food, Hilltop is your place. Filet and shrimp were perfect! Generous on the ounces of steak and perfect season on some very large shrimp. All accompanied by an old fashioned like only a supper club can make!!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Went with 9 other friends for our monthly supper club/fish fry night and it was incredible. Great drinks, fish fry and you definitely have to save room for the ice cream cocktails to end the night on. Randall, our server, was also sensational and the bartenders, while we waited for our table, were attentive and fast, especially with how busy it was on a Friday night. Will definitely return!

Source: Google

★ 5

A true Wisconsin super club!

Source: Google

★ 5

The best prime rib

Source: Google

★ 5

There are so many wonderful, delicious things about this family owned business, I don’t know where to begin. The Hilltop is a Supper Club in the truest definition. From the friendly hostesses, the bartenders speed and the servers efficiency is only topped by the chefs magic. First things first, a must have …an old fashion of course. They muddle the sugar cube with the goodness. Complimentary homemade cheese balls are set out at the bar on Friday and Saturday. ( They are also on the menu, so order 1 to take to your next party) My favorite menu item is the combo. A 6oz fillet and 4 shrimp. The filet is so tender, a butter knife will cut it! The shrimp can be ordered grilled, fried or bourbon glazed. Homemade soup, deserts and other goodies are amazing. You will leave here with a happy tummy and heart!

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 5

At Hilltop for a group dinner (20+) service very efficient, food good. Great authentic Wisconsin supper club experience

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Waitress was awesome, such a great experience! Prime rib was like butter!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 3

Source: Google

★ 3

Source: Google

★ 5

We had great prime rib Saturday night (10/4/2017) at the Hilltop Restaurant located between Cross Plains and Pine Bluff. The atmosphere, service, food, and soft background music are all outstanding. We decided on the Hilltop for a special occasion and were not disappointed. We highly recommend this lovely restaurant to anyone who wish a fine dining experience and a reasonable price.

Source: Google

★ 4

Good food, classic Wisconsin supper club.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Excellent food and drinks

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Myself and 2 friends dined here for the first time and we're very glad we did. All of the food we ordered was delicious and arrived at the table hot. The one steak that was ordered was a perfect medium rare. Mary Ann was our server and she was excellent. The kitchen's timing was impeccable and Mary Ann took great care of us. She is a rarity today. I'm so glad we added the Hilltop to our supper clubs to try. This was number 21 on our list and will be one we will happily repeat. A classic not to be missed. Come early!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 4

Great service and good food All in all a very good supper club

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

A wonderful, authentic Supper Club! Meals were delicious.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 5

Always a great time. Prime Rib is worth the trip.

Source: Google

★ 5

I cannot say enough great things about The Hilltop! Each time we have gone, our food has been amazing! We had our holiday work party there this year. They were pretty busy that night, and I can tell you the service was still seamless! Very organized, great food, great drinks and friendly staff! Highly recommend!

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 3

Food was good.

Source: Google

★ 4

Food was good. Too expensive though.

Source: Google

★ 4

Stopped in for a cocktail and some apps. Had a perfectly made Whiskey old fashioned sour with olives. Had to order apps to go, no food at the bar except a delicious cheese ball. Look forward to trying dinner soon.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Fit in a party of 12 for Easter brunch. Great visit with family!!

Source: Google

★ 5

The steak around

Source: Google

★ 5

Always a great meal and service!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Wonderful atmosphere beautifully made old fashions not your normal kind I had a huckleberry old fashion was to die for!

Source: Google

★ 5

Excellent Food, Even Better Company.

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 5

Great meal and service!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 2

Disappointed actually. Service was good, but food was mediocre at best. Full portion of baked Friday Fish ($18) was 2 small pieces (total in size of a Twinkie) and the 1/2 portion ($14) of deep fried, was 2 pieces about 1.5 inch square. Tasteless! Relish tray ($9) minimal (8 carrot sticks, 8 celery sticks - 3 inches long, 6 pickle spears, 6 small tomatoes and 8 pieces of pickled beets). Will not recommend nor return.

Source: Google

★ 2

Very disappointing, particularly after reading the reviews. Last night had full portion of the baked cod. 12 oz was claimed on menu, but portion was half that. Two very small filets. Little flavor and a bit mushy. Came with good baked potato and a plastic cup with slaw; also included two small rolls and good honey butter. For $18, is was very disappointing and certainly did not compare to other supper clubs. The relish plate ($9), which the server said would provide “a real supper club experience”, was fresh but very limited…3 pickle spears, several carrot and celery pieces, 6 cherry tomatoes, and very good pickled beets. Bottom line: not bad food, but certainly not memorable (in a good sense), expensive, and will not be returning. There are much better options.

Source: Google

★ 5

Great old style Wisconsin supper club. Their menu varries daily. We love the fish fry and the broasted chicken. The bar is great, the staff are friendly and knowledgeable. It's also a very nice country drive from Madison. Definitely worth checking out.

Source: Google

★ 4

Source: Google

★ 5

Awesome to have an old school supper club back in operation!

The food was excellent, the drinks were strong and the patrons were as friendly as the bartenders and waitstaff.

This place brings back memories of how supper clubs used to be.

Arrive early, make reservations, enjoy the cheeseball and crackers at the bar before dinner and order an old fashion brandy sour with a slice of lime. Save room (if that's possible) for dessert and one of those tasty ice creams drinks!

The secret is out, this place has it figured out!

Source: Google

★ 5

Wonderful food. Attentive staff.

Source: Google

★ 5

Always great here and great atmosphere. The employees are always super nice!

Source: Google

★ 5

OMG! Had a fabulous time at The Hilltop. The food and service was was amazing. Had to wait a little for our table but it as with it for the prime rib dinner. It was the best prime rib I have had in a long time!

Source: Google

★ 2

VERY PRICEY FOR THE SETTING.. THEY RUINED SUCH A GREAT PRIME RIB!!! Prime rib WAS AMAZING 3 YEARS AGO and WORTH IT EVERY TIME.. Didn't even need salt.. BUT idk if their cook QUIT or what... BUT for LAST 3 YEARS it's SOOOO BLAHHHHH NOW!!!!! NO FLAVOR!!! I GO IN ONCE A YEAR PRAYING THEY BROUGHT THE OLD DELICIOUS, FLAVORFUL PRIME RIB BACK... They KEPT the PRICE on NEW/VERY AVERAGE PRIME RIB THE SAME!!! ALL IT LOST WAS FLAVOR!!!

Source: Google

★ 5

Great food

Source: Google

★ 5

We went to The Hilltop for our first time for Friday Fish and it was excellent! Looking forward to going back to try the steaks and BBQ ribs. The desserts were also amazing! Thank you!

Source: Google

★ 5

Excellent food, service, and atmosphere. My favorite place for Friday fish fry and an Old Fashioned.

Source: Google

★ 5

Classic supper club experience. Busy bartenders were nonetheless attentive and friendly. Food was excellent and served hot. Waitress was intelligent and pretty. Just do it!!!

Source: Google

★ 5

I came here with some friends a few weeks ago and it did not disappoint! The waitresses were on point and one of the bus boys was on his game. He made sure we had water all throughout our time there. We had the perch with the rice pilaf. Truly amazing and would definitely come back!

Source: Google

★ 5

Good food, a little pricey.

Source: Google

★ 2

Had the perch fish fry and was terrible! Received six pieces though mostly batter, greasy and expensive! Wait staff was great! Would not recommend.

Source: Google

★ 5

Exceptional Supper Club. Filet was great!

Source: Google

★ 5

The food was very good - requisite prime rib in WI on a Saturday night. Service was slow, but perfectly understandable as there was few waitstaff for a very busy night. Would definitely go here again.

Source: Google

★ 5

Great food and staff! Love this place! Caleb at the bar is great!

Source: Google

★ 5

Source: Google

★ 4

First time customer, but will definitely return. Salmon and filet were perfect!

Source: Google