The Lost Pirate Tiki Bar and Grill

Buffalo City, 175 S River Rd, Buffalo City, WI 54622, United States | ★ 4.3 (151 Review)

📞 +1 608-248-2683

Last Search

Category

Bar Restaurant

Description

Short 5 minutes off of HWY 35 located on the Mississippi River. Great views, food, and drinks. Families are welcome.

Photos

 The Lost Pirate Tiki Bar and Grill
 The Lost Pirate Tiki Bar and Grill
 The Lost Pirate Tiki Bar and Grill
 The Lost Pirate Tiki Bar and Grill
 The Lost Pirate Tiki Bar and Grill
 The Lost Pirate Tiki Bar and Grill
 The Lost Pirate Tiki Bar and Grill

Leave a Review

Reviews

Sheila Kersten

★ 5

We came to Buffalo City to fish & found a terrific place for an amazing Bloody n food.♥️🙏

Source: Google

Keith Osgood

★ 5

Nice place didn't look like much from the outside but the inside was pleasantly surprising lots of funny signs nice people

Source: Google

Ken Johanson

★ 5

Real tropical vibe right here in Wisconsin!

Source: Google

Jenee Cummings

★ 5

Didn’t eat so can’t rate the food. But Keith is awesome. Live on demand entertainment ❤️

Source: Google

John Stasiak

★ 5

Best bloody Mary's in Wisconsin

Source: Google

Melissa Bartsch

★ 5

We didn’t have food so I can’t rate that. The owner/bartender was awesome. He was very engaging with his customers. He also played music for us, which was amazing. The atmosphere and views were wonderful. We will be back.

Source: Google

Colleen Lange

★ 5

Owner was super friendly and welcoming. Food hit the spot on a chilly Spring day.

Source: Google

Elizabeth “Liz” Schwab

★ 5

Such a fun place to watch a game, have a beer, and visit with friends . Keith the owner is top notch, fun and a very talented musician.

Source: Google

Kevin Long

★ 5

Keith is fantastic! Love this bar! Service is incredible, bloody Mary was exceptional! We would highly recommend this establishment!

Source: Google

Jay Jewson

★ 5

What a great place!! How often does the owner break out his guitar and give you a free concert??

Source: Google

Stacy Eberle

★ 5

Locals are friendly. The owner/bartender plays guitar and will sing for you.

Source: Google

thomas lorenz

★ 3

Live music from the owner upon request. You can sing at the bar with Kareoke. Good pizza, etc

Source: Google

Cindy Fernholz

★ 5

Went there for a celebration of life.

Source: Google

Jeff Wellendorf

★ 5

Owner is great and he also can play and don't amazing!!! Cole slaw is amazingly good!!

Source: Google

Mitchel Mueller

★ 1

Treats his employees like trash.
Editing as to respond, where was I? Not supporting your establishment, as you had made my little sister who worked for you cry on my first visit to your "Bar and Grill"

Source: Google

Kristy Thorson

★ 5

Great time at the Lost Pirates Tiki! Great pizza with lots of toppings and a singing bartender for Kathy’s birthday! So fun! Stop by if you are in the area!

Source: Google

Mike Davis

★ 5

Pizza was excellent !!

Source: Google

Mark Shuda

★ 5

Very nice bar! Awesome Service.

Source: Google

Matthew Hendren

★ 5

Source: Google

Maria Thier

★ 5

Keith was amazing! He bartended, made home-made pizza and sang for us. Over the top service. A must stop when on the Mississippi or in Wisconsin. Can't say enough about the great service and food! Accomadated a group with NO hesitation. Cheap prices and excellent service

Source: Google

becky weber

★ 5

Source: Google

Gina DeFrang

★ 2

Source: Google

Angie Canter

★ 5

This place is amazing! The atmosphere is tropical with a view of the water. The bartender/owner sings and plays instruments, all while providing great, pleasant service and making awesome food!

Source: Google

Lee Lewis

★ 5

Nice people good food and drinks

Source: Google

Marshall Behrens

★ 5

This may singlehandedly be one of the coolest places I have been in the last 6 months. An authentic tiki bar on the river and literally 3 minutes off of the WI rive road. Keith the owner/bartender is an amazing musician. We were blessed to get a 30 minute acoustic set behind the bar! Do not miss this place!

Source: Google

Dawn Allert

★ 5

Thanks Keith!!
We had a great time. We will be back to see you. The atmosphere and beautiful view of the river. We love Wisconsin in the fall.
And the entertainment was spectacular!! 😎🧡

Source: Google

Bud Kleppe

★ 5

Fun place to get your tropical cocktail fix

Source: Google

Keith Mann

★ 5

Great owners. Great atmosphere.

Source: Google

Captain Art Wilson

★ 4

Sadly, this place is understaffed. Kinda spendy. 2 Jameson's and a mini brat $25

Source: Google

Angela Katterhagen

★ 5

Love the atmosphere and the regulars make you feel welcome! I recommend the build your burger option with the jalapeno! YUMMMMMM!
Anytime we are this way we Are Stopping!!!!

Source: Google

Franklin Heimer

★ 5

Nice place to eat

Source: Google

Bill Robbins

★ 5

Smoked Manhattan at the Lost Pirate Tiki Bar!! Very well done Keith

Source: Google

Steve Zastrow

★ 4

Bar owner is nice!

Source: Google

Dawn Appel

★ 5

The best onion rings ever!!! Great service. The owners go out of their way the make your experience memorable. Stopped in on a Sunday drive from Lake City. We'll be back!

Source: Google

Katy Rausch

★ 5

Great service and food. Employees and owner are really friendly

Source: Google

Travis M

★ 5

Source: Google

Joseph Vogel

★ 5

Nice breeze, friendly staff, cold beer, great food! Every time I come to Minnesota from Colorado , this is one of my stops...love this place!

Source: Google

Joey Fernholz

★ 5

Source: Google

Leo Bronston

★ 5

Pleasant surprise this off road tavern. A must stop! Great service! Keith and Kris know how to entertain

Source: Google

Denise Okstad

★ 4

🎉wonderful service! Food was wonderful! The onion rings are to die for....not frozen to deep fryer. They have a homemade beer batter that is light and flavorful...so worth the little drive!!

Source: Google

Emma Hansen

★ 2

Been over here for years when it was the Cove. Loved their food and drinks. This time, with new owners, cold food and nothing special about the drinks. Tried it. Won't be back

Source: Google

Sydne Egland

★ 5

Source: Google

Jennifer Tougas

★ 5

Excellent food, service and cleanliness! And the pirate cam and sang for us then let me sing sloop John b!

Source: Google

will schweisberger

★ 4

Good place to eat

Source: Google

Ann Mann

★ 1

Source: Google

Linda Knott

★ 4

Source: Google

Laura Nolen

★ 5

Source: Google

Barry McRaith

★ 5

Great food... and so fun listening to the owner sing and play his guitar. Great family run business!

Source: Google

Taylor Spalding

★ 1

The new owner is rude and self-absorbed. He'd rather play his guitar than get you a drink. Prices are outragous for the area. Bloodies are not the same. Service is absolutely horrible. Food took forever and had hair in it. Weeds are overgrown on the patio and cement. Don't recommend.

Source: Google

laura nolen

★ 5

Love the owners and the food is delicious each and every time!

Source: Google

Cody Schueler

★ 1

Extremely small portions for very overpriced food. I even asked the owned if they made a mistake as to why I was paying more then $10 for a chicken burger that my 5 year old child could have eaten 2 of. Chewing on said chicken burger was like eating solid bread.

Source: Google

Shannon Sullivan

★ 5

Source: Google

Bell

★ 4

Laid back, food looked amazing. Service was great. Bathrooms were nice and clean.

Source: Google

James Haugen

★ 5

Nice atmosphere. Great friendly service, good, reasonably priced food..

Source: Google

Andrew Fernholz

★ 5

Source: Google

Duane Johnson

★ 4

Source: Google

Josh Flury

★ 5

Good food and friendly service

Source: Google

Amy Baertsch

★ 3

Bloodies are lacking in condiments compared to what they used to be. View is great.

Source: Google

Nick Relich

★ 1

Source: Google

Derek Fahy

★ 5

Source: Google

Robbin Peterson

★ 5

Source: Google

Braden Knutson

★ 5

Source: Google

Ray Lars

★ 4

Source: Google

Ken Konkel

★ 4

Excellent bloody food was good

Source: Google

Paul Holman

★ 4

New owners. The place is a great stop today for us on our Loop around the Mississippi. Service was great and food was very good. My old fashion was spot on. I look forward to watching the new owners take this gem to a new family friendly level of Tiki Bar on the river. Can't beat the view!

Source: Google

Cheyenne Prahl

★ 5

Source: Google

Gary Meldahl

★ 5

Excellent Bloody Mary's and burgers

Source: Google

Sara Lueke

★ 5

Good food! Great location!

Source: Google

Danica Bossert

★ 3

Source: Google

Peggy Burrichter

★ 5

Been open all winter. Good food & drink

Source: Google

Randy Schroeder

★ 5

The service was better than it used to be, the food was okay but bland, the prices remain really reasonable. Overall an okay experience and we will go back just for a change of pace.

Source: Google

Stacey Runkle

★ 5

Source: Google

jason lindell

★ 5

Great food and service.

Source: Google

TJ Notorious

★ 5

I had the huge Cove burger. It was great! Friendly staff.

Source: Google

Chris Gravholt

★ 5

Source: Google

Jeff Shrader

★ 4

Source: Google

tashia klassen

★ 4

Source: Google

Diane Bossert

★ 5

Very good lunch. They offered free lunches to our Veterans. Very friendly and helpful wait staff.

Source: Google

Carrie Fritsch

★ 3

Waitress was so nice. It was quite noisy for dining pleasure.

Source: Google

Dawn Cowell

★ 5

Very good. Served food drank beer. To yum yum

Source: Google

Lynn Bignell

★ 4

Good food, cold beverages, strange hours.

Source: Google

Thomas Johnston

★ 4

Source: Google

Linda Stamschror

★ 5

Great prime rib on Saturday nights.

Source: Google

Mary Gauthier

★ 1

We placed a to go order for 5 people and when we got home, we were very disappointed. We all ordered different items and the meat in every meal was burnt The woman that rang up our order was very nice though None of us will be returning there and we will not be recommending this place to anyone

Source: Google

Chris Galewski

★ 4

Nice atmosphere.

Source: Google

Bryant Adams

★ 5

Source: Google

Allan Streveler

★ 4

Source: Google

Eric Mueller

★ 5

Cozy place with a great view of the Mississippi river, and awesome food as well!

Source: Google

Lori Christianson

★ 4

Source: Google

Jerry Pross

★ 5

An enchanting place

Source: Google

Dean Kafka

★ 5

Great Local Bar!! Great food!

Source: Google

Sue Hutson

★ 4

The wait staff was very friendly. She must be new, because she was a little inexperienced. The food was good, and very generous. Prices were somewhat high for a small town restaurant.

Source: Google

Pati harm

★ 5

Great meals and great bartender my son

Source: Google

Jen

★ 1

The service was awful. They have signs that say seat Yourself. So we did. We went outside to the patio, the waitress came out four times and never once stopped to take a drink give us menus etc. there was only one other party on the patio at that time.

The bees were so horrible on the patio we went inside. The service did not get any better. We ordered the chicken and waffle nachos and were brought the nacho supreme. When questioned she told The bees were so horrible on the patio we went inside. The service did not get any better. We ordered the chicken and waffle nachos and were brought the nacho supreme. When questioned as to why we had nachos supreme she said that’s what you ordered. It was not. She then said I would have told you we were out of waffle fries. She did not. She never once checked on us and it one time she sat down in the dining room took off her shoes adjusted her socks put her shoes back on and then went in to the kitchen and brought out plates of food.

However, the worst part is four days later I am still dealing with the side effects of food poisoning.

Source: Google

Lindsay Salo

★ 4

We stopped here on a road trip not knowing what to expect. Everyone enjoyed their food and it was resonably priced. The restaurant was absolutely freezing inside though. I haven't touched a sweatshirt in months, but found myself rummaging through my vehicle to find one to wear. In fact, our whole table did the same thing.

Source: Google

Mary Sprick

★ 5

Source: Google

Samantha Kupietz

★ 5

Source: Google

Ella Toellner

★ 3

Source: Google

Riley Connell

★ 5

Source: Google

John Freidinger

★ 5

Awesome place to eat

Source: Google

Mark Dresser

★ 4

Source: Google

Michael Brown

★ 5

Love this place

Source: Google

Sarah Tifft

★ 5

Get the cheese curds!!!!

Source: Google

Anthony Mikesell

★ 3

Lots of bar fights occur here.......good food though.......fights tend to happen at night past kitchen hours

Source: Google

Curt Wilber

★ 4

Friendly bartender and good food.

Source: Google

Debbie Colmenares

★ 4

Source: Google

0tt0 Mobile

★ 4

I liked the shrimp dinner.

Source: Google

David Schultz

★ 3

Source: Google

LaVerne Franzwa

★ 5

Food was great, the atmosphere was great. Great service.

Source: Google

Ed Davis

★ 4

Source: Google

Krista Hohlfeld

★ 4

Awesome Bloody Mary's and good

Source: Google

Kevin Fox

★ 4

Great little bar, great people great times.

Source: Google

Rhonda Bignell

★ 5

Great dinner... Great prices... Full bar it was an awesome time... Friendly employees, just a great time....

Source: Google

Rhonda Anderson

★ 4

Good place to eat and drink. Very nice and quite just the way I like it.

Source: Google

Ashley Becker

★ 5

Source: Google

J H

★ 4

Good bloody Mary, could use another dart board or 2 though.

Source: Google

Robert Baldridge

★ 5

Source: Google

C S

★ 5

Source: Google

Jeani Wodele

★ 5

They were awesome!!! We were an unexpected group of 20 and were given the best service and great food! 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟

Source: Google

Joe Mosier

★ 5

Source: Google

Craig Loewenhagen

★ 1

Crappy Service

Source: Google

Sherry Lambert

★ 3

Sunday around 10am..a lot of people and only one server, Macy. She had her hands full..She forgot our toast and yet it was on the bill, no syrup, I got it myself, no butter, again me..coffee, again me..no silverware, again me. She was in the back a lot and never out front. I really wanted the buffet, BUT there wasn't much there for variety, no fruit, no pancakes or french toast, just eggs and meat. Not real impressed

Source: Google

Todd Wyttenbach

★ 4

Very good sandwiches!

Source: Google

Mitch Raebel

★ 4

Source: Google

Ricky Egan

★ 5

Source: Google

Jason Ratz

★ 5

Great place

Source: Google

Alan Quinlan

★ 4

Source: Google

Marcus Petty

★ 4

Source: Google

lennie mastenbrook

★ 5

Source: Google

Diane Heusi

★ 5

Source: Google

Justin Cameron

★ 1

Used to be a great place to go prior to new ownership. Food has been mediocre as of late. Service poor, atmosphere cliquey.

Source: Google

Tim Neitzel

★ 5

Very friendly atmosphere

Source: Google

Jade Beck

★ 3

The view and the place itself are nice, but the service and food are lacking.

Source: Google

Stevia Rae Asher

★ 5

Source: Google

rhonda anderson

★ 4

Warm and friendly. They make you feel like a long lost friend they haven't seen for a long time. Always friendly and smiles when you walk in
I will go back every chance I can!!!!

Source: Google

Becky Severson

★ 1

Ate there 5 years ago it was awesome.ate there tonight terrible

Source: Google

Conager Mrozek

★ 5

Amazing food, amazing people and what a lovely view.

Source: Google

Richard Sattre

★ 5

Source: Google

Amy Baker

★ 5

Fantastic pan fried fish on Friday nights!

Source: Google

James Steiner

★ 5

Source: Google

Darryl Fox

★ 4

Source: Google

Matt Lietha

★ 5

Source: Google

Anthony Engberg

★ 4

Great burger for lunch.

Source: Google

Reba Weber

★ 4

Source: Google

Chris Peterson

★ 4

Source: Google

James F

★ 5

Great food and great Bloody Marys! Be sure to try them!

Source: Google

TJ Cook

★ 4

Good small town bar, on the backwaters of Mississippi river. Has shake of the day

Source: Google

Gretchen Miller

★ 4

Good food and river atmosphere

Source: Google

Jessica Ask

★ 5

Great wings and burgers

Source: Google

John Benson

★ 5

Great place

Source: Google

Chris Bates

★ 5

Good atmosphere, excellent bloody Mary's, great food.

Source: Google