Category
Restaurant American restaurant Bar Bar & grillDescription
Inspired by the traditions of Wisconsin taverns and supper clubs, The Old Fashioned exists to pay tribute to the foods and spirits that make our state famous.
Here, that means so much more than beers, brats, and cheese. Don't worry, we take all those things very seriously, but we're equally committed to preserving the unique heritage that defines our way of life. When you walk through our doors, you'll not only experience what Wisconsin was, you’ll taste what it always will be.
Photos
Leave a Review
Reviews
Alex Polivka
★ 5
Source: Google
Karel Ambroz
★ 5
Great neighborhood place. Everyone was friendly. Step outside the tourist lane.
Source: Google
Jesse Rhodes
★ 5
Great place! The cheese curds were amazing!
Source: Google
Samantha Payne
★ 5
The atmosphere here was great and the staff were all very friendly and attentive. We tried the cheese curds, those weren’t my favorite. However, the root beer on tap was incredible! For the entree I had the Mac and Cheese but I asked to add chicken to it so I had some protein too. They were happy to do so and it was more than enough for me! I will go back the next time I’m through the area!
Source: Google
Tammy Hofmeister
★ 5
Source: Google
Tracy Kreider
★ 5
Really cool place to hold a venue upstairs... Definitely had great feedback regarding the food.. Our server had no problems setting up the room to our needs.
However, was not attentive to our group.And we had to seek her out several times.. She was not very community or grateful at the end of the evening.
It would have been a much better experience if we had a different server... it wasn't "horrible" because of her.... Just could have been a better experience!!
It was a great building, a great space and we would come back again
Source: Google
Chase Randall
★ 5
Great draft selection! Service was top-notch!!!
Source: Google
Dennis Rigby
★ 5
Fun spot in Madison!
Source: Google
mr Don
★ 3
We went to the old fashion for the first time ever meet and my wife and we sat down and it was a nice atmosphere and took him a while to get to us to bring us a drink but that was OK and then when we finally got the fish we wanted a choice of potatoes and all they offer is French fries which we can't stand I wanted fried American fries or mashed potatoes are fully loaded baked potatoes they don't offer that anyway the fish I got the deep fried Cod and it was very oily it was worse than culvers and I guess that's just the way it is there from talking to people so if you like fish don't get it there I think they caught it out in the lake Monona or something and let it sit in Greece.. And my wife had the walleye and it was a small small portion and the flavor was terrible I would not be 1 bit surprised if it was lab grown My recommendation don't eat the fish at the old-fashioned I don't know about the other food but the fish is definitely a no no...
Source: Google
Paul Hanshaw
★ 5
Source: Google
Claire Considine
★ 1
The food is usually really amazing. The portion size compared to other photos in reviews was really small for cheese curds. The corner table we sat at head over 20 flies surrounding us and when it was mentioned as we tried to rush out as quickly as possible due to there being so many flies. I didn’t take pictures I was pretty disgusted. It seems like a health hazard. I have loved this place for years but I really wouldn’t go back after this and being dismissed by our server about the flies all over and the new table next to us also having issues. It’s disappointing as this has been my favorite restaurant for many years and sad to say I won’t come back.
Source: Google
Thomas Doyle
★ 5
Source: Google
Bill A
★ 5
This place has not only great food, including house made chips, fried walleye and a great Schnitzel sandwich, but like 60 local drafts! Wow.
Source: Google
D. Stuart Morelli
★ 5
Source: Google
Ben Spain
★ 5
The best Cheese Curds
Source: Google
Barry Resgonia
★ 5
Source: Google
Drew Thornsberry
★ 5
Source: Google
Krista Atyeo-Gortmaker
★ 5
Source: Google
Richard Muller
★ 5
Cheese curds A+
Beer selection A+
Service A+
Source: Google
Jessica
★ 5
The food was delicious and the server we had was great! Just be prepared for a long wait, it is a very busy place! But it was well worth the wait.
Source: Google
Diego Vasquez
★ 5
Lovely place in downtown Madison, excellent food and service
Source: Google
K Z
★ 2
The food was good, it was just really bad service. Our server was rude and uninterested the whole time. And then we found it hilarious that we were being kicked out before 9pm. It was 8:47 and the bidder was literally standing 20 feet away with a spay bottle and rag in hand waiting for us to leave. Can’t even stay busy past 8:30pm so I guess that tells you what you need to know.
Source: Google
Ryan Randolph
★ 5
Source: Google
CA Humphrey
★ 5
One of the best burgers ever! Wonderful service and great location.
Source: Google
Lynne Marie
★ 5
Source: Google
Paul “Gilby” Gilbertson
★ 5
Iconic Must See...
Source: Google
Alexa Dietz
★ 4
Food was pretty good! Had some friends and family visiting from out of state and the menu definitely helped give them a taste of Wisconsin! We were crammed around a small table and then it became uncomfortably hot in there, but other than that it was a good time.
Source: Google
Cassandra Washington
★ 2
I was in Madison for a conference and a hotel staff member recommended Old Fashioned. It was a short walk to the restaurant, so I decided to try the restaurant.
I was seated right away by a nice young man. The waiter came to my table quickly and was nice and described the specials for the evening. I decided to try the duck special based on his recommendation.
Whe my food arrived it looked delicious, but it was not hot. It was barely lukewarm. The flavor was good, but the food temperature was not good at all. When I mentioned it to the waiter, he said, “That’s how it’s supposed to be.” Hmmmm! Anyway it was a disappointing experience and meal.
Source: Google
Gerson Esquivel
★ 5
Source: Google
Devi
★ 4
Must stop here for their old fashioned. We also tried their cheese curds and lunch specials. Delicious seasonal sandwiches offered in the summer - smothered sandwiches and fresh heirloom tomato BLT’s! This is also the spot to go for their namesake old fashioned if you drink alcohol.
My favorite items was their cheese curds though. It was crispy and not too oily!
Source: Google
Jennifer Maish
★ 4
Didn't eat, couldn't find parking, but it sure looked neat.
Source: Google
Daniel Kapper
★ 5
Great service and the curds were fire!!!!
Source: Google
Gus Dennison
★ 5
Always one of my favorite places when I'm downtown. A must try if you've never been.
Source: Google
Bailey K
★ 5
We had cheese curds, a Reuben, and a beer cheese soup. Our child had the fish sticks. All was great. Service was great, and it was a cool atmosphere.
Source: Google
Katie Moureau
★ 5
Source: Google
steve maloney
★ 5
Source: Google
Lord T-Lars
★ 5
Great place with excellent food and drinks. Best potato salad I've ever had!
Source: Google
S H
★ 4
I've been here many times through the years and the beer cheese soup with the popcorn never disappoints, neither do their cheese curds. ❤️
Source: Google
Xin Ding
★ 3
Source: Google
Nathan Yeo
★ 5
Source: Google
Janet Calhoun
★ 5
The Old Fashioned has THE BEST Reuben in town. Piled high with hand carved corned beef - mmmmm. I take half home every time.
Great food and beers on tap.
Friendly and welcoming service.
Source: Google
MrDjdoughd
★ 5
We were passing through Madison and looked up Wisconsins best cheese curds and this restaurant came up. It definitely has to be one of the best. The cheese curds were so good. We also got the cheese fondue and the poutine. I dipped my cheese curds in the cheese and it was fabulous. By the end I had a cheese overload lol. The poutine was my least favorite in that I wasn’t really fond of the sausage gravy. It made it a bit weird but it was still more than edible. I also had a burger which was really good. The service was excellent and the atmosphere was nostalgic in a nice little spot downtown. On our way back I wanted to stop again but we chose to try another spots cheese curds and they didn’t even compare. Great job and awesome cheese curds.
Source: Google
Steven Hartman
★ 5
What a great funky little spot right next to the capital in downtown Madison. Great selection of beers on tap, great food, and was a lovely joint. The burger was scrumptious, and cheese curds divine. Next time I’m passing through - I’ll for sure be a repeat customer. Cheers.
Source: Google
Duane Bennett
★ 4
Friendly staff, very crowded so you can not talk very well
Source: Google
Wes
★ 1
I've been discriminated against when shopping here previously. Won't ever return just wanted to send out this PSA
Source: Google
Robert Gutowski
★ 5
Great place, amazing drinks, good food
Bar staff was very friendly and attentive.
Source: Google
Dawn Gramse
★ 5
Last minute group with a very large number and they were able to accommodate!
Source: Google
Justine
★ 5
Source: Google
Samuel Page
★ 5
Cozy bar and grill right next to the capital. Servers were were fast a pleasant. Kitchen provided some yummy food at at exceptional speed.
Source: Google
Katrina Moshier
★ 5
Source: Google
Jack Kruse
★ 5
Good food, 50 beers on tap to choose from!!!
Source: Google
Jon D
★ 5
One of my go to spots when I visit madison
Source: Google
Nathalia Alfaro
★ 5
I came here specifically for the cheese curds & they did not disappoint. Hands down, some of the best I’ve had in Wisconsin possibly the best. Crispy, gooey & full of flavor.
If you’re a cheese curd fan, this place is a must. Grab a cold beer on tap & enjoy the experience. I’ll definitely be back!
Source: Google
Laura O'Malley
★ 5
Curds are the best I've had, and the old fashioned cocktail was delicious! Great comfort food done right!
Source: Google
MrsOlatubi
★ 5
This restaurant is a must in Madison. Located right across the street from the State Capitol in downtown Madison. The service is hospitable from the time you enter the door til you leave. The service is a well run engine smooth and consistent. The servers are quick and great with following up with their patrons. The food is hands down great. If you like salty and savory, the Pountine are fries, cheese curds topped with sausage gravy. Those cheese curds are yummy! We also tried the Schnitzel, Reuben,, Fish and Chips, and the Salmon Salad all of the dishes can hold their own in terms of flavor. The Schnitzel is a hefty portion and you will definitely have left overs. Overall, a great dining experience.
Source: Google
Richard Butin
★ 5
Source: Google
Joe Kaderly
★ 5
Source: Google
Kim Galindo
★ 4
Source: Google
Renee G
★ 4
Source: Google
Sylvain Francois
★ 4
Cute old-style decoration inside, and great view on the Capitol outside. Great vibes. Was expecting a dark crowded place, but it felt spacious with plenty of natural light. Now, we were happy to taste Wisconsin specialties, but not brave enough not finish anything. Nothing to blame on the preparations, was better than what we ate at other places, but so greasy, so heavy. You need lots of alcohol to burn all this hard stuff. And a 1w of veggie diet to rebalance your stomach. And I'm still looking for real 🧀
Source: Google
Greg Leuthold
★ 5
Source: Google
Matthew
★ 5
Source: Google
Randy Calanca
★ 5
Best place around
Source: Google
David Fischer
★ 5
Source: Google
Jason Nesbit
★ 4
Great place to eat. It got very loud. Couldn't talk to each other.
Source: Google
Mohamad Awwa
★ 5
It’s kind of … odd fashioned :)
Source: Google
Jon Bailey
★ 4
Best cheese curds I've tried so far. Light and fluffy but so delicious.
Source: Google
Marc Hagan
★ 5
Source: Google
Katherine Barlow
★ 4
Source: Google
Emilya nas
★ 4
Everything was tasty from the cheese curds and fried onions to the steak and sloppy Joe. Really recommend to everyone!
Source: Google
Tim Hattan
★ 4
Source: Google
Joaquín Endara
★ 3
Cheese curds are great. The rest needs a bit of work. I was there on a Monday night... The wait was 50 min plus so be ready for the wait... Server were not willing to answer questions about the menu. We order two appetizers with our food, one arrive before the drinks and the second after all the main dishes...
Source: Google
Cindy Ng
★ 4
Friday fish fry is delightful. Never enough tartar sauce but the fish is well fried and comes with fries, cole slaw, and bread. Cheese curds are perfection! Lightly battered and melty with a good cheese pull, freshly fried. It gets a wee bit loud in there, sometimes feels like everyone is screaming and it’s hard to hear. But overall an excellent meal!
Source: Google
Eric Fuentes-Ruiz
★ 3
Source: Google
Michael McDonald
★ 5
Wisconsin has a unique take on Old Fashion drinks and this is the place to get one. Specifically, they use brandy and a sweet wash of soda or seltzer. Get all the varieties here. The food is also great. I had a walleye sandwich.
Source: Google
Mathias Albert
★ 5
Source: Google
Hayati Silsüpür
★ 4
Source: Google
Rachel Buell
★ 5
Stopped here for lunch after Googling the number one cheese curds in Wisconsin. We weren’t disappointed! They were light, crispy, gooey with a great flavor. Just perfect! My group also ordered the poutine and fondue. Dipping the cheese curds into the fondue was amazing! The poutine wasn’t my favorite with the sausage gravy on top. My heirloom tomato blt was huge and really good. The atmosphere and service were great as well
Source: Google
Cayce Roy
★ 4
Source: Google
Josh Goeser
★ 5
Source: Google
chikara
★ 5
Source: Google
Maya Shb
★ 3
The starters are so much better than main course, but overall i would say the menu is well priced. The quality is normal
Source: Google
Frank Arev
★ 5
Been there perhaps 6-7 times and the overall experience is wonderful. Take pride to service Wisconsin dishes and beverages. When busy, the staff can be overwhelmed a bit so service is a bit off but overall highly recommend. If you want a view of the capitol building, ask to be seated by a window.
Source: Google
Wendee Brungardt
★ 5
We were only in Madison for a half of a day and we were told to have lunch/dinner here. I had one is their famous old fashions and it was delicious. It was unlike any I've had but light refreshing and wonderful orange and cherry flavor. I did it less sweet which meant soda water instead of 7 up. I can't imagine it any sweet but I don't like sweet stuff. My hubby had a Spotted Cow by New Glarus brewing. He said it was a light, refreshing yummy ale.
We shared the cheese curds and I know they are voted top in the area but we thought they were just ok. They are very tiny and so more batter than we would like. And they were fairly greasy. We had them at Lakefront Brewing in Milwaukee and theirs are ten times better. They are much larger and a lighter beer batter.
My hubby had a bowl of beer cheese soup and he loved it. I had the salad with cherries, almonds and blue cheese & it was so delicious. I added grilled chicken and beets. I got the sherry vinaigrette on the side and it was the most delicious fresh dressing ever.
We had a great server and quick service. I would definitely recommend especially if you like local Wisconsin beers. They have 52 on tap and I think over 100 bottles/cans. Amazing selection and I love that they highlight local.
Source: Google
Michael McComb
★ 5
Very enjoyable for lunch. They added heirloom tomatoes to my grilled cheese sandwich and it was amazing. Local beers and sodas. Old beer signs provide charm. Servers are helpful and friendly. Good lunch menu choices. Everyone seemed to really enjoy the food and service.
Source: Google
Jodi Healy
★ 4
The Old Fashioned is always a solid choice if you’re craving classic Wisconsin comfort food and a great local atmosphere. The weekends can be very busy, so expect a bit of a wait, especially during dinner hours—but it’s worth it. Our server was attentive and friendly, making sure drinks stayed full and checking in at just the right moments without feeling intrusive. The food came out hot and fresh, and the portions were generous. The menu has plenty of local favorites, and the overall vibe is warm and lively, especially if you enjoy the energy of a bustling dining room.
Source: Google
Viggy Vanchi
★ 5
Visited this restaurant in pursuit of the city's best cheese curds after seeing many recommendations on reddit/internet. They did not disappoint! We ordered the fried cheese curds, beer cheese soup, and poutine (which, surprisingly, also had cheese curds in them). Everything was delicious, but we WAY over-ordered and had to fight to finish as much as possible. Portions are enormous, which was very welcome. I'd recommend getting the poutine instead of the plain cheese curds, as that many tends to get somewhat heavy after a while. The beer cheese soup was splendid as well.
Source: Google
Tracy Jacobson
★ 5
Cool Wisconsin bar/restaurant.
Source: Google
Ryan Stamey
★ 5
Was on a road trip vacation and the last day we stopped in Madison for a tour of the capital building and stopped in The Old Fashioned first. Be sure you’re hungry when you stop in. Portions are huge! Cheese curds are a must. They were to die for. Everyone loved their sandwiches. I had the Walleye sandwich and a side salad and it was delicious.
Source: Google
Joe Kelly
★ 5
Source: Google
JC
★ 4
Overall good place, but little crowded, meaning close tables, tight walkway to bathroom between bar and tables, etc. overall good and would return for a wide variety of food, which was all good. Two appetizers and three different entrees were all reviewed positively by our party
Source: Google
Steve LeFevre
★ 4
Source: Google
Bill Kilbey
★ 4
Classic Wisconsin bar. Five of us and two children stopped in for lunch and had a variety of menu items. The chili and beer cheese soup were very tasty. the heirloom tomato BLT was a nice treat. Chicken sandwich with so-so they really need to work on their salad game.
Source: Google
Ursula R.
★ 5
Mega BBQ-Dinner!!!!! Das Fleisch fiel praktisch von selbst vom Knochen und zerging auf der Zunge!
Source: Google
Laura Schoonover
★ 5
Source: Google
Messiah Cameron
★ 5
Trendy and bright with a youthful, energetic crowd
Source: Google
Lisa Haque
★ 4
Source: Google
arnoud hassett
★ 5
Such kind staff.
Source: Google
Robert Turfle
★ 5
Delicious 😋
Source: Google
Stella Maris
★ 5
Visiting from Oregon and stopped by on a long drive from Minnesota to Michigan. Glad we did- great sandwiches, atmosphere/location, and hospitality...and yes, we loved the fried cheese curds!
Source: Google
Rory
★ 4
Source: Google
Michael Smith
★ 5
Source: Google
Ryan Moyer
★ 5
Source: Google
Lexi Peterson
★ 4
Source: Google
J Jones
★ 5
Source: Google
Gavin Battig
★ 5
Very full and popular spot. The food and drinks were fantastic and the cheese curds and soup were so delicious! Great place to get classic food with local influences!
Source: Google
Jennifer Flanagan
★ 5
Source: Google
Hillary Timm
★ 5
Source: Google
Alvin Chen
★ 5
Best cheesecurd we have ever tried, bar none!
Source: Google
Lucius Kauer
★ 4
Burger and fish fry was good.
Source: Google
John
★ 2
Soup was cold.
Source: Google
Chris Jones
★ 5
Best burger I have ever had. In-your-face Wisconsin vibe but not in a bad way. The house beer is $3.
Source: Google
Roxanne Zick
★ 5
Great venue. Friendly staff. Good food
Source: Google
Camille Baland
★ 5
Source: Google
James Leon
★ 4
Source: Google
Jim's Office
★ 5
Source: Google
Keilian Meyer
★ 5
Source: Google
David Moe
★ 5
A bit of a wait but it was worth it.
Source: Google
Bryan Endres
★ 5
Source: Google
Jessica Pickett
★ 5
Food was excellent especially the cheese curds. Drinks were delicious. Loved the views from where we were sitting.
Source: Google
Monica Harlan
★ 5
Had cheese curds, which were the bestw we'd had while in Madison. Also had the Sloppy Joe sandwich, yummy. They have GF buns.
Source: Google
Keith Odonnell
★ 4
Had a steak sandwich, chips and beer cheese soup, Portion size was enough to take home half the sandwich. Food was very good. My only complaint is lack of parking
Source: Google
Marc Viader
★ 5
Source: Google
Melanie Mishra
★ 5
Good food. Nice menu choices. Reasonable prices.
Source: Google
Thomas Verriden
★ 5
WOW, what a perfect place 😍
Source: Google
Melissa B
★ 5
The brandy slush woth a splash of Door County cherry juice is so refreshing on a hot day. Bring your own straw because they give you paper straws that get soggy and unuseable.
Source: Google
Dennis Zehr
★ 5
excellent food and great atmosphere
Source: Google
Lawrence Byrd
★ 5
Source: Google
Jennifer Hill
★ 5
Great food, great service, nothing more to say
Source: Google
Thomas Dull
★ 5
Source: Google
Natalie Rhodes
★ 5
Source: Google
Amber Michur
★ 4
Great meal, great old fashion, great service. Ambience was not quite what we were expecting, but still a great place to visit.
Source: Google
John Salazar
★ 5
Just a small quaint tavern in the shadow of the capital building. Inexpensive menu, great bar and wonderful memorabilia on the walls!
Source: Google
Erin K
★ 4
Just ordered take out, I asked about utensils before I picked up my order, and I got to my hotel and I don’t have a spoon for my soup, and there is no butter for the bread. The food it good, but details matter
Source: Google
Jess Walters
★ 5
Fun place! Really good old fashioned
Source: Google
Felipe Faleco
★ 5
Source: Google
Terry Sullivan
★ 3
Source: Google
Nathan Wischnewski
★ 5
Wells Farm Patty melt.
So freaking good.
Source: Google
Barry Dean
★ 4
Best cheese curds I've ever had. Lots of snack options and great food. The cheddar spread is delicious!
Source: Google
Paul Bauer
★ 5
Da Bomb
Source: Google
Ralph Sordyl
★ 5
Great bartenders.
Source: Google
Tyler Slaymaker
★ 5
Source: Google
Colin Erskine
★ 3
This still is the busiest place to go when you're in town or downtown. The food is all right, the drinks were better than normal but it's "so people'y" up in there. Especially me being on crushes, I always felt like I was in the way of somebody.
Source: Google
Karen Knipfer
★ 5
Source: Google
Nicholas Sinn
★ 5
The Old Fashioned is a true Madison staple. The food and service are consistently reliable, and it’s one of the best places to experience classic Midwestern comfort food. The cheese curds are some of the best in town—crispy, melty, and always satisfying. Portion sizes are generous, making it a great spot whether you're sharing with friends or looking for a hearty solo meal. It’s the kind of place that feels familiar, even on your first visit.
Source: Google
Nathan Rhodes
★ 5
Great food and service. They had a BLT special with heirloom tomatoes that was beyond incredible.
Source: Google
Nasim Eshgarf
★ 5
Nice place in a great location with perfect, friendly staff. They were very helpful when we ordered. I had an amazing Old Fashioned, and honestly, I think I got the best onion rings of my life here!
It’s a must-try spot if you visit Madison. I highly recommend it!
Source: Google
Kristin Dvorsky
★ 5
Source: Google
Jessie Schmitz
★ 4
Source: Google
Owen Cushing
★ 5
Source: Google
Matt Lott
★ 5
Source: Google
Elif Bilal
★ 5
Their cheese curds and burgers were delicious, and the portions were big and more than enough for both myself and my friend. They have an awesome variety of beers as well, and the prices are great. The server was very nice and overall my experience was great. Highly recommended.
Source: Google
Amy
★ 1
We visited here during the farmers market so understood it was goin to be busy but the waitress we had was very inattentive to our table.
The food was flavorless except the cheese curds. We are cheese curd snobs, and these were amazing. Id say they were very, very good but not the best.
I got a burger-it was gross. It was supposed to have mayo on it and it didn't so I asked for some and got charged for it.
My kid got the pulled pork and it didn't taste like pork at all. Not sure what kid of meat it was.
The dr pepper was flat
The sugar bun was ok but hard as a rock
The waffle was ok but asked for stuff on the side and it came plain.
2 kids that ordered Tenders were charged for sauce that should have come with it.
Will probably not come back except to order curds
Source: Google
Kurtis Blake
★ 5
Old time bar with restaurant flair.
Source: Google
Ashley Stallings
★ 4
Our driver to the hotel was a local that recommended this place. Short walk to where we stayed, had everything on our list to want to try in Wisconsin, so we made the visit to The Old Fashion. Atmosphere was pub-like and host were friendly. We were sat upstairs where it was definitely a lot cooler in temp. Ordered cheese curds and poutine right away. We also tried out the classic old fashion was sweet and tasty. Altogether we ordered Mac and cheese, fried walleye and patty melt for our mains. Everything was okay. The cheese curds were salty and seemed like they may have been sitting so they didn’t have that cheesy effect I was expecting. I had the walleye (as pictured) not as good as I thought it would be. Bland in taste but my favorite of everything I ate were the fries. Considering the number of reviews and the fact that they’re well known for their cheese curds, I was rather disappointed in the visit. Had great company and glad I got to at least give this place a try.
Source: Google
Lester Miller
★ 5
Source: Google
Andrew Westbury
★ 5
We had a wonderful lunch at Old Fashioned. Ben was our server & could not have been nicer!! The food was unique for us because we are visiting Wisconsin from California. The cheese curds lived up to the reputation!! Location is nice and we sat outside with a view of the capital.
Source: Google
Bryan Johnson
★ 3
Probably the worst old fashioned I’ve ever had
Source: Google
Vicky Hopper
★ 5
The beef and cheese on the hamburger were so tasty! Loved the cheese curds.
Only downside is that they will lump in your order on one ticket, so if you have a group, be prepared.
Source: Google
Thomas Kraemer
★ 5
Knowledgeable waitress, honest and a straight shooter. No b's which is what I like. Food was pretty darn good.
Source: Google
Gabrielle Phillips
★ 4
Source: Google
Mallory Phillips
★ 5
Source: Google
Eric Cutler
★ 3
Cheese curds, yes. BBQ sampler, no thanks. 🧀🥩🍸
We stumbled across The Old Fashioned while spending the night in Madison and figured we’d give it a try. The place has a great vibe, and the cheese curds? Absolute perfection—crispy, gooey, everything you dream Wisconsin curds should be.
Then came the BBQ sampler plate… and that dream took a nosedive. The meat was so salty and overloaded with pepper that we couldn’t even finish it. Total letdown.
Cocktails were just okay—not bad, but definitely not memorable.
If you’re here, grab a beer, order the cheese curds, and maybe skip the BBQ unless you’re craving disappointment with a side of spice.
Source: Google
Bob Musser
★ 5
Great lunch. I had a tenderloin sandwich, and beer cheese soup. Donna had an heirloom tomato BLT, with house salad and loved it.
Source: Google
Ranger Ben
★ 5
Classic Wisconsin supper club food. I highly recommend this restaurant.
Source: Google
Karen Thorpe
★ 5
If you are visiting Madison, this restaurant bar is a must stop!
Source: Google
Paul Hines
★ 5
Must eat cheese curds! Great service!
Source: Google
Raman Pfaff
★ 5
I just popped in for a glass of wine. Very lively for lunchtime (most tables after used) but a few bar seats were available (which is all I wanted). Bartender was very nice and let me know about the history of the building. Decent wine selection for a mostly bar/beer sort of place. Lots of regulars were there chatting with staff, so clearly a good spot.
Source: Google
Dan Delk
★ 5
Good food, great Old Fashions!
Source: Google
Laurie Rolnick
★ 5
Wonderful celebration of all things Wisconsin! Great Korbel Old Fashioneds. Lovely local cherry salads, cheese curds, food and service was great. Highly recommend
Source: Google
Mr. Moxie
★ 5
Source: Google
Cory McClain
★ 5
Food - This place brags about the cheese curds, so we needed to first try them out. Did not disappoint. The batter had an almost slightly sweet flavor paired with the paprika dipping sauce, which was fantastic. Next, we ordered 2 old fashions. One was the cherry old fashioned with bourbon, and the second was a regular old fashioned with brandy. Perfectly done and very tasty. For the main, we had the chicken and biscuits, which was basically an inside-out pot pie. Biscuits were soft and buttery, and the chicken and vegetables were excellent. We also had the Ruben. It was piled high and one of the best I have had in some time. Meat was cooked perfectly, and the extra 1000 island sauce for dipping was nice.
Service - We didn't have reservations, so we sat at the bar. The bartender was very kind and was easily managing the crowd at the bar. There are 2 parts of the restaurant for seating, but it would be highly suggested to make a reservation no matter what.
Restaurant - Everything we saw was clean and maintained. Floors were taken care of, and the bar was not sticky. It is pretty cramped inside, mainly due to the popularity and wanting to get as many tables inside and available. Lots of old signs and pictures adorn the walls.
Overall - Great food, great drinks. Would visit again with some friends or family, we did see a few other dishes being brought out to other tables that looked amazing. Make reservations, we went an hour before closing, and it was still packed.
Source: Google
Karleen Wege
★ 5
our server was awesome 💖
Source: Google
Ernesto Soto
★ 5
Must visit spot if you are in Madison. Generous portions, great menu selections, classy atmosphere. I will definitely visit again when I return to Madison.
Source: Google
Tom Krueger
★ 2
Source: Google
Nicole Moore
★ 3
Source: Google
M Carrizales
★ 5
Source: Google
Donna Yannias
★ 5
Stopped in for a cocktail after walking the downtown area and was greeted by a friendly hostess. Great cold beer and great appetizers. We will be back!!
Source: Google
T S
★ 5
Excellent food, service and atmosphere.
Source: Google
Daine Pavloski
★ 5
Source: Google
Fatemeh F
★ 4
Famous for their burgers
Source: Google
Narendra Swamy
★ 4
Good meat fest food not poor option la for vegetarians.
Source: Google
Gary Kautz
★ 5
Absolutely fantastic. T-Rex deserves a raise. First timers, up from Illinois. We'll be back.
Source: Google
V Zach Bird
★ 5
Nice Bar
Source: Google
Logan Garvey
★ 5
Great food!
Source: Google
Brian Hardgrave
★ 5
Nice little place.. Stopped in and had a Grilled cheese with roasted red peppers.. SO tasty! Right across from the capitol building!
Source: Google
jeffrey macmillen
★ 5
Great atmosphere, staff , food $ cold beverages!
Source: Google
Mike Nichols
★ 1
Visitors beware… probably worst old fashioned I’ve ever had. Premixed old fashioned at hotel was better. Might want to consider a name change. Ordered cheese curds as an appetizer and was never asked if I wanted more food. Do better.
Source: Google
Mike Lawrence
★ 5
Great experience
Source: Google
Sean Keady
★ 5
Source: Google
HOWARD L SOFEN
★ 5
Excellent food
Source: Google
Laurel Hoog
★ 5
Good service and food.
Source: Google
Chas Ruby
★ 4
I give top marks for the food. We did wait a fair amount to get served, but a Phillip Seymore Hoffman type made sure we were well watched. The loud noise and crying babies were treats left for someone else. The Old Fashion burger was great. Also, along with the Old Fashion Burger, which was delicious
Was a plain salad that went quickly as it was so tasty. Old Fashion drinks were a little disappointing. The 2nd visit the drink was poor. I am extremely disappointed since that's their name. I had to take a star off their food review 😩 for this, but all the food was great.
Source: Google
Anna S
★ 5
Source: Google
Carole Giersch
★ 5
Source: Google
Marcin Baranowski
★ 5
Source: Google
Christina Russell
★ 5
Source: Google
Jeff W
★ 4
Food was pretty good. I got the Wisconsin fish fry and it was as expected. Fried fish. The cheese platter was awesome, highly recommend.
Source: Google
Lydia D
★ 5
We love the Old Fashioned! Their cheese curds are absolutely amazing. I like to pair them with a salad to balance them out. My husband loves their WI Old Fashions. Service is always fast and friendly.
Source: Google
Naz
★ 5
Yes! I had Old fashioned at the old fashioned 😁 everything was so good!
Source: Google