Thunder Bay Grille Pewaukee

Pewaukee, N14W24130 Tower Pl, Pewaukee, WI 53072 | ★ 4.2 (2555 Review)

📞 +1 262-523-4244

Last Search

Category

Grill American restaurant Bar & grill Brunch restaurant Catering food and drink supplier Restaurant Steak house Wine bar

Description

Thunder Bay Grille offers casual dining with an exceptional menu of top-notch steaks, fresh seafood, Cajun specialties, pasta, burgers, and more. Rustic décor and cozy fireplaces create a welcoming atmosphere, perfect for business or leisure. We also provide banquets and catering services, making us your destination for dining and events.

Photos

 Thunder Bay Grille Pewaukee
 Thunder Bay Grille Pewaukee
 Thunder Bay Grille Pewaukee
 Thunder Bay Grille Pewaukee
 Thunder Bay Grille Pewaukee
 Thunder Bay Grille Pewaukee
 Thunder Bay Grille Pewaukee
 Thunder Bay Grille Pewaukee
 Thunder Bay Grille Pewaukee
 Thunder Bay Grille Pewaukee
 Thunder Bay Grille Pewaukee

Leave a Review

Reviews

Debbie Podlesnik

★ 5

Source: Google

Keri Agnello

★ 5

Great food! I had the shrimp jambalaya, which may be spicy for some. Salad was crisp. I had the banana cheesecake, because I had never heard of it. It was nothing to brag about. Was there with a group of 25. Two servers were very attentive and did a great job keeping water glasses filled and dirty dishes cleared.

Source: Google

Marcus L

★ 4

I ordered the bison burger, it wasn't bad but it wasn't anything to write home about either. The cheese curds were light and crispy, the Chipotle raspberry sauce that came with it was surprisingly tasty. Salad bar offerings were good but we wished the rolls weren't left under a heat lamp, they were like hard rocks. Good lemonade and the dessert we shared was a delicious molten chocolate cake.
Our server was very nice and decently attentive despite how busy it suddenly shortly after we arrived.

Source: Google

Karen Brimley-Massey

★ 5

We had a family gathering for Sunday brunch.There were about 16 of us and they were very accommodating, without being pushy. The food was buffet style with prime rib, BBQ ribs, fried chicken, fish, Belgian waffles, made to order omelettes, etc..oh yeah and let's not forget the bottomless mimosas. 10 out of 10.

Source: Google

Kim Marie Vomberg

★ 5

Source: Google

Ezio

★ 5

Today I had an amazing dinner with Jessie as our server.She was one of the best server I've ever had, she helped so much with the menu and such and she had super nice banter, we talked about Kirby and clothing, and she was also very attentive, 10/10 server!!!

Source: Google

gary porth

★ 5

Source: Google

Jason Schreiber

★ 4

Source: Google

J L

★ 5

Excellent food, outstanding service

Source: Google

Marge Legwinski

★ 5

The charbroiled ribeye and the ribs were fabulous. French onion soup also extremely delicious. House made focacia bread was very tasty. Our server Shayna was very attentive and pleasant. Looking forward to coming back!

Source: Google

Joseph Fikejs

★ 4

Source: Google

Anonymous

★ 2

Amazing waitress, best food ever and I love the manager. The cheese curds ohhhhh gosh they’re too good. Will come here again!!
Edit 9-21-25: I don’t know what happened. This place used to be heavenly for food. You have to really mess up food for me to hate it. This is undoubtedly the worst food I’ve ever eaten. The ribs were still raw, the potatoes were dry, Mac and cheese was doused in butter, cheese casserole was good though, vegetable medley was good, milk was expired as I saw some dairy floating in it. Waiter was a Nice to my parents. I’m in utter disbelief. What happened?? New chefs that are terrible? Food was bad this time. Will return for my birthday dinner and see how it goes. Will make sure to edit in December. Only reason why I’m giving the review a 2 star is the waiter and manager are nice.

Source: Google

Brian Gillman

★ 5

Went for the brunch buffet. For the food you get, it was a little pricey. Still one of the better brunch buffet I have gone to. Staff was attentive, would go back again.

Source: Google

Lori Rosenberg

★ 5

Source: Google

Lacey Powell

★ 4

Source: Google

Cynthia Nelson

★ 4

We reserved one of the dining rooms for a party of 13. We were seated right away. We had two servers take our beverage orders as soon as our whole party was seated. We needed a little time to get our orders in. It was lunch. Half our party did salad/soup bar. Soup must be gotten from server rather than the salad bar A bit of a wait for the rest of our party who order sandwiches or entrees. Food was good, hot, tasty. Cost for lunch for good unless you choose higher priced full entrees such as steak, seafood. They did separate some of checks within our group, we were thankful for that convenience. Improved overall from our previous visits, will be back.

Source: Google

David Heinrich

★ 5

Source: Google

Judie Suleski

★ 5

It's been awhile since we were at Thunder Bay. We'll be back real soon, because the service was great. I had the fish fry and loved it. It included their huge salad bar. It also came with a choice of baked potato, fries, or mashed. And I was able to get half baked, and half fried. Both were delicious. The old fashioned's were good too.

Source: Google

SBR84

★ 5

Here visiting from our of town, had really good food along with great customer care thank you for the service

Source: Google

Christopher L

★ 5

Source: Google

Scott Hendrix

★ 5

Nice place with good seafood, steaks, burgers, and more. Ashley was our waitress and she was great. :-)

Source: Google

Greta

★ 4

Had a great dinner a few nights ago. Came on a weekday evening and was not busy compared to weekend service. Salad bar was fresh and well taken care of. Server was attentive. Ordered the half rack of ribs and nearly devoured them until I hit the last 2 bones and found a piece of plastic still on them. Besides this hiccup, the food did not taste bad and was still flavorful. We will return again!

Source: Google

Lottie Seaman

★ 5

Source: Google

Larry Jost

★ 5

Excellent food in a nice quiet well appointed setting. Service is friendly and relaxed. They have lots of seating and well appointed space.

Source: Google

Cheri Hoffman

★ 4

Source: Google

Melony Howard

★ 5

Source: Google

Bob Wylie

★ 4

Good food, service was a bit slow.

Source: Google

ted schuette

★ 5

Source: Google

A. Seiler

★ 3

There's nothing awful and nothing great about this place. The buffet is not worth it to me and the menu items aren't a great value but food was just ok

Source: Google

Margaret McGrath

★ 5

We held a rehearsal reception at this location on August 8. The manager Jay moved us to a larger room to accommodate our growing guest list to a private room at no charge. Layla our waitress was phenomenal! She provided fast service, handled special requests, checked with us hosts regularly and staggered the food perfectly as we asked. It was a fabulous experience all around!

Source: Google

S T

★ 3

I like their made to order food better.

Source: Google

Gracie F

★ 5

Very nice dining experience.

Source: Google

Rebekah McDonald

★ 5

Source: Google

Ronnie Rea

★ 5

Source: Google

Robyn Markelz

★ 1

Had the worst experience for lunch today. Waited an hour for two sandwiches on our lunch hour. Asked twice about food and still didn’t come out. Never got refill on drinks or an apology for the wait. This is the third time it’s happened to us. Is it’s not enough cooks or what the issue is.

Source: Google

Erik Nolte

★ 5

Source: Google

Krys Yacks

★ 5

The beef wellington was amazing. So was the mashed potatoes!!!!

Source: Google

Noel Latus

★ 4

The salad bar was awesome. The chicken sandwich was very over cooked.

Source: Google

Maureen Meer

★ 5

Great food and great salad bar. Beef Wellington is excellent.

Source: Google

huang ruixuan

★ 5

Nice service here — The food was also absolutely delicious and exceeded my expectations. I’ll definitely be coming back!

Source: Google

HDBob 357

★ 1

We eat out quite a bit as we travel. Haven't been back here in ~7 years. One thing, it was quiet, no patrons. WOW what a surprise, worst food experience in a LONG time. My steak could have showed the left rear on a work horse. My dad's steak, a filet, was 1 3/4 x 1 3/4 by 3/4" tall. Lots of money for, over well done, crap! Mother's dish was shrimp and noodles, this 10" plate full of noodles had 5, five, small shrimp. NEVER AGAIN!!!!

Source: Google

Jeremy Caffrey

★ 5

Great food! Great atmosphere!

Source: Google

Jason Kelley

★ 1

Crazy expensive for what you get. A Ceasar salad, fish fry and mushroom appetizer, no alcoholic beverages for 2 people was $100.

Source: Google

Kevin Quinn

★ 2

For our Wedding anniversary, my wife and I chose Thunder Bay Grille for dinner after reading various Net reviews. Despite all these reviews, we were very disappointed with the whole experience.
Upon arrival, we ordered drinks, which took "for ever" to arrive. The appertiser that we ordered (calamari) when finally delivered to our table was found to be an experience in eating "rubber bands" as they were way over-cooked and tough.
Next came the salad bar. In general it was good apart from some of the broccolli being "aged" to the point of being yellow, while another piece had brown rot at the base of the stalk. Definitely NOT GOOD.
When the entrees arrived, my wife's oven baked fish was almost stone cold, while the sweet potato fries appeared to have been prepared last week as they were well over-cooked to the point of some being patially burnt. My entree was fine.
Then it came to paying the bill! Our waitress had been very slow throughout the meal, but to get the bill, we had to call upon the busboy to see if he could find her to get our bill. We waited almost 15 minutes, despite the busboy returning promptly to advise that he had passed the message. The restaurant was definitely not busy, but seemingly short handed.
We will definitely not be back for more substandard food and service.

Source: Google

SadSaltyQueen

★ 3

Went there for a reservation at 7pm. We were stuck there until closes because service took forever. Got sat down, waited almost 30 min until asked what drinks, waited another 15 for said drinks, immediately put order in for food, waited for over an hour for food. Was there for 3 hours when it should've taken only 1.5 minimum for a dinner. Server seemed new and very flustered but was very kind. Will not be going back due to long service.

Source: Google

Joshua Bizub

★ 4

Hadn’t been here in about 10 years and decided to go back recently. Quite similar to how I remembered it. Food was good (but not over the top), service was a little slow and scattered but overall a nice experience. I do feel that for the price of the beef wellington it should’ve been a bigger portion size. Will likely be back in the future. Seems to be a great spot for family get together a.

Source: Google

L Susan F

★ 4

Source: Google

Courtney Jedele

★ 5

We went for their Sunday brunch. It was amazing! Their eggs weren't rubbery, everything was cooked to perfection, and the variety was amazing. The fried fish they had on the buffet was to die for. Best brunch buffet we've ever been to. Our waitress was wonderful too.

Source: Google

Strong Homecare & Companions

★ 2

I am writing to express my concern about an incident that occurred during my visit to your establishment on Sunday. I had hoped to enjoy the patio, but upon arrival, I encountered two large Rottweilers on the patio.

Not all customers are comfortable with pets, and having to dine in an environment where I feared for my safety was unacceptable. I inquired with an individual who appeared to be a manager about your pet policy, and she responded that it was "fine with her."

I believe that allowing such animals to freely roam in dining areas poses a significant risk to customer safety. It seems that the potential for someone to be bitten or seriously harmed is not being taken seriously. I urge you to reconsider your pet policy to prioritize the safety and comfort of all your patrons.

Source: Google

Lisa Orlowski

★ 5

Michael, our waiter was great.

Source: Google

Jeff Runa

★ 5

This place is awesome! The Sunday brunch is always great, with a wide selection of food (breakfast and lunch options), desserts and a fabulous salad bar. I usually go for here for lunch or dinner with several favorites on the menu. The servers are friendly and the atmosphere is not loud, easy to socialize.

Source: Google

William Jackson

★ 4

This place is great for a family or even for a couple. I like going here because of my family. You can sit and be able to talk to each other, not having people being too loud just being able to relax, and have a fantastic night. I wish there was more restaurants like this. Where people can be have a wonderful time

Source: Google

Debra Pritchard

★ 5

Great upscale experience! The restaurant was clean, spacious, and comfortable. The menu had many options available that were priced reasonably. We had the Friday Fish Fry. It included a large salad bar, all-you-can eat baked and fried cod. The food was amazing. Even the bread, tartar sauce, and ketchup tasted freshly made. The service was excellent. Our server, Jessie, was friendly, efficient, and very attentive. It was a great dining experience that I highly recommend.

Source: Google

Shontenee S

★ 4

Source: Google

Laura Poenitsch

★ 5

Great food, great atmosphere, the best service!!! We had a party of 20 and the service was spot on.

Source: Google

Megan Tylock

★ 5

Thunder Bay is a restaurant that my family goes to when we want a very special meal. They have a wonderful salad bar that my husband usually adds to his entree, and I like their lunch specials! They even have a list of kids meals and offer a mat to color on to give the kids something to do while they're waiting for their food. We would definitely recommend it!

Source: Google

Sharon Bubolz

★ 2

Service was extremely slow. So don't go if your hungry. Took forever to get our drinks and food. Upside food was very good.

Source: Google

DENNY GORDON

★ 5

FIRST TIME HERE.. BUFFET LOOKED AMAZING BUT PRETTY EXPENSIVE IF YOU'RE GONNA EAT ONLY ONE PLATE.. WE OPTED OUT OF BUFFET & HAD MEALS.. SHRIMP JAMBALAYA FOR HUBBY & THE 3 MEDALLIONS FOR MYSELF.. THE SAUCE WAS AMAZING THE ASPARAGUS WHILE SLIGHTLY COLD HAD A GREAT FLAVOR & SWEET POTATO FRIES...YUM.. MY HUBBY HAD TOMATO BISQUE SOUP & I HAD CREAMY POTATO & BACON.. BOTH VERY GOOD.. I LOVED MY POTATO SOUP NOT ONLY CUZ IT WAS VERY FLAVORFUL BUT BECAUSE THERE WERE ACTUAL CHUNKS OF POTATOES WITH THE SKIN ON THEM.. BEST PART.. WE WILL BE BACK TO TRY OTHER ITEM'S ON LIST.. SURE HOPE THEY GET KING CRAB LEGS IN & LOBSTER..

Source: Google

Amber Richmond

★ 5

Source: Google

T. Williams

★ 5

Source: Google

Eric W

★ 2

The host and server were fantastic unfortunately the food was not at the same level.

Source: Google

Chris Reece

★ 4

Source: Google

Janet Davis

★ 5

Source: Google

steven hines

★ 5

Good food decent prices and a lively yet cozy atmosphere

Source: Google

Sarah Shagam

★ 3

The staff was amazing. The food was not. My scallops had sand in them, making for an unpleasant dining experience. The risotto was bland, the crab cakes were excessively salty, and the Parmesan crust on the filet medallion overpowered the powerfully cooked pieces of meat. The price was high for a mediocre meal.

Source: Google

Donnie Brown

★ 5

Amazing location. Food was delicious. Portions match the price. The fish was top tier.

Source: Google

Yvonne Cummings

★ 5

The food has always been excellent. There was just once after being seated that no one waited on us for about 10-15 minutes.

Source: Google

Ms. Ratliffe

★ 3

Source: Google

Mike Nichols

★ 4

Source: Google

Lou Hernandez

★ 3

Source: Google

David Stuck

★ 5

Source: Google

Lavern Ehlert

★ 4

Stopped for a beer and aps. After a funeral pleasant staff and good apistierrs

Source: Google

Tanya Dacquisto-Balfanz

★ 5

I have been here several times and have always had a wonderful experience. The atmosphere is calming, the staff is friendly, and the food is wonderful. They also offer a very large salad bar for meal or added on for an extra price.

Source: Google

Chris Lokken

★ 5

Source: Google

Adam Pouchert

★ 4

Sunday brunch buffet is good but can be crowded and a bit expensive

Source: Google

Ms. M.R. Jones

★ 4

Went with family for Mother's Day brunch, the food was okay, service was good and atmosphere was good.

Source: Google

Nick Podushak

★ 3

Food was okay but I'm tired of eating crappy foul french fries. On a $30 per person meal can anybody make french fries that actually taste like potatoes. Do you use the cheapest lowest price frozen crappy french fries from your cheapest vendor you can find?
I'll bet the answer is yes!

Source: Google

Toni Seydel

★ 4

Source: Google

Kris Jackson

★ 4

Source: Google

Scott Wilson

★ 4

Source: Google

Benjamin Park

★ 3

Source: Google

Jerry Garcia

★ 5

Great salad bar. Awesome place to take family on Mother's day!

Source: Google

Rose F

★ 5

We were here for Mother's Day brunch and it was just lovely.

Source: Google

Amy Reid

★ 5

Wonderful food and server I can’t tell you how friendly and kind our server Kelly was… makes sure we had everything we needed and was always cleaning away the dirty plates. Food was fresh and the whole staff is amazing.

Source: Google

Evan Ferree

★ 5

These guys killed it for Mother's Day. They did an excellent job of continually stocking high quality food the entire time we were there. Great work.

Source: Google

Mackenzie Brenaman

★ 5

kelly is the best!

Source: Google

Brett Christian

★ 5

Kelly was amazing for Mother’s Day! Great brunch!

Source: Google

Amanda Christian

★ 5

Here for Mother’s Day brunch and everything was amazing. Kelly was our server and she was so good with all the kids and was very quick with refills on beverages. Thank you for everything!

Source: Google

Christina Wolfgramm

★ 5

Ordered the Salmon Fresca. Delicious! Everything down to the bread was phenomenal.

Source: Google

Joanne Chaput

★ 5

Source: Google

Aaron DeVore

★ 5

I had a late night dinner here. The food was good, and the service was a bit rushed, but not so rushed as to be annoying. I would go back.

Source: Google

Kurt McDowell

★ 5

Source: Google

Deeann Leda

★ 5

Source: Google

Anthony Prater

★ 5

Source: Google

Don Bebee

★ 5

Just great but a bit pricey.

Source: Google

Jean Nohr

★ 5

Source: Google

Melissa J

★ 5

Awesome salad bar!

Source: Google

Kathleen Anderson

★ 5

Source: Google

Cameron Vetter

★ 4

It's a decent generic American food restaurant, nothing special but nothing great

Source: Google

Nels Huse

★ 5

Source: Google

Craig & Bernice

★ 1

Never seen a prime rib look like this! Disappointed

Source: Google

Brandy S.

★ 4

Source: Google

Pam Markulin-Schweitzer

★ 5

The servers were friendly and knowledgeable. Food was great, salad bar was well-stocked and the atmosphere was welcoming. Upper-end dining.

Source: Google

Gypsi Kernats

★ 3

My burger was Luke warm, the calamari were rubbery, overcooked and cool when they came to the table. Our servers were wonderful. We had a large party. They were attentive. I just was NOT happy with the food. The creme brulee tasted like pudding. They've done better!

Source: Google

Latisha Carter

★ 5

Source: Google

Leia Oliveira

★ 5

Source: Google

Bernie Dunne

★ 5

Nice place, we just had drinks, but food looked good that others got next to us. Will try sometime

Source: Google

Justin Grooms

★ 5

This place just keeps getting better and better. It's been fun to watch them grow over the years. Especially lately, they just seem to have really kicked their food and service up a few notches.

Source: Google

Victoria F

★ 4

Source: Google

Greg Anderson

★ 4

Source: Google

Phil B

★ 3

Source: Google

Bryan Hintz

★ 5

Thunder Bay Grill has the best salad bar in town. I don’t know of another place in town that has the variety they do on their salad bar. One of my favorite places for lunch in the greater Milwaukee Area.

Source: Google

Fred Neve

★ 4

Source: Google

Kimberly Labinski

★ 5

We held my nieces wedding shower there. Everyone commented on what a nice place it was and how good the food was! The gal that served our drinks was so sweet and accommodating. It was truly a wonderful experience, and I would recommend it to others.

Source: Google

Doug Hoffman

★ 5

Excellent dinner. The beef wellington is absolutely the best. Not seen too often, as it takes care to prepare properly. Others had the filet mignon. Great cuts. Baked potatoes huge and just right. Also had the baked vegetables. Excellent meal and service.

Source: Google

Maria Ulrich

★ 4

Source: Google

Andy Weber

★ 5

Been here many times through the years.
The food, service and atmosphere have always been great !! Steaks have always been done to perfection. Deserts are told made in house and never disappoint !!

Source: Google

Kathy Nichols

★ 5

Source: Google

George Bowman

★ 5

Source: Google

Elaine Laverenz

★ 5

Source: Google

Patricia

★ 5

Source: Google

Common Sense

★ 2

I attended the Mardi Gras buffet. It was subpar. There was not much to the buffet, at least not what was listed on the menu. The main problem was that the buffet was constantly either empty of items like the catfish, shrimp & and grits, and the corn bread. I arrived at 5:30 and the beignets were gone by 6:00 and never replenished. If you wanted frogs legs, you had to request them, which was not mentioned to us by the waitress it was the same for the desserts. If you didn't request the banana's fosted it was not offered. The food, as I mentioned, was favorable it was nicely spiced. The waitress was just ok, after she was paid the check she was never seen again. I did learn one thing from this buffet, and it's that I will never attend another. There was an individual moving from station sampling each and every dish, and they wonder why diseases spread so easily.

Source: Google

Meg Clare

★ 5

After a mishap with a reservation at a different restaurant, my husband and I decided to go to Thunder Bay, as it was on our way home. It was a Saturday night around 6:00, and there was surprisingly no wait. We were sat in a large room with only a couple other occupied tables, which was very nice to be able to have a conversation and hear one another. Shortly after being seated, our server, Shayna, welcomed us. From the moment she introduced herself, she was amazing. We ordered the crab cake appetizer, which was delicious. My husband ordered the prime rib, and I ordered the filet medallions. Shayna also brought us a HUGE basket of focaccia bread right out of the oven. Both of our mains were cooked to perfection. Unfortunately, with all of the wonderful food, we didn’t have room for dessert. It’ll definitely be something we plan for next time. It’s been YEARS since we had been to Thunder Bay, but we will be returning soon and hopefully request Shayna again. She was absolutely stellar. I don’t review places often, but the food was worth a few minutes of time, and I want to make sure the managers are aware of how wonderful Shayna was and that she truly took such amazing care of us!!

Source: Google

Dawn

★ 1

Went for a Birthday lunch. Was seated in the back of a rather quiet restaurant. Was told server would be right with us, after sitting over 10 minutes and no one coming we walked out.

Source: Google

Greyling Naughton

★ 5

Source: Google

Bob Wallner

★ 5

Outstanding. Salad bar was super fresh

Source: Google

Carolina Schulz

★ 5

Recently, we had a business meeting at Thunder Bay Grille. The details were handled very professionally by the manager, Laura, and I was very impressed by the elegance of our room and the efficiency of our waiter, Willow, who arranged everything according to our specifications. He was attentive to our group so that we could have an efficient and comfortable meeting and a delicious lunch. Being multilingual, Willow was able to converse with several of the members who are from other countries such as Spain, France, Germany, and Italy. I highly recommend the facilities at Thunder Bay Grille for a comfortable business meeting. The service was amazing. In the future, I will plan on having our meetings again at Thunder Bay Grille.

Source: Google

Amy Forsberg

★ 5

Jerri is our favorite server, so sweet and very attentive!

Source: Google

Javier Hernandez

★ 5

Source: Google

Kelly Brunmeier

★ 5

Best bread I've ever had.
Our waitress was a it slow on helping us. I had to flag her down once we got our food she disappeared. we were waiting to get our bill for a long time, guess we are just fast eaters.

Source: Google

Bruce Waddell

★ 4

The food was great and the menu is nice. We had a business lunch including a Philly cheese steak sandwich.

Source: Google

Andrea Islas

★ 5

Came for a business lunch. Sat immediately and service was prompt. Had the salmon which was delicious.

Source: Google

Harleen Mann

★ 3

Source: Google

Tasha

★ 3

Ok

Source: Google

Erin Ellefson

★ 5

Had our daughter's college graduation dinner here. From the planning, to the staff, to the wonderful food and atmosphere, everything was wonderful. It was the perfect venue for our small gathering and we were so thankful for the staff for making it a great evening of celebration!

Source: Google

Sarayut Hemkamonphan

★ 5

Source: Google

Bill Fontanazza

★ 5

Source: Google

Matt McC

★ 3

Nice place and service is great but the food was not much better than Texas Roadhouse just more expensive $58 steak and mashed potatoes just way too much money for the quality

Source: Google

Alexandria Hilgart

★ 1

Waiter added charges to my card! Tried this place for the first time this past weekend with my sister. Food was ok. I tipped generously in cash but waiter still decided to give himself a 50% tip on my card! His name is Willow.

Source: Google

C G

★ 4

Great food and nice atmosphere.

Source: Google

J. D

★ 3

Kinda gone downhill. Went for the all you can eat fish fry. I was there years ago and looked forward to coming back. They changed the fish. Not the thick subs of cod for the broiled and not the buttery beer batter on the fried. Would not serve it family style like they did in the past, too. It was good, but not memorable.

Source: Google

Eric Hilgendorf

★ 5

Met a friend there on a first date. The waitress sat us right in front of the fire. Really nice. The food was delicious, service was excellent. And it wasn't busy, so they didn't mind us sitting at the table for a while.

Source: Google

George W.

★ 5

We always have a good experience here.

Source: Google

Dr Ron Campopiano

★ 5

Overall - great on all three accounts. Fast, friendly, clean, great inside setting and everyone's food was hot, tasty and cooked well.

Source: Google

Deb Northrup

★ 5

Delicious Food and Friendly and Clean!

Source: Google

Dan Wech

★ 5

Nice Sunday brunch.

Source: Google

Brittany Elizabeth

★ 4

We had a large party and the service unfortunately was not the greatest. Didn't really clear the table of any dirty dishes. Didn't come back to check on us. Forgot to come back with extra glass of wine for people in party. Overall, the food was ok but nothing I would say I'd crave to return again.

Source: Google

Heather Roozee

★ 5

Source: Google

Mandy Wienke

★ 4

I can only speak for the Sunday brunch experience. We were really excited to be able to go for a brunch since I usually work on Sundays. The brunch does not come with beverages, they are additional. The freshly made omelets were the star of the brunch. The food in the warmers were usually warm enough but there were several items that were cold by the time you got back to your table. The salad area was fantastic and the service was great and your table was cleaned off constantly. I would have to say the worst part about the whole experience was the bathrooms. They were terrible for a restaurant of that quality.You expect clean restrooms?Not only were they not clean they had two stalls out of order.

Source: Google

Kyle Wendtland

★ 4

Food was good. Service was good. Air was chilly.

Source: Google

Robert Davidson

★ 5

Source: Google

Jessie Wimber

★ 5

Brunch buffet is amazing. Had something for everyone

Source: Google

E Will

★ 4

Does any know who this kid is? See photos posted on 12/21/24. He tried breaking into our vehicle last night. #CyberTruck #Pewaukee #Waukesha #ThunderBayGrille #Cyberpunk

Source: Google

Donna Langham

★ 5

Brunch is amazing.

Source: Google

Kurt Owens

★ 4

Source: Google

Cathi Gallagher

★ 5

Source: Google

Karen Kirkpatrick

★ 5

Source: Google

Davina Anderson

★ 5

Source: Google

Bingo Emmons

★ 5

Nice service!

Source: Google

E L

★ 5

Source: Google

angela Wiklin

★ 4

Source: Google

Michael Schony

★ 2

Parking lot full? Better find another place to eat....must have had parties.....dining room not full...slow slow slow....finally took our food to go. Not sure how food was....will eat it tomorrow. Always my spot to take out of town guests...how embarrassing. Ugh.

Source: Google

Netty Ziegler

★ 5

There were 19 ladies and we were there for the buffet. The food was fabulous! The service was GREAT! I cannot wait to come back!!!! Highly recommended!!!

Source: Google

Rick

★ 5

Source: Google

Dani Garcia

★ 5

Source: Google

JL P

★ 4

Source: Google

Terry J Bacon II

★ 5

Went there for Thanksgiving dinner and the buffet was awesome the service and atmosphere was excellent

Source: Google

Sara Elmer

★ 5

My family and I have been here many times for holiday dinners, and we will continue coming back!

Source: Google

LR

★ 5

Source: Google

Beth Schmitt

★ 5

Best salad bar around! Awesome soup choices. Superb carrot cake, the atmosphere is really relaxing. Roomy even when parking lot is full.

Source: Google

Leah Smith

★ 1

I couldn't give any stars for the food because we never got any. We were sat and waited 25 minutes for drinks. We were there to celebrate a birthday.

Our server was incredibly terrible. She brought us beer in a can like we were at a dive bar. For those prices, I'd expect the service to be on par with the fancy cost. She wasn't nice, or easy to talk to. Waiting that long for a drink was a sign that the rest of dinner would have been just as bad.

When we asked if we could just get the check for our drinks and leave, she said "Are you going to drink them?" Uh, what? We want to pay, we want to leave. The end. We won't be back.

Service needs to step up to the prices. You have a couple of amazing servers, you know who they are. Overhaul the front of house, and let me know when we can come back.

Source: Google

Scott Golimowski

★ 2

Atmosphere is nice. Should have got the salad bar. Had the meatloaf instead. It was overcooked and had pepper in it that made your mouth burn!! Ththehad some weird vegetable that was impossible to eat!! It was hard. Service was hit or miss. Being forgetful with things.

Source: Google

Brandon Barnes

★ 1

The food is fine, maybe a bit ambitious and a little overpriced. Service is very inconsistent, there are 3-4 servers that do a good job, but if you don't get one of them, you're going to have a horrible time. Like 20 mins for drinks kind of bad. We had been going here fairly regularly for about 6 years, but after to many bad visits, we will not be back.

Source: Google

Kathy Pica

★ 5

I was at a special event seminar. The food was excellant. Service great, too.

Source: Google

Michael Gumpert

★ 5

What a great place for beverages and great food!

Source: Google

Joe Tomter

★ 5

Good staple

Source: Google

Marie Hanrahan-Fox

★ 4

Source: Google

Robert Fourn

★ 5

Source: Google

Joe Stockinger

★ 4

Source: Google

Josh Kennedy

★ 4

Source: Google

Ken Walter

★ 5

Source: Google

Jose Velasquez

★ 5

A must stop for the cheese curds. If there is one thing Wisconsin knows, it's the CHEESE. The Rib was amazing, but the Bison burger fell short. Even tho the burger was not all that great, the rest of the food made up for it. That's why I still gave it a 5⭐️ rating on the food.

Source: Google

Jason Marsh

★ 5

Source: Google

Mary

★ 4

Source: Google

V L (Sussex)

★ 5

Been there several times, recently. Always moderately busy, but almost never a wait.

Food always arrives hot and prepared as expected. They have never made a mistake on an order (that I can recall).

It is not "cheap" but that's a good thing. Portions are generous. Items are freshly cooked; not sitting and waiting.

Servers have been friendly, engaging, and almost always know the menu better than we do. No fault intended; sometimes people are in training, but still do a very good job of handling customers.

Source: Google

John Are

★ 5

Source: Google

Donna Roeber

★ 5

We were there for a birthday party & everything was great. We were a party of 17. The food came out all together. It tasted great. Service was excellent.

Source: Google

Karen Boyle

★ 5

I had the Salmon Alfredo and it was amazing. Shannon was the server and she did a wonderful job as well as the atmosphere. A great place to go and relax.

Source: Google

Thomas D

★ 5

Brunch buffet runs until 2. Just as good as before the pandemic.

Source: Google

Beth Mortl

★ 4

Source: Google

Renae Grill

★ 4

Source: Google

Craig Berentsen

★ 3

Source: Google

Kurt Schummer

★ 5

Held a seminar here. Service was fantastic. Guests were extremely complimentary of the food. Great space & atmosphere.

Source: Google

Andrew Kletzien

★ 3

Service was great, but nothing was seasoned. Calamari, cheese curds, and fish & chips all tasted the exact same, incredibly bland. French onion soup was good, mashed potatoes were good, and shrimp was good. Salad bar was solid.

Source: Google

Kenneth Kosek

★ 3

Food is expensive

Source: Google

Elizabeth Hathaway

★ 4

Source: Google

Laura Mikow

★ 3

We were a large group gathering after a funeral. They had only one server to take care of about 25 people. So, service was glacial. I'm not impressed.

Source: Google

Devan Kapke

★ 5

Peter was absolutely great with the service tonight! He checked in from time to time (and thankfully not mid bite like most servers do) and was super friendly! Also, the kitchen staff prepared everything perfectly! We will absolutely be back, and thank you for making our date night special!

Source: Google

Jeff Rydberg

★ 2

Source: Google

Jeffrey Wagner

★ 5

If you are in the area Thunder Bay Grille is a must stop for lunch or dinner or even brunch on a Sunday. Service was amazing, and food options are plentiful.

Source: Google