Zaffiro's Pizza The Original

Milwaukee, 1724 N Farwell Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202, United States | ★ 4.5 (1514 Review)

📞 +1 414-289-8776

Last Search

Category

Pizza restaurant Italian restaurant Restaurant

Description

Craving a truly authentic Milwaukee pizza experience? Look no further than Zaffiro's Pizza The Original! Nestled on North Farwell Avenue, this beloved restaurant offers a taste of tradition with every slice. Step inside and discover why Zaffiro's has become a local institution, serving up delicious pizzas that keep generations coming back for more. Visit us and savor the flavor that made us famous.

(All Togo orders and deliveries must be placed by calling us directly on the telephone. We do not associate with any delivery websites or online ordering)!

Photos

 Zaffiro's Pizza The Original
 Zaffiro's Pizza The Original
 Zaffiro's Pizza The Original
 Zaffiro's Pizza The Original
 Zaffiro's Pizza The Original
 Zaffiro's Pizza The Original
 Zaffiro's Pizza The Original
 Zaffiro's Pizza The Original
 Zaffiro's Pizza The Original
 Zaffiro's Pizza The Original

Leave a Review

Reviews

Jim harvey

★ 5

Came to Milwaukee from England to see the Alan Jackson concert at the Fiserv forum.
Bit of research and Zaffiros was clearly the place for dinner.
Yes, yes and yes was the answer.
Cool old fashioned bar/restaurant
Cool old fashioned service
Freaking awesome food

Source: Google

Antonio

★ 5

Source: Google

Dylan M

★ 5

First time on Friday nite. Delicious. Will be returning.

Source: Google

ronald krygsman

★ 5

Source: Google

James Petraski

★ 1

4th generation pizza place, hoping it is the last generation!
Worst pizza I've ever paid $22 for, never again. Crust like cardboard. Not impressed. Usually hole in the wall old Italian restaurants are the best, NOT this one!

Source: Google

Joel Estrada

★ 5

Best veggie pizza ever, extremely thin crust, extremely delicious, very good ambiance, recommended.

Source: Google

Hank Kollross

★ 2

The bartender and host last Saturday were so rude that we almost left. This place use to be a steady MKE classic. The pizza is always good (though isn't like it use to be). The vibe has not changed, literally stuck in the past, but that's ok. The bartender and host treated everyone like total crap. They weren't busy, they were just stuck up jerks to every person in our group and others at the bar. The customers were actually talking amongst ourselves about the chips on their shoulders. - We'll never go back, nor will the new people who we brought for their first time.

Source: Google

Tony Berger

★ 5

I might be willing to fight you if you claim to know a better pizza in MKE! Hell, I started my bachelor party here 23 years ago! As great as it is for take out, and it is, it's a thousand times better on site!

Source: Google

Kurt

★ 5

Timeless mom and pop pizza place that takes you back to 1950.

Source: Google

Ali Abedi

★ 5

Crust was so thin that totally eliminates the guilt associated with having pizza. Veggies were fresh crisp and the Italian touch just cap it off. Healthy low cal and a different pizza experience in heart of MKE, even lactose intolerant folks can have it, as the cheese is very minimal.

Source: Google

Tom Mourafetis

★ 5

Top notch thin crust !

Source: Google

Kelly Scott

★ 5

Classic old school Italian joint. The pizza is out of this world great! Vibe is just classic, like you stepped back into the 50s. Staff are great and attentive to customers needs. Worth the trip for sure.

Source: Google

Len

★ 3

Pizza is great...but, it is pretty expensive for what you get. Price is where my rating takes a hit.

Source: Google

Mike Watson

★ 4

The pizza was good, but not as crispy as I was expecting. I’ll give it another try another day.

Source: Google

Jessica Goldstein

★ 5

From the outside, you’d never expect much, but stepping inside feels like walking into a cozy little tavern that’s full of character. It has that classic, welcoming vibe where you instantly feel comfortable. The pizza was exactly what you’d hope for from a tavern-style spot — thin crust, cut into perfect pieces,and absolutely delicious. We’re from New Jersey, so we’ve had our fair share of great pizza, and I can honestly say this was really, really good. A hidden gem worth finding!

Source: Google

Esha Sharma

★ 5

Amazing pizza

Source: Google

John Patrick

★ 4

Pretty good pizza and good service.

Source: Google

Steven Lechter

★ 5

Source: Google

Michael Anderson

★ 5

Source: Google

Matt Ryan

★ 5

Source: Google

Amber

★ 5

Great food, great service nice place overall.

Source: Google

Tyrone Leazer

★ 5

Delicious pizza, great service

Source: Google

Nayele Garcia

★ 1

Source: Google

mark stewart

★ 5

This is a classic Milwaukee tavern and pizza joint. It’s not fancy, but it’s welcoming and the thin crust pizza is off the hook! They do a lot of take out so cook times can run a bit long. Worth it.

Source: Google

Ron Quimby

★ 5

I stopped for pickup and was very pleased with the service, the pizza and the employees who I interacted with during my wait. A no frills, old fashioned atmosphere (In a good way). Next time will definitely try dining in. A thin crust pizza with very generous toppings.

Source: Google

S Work

★ 5

Definitely a great place to try Milwaukee style pizza.. thin crispy crust.. The Everything Pizza was great; the size of the pizza and the amount of toppings were fair for the price. The bartenders and waiters were attentive and friendly. Only negative the bathroom situation was awkward (not really a designated bathroom area just toilets and a urinal with a sink outside). Parking was out in the street but I think there is parking behind the building to the east. Don't park to the north/ beside the building you could get towed.

Source: Google

Team Fil-Am Vlogs

★ 5

Best pizza in the City .

Source: Google

Bryan Simkus

★ 5

The first bite wasn’t just pizza—it was a cosmic handshake between my taste buds and the divine.

Source: Google

Wendee Brungardt

★ 5

We were told by a local to go here and have their authentic pizza. We are so glad we did because it was so delicious. The pizza is very thin and slightly crispy. They put a nice marinara on it and really good Italian sausage. For 2 people, we shared the large.

The service was very kind, although when we walked in we asked if it was ok to park in the lot by the restaurant and we practically got yelled at by the guy behind the bar. It was odd. We aren't from there and there wasn't any good signs to show where we should it shouldn't park. It definitely wasn't a way to be greeted and had the local not told us to go there, we would have just left.

The atmosphere is outdated and run down but that didn't bother us, made it more authentic. I highly suggest going here for lunch and getting any of their pizzas. So delicious and very affordable.

Source: Google

Andrew Burke

★ 5

Definitely lives up to the reviews. Thinnest crust I've ever seen on a pizza in my life, and it's perfectly crispy. Loaded with toppings. I might have to drive the 6 hours from my house just to come back here.

Source: Google

Dan Hathorn

★ 1

If I could list zero stars I would!

Website listed three sizes of pizza, 10”,12”,14”. I ordered 2 x 14” for delivery at 315 to be delivered “whenever the delivery guy shows up”. The young gal on the phone had no clue about anything on the menu and certainly didn’t think far enough in advance that asking someone of higher authority would be the best solution, just kept saying “I don’t know”.

Pizza showed up in decent fashion, and we paid cash. Upon opening the boxes it was discovered the pizza was 2 x 12” not 14”. Called the store and was met with the manager who flatly declared that “I cooked 14” and that’s that”. So I took pictures and measured….you’re clearly robbing people on sizes by charging more for larger sizes and giving them smaller.

Source: Google

Will Kipp

★ 5

Will plan on coming back in the future great food and atmosphere a true Milwaukee staple

Source: Google

Rachel O'brien

★ 1

Source: Google

Raymond Slisz

★ 5

Popular place! Great pizza! Thinnest pizza crust ever!! Generous toppings!!

Source: Google

Heidi H

★ 5

The restaurant is clean! The food was absolutely delicious! My pizza honestly was incredible. The service was kind and friendly. I really recommend this place. Honestly best pizza in Milwaukee

Source: Google

Jason Williams

★ 5

Unfortunately I now live in California and do not get to go to Zaffiro’s. But when I’m back home it’s the first restaurant I go to. I promise you you will not be disappointed with their food.

Source: Google

Mark Jonas

★ 5

Great pizza

Source: Google

James Schwetz

★ 5

Very good pizza

Source: Google

Kyle Ketelhut

★ 5

Great Staff, perfect atmosphere,delicious Milwaukee style Pizza

Source: Google

Daniel Bishop

★ 5

Best in city !!

Source: Google

Caroline S

★ 5

First time visiting- pizza was cooked perfectly. Wait time was minimal and service was great!

Source: Google

Andrea Dello Russo

★ 5

Pizza is like the thinnest crust ever but it is amaaaaaazing!!! Crowded and the servers still did a great job!

Source: Google

Martin King

★ 5

Try the Bloody Mary, the pizza is the best in Milwaukee.

Source: Google

Tim Burns

★ 5

Source: Google

Alicia

★ 5

Source: Google

Janet Cole

★ 5

Great old time tavern in lower East Side! Great thin crust pizza! Lots of old timers there! 😆

Source: Google

Instructions Not Included

★ 4

Just one thought and I wish I had been asked about the order. Milwaukee is known for its thin pizza and I love NY Style Pizza. So I got what I did not want but still was a great pizza. So it's just a complaint but all in all was great.

Source: Google

Adam Oldakowski

★ 5

Source: Google

Kristy O'Connor

★ 5

Source: Google

Michael

★ 5

Source: Google

John Hoffman

★ 5

Source: Google

Patty Meyer

★ 5

Source: Google

Righton

★ 5

I am very happy with how I’ve been treated very good people here!! Hard earned money well spent. want be disappointed nice family spot…Remy~

Source: Google

Hurley Wilbourne

★ 5

Source: Google

Bill Meek

★ 5

Awesome pizza and great help in there

Source: Google

Héctor Betances

★ 2

Source: Google

tim revis

★ 5

Source: Google

Patti Piotrowski

★ 5

Best Pizza in town!!!

Source: Google

Benjamin D

★ 5

Great thin crust pizza

Source: Google

Anton Iljazi

★ 1

The service was ok, but I waited almost a hour for my pizza. When I got it the edges were burnt and left a very bad aftertaste. After a few hours I started to feel sick and puked multiple times. This was the only meal I ate going in as well and it turns out I got food poisoning! Don’t recommend to anyone.

Source: Google

William Okon

★ 4

Nicky is best. Made for a great evening dinner.
Thanks Nick !

Source: Google

Liz

★ 2

Was so looking forward to coming in for a great pizza however it was bad. Too spicy hot like someone poured salt and pepper all over it. We could barely eat it. Waitress did not come by our table until we were ready to go so I had no refill on my drink and we couldn’t address our concerns about the spicy flavor that we never had before. It wasn’t just the sausage that was spicy it was the entire pizza. We were there at 4:00 so it wasn’t busy yet so there were no excuses for the lack of attention from our server. Oh well. We won’t come back.

Source: Google

Lisa Ennis

★ 3

Cut your round pizza in triangles!!! No one cuts a round pizza in squares!! It's just wrong.

Source: Google

Omayra Nieves

★ 4

Source: Google

Brian Cummings

★ 5

Source: Google

Julie A

★ 5

Favorite 😍

Source: Google

Dave Blanchard

★ 5

The OG of Milwaukee pizza on the east side, this original Zafirro's location is my favorite. With red and white checkered table cloths, house chianti in a carafe and the best thin crust pizza in town, one cannot go wrong stopping in this quaint little spot.

Source: Google

Dante Scaffidi

★ 1

Horrible quality since deal change.
Pizza tastes different, and server was trying to charge me for soda refills. Pizza was disgusting compared to when we went on my birthday.

Source: Google

AJ Hamedi, DDS

★ 5

Great Pizza!

Source: Google

Oliver Gastelum Jr

★ 1

The host and waitress are so terrible. Check please. I'm out.
Hopefully the food is good

Source: Google

g gerl

★ 4

Good lunch specials. Doable whole personal pie. Expected more or a crunchy cracker crust but wasn't much at all, nice very thin but not very crispy. Decent ranch

Source: Google

Johnny Glover

★ 5

Source: Google

andrew ilecki

★ 5

Source: Google

Andrew Ish

★ 5

This is my favorite pizza place in Milwaukee! The thin crust is perfectly crispy, and the sauce is delicious and flavorful. Always a great experience.

Source: Google

Eileen Beckert

★ 5

The pizza is very unusual with a super thin crust, so you can really taste the ingredients. Service was excellent making sure we had everything we needed at all times and also went out of her way to take a family photo so all of us could be included. This was a one day visit to Mileaukee and I understand it is one of the few places open on Mondays!

Source: Google

Deb Miller

★ 5

In my humble opinion this is the very best pizza I have ever had. The cracker crust is unlike anything I've ever had before. My husband and I live in Waukesha and try to go once a month. I always recommend it to anyone who asks. Great old school restaurant.

Source: Google

Ben Middleton

★ 5

AMAZING PIZZA!!! Can't beat it! Thin crispy crust,solid sausage with a sweet sauce. Good service,nice people. The only bad thing is parking. Hard to find a place to park. Otherwise, its great!

Source: Google

Wisconsin Massage Clinic

★ 5

Source: Google

George Gomez

★ 5

Been a Favorite of mine for 55 years. Love those guys.

Source: Google

Jeff Herrem

★ 4

we love going here the pizza has been excellent everytime as well as the staff and the whole
place overall is great. but we ordered garlic bread this most recent time and it was the most horrendous piece of food i have ever eaten. not cooked at all and just covered with seasoning that tasted like 20 cigarette butts we're zested over it.

Source: Google

Dena Castellanos

★ 5

We are from Indiana and came to Milwaukee for a visit. The pizza at Zaffiro's was phenomenal! Our son (9 yo) is a picky eater usually but he went down on the pizza. He also said the pizza was "marvelous"! Lol The staff was super friendly (Nicki was awesome)! If/when we come back to Milwaukee, we will definitely hit up Zaffiro's again!!

Source: Google

S. Krug

★ 4

Ordered a large pizza with sausage mushrooms and artichoke. Sauce very good, other ingredients tasty and good balance. Mushrooms fresh or canned, so if u prefer former make sure to ask. Zaffiros crust often comes a bit overdone. I don't know if this can be addressed when ordering. Pickup staff well organized and friendly.

Source: Google

Linda Bullox

★ 3

Pizza has a great taste but not enough sausage for me. The sausage topping was very sparse and should have had larger pieces.

Source: Google

Ashley Carter

★ 4

They have the best pizza on the Eastside to me. I love the thin crispy crust and the toppings...Took a little longer than expected, though

Source: Google

George Petz

★ 5

The people that are "Zaffiro's" treated me, a first time customer, like I've been coming there for years. Very friendly and very though on everything including their very good Pizza. I almost forgot, the price was also very good. Thank You

Source: Google

Mary Ann Ciardo

★ 5

There on Friday. Every but as good as when I first became a customer in 1978. Service, food abd orices wonderful.❤

Source: Google

Omar Santibanez

★ 4

I came in here after escaping a Korean spot that served me what I can only describe as soy sauce sadness. I was down bad and just looking for comfort food that wouldn’t hurt me. First thing to hit the table? The garlic and cheesy bread. I was hopeful. Hungry. Vulnerable. And then, boom! Betrayal. The bread was dry. The garlic was missing like it owed someone money. The cheese? It was barely hanging on, like it didn’t even want to be there. I stared at it, took a bite, stared again….Like maybe I was the problem. But no. That bread was the culinary equivalent of a catfish. Looked promising, tasted like regret. I was on the edge. Ready to walk out and accept defeat. But then… the pepperoni pizza arrived.
Redemption.
It came in hot literally and emotionally. Perfectly crispy crust, saucy in all the right ways, and that cheese-pull? Cinematic. The pepperoni was doing laps around my taste buds like it trained for this moment. THIS is what I came for. THIS is what healed me. Overall, Pepperoni pizza was my therapy session .Garlic & cheesy bread is a public service warning. Will I be back? Yes, for the pizza. But I’ll pretend the bread never happened.

Source: Google

k keith

★ 5

Great old school pizza parlor. 🍕 Try the cheese n sausage thin crust.

Source: Google

Travis Wilson

★ 5

Source: Google

BeeJay Thao

★ 2

Pizza was a paper thin crust. Their website doesn’t indicate that it’s a thin crust pizza; Otherwise, I wouldn’t have ordered their pizza. Also, $18 for a super thin crust pizza isn’t a good price. The sauce and toppings were good. But I hate thin crust.

Source: Google

Gregg Bailey

★ 4

Source: Google

Ernest Coleman

★ 5

We came because this place was on the news regarding the SMO pizza. Was quite impressed with the product and the service. We'll come back again.

Source: Google

A.J. D.

★ 5

Great pizza! Authentic Milwaukee style THE BEST!!

Source: Google

Ati Gurcay

★ 4

The pizza is pretty good, not the best pizza I've ever eaten but one of the bests in Milwaukee. The space is cool, feels like an old restaurant. They had Heineken in their beer selection, which was surprising.

Source: Google

Vicky Grice

★ 5

Source: Google

Alexander Dey

★ 5

Amazing thin crust pizza.

Source: Google

Miguel Sanchez

★ 3

Food was, ok! However service was below average. Looks like they don’t practice timing between courses/meals. Overall I did not have a good experience.

Source: Google

Jeff Cubinski

★ 5

Best pizza in town

Source: Google

DeMarco Jackson

★ 5

Source: Google

Shad Emberton

★ 5

Source: Google

Claudine Lienau

★ 5

Pizza was great, as usual. My son had the pasta with red sauce. The leftovers are enough for about 2 more meals.

Source: Google

Chris L

★ 5

I love this place. If it’s not the best traditional thin crust pizza in Milwaukee it’s very close! And the price, service and atmosphere can’t be beat. Not to mention the killer fried eggplant which you should absolutely try.

Source: Google

Mackenzie Medema

★ 5

Source: Google

James Selje

★ 5

Pizza was excellent but garlic bread was incredibly disappointing. I will return here again because I enjoyed the pizza so much.

Update: I came back here again with coworkers and it was even better than the first time. Best pizza that I’ve had in Milwaukee. 5 ⭐️

Source: Google

Priya K

★ 5

Best pizza ever, came back after 10y, still the same pizza delicious 😊

Source: Google

Joe Kendziorski

★ 5

Awesome pizza and love the spunky waitress

Source: Google

Adam Kuborn

★ 5

Source: Google

Jamie Myetich

★ 5

Great place best pizza I've had in a long time. Sausage link was excellent. friendly staff awesome bartender. We stop here every time we are in town.

Source: Google

Daniel

★ 5

Source: Google

Cassandra Knudsen

★ 5

Source: Google

Janice Schwartz

★ 5

Source: Google

Benjamin Friesen

★ 5

Can’t say enough positive things about this place. Delicious cracker crust. We sat at the bar. Great service and the pizza was dreamy.

Source: Google

Robert Penner

★ 5

Why go to Pizza Shuttle when Zaffiro's is right down the street. Some of the most high quality and delicious pizza in Milwaukee, blows away all the East Side competition besides Lisa's. Crispy, square cut, tavern style pizza is a delight. The wait can be a little bit long when picking up but it is worth it. There is a reason why they are so busy...Don't bother with pizza chains or inferior joints. Just go to Zaffiro's.

Source: Google

justareview

★ 2

Source: Google

nick kingsbury

★ 1

This place was terrible. We arrived 90 minutes before our movie, ordered an appetizer platter that was 20 dollars, that that had nine dollars in up charges for half a plate of terrible fried food. Then we waited 40 minutes for two wraps that didn't arrive, so we finally had to go into the movie. The beer lines needed cleaning because both beers I tried tasted sour. We should have eaten literally anywhere else then came to the movie. Eat anywhere else or prepare to be ripped off and have terrible food.

Source: Google

Ben Butz

★ 5

Source: Google

Michael Morris

★ 5

Awesome pepperoni pie

Source: Google

allyson smith

★ 1

Rude servers. Good pizza. I think this will be my last time eating here. It’s a shame but they are rude

Source: Google

Derrar Benchekribou

★ 5

Best pizza in Milwaukee. You can taste the difference in freshness of all the ingredients. Prices aren’t bad either.

Source: Google

roger pfeifer

★ 5

Source: Google

Dylan Nice

★ 5

Source: Google

JIM CONWAY

★ 4

Source: Google

Deanna Stever

★ 5

Zaffiros never fails to deliver. They have outstanding pizza. I took a par baked to go with salad and the salad was great too.
I just don't like the parking due to the location.

Source: Google

Britt Saunders

★ 5

Absolutely LOVE Zaffiro's!! Very generous portions of delicious food, excellent service, comfy atmosphere. A Milwaukee institution!

Source: Google

Stephanie Schulko

★ 4

Source: Google

Matt Nelson

★ 2

Got a pizza and it was cold, tried to order a second time over an hour before they closed and they wouldn’t take my order. Not sure what the hype is all about

Source: Google

Lynette

★ 5

Busy and small, great thin crust pizza in Milwaukee

Source: Google

Jennifer Serna

★ 1

I went in today with a coworker for lunch as we are working across the street. We both ordered a beer which the bartender was cordial but nothing over the top as expected for a mom and pop hole in the wall. We were really excited to try the pizza as we are both huge foodies. As we were placing our order with an older woman we ordered the everything pizza with no mushroom or sausage and she rolled her eyes sighed very loudly and scribbled out the order and ripped out the order ticket very aggressively and slammed it on the counter and said ‘SO YOU DON’T WANT THE EVERYTHING PIZZA WHATTTT DO YOU WANT ON IT” we finished the order in shock over her behavior and decided against eating the food as we were afraid something would be done do our food. Not sure if she didn’t like our appearance or the fact that we are hispanics but this lafy was way over the top and I definitely do not recommend going there if you are lgbt or POC.

Source: Google

Basil Al Alami

★ 5

Omg the crunchy cheese pizza

Source: Google

Robert Borkowski

★ 5

One of best Pizza restaurants in Milwaukee

Source: Google

Matthew Newman

★ 5

Source: Google

brandon lopez

★ 5

Source: Google

A Rosebud Rejoicing

★ 5

Had the meatball Sandwich and added mozzarella. Delicious!

Source: Google

Jon Tout

★ 5

Great locals location. Not for big groups. Perfect for pizza.

Source: Google

Gail Bruce

★ 5

Source: Google

Todd Lash

★ 5

Well damn...I've got to go there. This place really couldn't be more my thing. It's absolutely old school Milwaukee in the best way. The building itself is charming, the bartenders were incredibly friendly and on point with service. The clientele is diverse with a great mix of old timers, younger folks, people who clearly are originally from other countries and everyone just vibes.

Now, the pizza.

I eat and cook pizza as a passion, an addiction, and a love. I came here just to try this pie. This super thin crust tavern-ish pizza was out of this world. I had the sausage special. The flavor was incredible, but the most amazing thing was how it maintained its superb crispness when pipping hot and once it had cooled. Crazy good pie.

Source: Google

RD

★ 5

Favorite pizza in the US since I discovered this place thirty years ago. Cracker crust thin with square slices to die for...

Source: Google

Freddy

★ 5

Source: Google

saad mohiuddin

★ 1

Ok so I have not eaten at this place so I cannot rate the food or the atmosphere. My review is based on my experience over the phone. I called and very politely asked if they offer The Big Z pizza challenge which I had heard about. The lady was so dismissive and had an angry tone in her voice. Apparently, they do not offer it at their normal locations but how would I have known that lol. I called on 10/22/2024 at 2:22pm.

Source: Google

Susan Skoczynski

★ 5

Nice thin crush pizzA

Source: Google

Scott W

★ 5

Came here as part of a Brady Street Food Tour. They served us some excellent think crust cheese pizza. It was excellent! We will be back for an entire meal.

Source: Google

Dan Baker

★ 5

Source: Google

Sean Richardson

★ 4

Source: Google

Ethan Heinzelman

★ 5

Source: Google

Beth Plambeck

★ 2

Source: Google

Michelle DiFiore

★ 5

Source: Google

Ian Dow

★ 5

Best pizza!!!

Source: Google

Kyle Efferding

★ 5

The original of originals! The best. And they’ll make it crispy for ya if ya just ask!!!! 👨🏻‍🍳

Source: Google

Arya Kulkarni

★ 5

Source: Google

Andrew Montalenti

★ 5

Source: Google

Nicole Allen

★ 5

Source: Google

Joshua Joyner

★ 2

I'm amazed reading some of these reviews about how this is the best pizza in Milwaukee- it tastes like greasier Digiorno but for 8x the price. You'd get a better price to quality ratio getting a pizza on uber eats from Chicago. It took an hour and a half for the order to be made, the crust was scorched (which some people may like), and the sauce was a solid 5/10. The mushrooms were the only reason we finished it. We will not be going here again, now we know.

Source: Google

dope tronixz

★ 5

pizza was good service was good must try !

Source: Google

Randal Gilbertson

★ 5

Pizza is fantastic!

Source: Google

Lindsey Zahn

★ 5

Source: Google

Theresa Granados

★ 5

Excellent crispy thin crust pizza!. Delicious. Good atmosphere if you want old school charm. Easy public parking directly across the street.

Source: Google

Shawn Ostendorf

★ 5

Source: Google

Pat Walloch

★ 4

Pizza was overcooked. Crust tasted like cardboard. Edges burnt. Person tried to tell me was O.K. Did not offer to remake or anything. Owner was not on-site.

Source: Google

Daniel Reed

★ 5

Source: Google

Steve Suminski

★ 5

Source: Google

Michelle Presswood

★ 4

Source: Google

Tom Hrlevich

★ 5

Probably one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had crispy perfectly cooked great ingredients. We sat at the bar, The bartender was as expected a great bartender with a wealth of Milwaukee knowledge! Loved it.

Source: Google

Cory Censky

★ 2

Pizza is pretty good but priced too expensive per weight. Also with the owners also part of Jacks frozen pizza this business should be run much better. They are leaching on the city.

Source: Google

Grant Farrelly

★ 5

Moved away 10 years ago and stopped in recently to see if it was just as good we remembered. It was! Salads are still huge and delicious. That thin crust is incredible on the pizza. Glad we went out of our way when we’re passing through Milwaukee to revisit this hidden gem.

Source: Google

Cayden Cohen

★ 1

Phew, here we go. To start the server didn’t bring drinks out to us until after the food came out where I had to remind him that we asked for drinks. The Mac and cheese I ordered seemed to be tossed together with milk as the only sauce. The chicken which costed 4$ to add to the plain pasta which was 13$ already(outrageous). Chicken was obviously microwaved and had different temperatures through each piece. The pizza was made of cardboard crust with cheap bowling alley taste to the sauce and grey cheese on top. This was some of the worst food I ever tried to force down my throat. Only way I would order another thing from this place is if they added mouthwash to the menu. Had to poop, shower, and brush my teeth to make my body forget I went here. 0/10

Source: Google

Katrina Kochanski

★ 5

Source: Google

Matt Chu

★ 5

Really good Italian beef sandwich. I definitely would go back.

Source: Google

Alice Markel

★ 2

Restaurant was very busy and we were put in a corner and our waitress barely visited us. My husband ended up going to the bar himself to get a second round. Pizza order came out wrong

Source: Google

Larry Howard

★ 4

Source: Google

Heather Kudla

★ 5

My parents and brother live in the area, but this was my first time. Amazing pizza and salad. Great service and atmosphere!!

Source: Google

Crystin Runyan

★ 5

We recently dined here on a random afternoon while moving our daughter and loved it so much we can't seem to get down there to eat it often enough!!!! The pizza is PHENOMENAL!!! We have done take out and it's still delicious, however dine in is our preference!!

Source: Google

Ricardo Trinidad

★ 5

Its been serving the crispiest thin crust pizza fir over 70 years. There is a reason why it's still so popular.

Source: Google

Chuck B

★ 4

I waited well over an hour for my pizza (to long) but the pizza was delicious. 🤷🏼‍♂️

Source: Google

SERGELATO

★ 4

We tried their zaffiro’s salad which was good, but didn’t have any noticeable dressing in it. We split a pizza which we got half pepperoni and half sausage. The pizza was thin, and the flavor was cheesy, mild salty, and had a nice undercarriage which I appreciated. The tenderloin steak sandwich was disappointing however because the sandwich was basically a seasoned meat patty and clearly needed some toppings to add diversity in flavor. It might as well come without bread, overall I would come back for the pizza.

Source: Google

chad buchen

★ 3

The pizza was amazing and so was the service, I highly recommend this place!!

Source: Google

Mitch Lechter

★ 5

If thin crust pizza is your passion, then Ziffiro's makes the best in Milwaukee. Our server was prompt, polite, and efficient. The kitchen is consistently excellent in preparation and timing. In terms of atmosphere, the eclectic crowd makes for fun people watching, but the decor could use an upgrade.

Source: Google

Brea MacK

★ 1

got my order wrong horrible food

Source: Google

Shane Kalepp

★ 1

Took over two and half hours to get my delivery and I’m only 10 minutes away. They kept saying it was traffic related but I think it was an excuse the driver forgot to take my order. When I asked if they could make it right they they said they couldn’t. Unfortunately, I won’t be eating from them again because. The lady was super rude on the phone.

Source: Google

Marshall Sunshine

★ 5

Amazing. Didn’t disappoint!

Source: Google

Bella Torri

★ 5

Oh how I missed this pizza! Nothing like this in AZ, so glad to be back in the Milwaukee area.

Source: Google

Tyler Diers

★ 5

Amazing tavern style pizza. For real, as a Chicagoan, I have to say, this stuff is legit.

Source: Google

Elliott Urquhart

★ 5

Still in the top 5 pizza restaurants in Milwaukee. I love the sauce, that’s what makes any pizza great.

Source: Google

Aden Sayers

★ 5

Source: Google

Jackie Ruszczak

★ 5

Source: Google

Nicole Riopelle

★ 5

We were visiting Milwaukee after being away for several years. I called in a delivery order. The staff member took the order quickly and shared it would be about an hour for delivery - which made sense given the time of our order. It arrived sooner than expected, and the delivery driver was the most delightful human. Our food was hot and delicious. Love that crispy, thin crust. Thank you!

Source: Google

Richard

★ 5

Source: Google

David Frieze

★ 5

Source: Google

Julia Stickney

★ 5

Source: Google

Joe Srofe (St Joe Adventures)

★ 4

Great food. Pizza has a very thin crust but delicious. Wait staff was very friendly and knowledgeable.

Source: Google

Theo Champetier

★ 3

I was recommended this pizza but it's really not great in my French opinion. Some toppings are good :)
We were told to come in 35 min but had to wait 15 more min in front of the restaurant, nothing great to see there although it was sunny outside.

Source: Google

Manuel Garcia

★ 5

Old school vibes, you can feel the history inside as soon as u walk in. The pizza is super crispy. We had the sausage special with onion.

Source: Google

Terrie Lynn Dignan

★ 4

Tasted okay. I wouldn't go head over heels for the place.
I wasn't necessarily fond of the restrooms. A very small room with only a toilet, no washing sink nor hand sanitizer.

Source: Google

Mason Kiss

★ 5

Source: Google

Anita Dyson

★ 5

Source: Google

Ken Weise

★ 4

I eat a lot of pizza. This is the cracker crust variety. We bought 4 pizzas. Most were pretty greasy. Flavors were good. One pizza came with unordered anchovies.

Not the best pizza I've had, but good

Source: Google

Taylor Jones

★ 5

Source: Google

Jared Meyer

★ 5

Source: Google

Durga Saranya T

★ 5

Source: Google

Ellery Kretlow

★ 5

Awesome pizza and eggplant.
Thx

Source: Google

Derick Downs Sr.

★ 5

Source: Google